You are on page 1of 7

Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jngse

Feasibility study, simulation and economical evaluation of natural


gas sweetening processes e Part 1: A case study on a low capacity
plant in iran
Abolghasem Kazemi a, *, Mojtaba Malayeri a, Abolfazl Gharibi kharaji a, Ahmad Shariati b
a
Chemical Engineering Department, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran
b
Natural Gas Engineering Department, Petroleum University of Technology, Ahwaz, Iran

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Considering the natural gas produced from one of Iranian gas fields, a suitable alkanolamine solution is
Received 2 May 2014 selected for the sweetening of this gas. Based on the selected alkanolamine solution, the alkanolamine
Received in revised form process is simulated with Aspen hysys simulator and economically evaluated with Aspen economic
2 June 2014
analyzer. Sulfinol-M process, LO-CAT process and shell process for natural gas sweetening are also
Accepted 4 June 2014
Available online 22 June 2014
simulated and economically evaluated with the use of Aspen process economic analyzer in order to
remove H2S and CO2 from the natural gas produced in this field to meet the pipeline specifications.
According to results, the LO-CAT and the mixed amine processes are the two processes which have better
Keywords:
Natural gas
performance based on rich solution acid gas loading and thus, have lower costs related to corrosion in
CO2 facilities. With regard to the two aspects the LO-CAT process is the best process when capital and
H2S operating costs along with acid gas loading are taken into account.
Sweetening © 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Simulation
Economic evaluation

1. Introduction process and sulfinol-M process. Alkalonamine solutions are the


most popular solutions for the acid gas removal from natural gas and
Before transmission of natural gas through pipelines, Removal of are commercially used for natural gas sweetening since early thirties
H2S and CO2 (acid gases) from the natural gas is desirable because (Kohl and Nielsen, 1997; Processors, 2004; Rinker et al., 2000). Since
presence of these components in the pipeline can cause technical methyldiethanol amine (MDEA) solution, alongside requiring rela-
difficulties (e.g. corrosion) (Campbell and Maddox, 1974; Datta and tively low energy for regeneration, is known for its high selectivity
Sen, 2006; Rufford et al., 2012); The maximum concentrations of toward H2S and addition of little amounts of primary or secondary
H2S and CO2 in the natural gas are restricted to 4 ppm and 2 mol% amines to MDEA, causes CO2 absorption rate of MDEA solution to
respectively by regulations (Abdulrahman and Sebastine, 2013). increase (Fouad and Berrouk, 2013; Nuchitprasittichai and
Numerous processes have been developed for the removal of these Cremaschi, 2011; Rangwala et al., 1992), The MDEA, DEA mixture
acid gases from the natural gas in different operating conditions of amines is selected as a suitable alkalonamine solution for treat-
and different CO2 and H2S concentrations in the sour gas (Kohl and ment of those gases which have high H2S and low CO2 content.
Nielsen, 1997; Processors, 2004; Rufford et al., 2012). Most of these (Fouad and Berrouk, 2013; Nuchitprasittichai and Cremaschi, 2011)
processes involve chemical and/or physical absorption of the acid In this study, this process is simulated and economically evaluated
gases with a regenerable solvent (Campbell and Maddox, 1974; and compared to three other processes which can perform well in
Kohl and Nielsen, 1997; Processors, 2004). sweetening of gases with high H2S (Elkanzi, 2009; Processors,
In this study the natural gas produced from one of gas fields in 2004). All of the four processes are economically evaluated with
iran, with relatively high H2S (5 mol %) fraction and relatively low the use of Aspen process economic analyzer v8.1, and the best pro-
CO2 (1.33 mol %) is considered and four of the well-developed pro- cess from an economical view is selected.
cesses for the natural gas sweetening are simulated in order to meet
with the pipeline specifications. These processes are mixed alka-
lonamine process (mixed MDEA and DEA), shell process, LO CAT 2. Sour gas composition

* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ98 9171492783. These four processes are designed for the purpose of sweetening
E-mail address: Abolghasemkazemi@gmail.com (A. Kazemi). of a typical gas produced in one of gas fields in iran. The natural gas

