Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
This study focused on assessing variables which may differentiate
suicidal drug abusers from nonabusers. Data from a sample of
drug abusing (n = 86) and nonabusing ( n = 298) suicide at-
tempters were subjected to a stepwise multiple regression analysis
to identify factors related to suicidal intent. The analysis revealed
that in our sample of suicide attempters, drug abuse status was
not a significant contributor to the severity of suicidal intent.
However, it was found that hopelessness accounted for a
significant proportion of the variance of intent. The findings
suggest that hopelessness among drug abusers, an important
determinant of suicidal behavior, presents an important target for
therapeutic intervention.
*To whom requests for reprints should be addressed at 133 South 36th Street, Room 602,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104.
45 1
Copyright @ 1979 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this work nor any
part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or
mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information
storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
452 WEISSMAN, BECK, A N D KOVACS
are drug abusers and that a high proportion of drug abusers exhibit
suicidal behaviors. Morris et al. (1974) reported that 10%of the completed
suicides in Phildadelphia in 1972 had histories of drug abuse. In Finland, a
10-year investigation of a random sample of brain injured war veterans
who committed suicide revealed that 42% of the cases were drug de-
pendent (Achte et al., 1970).
Among addicts the rate of death by suicide has been reported as nearly
five times the rate found in the population at large (O’Donnell, 1964). A
study by James revealed that the suicide rate in a male heroin addict
population in London, England was 50 times the aged-adjusted average
For personal use only.
Table 1 ul
P
Resource Table P
DeLeon et al. 1973 147 male and 61 female par- Six psychometric scales were administered with
ticipants in the Phoenix the following results:
Program’s facilities at all (1) Addicts who come to the program con-
stages of treatment and sistently score in the psychiatric range on
rehabilitation. 83.7 % were all scales.
heroin addicts; 16.3 % were (2) The magnitude of the pathology scores is
not. significantly lower for residents in the later
stage of the program.
(3) Scores also dropped significantly for a
group of residents retested after 7 1/2 months.
(4) Residents who left the program without
clinical advice revealed significantly higher
pathology scores than those who remained.
Frederick et al. 1973 Total N was 268 subjects aged A Morbidity Attitude Survey Scale and a
15-26 years from District of Depression Scale (Zung) were employed.
Columbia and suburban There was distinct evidence of depression
Maryland. The 268 were among the addicted groups compared with
broken down into the controls.
following groups: A greater incidence of suicide attempts among W
addicts than control groups, except Blacks. R
Methadone, N = 78 Hard-core
Findings suggest that suicide attempts among “R
Abstinence, N = 20 )addicts
young people are greater than is commonly P
Delinquent, N = 50 believed, particularly among addicts, and a z
U
Nonchurch, N = 30 total treatment program is necessary in R
Protestant, N = 30
Jewish, N = 30
1
Controls addition to the use of methadone.
9
Black, N =. 30
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
For personal use only.
James 1967 321 male and 115 female heroin (1) Suicide rate among male heroin addicts
addicts in Britain known was over 50 times the expected suicide rate for
to the Home Office Index a normal population, corrected for age.
during years 1955-1964 (2) Mortality rate among heroin addicts in the
and whose addiction origi- United Kingdom approximates to 22 per 1,OOO
nally derived from illicit per year-20 times that expected in a popula-
supplies of heroin. tion of comparable age distribution.
Morris et al. 1974 236 cases ruled as suicide This was an epidemiological study. Of the 236
by the Medical Examiner in cases, 10% were known to have abused
Philadelphia in 1972. drugs; 9 % were alcoholics or excessive drinkers.
O’Donnell 1964 266 White residents of Ken- ( I ) I13 died of natural causes.
tucky treated for narcotic (2) 37 died of nonnatural causes.
addiction at the U.S. Public (3) Approximately equal percentages of men
Health Service Hospital be- and women were addicted to narcotics but 2/3
tween May 1935 and of the women, compared to less than 1/3 of
December 1959. the men, were completely abstinent.
(4) 73 % of the men and 62 % of the women
would be classified as relapsed (all who had any
period of addiction subsequent to discharge).
Prescor and Surgeon 1940 28 subjects admitted to the Hypothetical individual most likely to be
U.S. Public Health Service genuinely suicidal : 40 years old, White,
Hospital for treatment of married prisoner serving a sentence of 3 years
drug addiction and who at or longer; addicted through physical illness
one time or another either some I 1 years prior to admission; 8th grade
overtly displayed or sub- education.
jectively professed self- Admits to marital problems due to his drug
destructive tendencies. addiction: denies any suicide attempts.
Fifteen were sincerely Usually has some affective disorder before
suicidal: 13 insincerely attempt; tries attempt on mental ward;
suicidal: 1036 patients were usually cuts throat or wrists with piece of
controls. broken razor blade.
