Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L E A D E R S H I P
OCTOBER 2008
Passion
and Purpose
Authentic
Leaders
Learn the Art of
Collaboration
Howard M. Guttman
Leadership Consultant Accepting Feedback
“Leadership Excellence is an exceptional
way to learn and then apply the best and
Take Three Actions
latest ideas in the field of leadership.”
—WARREN BENNIS, AUTHOR AND
USC PROFESSOR OF MANAGEMENT
w w w . L e a d e r E x c e l . c o m
© Greg Kinch
Excellence
L E A D E R S H I P
Make a Splash
Like these wild horses, leaders of charisma and character make a splash in the streams they
cross. Their exhilaration is contagious, their spirit indomitable, their soul joyous, as they
stretch their muscles, exercise their hearts and minds, make tracks, and leap gaps.
Editorial Purpose:
Use these to develop authentic leaders. Our mission is to promote personal and organi-
zational leadership based on constructive values,
sound ethics, and timeless principles.
W HO NEEDS LEADERSHIP
development (LD)? All
who aspire to leadership (aspi-
Use it to create a new LD program or improve
your current LD plan, program, or process.
A—Assess: Decide on meanings and
Corporate Bulk Rates (to same address)
US $190 each per year for 5 to 25
US $99 each per year for 26 and up
* Ask about logo and custom editions and
rants); all “high-potentials” (hi-pos); all who design a graphic LD model. foreign bulk rates.
are newly chosen, called on, assigned, hired, B—Birth: Create an effective LD plan, Article Reprints:
promoted, or elected to lead (new leaders); program and/or process. For reprints of 100 or more, please contact the
editorial department at 801-375-4060 or email
and all who are now leading (practitioners). C—Cultivate: Continue development by custserv@eep.com. Back Issues: (print) US
Why? Without effective, on-going LD, creating a sustainable performance culture. $25.00. Permission PDF US: $50.
your leadership tends to wilt—away from Even the best LD program won’t deliver Internet Address: www.eep.com
the ideal of authentic and accountable lead- desired results if it is seen as a Band-aid on
Submissions & Correspondence:
ers who serve as responsible stewards of the a broken culture characterized by counter- All correspondence, articles, letters, and
greatest good for all stakeholders—and tilt feit leadership at the top and at the core. requests to reprint articles should be sent to:
Editorial Department, Executive Excellence,
toward self-serving counterfeit leaders. This template is designed to trigger your 1806 North 1120 West, Provo, Utah 84604;
Once you recognize the need for effective best ideas and plans for developing leaders 801-375-4060, or editorial@eep.com.
LD, the question becomes: How can you best who best fit and function in your culture Customer Service/Circulation:
develop leaders for your team or organization? and get the results you most desire. For information on products and services call
1-877-250-1983 or email: custserv@eep.com.
In many places, this is a multi-million-dollar Use the 7P LeaderMeter to monitor, test,
question—and, given the immense invest- or spot-check your leadership practice. Executive Excellence Publishing:
Ken Shelton, CEO, Editor-in-Chief
ment, the stakes are high for desirable ROI. Access these LD templates, tools, at Scott Spjut, Asst. Editor
Sarah Hayes, Circulation Manager
We offer the ABC Template and LeaderMeter www.LeaderExcel.com, along with our Nancy Low, Marketing Manager
Tests to assist you in attracting, developing, annual ranking of top LD programs and Rob Kennedy, Business Manager
and testing authentic leaders for your team. practitioners. LE
Contributing Editors:
Chip Bell, Warren Bennis, Dianna Booher,
Small to midsize organizations 23. Goldcorp 11. Conference Board 15. Lebow Company Kevin Cashman, Marshall Goldsmith, Howard
1. Triage Consulting Group 24. UBS 12. Berkana Institute 16. Liminal Group Guttman, Jim Kouzes, Jim Loehr, Tom Peters,
2. Badger Mining 25. Black & Decker 13. Leader to Leader Institute 17. Benchmark Communications Norm Smallwood
3. Carnival Cruise Lines 26. Archer Daniels Midlalnd 14. CAEL 18. Table Group
4. Wieland (Homes) University 27. Textron 15. Baptist Leadership Institute 19. Chip Bell Group The table of contents art is a detail from
Splash (image cropped) © Bonnie Marris,
5. Americredit Financial Services 28. Amazon 16. SoL 20. Leadership Challenge/KP
and is courtesy of the artist and art print pub-
6. Container Store 29. Disney 17. Healthcare Businesswomen Assoc. 21. Authentic Leadership Institute lisher Greenwich Workshop.
7. Equity Residential 30. Medco 18. Addison Avenue Fed. Credit Union 22. Leadership Development Services
8. Johnson Controls 19. Rush University Medical Center 23. iLeadUSA For additional information on artwork by
9. Carilion Health System Education/universities/schools of 20. Best Practices in Leadership Devel. 26. Arneson Consulting Bonnie Marris, please contact:
10. InsureMe management and business 27. Sensei International Greenwich Workshop
11. Analytical Graphics 1. Univ. of Michigan/Ross Government/military 28. Right Management 151 Main Street
12. Simonton Windows 2. Center for Public Leadership, JFK 1. Defense Acquisition University 29. ISB Global Saymour, CT 06483
13. Acuity School of Government, Harvard 2. U.S. Marine Academy 30. The Prosen Center 1-800-243-4246
www.greenwichworkshop.com
14. Vulcan Materials Co. 3. Univ. of Chicago/GSB/Leadership 3. U.S. Air Force Academy
15. Genecor International 4. UCLA/Anderson 4. U.S. Army/Westpoint Large consulting groups Full view of table of contents art.
16. Saltwater Institute 5. USC/Marshall/CEO 5. FBI Academy 1. Linkage/GILD
17. Conway Transportation 6. Northwestern/Kellogg 6. U.S. Navy Naval Academy 2. Results-Based Leadership
18. Cross-Country Healthcare 7. Pennsylvania/Wharton 7. NASA/Leadership Alchemy 3. Accenture
8. MIT/Sloan 8. U.S. Army Rangers 4. Center for Creative Leadership
Large organizations 9. Harvard Business/True North 9. ASQ Baldrige Award 5. Senn-Delaney Leadership
1. Ritz-Carlton Hotels 10. Utah Valley Univ./CAL 10. U.S. Coast Guard 6. McKinsey/Leadership
2. General Electric 11. Duke/Fuqua 11. FAA 7. HSM/World Business Forum
3. Procter & Gamble 12. Yale Leadership Institute 12. U.S. National Guard 8. Vital Smarts
4. Boeing 13. Stanford/GSB Leadership 13. National Defense University 9. DDI
5. General Motors University 14. Emory Univ. 14. U.S. Tactical/Seals 10. Lee Hecht Harrison
6. Wachovia Corp. 15. BYU/Marriott/Leadership 15. Naval Undersea Warfare Center 11. Adizes Institute
7. Fed Ex/ELI 16. Pepperdine/Graziadio/SBM 12. Richard Chang Assoc.
8. McDonald’s/HU 17. Carnegie Mellon/Tepper/Leadership Consultants/trainers/coaches 13. Dialogos Copyright © 2008 Executive Excellence Publishing.
No part of this publication may be reproduced or
9. Microsoft 18. Alliant/MGSM 1. Zenger/Folkman 14. Booz Allen Hamilton
transmitted without written permission from the
10. Qualcomm 20. Ball State Univ./Ed. Leadership 2. Goldsmith/Katzenbach Partners 15. Hewitt/Leadership publisher. Quotations must be credited.
