Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Glenis Scadding
258
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Nitric oxide in the airways Scadding 259
Table 1 Uses of exhaled nitric oxide measurements Nasal nitric oxide has been reported as decreased in acute
eNO diagnostic use eNO other uses rhinosinusitis [30], nasal polyposis [31], primary ciliary
dyskinesia [32] and cystic fibrosis [33,34], and as normal
>20 ppb-asthma likely Level relates to asthma severity
<8 ppb-asthma unlikely Mild <30 >moderate or increased in allergic rhinitis [35–37]. In chronic rhi-
< severe >90 nosinusitis, Lindberg et al. [38] found lower nasal nitric
Intermediate values—perform level also relates to adherence oxide levels than in healthy controls; Arnal et al. [39]
a methacholine challenge and control
raised eNO predicts an found no significant difference.
FEV1 response to corticosteroid
eNO, exhaled nitric oxide; FEV1, forced expiratory rate in 1s.
Measurement of nasal nitric oxide
It is possible to measure gaseous nitric oxide by
sensitivity of 71% and a specificity of 93% for asthma chemiluminescence. Guidelines for FeNO and FnNO
relapse [27]. A large population study of 2200 adults has measurement have recently been produced [40].
shown that height, but not gender; asthma symptoms in
past month, reported use of inhaled steroids and atopy Stark et al. [41] suggested that the measurement should
were positively and independently associated with be made at the same time of day. Struben et al. [42]
FeNO, while there was a negative association with found no significant diurnal variation when examining
smoking. The median value was 16 ppb with a range the effect of aspiration flow on nasal nitric oxide concen-
from 2.4 to 199 ppb [28]. The uses of FeNO are sum- trations in air samples from one nostril, comparing FnNO
marized in Table 1. values and time to plateau in both nostrils with three
aspirations and assessing a short-term and long-term
Nasal nitric oxide from upper airway reproducibility. Mean FnNO at flows of 280 700 and
The situation in the upper respiratory tract is more 1200 ml per minute differed significantly (P < 0.01) at
complex. As in the lower airway, epithelial cells lining 854, 474, and 380 ppb. The plateau was reached more
the tract contain inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) slowly with the slower flow levels. The within-subject
and will form nitric oxide in response to inflammatory variability was always less than 5%. There was no differ-
stimuli (Fig. 1). In the sinuses, however, nitric oxide is ence in FnNO between left and right nostrils. FnNO
continually formed at levels around 20–25 parts per values after 6 h, 24 h and 7 days were not significantly
million (ppm), which are toxic to bacteria, viruses, fungi different. The measurement was reproducible, feasible,
and tumour cells and may form part of the upper airway and best with an aspiration flow of 700 ml/min.
defence. Theoretically, nasal nitric oxide (FnNO) levels
have been postulated to depend mainly on the amount of The production of nitric oxide by different sinuses and
nitric oxide produced by the ciliated epithelium of the the effect of intravenous arginine have been investigated
paranasal sinuses and the size of the paranasal sinus ostia in a volunteer [43]. Nitric oxide output in the nose was
[29]. largely unaffected by gaseous carbon dioxide; however,
production in the frontal and maxillary sinuses was pro-
Figure 1 The very different levels of nitric oxide in sinuses,
upper and lower airways
foundly inhibited by it. In both sinuses, suppression by
carbon dioxide was countered by oxygen. Alterations in
oxygen or carbon dioxide in the maxillary antrum did not
NO in respiratory tract alter nitric oxide output in the frontal sinus or vice versa.
After arginine, nasal nitric oxide output remained elev-
Continuous production ated for more than 1 h.
in sinuses
Inducible in airways
Humming has been shown to increase the passage of
nitric oxide from the sinuses into the nose [44]. The
phenomenon has been investigated using a syringe
model [45]. Computer modelling of this suggests that
alternating pressure in the nasal cavity forces the air plug
20–25 ppm
in the sinus resonators to vibrate, thus expelling from the
400–900 ppb cavity nitric oxide gas, which is trailed in the exhalatory
airstream. Humming has been suggested as a test of
<20 ppb patency of the ostiomeatal complex [44]; it improves
discrimination between healthy controls and children
with cystic fibrosis better than static nitric oxide measure-
Values given are the ranges from our laboratory using a Logan Sinclair
NO Analyser.
ments [46]. Sounding airflow during aerosol inhalation
increases drug deposition in sinuses [47]. Therapeutic
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
260 Allergy
effectiveness of continued humming in chronic rhino- nitric oxide in patients with PCD did not reach statistical
sinusitis has been suggested in a single case report [48]. significance [50]. Exhaled breath condensate [51] has
also been used as a means of nitric oxide measurement.
