Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Received 28 July 2004; received in revised form 21 January 2005; accepted 8 February 2005
Available online 10 May 2005
Abstract
In the present work several titanium alloys were evaluated as matrixes for diamond tools. The purpose is to find new metal matrixes
not containing cobalt or with the amount minimised. Due to the low expansion thermal coefficient of titanium, diamond composites were
produced by pressureless sintering, that means a relevant economic saving. The effect of different Ti–Ni ratio and of small aluminum and
cobalt additions on the mechanical properties of the alloys was investigated. The monolithic metal alloys and diamond composites were
characterized by density measurements. The structure was investigated by X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD), the microstructure by optical and
electron microscopy. Hardness as well as erosion tests were performed as mechanical characterization. The diamond retention capability and
the metal-diamond interface were evaluated by electron microscopy on the fracture surfaces of composites. Crack free composites, presenting
high relative density, were obtained. They show a strong diamond-metal interface. No graphitization evidence on diamond particles was
observed. Hardness value and an erosion resistance comparable with that of hot pressed cobalt was registered in some cases.
© 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction amond tools, while pure titanium was employed for diamond
grit coating [9]. In this study titanium was selected because
Cobalt powders are widely employed in the manufac- it is a carbide former and therefore it should form a strong
ture of metal matrix diamond tools designed for cutting and interface with diamond by a surface chemical reaction. In
drilling of hard rocks and concrete [1]. Due to high toxic- addition titanium has a low expansion thermal coefficient,
ity of cobalt, the exposure to metal powders or to metal dust so pressureless sintering can be applied, with a relevant eco-
during the cutting processes is particularly hazardous [2]. nomic saving. Finally its low elastic modulus can also be
So the main objective is to find new metal matrixes present- advantageous [10] and some intermetallic compounds con-
ing no toxic risk [3–5]. Chemical composition of the matrix taining titanium were recently claimed as high wear resis-
should be selected in order to obtain the diamond grains held tant materials [11]. Ni was added in order to decrease the
firmly by the matrix and to make the matrix abraded at a sintering temperature of the material, compared to commer-
rate compatible with the diamond breakdown [6–8]. In this cial titanium alloys. In fact the sintering temperature must
work three series of samples, presenting different chemical be lower than 1000◦ , in order to avoid diamond graphitiza-
composition, were prepared and characterized. The first se- tion.
ries include binary Ti–Ni alloys, the second series ternary
Ti–Ni–Co alloys and the third series ternary Ti–Ni–Al al-
loys. Titanium based alloys are not common matrixes for di- 2. Experimental procedure
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +39 0115644711; fax: +39 0115644699. Two types of samples were prepared for each series of
E-mail address: silvia.spriano@polito.it (S. Spriano). systems: the monolithic matrix and the diamond impreg-
0043-1648/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wear.2005.02.076
S. Spriano et al. / Wear 259 (2005) 1190–1196 1191
Table 2
Chemical composition and properties of the matrix samples
Series Sample code Composition (wt.%) Sintering time (min) Relative density (%) RB hardness
I A Ti90 Ni10 60 87 48
B Ti87 Ni13 60 89 79
C Ti72 Ni28 60 78 116
B1 Ti87 Ni13 15 78 72
B2 30 89 80
B3-(Ti-II) 60 89 79
Fig. 7. Diamond grits on the fracture surface of a composite (Ti87 Ni13 ma-
trix). Fig. 8. Erosion test data. All the samples were sintered for 60 min at 930 ◦ C.
Samples were ordered on X axis by considering their erosion rate at 20◦ .
number of diamond grits embedded on the fracture surface,
that is an evidence of the diamond retention capability of that of Co. A further refining of the sintering process might
the metal matrix. Similar observations were made on dia- possibly give higher relative density and still better results in
mond composites realized by using series II and series III ma- terms of erosion resistance.
trixes. No graphitization evidence on diamond particles was Among the binary components the best results are given by
observed the Ti87 Ni13 alloy (considering both erosion data at 20◦ and
90◦ ), in accordance with the results of the hardness and den-
sity tests. In the case of the Ti72 Ni28 sample the erosion rate
6. Erosion test at 90◦ shows a remarkable increment. SEM observations of
the worn surfaces confirmed that this sample behaves also at
The results of the erosion tests are shown in Fig. 8. Tests at 20◦ in more fragile way respect to the other samples (Fig. 9).
