Professional Documents
Culture Documents
New Solitary Waves For The KleinGordonZakharov Equations
New Solitary Waves For The KleinGordonZakharov Equations
This paper studies new solitary waves for the Klein–Gordon–Zakharov equations. The
obtained results are diverse and some specific ones emerge as dark, bright and bell-
shape. The two integration schemes lead to obtaining waves which propagate without
deformation as illustrated in graphical representations. Our obtained results are more
specific compared to those obtained by Refs. 8 and 31 [C. H. Zhao and Z. M. Sheng,
Acta Phys. Sin. 53 (2004) 29; S. Yakada, B. Depelair, G. Betchewe and S. Y. Doka,
Optik 197 (2019) 163108].
1. Introduction
Investigation of the exact traveling-waves solutions to nonlinear partial differential
equation (PDEs) and conformable fractional differential which describing physics
phenomena has become very important in literature.1–3 Therefore, a plethora of
integration techniques including sine-Gordon expansion method, new extended di-
rect algebraic method, auxiliary equation method, sine-cosine method, general-
ized beta approximation, multiple scales method, sinh-Gordon expansion method,
exp-function method, variational iteration method, auxiliary equation method, ex-
ponential rational function method, improved tan(φ(ξ)/2)-expansion method and
function variable method were involved to investigate specific solitary waves solu-
tions of PDEs nowadays.4–23,25,26
¶ Corresponding author.
2050246-1
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 2
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
2050246-2
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 3
2050246-3
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 4
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
p
−(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
φ3 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − + tanA −(µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
2σ 2σ
p
−pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
± secA 2
−(µ − 4λσ)ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] ,
2σ
(17)
p
(βω 2 ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
v3 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h 1 − + tan A −(µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
k − ω2 2σ 2σ
2
p
−pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
± secA −(µ2 − 4λσ)ξ +C, (18)
2σ
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
p
−(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
φ4 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − − cotA −(µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
2σ 2σ
p
−pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
± cscA 2
−(µ − 4λσ)ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] ,
2σ
(19)
p
(βω 2 ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
v4 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h 1 − − cotA −(µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
k − ω2 2σ 2σ
2
p
−pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
± cscA −(µ2 − 4λσ)ξ +C, (20)
2σ
p p
−(µ2 − 4λσ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ
φ5 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − − tanA ξ
2σ 2σ 4
p p
−(µ2 − 4λσ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
− cotA ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (21)
2σ 4
p p
(βω 2 ) −(µ2 − 4λσ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ
v5 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h 1 − − tan A ξ
k − ω2 2σ 2σ 4
p p 2
−(µ2 − 4λσ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
− cotA ξ +C, (22)
2σ 4
2050246-4
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 5
p p 2
(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ (µ − 4λσ)
φ7 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − + cothA ξ
2σ 2σ 2
× exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (25)
p p
(βω 2 ) (µ2 − 4λσ) (µ2 − 4λσ)
µ
v7 (x, t) = 2 h 0 + h1 − + coth A ξ ,
k − ω2 2σ 2σ 2
(26)
p
(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
φ8 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − + tanhA (µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
2σ 2σ
p
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
±i sechA 2
(µ − 4λσ)ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] ,
2σ
(27)
p
(βω 2 ) (µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
v8 (x, t) = 2 2
h0 + h1 − + tanhA (µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
k −ω 2σ 2σ
2
p
pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
±i sechA 2
(µ − 4λσ)ξ +C, (28)
2σ
p
(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
φ9 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − − cothA (µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
2σ 2σ
p
pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
± cschA (µ2 − 4λσ)ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (29)
2σ
p
(βω 2 ) (µ2 − 4λσ)
µ p
v9 (x, t) = 2 2
h0 + h1 − − cothA (µ2 − 4λσ)ξ
k −ω 2σ 2σ
2
p
pq(µ2 − 4λσ)
p
± cschA 2
(µ − 4λσ)ξ +C, (30)
2σ
p p 2
−(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ (µ − 4λσ)
φ10 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − − tanhA ξ
2σ 4σ 4
p p 2
(µ2 − 4λσ)
(µ − 4λσ)
− cothA ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (31)
4σ 4
p p 2
(βω 2 ) −(µ2 − 4λσ)
µ (µ − 4λσ)
v10 (x, t) = 2 h 0 + h1 − − tanh A ξ
k − ω2 2σ 4σ 4
p p 2
(µ2 − 4λσ) (µ2 − 4λσ)
− cothA ξ +C, (32)
4σ 4
2050246-5
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 6
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
2
(k2 −ω2 ) +k2 −ω2 +αβω2 h0 2
Result 3. For λσ > 0 and µ = 0, then h0 = 0 and C = − α(k2 −ω 2 ) ,
it is obtained.
