Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/339128711
CITATIONS
READS
2
3,820
2 authors, including:
Shalom Akhai
Chandigarh Group of Colleges
24 PUBLICATIONS 98 CITATIONS
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Shalom Akhai on 08 February 2020.
19
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
Once the temperature is brought down, usually through
quenching or normalizing, the austenite that is formed is
converted into martensite or bainite. These are responsible
for bringing about the hardness at the surface.
2 C + O2 → 2 CO
2 CO + Fe → C(active) + CO2
CO2 + C → 2 CO
The main agent here is the carbon monoxide that is
formed inside the pack. It is this carbon monoxide which
further donates the atomic carbon which diffuses into the
sample.
19
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
Equipment used can be either hand held spraying torches It is neither externally brittle nor ductile due to its lower
or sophisticated metallizing guns for more specialized carbon content. It has lower tensile strength and malleable.
applications. Thermal spraying techniques are coating Steel with low carbon steel has properties similar to iron.
processes in which melted (or heated) materials are sprayed As the carbon content increases, the metal becomes harder
onto a surface. The "feedstock" (coating precursor) is and stronger but less ductile and more difficult to weld.
heated by electrical (plasma or arc) or chemical means Case hardening is the process of hardening the surface of
(combustion flame). metal, often low carbon steel by infusing elements into the
metal surface forming a hard, wear resistance skin but
preserving a tough and ductile applied to gears, ball
bearings, railway wheels.
In this study, we will carry out the surface hardening
procedures of on steel of grade EN 353 which is used as a
digester screw in the wood pulp industry. Due to the
pressure exerted by the wood pulp on the threads of the
screw a lot wear occurs on the component. However, we
cannot go for traditional hardening methods such as
normalizing or quenching because we want to retain the
tensile strength provided by the low carbon steel. Thus, our
best option is to perform case hardening techniques on the
sample so that it retains it tensile strength and at the same
Fig 5: Thermal Spraying time becomes hard and resistant to wear.
Hence, the techniques used in the study are:
IV. PROBLEM FORMULATION
5.1 Pack Carburizing
In this paper, we study the mechanical behavior of
digester screw in the wood pulp industry. The volume Pack carburization is the oldest method among the case
between the successive threads in the screws decreases hardening treatments. Carburizing improves the hardness
with the length however, the volume of the wood pulp tries and durability of products like carbon steel wire springs
to remain constant. Thus we see the pulp exerts a shear and carbon steel forgings. Following are the steps followed
stress on the threads. This along with the wear of the thread for pack carburizing on the samples prepared :
due to wood pulp causes the threads to chip, leading to 1. In order to perform pack carburizing we start off by
failure. machining a sample with 8mm diameter and 1 inch
The material to make the digester screw is steel EN 353 length. This is done to make sure that the component
which is low carbon steel having a good toughness. Thus it can be tested for wear analysis later.
can take the shear stress exerted by the wood pulp. 2. Next we prepare the pack by mixing charcoal and
However due to its low surface hardness, it is not able to barium carbonate in 10:1 ratio by weight in the pack
withstand the wear process. To overcome the shortfall, we box. The charcoal would provide the carbon which
will try to come up with ways of increasing the surface will diffuse into the sample surface, and BaCO3 will
hardness of the sample by performing case hardening act as an activator in this reaction.
procedures. These are, two methods of carburizing: Gas 3. The samples are placed in this pack and are
and Pack and two methods of hardfacing: TIG (using surrounded by charcoal mixture from all sides. At
Stellite 6) and Thermal Spray coating of Tungsten carbide. least 1 inch space is provided between the samples so
We will then test various properties of these samples, that the rate of carbon diffusion is uniform across the
such as surface hardness, wear loss, microstructure, etc. sample.
and will try to determine which is the best method out of 4. Then, we cover the lid and the open crevices of the
the four that we have used. pack with powder of Paris so that the gases evolved in
the pack do not dissipate and carburizing takes place
V. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE effectively.
Low carbon steel has carbon content of 0.15% to 0.45%.
Low carbon steel is the most common form of steel as it’s
provides material properties that are acceptable for many
applications.
19
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
1. We start off by machining a sample with 8mm dia and
1 inch length. This is done to make sure that the
component can be tested for wear analysis later. A
wire is then wound around the sample and it is made
to hang from a rod.
