Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Momlab Exp6 Group1 Sec04b
Momlab Exp6 Group1 Sec04b
: Mohammad Abdulhadi C
(ME0105493)
D
:
E
G(i)
Group No : 1
G(ii)
Section : H
4B
I
The six active gauges cemented onto the cylinder in various position to measure strain
which differs at various angles along the axis. Negative reading equates to compressive
strain, whilst positive reading equates to tensile strain.
2
Table of Content
3
Summary / Abstract
In this experiment, the thin cylinder was the main apparatus of study. Thin cylinder is an apparatus used to
measure and observe biaxial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder itself. The theory of this
experiment involves the complex and two-dimensional stress systems which represents the stress and strain
within the oil of the cylinder.
However, the main objective of this experiment is to identify the principle stress under different
conditions specifically open-ends and closed-ends. These configurations can be set using the handwheel.
The results of strain and pressure readings are obtained through the software of the computer. The
controlling variable is the cylinder pressure, a total of 6 readings were taken starting from 0.5 MN/m 2 to
2.5 MN/m2 of cylinder pressure.
For each reading, the direct hoop pressure, strain values of all active gauges are also being tabulated
and recorded into a table. This is essential for the calculation of Young’s Modulus of the cylinder,
longitudinal strain against Hoop strain, Poisson’s ratio, principal strains and finally both theoretical and
actual Mohr’s Circle values. It can be shown that this experiment clearly illustrates the difference between
open and close ends of the thin cylinder, showcasing the effect axial stress has on a fluid within a capsuled
container.
Objectives
The objectives of this lab experiment include:
- To understand how aluminium alloy 6063 behaves in a thin cylinder that has open-ends and
closed-ends condition.
- To find out the principle strains for both the conditions above.
- To calculate and compare theoretical Mohr’s Circle with the actual Mohr’s Circle value.
4
Theory
For our thin cylinder, value for H (hoop stress) and L (longitudinal stress) may be assumed reasonably
constant over the area due to its small ratio of wall thickness to internal diameter. With each equation
shown below:
pd
H = (1)
2t
pd
L = (2)
4t
Open-ends condition
The cylinder in this condition has no end constraint and therefore the longitudinal component of stress σL
will be zero, but there will be some strain in this direction due to Poisson effect. Considering an element
of material:
σH will cause strains of:-
H
H = 1 (3)
E
− H
and L = 1 (4)
E
These are the two principal strains. As can be seen from equation (17), in this condition εL will be
negative quantity, i.e. the cylinder in the longitudinal direction will be in compression.
Closed-ends condition
By constraining the ends, a longitudinal as well as circumferential stress will be imposed upon the cylinder.
Considering an element of material:
σH will cause strains of:-
H
H = (5)
E
H
and L = − (6)
E
5
L
and H = − (8)
E
The principal strains may be evaluated, and a Mohr Strain Circle constructed for each test condition.
From this circle the strain at any position relative to the principal axes may be determined.
Mohr’s Circle
A negative quantity equates to a compressive strain. A positive quantity equates to a tensile strain. The
strains obtained from the equations from open-ends and closed-ends can be used to construct the Mohr’s
Circle.
As shown in figure 1,
- OR is the maximum principal strain.
- OP is the minimum principal strain.
- Q is the center of the strain circle, this is determined by dividing 2 between the maximum and
minimum.
6
Equipment
For this experiment, the cylinder unit is the main apparatus and another computer linked to it with a
software that allows the thin cylinder to be monitored in the most accurate way possible. The model name
for our thin cylinder is SM1007. The adjustment screw can be used to modify the different end condition
either open-ends or closed-ends. The maximum allowable operating pressure of the pressure gauge is at
3.5MN/m2. Closing the return valve located at the outlet of the pump will allow pressure to be increased,
whilst the hand pump will increase pressure when being stimulated. By unscrewing the return valve, the
pressure is released.
The actual cylinder unit is located and rested on four dowels within the piston, it is being supported
by the outer frame and is located at an axial position by the locking screw and the hand wheel. Figure 1
and 2 illustrates the thin cylinder model and the software used on the computer to monitor the equipment.