11. Yahoo 3. Korn/Ferry/Leadersource 16. Plante & Moran
12. Caterpillar University Non-profit organizations 4. Jim Collins 17. BlessingWhite Cover wrap photography: © Greg Kinch
13. Chevron 1. ASTD 5. Bluepoint Leadership 18. Franklin-Covey
14. AXA Equitable 2. SHRM 6. Ninth House 19. Ken Blanchard Companies
15. Farmer’s Insurance 3. American Management Assoc. (AMA) 7. Human Performance Institute 20. Integro Leadership Institute
16. MasterCard 4. HCI 8. Synthesis/Leaders Toolbox 21. Forum Leadership Development
17. Northrop Grumman 5. NYC Leadership Academy 9. Marcus Buckingham Company 22. Personnel Decisions Intl. (PDI)
18. Direct Energy 6. ISPI 10. Tom Peters Company 23. Human Potential Project
19. Schwan Food Company 7. HR.Com 11. Guttman Dev. Strategies 24. Crowe Horwath
20. Allied Barton 8. IQPC/Corporate University 12. Strategos 25. International Leadership Assoc.
21. AmTrust Bank 9. National Management Assoc. (NMA) 13. Maxcomm 26. Leadergrow
22. Bank of New York Mellon 10. Manchester Bidwell 14. Josh Bersin & Assoc. 27. Kepner-Tregoe
2 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
LEADERSHIP LEGACY • Collaboration. Today’s problems—
poverty, health care, education, energy,
environment, and peace—are too com-
Find Your True North plex for any single leader or organiza-
tion to solve. They must be addressed
Authentic leaders experience crucibles. through collaboration—bringing peo-
ple together who have the combined
capabilities to resolve the problems.
by Bill George beliefs. They get caught up in their egos The leader’s job is to align people
and external gratifications. But, as Peter around a common mission and values,
Drucker once wrote, “Leadership is not to empower them to lead, to act as a
I CHALLENGE YOU TO
think about your
leadership and your
about money, fame and power; leader- servant leader, and to collaborate with
ship is responsibility.” others to solve difficult problems.
calling to use your leadership gifts to 21st Centur y Leaders True North Crucibles
make the world a better place and to We need authentic leaders who accept What defines authentic leaders are
help develop leaders of the future. the calling to lead and follow their True their life stories where they find their
I’ve felt a sense of calling to develop North without deviating from their calling and passion to lead. Think
my gifts, but I struggled for years to beliefs and values. In the 20th century, about your own life story. Where do
discern the difference between God’s people looked to powerful leaders with you find your calling to lead?
calling and my ego desires and to find legions of followers, whom they trust- Most authentic leaders report hav-
the right place to devote my energies. ed and gave their loyalty. Too often, ing life-transforming events (crucibles)
When I decided I would be most these leaders betrayed our trust. that bring them to the meaning of their
effective as a leader in business, I cre- Today, leaders must be different. lives, challenge their beliefs, and
ated two goals: 1) to be a values-cen- Knowledge workers often know more enable them to find their calling. For
tered leader of a major corporation; than their bosses. They want to step up many, the crucible occurs early in life,
and 2) to influence others to bring a and lead now, not wait for 10 or 20 but they don’t understand its meaning
values-centered approach to business. years. I was division presi- or purpose until years later.
When I left Medtronic in 2002, I dent at 27 years old. If • Howard Schultz, founder
recognized I had done well with the young people don’t get of Starbucks, found his
first goal, but had little influence on opportunities, they’ll likely calling growing up with
other leaders. Now, I’m devoting move on. Trust and loyalty crime and poverty in the
myself to developing future leaders. must be earned, as people Brooklyn Housing Projects.
Are you doing all you can to devel- seek meaning in their work. After his father’s death,
op your God-given gifts as a leader, to At Medtronic, our mis- Howard wanted to create a
be true to His calling—not your sion was “to restore people company his father would
desires—to make a positive impact? to full life and health.” The be proud to work at, where
For the past decade, we’ve had a best event of the year was all employees have health
leadership crisis. Since many leaders the holiday party when six care and ensure their cus-
failed in their responsibilities and patients shared their stories about how tomers have good experiences.
destroyed or damaged their organiza- a Medtronic product blessed their lives. • Marilyn Nelson, chairman of Carlson
tions, we have lost trust in our leaders You can create more meaning in any Companies, discovered her calling in
and confidence in our institutions, work. David Dillon, CEO of Kroger, the wake of her daughter’s death at
causing many people to ask, “Where says, “When employees deliver kind- age 19. She decided to use the time her
have all the leaders gone?” There is no ness, they feel better about their work.” daughter didn’t have to make the
shortage of leaders—many outstand- world better for everyone and to use
ing leaders are just waiting to be New Definition of Leadership her gifts to empower people through-
asked to step up and lead. I propose a new definition of leader- out her far-flung global organization.
You have been given leadership ship, based in four words: • Oprah Winfrey grew up in the South,
gifts and called to use them. Are you • Align. Align people around a com- with poverty and discrimination. She
following that call and using your mon mission and values. At Johnson & found refuge in her church. At nine,
gifts to make a difference? Johnson, employees have followed the she was sexually abused by a rela-
The root cause of our leadership cri- J&J Credo for 60 years. But many lead- tive—abuse that was perpetrated on
sis is that we often choose the wrong ers lose sight of their customers and her by other family members. When,
leaders for the wrong reasons. We their True North by following the dic- at age 36, she realized that she wasn’t
choose them for: Charisma instead of tate to “maximize shareholder value.” responsible for this abuse, she decided
character, style instead of substance, and • Empower. Empower others to step up to build her career around helping peo-
image instead of integrity. Why, then, are and lead, as opposed to exercising ple take responsibility for their lives.
we surprised when they lack character, power over others to get them to follow • I describe my life as a series of cru-
substance, and integrity? In a climate you. By empowering people, you moti- cibles. After a successful 20-year career,
of public impressions and short-term vate them to contribute and increase the I hit the wall in my mid-forties. I was at
performance, many good leaders lose net power. Organizations of empow- Honeywell and in line to become CEO,
sight of their calling, or their “True ered leaders are more successful. but I was miserable, even with a won-
North,” and are pulled off course by • Service. Authentic leaders serve derful wife, two fine sons, and great
pressures and seductions. They are not their employees and customers and friends. I’d lost sight of being the val-
well-grounded in their faith and become “servant leaders.” ues-centered, purpose-driven leader. I
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 3
then became president of Medtronic—a MANAGEMENT COMMITMENT internal and external customers. It is
place where I could make a difference, informal and ambiguous, often outside
work with people of like minds and
similar values, and make the transfor- Commitment the bounds of the standard job descrip-
tions. This makes it difficult to manage
mation from “I” to “We.” It unleashes your potential. and reward tacit work with the current
Have you made that transforma- management practices and tools, even
tion? If not, you need to go through a though employees may spend most of
process of finding your True North. the day engaged in it.
by Chris Majer
It is time to revolutionize the practice
F i n d i n g Your True North of management. Welcome to Commitment-
Focus on these six areas:
1. Pursuing your purpose. First, dis-
cern the purpose of your leadership.
L EADERS WORLDWIDE
face the same chal-
Based Management. It is a set of distinct
principles, practices, and tools that enable
lenge: How do we develop managers to design and deliver powerful
That discernment might come early or and sustain competitive advantage? Our offers to their customers, generate inno-
after years of trial and error. Andrea practices of leadership and management vation, and manage organizations to gen-
Jung, CEO of Avon Products, followed are inadequate—we need to re-invent erate performance and profits by getting
her compass, not her clock, and changed our philosophies, practices, and tools. the most value from their tacit workers.
the vision of Avon from cosmetics to The breakdown we face is revealed
“the empowerment of women.” when we examine two standard means A N e w L o o k a t Wo r k
2. Self-awareness. We all have blind for generating competitive advantage. The core principle of Commitment-
spots and vulnerabilities. To be self- 1. We develop a unique strategy. Based Management is simple. Instead of
aware, we must first have leadership Today, with the information and analy- seeing work as a mechanistic connec-
experiences, get honest feedback about sis available on the Internet, it’s hard tion of activities, we see it as a dynam-
our leadership and the areas we need to gain competitive advantage in a ic set of nested commitments. Activity
to improve, and reflect on that feed- unique strategy. Since the information is generated by commitments. When
back, perhaps with a trusted colleague that you use to craft a strategy is avail- these are clear and focused, we gener-
or mentor, about how others see us and able to anyone, your competitors are ate high performance. When they are
how to make authentic connections. likely following the same strategy. unclear or weak, we generate waste
3. Practicing our values. It is easy to 2. We devise a unique deployment of and unproductive moods. In manufac-
preach values when things go well. The technology. Any technology that you turing, we have effective tools for elim-
test comes when things aren’t going can acquire, consultant you can hire, or inating waste. However, in tacit work,
well and people are watching. Only software you can purchase we generate untold billions
when all you’ve built for a decade or can be purchased by your of waste. Every time there
more hangs in the balance will you competitors. Technology is a miscoordination, mis-
know how solid your values are. has become commoditized. communication, or a com-
4. Motivations and motivated capa- What does that leave mitment that isn’t fulfilled
bilities. We all like to receive positive you with? Your only source as promised, we generate
feedback, recognition, or compensa- of sustainable competitive waste; hence, up to 70 per-
tion. But we need to balance these advantage is your capacity cent of payroll dollars
extrinsic motivations with intrinsic to mobilize your people to don’t generate much value.
