Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10
Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Sales 132,096 132,096 132,096 132,096 132,096
Cost of sales 79,258 79,258 79,258 79,258 79,258
Gross profit 52,838 52,838 52,838 52,838 52,838
Fixed cash 40,000 40,000 40,000 40,000 40,000
Depreciation 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000
NOI 2,838 2,838 2,838 2,838 2,838
Taxes (30%) 852 852 852 852 852
NOPAT 0 3,690 3,690 3,690 3,690 3,690
plus: Dep 0 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000
Initial outlay -55,000 0 0 0 0 0
Salvage value 0 0 0 0 0 5,000
FCF -55,000 13,690 13,690 13,690 13,690 18,690
12
Project Cost of Capital
Firm-wide WACC can bias investment decisions
toward risky projects
2. Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate (RADR)
• CAPM Model, which only reflects non-diversifiable
risk, provides a “rough estimate”
Project X Project Y
NPV @ 12% 10,560.24 19,211.70
NPV @ RADR 5,008.13 4,981.88
3. Certainty Equivalents
• Technique that adjusts the risky after-tax cash
flows to certain cash flows.
• The greater the risk associated with a
particular cash flow, the smaller the CE factor
(in %)
n
NPV = Σt=1
Certain CFt
(1 + Rf) t
- CF0
18
Certainty Equivalents
ACYFMG is considering a new project that their research division has
proposed and have decided to use the certainty equivalent approach
to evaluate it. The expected cash flows and the estimated certainty
equivalent coefficients associated with this project are as follows:
Year Expected Certainty Equivalent
Cash Flows Coefficients
0 -P71,000 1.00
1 18,000 .90
2 28,000 .80
3 38,000 .70
4 28,000 .60
5 18,000 .50
Compute for change/s in NPV if: unit sales (+5%), sales price (+5%),
variable cost per unit (+5%) and cash fixed cost (+5%)
Sensi0vity Analysis
The following table shows the impact on NPV of changes in the
value drivers.
Expected 1,001,714.68 26.65%
From the analysis, we can conclude that this is a risky investment because
NPV negative at worst case scenario but more than doubled at best case
30
7. Probability Trees
• A probability tree (or decision tree)
is a visual representation of the
sequential choices that managers
face over time with regard to a
particular investment.
! The value of decision trees is that they force analysts
to think through a series of “if-then” statements that
describe how they will react as the future unfolds.
! To work through a decision tree, begin calculation of
expected NPV at the end and then work backward to
the to evaluate today’s decision.
Probability Tree
• A fast food chain is deciding whether spend P675,000 to
test market acceptability of a branch at a new location
• If consumer acceptance is high (50% chance), the fast
food chain may spend an additional P1.3M one year later
to open the branch at the new location. The company
predicts that the new branch will generate net cash
inflows of P550,000 per year for 12 years after opening
the branch.
• If consumers respond less favorably in the market test,
the fast food chain will not proceed with opening the new
branch.
• Cost of capital is 15%.
