Professional Documents
Culture Documents
103–108
www.elsevier.comrlocaterpowtec
Received 1 November 1999; received in revised form 1 August 2000; accepted 4 September 2000
Abstract
This study compares the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller ŽBET. and Langmuir equations when applied to N2 adsorption isotherms at 77 K
on various carbon blacks and activated carbons. Adsorbent samples varied greatly in the degree of development of their surface area and
porosity. The activated carbons were more microporous and less mesoporous than the carbon blacks. The equations were applied up to
prp 0 s 0.20, 0.30, and 0.40. The values of the lineal correlation coefficient as a rule were above 0.990. From the derived BET Ž SBET .
and Langmuir Ž SL . surface areas, the conversion factor Ž a . of SL to SBET was calculated. The a mean value Ž a . and the standard
deviation coefficient Ž s . were also obtained. The N2 isotherms fit better to the Langmuir equation for the activated carbons and to the
BET equation for the carbon blacks. The factor a was markedly higher than the unit for all carbons. It increased significantly with
increasing prp 0 range. The a values were closer for each series of carbons, and larger for the carbon blacks than for the activated
carbons; in spite of the fact that the carbon blacks were more mesoporous. As shown by the a increments, the dependence of a on the
prp 0 range was less strong for the activated carbons for the two narrowest prp 0 ranges. The s values indicated that the influence of the
type of carbon on a was greater for the carbon blacks when fitting up to prp 0 s 0.30 or 0.40. q 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights
reserved.
0032-5910r01r$ - see front matter q 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 3 2 - 5 9 1 0 Ž 0 0 . 0 0 3 6 7 - 3
104 ´
V. Gomez-Serrano et al.r Powder Technology 116 (2001) 103–108
The series of carbon blacks used in this study was made From the adsorption isotherms, the micropore volume
X
up of eight carbons Žnotations are indicated in parentheses.: Ž Vmi . and mesopore volumes Ž Vme , Vme . were obtained.
X
Sterling V ŽSV., Vulcan 3 ŽV3., Vulcan 6 ŽV6., Black Also, the percentages of microporosity Ž Pmi , Pmi . and
X
Pearls 800 ŽBP800., Black Pearls 880 ŽBP880., Black mesoporosity, Pme , Pme were calculated. The resultant
Ž .
X X
Pearls 1000 ŽBP1000., Black Pearls 1300 ŽBP1300. and values of Vmi , Vme , Vme , Pmi , and Pmi are listed in Table 2.
Black Pearls 2000 ŽBP2000., provided kindly by Cabot in The mesopore volume and the mesoporosity percentage
Spain. These carbons were sized, the fraction of particles have been estimated at two prp 0 values, i.e., 0.40 and
with sizes smaller than 0.32 mm being chosen. The series 0.95. These prp 0 values are the upper prp 0 limit of
´
V. Gomez-Serrano et al.r Powder Technology 116 (2001) 103–108 105
Fig. 1. Adsorption isotherms for carbon blacks. Fig. 3. Adsorption isotherms for the activated carbons.
application of the BET and Langmuir equations in this The values of the pore volumes ŽTable 2. show that, in
study, as seen below, and the prp 0 at which the mesopore general, regardless of the prp 0 value at which the meso-
volume is usually derived from the adsorption isotherms, pore volume is obtained, the activated carbons are more
simply by reading the volume of gas adsorbed at prp 0 s microporous than the carbon blacks and that these carbons
0.95. Therefore, Vme represents the volume of mesopores are more mesoporous than the activated carbons. The
X
that take part in the adsorption process of N2 at prp 0 s highest Pmi Ž89.7. and Pmi Ž82.1. values correspond to NE
X X
0.40 and Vme is the mesopore volume actually present in and those of Pme Ž35.5. and Pme Ž87.0. to SV and V6 and
X
the adsorbents. Obviously, the values of Vmi , Vme and Vme to BP800, respectively. Allowing for the morphological
will be more or less close to the true values for the pore properties of carbon blacks, their mesoporosity may be
volumes depending on the degree of involvement of the originated in the voids being between primary particles
wider pores of the carbons in the adsorption of N2 at the within a secondary particle Ži.e., assemblage of particles
aforementioned prp 0 values. In this connection, it should termed aggregate. together with those between a secondary
be recalled here that the physical adsorption of gases, by particle and its neighbors w4x. The pore size will depend on
virtue of the enhanced interaction potential w4,22x, is as- the shape of the carbon black aggregates. These vary in
sumed to occur preferably in narrower pores. Also, the
external surface may contribute to the extent of N2 adsorp-
Table 2
tion. If so, the deviation of the estimated pore volumes
Pore volumes for the carbon blacks and activated carbonsa
should be greater for the less porous carbons. X X X
Carbon Vmi Vme Vme Pmi Pme Pmi Pme
Žcm3 gy1 .