motivations—like making a difference, implement your strategy In a commitment-based
mentoring others, developing our- faster and more effectively organization, the core unit
selves, having a healthy family, or ful- than your competition. of work is not activity, but the making
filling our inner purpose. When you Why is it so difficult to mobilize of a commitment between two people
are clear about your motivations, you people? The practices that we use in (customer and holder). When holders
can employ your motivated capabili- transactional and transformational promise the customer that they’ll do
ties in places where you’ll be effective. work are out of date. When times call something by a certain time, they
5. Building a support team. Since for innovation, hierarchy and process make a commitment. The making and
leadership is inherently lonely, you fail us, as these try to standardize the managing of commitments is largely a
need a support team, starting with one activities that generate innovation. At linguistic competence.
person with whom you can be honest best this produces marginal or incre- The practice of management must
and open. It could be your spouse, best mental innovation and at worst kills be seen not as supervising, measuring,
friend, mentor, or therapist. Start now breakthrough innovations. Process and and assessing activities but as design-
to build a trusted support team. hierarchy are focused on monitoring ing, coordinating, and fulfilling com-
6. Leading an integrated life. With and measuring activity. However, they mitments. This requires new compe-
all the pressures, you will struggle to don’t work so well in the emerging tencies—building trust, managing
find a perfect balance between your work that is dominated by tacit work. moods, and mastering conversations
work and personal life. Live your life Tacit work requires high interaction that enable people to design and deliv-
with the integrity of being the same per- and coordination skills, the capacity to er on their commitments consistently.
son in all settings and circumstances. build networks, the competence to think Commitment-Based Management opens
These six keys prepare you to serve strategically and innovate, and resolve doors to a new world of productivity,
and empower others to lead. LE complex breakdowns. Tacit work profitability, and innovation. LE
requires more than just knowledge. The
Bill George is author of True North: Discover Your Authentic Chris Majer is CEO of the Human Potential Project, a leader
Leadership and Finding Your True North. This article is adapt- essential components are observing, in changing cultures. Visit www.humanpotentialproject.com or
ed from his speech at the Willow Creek Leadership Summit. assessing, declaring, and mobilizing email chris.majer@humanpotentialproject.com.
ACTION: Empower others to lead. action to attend to the concerns of both ACTION: Make and manage commitments.
4 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
CHANGE CONVERSATION must be led—a manager can’t change
the way a unit behaves; only its mem-
bers can do that. During times of
Leading Change change, managers feel at risk because
of performance pressures and in con-
Do it with conversation. flict because they are also trying to
manage change. The irony is that they
can get through the change more quickly
lar units in the same company that and perform better if they take time for
by Susan Albers Mohrman
were operating under the same leader- sense-making and for building the
ship and within similar new strategies new agreements and practices.
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 5
LEADERSHIP GLOBAL global contacts in a personal way.
• Use the right tools at the right time. To
communicate with people you seldom
Leadership Leap see, understand, and utilize the com-
munication options that technology
presents. A virtual PowerPoint with
Go from garage to globe. conference may work better than an e-
mail chat or Skype, or the issue may
simply require a face-to-face meeting.
Humanize your work with stories. 4. Build partnerships and alliances.
by Maya Hu-Chan
Rather than using sweeping global A partnership is usually an association
management lingo, share the details of of two or more people, whereas an
6 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES written about since the mid-1950s.
However, until the business book rev-
olution was ignited in 1982 with the
Inside Drucker publications of In Search of Excellence
(Peters and Waterman), and The One
Apply five timeless principles. Minute Manager (Blanchard and
Johnson), business was not the phe-
nomenon it would later become.
institutions of the era. He spoke of basic Drucker was never hip; he was never
by Jeffrey A. Krames
beliefs of American society and how its sexy; but he was almost always first.
institutions must bestow the appropri- 3. Gain an outside-in perspective:
P ETER DRUCKER
always thought
that what was right
ate status to the individual. And he also
concluded that the dignity and status
he was describing can only by derived
Drucker was the first writer to under-
stand the potentially debilitating effects
of being a captive of an organization.
was more important than who was through work and the corporation. That was because what goes on within
right—a principle he learned from 2. Execution, first and always: By the an organization is not half as important
Alfred Sloan, former CEO of General time Larry Bossidy and Ram Charan as what goes on in the only place that
Motors and the man Drucker wrote their bestselling book, Execution: counts—the marketplace. The problem
researched in the first study of any The Discipline of Getting Things Done, is that there are too many factors cloud-
large American corporation. That Drucker had been writing and speaking ing the manager’s vision, removing any
study led to his first business book, about execution for decades. He just chance of a clear sense of things.
Concept of the Corporation (1946). didn’t call it “execution.” Instead he Drucker wrote of “thick and distorting
Today’s effective leaders still adhere used words like “performance” and glasses” of the manager, and how he
to the enduring leadership principles “results,” “achieving” and “doing.” The must see the marketplace through “an
espoused by Peter Drucker. Many best- entire Drucker body of work is steeped organizational filter of reports.” That’s
selling business books include ideas in words and phrases that suggest that a real problem because “results and
that he originated. He was the inven- action and results are the only authentic resources exist only on the outside.”
tor of management, and he established measures of success. Lately some authors and business
management as a social discipline. Those leaders have written about the need to
are his two greatest contributions. see things from the outside-in—from
Along with those loftier accom- the view of the customer. Lou Gerstner
plishments, he also gave us solid and talked about a form of it when he
enduring principles to help managers turned around IBM in the 1990s. So
run their business. Regardless of your did Jack Welch in a 1999 speech in
firm’s size or structure, Drucker’s New York, declaring “outside-in” to be
ideas can help you to get much better “an important idea”—a game changer.
at what you do. Noel Tichy and Ram Charan wrote
about it in their strong-selling book,
Five Greatest Ideas Every Business Is a Growth Business
Here are five of Drucker’s greatest (2000). However, as we have seen with
ideas, which remain relevant today: so many other important topics, Peter
1. Lead like Jefferson: Before For example, in his 1973 book, Drucker was the intellectual father of
Drucker, workers were looked down Management, Drucker argues, the outside-in corporation.
upon. They were called “helpers” by “Objectives must be derived from Some ideas for developing an out-
Frederick Taylor. They were not seen what our business is, what it will be, side-in perspective include: “go where
as assets, but as costs. From his first and what it should be. They are not they are.” Force yourself and your
book, Drucker changed the calculus abstractions. They are the action com- direct reports to spend time with your
and the conversation: he established mitments through which the mission customers (and with non-customers as
the importance of workers, and made of a business is to be carried out, and well). Urge your people to spend two
dignity a critical part of the practice of the standards against which perfor- hours per week in competitive stores
management. Those themes of dignity mance is to be measured. Objectives, and websites. One top British retailer,
and humility dominated his works. in other words, represent the funda- Tesco, asks its top managers to switch
This signified an important change in mental strategy of a business.” jobs with its people in the field for one
the way organizations regarded and Three decades later, Bossidy and week per year to remove the “distort-
treated their workers. Charan wrote, “Putting an execution ing” lenses Drucker felt inhibited a
In Jefferson’s first Inaugural in 1801, environment in place is hard, but los- manager’s vision.
he espoused the kind of rhetoric and ing it is easy.” “People think of execu- 4. Audit strengths: In the last decade,
sentiments that Drucker would later use tion as the tactical side of the business, there have been some terrific books on
in his earliest works. Jefferson argued something leaders delegate while they focusing on strengths in organizations.
