Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Innovations in Marketing:
Competitive Advantage through
Sustainability
pg. 1
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Table of Contents
Task 1: Organizational Summary Report
pg. 2
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 3
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Task 1
Organisational Summary
Report
‘Where we are now’
pg. 4
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 5
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Due to Global trends such as ‘the plastic kickback’, climate change, increased nationalistic views
(McClimon, 2019) and specified principles like EPR (Lindhqvist, 1992. Cited in Johnson and McCarthy
et al, 2014), sustainability has become a primary concern throughout the market. Considering that
the Centre for Environmental Justice (2021, p2) stated that “The most common plastic waste
products are straws, yoghurt cups, mega bottles, lunch sheets, milk packets, meal boxes,
polyethylene bags, sachet packets and wrappers” and “multi-national companies such as Coca Cola,
Unilever and Nestle contribute the most plastic pollution in Sri Lanka”, it is in Elephant House’s best
interest to capitalize on this global trend which has not been explored yet in the Sri Lankan soft
drinks market.
As shown by figure 1.A.3, in the month of July 2021, there has been a decrease in the number of
stores selling Elephant House CSDs with a rise in the volume of soft drink produced. This rise in
weighted distribution was caused by the adverse effects of the lockdown, closing down smaller
shops resulting in the 5% decrease in EBITDA during the financial year as shown in table 1.A.1.
pg. 6
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 7
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
(1.B.2)Competitor analysis.
As seen below in table 1.B.2, Elephant House is the current market leader in the CSD industry. With
the main sales primarily up to the vendors, and marketing campaigns saturated, the current market
is in an oligopolistic deadlock, especially among the main 3 brands due to strong digital marketing
and sales frameworks that have been implemented.
Key Success Elephant House Coca Cola Pepsi My Cola Regional brands
Factor (Max Cola, Lanka
Cola)
Org. size 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Market share 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Recognition 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Product range 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Loyalty 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Expansion 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Total 27/30 25/30 17/30 15/30 7/30
Table 1.B.2 Competitor analysis (Hooley et al, 2008)
Insights suggest that in order to make an impact, the next move would have to be one not taken by
any other brand. As such the Senior Management Team (SMT) will need to evaluate possible
innovations to gain a sustainable competitive advantage.
pg. 8
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 9
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Task 2
Innovative Business Case
and Proposal
‘What we need to do’
pg. 10
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 11
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 12
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
(2.B) Strategic options & justification for innovation to achieve sustainable competitive advantage.
As a main innovation, this case proposes the launching of a recyclable plastics collection centre in
order to display reputable EPR while capitalizing on the changing social views and values.
(2.B.1) Evaluation of the Collection Centre as a strategic option for competitive advantage
(2.B.1.1) Service/product offering
Due to the increased concern about recycling and managing waste, launching a plastics collection
centre would reduce the number of Elephant House plastics reaching garbage dumps as well as aid
in the disposal of plastic waste coming from the factories. Ceylon Cold Stores also plans to open
trading with other companies and individuals who wish to recycle plastics.
(2.B.1.2) Cost saving
Although this project is mainly focused on environmental sustainability and brand image, this has
direct cost-saving aspects of it as well. This will reduce the cost of disposal of factory plastics as well
as the production cost of PET bottles due to the recycled plastic syphoned off from the centre to the
factories to enter the production cycle.
(2.B.1.3) Long-term benefits
Apart from the immediate savings and benefits of recycling, this provides a unique opportunity for
Elephant House to rebrand itself as an eco-friendly company trying to make a difference about the
waste disposal issue in Sri Lanka. Other companies can also enter contracts with the centre for their
plastics disposal, which provides another source on income in the long-term.
(2.B.1.4) Benchmarking
This will be benchmarked against the cost-effectiveness of the centre, the rise in brand image, value,
market share & dominance, as well as overall rise in sales.
It will be indirectly benchmarked by the rise in company value as well as investment value do
measure its effectiveness
pg. 13
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
marketing campaigns.
Potential brand damage caused by failure to deliver Sustainability-based superiority among competitors,
the promised scale or level of recycling. greatly improving the brand image.
A lack of strategic guidance could result in the project Improved sales and customer acquisition & retention.
failing.
Failure to meet the necessary targets placed by the Increased brand goodwill, sustainability and long
senior management. term cost-reductions.
Operational
Inability to optimise the recycling process of the Having a self-sustaining and self-sufficient plant
plant. which requires less guidance and strategic analysis.