19
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
This will be done by first measuring the surface hardness 5.5.2 Wear Testing
of the sample using C scale of the hardness tester. Values
which do not come under this scale will be separately Our next step is to perform wear testing on the sample
mentioned. and find out the loss in weight after a specific period in
Next we will measure the wear that takes place in each time. For this we follow the following steps:
sample, which will be done using the Wear Testing 1. We start by weighing the sample on a sensitive
machine. Finally, we will see the microstructure of each milligram scale. This is done so that we can find the
sample and try to see what is happening at the weight loss due to wear.
microstructure level.
5.5.1 Hardness Testing
The heat treated specimens hardness was measured by
means of Rockwell hardness tester. The procedure adopted
can be listed as follows:
19
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
4. Observing the microstructure under a metallurgical 6.3 Microstructure Analysis
microscope.
In order to look at the microstructure, we first fine grind
VI. RESULTS the sample and then polish it. We then etch the sample and
observe its microstructure. The magnification of the images
Once we performed the various surface hardening is X100.
process on our given steel sample, we did the various
mechanical tests on them to determine the final properties
of the samples and try to determine which one is the best
procedure. In this section, we will present the results of the
tests we performed and the discussions and conclusions
will follow in the next chapters.
6.1 Tabulation of Hardness Testing
The load applied for the following values is 150kgf and
the dwell time is 5 seconds.
Table 1:
Hardness values of the samples
20
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
Hardness ( HRC)
Axis Title
Fig 18: Etched Gas Carburized sample (edge), T = 910o, t = 1 hour
20
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
The TIG welder is small, almost like a pen, which allows
welders to use it for nearly any purpose. The inert gas used
in the welder allows it to work on different metals. Argon
is best for steel and titanium, helium is best for stainless
steel and copper, and an argon-and-helium combination is
best for aluminum and alloys that include aluminum.
In Thermal spray, there is a comprehensive choice of
coating materials to meet the needs of a wide variety of
applications, in particular protection from wear and
corrosion damage. Coatings of metal, cermets, ceramic and
plastic can be applied to any substrate that will not degrade
from the heat of the impinging particles or gas jets. The
Fig 22: Graphs of Wear Loss in the samples coating is formed with minimal heating of the substrate and
the coating does not need to fuse with the substrate to form
a bond. Substrate temperature seldom exceeds 300°C. As a
consequence, coatings can be applied to components with
little or no pre- or post-heat treatment and component
distortion is minimal. The coatings can also be applied to
thermal sensitive substrates such as low melting point
metals and plastics. Thick coatings, typically up to 10mm,
can be applied and often at high deposition rates. This
means that thermal spraying can also be used for
component reclamation and spray forming. Parts can be
rebuilt quickly and at low cost, usually at a fraction of the
replacement price. Thermal spraying has the capacity to
form barrier and functional coatings on a wide range of
substrates. More recently, thermal spraying has been
Fig 23: Comparison of Hardness and Wear loss of the samples recognized as a key process for the synthesis of specialized
coatings and materials. It offers the ability to create
Bulk hardness tests (Rockwell or Brinell) which measure freestanding structures for net-shaped manufacture of high
the average hardness of both the carbide and matrix performance ceramics, composites and functional graded
together over a relatively large area, often register the same materials. It is also used for the rapid-solidification
hardness as that of other conventional metals. synthesis of specialized materials. Thermal spraying is now
Similarly, when comparing several surfacing alloys with being considered for the synthesis of advanced functional
each other, equally high bulk hardness ratings is not the surfaces such as catalytic coatings, dielectrics, ferrites,
only factor assuring resistance to wear. Resistance bioactive materials and solid oxide fuel cells.
