Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BASED SANITATION
A Dissertation
Presented to the Faculty of the
Polytechnic University of the Philippines
Sta. Mesa, Manila
by
February 2022
TABLE OF CONTENTS
2
Chapter 1
The coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic has changed the way we do a lot of things
these days including how we shop for our groceries. Food and Agriculture Organization of
the United Nations [FAO] and World Health Organization [WHO] proposed that touching
food packages or containers contaminated with SARS-CoV-2 could transmit the virus to
the mouth, nose, or eyes. The infectious dose of most respiratory viruses is low; thus, the
handling or consumption of food products could represent a risk for infection (McCallum,
2020). While the risk of getting sick from contaminated groceries is low, the use of
preventive measures such as washing and sanitizing fresh produce surfaces and
groceries as well as the implementation of good personal hygiene reduces the risk of virus
transmission (Bosch, 2018). Sanitation has become one of the most essential parts of
community well-being since it preserves human health given the status quo and can
the eyes, mouth, or nose. Infected hands can also transport the virus from one surface to
another, allowing for an indirect transmission channel. There is no confirmed timeline how
long a COVID-19 virus survives on surfaces. However, most likely it behaves like other
coronaviruses. Studies show that coronaviruses can survive on surfaces for a few hours
3
According to the CDC, the virus that causes COVID-19, SARS-CoV-2, is an
encapsulated virus, meaning its genetic material is contained inside an outer layer
of proteins and lipids. The envelope includes features that allow the virus to bind to human
cells during infection. Like other encapsulated respiratory viruses, SARS-CoV-2 is easily
broken down and can quickly disintegrate when exposed to surfactants found in cleaning
solutions and under environmental conditions (2021). While this virus will easily break
down when exposed to surfactants, it can still survive on surfaces that are not disinfected.
During the pandemic, people are forced to stay at home to prevent the transmission of
viruses due to physical contact. However, people need to go outside to buy their
2021). Community locations other than health-care settings, including publicly accessible
2020). Just because individuals keep their distance from one another does not guarantee
they will not catch the virus. People are still vulnerable to secondary transmission.
Disinfecting items outside the home before bringing them inside can help lower the risk of
getting COVID-19. Groceries are the most common products that individuals bring home
from outside. The virus may dwell on the surface of groceries, putting the individuals in a
home at risk.
According to Kumar et al., this virus is capable of spreading from person to person.
Additionally, the virus is spread by tiny droplets in the air created when an infected
individual coughs, speaks, or sneezes. When a healthy person comes into contact or is in
4
close proximity to an infected individual or contaminated surfaces, he or she becomes
sick. He or she becomes infected by rubbing his or her eyes, nose, or mouth (2020). Due
to the vaccine’s limited availability thus far, it is only necessary to take substantial
steps to prevent the virus's spread once countries attempt to restart their economic
sanitizing/disinfecting the surfaces of products mainly bought from groceries and other
retailers.
Conceptual Framework
esi n i ation
sin co te
o osition o so t a e ation o anitation
o cts o ht in a a an a
ho seho esi n otot in sanitation
a o ho seho s sin the otot e
ith o inco e estin
o ho seho s i e ence et een coho ons tion
ith hi h inco e an a han a an a
sanitation an sanitation
o eo oce a to atic sanitation in sin the otot e
o cts o ht in a te s o
ho seho a ation an
a o ho seho s a coho
ith o inco e cons tion
o ho seho s
ith hi h inco e
ee ac
5
For the conceptual framework, an Input-Process-Output (IPO) model was used.
As shown in the model above, the study aims to identify the duration of sanitizing grocery
products and the amount of alcohol to be consumed using the device. These variables
highly depend on the performance of the device. To determine these, design simulation,
prototyping, and testing will be done. The composition and volume of products bought in
a household used were set as independent variables and will not be affected by the
became limited that made consumers to hoard or buy in bulk. One of the current issues
that come with this is the difficulty of sanitizing products that we purchase in bulk onto our
homes. Most of the current ways of sanitizing products are by manual spraying of alcohol
or rubbing alcohol with a wiper. These methods take so much effort and time.