20◦ and 90◦ were performed in order to investigate the erosion This can be related to the high amount of intermetallic com-
mechanism, considering that vertical impact causes high ero- pound. This is also the case of the Co10 (Ti87 Ni13 ) alloy, which
sion in fragile materials, while ductile samples are faster worn present a similar worn surface morphology after tests at 20◦ .
away during tests at 20◦ . All the investigated samples show In Fig. 9 the worn surfaces of pure Co and F2-b sample were
an erosion rate at 20◦ higher than that at 90◦ , so it can be con- also reported. In these cases wear mechanism seams to be
cluded that none shows a really fragile fracture mechanism. pretty ductile and there is evidence of crawling of alumina
The Al5 (Ti87 Ni13 )95 alloy (F2b sample) obtained interesting particles. Some alumina particles inserted on the worn surface
good results, with an erosion speed only 20% higher than were found in the case of pure Co. The difference among F2-a
Fig. 9. SEM images of worn surfaces. (a) Pure Co (HP Co sample); (b) Al5 (Ti87 Ni13 )95 alloy (F2b sample); (c) Ti72 Ni28 (C sample).
1196 S. Spriano et al. / Wear 259 (2005) 1190–1196
and -b samples, can be related to the effect of the aluminium [3] R.G. Ojeda, M. Del Villar, P. Muro, I. Turriza, F. Castro, Densifi-
dissolution into the intermetallic compound. In the F2-a case cation of diamond tools with Co, Ni and Fe based metallic binders,
the worn surface reveals a slight more fragile mechanism. in: Proceedings of Powder Metals World Congress, 1998, p. 481.
[4] Y.-Z. Hsieh, S.-T. Lin, Diamond tool bits with iron alloys as the
binding matrices, Mat. Chem. Phys. 72 (2001) 121.
[5] M. DelVillar, P. Muro, J.M. Sanchez, I. Iturriza, F. Castro, Consol-
7. Conclusions idation of diamond tools using Cu–Co–Fe based alloys as metallic
binders, Powder Metall. 44 (2001) 82.
Binary Ti–Ni and ternary Ti–Co–Ni and Ti–Al–Ni alloys [6] J. Konstanty, Production and application of diamond tools, Int. PM
Direct. (2002–03) 45.
were sinterized and characterized in order to evaluate their [7] J. Konstanty, A. Romanski, H. Frydrych, Effect of mechanical prop-
performance as matrix for diamond tools. Free sintering of erties of the matrix on its diamond retention capacity and wear
elemental powders allows reactive sintering and equilibrium characteristics during sawing hard stone by means of diamond im-
condition is reached. A good compromise between high hard- pregnated tools, in: Proceedings of 2000 Powder Metallurgy World
ness, relative density and erosion resistance was found in Congress, Kyoto, November 12–16, 2000, pp. 1629–1632.
[8] O.M. Ivasishin, D.D. Savvakin, F. Froes, V.C. Mokson, Synthesis of
the case of a Ti–Al–Ni alloy. All the titanium based alloys alloy Ti–6Al–4V with low residual porosity by a powder metallurgy
explored show good diamond retention ability and a strong method, Powder Metall. Metal Ceram. 41 (7-8) (2002) 382–389.
interface with diamond grits, probably due to a chemical sur- [9] Y.H. Wang, J.B. Zang, M.Z. Wang, Y. Guan, Y.Z. Zheng, Properties
face reaction, as suggested by Ti presence on the diamond and applications of Ti-coated diamond grits, J. Mat. Proc. Tech. 129
grits protruding on fracture surfaces. (2002) 369.
[10] J. Konstanty, Diamond retention characteristics of PM processed ma-
trix materials, in: Proceedings of The Cobalt Conference, Guildford,
Surrey, UK, 2002.
Acknowledgements [11] M.R. Bateni, F. Ashrafizadeh, J.A. Szpunar, R.A.L. Drew, Improving
the tribological behavior of copper through novel Ti–Cu intermetallic
Pro.ba. Forni is acknowledged for the vacuum sintering coatings, Wear 253 (2002) 626.
[12] M. Igharo, J.V. Wood, Compaction and sintering phenomena in
furnace kindly supplied. Eurotungstene and DeBeers are ac- titanium-nickel shape memory alloys, Powder Metall. 28 (1985) 131.
knowledged for the material kindly supplied. [13] Metals handbook, ASM International, 1990.
[14] P.A. De Chalus, Eurotungstene introduces the NEXT step, Met. Pow-
der Rep. 53 (1998) 22.
[15] M. Bonneau, M. Moltenni, Wire manufacturing and free sintering
References with NEXT, Ind. Diam. Rev. 62 (2002) 263.
[16] T. Tanaka, Y. Isono, Influences of metal constituents to the charac-
[1] J.D. Dwan, Impact properties of diamond impregnated metal matri- teristics and grinding abilities of metal bonded diamond wheel, J.
ces, Ind. Diam. Rev. 63 (2003) 50. Mat. Proc. Tech. 63 (1997) 175.
[2] D. Lison, Human toxicity of cobalt-containing dust and experimental [17] A. Molinari, F. Marchetti, S. Gialanella, P. Scardi, A. Tiziani, Study
studies on the mechanism of interstitial lung disease (hard metal of the diamond-matrix interface in hot-pressed cobalt-based tools,
disease), Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 26 (1996) 585. Mat. Sci. Eng. A 130 (1990) 257.