Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Materials
Processing
Technology
ELSEVIER Journal of Materials Processing Technology 58 (1996) 174 183
Industrial summary
In this work, a process sequence for multi-stage cold forging is designed with the rigid-plastic finite element method to form a
constant-velocity joint (CVJ) housing with shaft. The material flow during the forming of a CVJ housing is axisymmetric until the
final forging process for the forming of the ball grooves. The numerical approach in this study treats the deformation as an
axisymmetric case. The main objective of the process-sequence design is to design preforms which satisfy the design criterion of
a near-net-shape product requiring less machining after forming without any defects. It also included investigation of velocity
distributions, effective strain distributions, and forging loads, which are useful information in process design. A systematic
approach to process-sequence design is established using the finite-element method for the cold forging of the CVJ housing.
1
Fig. 2. Results of simulations of the conventional five-operation process [19].
176 J.-H. Lee et al./ Journal of Materials Processing Technology 58 (1996) 174 183
_d- -t_
Die s e m i - a n g l e : 35.50
R e d u c t i o n of a r e a : 64%
Fig. 4. Simulation of forward extrusion: (a) initial billet; (b) stroke of 60%; and (c) final deformation and effective-strain distribution.
Fig. 5(c). The high value of effective strain near to the final product, it would be helpful to be able to
the punch tip reflects severe plastic deformation, as obtain some knowledge of the metal flow involved in
shown in Fig. 5(b). In the next operation of deep the backward extrusion. Simulations are conducted us-
backward-extrusion, mainly the upper part of Y-shaped ing the trial dies with punch I and die I, as shown in
Preform P C D F deforms. Complete filling in this opera- Fig. 6(a). The simulation results of the backward extru-
tion can cause the final forging load exceeding the press sion and the last operation of ironing process appear in
capacity so that the upsetting operation is stopped Figs. 8(a) and (b), respectively.
before complete filling. It is necessary that the preform The left side of Fig. 8(c) displays the velocity field of
be annealed to obtain sufficient formability prior to the preform (Preform PDBE-I) after the third opera-
deep backward-extrusion. Since the annealing treat- tion, and the right side of the figure describes the final
ment of the workpiece means a strain-free state in product, with dimensions, after the ironing operation.
simulation using the finite-element method, Preform As shown in Fig. 8(b), the top surface of the cup
P C D F is considered to be in the state of zero-strain at opening in the final product is not in close contact with
the start of the next simulation. Remeshing is carried the punch after ironing, which indicates that sound and
out again for simulation of the next operation (see precise forming at the top surface is not achieved. The
Fig. 5(c)). undesirable forming at the top surface can be assumed
Fig. 6 shows the die configuration designed for the to occur for the reason that an excessive amount of
following deep backward-extrusion process, hereinafter material deforms radially outside at the top part in the
the process being referred to as backward extrusion. backward extrusion, as shown in the right side of Fig.
In this operation, the dies are designed carefully, 8(a). During the ironing operation, the thickness of the
since the backward-extrusion process affects, directly, cup bottom becomes less than that of Preform PDBE-I.
the precision forming of the final product. In order to The dimensions in Fig. 8(c) differ from those of the real
obtain the net-shape final product, the preform from product of the CVJ housing (see Fig. 3(b)). The slope
the backward extrusion should be formed soundly and angle of the cup opening in the simulation is 33 ° , whilst
precisely before being used in the last operation, an the angle in the real product is 25 ° .
ironing process. The most stringent forging operation amongst all the
Fig. 7 shows the dies for ironing which is conducted operations is the third operation. Surface cracks may
by covering the male die of ball groove shape with the appear in the forming material near to the cup bottom
workpiece and having the female die extrude the outer along the direction of the circumference. Fig. 9 shows
rim of the workpiece upwards with bending. the relationship between the crack generation during
When investigating the effects of the preform shape forging and the thickness of the cup bottom in the case
derived from the backward extrusion on the forming of of CVJ forming with carbon steel [22].