(roonrinued)
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
For personal use only.
Table 1 (continued)
Aut ho r(s) Year Subjects Findings
R
OI
Vaillant 1966 50 Black and 50 White New Followed patients for 12 years. Findings
York narcotic addicts first suggest :
admitted to the U S . Public ( I ) Such individuals have been deprived not
Health Service Hospital. only in a sociological sense by virtue of
minority group membership and slum
residence, but also by physical loss of parents
and having been born into a culture different
from the one in which their parents were
reared.
(2) Delinquency later preceded drug use.
(3) Use of drugs did not conceal a latent
psychotic condition.
(4) Ethnic differences did not lead to different
patterns of drug usage.
(5) Less difference between the urban heroin
and the chronically delinquent nonaddict.
Willis 1969 42 male and 16 female hos- (1) Both the U.S. and U.K. patients showed
pitalized inpatients admitted similar degrees of intrafamilial disturbance in E
to psychiatric hospital in terms of parental disharmony. Also a similar B
United Kingdom for treat- degree of overt familial psychiatric dis-
ment of diamorphine turbance including alcoholism in parents.
Z
addiction. (2) Extent of delinquent behavior under
W
35 male and 15 female dia- achievement at school and poor work m
morphine addicts in New records were similar. "R
York Hospital. (3) In U.K.,they chose drugs as a form of
100 controls. relief of turbulent feelings against a setting
of intrafamilial disturbance with negligible
socioeconomic deprivation.
(4) In U.S., personal pathology was set
clearly against a background of real material
deprivation and environmental influence
where delinquency and hopelessness seemed
omni present.
DRUG ABUSE, HOPELESSNESS, AND SUICIDAL BEHAVIOR 457
METHOD
Subjects
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
Procedure
Each patient in the study was seen by members of our research staff
within 48 hours of admission to the hospital. In a psychiatric interview, an
experienced clinician elicited information pertaining to the patient’s drug
use and also completed the Suicidal Intent Scale (SIS). The SIS is a 15-
item scale that evaluates the seriousness of the patient’s psychological
intent to kill himself. It assesses the circumstances surrounding the suicide
attempt and the patient’s postattempt description of his intentions and
expectations during the attempt. The SIS has an interrater reliability of .95
and has been consistently validated as a measure of the severity of intent
connected with a suicide attempt (Beck, Beck, and Kovacs, 1975; Beck,
Herman, and Schuyler, 1974; R. Beck, Morris and Beck, 1974). Each item
is coded on a three-point continuum from 0 to 2; thus the possible range of
scores is 0 to 30.
458 WEISSMAN, BECK, AND KOVACS
reported.
For the purposes of this study, patients who were judged to be
dependent on drugs were grouped together (n = 86) and compared with
Table 2
Demographic Characteristics of Drug Abusers and Nonabusers
Who Attempted Suicide (in percent)
Sex :
Male 39.5 40.9
Female 60.5 59.1
Race :
White 54.1 50.2
Nonwhite 45.3 49.8
Age l a
30 80.2 53.1
30-59 19.8 43.9
60+ 0.0 3 .O
Marital status:
Single 50.6 39.7
Married 8.2 19.9
Separated, divorced, widowed 30.6 35.4
Cohabitating 10.6 5.0
Last grade completed:
Grade school or less 12.8 15.2
High school 69.8 71.6
College or more 17.4 13.2
Employment status:
Unemployed, retired, housewife 16.5 71.9
Employed 16.4 21.8
Student 7.1 6.3
"Drug abusers were significantly younger than nonabusers, p < .001.
DRUG ABUSE, HOPELESSNESS, A N D SUICIDAL BEHAVIOR 459
Table 3
Mean Suicidal Intent Scores by Levels of Depression and Hopelessness
Sample
Drug abusers Nonabusers
Depression level :
Low 9.7 (n = 30) 11.6(n = 105)
Moderate 12.6 (n = 23) 14.0(n = 87)
High 15.5 (n = 33) 14.9 (n = 106)
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
Hopelessness level :
Low 8.9 (n = 28) 11.6(n = 97)
Moderate 13.6 (n = 22) 13.1 (n = 109)
High 15.2 (n = 36) 15.9 (n = 92)
R ESU LTS
Scores on the SIS constituted the dependent variable under exam-
ination. Two separate analyses were performed to test the relative contri-
butions of level of depression (BDI) and hopelessness (HS) in conjunction
with the drug abuse status of the patient to changes in suicidal intent
scores, Table 3 presents the mean SIS scores for abusers and nonabusers
by levels of depression and hopelessness.