32
Probability Tree
Year 0 Year 1-13
Favorable and open
50% CF (1) = -1.3M
CF (2-13) = 550,000/ yr
Test
(-675,000)
Not test
(nil)
Probability Tree
Year 0 Year 1-13
Favorable and open
50% CF (1) = -1.3M
CF (2-13) = 550,000/ yr
Test
(-675,000) NPV = 1,681,340.45
NPV = nil
Not test
(nil)
35
Real or Strategic Op0ons
in Capital Budge0ng
Opportunities that allow for the alteration of the
project’s cash flow stream while the project is being
operated
Contract,
Shut-down, • options to slow down production,
and halt production temporarily, or stop
production permanently
Abandonment
(abandonment)
options
Types of Real Op0ons
Follow-on
investment • Similar to expansion options, but
more complex (Ex: movie rights to
options sequel)
P(favorable)
=50% NPV= P1,500,000
=[(650,000/10%)-5M]
Expected NPV to
build (without
op0on)=-500,000
NPV = -P2,500,000
P(Unfavorable)
[(250,000/10%)-5M]
=50%
Recognizing Real Op0ons
P(favorable)
=50% Build up to 10 restaurants
NPV =10 x
[(650,000/10%)-5M]= 15M
Expected NPV to build
(with op0ons)= P6,250,000
Build only 1 restaurant
NPV =
P(Unfavorable)
[(250,000/10%)-5M]=
=50% -2.5M
Recognizing Real Op0ons
Expected NPV (without option)
= [(50%)(P1,500,000)] + [(50%)(-P2,500,000)]
= -P500,000
-500,000 ? 6,250,000
P 6,750,000
Illustra0ve: Real Op0ons
A celebrity was offered a two-year exclusive
contract by his current network for P3,000,000
annually. If he accept the contract, the network
retains the rights and he will not be able to
accept projects of other network during the
contract period. He was also offered a non-
exclusive contract at a price of P2,000,000 per
year wherein he will be allowed to accept
projects of other networks. What is the value of
the op0on to accept projects from other
networks during the two-year contract? Assume a
discount rate of 5%.
44
CONTENTS
2.4.1 Risk and the Investment Decision
2.4.2 Incorpora0ng Risk into Capital Budge0ng
2.4.2.1 Breakeven Cash Inflow
2.4.2.2 Risk-Adjusted Discount Rates
2.4.2.3 Certainty Equivalents
2.4.2.4 Simula0on
2.4.2.5 Sensi0vity and Scenario Analysis
2.4.2.6 Probability Trees
2.4.3 Real Op0ons in Capital Budge0ng
Key Takeaways
• ?
End of 2.4
Prepare for Quiz 3
Knowledge Check
KC: True or False
1. When a project’s NPV is nega0ve, it will not have a
discounted payback period because the ini0al
investment will be unrecoverable.
2. The NPV and IRR conflict in ranking projects may be
due to their differing assump0on on reinvestment of
intermediate cash inflows.
3. Simula0on is a more complex form of sensi0vity
analysis
4. Capital ra0oning is the situa0on in which a firm can
raise only a specified, limited amount of capital
regardless of how many good projects it has.
5. Op0ons can transform a project’s posi0ve NPV into
nega0ve NPV
49
KC: True or False
6. A conflict will exist between the NPV and IRR methods, when
used to evaluate two projects, if the projects' cost of capital is
higher than the crossover rate of the two projects.
7. The greater the risk associated with a par0cular cash flow, the
larger its Certainty Equivalent factor.
8. An increase in the firm's WACC would have no impact on its
IRR. However, this could change the accept/reject decision
under the IRR method.
9. Profitability index allows comparison of the rela0ve
desirability of projects that require differing ini0al
investments
10. The NPV of a project whose large cash flows are received
early in the project’s life will be more sensi0ve to changes in
the discount rate than the NPV of a project whose cash flows
come in later in its life.
KC: Mul0ple Choice
11. Sensi0vity and Scenario analysis both evaluates the
effect of changing value drivers on the project’s NPV;
their difference is that Sensi0vity analysis involves
changing ___ while Scenario analysis involves
changing ____.
A. the discount rate, the cash flows
B. The cash flows, the discount rate
C. one value driver, mul0ple value drivers
D. mul0ple value drivers, one value driver
51
KC: Mul0ple Choice
12. When a project’s NPV is posi0ve, its
profitability index is greater than ___ and its
IRR is ____ its cost of capital
52
KC: Mul0ple Choice
13. Deficiencies associated with using the
payback method to evaluate investment
alterna0ves include:
53
KC: Mul0ple Choice
14. The accountant of AT, Inc. has prepared an analysis of a
proposed capital project using net present value technique.
