Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Action Research
Submitted by:
SHAIRA B. ABELLO
TRINIDAD A. SALASAYO
JENNIFER B. PIOQUINTO
Research Teachers
NOVIE D. DANIEL
ARIEL S. CABALIDA
Statisticians
TRINIDAD A. SALASAYO
Principal I
Don Jose Aguirre National High School
December 2019
ABSTRACT
Pages
INTRODUCTION
OF DATA 14-24
APPENDIX 30-32
REFERENCES 33
Page 1
INTRODUCTION
The Policy Guidelines on Classroom Assessment for the K-12 Basic Education
Program, D.O. # 8, s. 2015 clearly emphasized the need for teachers to conduct formative
assessment to their learners.
Teaching concepts and skills to the students inside the classroom is not enough. A
teacher must also know how far have the learners understood the lesson through evaluation
or assessment as a tool to measure students’ academic achievement. Normally, different
students have varying capacities in grasping what the teacher wants to teach them. Some are
fast learners while others are average and even slow in absorbing the concepts fed to them.
This is commonly observed in a heterogeneous class with learners of multiple intelligences.
The task of a teacher is not only to teach the students concepts and skills but also to give
interventions or remediation to students who do not master the competency as revealed in the
formative assessment result in order for the teacher to attain a good result on the students’
academic achievement.
The school principal is tasked to provide technical assistance to teachers on classroom
instruction, the following problems were noted during observation of classes. Using
the Gap Analysis, gaps were critically analyzed to identify the gaps of the following :
About 41% of the teachers do not employ remediation to students who have not
mastered the lesson before ending the class session.
About 82% of the teachers don not give differentiated activities in his/her class
instructions.
About 41% of the teachers do not give written evaluation before ending the
class session to get the learners’ mastery level.
Page 2
About 41% of the teachers do not contextualize and localize his/her lesson.
About 18% of the teachers do not have CGs and TGs.
About 12% of the teachers do not have visual aids for his/her lesson.
About 71% of the teachers do not submit themselves for post conference after
class observation.
As various gaps in the particular area were determined, they were ranked accordingly
to determine the problem to focus on first. With the use of a scale from 1 as the lowest to 5 as
the highest, the identified gaps were ranked based on their relevance, importance, urgency
and doability. The prioritization, after ranking the identified gaps, have shown that teachers
lack the skills in pacing the lesson ranked first. Based on the aforesaid proposition, the
researchers have decided to conduct this research to assist teachers in acquiring skills on
pacing their lessons that would enable them to conduct remediation activities and finally
improve learners’ academic achievement.
From the Critical thinking table, the gap “7 out of 17” observed teachers do not
employ remediation activities to students who have not mastered the lesson before ending the
class session. To find out the immediate causes, the underlying causes and finally the root
cause of the problem.
After careful examination of the problem, the subsequent immediate causes were
pointed out; some teachers were observed to (1) have not conducted remediation activities;
(2) have not given written evaluation; and (3) have not identified all learners who have not
mastered the lesson.
The problem tree have shown that some teachers have not prepared their remediation
activities due to lack of time to prepare because they are overloaded with subjects and
ancillary assignments while others do not have interests to prepare remedial activities due to
lack of commitment.
There are some teachers who have not given remediation activities because they failed
to give written evaluation to their students due to insufficient time. They have spent all the
instructional time on other parts of the lesson leaving no time for evaluation. Other teachers
failed to make written evaluation due to lack of commitment.
Page 3
Some teachers have not identified all learners who need remediation because they
have not checked the test papers right after the evaluation due to lack of time. Some of them
just gave oral evaluation to few students because they failed to construct the written form.
To be able to identify the immediate solutions, the underlying solutions and the root
solutions to the problem, “ 7 out of 10 observed teachers lack skills in pacing the lesson”, an
analysis of the Problem Tree was made prior to the preparation of the Opportunity Tree.
The succeeding immediate solutions were identified after a thorough examination of
the problem was conducted. Teachers who were observed must (1) have skills in pacing
lesson; (2) be committed in making written evaluation questions and remediation activities;
and (3) must be committed in giving written evaluation and remediation activities to the
learners as planned.