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jngse.2014.06.001
1875-5100/© 2014 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
A. Kazemi et al. / Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22 17

produced from this field has H2S content of 5% and CO2 content of operate at high temperatures and low pressures and the regeneration
1.33%. There are also light components such as CO, CO2 and N2 with column to operate at high temperatures and low pressures.
low mole fraction present in this gas. However methane with mole Several studies have been carried out for the purpose of simu-
fraction of 0.7203 and ethane with mole fraction of 0.1021 are the lation of amine sweetening units with Hysys process simulator
major components in this gas. The feed gas temperature and (Kumar et al., 2014). One of the reasons is that this simulator is
pressure are equal to 54  C and 24.5 bar respectively and its average benefited from a powerful fluid property package (amine package)
MW is 23.4. suitable for the simulation of amine sweetening units. Aspen hysys
Simulations of sulfinol-M and lo cat processes for the sweet- v8.1 is used for the simulation of this process. A screenshot of the
ening of this gas have been carried out with the use of Aspen plus simulation flow sheet is shown in Fig. 1 (Aspenone-examples,
v7.3 and for shell and amine processes Aspen hysys v7.3 and Aspen 2013).
hysys v8.1 have been used respectively.
3.2. Sulfinol-M process
3. An overview of the four processes
As suggested by Hiller et al. (2006) Sulfinol process is suitable
3.1. Mixed amine process for the sweetening of gases having a summation of partial pressures
of H2S and CO2 higher than 1 bar (Hiller et al., 2006). In the natural
Alkalonamines are widely used for the removal of acid gases gas of interest (described in Section 2), the summation of partial
from the natural gas. Alkalonamines are classified (based on the pressures of H2S and CO2 is calculated to be 1.4904 bar so the sul-
number of alkyl groups which make bonds to the N atom of amino finol process could be a good choice for the sweetening of this gas.
group) to primary amines (e.g. MEA), secondary amines (e.g. DEA) In the Sulfinol-M process the acid gas removal from the natural gas
and tertiary amines (e.g. MDEA), each of which have advantages is carried out with the use of Sulfinol-M solution which consists of
and disadvantages (Fouad and Berrouk, 2013; Padurean et al., water, sulfolane and MDEA (methyl-diethanolamine). Sulfolane is a
2011). Primary amines have higher reaction rates while tertiary polar organic compound which has potential for absorbing acid
amines need less energy for regeneration (Mudhasakul et al., 2013). gases (H2S and CO2) (Jou et al., 1990), it is synthesized by reacting
Selection of a suitable amine solution for sweetening can affect sulfur dioxide gas and butadiene to produce the intermediate
equipment sizing and operating costs. Methyl-diethanolamine product 3-sulfolene and then the reaction of 3-sulfolene with
(MDEA) is known for its high selectivity toward H2S in presence hydrogen gas to sulfolane and this chemical is commercially pro-
of CO2 and it's reaction with H2S is nearly instantaneous, while duced and available for purchase (Stewart and Minnear, 2010). The
absorption of CO2 in MDEA occurs at low rates (Fouad and Berrouk, sulfinol-M solution is mainly used for the selective absorption of
2013; Haimour and Sandall, 1987; Mudhasakul et al., 2013; Rufford H2S from the natural gas in presence of CO2 (Nasir, 1990). Sulfinol-
et al., 2012) furthermore, regeneration of tertiary amines requires M solution is a physical e chemical solution in which, sulfolane is