Groupings into levels of depression and hopelessness (low, moderate,
and high) were accomplished by dividing the sample into three approx-
imately equal size groups, first according to the BDI and then according to
the HS score. The first 3 x 2 (Depression Level x Drug Abuse Status)
analysis of variance for unequal n’s revealed a highly significant effect due
to the level of depression (F = 19.30,p < .001). In this analysis the drug
abuse component accounted for practically none of the variance. In
addition, there was no significant interaction.
A similar 3 x 2 analysis was carried out with level of hopelessness as
the independent variable. The data analysis yielded a highly significant
hopelessness effect ( F = 20.05, p < .001),and again virtually no effect due
to either drug abuse or an interaction.
These results indicate that the severity of suicidal intent is not
dependent upon whether the patient is a drug abuser or nonabuser. From
460 WEISSMAN, BECK, AND KOVACS
these data, one may infer that among individuals who attempted suicide
only two of the examined variables, namely depression and hopelessness,
are significant determinants of degree of suicidal intent.
To obtain a further understanding of the power of the BDI and HS to
predict suicidal intent, the data were separately analyzed for the drug
abusers and nonabusers. The raw, multiple, and partial correlations of the
BDI and HS scores with SIS are shown in Table 4. Previous findings that
the BDI, HS, and SIS are significantly correlated were corroborated in
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
15% for the BDI taken alone. Thus, while from a statistical viewpoint the
HS was not a significantly better predictor of SIS than the BDI, the two
measures taken together produced no better predictions than the HS
alone.
The multiple correlation patterns for the nonabusers were similar to
those for the abusers. The HS scores were consistently better predictors of
the measure of suicidal intent than the BDI scores. In general, the data for
both drug abusers and nonabusers support the expectation that both
instruments (i.e., BDI and HS) account for complementary portions of the
Table 4
Correlations of Depression ( B D i ) and Hopelessness ( H S ) with Suicidal intent
r R (R2) Partial r
*p < .01.
**p < .001.
DRUG ABUSE, HOPELESSNESS, A N D SUICIDAL BEHAVIOR 46 1
DISCUSSION
The results of the present study provide some clarification of the
complex relationship between drug abuse and suicidal behavior. The data
obtained from a group of drug abusers and nonabusers who had at-
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
tempted suicide reveal that for both groups hopelessness rather than
depression accounts for a greater portion of variance of suicidal intent.
Moreover, the data indicate that among individuals hospitalized for
suicide attempts, drug abuse status does not appear to be a relevant
clinical variable vis-u-uis suicidal intent.
Hopelessness, defined in terms of negative expectancies, appears to be
the key determinant of suicidal intent for both drug abusers and non-
abusers. As indicated above, hopelessness has been demonstrated to be a
link between depression and suicidal behavior in previous clinical and
empirical studies of suicidal individuals. It is evident from the present
For personal use only.
substantially reduced, the therapist can deal with the problem of the
patient’s drug abuse.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
REFERENCES
For personal use only.
ACHTE, K.A.. LONNQUIST, J., and HILLBOM, E. Suicide of war brain-injured veterans.
Finn. Psychiatry pp. 231-239, 1970.
AMERICAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION. Diagnostic and Slatistical Manual oJ
Mental Disorders. 2nd ed., Washington, D.C., 1968.
BECK, A.T. Depression: Clinical, E.xperimental and Theoretical Aspects. New York: Hoeber,
1967. Republished as Depression: Causes and Treatment. Philadelphia: University of
Pennsylvania Press, 1972.
BECK, A.T., and BEAMESDERFER, A. Assessment of depression: The depression
inventory. In P. Pichot (ed.) Psychological Measurements in Psychopharmacology
(Modern Problems in Pharmacopsychiatry, Vol. 7). Basel: Karger, 1974.
BECK, A.T., BECK, R., and KOVACS, M. Classification of suicidal behaviors, I:
Quantifying intent and medical lethality. Am. J. Psychiatry 132: 285-287, 1975.
BECK, A.T., and GREENBERG, R.L. Cognitive therapy with depressed women. In V.
Franks and V. Burtle (eds.) Women and Therapy: New Psycholherapies,for a Changing
Society. New York: Brunner/Mazel, 1974, pp. 113-131.
BECK, A.T., HERMAN, I., and SCHUYLER, D. Development of suicidal intent scales. In
A. T. Beck, H. L. P. Resnik, and D. Lettieri (eds.) The Prediction oj’suicide. Bowie,
Maryland: Charles Press, 1974.
BECK, A.T., KOVACS, M., and WEISSMAN, A. Hopelessness and suicidal behavior: An
overview. J . Am. Med. Assoc. 234(11): 1146-1149, 1975.