The best way to address this issue is by coming up with a device that can sanitize
products without requiring too much time and effort. The researchers opted to design a
device that will disinfect grocery products in bulk. Grocery Products that are expected to
be put in the machine are packaged non-perishable items such as canned goods, noodles,
powdered milk, bottles of shampoo, etc. Items that are excluded in this study are:
vegetables, fruits, wet products like raw meat and fish, etc.
time. Items that on its own exceed more than x kgs such as: one or half a sack of rice.
The initial state of the products that are to be put in the machine is presumably dry, dusty
and unsanitized as it has been distributed from the manufacturer to the supermarket.
6
The study aims to answer the following question:
sanitizing grocery products using the device and manual hand sanitation?
Hypothesis
Hypotheses 1
The device is more time-efficient in sanitizing grocery products over manual sanitation.
Alternative Hypotheses
The device is less time-efficient in sanitizing grocery products over manual sanitation.
Hypotheses 2
The device consumes less alcohol content in sanitizing grocery products over manual
sanitation.
7
Alternative Hypotheses
The device consumes more alcohol content in sanitizing grocery products over manual
sanitation.
The findings of the study will benefit people that purchase grocery products (where
the presence of viruses and bacteria) particularly the novel COVID-19 virus, may transmit
due to close contact of products with other buyers. The study will also benefit the following
sectors:
a. Society. The spread of viruses and bacteria due to close contact with products that
we buy may decrease the population of the society. With proper care and
sanitization of tools and equipment, medical professionals will ensure the safety of
c. Other future researchers. This study provides analysis and treatment that can be
and conclusions. This study also provides cross-references that will give future
researchers broad information, data, and conclusions that will provide a guide for
8
Scope and Delimitations
The objective of this study is to create a machine that can help families
sanitize/disinfect goods bought in bulk efficiently and not too time consuming. This
study impacts all households that buy groceries at least once a month since there
are still restrictions on going outside due to the pandemic. Hence, the reason for
households buying goods in bulk instead of a shorter gap between purchases. The
design of the device is suited for the sanitation of many grocery products.
This study only focuses on the setting of a household where the large number of
grocery products will be sanitized using the device. Since the goods have been
manufactured and distributed throughout the country, it has been exposed to the
environment and through various people handling the distribution. An experimental type
of research is the most befitting for the main topic of this research as the researchers are
trying to implement a faster and efficient way of sanitizing goods that were bought in bulk.
Limitations
The goal of this research is to determine how Home Grocery Sanitizer - Alcohol
Base Sanitation may aid in the establishment of a development program. Our study has
certain limitations, and some of the findings must be taken with caution. Some limitations
of this study include the necessity for the product to be kept on surfaces for as short or
long period of time, depending on the type of disinfectant utilized as a reliable source. This
the machine. Moreover, this study will use an alcohol with x% concentration.
9
Chapter 2
the risk of infection for themselves or family members. For the past ten months, it has
been by far the most prominent issue. In recent months, economic worries have been
pushed aside by the dread of infecting other friends and family, as well as the inability to
The redrawing of the store, pandemic shopping has brought in broader aisles,
Severson's blog (2020). And consumers want these improvements to remain indefinitely.
In the Philippines, we've seen that several businesses feature an arrow indicating which
way the aisles are for. Stores created these to promote the pandemic's social distancing
guidelines.
10
According to the World Health Organization (2020), Coronaviruses need a live
animal or human host to multiply and survive and cannot multiply on the surface of food
packages. It is not necessary to disinfect food packaging materials, but hands should be
properly washed after handling food packages and before eating. But also, The handles
and trash bins should be placed outside the retail premises close to the trolley park for
customers to use.
Disinfection is the most important thing to do in order to stay hygienic and control
the spread of diseases. It involves the use of physical or chemical processes to eliminate
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), COVID-19 may remain viable for a
long time on surfaces. They also suggest that the best way to prevent the expansion of
Proper cleaning and disinfection processes are essential to keep everyone safe.