lower energy than primary and secondary amines (Yildirim et al., responsible for the physical absorption and MDEA for chemical
2012), so MDEA seems to be a good choice for the sweetening of absorption through reactions (1e4) (D.L. Nikolic, 2009; Kohl and
the natural gas with 5% H2S and 1.33% CO2. The previous studies Nielsen, 1997; Processors, 2004) by simultaneously utilizing phys-
suggest that in order to increase the CO2 absorption rate of tertiary ical and chemical solvents, the sulfinol-M process is benefited by
amines (e.g. MDEA), little amounts of primary or secondary amines advantages of the both solvents which are the high solvent capacity
(e.g. DEA) should be added to the solution (Anufrikov et al., 2007; of physical solvents and high purity of sweetened gas of chemical
Nuchitprasittichai and Cremaschi, 2011) another reason of mixing solvents (Kunkel, 1971; Nikolic).
primary or secondary amines with tertiary amines is to combine Aspen plus v7.3 was used for simulation of this process and a
high reactivity of primary and secondary amines with low energy screenshot of the simulation is shown in Fig. 2. ELECNRTL model is
requirement for regeneration of tertiary amines (Fouad and used for the simulation of this process.
Berrouk, 2013); Based on this information, a solution of 35mass%
MDEA and 5mass% DEA is selected for the sweetening of natural gas 3.3. Chelated iron (LO CAT) process
with the specifications described in Section 2. MDEA can be syn-
thesized from reaction of the intermediate mono methyl ethanol- The LO CAT process uses ferric iron solution for the removal of
amine and ethylene oxide, while, Mono methyl ethanolamine is H2S, the use of Fe(III) as a regenerable oxidant for the removal of
produced from the reaction of ethylene oxide and mono methyl- H2S from gases began at 1830 with introduction of Fe2O3 (Kohl and
amine. DEA also can be produced by reacing ethylene oxide and Nielsen, 1997). The gas sweetening with the use of chelated iron
ammonia (Jones et al., 2004). MDEA and DEA both are commer- solution is an economical and environmentally clean process and
cially produced and available for purchase. These amines absorb the solution in this process is not toxic (Kohl and Nielsen, 1997; Yu
the acid gases through these chemical reactions (Cummings et al., et al., 2014). The technology of using iron evolved to homogenous
2007; Lu et al., 2006; Nuchitprasittichai and Cremaschi, 2011): redox catalysts using Fe(EDTA) (Thompson, 1980). EDTA is an
abbreviation for Ethylene Diamine Tetra Acetic which is available
Secondary amines: R2NH þ H2S / (R2NH)þ þ (HS) (1) for purchase. H2S absorbed in the solution is oxidized by ferric ion
and is then converted to elemental sulfur (Kohl and Nielsen, 1997);
Tertiary amines: R3N þ H2S / (R3NH)þ þ (HS) (2)
2Fe3þ þ HS )/ 2Fe2þ þ S þ Hþ (5)
Secondary amines: CO2 þ R2NH 4 R2NHþCOO (3)
1
Tertiary amines : CO2 þ R3 N þ H2 O4R3 NHþ þ HCO 2Fe2þ þ O þH2 O)/2Fe3þ þ20H (6)
3 (4) 2 2
High pressure and low temperature favor the extent of the re- Simulation of this process is carried out with the use of Aspen
actions while the reverse of these reactions is favored by high tem- plus v7.3. The simulation flow sheet is shown in Fig. 3. Because of
perature and low pressure (Fouad and Berrouk, 2013). Also (Ebenezer, the ionic nature of the absorption reactions, the ELECNRTL model
2005) suggests that the absorber of amine sweetening plant should has been used for the simulation of this process.
18 A. Kazemi et al. / Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22