for the rights of the common man, equal focus on the perceived ‘bigger issues.’ Chief among them were Buckingham
laws, and for the violation of oppres- This idea is completely wrong.” and Clifton’s million-copy-plus-best-
sion. He rallied citizens to come togeth- Bossidy and Charan describe execu- seller, Now, Discover Your Strengths.
er—united in heart and mind. tion as something that must be incor- They wrote the book to help managers
Drucker’s Concept of the Corporation porated into a firm’s strategy and capitalize on the differences of their
is a Jeffersonian-inspired plea of the culture. Using different terms and employees. The book also urges peo-
worth of the individual over the cold labels, they describe what Drucker had ple “to play to their signature talents”
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 7
by making sure they are in positions LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT deliver a session for managers on such
where they can contribute the most. topics as leading change, building
However, Drucker’s work on teams, and coaching. Serve as a cross-
strengths theory pre-dates Buckingham Developing Leaders functional “talent broker” by making it
and Clifton’s by half a century. In 1954, Get creative on a tight budget. easy for leaders to schedule visits to
Drucker urged managers to focus on each others’ team or meetings to talk
people’s strengths in The Practice of about their area. Ask senior managers
Management. In that work, Drucker to serve as “buddies” for incoming
by Steve Arneson
asserts that nothing hurts the morale of executive hires. Create informal book
an organization faster than focusing on clubs to spark dialogue on hot topics.
people’s weaknesses. He stated
unequivocally that the biggest blunder
an organization can make is to “try to
L EADERSHIP DEVELOP-
ment (LD) has long
been the centerpiece of
3. Profile leaders on your web por-
tal. Use your intranet to spotlight and
profile leaders. Interview leaders about
build on weakness.” A decade later, the learning budget. LD has become a their philosophy and ask them to share
Drucker explained that organizations multi-billion dollar industry, as compa- leadership lessons. Describe where they
must be built in such a way that nies pour resources into assessment work and what they do. Document
matches a person’s strength to his or tools, leadership programs, executive how they stay current, and let their
her specific work assignment. coaching, and leadership training. enthusiasm and passion shine through.
To their credit, Buckingham and When revenues and profits are down, 4. Explore action-learning projects.
Clifton credit Drucker’s ideas on build- you may cut back on LD. Effective LD, Find senior leaders who have a pas-
ing on strengths. However, it is still a however, doesn’t have to cost millions sion for development, and help them
case of Drucker getting there first. of dollars; in fact, several best practices coordinate action-learning projects.
5. Build innovation into the fabric of require little or no budget. These small-group experiences, often
the organization: Peter Drucker told LD is first and foremost a mindset found in formal LD programs, can be
me that while he had been thinking (not a program). Companies that excel implemented at any time. Help the
about innovation for years, he was not at sustaining a leadership pipeline leader start the process—choosing in-
ready to write about it until the mid- establish a culture of development and dividuals to come together as a team,
1980s with the publication of reinforce it at every level. They expect giving them a choice of projects, pro-
Innovation and Entrepreneurship (1985). leaders to pass on their experience. viding feedback and support, and
He also told me that, out of all the They spend valuable time sponsoring, showing commitment for decisions.
books he had written (38 in all), that supporting, and leveraging 5. Create your own 360-
was one of the six most important. LD because they make it a degree feedback tool. Design
Since then, there have been many priority and “ground” LD a 360-feedback tool based
other books on innovation, but few as a core element of their on your leadership compe-
better than Clayton Christensen’s The culture. And much of what tencies, and set up a sched-
Innovator’s Dilemma (1997). He argues they do to develop leaders ule and process for
that successful companies often get doesn’t cost a dime. implementing the tool and
blindsided by a new or what he called facilitating feedback ses-
a “disruptive” technology. That’s Six Best Practices in LD sions. Target your top 100
because success tends to breed com- You can excel at LD, on leaders, and pace and
placency. One way to innovate, he a low budget, in six ways: sequence the process to col-
wrote, is to set up a separate, distinct 1. Get your CEO and lect feedback on 12 to 15
operating unit that can get enthusiastic senior execs into the game. Look for leaders a month. Enlist HR partners to
about even minor accomplishments, ways to engage your CEO and other help you debrief the feedback reports.
and set more realistic goals that are in senior executives in developing leaders. 6. Develop a rigorous talent review
line with their size and scope. Establish a CEO Leadership Lunch, where process. Develop leaders by giving
A decade earlier, however, Drucker a few mid-level leaders join the CEO. them various leadership experiences
made the same point when he wrote Set up an Executive Speaker Series, where and having a twice-annual talent
that “babies” should not be put in the senior executives share their leadership review process where the CEO and
living room—they should be put in the journey and lessons learned. Invite your senior executives meet to talk about
“nursery.” He argued that it is danger- leaders to serve on Boards for local char- talent. Create the data and metrics for
ous to trust new concepts and ideas to ities or non-profits (and to share their ex- making informed movement and
existing operating units. periences). Set up lunches with leaders developmental decisions based on
Drucker got there first on many key at other companies to share best prac- assessment results, leadership poten-
management and leadership concepts. tices. Work with leaders to design and tial ratings, attrition risk analysis, and
However, he hardly appears at all in deliver leadership content in meetings. bench strength or replacement plan-
today’s textbooks. That’s because he 2. Leverage leaders as teachers and ning charts. Make movement an out-
did not adhere to the traditional rules mentors. A company-wide commitment come of these sessions, and then help
of the academic elite. Perhaps that will to LD is often sparked by leaders serv- facilitate the leader’s move with a New
change, as the scope of his accomplish- ing as teachers and mentors. VP leaders Leader Assimilation process.
ments are measured and studied. LE are more accessible, as they work close- By involving everyone in LD, you
ly with directors and managers to exe- create a great leadership culture. LE
Jeffrey A. Krames is the author of Inside Drucker’s Brain
and Editorial Director of Portfolio, a division of the Penguin cute the strategy. Help them connect
Steve Arneson, Ph.D., is president, Arneson Leadership
Group. Visit www.INSIDEDRUCKERSBRAIN.COM or with emerging leaders by establishing a Consulting. Visit www.arnesonleadership.com.
www.jeffreykrames.com.
mentoring program. Set up Leadership
ACTION: Apply Drucker’s five core ideas. Workshops, where leaders develop and ACTION: Create a leadership development culture.
8 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
PERFORMANCE PROFITS build cultures that inspire people to
want to work harder and care more
about their jobs. People feel cared for
Profitable Leadership and respected as leaders clear away
obstacles, that in turn creates a culture
Extraordinary leaders double profits. that encourages teams to flourish.
• Leading change is a vital function
for gaining competitive advantage.
profit is 100 percent. Even if productivity High-performing leaders are strong in
improvement is just 5 percent and peo- three or four areas; however, these
ple costs are 50 percent, that’s still an need to be spread out, not clumped in
increase in pre-tax profit of 50 percent! one area. A leader can be exceptional
Affecting employee satisfaction, in just a few of the 16 competencies
by Jack Zenger, Joe Folkman, commitment, turnover, and retention and be an extremely good leader who
and Scott K. Edinger certainly impacts the bottom line, but boosts productivity and profitability.
is a 10 percent productivity gain rea- Leaders who have no glaring weak-
W E’VE SPENT YEARS DECODING LEAD- sonable? Yes, leaders have many ways nesses or extraordinary strengths fall
ership trends and discovered an to impact productivity by 10 percent.
interesting pattern: extraordinary
into the bottom third of the leadership
distribution. Even one strength works
leaders can double profits. Developing Extraordinar y Leaders wonders in the perception of leader-
This bold assertion invites several Many organizations show gains in ship. Three strengths will raise the per-
questions: How does leadership drive productivity over time as a direct re- ception of leadership effectiveness to
profit? How do leaders maximize, if sult of their LD programs. To realize the 81st percentile and four and five
not double, profit opportunity? How increases in productivity and to sus- strengths to the 90th percentile!
do we capitalize on leadership as a tain these gains, you must rely on a One competency is most powerful:
means to profit and growth? What LD model that defines the competen- inspires and motivates others to high
issues can leaders impact that will cies that make a difference and use performance. This interpersonal com-
drive profit? How do we identify and effective development methods. petency is seen as the most important.