The subsequent marketing plan failing to take off and Ability to undergo complete rebranding under the
make an impact with the market. “green” marketing banner, pioneering eco-
friendliness in the CSD industry.
Issues with waste distribution lines might break the Higher customer convenience and overall attraction
faith of the centres personal clients in the long run. due to the unique service.
Tactical
Lack of competency of the workers leading to plant Cost-effective and efficient work at the plant with
failure. trained supervision
Unexpected costs on the plant floor. Reduced overall corporate costs of the company.
pg. 14
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
essential to the rebranding aspect of this innovation. As such appeasing the customer mind-set
while maintaining a favourable position will prove this strategy a success.
l
Government Elephant House's strategy modifications must adhere to all applicable regulations, orders, and
guidelines. As a result, it's critical to maintain regular and honest communication with
government and regulatory organizations while also contributing to the country's economic
growth.
Suppliers To ensure the seamless continuation of operations and optimized assistance on value
generation, Ceylon Cold Stores must have an open discussion with all of its suppliers and
business partners. Maintaining a healthy supplier relationship requires fair and transparent
pricing, simplicity of transaction, and regular payments.
Table 2.C.3 Stakeholder breakdown
Internal 1. Employees,
2. Shareholders
3. Management
External 4. Competitors
5. General public
6. Customers
7. Governments
8. Media
9. Suppliers
- Effective logistic network - Strong financial position Due to these factors, and the breakdown in
- Recycling plant
table 2.C.6, Elephant House would be able
Threshold competencies Unique competencies to
- Young, committed
2.C.6 Resource -based
Uniqueview
Competency
pg. 16
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Task 3
Innovation in Action:
Marketing and Communication
Plan
‘Making a difference’
pg. 17
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
(3.A) Marketing and Communication plan for the new Elephant House innovative campaign:
Plastics Recycling Collection Centre.
Background.
Even with the raised awareness on the environment in the recent years, due to the Covid-19
pandemic and the subsequent side-effects, no brand has been able to prioritise and attempt to help
the environment. Seeing this gap in the market, CCS decided to partner up with Plasticycle and
ZeroTrash to create a plastic recycling centre. By using P.R. Smith’s SOSTAC Model, CCS will be able
to formulate an effective corporate plan to carry out the innovation proposed in (2.B).
(3.A.2) Objectives.
Marketing Objectives Corporate Objectives
External - Achieve a sale increase of 8% by 2024/2025 - Increase in market share by 5% by 2024/2025
- 20% increase in brand awareness by 2024/2025 - Reduce the carbon footprint of the factories
- Increase the brand equity by 5% by 2024/2025 by 5% by 2024/2025
- Increase recycling of Elephant House plastics by
consumers by 60% by 2024/2025
Internal - Reduce manufacturing waste by 40% by 2024/2025
Objectives - Increased efficiency of the collection centre by 15% by 2024/2025
- Reduce production cost by 15% by2024/2025
Table 3.A.2 Objectives of CCS and Elephant House.
pg. 18
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
(3.A.3) Strategy
(3.A.3.1) Segmentation.
Their target market can be identified as Youthful teens, Young adults, Steady drinkers and Fan-
parents. They have been segmented as per Diasz et al. (2017) in Appendix 1, which has been used to
create the below profile of the Key Customer Segment in table 3.A.3.
Young Adults
Demographic Age 18-35
Higher-education to corporate sector or self-employment
Income of LKR 35,000-150,000
Bachelor to full nest 1 family cycle
Large segment size.
Geographic Urban-Suburban cities
Psychographic Millennial to Gen Z
Trendsetter or conservative lifestyle
Middle to Upper-middle social circle.
Behavioural Purchases impulsively or planned
Looks taste and convenience
Regular usage rate
Medium-high loyalty
Indifferent-positive perception of the brand,
Mainly interacts with the brand through digital and print media
Table 3.A.3 Key Customer Segment Profile
(3.A.3.2) Targeting
Competitive advantage
Lower cost Differentiation As clarified in (2.B.3) and (2.C.3), Elephant House will
be leaning into the high impact of societal influence
Cost Leadership Differentiation
Broad
Leader
competitive advantage, by differentiating itself from
the rest of the market
Narrow
(3.A.3.3) Positioning
As stated in (2.C), Elephant House
would look to re-brand itself in a more
eco-friendly and ‘green’ manner,
similarly to how Keells Super rebranded
itself (Wavemakerglobal, 2018).
pg. 19
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 20
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
(3.A.7.3) Marketing communication strategy: Push, Pull and Profile as per Fill et al (2016)
Push -Using third-party companies/organizations to reach out to the target audience
strategy Placing temporary plastics collection points at major events next to drink stalls
Social Media trends (TikTok challenges, Instagram competitions, etc.