178 J.-H. Lee et al./Journal of Materials Processing Technology 58 (I996) 174 183
(Unit : ram)
Preform PCDF
~95.0
~40.0
2 2!'5
1.51 2.0
2 (
~,o
(Unit : mm)
"-.j/N/A ~,
"1 '5.
DIE I DIE II
Fig. 6. Dimensions and configurations of the dies for deep backward-extrusion.
J.-H. Lee et al./Journal of Materials" Processing Technology 58 (1996) 174-183 179
(Unit : m m )
] 75.0
70.0
PUNCII 65.0
~- 2~ DIE +~ 60.0
"Q) 55,0
O DANGER ZONE / aJ C
>~ 50.0 /
DIE SAFE ZONE
//
/
/
11:3R]~ 1 0.0
0.0 l/ lo'.o 1 .o
/
14'.o 16.0
Bottom thickness(ram)
. ~ ¢a6.0 F
Fig. 9. Forming limit for surface cracks in the inner surface near to
Before ironing During i r o n i n g the cup bottom [22].
Fig. 7. Dimension and configuration of the dies for the ironing
process. height and corner radius of the punch are reduced
compared to those of punch I. The newly designed
The value calculated by the dimensions in Fig. 8(c) is punch is shown in Fig. 6(b) and is called punch II,
plotted as point A in Fig. 9, indicated to be inside the based on the previous discussion.
danger zone where surface cracks may occur. This is Fig. 10 shows the simulation results using the die set
caused by a large amount of deformation being concen- of punch II and die I, the third operation being shown
trated in the cup-bottom area of the forging. Based on in Fig. 10(a), and the last ironing operation in Fig.
the simulation results, the preform derived from the 10(b). Also, Fig. 10(c) shows the velocity field of the
backward extrusion influences the final product signifi- preform (Preform PDBE-II) formed in the third opera-
cantly. Especially, the control of the material flow near tion and the dimensions of the final product formed in
to the cup opening affects the configuration of the final the last operation.
product critically. In order to obtain the same dimen- For the case using Preform PDBE-II, the amount of
sions of the cup bottom and the same slope angle, and material flow into the top part is reduced in comparison
to fill the undeformed part near to the cup opening, the with the case of Preform PDBE-I. The deformation of
undesirable
formation
(Unit : ram)
• i
(Unit : ram)
Preform
_ 3 o ' ~
the inward cup opening is almost complete and the the stage when the inside punch is filled completely.
configuration of the final product in Fig. 10(c) is far Three stages of the last operation of ironing are shown
more desirable than the final configuration using Pre- in the right side of Fig. l l(a) (c).
form PDBE-I: however, it still does not satisfy the As shown in the right side of Fig. 1 l(c), there is no
dimensions of the cup bottom thickness and slope angle undeforming part, but the final dimensions are not the
of the CVJ housing. A surface crack does not appear in same as those of the product in Fig. 3(b). The slope
the forming material, the latter being represented by angle of the cup opening is 29 ° , which is larger than the
point B in Fig. 9. desired angle, but no surface cracks occur near to the
An attempt has been made to redesign the dies to cup bottom: point C in Fig. 9. The maximum die load
produce net-shape products without machining after in the backward extrusion is 1500 tonne at the final
forming. Fig. 6(c) shows the finally-designed die set stage with completion, which will be shown later in Fig.
consisting of punch III and die II for deep backward- 15(c). Because the available press capacity is 1000
extrusion, the design of the die set reflecting the simula- tonne, the process should be modified to reduce the
tion results in Fig. 10. maximum die load. The present preform does not de-
The left side of Fig. ll(a) shows the simulation form satisfactorily with respect to all of the final crite-
results of the third operation using the die set in Fig. ria. The dimensions of the final product, however, are
6(c), where the backward extrusion is carried out up to similar to those of the real product. Thus, a slight
(Unit : m m )
• unlilled
eavity
ro,orm=:
Fig. 12. As for Fig. 11, but for a punch stroke of 95%.
