Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Successful introduction of ICT in technical education comes with a price - as not only the
technology is expensive, it is ineffective unless teachers are trained and made
comfortable with its use. As technical schools contribute and prepare skilled workforce for
Malaysian economy, the need for teachers to be ICT literate is immensely critical. This
paper presents findings of a study designed to investigate the existing level of ICT
competency of teachers in Malaysian technical schools. The results show that the
majority of teachers in Malaysian technical schools are still novice users of IT. Some of
the reason deduced from the survey and the interview were low level of computer
competency, less focus on the new computing skills, limited training program, technofear,
limited infrastructure and support. Recommendations in addressing these issues
especially regarding the provision of supportive teaching environment in technical
schools are put forth.
Learning and Teaching (2.15). The (46.4%) of the sample said that they had
respondents reported to be moderately undergone in-service training provided by
competent in Operational Basics (3.25), the Ministry of Education and in-house
Basic Internet (2.86), followed by training related to computer and IT. Result
Computer Knowledge and Its Social of a t-test shows that those who had in-
Impact (2.58) and Computer Assisted service computer training have
Learning and Teaching (2.54). significantly higher mean score on
Within the range of means, the computer competency than those who did
highest score is in Operational Basics not get any computer training at 0.01
(3.25). This shows that the respondents significance level.
claimed that they were moderately The lowest mean is in Computer
competent to do basic tasks with the Mediated Communication. The specific
computer. The respondents reported that competencies in this category deal with
they were able to log-on and run the the use of e-mail for consultation and
computer program. They were also able to communication with students. Other
print selected documents. They were elements include establishing network with
moderately competent to use applications other schools and other students for
software such as word processor for collaborative projects and to contact
clerical work, presentation program to experts for views and advice. The
create slide show, database and teachers reported they were not
spreadsheet to generate list, charts and competent in handling such tasks and
tables. needed help, for example, in subscribing
The relatively “high” mean score in and participating in discussion group,
the Operational Basics may be due to forum or mailing list. There are many
several reasons. About 43% of the sample reasons that contributed to low
responded they had taken computer- competency in this category. The critical
related courses during their teacher ones include lack of training and lack of
training years. Those courses may help Internet access.
them to grasp the basics in computer
technology and provide a good
background for them to learn the new
skills like the use of Internet, Computer
Mediated Communication and Web-Based
Learning and Teaching. Almost half
perform basic computing task they still highly competent in IT. These findings
needed help as they were not proficient implicate that only a minority of the
users yet. A relatively high percentage of teachers in technical schools in Malaysia
the respondents (27.8%) perceive have expertise to use IT in teaching.
themselves as incompetent IT users and Majority of them said that they could not
needed substantial assistance to perform help or teach others. This findings support
computer-related tasks. an earlier study of a nation-wide survey on
From the total sample, 29.6% of the Malaysian teachers readiness towards
them were categorized as moderately the application of computer-assisted
competent. Only 1.9% of the respondents teaching where majority of the teachers
perceived that they are competent and responded that they are technically not
none of the respondents claimed to be ready (Abdul Razak, 1998).
Attribute Mean
Anxiety 3.67
Liking of computer 3.53
Confidence of computer 3.55
Usefulness of computer 3.67
Overall 3.60
the respondents received. The majority schools and therefore, the opportunity to
of the sample (51.9%) received in-service go off for training was very limited.
training provided by the school. About the Teachers had the opportunity to attend
same percentage of respondents (21.2% computer-related workshop but only few
and 21.6%) received support in terms of received such support (21.4%). It was
in-service training provided by the also noted that very few teachers were
computer vendors and the Ministry of given the support to develop new software
Education, respectively. From the (8.9%) and to participate in software
interview data, some respondents assert competition (6.0%).
that there were not enough teachers in the
Support Percentage
(%)
Loan to buy computer 37.3%
Time off from teaching to go for training 19.6%
In-service training at school 51.9%
In-service training from computer company 21.2%
In-service training from Ministry of Education 21.6%
Recognition for software developed 8.9%
Chances to attend computer related seminar 21.4%
Software competition 6.0%
barrier to effective use of IT for such need to find resources to equip and
purposes. sustain their computer labs.
Technofear References
The major finding on the teachers’ attitude
towards computer is technofear. In the Abdul Manab, N. & Othman, A. (1999,
interview conducted, it was found that the December). The implementation of
teachers’ low competency in using IT information and communication
was partly due to fear of change. They technology in nurturing smart school
feared that with the use of IT, they would learning environment in Malaysia: The
have more work and the shift from TigerWeb project. Paper presented at
conventional teaching to the use of IT the MERA Conference, Melaka,
could create more confusion among the Malaysia.
teachers and students. Therefore, IT Abdul Razak, N. (1998). CALL: Some
awareness program should conducted on pedagogical issues. Bangi, Malaysia:
regular basis could correct this Faculty of Language Studies
misconception. Publication Series, Universiti
Kebangsaan Malaysia.