develop extraordinary leaders? In creating our LD model, we iden- It correlates most with employee
Our research supports the claim tified 16 competencies that separate the engagement and productivity.
that leaders, good and bad, directly Each of the 16 differentiating com-
affect the bottom line. We’ve analyzed petencies—including inspiring and
a database of over 300,000 360-degree motivating others—has several com-
feedback reports on about 30,000 man- panion behaviors or competency com-
agers on this premise—if you want to panions. Enhancing these companion
learn the effectiveness of a leader, ask behaviors strengthens the behavior.
those who are led. Having performance We liken it to cross-training in sports.
metrics on these managers enabled us So, if you desire more inspiring and
to compare their business results with motivational leaders, you need to
their leadership effectiveness. develop the companion competencies:
Our leadership development (LD) setting stretch goals, establishing a
model and process are focused on clear vision and direction, being more
business outcomes, converting LD best companies from the rest. Develop- innovative and risk taking, developing
into desirable results (double profits). ing these competencies or strengths be- others, practicing greater teamwork
Do extraordinary leaders double comes the clear path to extraordinary and collaboration, taking greater initia-
profit in every case? No, but the trend leadership, productivity, and profits. tive, and being a role model.
line looks the same, regardless of raw These 16 competencies of extraordi-
numbers or percentages. Good leaders nary leadership can be categorized into S u s t a i n i n g C h a n g e
create more economic value than poor five clusters or behavior: 1) focus on What people learn in your LD pro-
leaders, and extraordinary leaders cre- results, 2) leading change, 3) character, gram they will soon forget unless there
ate far more value than the rest. 4) interpersonal skills, and 5) personal is systematic follow-up. This can be as
Since we can measure the perfor- capability. The links between these simple as asking for progress reports,
mance of leaders on factors that impact behaviors and performance are critical. requesting suggestions, or conducting
profits, we can measure leadership’s For instance, the leader who focuses surveys every six months to reveal
affect on the bottom line. These factors on results learns that what gets areas for improvement. Record achieve-
include retention, turnover, commitment, focused on gets better: seeing improve- ments and milestones, deliver progress
morale, satisfaction, attitudes, productiv- ment, people respond to this focus and and completion reminders, and ask
ity and customer satisfaction. This is how follow it. The leader’s focus then cre- what leaders have done and plan to do
extraordinary leaders double profits! ates a cycle of success. to achieve their goals. This keeps LD at
How can you develop extraordinary • First-rate, talented people are the forefront of the leaders awareness
leaders who inspire people to perform attracted to honesty and integrity and and shows progress—which leads to
at higher levels, remove obstacles to to leaders who are competent problem- improved productivity and profits! LE
productivity, and double profits? solvers. What better way to attract the
John H. “Jack” Zenger and Joseph Folkman are coauthors of The
We find that if people costs are 50 best talent than to display fair ethics, Extraordinary Leader and principals of Zenger/Folkman. Scott
percent and productivity improvement character, and personal capability? K. Edinger is Exec. VP of sales. Visit www.ZengerFolkman.com.
is 10 percent, the increase in pre-tax • Leaders with interpersonal skills ACTION: Develop extraordinary leaders.
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 9
COMPETENCY COACHING New leaders have two priority areas six-fold ROI, whether it’s done by an
for development: 1) management skills external coach, manager, or HR pro.
—understanding finances, business pro-
New Leaders cesses, how work gets done and things
get made, conducting performance re-
Two Case Studies
How coaching can help maximize
Coach them for success. views, and creating management reports the contribution of a New Leader is
(most organizations address these illustrated in two case studies.
needs through training courses and Case 1: Advancing a top contributor
by Stephen L. Cohen established resources); and 2) emotional to a senior executive in a fast-growing
intelligence—understanding how their business. A new leader was promoted
behavior influences others and how the into the role of a financial controller
M ANY LEADERSHIP
books directed
at women in the 80s
are looking for long-term sustainable
results and innovative solutions.
They can’t achieve this without
C REATING A HIGH-TRUST
organization (HTO)
brings an incredible sus-
and 90s spoke about women having engaged people. tainable advantage. Unfortunately,
a natural tendency toward leader- Engagement is an emotional issue, most leaders create a low-trust organi-
ship. In fact, I was interviewed for a not an intellectual one. You can go to zation (LTO). I contrast HTOs with
book published in 1991 called Star work with your head, but it isn’t LTOs along 10 dimensions:
Teams, Key Players, by Michelle until your heart is engaged that you • Solving problems. In HTOs, prob-
Jackman. She states that women are can bring about superior and sus- lems are dealt with easily and effi-
natural leaders because of their tainable results. Effective leadership ciently. In LTOs, problems become big
innate ability to work in teams. I requires passion, creativity and inno- obstacles as leaders work to unscram-
have never fully bought vation, and you can’t ble the mess to find out who said what
into the idea that these do that without an or who caused the problem to spiral
natural talents are what engaged heart. out of control. Often feelings are hurt
get us ahead. I believe that if we and relationships damaged. Problems
To the contrary, I embraced ourselves take much longer to resolve in LTOs.
often find that women more fully and started • Focused energy. In HTOs, people do
who succeed in corpo- to unapologetically not need to be defensive. They focus
rate life put aside their bring our full selves energy on achieving the vision and mis-
natural feminine attrib- to work, our business sion. They direct their energy toward
utes—including their relationships would the customer and against the competi-
hearts—in order to flourish. Showing tion. In LTOs, people waste energy due
thrive. At times, women emotion is no longer a to infighting and politics. Their focus is
even do this more fre- sign of weakness, it on internal squabbles and destructive
quently than their male opens a window to turf battles. Bad blood between people
counterparts! who we truly are— creates issues that distract managers
When you are in the minority, it and the truth is that people do busi- from the pursuit of excellence. Instead,
doesn’t help to be considered differ- ness with those they like. If your they play referee all day.
ent. It takes a lot more courage and staff and your clients do not relate to • Efficient communication. When
effort to stick it out, especially when you, it’s nearly impossible to build trust is high, communication is effi-
there is no proven track record that trust and long-term relationships, cient as leaders freely share valuable
different will be rewarded. Business especially in today’s globally com- insights about business conditions and
has been a place where the heart petitive and ever-changing market. strategy. In LTOs, rumors and gossip
and its many expressions were dis- Business is personal, but you can’t zap about like laser beams in a hall of
couraged. Therefore, many women take it personally. While you do need mirrors. Soon, leaders are blinded with
became “little men” or, as I like to to bring a human aspect to work by problems coming from every direction.
call say, “she-men”. bringing your heart, you also need to Trying to control the zapping informa-
What’s a she-man? A “she-man” keep your head engaged and under- tion takes energy away from the mis-
is a woman who has completely stand that business is not personal. sion and strategy. HTOs rely on solid,
disconnected herself from her femi- This is the magical dance you believable communication; LTOs rely
nine attributes in the workplace must do between the management on controlling damage and minimiz-
because she believes it has no pur- demands of the business and the ing unrest. Since people’s reality is
pose or value in business. While I leadership demands of the people what they believe, not what is objec-
do believe this is particularly rele- around you. The problem is that tively happening, the need for damage
vant for women, I have seem men business has been overly skewed to control in LTOs is often a huge burden.
suffer from this as well by leaving the management side of the equa- • Retaining customers. In HTOs, peo-
their heart-driven creativity, com- tion; but to achieve sustainable ple have a passion for their work that
passion, and sensitivity at the door. results, businesses need some heart! is obvious to customers. When trust is
Unfortunately, I believe that as And it starts with every one of us— low, workers display an apathy that is
women we are often guilty of nega- women and men alike! LE transparent to customers. This under-
tively judging these natural, femi- mines top line growth as customers
Laura Lopez, former VP at The Coca-Cola Company and
nine skills and, as a result, we leave author of The Connected and Committed Leader, is a turn to upbeat groups for services. All
them at home. I know that I and performance strategist helping companies achieve superior it takes is the roll of eyes or shoddy
results with effective leadership. Visit www.laura-lopez.com.
many other women I worked with body language to lose customers.
had these assumptions. The truth is ACTION: Show some heart in your leadership. • A “real” culture. People who work
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 11
in HTOs describe the culture as “real.” LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT dream, and action without vision is a
They are not playing games in a futile nightmare.” When vision fails, a lack of
attempt to outdo or embarrass others. specificity is often to blame. Beware of
Rather, they are aligned under a com- Creating New Leaders creating a leader who is only visionary.
mon goal that permeates all activities. Go from fire-fighters to visionaries. From vision flows decisions that deter-
When something is real, people know mine what people will and won’t do. If
it and respond positively. When trust few options are eliminated, action is
is high, people have greater respect for unfocused. “Seers” create organizations
by Drew Marshall
each other. They support and reinforce of unrealized potential.
the good deeds done by colleagues. Vision is malleable and scalable. For
Reducing the infighting creates extra
time to spend on achieving goals.