Fig. 1. A screenshot of process flow diagram of the mixed amine process.

Fig. 2. A screenshot of process flow diagram of the sulfinol-M process.

Fig. 3. A screenshot of process flow diagram of the Lo-cat process.

A typical molar ratio of iron in the solution to H2S in the feed gas of the solution in circulation is needed (Kohl and Nielsen, 1997;
is 4:1 (Kohl and Nielsen, 1997). This ratio is applied for determi- Processors, 2004).
nation of concentration of iron in the solution. The regeneration of
the solution is carried out with the use of air at the regeneration 3.4. Shell paques process
column's pressure. The regeneration reaction usually occurs in a
packed or spray bed (Yang et al., 2002). The development of shell e paques technology by shell and
Efficiency of hydrogen sulfide removal of this process is close to paques companies, was originally for treatment of natural gas,
100%.(Kohl and Nielsen, 1997). In this process no heating or cooling synthesis gas and the tail gases of the clause process. This process
A. Kazemi et al. / Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22 19

uses the same technology as thiopaq technology, which is used for One of the most important parameters in the acid gas removal
treatment of high pressure sour gases (up to 1300 psig) in oil, gas units is the flow rate (gpm) of the solution in circulation and the
and petrochemical industries (Benschop et al., 2002). This process project costs are strong functions of solution in circulation. As re-
is suitable for H2S range of 100 ppmv to very high H2S concentra- ported by (Chan and Tontiwachwuthi, 1996) 70% of the investment
tions and pressure range of 1e75 bar and complete removal of H2S of a plant is directly related to this parameter. The reason of this
can be achieved in this process (Benschop et al., 2002). In the shell influence is that the solution circulation rate affects the size of fa-
process the absorption of acid gases is carried out with the use of cilities like absorber, piping and regenerator (Chan and
caustic solution which contains caustic soda, water and sulfur Tontiwachwuthikul, 1996). After completing the simulation for
bacteria (Processors, 2004). Sodium hydroxide solutions are the four processes, this parameter is extracted from the simulators
commercially available for purchase. The solution contacts the sour and the results are shown in Fig. 5.
gas in the absorber column and the caustic soda (NaOH) absorbs Thus, based on the data extracted from the simulators, the shell
H2S, the rich solution goes to a bioreactor in which the solution is process needs the lowest solution flow rate for acid gas removal (in
aerated and H2S is converted to elemental sulfur (Processors, 2004). order to meet pipeline specifications). The Sulfinol-M and mixed
The reaction of absorption of H2S is (Sherbaniuk et al., 2003): amine processes also need lower solution flow rates than the LO
CAT process. The difference between the needed flow rate of shell
NaOH / Naþ þ OH (7) process and the other three processes is significant, while the
needed flow rate of solution for mixed amine, sulfinol-M and LO
H2S þ OH / HS þ H2O (8) CAT processes are relatively close. High solution flow rate causes
the plant to require larger equipment and thus causes the costs of
It can be concluded from reactions (7) and (8) that absorption of the plant to increase, on the other hand the rich solution acid gas
H2S consumes the OH ion (and thus caustic solution). And the re- concentration will decrease due to high flow rate of the solution
action occurring in the bioreactor producing the consumed OH is: and thus the corrosion rate will decrease at the pipes and equip-
ment. Based on this information, a process cannot be chosen only
1 1 based on the solution flow rate.
HS þ O2 / S8 þOH (9)
2 8 Another important operating parameter in the acid gas removal
Existence of micro-organisms in the bioreactor increases the unit is the solution loading which is defined as the number of moles
rate of reaction (9), in which hydroxyl ion is reproduced. The of acid gas removed from the natural gas to the number of the moles
reproduced OH ion can absorb another H2S molecule in the of the material which is used for the purpose of absorption. The
absorber. Absorption rate of CO2 is low and this solution selectively loading describes the capability of 1 mol of the solvent in absorbing
absorbs H2S from the natural gas. Based on reaching pipeline the acid gases. When the acid gas loading is high, the corrosion rate in
specifications for the sweet natural gas, simulation of this process is facilities would be high too, so in accordance to Fig. 6 the shell process
carried out using Aspen hysys v7.3. The PRSV property package has has the worst performance when corrosion is taken into account. And
been used in this simulation and a screenshot of simulation flow the best process in this case is the mixed amine process, while per-
sheet is shown in Fig. 4. formance of the LO CAT process is well too. Of course this parameter
shouldn't be taken into account separated from the solution flow rate,
because as the rich amine acid gas loading increases, the solution
4. Results and discussion flow rate needed (for a specific feed gas) decreases, thus the unit
would have higher costs related to corrosion in facilities while lower
4.1. Economic evaluation of the four processes fixed and operating costs related to solution flow rate.
The operating costs of the processes are extracted from the
The economic evaluation for all of the four processes is carried Aspen process economic analyzer v8.1 for four different flow rates
out with use of Aspen process economic analyzer 8.1. of the sour gas and the results are shown in Fig. 7. The main

Fig. 4. A screenshot of process flow diagram of shell process.


20 A. Kazemi et al. / Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22

Fig. 5. Required solution flow rate (gpm) in order to meet pipeline specifications for different sour gas flow rates.

Fig. 6. Rich solution loading for different processes at different sour gas flow rates.

operating costs for sweetening units are the costs related to the The total capital costs of the four processes are extracted from
energy consumed in the reboilers of the regeneration columns (or ASPEN process economic analyzer v8.1 and the results are shown in
production of open steam), pumps and heaters. Fig. 8.
As indicated in Fig. 7, in this case study, the best process for acid As shown in Fig. 8 based on total capital costs, the LO CAT
gas removal based on the total annual operating costs is the LO CAT process is the best process for the removal of acid gases from the
process, the shell and the sulfinol-M processes also have lower sour natural gas described in Section 2. The sulfinol-M has the
operating costs than the mixed amine process. highest capital costs among the four processes and mixed amine

Fig. 7. Annual operating costs (US$/year) for different processes at different sour gas flow rates.
A. Kazemi et al. / Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22 21