Pull -Customers' demand-generating strategies
strategy Paid media campaigns
Telemarketing campaigns
Social Media promotions and sponsorships
Profile -Elephant House's profile and image are boosted through these strategies
strategy Press releases, awards and achievements about the innovative strategy.
Offering sponsorships for government partnered projects
pg. 21
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 22
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Changing the Elephant House's risk-taking mentality displays the company's willingness to pursue risky
opportunities. The marketing department must lead the way in supporting individuals and
attitude to risk teams who innovate and take calculated risks in order to foster as much creativity as
taking possible from workers.
Regardless of their likelihood of success, wise risk judgments must be admired. In this view,
encouraging the creation of a risk-taking climate among employees using platforms like
knowledge management systems (2.A.4) might motivate them to contribute to the
organization's innovation performance.
pg. 23
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Appendices
Appendix 1 Customer Segmentation Matrix as per Diasz et al. (2017)
Geographic
Region City City City City
Population Urban Urban Urban Suburban
Suburban Suburban
Psychographic
Lifestyle Trendsetter Trendsetter/ Conservative Conservative
Conservative
Social Class Lower to Upper Middle to Upper- Middle Middle to Upper
middle
Generation Gen Z Gen Z Milennials Gen X
Milennials
Behavioural
Benefits sought Taste and trendiness Taste Taste Convenience and
Convenience Convenience preference of
dependants
Purchase Occasion Impulse Impulse Planned Planned
Planned Bulk
Usage rate Regular Regular - High High Occasional – Regular
(Based on
dependants)
Loyalty Medium Medium- high Low Medium
Perception Positive Indifferent - Positive Positive Indifferent
Media used Digital* Digital* Digital* Digital*
Print Print Print Print
*Rose in due to Covid-19
pg. 24
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 25
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Firm 123 official Keells Super outlets island-wide with sufficient employees and a supervising
Infrastructure branch manager for each with collection and operation centres.
Secondary Activities
HRM 6,698 employees recruited for their unique skillset. 42% retention rate with 43 million rs
invested in training. Fair wages, 39% female representation, with a safety first culture.
Technology Online retail, digital Ai scanning of customer behaviour to determine preferences, trends
and delivery preferences. Rs. 34 million invested in R&D with 11 new products launched
in 2020-2021
Procurement Fully operational network for timely collection and delivery of goods, as well as effective
inventory management across all branches. Backward integration is also carried out in a
systematic manner.
Inbound logistics Operations Outbound logistics Sales & marketing After sales service
Primary Activities
Beverages are Effective operations Storage & Mainly ATL and BTL Customer care
sourced directly in all branches and warehouse based mass centre will take in
from factories to other small retailers management is marketing. Digital grievances brought
distributors. through proper done for each media is rising in forward by retailers
forward outlet and popularity. and end-users
integration. distribution centre. through the
forward integration
line.
pg. 26
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Activity Implementation
Idea generation Internally, from a staff member, or externally, from a customer.
Using a SWOT analysis CCS can identify practical and achievable ideas.
By conducting thorough market research
Customer feedback, complaints, and ideas are all taken into consideration.
Idea screening After examining trends, client needs, ROI, and, most importantly, sustainability and
environmental friendliness, the most practical and suitable ideas should be chosen.
Concept development & The idea should be developed into a presentable form, and the ideas that pass the
testing screening process are transformed into concepts. The concept is then presented to the
target stakeholder audience, who are given necessary details and given input to see if
the concept meets their needs and wants adequately.
Strategy analysis & Marketing, branding, financial feasibility, marketing mix, competitive rivalry,
development competency, pricing strategies, originality, and innovativeness are all factors to consider.
Product/process All strategies are utilized in the finalization of the product/process, which is now ready
development for testing.
Test marketing Feedback is collected in order to make additional adjustments. It is validated at this step.
Launching The marketing mix will be appropriately adjusted and adapted to carry out the
product/process successfully.
pg. 27
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
Reference List
CCBM (c.a.2021) Innovations in Marketing Text Book. Sri Lanka, Cambridge College of Business
Management.
pg. 28
Innovations in Marketing (2211) Membership No. 40083260 December 2021
pg. 29