Saving time and reducing costs. HTOs
T HE COMPLEXITY OF
organizations re-
a manager, on the path to becoming a
leader, learning how to develop vision
flects the inter-connect- can start early. Ask managers to craft a
get things done more quickly because edness of systems, processes, and vision for their team within the context
there are fewer distractions and no need people. Without a path that builds of the organization’s vision and strate-
to double-check everything, since peo- long-term stewardship skills, leaders gy. Good leaders craft a vision that
ple generally do things right. In LTOs, burn out—and organizations suffer. reflects the language of the group to
there is a constant need to spin things Are long hours a badge of honor or a describe a future that is specific, com-
to be acceptable and then explain them. hazard? Is darting from issue to issue a pelling, shared, and comprehensive
This takes time and drives costs up. testament to flexibility or an inability enough to be meaningful to all.
• Perfection not required. A culture of to have meaningful impact? Change. The ability to manage change
high trust relieves leaders from the need is the next range of skills for developing
to be perfect. In HTOs, people sense the The Three-Fold Leader managers as leaders. As John Porter
intent of a communication, even if it is Effective leaders balance the time says: People underestimate their capacity
poorly phrased. In LTOs, the leader they spend on vision and doing, and for change. There is never a right time to do
must be perfect because people spring occasional resolution. Leaders can’t del- a difficult thing. A leader’s job is to help
on every misstep to prove the leader egate or neglect the creation of a com- people have vision of their potential.
untrustworthy. Without trust, speaking pelling and engaging vision. They can’t With clear vision, anything is possi-
to groups is like walking on egg shells. remain fire-fighters or get lost in the ble. Making it probable is the hard part.
• More development and growth. In details of implementation. The deci- The key for successful change is the
LTOs, people stagnate because there is sions leaders make drive human element. Nothing
little emphasis on growth. All energy strategy implementation. beats the power of people
is spent jousting. HTOs emphasize The problems they solve are working in concert, their
development; there is a constant focus the most intractable. end goal shared and their
on personal and organizational growth. We need to develop high- objectives aligned. Good
• Better reinforcement. When trust is potential managers into project managers can
high, positive reinforcement works three-fold leaders who: 1) become good leaders.
because it is sincere and well executed. envision a better future; 2) Leaders manage expecta-
In low-trust organizations, reinforce- grow from successful indi- tions, commitments and
ment is often considered phony, vidual contributors into accountability and tie it all
manipulative, or duplicitous which mentors who get the best together with communica-
lowers morale. Without trust, attempts from everyone; and 3) tion. But the leader’s role is
to improve motivation through rein- resolve operational issues rarely, when not to do but to enable. Chief Doers
forcement programs often backfire. they, and they alone, can resolve them. can’t achieve what they must as lead-
• Positive culture. The HTO culture is Vision. We need to develop leaders ers if they micro-manage activity. Lead-
refreshing and light. People enjoy com- who embrace vision over motion, change ers use vision to inform implementation.
ing to work because they have fun and management over meaningless action, Resolution. Great leaders see chal-
enjoy their coworkers. They are also and issue resolution over fire-fighting. lenges within a strategic context and
twice as productive as their LTO coun- Success is not tied to the latest technolo- reach beyond the impulse to fix things.
terparts. In LTOs, work is a hopeless gy or business model. It is the way our Typically leaders are drawn from the
string of sapping activities foisted leaders see the future, create a path to best problem solvers. But past success is
upon them by clueless morons. realize it, and resolve impediments. why too many leaders focus on opera-
LTOs can’t be fixed by an outsider. Vision drives change and deter- tional rather than strategic issues. We
The leader needs to say, “The culture mines the future. Without a clear, com- love the heroic “Fire Fighter,” but the
here stinks, and it must be my fault pelling vision, organizations are left to very fires being extinguished arise due
because I’m in charge. How can I the shifting winds of market forces— to a lack of vision and planning. By
change my behavior to create higher essentially responding to the enacted focusing new leaders on the vision and
trust?” With that attitude, there is a real vision of other enterprises! Yet most its implementation, we can convert the
possibility an outside coach or consul- vision statements possess the vigor of best fire-fighters into visionaries.
tant can help the organization. Sadly, wet rag and fail to galvanize people. By developing leaders who can cre-
most leaders are blind to how they Vision is specific, compelling, shared, ate a vision, manage change, and
contribute to low trust; in those cases, and comprehensive enough to enable resolve issues, we can build the bench
there’s little hope of lasting change. LE people to start with the end in sight. strength for tomorrow’s success. LE
Robert T. Whipple is CEO of Leadergrow and author of The Every action is a step on the path to Drew Marshall is Chief Innovation Officer at Kepner-Tregoe.
Trust Factor. Visit www.leadergrow.com or call 585-392-7763. achieving the promise of the future. Visit www.kepner-tregoe.com or email info@kepner-tregoe.com.
ACTION: Create a high-trust culture. “Vision without action is a day- ACTION: Develop three-fold leaders.
12 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
COMPETENCY FEEDBACK Shepherd’s team leader was text-
book perfect: He depersonalized the
group’s comments, treating them as a
Accepting Feedback “business case” rather than an attack.
Depersonalizing feedback was hard
It’s a challenge for all leaders. for Roy Anise, former VP and GM of
Chrysalis Technologies, a division of
Philip Morris USA, and his team. He
natural fear in the system. You have to says: “Their self-worth always seemed
by Howard M. Guttman
disarm people if you want the truth, to be on trial. They didn’t understand
and the faster you can get the truth, that being questioned didn’t imply
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 13
LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT development goals and spur growth.
6. Structure informal learning oppor-
tunities. Employers should integrate
L EADERSHIP DEVELOP-
ment and succes-
sion planning are hot
3. Strategically position L&D func-
tions within senior management. A HR
leader or CLO must be part of the top
grams including Corporate Citizenship,
which provides leadership training
through volunteer opportunities.
topics—for good reason. As Boomers management team. Consider creating Diamond also developed a Knowledge
approach retirement age, many worry new roles and functions to lead talent Center available to employees 24/7.
about the loss of skills, knowledge, development. US Cellular created a VP 7. Use innovative technology to meet
and experience and see the need to of Organizational Learning and Chief learning objectives and to manage your
build next-generation leaders. Teaching Officer to lead the design education and training offerings.