SV 0.014 0.0077 0.05 64.5 35.5 21.9 78.1
V3 0.03 0.015 0.13 66.7 33.3 18.7 81.3
V6 0.04 0.022 0.21 64.5 35.5 16.0 84.0
BP800 0.09 0.037 0.56 70.9 29.1 13.8 86.2
BP880 0.09 0.040 0.60 69.2 30.8 13.0 87.0
BP1000 0.13 0.046 0.65 73.9 26.1 16.7 83.3
BP1300 0.21 0.073 0.64 74.2 25.8 24.7 75.3
BP2000 0.60 0.170 0.88 77.9 22.1 40.5 59.5
Table 3
Application of the BET and Langmuir equations to the N2 adsorption isotherms at 77 K for the carbons. Values for the lineal correlation coefficient Ž r .
Carbon Langmuir equation BET equation
prp 0 y 1 prp 0 y 2 prp 0 y 3 prp 0 y 1 prp 0 y 2 prp 0 y 3
SV 0.9966 0.9922 0.9858 0.9999 0.9999 0.9997
V3 0.9970 0.9923 0.9857 0.9999 0.9997 0.9997
V6 0.9980 0.9933 0.9880 0.9999 0.9999 0.9996
BP800 0.9982 0.9942 0.9895 0.9999 0.9998 0.9988
BP880 0.9981 0.9940 0.9889 0.9999 0.9999 0.9993
BP1000 0.9983 0.9954 0.9921 0.9999 0.9995 0.9981
BP1300 0.9990 0.9974 0.9935 0.9999 0.9996 0.9978
BP2000 0.9990 0.9976 0.9967 0.9999 0.9985 0.9947
shape from individual spheroidal particles that are found in the BET equation, it follows that the N2 isotherms fit very
some carbons to the more clustered and fibrous types that well to both equations. Their r value depends on the kind
are common in other carbons w23x. of carbonaceous materials and on the prp 0 range. Gener-
ally, it is noticeably larger either for the activated carbons
3.3. Surface areas ŽLangmuir equation. or for the carbon blacks ŽBET equa-
tion.. Furthermore, r as a rule undergoes a progressive
To estimate the surface area of the carbons, the BET decrease with increasing prp 0 range. For some carbons
and Langmuir equations have been applied to three gradu- ŽSV, V3 and V6, BET equation; NE, Langmuir equation.,
ally wider prp 0 ranges of the N2 isotherms. The upper however, the variation of r is of little significance. Notice
prp 0 limits for such ranges are 0.20 Ž prp 0 y 1., 0.30 that in the case of the Langmuir equation r increases
Ž prp 0 y 2., and 0.40 Ž prp 0 y 3.. Their choice was made slightly for NE, which is a typical microporous activated
by bearing in mind that the usual prp 0 range of applica- carbon.
tion of the BET equation is up to prp 0 s 0.30–0.35 w4–8x With regard to the values of S L and SBET ŽTable 4., it
and that for activated carbons this prp 0 value is lower is interesting to note first that both S L and S BET vary
w9,10x. From the calculated values of the lineal correlation greatly for carbons. For BP2000 and NE, particularly, the
coefficient Ž r, Table 3., which are commonly larger than degree of surface development is much larger than for the
0.990 for the Langmuir equation and larger than 0.999 for rest of carbons. Therefore, the carbons used in this study
Table 4
Calculated S BE T and S L values for three prp 0 ranges.a Values of the correlation parameter between S L and S BET
Carbon S L Žm2 gy1 .rSBET Žm2 gy1 . a p r p 0y1 a p r p 0y2 a p r p 0y3
0 0 0
prp y 1 prp y 2 prp y 3
SV 47r37 54r37 62r36 1.27 1.46 1.72
V3 103r80 120r80 134r79 1.29 1.50 1.70
V6 149r115 171r114 191r112 1.30 1.50 1.71
BP800 301r235 338r230 375r222 1.28 1.47 1.69
BP880 291r227 331r224 367r218 1.28 1.48 1.68
BP1000 423r331 470r320 514r306 1.28 1.47 1.68
BP1300 679r529 731r515 801r489 1.28 1.42 1.64
BP2000 1958r1543 2091r1465 2237r1335 1.27 1.43 1.68
not only may show marked differences in their porous axis, which are used in the graphical representations, for a
structure, as described above, but also in the extent of their given prp 0 value are only a function of the volume
surface area. Second, S L increases, whereas S BET usually adsorbed of N2 Žstp. and therefore of the total volume of
decreases, significantly as the prp 0 range increases. Ac- pores present in the carbon that participate actually in the
cordingly, the estimated values of S L and S BET are influ- absorption process of N2 at such a prp 0 value. Needless
enced in opposite direction by the prp 0 range, which to say, the degree of conformity influences the values of
must also be stressed here. slope and intercept for the straight lines of the BET and
To facilitate the comparison of SL and S BET , the sur- Langmuir plots and, hence, the calculated values of SL and
face area ratio a s S LrSBET is used. Thus, the value of S BET and as a last resort of a . Owing to these facts,
this conversion factor indicates the degree of deviation of perhaps it would be interesting to further investigate the
S L from SBET . From the above SBET and SL values, a has extent to which a hypothetical variation of the pore size
been first calculated for the various carbons at the three distribution for a few selected carbons would affect a .