" !#
r
λ √
φ11 (x, t) = h0 + h1 tanA λσξ exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (33)
σ
" !#2
(βω 2 )
r
λ √
v11 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h1 tanA λσξ +C, (34)
k − ω2 σ
" !#
r
λ √
φ12 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − cotA λσξ exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (35)
σ
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
" !#2
(βω 2 )
r
λ √
v12 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h1 − cotA λσξ +C, (36)
k − ω2 σ
" "r !#
λ √ r
λ √
φ13 (x, t) = h0 + h1 tanA 2λσξ ± pq secA 2λσξ
σ σ
+C , (38)
" !#
r
λ √ r
λ √
φ14 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − cotA 2λσξ ± pq cscA 2λσξ
σ σ
+C , (40)
" r √ ! r √ !!!#
1 λ λσ λ λσ
φ15 (ξ) = h0 + h1 tanA ξ − cotA ξ
2 σ 2 σ 2
+C , (42)
2050246-6
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 7
2
(k2 −ω2 ) +k2 −ω 2 +αβω 2 h0 2
Result 4. For λσ < 0 and µ = 0, then h0 = 0 and C = − α(k2 −ω 2 ) .
" r !#
−λ √
φ16 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − tanhA −λσξ exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (43)
σ
" r !#2
βω 2 −λ √
v16 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h1 − tanhA −λσξ +C, (44)
k − ω2 σ
" r !#
−λ √
φ17 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − cothA −λσξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (45)
σ
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
" r !#2
βω 2 −λ √
v17 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h1 − cothA −λσξ +C, (46)
k − ω2 σ
" !#
r
−λ √ r
−pqλ √
φ18 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − tanhA 2λσξ ± i pq sechA 2 −λσξ
σ σ
" r √ r √ !!#
1 −λ −λσ −λ −λσ
φ20 (x, t) = h0 + h1 − tanhA ξ + cothA ξ
2 σ 2 σ 2
2050246-7
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 8
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
" r √
βω 2
1 −λ −λσ
v20 (x, t) = 2 h0 + h1 − tanhA ξ
k − ω2 2 σ 2
r √ !!#2
−λ −λσ
+ cothA ξ +C. (52)
σ 2
−(k2 −ω 2 )(2(Ln(A))2 σ 2 −1)−1
Result 5. For µ = 0 and λ = σ, then h0 = 0 and C = α .
φ21 (x, t) = [h1 tanA (λξ)] exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (53)
βω 2 2
v21 (x, t) = [h1 tanA (λξ)] + C , (54)
k2 − ω2
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
βω 2 √ 2
v23 (x, t) = [h1 (tanA (2λξ) ± pq secA (2λξ))] + C , (58)
k2
− ω2
√
φ24 (x, t) = h1 [− cotA (2λξ) ± pq cscA (2λξ)] exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (59)
βω 2 √ 2
v24 (x, t) =
2 2
[h1 (− cotA (2λξ) ± pq cscA (2λξ))] + C , (60)
k −ω
1 λ λ
φ25 (x, t) = h1 tanA ξ − cotA ξ exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (61)
2 2 2
2
βω 2
1 λ λ
v25 (x, t) = 2 h 1 tan A ξ − cot A ξ +C, (62)
k − ω2 2 2 2
βω 2 √ 2
v28 = 2 2
[h1 (− tanhA (2λξ) ± i pq sechA (2λξ))] + C , (68)
k −ω
2050246-8
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 9
√
φ29 (ξ) = h1 (− cothA (2λξ) ± pq cschA (2λξ)) exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (69)
βω 2 √ 2
v29 (ξ) = [h1 (− cothA (2λξ) ± pq cschA (2λξ))] + C , (70)
k2 − ω2
h1 λ λ
φ30 (x, t) = − tanhA ( ξ) + cothA ξ exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (71)
2 2 2
2
βω 2
h1 λ λ
v30 (x, t) = 2 2
− tanhA ξ + coth A ξ +C, (72)
k −ω 2 2 2
√
2Ln(A) λ σ (k2 −ω 2 ) 2
+1−ω 2
Result 7. µ2 = 4λσ, then h0 = − , and C = − k .