Fig. 8. Total capital costs (US$) for different processes at different sour gas flow rates.

and shell processes have lower capital costs than Sulfinol-M pro- Cummings, A.L., Smith, G.D., Nelsen, D.K., 2007. Advances in amine reclaimingewhy
there's no excuse to operate a dirty amine system. In: Reid Gas Conditioning
cess and higher than LO CAT process.
Conference on February, vol. 27.
To choose one of the four processes, not only capital and oper- Datta, A.K., Sen, P.K., 2006. Optimization of membrane unit for removing carbon
ating costs, but also costs related to high corrosion rate for the dioxide from natural gas. J. Membr. Sci. 283 (1), 291e300.
processes should be taken into account. As shown in Figs. 7 and 8, Ebenezer, S.A., 2005. Removal of Carbon Dioxide from Natural Gas For LNG Pro-
duction. Institute of Petroleum Technology, Norwegian University of Science
the LO CAT process has the best economic performance for this feed and Technology, Trondheim, Norway.
at developmental sour gas flow rates (5-20 MMSCFD). Also from Elkanzi, E.M., 2009. Simulation of the process of biological removal of hydrogen
Fig. 6 it is clear that the LO CAT and the mixed amine processes are sulfide from gas. In: Proceedings of the 1st Annual Gas Processing Symposium,
pp. 266e275.
the two processes which have better performance based on rich Fouad, W.A., Berrouk, A.S., 2013. Using mixed tertiary amines for gas sweetening
solution acid gas loading and thus, have lower costs related to energy requirement reduction. J. Nat. Gas. Sci. Eng. 11, 12e17.
corrosion in facilities. With regard to the two aspects, it seems that Haimour, N., Sandall, O.C., 1987. Absorption of H2S into aqueous methyldiethanol-
amine. Chem. Eng. Commun. 59 (1e6), 85e93.
the LO CAT process is the best process when capital and operating Hiller, H., Reimert, R., Marschner, F., Renner, H.J., Boll, W., Supp, E., Driesen, H.E.,
costs along with acid gas loading are taken into account. As indi- 2006. Gas production. Ullmann's Encycl. Ind. Chem. 16.
cated in Figs. 5e8, the simulation and economic evaluation of the Jones, C., Edens, M.R., Lochary, J.F., 2004. Alkanolamines from Olefin Oxides and
Ammonia. In: Kirk-othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology.
four processes have been carried out for low (developmental) sour Jou, F.Y., Deshmukh, R.D., Otto, F.D., Mather, A.E., 1990. Solubility of H2S, CO2, CH4
gas flow rates. However the large flow rates of sour natural gas for and C2H6 in sulfolane at elevated pressures. Fluid Ph. Equilib. 56, 313e324.
industrial applications can be the topic of the future studies. Kohl, A.L., Nielsen, R., 1997. Gas Purification. Gulf Professional Publishing.
Kumar, S., Cho, J.H., Moon, I., 2014. Ionic liquid-amine blends and CO2 BOLs: pro-
spective solvents for natural gas sweetening and CO2 capture technologyda
review. Int. J. Greenh. Gas Control 20, 87e116.
5. Conclusions Kunkel, L. Precontacting Hydrogen Sulfide Containing Gas Streams With Rich Sul-
finol. U.S. Patent 3,630,666, issued December 28, 1971.
For the purpose of sweetening of the natural gas with relatively Lu, J.G., Zheng, Y.F., He, D.L., 2006. Selective absorption of H2S from gas mixtures
into aqueous solutions of blended amines of methyldiethanolamine and 2-
high H2S content 5 mol% and low CO2 content 1.33 mol% with the tertiarybutylamino-2-ethoxyethanol in a packed column. Sep. Purif. Technol.
conditions described in Section 2, a suitable alkalonamine solution 52 (2), 209e217.
is selected and then the process of sweetening with the use of Mudhasakul, S., Ku, H.M., Douglas, P.L., 2013. A simulation model of a CO2 ab-
sorption process with methyldiethanolamine solvent and piperazine as an
alkalonamines is simulated and economically evaluated; three
activator. Int. J. Greenh. Gas. Control 15, 134e141.