Nasal nitric oxide is reduced in sleep and may be This may aid diagnosis of PCD in neonates [52].
involved in sleep physiology [49].
FnNO and FeNO measurements may be useful in the
Diagnostic uses of nasal nitric oxide coughing child in whom asthma is suspected but not
The value of nasal nitric oxide measurements is not yet proven. In the presence of a normal FeNO and abnormal
clearly defined but very low levels (90% lower than in FnNO, my suggestion is that the upper respiratory tract
normal subjects) are consistently found in primary ciliary should be targeted for therapy and the lower respiratory
dyskinesia (PCD) in which condition the epithelial cells tract monitored.
lack iNOS (Fig. 2). In a recent study [50], nasal nitric
oxide was significantly lower in those children with Allergic rhinitis
proven PCD (geometric mean; 13.7 ppb), compared with Several studies have attempted to assess nasal nitric oxide
those who had negative biopsy results (132.7 ppb) and levels in allergic rhinitis, with differences in results.
healthy control subjects (223.7 ppb). The measurement Further investigation by studying airway nitric oxide in
of nasal nitric oxide in this study population showed, 18 patients with birch pollen allergic rhinitis during
below a cut-off level of less than 105 ppb, a specificity of seasonal exposure and 18 controls [53] showed that
88% for PCD, and positive predictive value of 89%. Nasal allergic rhinitis subjects were characterized by no differ-
nitric oxide above a cut-off level of 105 ppb excluded ence in nasal nitric oxide, but higher orally exhaled nitric
PCD with a 100% certainty. The lower levels of exhaled oxide and a larger interindividual spread in nasal and
orally exhaled nitric oxide compared with controls. There
Figure 2 Possible implications of abnormal nasal nitric oxide was a greater reduction in nasal nitric oxide after
levels L-NAME (an iNOS inhibitor) in patients compared with
controls. Nitric oxide production in the nasal mucosa of
patients with allergic rhinitis may be upregulated. On the
other hand, this increase could be counteracted by swel-
ling of the mucosa and secretions resulting in impaired
nitric oxide diffusion from, for example, the paranasal
sinuses, where particularly high levels of nitric oxide
have been found. Also, the high background levels of
nitric oxide from constitutive sources in the nose may
blunt smaller increases in mucosal nitric oxide output.
Methods for measurement of nasal nitric oxide need to be
improved and standardized before this test can be used in
monitoring inflammation in allergic rhinitis.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Nitric oxide in the airways Scadding 261
oxide correlated well with computed tomography the release of caspase-3, its activation and execution
changes, and the percentage rise in nasal nitric of apoptosis [63].
oxide seen on medical and surgical treatment of chronic
rhinosinusitis correlated with changes in symptom Inhibitors of iNOS are under development as treatment
scores, saccharine clearance time, endoscopic changes for inflammatory airways disorders. It is to be hoped that
(all P < 0.001), polyp grades (P < 0.05 at 6 months, iNOS inhibition is not detrimental to the defence of
P < 0.01 at 12 months) and surgical scores (P < 0.01). the airways.