According to Joyce McLeod, Jan Fisher and Ginny Hoover in a research reported in
Wong (1998), pacing the lesson is the teacher’s appropriate speed or rate in presenting the
lesson. Goldsmith, Joshua (2009), also stressed that pacing (micro level) the lesson is
deciding how long to spend on one activity and its various sub-activities; (Meso-level) is
deciding how long to spend on various activities in the class period in relation to one another
(http://www. iseesam.com>text>behaviour>LRPI).
In relation to the aforesaid, it is described in the opportunity tree that if teachers will
be equipped with the necessary skills in pacing the lesson, they could have time for the
written evaluation as the most significant part of the session that determines whether or not
learning occurs within the learners. In such way, they are guided if remedial activity is
needed in the process and could be able to conduct remediation to those who have not
mastered the lesson as said to maximize and improve students’ academic achievement.
As presented in the opportunity tree, if the division will conduct seminars/trainings on
pacing lessons and in making remedial activities, these teachers will enhance their skills in
pacing their instructional time and in making remedial activities and would have great impact
to the learners’ academic achievement.
Page 4
Furthermore, the opportunity tree have shown that if teachers are committed to make
and give written formative evaluation and remedial activities to the learners who have not
mastered the lesson, learners’ academic performance are tracked and checked.
The possible solutions shown in the opportunity tree will be a great help to the
researchers to determine the best solution(s) to the problem.
Being an educational manager, the researchers made decisions on the basis of the
enumerated solutions which were ranked based on the used criteria. The use of this decision-
making model started from the analysis of the gaps, identification of the causes of the
problem and in identification of possible solutions to the problem.
With the use of gap analysis and critical thinking, the problem, “7 out of 17 observed
teachers, lack the skills in pacing the lesson”, was found to be the most significant and critical
problem among the enumerated gaps.
To guide the researchers in their decisions, the decision criteria namely: Significance,
learning outcomes, impact, relevance, manageability and efficiency are used to solve the
problem. Significance is the importance of the problem because it is within the duties and
responsibilities attached to the position of school principal; learning outcomes indicate the
development that happens as a result of a training, activity or process; impact is the direct
effect or the influence of the training to the end goal of the school head which is to improve
the academic performance of the school; relevance is the connection or relation of the
training to the problem at hand; manageability is the ability to handle an activity with a
degree of skill; and efficiency is the ability to do something without wasting time materials,
time and energy.
Weight were assigned to each criterion, since they are not equally important and to
come up with the most prioritized decision. Each criterion was assigned with corresponding
weights from the most important to the least important: Significance – 6, Learning Outcomes-
5, Impact-4, Relevance- 3, Manageability-2 and Efficiency-1.
In looking for alternatives, possible solutions shown in the Opportunity tree were
recorded and weights are assigned according to their importance. A weight of 5 was given to
Page 5
“Conduct trainings/seminars on pacing the lesson”; “Developing within the teachers the
commitment in making written evaluation” was assigned with 4; “ Developing within the
teachers’ commitment and industry in giving written evaluation questions” was assigned
with 3; “Providing teachers the necessary skills in making remediation activities” was
assigned with 2 and; “Developing within the teachers’ the commitment and industry in
making remediation activities” was assigned with a weight of 1.
The weight of the alternatives solutions were multiplied by the weight as perceived by
the researchers when analysis of the alternative was conducted considering the ceiling
allocated for each criterion. After the process, the “Conduct of trainings/seminar-workshops
on pacing lessons” ranked 1.
To minimize, if not to resolve the problem, the alternative solution with the highest
weighted score will be the focus of the researcher. The chosen solution will then be imparted
to the teachers for its stern implementation
in the field.
Ideally, in the class, a teacher starts the lesson by reviewing the past lesson and
connects it to the current topic if possible then followed by motivation, presentation of the
lesson, discussion, generalization, application and evaluation are sequentially done.
Evaluation results become the baseline of the teacher’s tool to determine students’
performance and to determine whether or not a remediation is to be provided. Learners who
scored below the mastery level are the subject to the remedial activity before ending up the
lesson in order to improve their academic achievement by correcting their weakness in the
said lesson of the teacher.
Most of the time, however, the conduct of remediation activity as planned is not
realized due to the inability of the teacher to evaluate students’ learning on the lesson due to
lack of time.