The Boomer retirement bubble is and execution of its L&D strategies. Deloitte effectively uses e-learning by
exacerbated by an education gap. 4. Emphasize LD at all levels. Since offering 6,000+ online courses on their
Among 55- to 64-year-olds, the U.S. leadership skills are essential for all Learning Center Web site. Courses use
ranks first in employees with postsec- employees, you need to develop talent a blended approach that combines an
ondary credentials (36 percent). But from within. Focusing only on Hi-Pos e-learning course with an instructor-
among young adults (25 to 34), only 37 poised for top positions won’t prevent led course. This application-based
percent have such credentials; in some the talent crunch. GE Commercial learning integrates business concepts
other countries, over 50 percent of Finance fosters a growth culture for into training so employees can imme-
employees in this age group have such future leaders with a leadership pro- diately apply what they learn.
credentials, dropping the U.S. ranking 8. Form alliances with educational
to 10th place behind countries like institutions. Develop customized
Canada, Korea, and Japan. These stats degree, certificate and non-credit pro-
do not bode well for U.S. companies. grams collaboratively with education
Hence, many employers are look- and training providers to ensure that
ing beyond Hi-Pos to their entire the curriculum meets talent and skills
pipeline of talent. What practices pro- needs. Advocate, a Chicago healthcare
mote development at every career provider, has created partnerships with
stage? What policies encourage local community colleges to develop
advance degree attainment? What are programs (including degree- and cer-
leading employers doing to prepare tificate-bearing programs). They also
their workforce for future challenges? participate in the DuPage Health Care
Leadership Group, which unites local
CA E L’s L&D Practices gram that combines job rotations by health care providers with colleges and
The Council for Adult and Experien- assignment, leadership interaction, universities to discuss learning needs.
tial Learning (CAEL), a non-profit orga- and unique training opportunities. All 9. Assess the impact of T&D invest-
nization, has nine exemplary practices employees gain a broad view of the ments. This can include analyzing how
for building emerging leaders. company while quickly developing training and tuition assistance partici-
1. Drive learning with leadership core professional skills and experience. pants perform against other employ-
vision and commitment. The CEO and 5. Expand knowledge beyond job- ees, and looking at the effects on
senior managers must elevate learning related or technical skills. Investments performance, recruitment, retention,
and development. Tim Reedy, CEO of should be made to develop well-round- bill rates, and other factors. To analyze
Conference Plus, discusses develop- ed, versatile employees through tuition the ROI of its training, Accenture part-
ment with employees through group assistance programs, customized on- nered with the University of Chicago.
“Lunch and Learns” and quarterly “All site training, and personal development The study showed that Accenture
Hands Calls,” enabling every employee options. To meet skill shortages, North- receives a 353 percent return on learning.
to be informed and heard by the CEO. western Memorial Hospital (NMH) is Through CAEL’s Tuition Assistance
2. Align employee learning with bus- developing its people for future health Management Service, Verizon Wireless
iness goals. Top leaders should adopt care leadership positions. NMH partici- has quantified results on its tuition ass-
clear goals, communicate them wide- pates in the School at Work program. istance and career advising program
ly, and ensure that L&D activities are Once a week at work, participants are and assessed the impact on recruitment,
aligned with the goals. IBM’s goal, for exposed to several health care occupa- retention, mobility, and performance.
example, is to help set the innovation tions, given career planning tips, and Implement these exemplary prac-
agenda for its clients. IBM wants its meet with college counselors. tices to build your talent pipeline. LE
people to be innovators in their roles Tuition assistance programs must Pamela Tate is President and CEO at CAEL. Call 312-499-
so that they can be resources for their be managed effectively and evaluated 2600 or visit www.CAEL.org.
clients. The innovation theme is incor- against best practices to meet talent ACTION: Fill your emerging leader pipeline.
14 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
LEADERSHIP PROGRAM Jobs, but rather someone much more
potent—the best leadership version of
themselves. A program designed to help
Designed Development participants accelerate the development
of their natural strengths is more potent
How good is your LD program? than one designed to fix participants or
change them into the model leaders.
6. Intense experiences. When I ask
her current story and have it honored workshop participants to reflect on five
by Gregg Thompson
in the classroom. Once this happens, a items and select the one that has the
new story can be crafted. The greater most influence on their development
L EADERSHIP DEVELOP-
ment workshops
the story, the greater the development.
4. Feedback. No workshop ingredi-
are expensive. And I’m ent is more potent than feedback.
as a leader: 1) reading and research; 2)
performance appraisals; 3) coaching
and mentoring; 4) challenging experi-
not just referring to the cost of facili- Whether it be multi-rater assessments ences; and 5) formal training, I find
ties, materials, trainers, and bagels. or direct one-on-one communication, that challenging experiences is selected
When a company takes 20 managers feedback is a powerful stimulus for by over 90 percent of respondents (per-
out for several days, it makes a major personal change. That’s what leader- formance appraisal always comes in last).
investment in their development. ship development is—personal change. And yet most designers fill the agenda
The architects of LD workshops What limits the use of feedback in with content such as succession plan-
need to ask: Have we designed a pro- leadership workshops? It is largely our ning models, managerial competencies,
gram worthy of this investment? own arrogance. Too often we feel that and corporate values. While the inten-
We’ve learned that 10 core design participants can’t handle the feedback. tion to provide relevant material is
principles lead to a great experience. They are too fragile. They will some- laudable, this information is largely
1. Research-based content. Anyone how be damaged by our words or ignored. People can read. Give them
can cobble together some interesting those of colleagues. Or it may be our the content beforehand. Use the work-
exercises and experiences, but to what own insecurities. We might lose control shop as a learning laboratory where
end? We know the outcomes of great of the workshop. Emotions might run the participants are confronted with
leadership—alignment, engagement, rampant. We will not survive the real leadership situations. Challenge
retention, productivity, teamwork, them to practice leading higher levels.
agility. There is little mystery here. Create a curriculum that exposes par-
What many designers ignore is all the ticipants to intense experiences, and
research on what specific leadership allow them to experiment with new
behaviors, practices, and approaches behaviors and approaches. This will
create these outcomes. A great LD pro- accelerate their development. (Most
gram enables participants to make an savvy managers have read many of the
immediate, positive impact. tenets and books on leadership.)
2. Engagement. The frenzied pace 7. Peer coaching. In my survey,
that most managers face today has Coaching and Mentoring always comes
turned thoughtful participants into in second. One-on-one learning is pow-
skittish, distracted bystanders infected erful because, for a time, it really is all
by a self-imposed form of ADD with about me. Because coaching requires no
one eye on their Blackberry and the resulting damage. Remember, the content knowledge, any participant can
other eye on the door. It’s not that workshop is not about you; it’s about coach another with a little guidance. For
these managers are disinterested in the participant. Be bold in creating a those of us who make our living stand-
their development; they are simply feedback-rich environment. Someday, ing in the front of a classroom trying to
products of today’s frenzy. To get their participants will thank you for the gift. be insightful, witty and sage-like, we
attention, you must entertain them. 5. Appreciation. The problem with can’t accept that the average peer coach-
Describing a good LD program as many LD workshops is an underlying ing session is more effective than our
entertaining may be reckless, but if the assumption that the ideal leader needs most brilliant lecture. When possible, get
program can’t compete with the myri- to develop a predetermined set of com- your body and ego out of the way and
ad distractions facing managers, you petencies while becoming some fantas- let participants talk to each other.
will simply be hosting adult day-care. tic amalgamation of Mother Teresa, 8. Self-awareness. It has been said
Videos, stories, games, debates, physi- Martin Luther King, Gandhi, and Jack that LD is an inside-out game. I like
cal experiences and colorful materials Welch. We do not discard these ele- the way Manfred Kets De Vries puts it:
play a role in participant engagement. ments entirely from the design process. “Healthy leaders are passionate . . . They
3. Story-telling. Every participant Culture and strategy rightly have a are very talented in self-observation and
comes to the workshop with their bearing on workshop design, and we self-analysis; the best leaders are highly
own unique leadership story that has can learn much from great leaders. motivated to spend time in self-reflection.”
grown out of their experiences, beliefs, However, the best LD workshops are The LD program provides the perfect
fears, biases, and aspirations. A great based on the assumption that all partic- opportunity for the leader to step out
workshop challenges the participant ipants come uniquely gifted for the of his or her chaotic schedule, put it in
to create a bigger story for him or her- challenge of leadership, and the role of neutral, and take a long, fresh look
self and the people that they lead. the workshop is to help them identify inward. After all, the only thing partic-
This can only happen when the partic- and cultivate these gifts. It is not our ipants can work on to improve their
ipant has the opportunity to tell his or job to help them become the next Steve leadership is themselves. Put sufficient
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 15
white space into the workshop design LEADERSHIP ENERGY reflecting and then writing down your
so participants can personalize the core values and sharing those values
learning. Most managers can’t remem- with others can focus your energy. The
ber the last time they took 15 minutes Energetic Leadership values you discover are likely to be val-
to contemplate their own leadership Build capacity for sustained success. ues that are closely held by others.
