English (/)

(/misc/sitemap/categories.html)
 En Français (https://fr.allafrica.com/)
(/commerce/user/manage/)



Countries
Topics
Coronavirus (/coronavirus/)
Development
BizTech
Entertainment
Sport
Africa/World
Governance
Multimedia
Sustainability (/sustainable/)

By AllAfrica (/inhouse/)
News Sources (/list/publisher/editorial/editorial/type/pub.html)
Media Kit (https://partners.allafrica.com/)
Who We Are (/misc/info/about/)
Contact Us (/misc/forms/general.html)
Donate (/commerce/contribute/)

Uganda Surrenders Airport for China Cash

Morgan Mb ab azi / East African (https://www.theeastafrican.co.ke/tea/b usiness/foreign-financiers-troop-to-uganda-eye-

Entebbe International Airport in 2013.

The Monitor (Kampala)

(http://www.monitor.co.ug/)
By Yasiin Mugerwa

Top Ugandan officials have been boxed into a corner of bother after lenders in China rejected their request to re-negotiate 'toxic c
picked six years ago to expand Entebbe International Airport.

Some of the unfavourable provisions in the loan agreement that Uganda signed with the Export-Import (Exim) Bank of China on M
Uganda's sovereign assets to attachments and take-over upon arbitration awards in Beijing.

Our investigations found out that any proceedings against Uganda Civil Aviation Authority (UCAA) assets by the lender would no
since Uganda government, in the 2015 deal, waived the immunity on airport assets.

Highly-placed sources said the risk presented by the Financing Agreement on March 7, 2019, prompted Uganda to send an 11-m
with Exim Bank to renegotiate the clauses now impugned by Kampala.

The joint team from the Works, Foreign Affairs, and Finance ministries, as well as UCAA and Attorney General's Chambers, was
Ambassador to China.
In the meeting, the four Exim Bank executives reportedly rejected any amendments to clauses of the signed Financing Agreeme
English (/)
executives that any attempts to make alterations would set a (/misc/sitemap/categories.html)
bad precedent. In addition, the Chinese told their guests that they
 En Français (https://fr.allafrica.com/)
amendment. (/commerce/user/manage/)

The lenders advised Dr Kiyonga and his team to accept "friendly consultations" from time to time, to ensure smooth implementa
They also agreed to keep the details of the meeting confidential.

China freezes cash

Our investigations over several months show that Uganda dispatched a delegation to Beijing after Exim Bank suspended funding
after UCAA failed to implement some of the clauses, which were not favourable to Uganda.

The loan agreement requires UCAA to set up an escrow account to hold all of the Authority's revenues.

An escrow is a contractual arrangement in which a third party receives and disburses money or property for the primary transact
dependent on conditions agreed to by the transacting parties, according to Wikipedia.

The agreement provides that UCAA cannot use any of the accrued money for whatever expenditure without approval from Beijing

Realising that some of the loan agreement clauses were not being implemented, Exim Bank froze cash flow to the contractor, a

For instance, the construction firm's payment certificate No.11 up to 23, amounting to $24.5m (Shs87b) for work done from Dece
paid.

Lack of finances affected the contractor and work slowed down almost to a standstill. By the time the Chinese accepted to resu
days and the country was under lockdown.

"These conditions were not palatable for an international airport of a sovereign State whose operations are dynamic and sometim
latest response to queries by Parliament.

The Chinese agreed to resume bankrolling the project, but refused to amend the problematic clauses that they signed with the g

They instead proposed a clarification of the contentious clauses, which UCAA now considers insufficient.

While the initial agenda of the meeting in Beijing was to cause a re-negotiation of specific clauses in the original Financing Agre
in his response to the aviation and Works ministry officials, noted:

"The Exim Bank officials made it clear from the onset that re-negotiation and amendment of the loan agreement were not agreea

In two letters with similar content, but dated differently; September 5, 2019 and January 14, 2020, Mr Kasaija told former Works
meeting in Beijing endorsed a mutually-agreed 'minute of resolutions' reached as an output rather than amendment of the loan ag
Ugandan officials restless.

"It was the understanding of all parties that to achieve a win-win situation, the contentious clauses would be interpreted with a vie
enable resumption of disbursements without necessarily amending the agreement," Mr Kasaija's January 14, 2020 letter reads in

Consternation

In the corridors of Works and UCAA, Mr Kasaija's response on the matter according to sources, was treated with disdain for alle
real risks to Uganda's sovereign assets.

The technocrats accused the minister of risking Entebbe International Airport, and other national assets, and Works ministry sp
of the problematic clauses.