Page 6
Teacher’s capacity to regulate his speed when teaching, giving enough time to each
part of the lesson will enable him to carry out all planned activities and provide assistance to
those learners who have not mastered the lesson through remediation.
This action research aims to study the impact of teacher’s skills in pacing the lesson
on students’ academic achievement.
This research specifically answered the following questions:
1. How can teachers be described in terms of their skills in pacing their lesson?
2. How can the teacher’s acquisition of lesson pacing skills be correlated to the
frequency and level of the students’ academic achievement?
3. How may the proposed intervention utilized to enhance the lesson pacing skills of
teachers to improve the students’ academic achievement?
4. Is there a significant relationship between teacher’s skill in pacing (speed) the
lesson and students’ academic achievement?
HYPOTHESES
The statement of Michael Alpert that pacing of a lesson should be always controlled
whether teaching in the elementary or in high school supports the conclusion that too fast or
too slow a pace does not promote learning and a moderate pace of instruction is best.
( http://www.iseesam.com>text.behaviour>LRPI)
The Impact Teachers (April 4, 2016) also stressed that to keep students engaged in the
lesson is to consider crucially the speed at which a teacher moves through a lesson and the
rate of delivery for the different parts of the lesson.
According to Rebecca Alber (Dec. 17, 2012) one of the essential features in pacing a
lesson is checking for the understanding of students on the lesson.
It is through the result of the formative assessment that a teacher could identify the
learners who need remediation on the concept/skill taught and determine the type of
remediation he has to provide that could enhance the students’ achievements in class.
This action research aimed to present the effectiveness of teachers’ skills in pacing the
lesson on students’ academic ahievement. After then, the following would benefit from the
study:
Teachers. They were informed that skills in pacing their lesson would be a
significant factor to be considered that will enable them to conduct the different remediation
activities to address the needs of struggling learners in their respective classes in enhancing
students’ academic achievement. They would also realize that remediation activities should
be accompanied with the appropriate instructional materials to maximize their achievements
as their outcomes.
Page 8
Researchers. They would be able to find out the effectiveness of teachers’ skills in
pacing their lessons to improve the academic achievement of the students. Through this,
they can design school-based training programs focused on “pacing the lesson, time-on-task
and remediation strategies that will benefit both the teachers and most especially the
students and on their academic achievement.
This study covered all teachers and students in Don Jose Aguirre National High
School teaching the eight (8) subject areas for school year 2019-2020.
Page 9
Good lesson planning is essential to the process of teaching and learning. A teacher
who is prepared is well on his/her way to a successful instructional experience. The
development of interesting lessons takes a great deal of time and effort. As a new teacher you
must be committed to spending the necessary time in this endeavour.
It is also important to realize that the best planned lesson is worthless if interesting
delivery procedures along with good classroom management techniques, are not in evidence.
They are skills that must be researched, structured to your individual style, implemented in a
teacher/ learning situation, and constantly evaluated and revamped when necessary.
Consistency is of the utmost importance in the implementation of a classroom management
plan. (kean.edu/-tpc/Classroom)
Good pacing gives students the illusion of speed. Pacing is the skill of creating a
perception that a class is moving at “just the right speed” for students. Generally, this will
mean that the lesson appears to unfold more quickly.
Students see any change as an indicator or marker which helps them gauge the speed
of a lesson’s progress. A good pace helps students feel like they are moving along.
(https://resources.finalsite.net)
Intervention means an act of inserting one thing between strategies which is designed
to help and to make things better. In education, intervention is a strategy designed to help
students progress in their learning based on their individual needs. (http:// skills-
mastery.co.uk> intervention)
Page 10
This research used the descriptive method that required the collection of data using
the class observation sheets and the student’s questionnaire. The design was purposely done
to gather information on the teacher’s skills in managing instructional time by pacing the
lesson to conduct remediation for enhancing and improving students’ academic achievement.
There were 18 teachers who were the target population of the study who were observed by
the school head as one of the researchers.
The data for the study were collected with the use of two sets of questionnaires. The
first questionnaire was able to collect the data which described the teacher’s skills in pacing
the lesson, while the second questionnaire was able to show the frequency of students’
average grades in the first quarter of school year 2019-2020.