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
q
−2 α1β ω α β α
2λ(µξLn(A) + 2)
φ31 (ξ) = h0 − h1 exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (73)
µ2 ξLn(A)
2
βω 2
2λ(µξLn(A) + 2)
v31 (ξ) = 2 h0 − h 1 +C, (74)
k − ω2 µ2 ξLn(A)
q
1
−2 1
αβ (k2 −ω2 )Ln(A) 2 Ln(A)σ (k2 −ω 2 )
Result 9. µ 6= 0 and λ = 0, then h0 = 2 ω , h1 = q ,
−2 α1β ω α β
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
1 k µ (Ln(A)) −2 k −µ (Ln(A)) ω +2 ω −2
C= 2 α .
pµ
φ33 (ξ) = h0 + h1 exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (77)
σ(coshA (µξ) − sinhA (µξ) − p)
2
βω 2
pµ
v33 (ξ) = 2 h0 + h1 +C, (78)
k − ω2 σ(coshA (µξ) − sinhA (µξ) − p)
µ(sinhA (µξ) + coshA (µξ))
φ34 (ξ) = h0 − h1 exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (79)
σ(coshA (µξ) − sinhA (µξ) + q)
2
βω 2
µ(sinhA (µξ) + coshA (µξ))
v34 (ξ) = 2 h0 − h1 +C, (80)
k − ω2 σ(coshA (µξ) − sinhA (µξ) + q)
2050246-9
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 10
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
Ln(A)k(k2 −ω 2 )
Result 10. µ = k and σ = mk(m 6= 0) and λ = 0, then h0 = − √
−2 α βω
,
√ 2 4 2 2 2 2 2
−2 α βkω Ln(A)
h1 = k2 −ω 2 , and C = 12 (Ln(A)) k −k (Ln(A))
α
ω −2k −2+2 ω
.
pAkξ
φ35 (ξ) = h0 − h1 exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (81)
q − mpAkξ
2
βω 2 pAkξ
v35 (ξ) = 2 h0 − h 1 +C, (82)
k − ω2 q − mpAkξ
the details of the generalized hyperbolic and triangular function are given by
Refs. 30 and 31.
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
where sin(s) = sech(ξ), cos(s) = tanh(ξ), and Aj (j = ±1, ±2, ±3, . . . ) and Bj (j =
±1, ±2, ±3, . . . ) are constant to be determined. By using the balance between ψ 00
and ψ 3 , it is obtained N = 1. Then,
ψ(s) = B1 sin(s(ξ)) + A1 cos(s(ξ)) + A0 . (85)
Substituting (86) into (9), the nonlinear algebraic equation is obtained.
3α β ω 2 A0 A1 2
cos(s(ξ))2 : (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
3α β ω 2 A1 2 B1 α β ω 2 B1 3
sin(s(ξ)) cos(s(ξ))2 : (k2 −ω 2 )2
+ 2 B1 − (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
3α β ω 2 A1 B1 2 α β ω 2 A1 3
cos(s(ξ)) sin(s(ξ))2 : −2 A1 + (k2 −ω 2 )2
− (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
6α β ω 2 A0 A1 B1
cos(s(ξ)) sin(s(ξ)): (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
α CA1 k2 A1 3α β ω 2 A0 2 A1 A1 ω 2 A1 α β ω 2 A1 3
cos(s(ξ)): k2 −ω 2 + k2 −ω 2 + (k2 −ω 2 )2
+ k2 −ω 2 − k2 −ω 2 + (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
3α β ω 2 A0 B1 2
sin(s(ξ))2 : (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
α β ω 2 B1 3 B1 ω 2 B1 k 2 B1 α CB1 3α β ω 2 A0 2 B1
sin(s(ξ)): (k2 −ω 2 )2
+ k2 −ω 2 − k2 −ω 2 − B1 + k2 −ω 2 + k2 −ω 2 + (k2 −ω 2 )2
= 0,
2050246-10
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 11
α CA0 α β ω 2 A0 3 k 2 A0 ω 2 A0 A0
Const. k2 −ω 2 + (k2 −ω 2 )2
+ k2 −ω 2 − k2 −ω 2 + k2 −ω 2 = 0.