modification of the preform is made to keep the maxi- The ironing operation is carried out using the preform
mum die load during backward extrusion below 1000 (Preform PDBE-III) in Fig. 12(c), as shown in Fig. 13.
tonne and to obtain dimensions identical to those of the Fig. 14(a) shows the velocity field and the effective-
real product. In comparison with the real product in strain distribution after deep backward-extrusion, and
Fig. 3(c), it is necessary to increase the cup bottom Fig. 14(b) the dimensions and the effective-strain distri-
thickness by 0.9 mm and to decrease the amount of bution of the final product.
material which contributes to the formation of the As shown in the shape and velocity field of Preform
slope angle. For these purposes, the simulation of back- PDBE-III, the material flow towards the outside of the
ward extrusion is stopped at the stage when the punch cup opening is smaller than that in the previous cases.
stroke is less than 100%, and the derived preform is The maximum effective strain occurs near to the cup
used for the ironing process. The dies in Fig. 6(c) are bottom, as displayed in Fig. 14(a). Therefore, it is
used without modification during deep backward-extru- known that should a surface crack occur, it will be
sion. It is possible to maintain the forging load within located near to the cup bottom. Also, an undeformed
the press capacity because the load increases rapidly part does not appear near to the cup opening, and the
near the end stroke. cup bottom thickness remains unchanged during the
Fig. 12 shows the simulation of backward extrusion ironing process. The outside surface of the cup is
to a punch stroke of 95%, the darkened area in Fig. deformed mainly by the ring-typed die in the ironing
12(c) indicating an unfilled cavity of very small volume. process. The dimensions of the final product in Fig.
L,
(Unit : mm) 95%. The criterion for press capacity is thus satisfied
throughout all of the forming operations.
Preform
PDBE-III 0.8
o.
0.2
4. Conclusions
~
i
3. A systematic approach to process-sequence design
o
300 60b [ has been established using the finite-element method for
< multi-stage cold forging to form a constant-velocity-
C~ 200 ~400
joint housing. This specific case can be considered as an
I00 2oo / / / ~ example of the application of the method and for
/ development of the sequence-design methodology in
% 20' 40' 6 o' co' 100 o 20' 40' 6 o' 80 ' 100
general.
STROKE(%) STROKE(Z)
(~) (b)
1800 500 [
References
400F
120C
~ ~o~ 3o0 [l] K. Lange, Closed-Die Forging of Steel (in German), Springer,
ooc Berlin, 1958.
200 [2] T. Altan, F.W. Boulger, J.R. Becket, N. Akgerman and H.J.
4OO
Henning, Forging Equipment, Materials and Practices, MC1C-
,00 HB-03, Battelle-Columbus Laboratories, Columbus, OH, 1973.
[3] J.A. Pale, R. Shivpuri and T. Altan, Recent developments in
o
2o 40 60 8o loo 20 40 60 8o 1o0 tooling, machines and research in cold forging of complex parts,
STZ~OKE(~) STROKE(%) J. Mater. Process. Technol. 33 (1992) 1 29.
(c) (d) [4] S.K. Biswas and W.A. Knight, Preform design for closed die
Fig. 15. Load-stroke curves for the four-operation process: (a) forgings: experimental basics for computer aided design, Int. J.
extrusion; (b) closed-die forging; (c) deep backward-extrusion using Math. Tool Des. Res., 15 (1975) 179 193.
the dies in Fig. 6(c); and (d) ironing. [5] G.B. Yu and T.A. Dean, A practical computer-aided approach
to mould design for axisymmetric forging die cavities, lnt. J.
Mach. Tool. Des. Res., 25(1) (1985) 1 3.
14(b) are almost the same as those of the real product [6] K. Sevenler, P.S. Raghupati and T. Altan, Forming sequence
design for multistage cold forging, J. Mech. Work. Technol., 14
of the CVJ housing. The slope angle obtained in 25 °,
(1987) 121 135.
which can be considered as almost the same as that in [7] K. Osakada, T. Kado and G.B. Yang, Application of AI-tech-
the real product. Also, a surface crack does not occur, nique to process planning of cold forging, Ann. C1RP, 37(1)
as indicated by point D in Fig. 9. (1988) 239 -242.