other processes which are also suitable for the sweetening of nat- Nasir, P., 1990. A Mixed Solvent for a Low Total Sulfur Specification. AIChE National
ural gas of this type are simulated and economically evaluated and Meeting, San Diego, CA.
then compared to the alkalonamine process. It has been revealed Nikolic, D.C.M. Sulfinol-x For Acid Gas Removal: a Solution for Long Production
from Contaminated Gas. Shell Global Solutions International. Amsterdam, the
that in this case, the LO CAT process is more economical than the Netherlands.
alkalonamine process which is the most popular process for the Nikolic, D.L., 2009. Sulfinol-x for Acid Gas Removal: a Solution for LNG Production
purpose of natural gas sweetening. from Contaminated Gas. Process Engineering Center Gas & LNG.
Nuchitprasittichai, A., Cremaschi, S., 2011. Optimization of CO2 capture process with
aqueous amines using response surface methodology. Comput. Chem. Eng. 35
(8), 1521e1531.
References Padurean, A., Cormos, C.C., Cormos, A.M., Agachi, P.S., 2011. Multicriterial analysis of
post-combustion carbon dioxide capture using alkanolamines. Int. J. Greenh.
Abdulrahman, R.K., Sebastine, I.M., 2013. Natural gas sweetening process simulation Gas. Control 5 (4), 676e685.
and optimization: a case study of Khurmala field in Iraqi Kurdistan region. Processors, G., 2004. Suppliers Association (GPSA) Engineering Data Book. Gas
J. Nat. Gas. Sci. Eng. 14, 116e120. Processors and Suppliers Association, Tulsa, OK, USA.
Anufrikov, Y.A., Kuranov, G.L., Smirnova, N.A., 2007. Solubility of CO2 and H2S in Rangwala, H.A., Morrell, B.R., Mather, A.E., Otto, F.D., 1992. Absorption of CO2 into
alkanolamine-containing aqueous solutions. Russ. J. Appl. Chem. 80 (4), aqueous tertiary amine/MEA solutions. Can. J. Chem. Eng. 70 (3), 482e490.
515e527. Rinker, E.B., Ashour, S.S., Sandall, O.C., 2000. Absorption of carbon dioxide into
Aspenone-examples, 2013. aqueous blends of diethanolamine and methyldiethanolamine. Ind. Eng. Chem.
Benschop, A., Janssen, A., Hoksberg, M., Seriwala, R., Abry, R., Ngai, C., 2002. The Res. 39 (11), 4346e4356.
Shell-Paques/THIOPAQ Gas Desulphurization Process: Successful Start up First Rufford, T.E., Smart, S., Watson, G.C.Y., Graham, B.F., Boxall, J., Diniz da Costa, J.C.,
Commercial Unit. May, E.F., 2012. The removal of CO2 and N2 from natural gas: a review of con-
Campbell, J.M., Maddox, R.N., 1974. Gas Conditioning and Processing. In: Campbell ventional and emerging process technologies. J. Pet. Sci. Eng. 94, 123e154.
Petroleum Series, vol. 121. Sherbaniuk, R., Beasley, T., Abry, R.G.F., 2003. Reducing solution gas flaring has
Chan, C.W., Tontiwachwuthikul, P., 1996. A decision support system for solvent many positive results and managing hydrogen sulphide the natural way. Energy
selection of CO2 separation processes. Energy Convers. Manag. 37 (6), 941e946. Proc. Can. 96 (1), 8e16.
22 A. Kazemi et al. / Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 20 (2014) 16e22

Stewart, O., Minnear, L., 2010. Sulfolane Technical Assistance and Evaluation Report. € Kiss, A.A., Hüser, N., Leßmann, K., Kenig, E.Y., 2012. Reactive absorption
Yildirim, O.,
Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation. in chemical process industry: a review on current activities. Chem. Eng. J. 213,
Thompson, R.B., 1980. U.S. Patent No. 4,189,462. U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, 371e391.
Washington, DC. Yu, Yong, Liu, Youzhi, Qi, Guisheng, 2014. Rapid regeneration of chelated iron
Yang, J.P., Li, H.T., Xiao, J.G., 2002. Study on desulfurization from acidic gaseous desulfurization solution using electrochemical reactor with rotating cylindrical
stream by chelate iron. J. Chem. Ind. Eng. 23 (2), 23e24 (in Chinese). electrodes. Chin. J. Chem. Eng. 22 (2), 136e140.

You might also like