After solving the above system of algebraic equations with the help of MAPLE,
it is obtained.
q
2 2 2
αβ (k −ω )
2
−ω 2 )+1
S1: A0 = 0, A1 = 0, B1 = ω , ω = ω, v = v, C = − 2(k α , k = k.
The bright solitons to (1) and (2) are revealed
r
2 2
φ32 (x, t) = (k − ω 2 )sech [(ωx + kt)] exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (86)
αβ
2(k 2 − ω 2 ) 2(k 2 − ω 2 ) + 1
v32 (x, t) = sech2 [(ωx + kt)] exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] − ,
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
α α
(87)
q
2
− αβ (k2 −ω 2 ) 2 2
S2: A0 = 0, A1 = ω , B1 = 0 ω = ω, v = v, C = k −ω α
−1
, k = k. Dark
solitons to (1) and (2) are gained,
q
2
− αβ (k 2 − ω 2 )
φ33 (x, t) = tanh[(ωx + kt+)] exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (88)
ω
2(k 2 − ω 2 ) k2 − ω2 − 1
v33 (x, t) = − tanh2 [(ωx + kt)] exp[i(kx + ωt + θ)] + ,
α α
(89)
q q
2
− αβ (k2 −ω 2 ) 2 2 2
αβ (k −ω ) 2 2
S3: A0 = 0, A1 = ω , B1 = ω ω = ω, v = v, C = − 21 k −ω α
+2
,
k = k. Bright-dark soliton solutions to (1) and (2) are recovered,
q q
2 2 2 2
αβ (k − ω ) − αβ (k 2 − ω 2 )
φ33 (x, t) = sech [(ωx + kt)] + tanh [(ωx + kt)]
ω ω
× exp [i(kx + ωt + θ)] , (90)
q
2 2 2
βω 2 αβ (k − ω )
v33 (x, t) = 2 sech [(ωx + kt)]
k − ω2 ω
q 2
2
− αβ (k 2 − ω 2 ) 1 k2 − ω2 + 2
+ tanh [(ωx + kt)] − . (91)
ω 2 α
2050246-11
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 12
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
Mod. Phys. Lett. B 2020.34. Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
Fig. 1. (Color online) Spatiotemporal plot of the dark solitons |φ6( x, t)|2 for (a) µ = 0, 25,
σ = 0.525, λ = 0.00025, h1 = −10.05, k = 1.5, ω = 4.58. (b) µ = 0, 0125, σ = 3.75, λ = 0.0523,
h1 = −12.05, k = −0.75, ω = 1.58. (c) µ = 0, 125, σ = 3.75, λ = 0.00523, h1 = −12.05, k = −3.15,
ω = 1.58. (d) µ = 0, 25, σ = 3.58, λ = 0.00025, h1 = −10.05, k = 1.5, ω = 4.58, respectively.
Fig. 2. (Color online) Spatiotemporal plot of v6 (x, t). (a) µ = 0, 25, σ = 3.75, λ = 0.00523,
h1 = −12.05, k = −3.155, ω = 4.58, β = 0.5, C = 1; (b) µ = −0, 125, σ = 3.75, λ = 0.0533,
h1 = −12.05, k = −3.155, ω = 2.58, β = 0.005, C = 5; (c) µ = −0, 000125, σ = 3.75, λ = 0.0523,
h1 = −12.05, k = −0.15, ω = 2.56, β = 0.005, C = 5 and (d) µ = −0, 000125, σ = 3.75,
λ = 0.0523, h1 = −12.05, k = −1.15, ω = 2.50, β = 0.005, C = 5, respectively.