7
Open-Ends Condition
To alter the condition of the cylinder to open-ends, the hand wheel is screw inwards, this causes the piston
distance from the end plate, whilst ensuring full load axially from the frame; this results to the removal of
longitudinal stress from the cylinder. Full transmission of axial load from the cylinder to frame is
maintained by the hardened steel rollers situated at the end of the locking screw and hand wheel. This is
illustrated in Figure 3.
Closed-Ends Condition
For closed-ends condition, the opposite is being performed. The handwheel is screw outwards, this causes
the piston to push towards the caps at the end plate by the pressurized oil within the cylinder; this
configuration causes a closed-ends condition within the thin cylinder. Hence, longitudinal stress is being
taken by the cylinder wall. This is illustrated in Figure 4.
8
Strain gauges
The six active gauges cemented onto the cylinder in various position to measure strain which differs at
various angles along the axis. Negative reading equates to compressive strain, whilst positive reading
equates to tensile strain. The readings are then multiplied with a gauge factor; this factor allows better
consistent result from strain gauges of different manufacturers.
9
Procedure
1) All appliances are first ensured to be switched on including the computer and the thin cylinder.
Pressure to the thin cylinder is also turned on.
2) Next, the software for the thin cylinder is turned on and time was given for connection of the
equipment to the computer.
Open-ends condition
3) To begin with open-ends condition, the hand wheel is first screwed inwards and the release valve
is unscrewed to release pressure within the cylinder.
4) After pressure is relieved, the release valve is screwed back and the button for calibration is hold
until the strain gauge readings become zero.
5) Furthermore, pressure is increased to 0.5 MN/m2 by using the pumping the handpump. A few
seconds is given to allow stabilization of the pressure and strain readings. After stabilizing, readings
of the strain gauges, cylinder pressure and hoop stress are being recorded.
6) Step 5 is repeated for 1.0 MN/m2, 1.5 MN/m2, 2.0 MN/m2, 2.25 MN/m2 and 2.5 MN/m2.
7) After completion, pressure is relieved with the release valve.
Closed-ends condition
8) For closed-ends condition, the handwheel is screwed outwards and the release valve is also
unscrewed to release the pressure within the cylinder.
9) Steps 4, 5 and 6 is repeated here.
10) Finally, ensure all electrical appliances are switched off and pressure to the thin cylinder is off.
10
Data and observations
11
7 2.50 33.33 511 -184 -16 169 336 520
Values from actual Mohr’s Circle
(at 3 MN.m-2) - -217 -9 200 405 -
Values from theoretical Mohr’s
Circle 580 -191 2 195 388 580
(at 3 MN.m-2)
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Hoop Strain (MN/m2)
12
Young’s Modulus is 65.6GPa according to Graph 1.
(Gradient of graph is 0.0656TPa)
The actual value of Young’s Modulus is 69GPa.
Percentage Error = (69-65.6)/(69) = 4.93%
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Longitudinal Strain
-50
-100
-150
y = -0.3564x + 3.8884
-200
Hoop Strain
13
3) Closed Ends Condition
From the graph the average experimental value of Young’s Modulus is obtained:-
69.0−69.6
% error = | | × 100 = 4.93%
69.0
L
− =
1
H 1
L − 205
− = = = 0.354
1
Therefore
H 1 579
14
3) Calculation of Principle Strains – ‘Open Ends Condition’
From equation (16):-
H
H =
1
E
Therefore
H 40.0MN / m 2
H = 1 = = 575
E 69.6GN / m 2
− H
L =
1
E
L
= -191 με (Gauge 2 )
1
Closed Ends:
1
H = ( H − L )
E
H =
L = 99με (Gauge 2 )
15
n = ( ( (99+484)/2 ) +( (484-99) /2 ) ) (cos 60)
− H
L =1
E
Where − = 0.354
Discussion
Answering questions from the lab manual
Open Ends Conditions
1. Plot a graph of Hoop Stress against Hoop Strain. Find the Young’s Modulus for the cylinder
material. Compare your result.
• refer Graph 1
2. Plot a Longitudinal Strain against Hoop Strain. Find the Poisson’s ratio for the cylinder material.
Compare your result.