On September 8, the then UCAA acting director general, Mr Fred Bamwesigye, now the substantive office holder, wrote to Work
Wamala, reminding him about the need to renegotiate the loan Financing Agreement.

He also requested him to remind Minister Kasaija to notify Exim Bank of the need to amend the agreement to make it consisten

"Whereas some of the provisions referred to were alluded to in the Minutes of the Negotiations, the unfair clauses remain embed
cases, they were not dealt with at all... There is, therefore, an urgent need to start the review and renegotiation of the Governmen
order to reduce the intentions of the parties into a legally-binding agreement," Mr Bamwesigye wrote. He attached a list of unfair

Bounced to AG

Ms Susan Kataike, the Ministry of Works spokesperson, and her Finance counterpart Jim Mugunga, declined to comment on th
that have turned into a legal and diplomatic conundrum for Uganda.

They referred this newspaper for explanation to Attorney General Kiryowa Kiwanuka, who is just five months on the job yet gover

Mr Kiryowa was in Parliament and unable to speak when we contacted him yesterday.

Solicitor General Francis Atoke, the top technocrat in the Attorney General's office, said he was not aware of the problematic cla
unable to comment.

We were unable to reach Exim Bank officials in China by press time.

Toxic clauses

Back in Uganda, UCAA officials, have flagged up to 13 clauses in the agreement as "unfair and erode the sovereignty of Uganda

The agreements authorises Exim Bank to approve UCAA withdrawals yet there is a statutory board mandated to do so.

"It's clear that [U]CAA will lose its rights of use and control over its revenues... . as a self-financing institution with limited funding
organisation to risk of failure in service delivery and bankruptcy," a source said.
Among the controversial provisions is a surrendering under the airport loan agreement of the approval of UCAA budget, master an
English (/)
(/misc/sitemap/categories.html)
the mandates of the aviation regulator's board, to Exim Bank in Beijing.  En Français (https://fr.allafrica.com/)
(/commerce/user/manage/)
"This also exposes UCAA to risk of failure to deliver its mandate, and infringes on State's effective control over UCAA," Prof Davi
general, who retired in June last year, wrote. He added: "There is, therefore, urgent need to start the review and renegotiation of t
Agreement on the upgrading and expansion of Entebbe International Airport Phase I project, together with [other] agreements...
parties into a legally binding agreement."

The Government Concessional Loan Agreement provides conditions for signing three other agreements: On-lending agreement b
Mechanism Agreement between Exim Bank and Uganda and [U]CAA and then, Escrow Account Agreement between Uganda, U

Under Section 3 of the Repayment Mechanism Agreement and Section 3.1 (a) of the Escrow Account Agreement, it's required t
will be prepared and submitted for approval to both government and Exim Bank. Under subsection (b), Exim Bank has the right t

Similarly, monthly operating budgets are to be approved to the escrow account in a form acceptable to Exim Bank. The bank is
and government Books of Accounts, which erodes the sovereignty of the State.

More gaps

Whereas Section 14.1 of Repayment Mechanism Agreement provides that the governing laws shall be the laws of Uganda, Sect
where mutual discussions fail, be resolved by the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (CIETAC) in B
Kasaija, "directly undermines the legal regime to which the entire agreement is subject to."

Section 11.1 (f) of the Escrow Account Agreement put emphasis on the fact that the arbitration in Beijing court is legal, valid, bin
any award obtained in CIETAC will, if introduced, be received and accepted for enforcement in any proceedings against the borro
their respective assets in Uganda.

Red flag

On December 11, 2019, Prof Kakuba warned Mr Kasaija that Exim Bank can legally enforce any clauses of the loan agreement
earlier.

"Any seeming delay or any form of understanding that is not reduced into an amended agreement of the signed ones, would mai
the disputed agreement," he wrote.

Section 10.3 of the Repayment Mechanism Agreement provides for waiver of immunity, and states as follows:

"Each obligor hereby irrevocably waives any immunity on grounds of sovereign or other immunity for itself or any of its property in
proceeding or with enforcement of any arbitral awards any court judgement.'

Such a provision, if not amended, argued Prof Kakuba, "exposes government assets to attachments and take-over upon arbitrati

MPs grill Kasaija

During the October 28 interface with Cosase, members tasked Mr Kasaija and his technical team to explain the airport loan agre
diligence, but he could not explain how Uganda ended up surrendering its sovereignty to the Chinese for cash.

Mr Juvenal Muhumuza, an assistant commissioner at the Finance ministry, and Ms Molly Apio, a legal adviser at the same mini
that they reviewed the agreement, especially on the waiver of immunity and that some conditions could not be negotiated.