There was no significant correlation with age, sex, smok-
ing or allergy. The authors suggested that nasal nitric Conclusion
oxide provides a valuable noninvasive objective measure Nitric oxide is a highly conserved molecule that is
of the response of chronic rhinosinusitis to therapy, of importance in many processes in the airways,
but that topical nasal corticosteroids may be needed both protective and inflammatory. Much remains to
to reduce the contribution of nasal epithelial nitric be elucidated about its functions and interactions. At
oxide and allow that emanating from the sinuses to be present, measurements of FeNO are of use in asthma
measured. diagnosis and therapy, and nasal nitric oxide monitoring
is helpful in the diagnosis of primary ciliary dyskinesia,
Treatment effects but may also prove valuable in chronic rhinosinusitis,
FnNO can be used to examine treatment effects. It has both in assessment of ostiomeatal patency and in asses-
been shown that topical nasal corticosteroids reduce sing outcomes. Therapeutic use of iNOS inhibitors
elevated FnNO in allergic rhinitis, but raise FnNO levels and nitric oxide donors is likely to increase under-
in nasal polyposis [31]. The combination of topical standing of the pathophysiology of nitric oxide and its
steroids to nose and chest was significantly better than metabolites.
montelukast and cetirizine in reducing FnNO and FeNO
[58]. Saline has been shown to cause vasoconstriction References and recommended reading
and reduce nitric oxide in the nose [59]. Papers of particular interest, published within the annual period of review, have
been highlighted as:
of special interest
Nitric oxide adjustment is also being tried therapeuti- of outstanding interest
Additional references related to this topic can also be found in the Current
cally. S-nitrosoglutathione which, like nitric oxide, is low World Literature section in this issue (p. 291).
in the cystic fibrosis airway, has been used in vitro on
1 Lundberg JO, Rinder J, Weitzberg E, et al. Nasally exhaled nitric oxide in
epithelia from patients with cystic fibrosis for patients humans originates mainly in the paranasal sinuses. Acta Physiol Scand 1994;
where it appears to have increased chloride flux [60]. The 152:431–432.
correlation between endogenous nitric oxide and ciliary 2 Lundberg JO, Farkas-Szallasi T, Weitzberg E, et al. High nitric oxide produc-
beating was explored by Alberty et al. [61] in an in-vitro tion in human paranasal sinuses. Nat Med 1995; 1:370–373.
3 Gaston B, Reilly J, Drazen JM, et al. Endogenous nitrogen oxides and
model using cultures of nasal mucosa. Blocking of bronchodilator S-nitrosothiols in human airways. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
the endogenous nitric oxide synthesis in TNF-alpha/ 1993; 90:10957–10961.
LPS-stimulated cultures reduced baseline ciliary beat 4 Liu SF, Crawley DE, Barnes PJ, Evans TW. Endothelium-derived relaxing
factor inhibits hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction in rats. Am Rev Respir Dis
frequency (CBF) by 10.6þ/2.1% (P < 0.05) but the 1991; 143:32–37.
effect of mechanical ciliostimulation on CBF remained 5 Martinez C, Cases E, Vila JM, et al. Influence of endothelial nitric oxide on
unchanged. They concluded that endogenous NO-depen- neurogenic contraction of human pulmonary arteries. Eur Respir J 1995;
8:1328–1332.
dent and Ca(2þ)-dependent mechanical stimulation of
6 Bai TR, Bramley AM. Effect of an inhibitor of nitric oxide synthase on neural
ciliary activity probably use independent intracellular relaxation of human bronchi. Am J Physiol 1993; 264 (5 Pt 1):L425–
signalling pathways. L430.
7 Belvisi MG, Stretton CD, Miura M, et al. Inhibitory NANC nerves in human
tracheal smooth muscle: a quest for the neurotransmitter. J Appl Physiol
The pathophysiological effects of nitric oxide are not yet 1992; 73:2505–2510.
fully understood. There appears to be an intimate link 8 Wei XQ, Charles IG, Smith A, et al. Altered immune responses in mice lacking
between nitric oxide production and the ability of cilia to inducible nitric oxide synthase. Nature 1995; 375:408–411.
beat, demonstrated above, in PCD and in the Ragab 9 Laubach VE, Shesely EG, Smithies O, Sherman PA. Mice lacking inducible
nitric oxide synthase are not resistant to lipopolysaccharide-induced death.
study. Recently [62], a decrease in maximal nitric oxide Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1995; 92:10688–10692.
output from conducting airways was associated with 10 Xie K, Fidler IJ. Therapy of cancer metastasis by activation of the inducible
limited airflow impairment in PCD. The recent discovery nitric oxide synthase. Cancer Metastasis Rev 1998; 17:55–75.