The load-stroke curves during the four operations [8] P. Bariani and W. Knight, Computer-aided cold-forging process
design: a knowledge based system approach to forming sequence
for the cold forging of the CVJ housing are displayed in
generation, Ann. CIRP, 37(1) (1988) 243 246.
Fig. 15. [9] K.R. Vemuri, S.I. Oh and T. Altan, BID: a knowledge-based
Point B in Fig. 15(c) is the maximum load of 980 system to automate blocker design, Int. J. Maeh. Tools Manu-
tonne for backward extrusion when the punch stroke is /act., 29(4)(1989) 505 518.
J.-H. Lee et al./Journal of Materials Processing Te~4mology 58 (1996) 174 I83 183
[10] J.J. Park, N. Rebelo and S. Kobayashi, A new approach to Preform design in flashless forging of Rib/Web-shaped plane-
preform design in metal forming with the finite element method, strain component, Accepted for publk'ation in J. Mater. Process.
Int. J. Mach. Tool Des. Res., 23(1) (1983) 71 79. Technol.,.
[11] S.M. Hwang and S. Kobayashi, Preform design in disk forging, [19] B.S. Kang and S. Kobayashi, Process sequence design in cold
Int. J. Mach. Tool Des. Res., 23(3) (1986) 231-243. forging to form a constant velocity joint housing, Accepted for
[12] D.Y. Yang and K.H. Kim, Rigid-plastic finite element analysis publication in Int. J. Mach. Tool. Manuf., 1994.
of plane strain ring rolling, Int. J. Mech. Sci., 30(8) (1988) [20] T. Maki, Trends in forging technology in field of constant-veloc-
571-580. ity joint, JIDOSHA-GIJUTSU(JSAE), 36 (1982) 898.
[13] B.S. Kang, N.S. Kim and S. Kobayashi, Computer-aided pre- [21] KOMATSU Ltd., KOMATSU Warm and Cold Forging System:
form design in forging of an airfoil section blade, Int. J. Mach. Constant-Velocity Joint Forging Line, FESA-E-G-003, 1982.
Tool Manuf, 30(1) (1990) 43 52. [22] S. Fujikawa, H. Yoshioka and S. Shimamura, Cold and warm-
[14] N.S. Kim and S. Kobayashi, Preform design in H-shaped cross forging applications in the automative industry, J. Mater. Pro-
sectional axisymmetric forging by the finite element method, Int. cess. Technol., 35 (1992) 317 342.
J. Mach. Tool Manufact., 30(2) (1990) 243 268. [23] Project Team of II-shin Cold Forging Company, Cold Forging
[15] B.S. Kang and S. Kobayashi, Preform design in ring rolling Process to Form a C.V. Joint Housing, Summary Report, II-shin
processes by the three-dimensional finite element method, Int. J. Cold Forging Company Ltd., Changwon, Korea, 1992.
Mach. Tool Manufact., 31(1) (1991) 139-151. [24] J.H. Yoon and D.Y. Yang, A three-dimensional rigid-plastic
[16] B.S. Kang, Process sequence design in a heading process, J. finite element analysis of bevel gear forging by using a remeshing
Mater. Proc. Technol., 27 (1991), 213-226. technique, Int. J. Mech. Sci., 32 (1990) 277-291.
[17] T. Altan and M. Knoerr, Application of the 2D finite element [25] O.C. Zienkiewicz, The Finite Element Method, McGraw-Hill,
method to simulation of cold-forging process, J. Mater. Process. New York, 1977.
Technol., 35 (1992) 275-302. [26] S.Kobayashi, S.I. Oh and T. Altan, Metal Forming and the
[18] B.S. Kang, J.H. Lee, B.M. Kim, C.C. Choi and S.M. Hwang, Finite-Element Method, Oxford University Press 1989.