The manager has ques0oned the accuracy of the results
because the discount factors employed in the analysis are
based on the assump0ons that the cash flows occurred at the
end of the year when they actually occurred uniformly
throughout each year. The net present value calculated by
the accountant
A. will be slightly overstated
B. will be slightly understated
C. will be misleading because the correc0on can reverse a posi0ve
NPV into a nega0ve NPV
D. will not need correc0on because the 0ming of cash flows does not
mater in NPV calcula0on
54
KC: Mul0ple Choice
15. In capital budge0ng analysis, the “payback
reciprocal” may provide a quick and useful es0mate
of the internal rate of return only when
A. Cash inflows do not extend beyond the length of the payback
period
B. Most of the cash inflows from an investment precede the
investment outlay
C. The investment outlays are made uniformly throughout the life
of the investment
D. Cash inflows are uniform throughout the life of an investment
which is long rela0ve to its payback period
55
KC: Mul0ple Choice
16. When the cost of capital of a project
decreases, its profitability index will:
A. increase
B. decrease
C. be the same
D. may increase or decrease
56
KC: Mul0ple Choice
17. If the internal rate of return on an
investment is zero:
A. its NPV is posi0ve
B. Its future cash flows equal its ini0al investment.
C. it is generally a wise investment.
D. its cash flows decrease over its life.
57
KC: Mul0ple Choice
18. Which of the following problem does
Modified IRR resolves?
A. Mul0ple IRR
B. Nonexistent IRR
C. Time disparity
D. Scale disparity
58
KC: Mul0ple Choice
19. Which technique put emphasis on the
impact of the project on the net income rather
than the expected cash flows.
59
KC: Mul0ple Choice
20. Which capital budge0ng methods require
the use of the present value?
A. Net present value and 0me-adjusted rate of return
B. Payback and accoun0ng rate of return
C. Accoun0ng rate of return and 0me-adjusted rate of
return
D. Accoun0ng rate of return, 0me-adjusted rate of return,
net present value and payback.
60
KC: Problem Solving
21. Grimaldi Company invested in an eight-year
project. It is expected that the annual cash
flow form the project, net of income taxes, will
be P82,500. Assuming that Amy based its
investment decision on an internal rate of
return of 13%, how much did the project cost?
61
KC: Problem Solving
22. A planned factory expansion project has an
es0mated ini0al cost of P800,000. Using a
discount rate of 20%, the present value of future
cost savings from the expansion is P843,000. To
yield a 0me adjusted rate of return of 20% or
more, the actual investment cost cannot exceed
the P800,000 es0mate by more than _____.
62
KC: Problem Solving
23. Silky Products is considering two pieces of
machinery. The first machine costs P50,000 more
than the second machine. During the two-year
life of these two alterna0ves, the first machine
has a P155,000 more cash flow in year one and a
P110,000 less cash flow in year two than the
second machine. All cash flows occur at year-end.
63
KC: Problem Solving
24. Jazz Insurance Company’s management is considering
an adver0sing program that would require an ini0al
expenditure of P291,280 and bring in addi0onal sales
over the next five years. The cost of adver0sing is
immediately recognized as expense. The projected
addi0onal sales revenue in Year 1 is P75,000, with
associated expenses of P25,000. The addi0onal sales
revenue and expenses from the adver0sing program
are projected to increase by 10% each year.
a. Assuming a tax rate of 30%, the payback period for
the adver0sing program is ___.
b. Compute for the payback reciprocal rate
64
KC: Problem Solving
25. OMG Company has decided to invest in some new
equipment. The equipment will have a three-year life
and will produce a uniform series of cash savings. The
net present value of the equipment is P115,700, using
a discount rate of 8%. The internal rate of return is
12%.
65
KC: Problem Solving
26. Swing Inc. is considering a project with the following cash flows.
Year Cash Flow
0 (P520,000)
1 P 255,000
2 P 160,000
3 P 347,000
4 (P 132,000)
5 P 289,500
68