Ms Apio, however, didn't tell the committee that the Chinese creditors had outrightly rejected any requests for renegotiation and
agreement.

The failure to renegotiate the toxic clauses has exposed Entebbe International Airport and other government assets staked for th

Cosase members asked Mr Kasaija to furnish them with the checklist used to evaluate the feasibility of the loan agreement for U

What is at stake?

The revelation that Uganda government signed an agreement and, among others, waived immunity for its sovereign assets has ra
scrutiny and due diligence that bureaucrats conduct before committing the country internationally.

Appearing before Parliament's Committee on Commissions, Statutory Authorities and State Enterprise (Cosase) chaired by Nak
Ssenyonyi on October 28, Finance Minister Matia Kasaija apologised over the less-than-satisfactory scrutiny of the Entebbe Inte
Agreement.

"In the unlikely event that UCAA were to fail to generate sufficient revenue to service the loan [from Exim Bank), then the central
journalists after appearing before Cosase.

Mr Kasaija told MPs that they at the time in 2015 considered the China loan offer as the "best possible alternative and jumped o
countries walk into what academics and critics brand as Beijing's 'debt trap'.

SIGN UP FOR FREE ALLAFRICA NEWSLETTERS

Get the latest in African news delivered straight to your inbox
 English (/)
(/misc/sitemap/categories.html)
 En Français (https://fr.allafrica.com/)
(/commerce/user/manage/)

Top Headlines Uganda Transport

someone@example.com

By submitting above, you agree to our privacy policy (/misc/info/privacy.html).

A number of countries, some in Africa, have had to forfeit national assets for direct control by China after failing to repay comme
proper scrutiny, such as the Financing Agreement to bankroll new terminal, cargo and fuel centre works.

For instance, in December 2017, Sri Lanka lost its Hambantota Port to China for a 99-year lease after failing to show commitme
loans.

The transfer, according to New York Times, gave China full control of the territory just a few hundred miles off the shores of rival I

In September 2018, Zambia also lost Kenneth Kaunda International Airport to China over debt gone-wrong. The Chinese lenders
state broadcasting company, ZNBC.

Parliament criticized

Although MPs on Cosase queried Minister Kasaija and his technical team over failure to remove toxic clauses before signing the
ministry and UCAA, have accused the lawmakers of approving the loan request yet they contained glaring gaps.

Our investigations have also confirmed that the loan in question was scrutinised by Parliament's National Economy Committee a

According to document retrieved from Parliament Library, the National Economy Committee scrutinised this particular loan reque
the loan agreement.

On March 24, 2015, the Finance minister presented a formal motion in Parliament, seeking to borrow $325 million (Shs1.1 trillion

However, after scrutiny, the Committee chaired by former MP Xavier Kyooma discovered that $125m (Shs444b) lacked documen

During the consideration of the National Economy Committee report, presiding Speaker Jacob Oulanyah asked former Planning
motion.

After the minister amended the motion, Parliament authorised government to borrow $200m from Exim Bank at two percent upon
20 years, including a seven-year grace period.

The grace period lapses next year.

Authorities at UCAA learnt of the ambiguities in the Entebbe International Airport loan agreement during implementation and noti
also requested her Finance counterpart Kasaija to notify Exim Bank of the need to amend the loan agreement.

Available documents show that the government borrowed $325m from Exim Bank to finance and upgrade the expansion of Enteb

Exim Bank agreed and released $200m for the first phase of the upgrade and was later to provide additional $125m for the secon

The design-and-build contract for Entebbe International Airport project is being implemented by UCAA at a contract price of $200
(Shair & Partners) supervising consultants at a supervision price of $1.18m, including Value Added Tax.

This is not the first project financed by China's Exim Bank. The bank has funded about 85 percent of two major Ugandan power p
The Chinese Bank also financed and built Kampala's $476 million (Shs1.7 trillion) Entebbe Express Highway to Entebbe.

Read the original article (https://www.monitor.co.ug/uganda/news/national/uganda-surrenders-airport-for-china-cash-363

(http://www.monitor.co.ug/).

Copyright (https://allafrica.com/misc/info/copyright.html) © 2021 The Monitor (http://www.monitor.co.ug/). All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Me
holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here. (https://allafrica.com/view/publisher/edi

AllAfrica is a voice of, by and about Africa - aggregating, producing and distributing 700 news and information items daily from over 100 African news
organizations and our own reporters to an African and global public. We operate from Cape Town, Dakar, Abuja, Johannesburg, Nairobi and Washington DC.

© 2021 AllAfrica (/misc/info/copyright.html)

AllAfrica - All the Time