Professionals agree that cleaning and disinfection of surfaces are important elements of
disinfection is highly required not only in healthcare facilities but also in other
you are going to clean many things. Facilities like hospitals often use automated
11
the preferred method in many facilities because of its consistency and greater efficiency
pathogenic microorganisms. The spreading of the virus can be prevented by efficient and
automated methods of disinfecting surfaces which may be contaminated with the virus.
The most commonly used systems are the Aerosolized hydrogen peroxide system (AHP),
H2O2 vapor H2O2 vapor system, and Ultraviolet C radiation (UVC) system. Aerosolized
hydrogen peroxide (AHP) AHP systems deliver an aerosol of hydrogen peroxide. Aerosols
generally have small particle sizes that are injected into the room, followed by passive
aeration. Aeration is the process by which air is circulated through, mixed with or dissolved
in a liquid or substance. Significant reduction of bacteria has been shown using these
systems.
12
throughout an enclosed area (enclosure). Two systems using H2O2 vapor are available
environmental surfaces. Safety features include sensors that when detecting motion and
13
Automated disinfection systems have high accuracy because it works for the
also designed for ease of use which guarantees that the process is easy once initial
Since the coronavirus broke out and spread over the world, demand for hand
sanitizers has skyrocketed. Hand sanitizers are often applied by pressing a pump with
one's hand to squirt the sanitizer liquid. As a result, a large number of people come into
touch with the pump handle, increasing the danger of viral transmission. On the market,
several hand sanitizers are automatically pumped. However, because hand sanitizer
containers and pump mechanisms are only designed to work with other products from the
same manufacturer, consumers must also replace the liquid container if they replace the
hand sanitizer.
14
The automatic hand sanitizer device is expected to assist to contactless hand
disinfection in public places and virus infection prevention. The design of automatic hand
one’s han c ose to the evice senso an the han sanitize containe i e e
once. The system squirts a certain amount of hand sanitizer at all times, making it easy to
manage refills and replacement. It is feasible to prevent many people from coming into
contact with the pump handle, preventing the spread of the virus and making the use of
Nozzles are the core element that creates the mist. Misting nozzles spray liquid in
the form of tiny droplets. If the wrong nozzles are chosen, the desired sanitation process
won't be implemented. By forcing fluid through a very small orifice at high pressure
sufficient turbulence is created to atomise the spray into a fine fog. At lower pressures
15
The aperture being blocked is the limiting aspect for this approach of making a
mist. Because the small orifice is responsible for all of the mist formation, it has a very
small free passage, and any small pollutants in the fluid could produce a blockage. When
Most individuals nowadays are extremely concerned with the issue of preventing
the transmission of illnesses and viruses. Using simple tactics such as soap, a large range
of disinfectants have been introduced on the market today. Alcohol as a disinfectant has
several applications, most of which people may be unaware of, maybe due to their
other places. In reality, alcohol is recognized as a disinfectant for all purposes that may
cleansers, and the greatest part is that it is also very affordable. As the coronavirus
epidemic spreads over the world, it is critical that we maintain ourselves and others around
us healthy right now. To avoid the spread of COVID-19, a lot of people have loaded up on
hand sanitizer, disinfecting wipes, and other sanitizing supplies. However, as the virus
spreads throughout the months, we're reminded that not all treatments on the market are
equally effective.
hygiene since Ancient Egypt (Brazier, 2018). It is widely recognized as an important anti-
microbial product, and alternatives are simply not as effective or reliable. Because of
alcohol's incredible capacity to halt bacteria in their tracks, it is critical to read the label or
data sheet for any hand sanitizer before purchasing. It is quite simple to choose an
16
alternative without knowing if it will be as efficient as a high alcohol content solution, but
what is clear is that no option will be as reliable and widely trusted as alcohol gel, which
has been demonstrated to be safe and consistent. The Center for Disease Control and
hand sanitizer, whereas the World Health Organization (WHO) recommends 70 percent
(Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, 2021). According to advice and testing, alcohol
concentrations lower than this may not function as effectively and may only slow the
growth of viruses and bacteria rather than killing them. Because of "denaturation," medical
institutions place such a significant value on alcohol. This is the technical word for alcohol's
germ-killing action, which indicates that the alcohol transforms the bacterium from its
original condition. "Alcohol" compounds, such as ethyl alcohol or ethanol, can break down
microorganisms from the inside out. After interacting with the bacterium, the alcohol can
bond with the molecules that make up the membranes that cover the virus's insides and
make them more soluble in water. The membrane instantly begins to lose structural
integrity and collapses, allowing alcohol to enter the bacterium and alter proteins in the
water. This is how alcohol "denatures" or changes microorganisms. The entire molecule
will finally break down, indicating that the alcohol has effectively completed its task.