of a novel mechanism of nitric oxide modulation of 11 Lala PK. Significance of nitric oxide in carcinogenesis, tumor progression and
cancer therapy. Cancer Metastasis Rev 1998; 17:1–6.
apoptosis, in which human airway epithelial cells exposed 12 Jain B, Rubinstein I, Robbins RA, et al. Modulation of airway epithelial cell
to nitric oxide via a nitric oxide donor induce ceramide ciliary beat frequency by nitric oxide. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 1993;
191:83–88.
generation via ceramide synthase. This ceramide induc-
13 Runer T, Cervin A, Lindberg S, Uddman R. Nitric oxide is a regulator of
tion does not lead to apoptosis, however, unless acidic mucociliary activity in the upper respiratory tract. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
sphingomyelinase(aSMase) is knocked down, allowing 1998; 119:278–287.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
262 Allergy
14 Runer T, Lindberg S. Effects of nitric oxide on blood flow and mucociliary 38 Lindberg S, Cervin A, Runer T. Nitric oxide (NO) production in the upper
activity in the human nose. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1998; 107:40– airways is decreased in chronic sinusitis. Acta Otolaryngol 1997; 117:113–
46. 117.
15 Gerlach H, Rossaint R, Pappert D, Falke KJ. Time-course and dose-response 39 Arnal JF, Flores P, Rami J, et al. Nasal nitric oxide concentration in paranasal
of nitric oxide inhalation for systemic oxygenation and pulmonary hypertension sinus inflammatory diseases. Eur Respir J 1999; 13:307–312.
in patients with adult respiratory distress syndrome. Eur J Clin Invest 1993;
40 ATS/ERS Recommendations for Standardized Procedures for the Online and
23:499–502.
Offline measurement of Exhaled Lower Respiratory Nitric Oxide and Nasal
16 Puybasset L, Rouby JJ, Mourgeon E, et al. Inhaled nitric oxide in acute Nitric oxide, 2005. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2005; 171:912–930.
respiratory failure: dose-response curves. Intensive Care Med 1994; 20:
41 Stark H, Purokivi M, Kiviranta J, et al. Short-term and seasonal variations of
319–327.
exhaled and nasal NO in healthy subjects. Respir Med 2007; 101:265–271;
17 Beckman JS, Beckman TW, Chen J, et al. Apparent hydroxyl radical produc- Epub 2006 Jun 22.
tion by peroxynitrite: implications for endothelial injury from nitric oxide and
42 Struben VM, Wieringa MH, Mantingh CJ, et al. Nasal NO measurement by
superoxide. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1990; 87:1620–1624.
direct sampling from the nose during breathhold: Aspiration flow, nasal
18 Rubbo H, Radi R, Trujillo M, et al. Nitric oxide regulation of superoxide resistance and reproducibility. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2006; 263:723–
and peroxynitrite-dependent lipid peroxidation. Formation of novel nitrogen- 728; Epub 2006 May 19.
containing oxidized lipid derivatives. J Biol Chem 1994; 269:26066– Good background data on making accurate NO measurements.
26075.
43 Qian W, Makitie AA, Witterick I, Haight JS. A comparison between nitric oxide
19 Bove PF, van der Vliet A. Nitric oxide and reactive nitrogen species in airway output in the nose and sinuses: A pilot study in one volunteer. Acta Otolar-
epithelial signalling and inflammation. Free Radic Biol Med 2006; 41:515– yngol 2005; 125:1080–1085.
527; Epub 2006 May 26.
44 Maniscalco M, Weitzberg E, Sundberg J, et al. Assessment of nasal and sinus
20 Warke TJ, Mairs V, Fitch PS, et al. Exhaled nitric oxide in relation to the clinical nitric oxide output using single breath humming exhalations. Eur Respir J
features of childhood asthma. J Asthma 2004; 41:751–757. 2003; 22:323–329.