The Chi-Square formula was used to test the gathered data by the instruments and
would determine whether the two variables are related to each other or not. It is one way to
show a the relationship between the two variables in the study- (1) teachers’ skill in pacing
A. ACTION PLAN
Before doing anything else in relation to this research, the researchers had made this
action plan as a guide of what activities have to be done before, during and after the
implementation of the study. This minimized the waste of resources and ensured that the
desired output was achieved.
The plan indicated the activities in the stages of the study; the Pre-implementation stage,
Implementation stage and the Post-implementation stage. It reflected the objectives,
activities, responsible persons in each activity, time frame, resources needed, expected
outputs and the statistical tools to measure the gathered outputs.
Page 12
This part presents the results, analyses, and interpretation of the collected data. Table
were used to briefly and clearly present all the data.
Table 1. Pacing lesson in terms of Time Allotment
Table 1 presents the profile of the teacher respondents in pacing lesson in terms of
time allotment. Among the five skills, four of them were often done by the teachers; (1)
started the lesson on time; (2) review and motivation were given time allotment of not more
than three minutes each; (4) group presentation of output was given time allotment of not
more than three minutes and; (5) conducted the complete parts of the complete parts of the
lesson and ends the lesson on time. One skill is sometimes done by the teachers wherein each
group activity is given time allotment of not more than three minutes each. As a whole,
pacing lesson in terms of time allotment has a group mean of 3.90.
Page 15
The result implies that most teachers in Don Jose Aguirre National High School often
use and practice the skills needed in pacing lesson in terms of time allotment. Teachers pay
attention and value the utilization of time in class sessions.
The result implies that all teachers in Don Jose Aguirre National High School
often use and practice the skills needed in pacing lesson in terms of teaching-learning process
and strategies used. Teachers properly utilize and apply the varied strategies in the teaching-
learning process in the pacing lesson.
Weighted Interpretation
Skills Mean
1. Provides at most three (3) group activities for the class 3.83 Often
session.
2. Prepares group activities instruction prior to class 4.11 Often
session.
3. Directions for group activities are clearly stated. 4.06 Often
4. Supervises students during group activities. 4.39 Often
5. Prepares materials for group activities before the class 4.28 Often
session.
Group Mean 4.13 Often
The result implies that all the teachers of Don Jose Aguirre National High School often apply
varied student activities to maximize students’ learning at their own rate. This further shows
that there is a high chance of meaningful learning since the learners are expose to
differentiated instruction which would elevate their potential in solving varied issues from the
different subject areas.
Weighted
Interpretation
Skills Mean
1. Prepares 5-item written evaluation questions with clear
4.39 Often
direction before the class starts.
2. Gives 5-item multiple choice type of written evaluation
4.17 Often
to the students.
3. Computes Mastery level of the class after the written
4.39 Often
evaluation.
ranked 3.33 Sometimes
5. Re-test the students who were given the remediation
3.11 Sometimes
using similar questions.
Group Mean 3.88 Often
teachers; (1) conducted remediation to the students who have not mastered the lesson on the
questions they failed to answer correctly; (2) conducted re-test to the students who were
given the remediation using similar questions. As a whole, pacing lesson in terms of
evaluation provided has a group mean of 3. 88.
The result implies that most of the teachers of Don Jose Aguirre National High
School often use and apply the skills needed in pacing lesson in terms or evaluation.
Weighted Interpretation
Skills Mean
1. Uses a system of checking students’ attendance to 4.33 Often
minimize time used.
2. Applies a systematic way of presenting audio-visual 3.72 Often
aids.
3. Utilizes short way of recognizing/praising good 4.22 Often
works/responses of students.
4. Reminds students of the house rules. 4.06 Often
5. Gives immediate and non-violent action to students’ 4.39 Often
misbehavior.
Group Mean 4.14 Often
praising works/ responses of students; (4) reminded students of the house rules; (5) gave
immediate and non-violent action to students’ misbehavior. As a whole, pacing lesson in
terms of classroom management applied has a group mean of 4.14.
The result implies that all teachers of Don Jose Aguirre National High School
often apply the skills needed in pacing lesson in terms of classroom management applied.
The result reflects that most of the well performing teachers in applying the
various skills in pacing lesson in different aspects come from female respondents, and less on
the male respondents.