Many people believe that high-percentage alcohol solutions provide better germ
prevention. The assumption is that because alcohol is the primary active component in
are the most effective. Any composition that exceeds this amount may be much less
effective for a variety of reasons. Because pure alcohols are so volatile, it is difficult to
attain this contact duration on a surface because they dry up in seconds, whereas most
disinfection agents have a contact time of at least a minute. This indicates that bacteria or
17
germs aren't coming into touch with the disinfectant long enough to be killed ((Why 70
A research from the Universidad de Sao Paulo tested the usefulness and
effectiveness of 60-80 percent alcohol in the disinfection of semi-critical materials that had
been cleansed or not. Microorganisms were found in 104/282 (36.9%) effectiveness tests
and 23/92 (25.0%) efficacy tests after materials were cleaned with alcohol. In the field
experiments, disinfection was not accomplished for 74/218 (33.9 percent) of the goods
that had previously been cleaned and for 30/64 (46.9 percent) of the products that had not
ineffective in 11/30 (36.7 percent) and 12/62 (19.4 percent) of the goods, respectively.
- cannot be recommended for all health care products without limitation. Disinfection can
Grocery
Why people buy groceries in bulk? The most obvious benefit of purchasing food in
ahead can make all the difference. Buying in bulk is generally less expensive than
shopping in a regular mass supermarket since people are not paying for superfluous
packaging. Buying in bulk means people get nothing except the goods, which is pure and
Purchasing in bulk reduces the number of trips to the store. Bulk purchases not
only mean fewer emergency trips to the shop, but they can also mean fewer trips overall.
18
With enough goods on hand, it's easier to space out store visits, resulting in less
opportunities to spend money on impulse purchases and less fuel and mileage spent
traveling. Buying in bulk makes it easier to deal with unexpected situations. Having a
significant supply of essential hygiene and food on hand ensures that you are prepared
for the worst in an emergency. Many people keep bulk supplies as a precaution.
Social classes are defined as groups of people who are more or less
homogeneous and are ranked against one another in a social hierarchy. We usually find
similar values, lifestyles, interests, and behaviors in individuals belonging to the same
social class, even in very large groups. A sociologist named W. Lloyd Warner proposed
the most influential classification of American class structure in 1941. Warner identified six
lower, lower-lower.
patterns. Disparities arise as a result of their differing purchasing power, but this is not the
only factor. Some researchers believe that people's behavior and purchasing habits can
help them identify and belong to a social class. People do not always buy the same
products, choose the same types of vacations, watch the same TV shows, read the same
magazines, have the same hobbies, or visit the same types of retailers and stores, despite
19
According to research done by Rachel Pechey and Pablo Monsivais about
expenditures, the volume of the groceries purchased had a difference of little to none, and
the results of the study showed that the main factor that influenced the volume of grocery
or food purchased is the number of people in a household and not the social economic
status. It shows that higher occupational social class was significantly associated with
greater food expenditure, which was in turn associated with healthier purchasing.
lower percentages of energy from fruit and vegetables and higher percentages of energy
from less-healthy foods/beverages than households using high-price (and not low-price)
20
Research done by Simone A French analyzed household income differences in
food sources and food items purchased. Results of the research showed that the overall
pattern of results was virtually identical to that observed for the per person dollars spent
fruits and vegetables, sweets and snacks. Compared with lower income households,
higher income households purchased a smaller percent of their total beverage ounces as
sugar sweetened beverages and paid more per ounce for fruits and vegetables (French,
S. et al., 2018).
Higher income households spent more money on all types of foods from a wide
range of sources. Population-based surveys of individual intake show that lower income
is associated with a poorer quality diet. Individuals with lower income consume fewer fruits
21
and vegetables, a greater proportion of energy from fat, and less fiber compared to higher
income individuals. Data show that income disparities have a greater effect on dietary
It can be concluded that the difference in the amount of grocery expenditure per
household greatly depends on the number of people within the household and not on the
social economic status. Therefore, the researchers will use the average weight of
groceries bought per person to obtain data of the volume of groceries bought per
household.