• refer Graph 2
3. Draw the Mohr’s Circle at 3 MN/m2. Identify the Principle Strains for Open Ends Conditions.
16
Theoretical Principal Strain
Poisson’s Ratio = 0.33
Young’s Modulus = 69GN/m²
Hoop Stress at 3MN/m² = 40N/m²
𝜀𝐻𝑜 = 𝜎𝐻𝑜/𝐸
𝜀𝐿𝑜 = −𝑣𝜎𝐻𝑜/𝐸
Principal Strain Hoop = 40/69*109 = 5.7971*10-10
Principal Strain Longitudinal = -0.33 * 40/69*109 = -1.913*10-10
17
Closed Ends Conditions
1. Draw the Mohr’s Circle at 3 MN/m2. Identify the Principle Strains for Closed Ends Conditions.
18
For the open-ends part of the experiment, longitudinal strain does not exist directly, however longitudinal
stress can still be found from gauge 2 and this is due to hoop stress for causing such stress. Depending on
the positive or negative value of the strain, positive equates to tension, whilst negative equates to
compression. According to the graph of longitudinal and hoop strain, the measured gradient of the line is
partially similar to the ratio of Poisson, this indicates that compressive stress causes longitudinal strain.
Finally, it is seen that the Mohr’s circle can predict direct strain perfectly for both open-ends and closed-
ends experiments.
Example for engineering applications with regards to the thin cylinder experiment for both open-
ends and closed-ends experiment.
The thin cylinder experiment for both open ends condition and closed ends condition is an important way
to describe and visualize the behaviour of pressure of a fluid within a cylinder. This is applied in especially
manufacturing pressure cylinders like gas extinguishers, as the pressure within the vessel also contains
different loads from different angles, the experiment will be extremely useful for testing the pressure limits
of these appliances.
Discussion on report
The results and data collected and calculated showcases how theoretical Mohr’s Circle and Poisson’s ratio
can be a great indicator of the behaviour of the fluids under a pressurised vessel. However, there are many
possible errors throughout this analysis. The main one being human errors, as most of the calculations are
done manually, error in calculation maybe a huge problem which will undoubtedly impact the overall result
and the conclusion. Next, calibration error and overall machine error is another factor in providing wrong
results, this is especially true in older machines such as ours, it might be uncalibrated, and the readings
taken might be inaccurate especially if the fluid consists of impurities through its life within the cylinder.
That said, some of the errors such as parallax errors do not exist, this is because data collected is
directly sent into the computer through software. Allowing the process to not only be more accurate, but
faster and efficient. For the final results, the obtained Young's Modulus, E, is 69.6 GN/m2. The Young's
Modulus percentage error was determined to be 0.87 percent. The computed Poisson's Ratio is 0.354. The
Principal Strains for the 'open ends' condition are computed to be H = 579 and L = -205. Circumferential
stress and coupled stress were both recognized concepts.
19
Conclusion
In conclusion, all objectives were achieved in this experiment. The behaviour of the aluminium alloy has
been observed for both conditions, allowing better visualization for learning engineers like ourselves. Next,
the principle strains were better understood in both conditions. Finally, Mohr’s circle was successfully
calculated and compared between the theoretical Mohr’s Circle and the actual Mohr’s Circle. Again, the
collected results showed that the Young's Modulus, E, is 69.6 GN/m2 with percentage error only being
0.87 percent. The computed Poisson's Ratio is 0.354. The Principal Strains for the 'open ends' condition
are computed to be H = 579 and L = -205. Circumferential stress and coupled stress were both recognized
concepts.
References
1. James F. Shackelford. 2000. Materials Science For Engineers. 5th edition. Upper Saddle River,
New Jersey : Prentice – Hall, Inc.
2. William D. Callister, Jr..2000. Materials Science and Engineering – An Introduction. 5th edition.
New York : John Wiley & Sons, Inc..
3. Ferdinand P. Beer, E. Russell Johnston, Jr. John T. Dewolf. 2004. Mechanics of Materials. Third
Edition In SI Unit. McGraw Hill
20