prp 0 ranges. Then, the a mean value a and the standard However, such a study falls outside the scope of the
deviation coefficient Ž s . have been obtained separately for present treatment.
the carbon blacks and for the activated carbons. The s As shown in Table 4, the a values are larger than unit,
value gives one idea of the influence of the type of carbon in particular for the carbon blacks. This is so in spite of the
on a . Table 4 lists the resultant values of a , whereas fact that for these carbons the adsorption mechanism of N2
those for a and s are set out in Table 5. Žin the mesopores, at least. should be monolayerrmulti-
For the three prp 0 ranges, the values of a ŽTable 4. layer and the Langmuir adsorption model should then be
are usually closer for the carbons belonging to each series followed more closely than for the activated carbons. The
of carbonaceous materials. This fact is important as such worse fitting of the adsorption data to the Langmuir equa-
carbons may differ greatly from the degree of development tion for the carbon blacks must contribute to the existing
of their microporosity and mesoporosity. As the best illus- discrepancy between the a values for both kinds of car-
trative example, notice the values of the pore volumes and bonaceous materials. It is corroborated with the results
porosity percentages for the couple SV and BP2000 ŽTable obtained for BP1300 and BP2000. For this couple of
X
2.. A more marked influence of Vmi on a p r p 0y1 and of carbons, both Pmi and Pmi ŽTable 2. are higher than for
Vme on a p r p 0y3 was expected. However, a correlation the remaining carbon blacks, the r values in the case of
between a and the pore volumes is not observed at all. the Langmuir equation ŽTable 3. are comparable to those
Neither is it found with respect to Pmi or Pme . Accord- for the activated carbons, and the a values Žfor two prp 0
ingly, it is clear that the structural parameter of the carbons ranges, at least; Table 4. are lower than for the other
that plays the essential role in connection with the magni- carbon blacks.
tude of a is not their pore volumes in the ranges of From the a values ŽTable 5., by comparing the a
micropores and small size mesopores Ži.e., the pores that increments Ž D a s a p r p 0yn y a p r p 0yny1 , with n s 2 and
participate in the adsorption process of N2 at prp 0 values 3., it can be deduced that a depends on the kind of
up to 0.10 and between 0.10 and 0.40, respectively.. Since carbonaceous materials and on the prp 0 range. Thus, the
the shape of the N2 isotherms ŽFigs. 1–3. is more similar D a values are rather close Ž0.19 and 0.22. for the carbon
for each series of carbons and as SL and S BET were blacks and significantly different Ž0.14 and 0.20. for the
obtained from such isotherms by applying the BET and activated carbons. For these carbons, also, the variation of
Langmuir equations within a particular prp 0 range, it is D a with the prp 0 range is less marked Ž D a s 0.14. in
evident that the a value is determined by the pore size the case of the two narrowest prp 0 ranges. Accordingly,
distribution of the carbons in such a prp 0 range. That is the a dependence on the prp 0 range is less strong when
to say, the a value depends on the variation of the volume the upper prp 0 limit is F 0.30. On the other hand, the
of pores Ži.e., it is dealt with an accumulative pore volume. higher s values ŽTable 5. that arise for the carbon blacks
with their size. for prp 0 y 2 and prp 0 y 3 denote a greater influence of
The pore size distribution of the carbons is also the the type of carbon on the a value. For the activated
responsible factor for the degree of conformity of the BET carbons, s presents the same value irrespective of the
and Langmuir equations. Thus, the values of the ordinate prp 0 range, and therefore the influence of the type of
carbon on a is similar for the three prp 0 ranges.
The above findings are really remarkable. This is so
Table 5
Values of a and s
mainly allowing for the widespread use of the BET and
Langmuir equations, together with the Dubinin–
Carbons a p r p 0y1 a p r p 0y2 a p r p 0y3 sp r p 0y1 sp r p 0y2 sp r p 0y3
Radushkevich equation w26x, in studies of the adsorption
Carbon 1.28 1.47 1.69 "0.01 "0.03 "0.02 process and in the structural characterization of solids. In
blacks
Activated 1.25 1.39 1.59 "0.01 "0.01 "0.01
particular, the relative magnitude of a for the two series
carbons of carbons is worth noting. It has been reported previously
w4x that a number of arguments suggest that for microp-
108 ´
V. Gomez-Serrano et al.r Powder Technology 116 (2001) 103–108