21 Berkman N, Avital A, Breuer R, et al. Exhaled nitric oxide in the diagnosis of 45 Granqvist S, Sundberg J, Lundberg JO, Weitzberg E. Paranasal sinus
asthma: comparison with bronchial provocation tests. Thorax 2005; 60:383– ventilation by humming. J Acoust Soc Am 2006; 119 (5 Pt 1):2611 –
388. 2617.
22 Warke TJ, Fitch PS, Brown V, et al. Exhaled nitric oxide correlates with airway 46 Struben VM, Sewbalak WV, Wieringa MH, et al. Nasal nitric oxide in cystic
eosinophils in childhood asthma. Thorax 2002; 57:383–387. fibrosis with and without humming. Eur J Clin Invest 2007; 37:140–144.
23 Batra J, Pratap Singh T, Mabalirajan U, et al. Association of inducible nitric A useful test for cystic fibrosis with improved differentiation from normal.
oxide synthase with asthma severity, total serum immunoglobulin E and blood 47 Maniscalco M, Sofia M, Weitzberg E, Lundberg JO. Sounding airflow en-
eosinophil levels. Thorax 2007; 62:16–22. hances aerosol delivery into the paranasal sinuses. Eur J Clin Invest 2006;
24 Smith AD, Cowan JO, Filsell S, et al. Diagnosing asthma. Comparisons 36:509–513.
between exhaled nitric oxide measurements and conventional tests. Am J This observation could be of use in chronic rhinosinusitis therapy.
Respir Crit Care Med 2004; 169:473–478. 48 Eby GA. Strong humming for one hour daily to terminate chronic rhinosinusitis
25 Smith AD, Cowan JO, Brassett KP, et al. Use of exhaled nitric oxide in four days: a case report and hypothesis for action by stimulation of
measurements to guide treatment in chronic asthma. New Engl J Med endogenous nasal nitric oxide production. Med Hypotheses 2006;
2005; 352:2163–2173. 66:851–854; Epub 2006 Jan 10.
26 Rabinovitch N, Zhang L, Gelfand EW. Elevated exhaled nitric oxide levels are 49 O’hearn DJ, Giraud GD, Sippel JM, et al. Exhaled nasal nitric oxide output is
associated with daily lung function declines and increased medication usage reduced in humans at night during the sleep period. Respir Physiol Neurobiol
in urban children with moderate to severe asthma despite use of inhaled 2007; 156:94–101; Epub 2006 Sep 14.
corticosteroids and long acting beta agonists. Poster at American Academy of Sleep is another area in which NO may be relevant and important.
Allergy, Asthma and Immunology, February 2007. 50 Corbelli R, Bringolf-Isler B, Amacher A, et al. Nasal nitric oxide measurements
27 Pijnenburg MW, Hofhuis W, Hop WC, de Jongste JC. Exhaled nitric to screen children for primary ciliary dyskinesia. Chest 2004; 126:1054–
oxide predicts asthma relapse in children with clinical asthma remission. 1059.
Thorax 2005; 60:215–218. 51 Silkoff PE, Erzurum SC, Lundberg JO, et al., American Thoracic Society; HOC
28 Olin A-C, Rosengren A, Thelle DS, et al. Height, age and atopy are associated Subcommittee of the Assembly on Allergy, Immunology, and Inflammation.
with fraction of exhaled nitric oxide in a large adult general population sample. ATS workshop proceedings: exhaled nitric oxide and nitric oxide oxidative
Chest 2006; 130:1319–1325. metabolism in exhaled breath condensate. Proc Am Thorac Soc 2006;
Basic population data on NO. 3:131–145.
Useful update on the uses of exhaled breath condensate as well as NO.
29 Persson MG, Zetterstrom O, Agrenius V, et al. Single-breath nitric oxide
measurements in asthmatic patients and smokers. Lancet 1994; 343:146– 52 Stehling F, Roll C, Ratjen F, Grasemann H. Nasal nitric oxide to diagnose
147. primary ciliary dyskinesia in newborns. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed
2006; 91:F233.
30 Baraldi E, Azzolin NM, Biban P, Zacchello F. Effect of antibiotic therapy on Early diagnosis is vital in primary ciliary dyskinesia so that physiotherapy can be
nasal nitric oxide concentration in children with acute sinusitis. Am J Respir instituted to protect the airways.