Page 20
The result reflects that those who are in the teaching service for more than 6-10
years can give more positive outcome in pacing lesson in terms of time allotment, teaching-
learning process and strategies used, student-activities provided, evaluation provided and
classroom management applied.
Page 21
The table presents the profile of respondents based on their marital status.
Among the 18 teacher respondents, 13 or 72.22 % is married, 4 or 22.22 % is single, 1 or
5.56% is single and none of them is separated or widow/widower.
The result reflects that although most of the teachers in Don Jose Aguirre
National are married, this does not affect their teaching performance in the class in pacing
lesson in terms of time allotment, teaching-learning process and strategies used, student-
activities provided, evaluation provided and classroom management applied.
Page 22
The table presents the summary on teacher’s skill in pacing (speed) the lesson.
Among the four aspects/ indicators, all were often used and applied by the teachers in Don
Jose Aguirre National High School. Pacing lesson in terms of classroom management applied
rank 1st with a weighted mean of 4.14. Pacing lesson in terms of student-activities provided
ranked 2nd with a weighted mean of 4. 13. Pacing lesson in terms of teaching-learning process
and strategies used ranked 3rd with a weighted mean of 4.06. Pacing lesson in terms of time
allotment ranked 4th with a weighted mean of 3.90 and pacing lesson in terms of evaluation
provided ranked 5th with a weighted mean of 3.88.
As reflected from the highest to the lowest rank, the result implies that the
teachers of Don Jose Aguirre National High School are mostly highly skilled, well versed and
keen enough in pacing lesson in terms of classroom management. Somehow, there is a need
to improve teachers’ skill in giving definite and precise time allotment in the conduct of the
lesson.
Page 23
The table presents the summary on the level of academic achievement of the
student-respondents. The total value of student-respondents (frequency) is 437, wherein 150
or 34.32% got the 1st rank having below average grades between 81-85; 139 or 31.81% got
the 2nd rank having poor grades between 75-80; 110 or 25.17% got the 3 rd rank having
average grades between 86-90; 37 or 8.47% got the 4th rank having above average grades
between 91-95; and 1 or 0.23% got the 5th rank having superior grades between 96-99.
Page 24
Table 11 shows the relationship between teachers’ skill in pacing (speed) the
lesson and students’ academic achievement. From tabular value of chi-square equal to 26.30
which is less than the computed chi-square values 19.09, 16.80, 14.02, 40.84 and 15.61
respectively. The extent teachers’ skill in pacing lesson (time allotment, teaching- learning
process and strategies used, student-activities provided, evaluation provided, classroom
management applied) has significant relationship with the students’ academic achievement.
Thus, the hypothesis aforementioned above teachers’ skill in pacing lesson has no significant
relationship with the students’ academic achievement was therefore rejected. This shows that
the teachers being the closest persons to the students in the school, especially in the teaching-
learning process and who have a directs control in them have significant influence on the
students in terms of their academic achievement.
Page 25
1. How can teachers be described in terms of their skills in pacing their lesson?
2. How can the teacher’s acquisition of lesson pacing skills be correlated to the
frequency and level of the students’ academic achievement?
3. How may the proposed intervention to enhance the lesson pacing skills of
teachers to improve the students’ academic achievement?
Page 26
Summary of Findings
1. In pacing lesson in terms of time allotment, 83% of the skills were often practiced and
17% of the remaining was sometimes practiced by the teachers in Don Jose Aguirre
National High School with a group/ average mean of 3.90.
2. In pacing lesson in terms of teaching-learning process and strategies used, all the
indicated skills were often practiced by the teachers in Don Jose Aguirre National
High School with a group/ average mean of 4.06.
3. In pacing lesson in terms of student-activities provided, all the indicated skills were
often practiced by the teachers in Don Jose Aguirre National High School with a
group/ average mean of 4.13.
4. In pacing lesson in terms of evaluation provided, 60% of the skills were often
practiced and 40% of the remaining skills were sometimes practiced by the teachers in
Don Jose Aguirre National High School with a group/ average mean of 3.88.
5. In pacing lesson in terms of classroom management applied, all the skills were often
practiced by the teachers in Don Jose Aguirre National High School with a group/
average mean of 4.14.