journey. Give them the 15 minutes. Purpose effectively focuses and use-
9. Performance breakthroughs. The fully expands energy. As evident in the
most frequently voiced dissatisfaction lives of passionate leaders, a sense of
by Kevin Cashman
with leadership workshops is the lack purpose generates great energy. Aligning
of application on the job. It’s not your energies with your purpose in
because workshop participants do not
want to change; it’s just that real
change is so difficult. The pressures of
S INCE ENERGY IS A DE-
fining characteristic
of leadership, how can
serving others creates more value in all
you do and benefits those you lead.
the job, lack of support from their man- you generate more energy for leading Healthy Habits
ager, no time . . . the list goes on. people in teams and organizations? What’s the secret to being more
Significant improvement in leadership One answer is to amp up your “rela- energetic? Ironically, it’s rest. Sound
effectiveness rarely occurs in one big tional energy” by being around other sleep, meditation, and deep breathing
leap. We don’t see the freshly-trained people who have high energy. For are habits that improve the physical,
leader walking through the hallways example, when asked to comment on mental, emotional, and spiritual
wearing saffron-colored robes, musing their experience in the grueling CEO aspects of life. Nature and its cycles of
about shared community values and Ironman Challenge, participating exec- rest and activity provide a reference
throwing rose petals on others utives often talk of the relational energy
point. The interplay of day and night
(metaphorically speaking, that is). they gain from their race mates, rather and the seasonal cycles constantly bal-
Change occurs incrementally and is ance a rest phase with an active phase.
than the physical energy drain of the test.
fueled by short-term successes—a Today, you can’t just be leaders by You get to choose the quantity and
process that needs to start in the class- rank, title, or position—you must be a quality of your activity and rest. Choose
room. Bar the classroom door and let true leader developed from the inside- poorly, and your life is out of whack.
no one leave until they have demon- out. Your ability to generate and Choose wisely, and you gain vitality.
strated at least 10 performance break- spread energy may be the most telling Energy management is largely a
throughs (metaphorically speaking). sign of your leadership. Managers matter of elevating the quality while
Real change starts in the workshop, not tend to such resources as time, money, reducing the quantity of your daily
back in the office. Start the habit of and technology. In contrast activities. Exercising, eating
experimentation and incremental to these resources, energy is healthy, quitting smoking,
change in the LD workshop. near-limitless—not so con- and reducing alcohol and
10. Learning accountability. I kick- strained by budgets and caffeine intake are healthy
off many of my leadership coaching boundaries and capable of habits. To improve your
assignments with the irritating ques- catalyzing great progress. emotional health, you can
tion: “So, Sally, if nothing changes in Energy is the subtext practice putting yourself in
your performance, what is likely to implied in “leading by the shoes of others and bet-
happen?” Besides the mischievous example.” To lead from a ter appreciate and express
delight I take in tormenting my clients, center of values and inter- appreciation to others. To
I’ve learned that I can serve them best ests, you must have a spark care for your mind, you
by insisting that they take full respon- of passion for or devotion to those can access learning resources—from
sibility for their actions, decisions, books to conversations to puzzles and
ideals. People don’t want to follow flat,
learning, and future. Unless they take motionless direction; what compels other forms of problem-solving.
personal accountability for their devel- them is bold, on-the-move inspiration. Spiritually, you can reflect more and
opment, they will always blame some- Switching from a time-management find trusted resources and communi-
one else—their board, staff, customer, ties to search out questions of the soul.
to an energetic leadership style requires
or mother. So, too, with a leadership a whole-person effort in physical, men- To boost your energy, you don’t
workshop. Often ask the question: tal, emotional, and spiritual domains. need to experience a dramatic transfor-
what have you learned about yourself Energy can emanate from people so mation—just focus on just one or two
and what are you going to do about it? powerfully that it reverberates through well-selected activities and practice
Our clients often report that the the culture for years. Consider the ROE them consistently. To gain and maintain
time they spend in our LD workshops (return on energy) of Martin Luther high daily energy, you need to cultivate
is the best of their careers. Is this King, Jr. and Mahatma Ghandi. Their the proper daily habits and state of
because we have great facilitators? Yes, being. As many CEOs have discovered,
vigor inspired people to act differently.
we do, and a great facilitator can turn deeply-engrained, focused energy is the
almost any curriculum into an impor- Purpose Drives Energ y lifeblood of high-impact leadership. It
tant learning experience. But we also To be powerful, energy needs to be fosters happiness and optimism, deeper
try to adhere to these design principles, rooted in shared meaning. Many people and more proactive thinking, and ulti-
which tell us that the workshop is not are active or busy, but their energy is mately brings about more accomplish-
about us but about the participants. LE misplaced in areas of secondary inter- ment with less investment. LE
est. To lead with purpose, you must
Gregg Thompson is President of Bluepoint Leadership. Email Kevin Cashman is a senior partner with Korn/Ferry
greggthompson@bluepointleadership.com or visit www.blue- take pause, listening to the body, mind International and leadership columnist for Forbes.com. E-mail
pointleadership.com. and spirit and appreciating the good kevincashman@leadersource.com.
ACTION: Redesign your LD program. things in your life. Sometimes simply ACTION: Practice energetic leadership.
16 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
PERFORMANCE SERVICE the belief that customers deserve their
best. However, ensuring that imagina-
tive service happens consistently
Imaginative Service requires a special brand of leadership.
Take-their-breath-away service
Cultivate qualities of imaginative leaders. requires an atmosphere of innovation.
Imaginative service leaders are innova-
tors. They seek out people doing new
customers giggle, reflect, swoon, or and different things and provide them
swell with pride? For example: support, eliminate obstacles, and
1. You take a vacation on a Disney ensure that their different drumbeat
Cruise Line trip that begins with a few always keeps them marching. They
days at Walt Disney World theme park. take the heat for these mavericks. They
The morning you are to shift from your are tolerant of eccentricities, choosing to
by Chip R. Bell and John R. Patterson hotel to the cruise ship, you are told to pay attention to results more than style,
leave your luggage in their hotel room to see special gifts as something more
18 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
PERFORMANCE EXAMPLES tage of opportunities.
Gary Kelly, CEO of Southwest.
Southwest Airlines posted its 35th con-
Rhino-Leaders secutive year of profitability, was the
most punctual, lost the fewest bags,
Why do these people excel? and had the fewest complaints. Why?
Southwest has a rhino for a leader
who communicates that while other
time when gas prices were soaring, the airlines are cutting back on amenities
by Christian D. Warren
housing market was in a big slump, and charging for services like checking
and the mood in the country could be bags, Southwest would offer more ser-
launched the updated iPhone at a in moving quickly and taking advan- ACTION: Start charging like a rhino.
L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 19
PERFORMANCE RECOVERY deadline. If not, deal with it immediate-
ly. When people fail to meet goals or
deadlines, ask what actions you can
Get Back on Track take and what’s required from others?
10. Are you watching for busywork?
Reaffirm strategy and priority. Attend to staff and other functions, such
as accounting, HR, and IT. Are they
effective way to instill accountability engaging in non-essential work and
and achieve objectives. It’s the perfect generating unnecessary reports instead
by Bob Prosen forum to review results, remove road- of actions that support top objectives?
blocks, ask for assistance, and hold 11. Have you run out of time to plan?
20 O c t o b e r 2 0 0 8 L e a d e r s h i p E x c e l l e n c e
Leadership Excellence
Celebrating 25 Years of Excellence
Team Leadership
($10/month) Leadership Excellence
F or 25 years, our three monthly magazines
have been the source for the best and
brightest insights from all the top consultants,
Leadership Excellence ■ 1-year (12 issues) $129 coaches, authors, and executives.
brings together the best ■ 2-year (24 issues) $219
Use our FREE Development Tools:
thinking in the world, from ■ 3-year (36 issues) $269
all the top practioners, in a • Personal Excellence Plan, an easy-to-use
time-effective format. guide designed to help you create and imple-
ment vision, mission, goals, and priorities.
Recent contributors include: Marshall Goldsmith, Jim Collins, Tom Peters, Anne Mulcahy,
Warren Bennis, Michael Porter, Margaret Wheatley, Patrick Lencioni, and many others! • Excellence Worksheet, the perfect way to
bring Excellence into your personal study
or team meeting.