22
Chapter 3
METHODOLOGY
Research Design
To provide a way of sanitizing grocery products at home with less effort is the main
goal of the study. The researchers designed a device that provides efficient sanitizing of
grocery products with minimal effort from the user. The idea behind it is to help consumers
avoid manual sanitizing of the products they purchase at the groceries or supermarket, for
it requires more effort and consumes most of their time. To prove that the device offers
better means of sanitizing grocery products, the duration of sanitation and amount of
alcohol consumed using both the device and manual sanitation were determined and
compared.
The device was designed to be lightweight and portable as possible for it was built
for households. As the skeleton of the device, galvanized steel tubes are used and
constructed forming a cube. Nozzles were mounted on the steel tubes and were properly
positioned to ensure that every part of each product will be sanitized. The grocery products
will be arranged on a grill-like platform located inside the device. Below that is a detachable
basin that will collect the remaining alcohol after the process. The device made use of a
funnel connected to an alcohol container where alcohol is being poured for supply. It also
uses a motor pump that distributes alcohol from the container to the nozzles. To start the
sanitation, a switch is located at the back of the device to open the nozzles. A tarpaulin
23
Materials and Equipment
Nozzle
This machine uses a nozzle that is fitted along the pipe fittings and functions as
the discharge point of alcohol to materials to be sanitized. It expands the alcohol flow to
produce a spray effect as it exits the pipe tubes. Nozzles shown in the figure below are
screwed and attached to pipe fittings in the top and middle along the body of tubes, also
shown below.
The figures below are the nozzle (left), pipe-fitting middle (middle) and pipe fitting top
(right).
Alcohol Container
The alcohol container will hold the solution that will be used to sanitize the different
items inside the device. It features a screw cap on top, where the container can be refilled,
with a hole for connecting the pump through a hose or tube. Furthermore, it will have labels
24
Pump
A small pump will be utilized to move the sanitizing solution from the alcohol bottle
to the pipes, which will subsequently come out of the device's nozzles. The upper portion
will be attached to the alcohol container, while the side opening will be connected to the
Frame
For the body of the machine, Galvanized steel is used. This is steel coated with a
thin layer of zinc, this coating protects the steel beneath it from rust. It is also resistant to
deterioration when exposed to the weather. It also stands up well against water — as long
as it is not salt water as it reacts to the zinc layer, corroding it. Galvanized steel is also
more ductile and easier to work with. In terms of economical, material and labor costs,
25
Body
For the cover of the pump compartment, a PVC-coated tent-cloth is used. This
material has a polyvinyl chloride coating on the exterior making it waterproof and also
weatherproof. There is no need to weather it prior to use unlike materials made from
cotton. To reduce the risk of condensation, the machine would be put in an open space
26
Platform
The basin of the machine whose function was to contain the alcohol consumed
after the disinfection process. It uses a slider to take the basin out of its frame to drain the
collected alcohol after usage. This component is fixed at the bottom of the machine.
The two figures below show the basin in its frame (left) and the basin taken out of
Basin
This component is located at the top of the basin where items subject to
disinfection will be placed on this platform. It will provide greater flow for alcohol to spray
the bottom parts of the items and increase movement for the consumed alcohol to go into
the basin. It also uses a slider to detach and attach the platform itself.
The two figures below show the platform in its frame (left) and the platform taken out of its
frame (right).
27
View of the Device
28
b. Figures of the skeleton device not enclosed with a body.