6. With regards to the gender of the teacher- respondents, 11.11% comprises male and
88.89% were female.
7. As regards to the number of years in service of the respondents, 22.22% have
teaching experiences for less than two (2) years, another 22.22% for the teachers who
have experiences for 2-5 years and 55.56% have experience for 6-10 years.
8. In terms of the marital status of the respondents, 5.56% singles parent, 22.22% single
and 72.22 married.
Page 27
9. As to the summary of the teachers’ skill in pacing (speed) the lesson, all the aspects/
indicators were often practiced by the teachers in Don Jose Aguirre National High
School wherein, pacing lesson in terms of classroom management applied ranked the
first with a weighted mean of 4.14, and pacing lesson in terms of evaluation provided
ranked the least with a weighted mean of 3.88.
10. In terms of the level of academic achievement of the student-respondents, average
grades of students between 81-85 ranked the first and 96-99 ranked the least.
11. There is significant relationship in the teacher’s pacing (speed) skill and students’
academic achievement.
Conclusions
The following conclusions are formulated based on the finding of the study:
2. Since majority of the teacher-respondents are female, the teaching skills applied
were also mostly influenced by a feministic way of dealing the teaching-learning
process.
3. None of the teacher-respondents were still able to reach 11-16 years in the teaching
service. Even there is 55.56% who has 6-10 years of experience, 44% has still lesser
years of experiences. These teachers still lacks the full potential and needs further
personal and professional enhancements.
Page 28
4. Most of the teacher-respondents are already married. Therefore, it would also be a
factor that the teachers may not always employ the skills aforementioned in different
aspects in pacing lesson since they should also prioritize their family especially their
children after work. Lesser time will be given to extra professional works if to be
brought at home, unlike the 22.22% teacher-respondents who are single they may
have the higher chance to bring work into their homes.
5. The teachers’ skill in pacing (speed) lesson has a significant relationship to the
students’ academic achievement. Although teachers are often involved in the
students’ learning process especially at school, this may not be enough as shown
in the students’ low-moderate average grades (academic achievement). To divert
the focus of teachers by intervening external factors can affect the students’
academic achievement.
Recommendations
The following recommendations are hereby suggested based on the findings and
conclusions made in the study:
Page 29
3. Invite speakers outside the school premise so that the teachers would also be
motivated, and be informed about the trends happening in other school
communities. This is the sole purpose of linkages, since learning cannot be
maximized only among the people whom you tend to see every day. The more
teachers will broaden their scope in acquiring new way in delivering lessons, the
more they will appreciate and be challenged to apply what they learned outside, to
their individual learning environment.
4. Conduct in-service trainings to all teachers regarding on pacing lesson that could
mature their ideas in teaching-learning process.
5. Conduct activities to teachers that would highlight time-management. Through
this, teachers could reflect themselves how important is it to give proper focus and
attention on how to deliver lesson in the classroom.
6. Conduct further study to other types of secondary schools and to other locations to
find differences or similarities of the results on the relationship of teachers’ skill
in pacing (speed) lesson to students’ academic achievement. Other teacher factors
must also be included such as age and cultural or religious group.
Page 33
REFERENCES
FunctionalBehavioralAssessment(fuba).iseesam.com/content/teachall/text/beha
vior/LRBIpdfs/lrbiresource_02.pdf.
http://www.impactteachers.com>paceOw.ly/B6MK3011HZ6#blog#education#im
pact#teacherlife.
“ Pacing and Time Allocation at the micro- and meso-level within the class
hour: Why pacing is important, how to study it, and what it implies for
individual lesson planning?”. Goldsmith, Joshua, University Autonoma de
Barcelona) Bellaterra: Journal of Teaching & Learning Language &
Literature, Vol.1, No. 1, November 2009, 30-48.
Synonym. http://classroom.synonym.com./
The Advantages of Remedial Activities in the Classroom: Behavior and
Motivation, by: Robin Mc Daniel (http://classroom.synonym.com>
2001- 2008, Leaf Group Ltd., ).
The key elements of classroom management: managing time and space,
student behavior, and instructional strategies. Joyce McLeod-Jan Fisher-
Ginny Hoover - Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development –
2003.