Limited infrastructure Abdul Razak, N. (2001). Online delivery
Some of the teachers interviewed systems: Setting baseline for
reported that lack of computer software in professional development of
schools and the priority to complete the educators. Malaysian Journal of
syllabus for the examination made their Educational Technology, 1:(2) 47-52.
effort to apply technology is even more Abdul Razak, N. & Abdul Rashid, S.
difficult. Most of the schools has only one (1997).Pengajaran bahasa
computer lab equipped with 20 computers berbantukan komputer: satu tinjauan
and due to the limited hardware and terhadap kesediaaan guru-gurur dan
facilities, teachers had to rotate and plan sekolah-sekolah menengah di
carefully their lab schedules to avoid Malaysia. UKM research final report
clashes. Teachers also reported lack of V1/95.
technical help in the computer lab.
Therefore, it is suggested that the schools
2166
SEMINAR INTERNASIONAL
Revitalisasi Pendidikan Kejuruan dalam Pengembangan SDM Nasional
Babbie, E. 1992. The practice of social and issues. The Modern Language
research. Belmont, CA: Wardsworth Journal, 75(1), 74-101.
Publishing Company. Goh, S. W. & Tobin, K. (1999). Student
Badusah, J. & Hussin, M. (2000, and teacher perspectives in computer-
October). Bilik darjah Internet: mediated learning environments in
Pengunaan pelbagai bahan media. teacher education. Learning
Paper presented at the National Environments Research, 2, 169-190.
Seminar on Educational Research and Jonassen, D. H. (1996). Computers in
Development, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia. the classroom: Mindtools for critical
Berita Harian (29 September 1999). KDP: thinking. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
10 komputer setiap sekolah. Prentice Hall.
Dalkey, N.C. (1975). Toward a theory of Kasem, B. (1979). The future of teacher
group estimation. In Linstone, H.A. & education in Thailand. Doctoral
Turoff, M. (eds.) The Delphi method: Dissertation. Universtiy of Alabama.
Techniques and applications.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Kirk, R.E. (1984). Elementary statistics.
Publishing Company. 2nd Ed. Monterey, California:
Dalkey, N.C., Rourke, D.L., Lewis, R. & Brooks/Cole Publishing Company.
Snyder, D. 1972. Studies in the quality Knezek, G. & Christensen, R. (1997,
of life: Delphi and decision-making. March). Internal consistency for the
Lexington, MA: Lexington Books. teachers’ attitudes toward information
Dusick, D. M. (1998). What social technology questionnaire. Presented
cognitive factors influence faculty at the Society of Information
member’s use of computer for Technology & Teacher Education
teaching: A literature review. Journal (SITE)’s International Conference,
of Research on Computing in Washington, DC.
Education, 31(2.), 123-137.
Economic Planning Unit. (1996). Seventh Krashen, S. D. & Terrell, T. D. (1983). The
Malaysia plan. 1996-2000. Kuala natural approach: Language
Lumpur: Percetakan Nasional acquisition in the classroom. Hayward,
Malaysia Bhd. CA: Alemany Press.
Embi, M.A. (2001). Development and
evaluation of SMART NET as an Maddux, C.D., Johnson, D.L., & Willis,
internet-based teaching and learning. J.W. (1997). Educational computing:
Unpublished Faculty Research Report. Learning with tomorrow’s technologies.
Bangi, Malaysia: Faculty of Education, Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia. Bacon.
Embi, M.A, Long, J. & Hamzah, M.I. Mai, N. & Neo, K. (2000, September).
(1998). Language learning strategies Multimedia technology: The paradigm
used by secondary school students in shift and its impact on society. Paper
Malaysia: A preliminary study. presented at the First UKM-UC
Research Report G1/97. Bangi: Regional Conference on Technology
Faculty of Education, Universiti and Society, Bangi Equatorial Hotel,
Kebangsaan Malaysia. Malaysia.
Fraser, B.J. (1986). Classroom Ministry of Education Malaysia. (1997).
environment. London: Croom Helm. Smart school flagship applications:
Fraser, B.J. (1998). Classroom The Malaysian smart school: A
environment instruments: conceptual blueprint. Kuala Lumpur:
Development, validity and applications. Malaysian Development Corporation
Learning Environments Research, 1, Muhamed, A.H., Hasan, H., Dzakiria, H.,
59-74. & Kassim, A. (1999, October). IT
Garrett, N. (1991). Technology in the impact on schools: Overcoming
service of language learning: Trends barriers in integrating computers in the
Malaysian primary schools. Paper
2167
SEMINAR INTERNASIONAL
Revitalisasi Pendidikan Kejuruan dalam Pengembangan SDM Nasional
2168