29
Dimension of the Device
30
Experimentation
This experiment aims to evaluate the alcohol consumption of the device when
Materials:
– Motor pump
– Grocery products
– Flow meter
3. Once all the grocery products is fully sanitized, check the reading on the flow
meter.
3. Check the alcohol bottle label and get the measurement from initial to final
consumption.
31
b. Difference in time consumed in manual sanitizing and sanitizing using the
presented device.
This experimentation aims to evaluate and determine the difference in terms of time
consumed during sanitation between manual sanitation and sanitation using the said
device.
Materials:
– Timer
– Alcohol
– Grocery products (2 sets with equal number of grocery products each set)
2. Start the timer, then place the grocery products and start the device.
1. With a spray bottle containing alcohol, manually sanitize the grocery products.
2. Using a timer, measure how long does it take to manually sanitize all the grocery
products.
4. Compare the collected data from the procedure A and procedure B to determine
32
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bosch, A., Gkogka, E., Le Guyader, F. S., Loisy-Hamon, F., Lee, A., van Lieshout, L., et
al. (2018). Foodborne viruses: detection, risk assessment, and control options in
cro.2018.06.001
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2021, April 5). Science Brief: SARS-CoV-2
ncov/more/science-and-research/surface-transmission.html.
from https://doh.gov.ph/COVID19/FAQs#:~:text=According%20to%20WHO%2C
%20there, %2C%20mouth%20or%20nose.
Kumar, D., Sonawane, U., Gohil, M. K., Pol, R., Patil, A. S., Mittal, R., & Agarwal, A. K.
https:// doi.org/10.1007/s41403-020-00138-2
ist.org/blog/articles/2020/apr/coronavirus-do-i-need-to-disinfect-my-groceries/
33
healthline.com/health-news/worried-about-contaminated-groceries-how-to-be-
safe
virus-live-on-food
Bedell, K., Buchaklian, A. H., & Perlman, S. (2016). Efficacy of an automated multiple
5(1), 1-10.
Boyer, R. R., & Chapman, B. (2020). COVID-19 FAQ for grocery stores: cleaning and
disinfection.
Brazier, Y. (2018, November 16). What was ancient Egyptian medicine like?
https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/323633
Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. (2021). QAs Hand sanitizer and COVID-19.
class/qa-consumers-hand-sanitizers-and-covid-19
French, S.A., Wall, M. & Mitchell, N.R. Household income differences in food sources and
34
food items purchased. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 7, 77 (2018).
https://doi.org/10.1186/1479-5868-7-77
https://www.disinfected.org/is-alcohol-a-good-disinfectant/
Lee, J., Lee, J.-Y., Cho, S.-M., Yoon, K.-C., Kim, Y. J., & Kim, K. G. (2020, July 31).
https://www.numerator.com/resources/blog/impact-covid-19-consumer-behavior
Otter, J. A., Yezli, S., Barbut, F., & Perl, T. M. (2020). An overview of automated room
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles-/PMC4910945/#bb0005
Ribeiro, M. M., Neumann, V. A., Padoveze, M. C., & Graziano, K. U. (2015). Efficacy and
https://doi.org/10.1590/0104-1169.0266.2611
Severson, K. (2020, September 8). 7 Ways the Pandemic Has Changed How We Shop
35
for Food. Retrieved from The New York Times:
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/09/08/dining/grocery-shopping-coronavirus.html
Tarka, P., & Nitsch-Osuch, A. (2020). No-touch automated disinfection system for
The Spray Nozzle People. (n.d.). Small orifice misting nozzles. Small orifice mist or fog
nozzles/fog-misting-nozzles/small-orifice
Why 70 Percent Alcohol Is A Better Disinfectant Than 95 Percent Alcohol. (2020, June
5 M XĒ https://bemoxe.com/blogs/news/why-70-alcohol-a-better-disinfectant-
than-95-alcohol-in-progress
World Health Organization. (2020, August 14). Coronavirus disease (COVID-19): Food
https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/coronavirus-
disease-covid-19-food-safety-and-
nutrition#:~:text=Yes%2C%20it%20is%20generally,food%20or%20food%20pack
aging.
36