BECK, A.T., WEISSMAN, A,, and KOVACS, M. Alcoholism, hopelessness, and suicidal
behavior. J . Stud. Alcohol 37(1): 66-77, 1976.
BECK. A.T., WEISSMAN, A., LESTER, D., and TREXLER, L. The measurement of
pessimism: The hopelessness scale. J . Consult. Clin. Psychol. 42: 861-865, 1974.
BECK, R., MORRIS, J., and BECK, A.T. Cross-validation of the suicidal intent scale.
P.Tychol. Rep. 34: 44-446, 1974.
464 WEISSMAN, BECK, A N D KOVACS
BLACHLY, P.H. The seduction threshold as a concept for prophylaxis of drug abuse. In P.
H. Blachly (ed.) Drug Abuse: Data and Debate. Springfield, Illinois: Thomas, 1970.
BLAKE, D.A., and DISTASIO, T . A comparison of level of anxiety, depression and
hostility with methadone plasma concentration in opioid-dependent patients receiving
methadone on a maintenance dosage schedule. In Proceedings qf the 5th National
Conference on Methudone Treatment. New York: NAPAN. 1973, pp. 1308-1315.
DeLEON, G., SKODOL, A,, and ROSENTHAL, M.S. Phoenix House: Changes in
psychopathological signs of resident drug addicts. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 28: 131-135,
1973.
FARBER, M.L. Theory qfsuicide. New York: Funk and Wagnalls, 1968.
Subst Use Misuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Osaka University on 10/28/14
FARBEROW, N.L. Bib1iograph.v on Suicide and Suicide Prevention (Public Health Service
Publication No. 1979). National Clearinghouse for Mental Health Information, 1969.
FRANK, J. The role of hope in psychotherapy. Int. J . Psychiatry 5: 383-395, 1968.
FREDERICK, C.J., RESNIK, H.L.P., and WITTLIN, B.J. Self-destructive aspects of hard
core addiction. Arch. Gen. Psychiarry 28: 579-585, 1973.
JAMES, I.P. Suicide and mortality .mongst heroin addicts in Britain. Br. J . Addict. 62:
391-398, 1967.
KOVACS, M., BECK, A.T., and WEISSMAN, A. Hopelessness: An indicator of suicidal
risk. Suicide 5(2): 98-103, 1975.
LESTER, D., and BECK, A.T. Suicidal intent, medical lethality of the suicide attempt and
components of depression. J . Clin. Psycho/. 31: 11-12, 1975.
For personal use only.
LITMAN. R.E., SHAFFER, M., and PECK, M.L. Suicidal behavior and methadone
treatment. In Proceedings ofrhe 4th National Conference on Methadone Treatment. New
York: NAPAN, 1972, pp. 483-485.
MENNINGER, K.A. Man Against Himself: New York: Harcourt Brace, 1938.
MINKOFF, K., BERGMAN, E., BECK, A.T., and BECK, R. Hopelessness, depression,
and attempted suicide. A m . J . Psychiatry 130: 455-459, 1973.
MORRIS, J.B., KOVACS, M., BECK, A.T., and WOLFFE, A. Notes toward a n epide-
miology of urban suicide. Compr. Psychiatry 15: 537-547, 1974.
O’DONNELL, J.A. A follow-up of narcotic addicts mortality, relapse and abstinence. Am.
J . Orthopsychiatrj) 34: 948-954, 1964.
PRESCOR, M.J., and SURGEON, P A . Suicide among hospitalized drug addicts. J . Nerv.
Ment. Dis. 91: 287-305, 1940.
RADO, S . The psychic effects of intoxicants: An attempt to evolve a psychcanalytical theory
of morbid cravings. Int. J . Psycho-Anal. 7: 1926.
RADO, S. The psychoanalysis of pharmacothymia (drug addiction). Psycl oanal. Q. 2: 1-23,
1933.
ROSEN, G. History in the study of suicide. Psychol. Med. 1: 267-285, 1971.
SHNEIDMAN, E.S. Suicide. Encyclopaedia Brirannica 21: 383-385, 1973.
VAILLANT, G.E. Twelve-year follow-up of New York narcotic addicts, 111: Some social
and psychiatric characteristics. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 15: 599-609, 1966.
WETZEL, R.D. Hopelessness, depression, and suicide intent. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 33:
1069-1073, 1976.
WILLIS, J.H. Drug dependence: Some demographic and psychiatric aspects in U.K. and
U.S. subjects. Br. J . Addict. 64: 135-146, 1969.
WURMSER, L. Methadone and the craving for narcotics: Observations of patients on
methadone maintenance in psychotherapy. In Proceedings of’the 4th National Con-
fiwnce on Methadone Treatment. New York, NAPAN, 1972, pp. 525-528.