Crit Care Med 1997; 155:1680–1683.
53 Palm JP, Alving K, Lundberg JO. Characterization of airway nitric oxide in
31 Colantonio D, Brouillette L, Parikh A, Scadding GK. Paradoxical low nasal allergic rhinitis: the effect of intranasal administration of L-NAME. Allergy
nitric oxide in nasal polyposis. Clin Exp Allergy 2002; 32:698–701. 2003; 58:885–892.
32 Lundberg JO, Weitzberg E, Nordvall SL, et al. Primarily nasal origin of exhaled 54 Vass G, Huszar E, Augusztinovicz M, et al. The effect of allergic rhinitis on
nitric oxide and absence in Kartagener’s syndrome. Eur Respir J 1994; adenosine concentration in exhaled breath condensate. Clin Exp Allergy
7:1501–1504. 2006; 36:742–747.
33 Balfour-Lynn IM, Laverty A, Dinwiddie R. Reduced upper airway nitric oxide in 55 Korn S, Beier J, Heilmann C, et al. Discrepant nasal and bronchial nitric oxide
cystic fibrosis. Arch Dis Child 1996; 75:319–322. kinetics during early and late phase allergic reactions. Respir Med 2005;
34 Dotsch J, Demirakca S, Terbrack HG, et al. Airway nitric oxide in asthmatic 99:1595–1599; Epub 2005 Apr.
children and patients with cystic fibrosis. Eur Respir J 1996; 9:2537– 56 Stark HJ, Randell JT, Hirvonen MR, et al. The effects of Aspergillus fumigatus
2540. challenge on exhaled and nasal NO levels. Eur Respir J 2005; 26:887–
35 Kharitonov SA, Rajakulasingam K, O’Connor B, et al. Nasal nitric oxide is 893.
increased in patients with asthma and allergic rhinitis and may be modulated 57 Ragab SM, Lund VJ, Scadding G. Evaluation of the medical and surgical
by nasal glucocorticoids. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1997; 99 (1 Pt 1):58– treatment of chronic rhinosinusitis: a prospective, randomised, controlled trial.
64. Laryngoscope 2004; 114:923–930.
36 Martin U, Bryden K, Devoy M, Howarth P. Increased levels of exhaled nitric 58 Barnes ML, Menzies D, Fardon TC, et al. Combined mediator blockade or
oxide during nasal and oral breathing in subjects with seasonal rhinitis. topical steroid for treating the unified allergic airway. Allergy 2007; 62:73–
J Allergy Clin Immunol 1996; 97:768–772. 80.
37 Arnal JF, Didier A, Rami J, et al. Nasal nitric oxide is increased in allergic Montelukast relieves symptoms but fails to reduce NO. This may have implications
rhinitis. Clin Exp Allergy 1997; 27:358–362. for remodelling.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Nitric oxide in the airways Scadding 263
59 Lacroix JS. Somato-sympathetic vasoconstriction to intranasal fluid adminis- 62 Mahut B, Escudier E, de Blic J, et al. Impairment of nitric oxide output of
tration with consecutive decrease in nasal nitric oxide. Acta Physiol Scand conducting airways in primary ciliary dyskinesia. Pediatr Pulmonol 2006;
2003; 177:507–515. 41:158–163.
The impairment of NO output was less pronounced in the lower than in the upper
60 Servetnyk Z, Krjukova J, Gaston B, et al. Activation of chloride transport in
(nasal) respiratory tract in PCD.
CF airway epithelial cell lines and primary CF nasal epithelial cells by
S-nitrosoglutathione. Respir Res 2006; 7:124.
61 Alberty J, Stoll W, Rudack C. The effect of endogenous nitric oxide on 63 Castillo SS, Levy M, Wang C, et al. Nitric oxide-enhanced caspase-3 and
mechanical ciliostimulation of human nasal mucosa. Clin Exp Allergy 2006; acidic sphingomyelinase interaction: A novel mechanism by which airway
36:1254–1259. epithelial cells escape ceramide-induced apoptosis. Exp Cell Res 2007;
Further information on the link between NO and ciliary beating. 313:816–823.
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.