1

MODUL PERKULIAHAN

W572100002
Sistem Rekayasa
dan Nilai
VE - Evaluasi Desain

Abstrak Sub-CPMK

Studi kasus VE Evaluasi desain

Fakultas Program Studi Tatap Muka Disusun Oleh

Teknik Magister Teknik Sipil

15 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
VE - Evaluasi Desain

Pendahuluan

Tinjauan teori dan penerapan rekayasa nilai khususnya pada proyek infrastruktur perlu
dipelajari lebih lanjut. Berikut, contoh kasus penerapan rekayasa nilai pada mega proyek
Jembatan Selat Sunda (JSS) atau Selat Sunda Bridge (SSB) dengan fokus pada
pengembangan alternatif berdasarkan evaluasi desain dengan tujuan optimalisasi fungsi
dan biaya.

Perhatikan kasus sejenis dan pelajari data, analisis serta hasil dan pembahasannya lebih
lanjut.

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

2 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Background

Infrastructure development plays an important role to stimulate nation’s economic

growth.

Along 2011, Infrastructure industry contributes 5,5% for GDP of Indonesia with real
growth of 9,3% (BMI, 2013)

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

3 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Introduction

The existence of Sunda Strait Bridge (SSB) is expected to contribute to national

economic growth by bridging economic connectivity between two major islands in
Indonesia, Java and Sumatera.

Sunda Strait Bridge (SSB) was offered as US$ 10 billion in 2008 but lack of
interest from private sector due to its feasibility.

The second revision in 2011, the SSB was offered as US$ 25 billion with additional
scope of works to build industrial areas along the site.

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

4 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
The Challenges

Value Engineering
approach
•Economic growth
•Technical aspect
enhancement
•Value creation •Financial aspect
•Infrastructure
connectivity •Quality improvement •Create value -
development •Innovation through added
additional functions
•Application new
SSB project Technology Feasibility project

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

5 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Creating Added Value

Creating value for money for Sunda Strait Bridge investment.

A need to create additional functions for the project i.e. Innovation and/or cost
reduction.

V = Value
F = Function (Requirement from Customers)
C = Cost (Life Cycle Cost)

(SAVE International, 2007)

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

6 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Research Methodology

Aim and
Objectives

Literature
Examination Review
VE Study
on current Analysis of Technical
(Innovation and
project and Economic aspect
Value Creation)
situation
Benchmarking
studies
First Phase

Financial Analysis Conceptual Design

Action Research
of SSB of SSB

Strategic Policy
Development Second Phase

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

7 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Theoritical Background
Function and Innovation

Identifying functions in VE study enables us to propose alternative ways to perform

those functions in the act of idea generation.

Real World Processes A

Outcomes Causality
Alt Processes
Recognition of processes in
Processes A relation to functions leads to
ideas. Further, this can be
extended to suggest new
functions and new purposes.
Purpose Functions

New Extended
Purpose Functions
Intentionality
Conceptual

Functional thinking enables Innovation

(Berawi & Woodhead, 2008)

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

8 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Theoritical Background
Risk Management

Risk management plays an important role to reduce losses or damage from unwanted
events that related to the situation and environment of SSB project.

Risk
Identification

Internal External

Operational
Planning and Political - Social -
Construction and
Design Environment Economic
Maintenance

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

9 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Theoritical Background
Public – Private Partnership (PPP) Scheme

Public Private Partnership (PPP) scheme is a collaboration between government and

private sectors in the provision of infrastructures development and services. This
scheme is expected to increase added value to both parties through division of
responsibility and fair financial and risk distribution of the project.

Public Common Private

Sector Interest Sector

Public private partnership collaboration

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

10 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Result and Discussion
I. Value Engineering
Additional Function (Innovation)

Innovation in Sunda Strait Bridge (SSB) is driven by seeking potential resources

lies around Sunda Strait including:

Natural resources such as great wind and moderate tidal current

Potential tourism to be developed at Sangiang island (700 ha) around

Sunda Strait

Potential efficiency in oil and gas distribution as well as providing

telecommunication and internet network

Heavy industries development in Java and Sumatra

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

11 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Result and Discussion
Fast Diagram

HOW IF - THEN WHY

Create Added Develop Infrastructure Resist Natural Ensure Safety

Value Connectivity Disaster

Design Objective All the Time Increase Economic

Function Function and Social Benefit

Construct
Hanging
Train

Construct
Toll Road

Construct
Construct Railway
Upper Protect
Structure Construct Public
Fiber optic Interest

Construct
Stimulate Transport Oil&Gas
Connecting Distribute Construct
Economic People and Pipeline Generate
two Island Load Bridge
Goods
Growth Income
Construct
Wind
Turbine
Create Expand Produce Transmit
Tourism Industrial Energy Data/Telecom Construct
Construct
Industry Areas & Electrical Lower
Tidal Power
Power Structure

Distribute Develop
Oil & Gas Manufacture
Industry
Support
Environment
Surrounding
Develop
National/
International
Port

Purpose FUNCTIONS ANALYSIS FOLLOWED BY PROCESSES Outcomes

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

12 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/
Daftar Pustaka

Developing Conceptual Design of Mega Infrastructure Project: Creating Innovation and Added Value
Mohammed Ali Berawi, University of Indonesia, 2013

2021 Sistem Rekayasa dan Nilai

13 Dr. Ir. Budi Susetyo, MT
Biro Bahan Ajar E-learning dan MKCU
http://pbael.mercubuana.ac.id/