(especially to low- and high-stress abrasion) depends rather As for the carburizing methods, we can clearly see that
on a combination of both hardness and the metallurgical gas carburizing gives a good surface hardness as compared
microstructure of the alloy. The microstructure of alloys to the other procedures followed. Further it is a good
varies according to the ratio of carbides to matrix and the method for obtaining surface hardening for low carbon
type of carbides in the alloy. The alloy with the hardest, alloys such as EN353. However, the wear resistance of the
most evenly dispersed carbides along with the highest gas carburized product is not as good as the sample with
percentage of carbides will have the best resistance to low- the thermal spray. This goes on to show that there is no
stress and high-stress abrasion. fixed relationship between surface hardness and wear
Advantages of TIG welding offers advantages in terms resistance.
of versatility and amperage use because it uses less energy The major determinant when opting between these two
than other welding methods. A clean weld is also achieved methods is the scale of operations. gas carburizing has a
by making a low-profile weld bead, and there is no slag left relatively cheap operational cost and we can improve the
over after the welding is complete. The largest advantage surface hardness of several small samples at the same time.
of TIG welding is control, both in terms of the electrode Thus, it is a mass production oriented sample.
itself and the current.
20
International Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering
Website: www.ijetae.com (ISSN 2250-2459, ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal, Volume 4, Issue 10, October
Whereas, thermal spray is done on relatively small Lastly, we come to pack carburizing which is the least
batches where wear resistance is the main aim. Therefore, desirable method of all. We cannot control the case depth
for a digester screw which is several feet in length, the and the wear resistance that we get is also not great. Even
thermal spray method not only gives a better wear though it is one of the cheapest methods out there, it just
resistance, but can also be aimed to target only the parts doesn’t give us the same properties like other surface
where the wear resistance is required. hardening procedures and is not suitable for our digester
As for the pack carburizing method, it gives us the least screw problem.
surface hardness and least wear resistance. Further it is a
very labor intensive method in which most of the reactants REFERENCES
get wasted. Also, there is no easy way of giving the sample [1] A. Hultgren, J. Iron Steel Inst., July 1951, p 245–257
the case depth that is required. There’s no doubt that this [2] W.F. Gale and T.C. Totemeier, Ed., Chap. 29, Heat Treatment,
method of surface hardness is now obsolete and is not used Smithells Metals Reference Book, 8th ed., Elsevier Butterworth-
anymore. Heinemann, 2004
[3] R. Collin, S. Gunnarson, and D. Thulin, A Mathematical Model for
Predicting Carbon Concentration Profiles of Gas-Carburized Steel, J.
VIII. CONCLUSIONS Iron Steel Inst., Vol 210 (No. 10), 1972, p 785–789
From the results and discussions above, we can see that [4] O. Boudouard, Ann. Chim. Phys., Vol 24 (No. 5), 1901, p 85
the sample with the Thermal spray has the best wear [5] M.L. Schmidt, Pre-Oxidation Prior to Gas Carburizing: Theory and
resistance. Thus, it is the technique which we will be using Its Effect on Pyrowear 53 Alloy, Carburizing Processing and
Performance, G. Krauss, Ed., ASM International, 1989, p 83–100
to line the cutting edge of the digester screw to prevent
[6] J. Wunning, Weiterentwicklung der Gasaufkohlungstechnik
wear from the wood pulp. (Advances in Gas Carburizing Technique), Härt.-Tech. Mitt., Vol 23
Gas carburizing comes a close second with surface (No. 3), 1968, p 101–109
hardness almost equal to the thermal spray sample. [7] U. Wyss, R. Hoffmann, and F. Neumann, Basic Requirements for
However that main difference that separates them both is Reducing the Consumption of Carburizing Gases, J. Heat Treat., Vol
the difference in wear loss. Thermal spray is a very specific 1 (No. 3), 1980, p 14–23
process as compared to gas carburizing and gives very [8] D.W. McCurdy and S.J. Midea, Benefits of Improved Carburizing
Accuracy Using 3-Gas IR Compensation of Oxygen Probes,
excellent results. Gas carburizing, though cheap and International Automotive Heat Treating Conference, 1998, p 29–31
efficient, is more of a mass production process which is [9] Afrox product reference manual – Hardfacing Comparative study of
used for smaller samples. Hardfacing of steel by three different welding processes
As for the TIG coating using Stellite 6, though it also an [10] www.millerwelds.com/pdf/gtawbook.pdf
effective method, it is has become obsolete and has been [11] www.aws.org/w/a/wj/2002/11/feature
replaced other methods such as thermal spray. Therefore,
even though it is a decent method, there are other methods
out there which are better than it.
20
View publication