2050246-12
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 13
4. Conclusion
In this work, abundant exact solutions for the KGZ equations were investigated by
adopting two integration schemes. To reach the goal, the traveling-wave hypothe-
sis was adopted the ordinary differential equation. To solve the obtained ODE, the
new extended direct algebraic scheme and the sine-Gordon expansion equation have
been used successfully. As results dark, dipole bright soliton solutions, trigonomet-
ric function solutions and some rational function solutions emerge. We note that
comparatively with the works,8,30,31 the obtained results are more specific. We hope
that the obtained one-soliton solutions should be useful in solitary waves theory.
References
1. S. Meng and Y. Cui, Complexity (2019) Article ID 8402347.
2. R. Tian, L. Fu, Y. Ren and H. Yang, Math. Meth. Appl. Sci. (2019).
3. J.-C. Sun, Z.-G. Zhang, H.-H. Dong and H.-W. Yang, Acta Phys. Sin. 68 (2019)
210201.
4. M. Song, B. S. Ahmed, E. Zerrad and A. Biswas, Chaos vol23(3) (2013) 033115.
5. H. Rezazadeh, S. M. Mirhosseini-Alizamini, M. Eslami, M. Rezazadeh, M. Mirzazadeh
and S. Abbagari, Optik 172 (2018) 545.
6. J. Chen, L. Liu and L. Liu, Adv. Math. Phys. (2014) Article ID 974050.
7. N. Masmoudi and K. Nakanishi, J. Hyperbolic Differ. Equ. 2 (2005) 975.
8. C. H. Zhao and Z. M. Sheng, Acta Phys. Sin. 53 (2004) 29.
2050246-13
August 24, 2020 22:29 MPLB S0217984920502462 page 14
S. Nestor et al.
by UNIVERSIDADE EST.PAULISTA JULIO DE MESQUITA FILHO on 08/03/22. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
18. T. S. Mohyud-Din, M. A. Noor and K. I. Noor, Math. Probl. Eng. Hindawi 2009
(2009) Article ID 234849.
19. S. Bibi, N. Ahmed, U. Khan and T. S. Mohyud-Din, Phys. Scripta 94(8) (2019).
20. T. S. Mohyud-Din, S. Bibi, N. Ahmed and U. Khan, Some exact solutions of the
nonlinear space-time fractional differential equations, Waves in Random and Complex
Media (Taylor & Francis, 2018), pp. 645–664.
21. S. Bibi, N. Ahmed, U. Khan and T. S. Mohyud-Din, Results Phys. 9 (2018) 648.
22. K. Berat, Optical and Quantum Electronics (Springer, 2018).
23. H. Rezazadeh, J. Vahidi, A. Zafar and A. Bekir, Int. J. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul.
(2020) doi:10.1515/ijnsns-2019-0064.
24. H. Rezazadeh, K. U. Tariq, J. Sabi’u and A. Bekir, Mod. Phys. Lett. B (2020), doi:10.
1142/S0217984920501183.
25. D. S. Tuluce and H. Bulut, Dark soliton solutions of Klein–Gordon–Zakharov equation
in (1 + 2) dimensions, AIP Conf. Proc., Vol. 1798, Issue 1 (2017) 020032.
26. A. Houwe, M. Justin, S. Y. Doka and K. T. Crepin, Asian-Eur. J. Math. 13 (2020)
2050022.
27. A. Korkmaz, O. E. Hepson, K. Hosseini, H. Rezazadeh and M. Eslami, J. King Saud
University-Sci. 32(1) (2018) 567.
28. T. S. Mohyud-Din, K. I. Noor and M. A. Noor, Int. J. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul.
10 (2009) 223.
29. P. Li, R. Yang and Z. Xu, Phys. Rev. E 82 (2010) 046603.
30. A. Houwe, Y. Klofai, H. M. Boudoué and S. Y. Doka, Appl. Math. Phys. 5 (2017) 77.
31. S. Yakada, B. Depelair, G. Betchewe and S. Y. Doka, Optik 197 (2019) 163108.
2050246-14