Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Well Forensics
Difficult wells require a
more detailed approach,
page 23
Also:
Maximizing ROI with
downhole cameras, page 29
Progressive well and pump
maintenance, page 36
NGWA
The Groundwater
Association
®
SAVE MONEY
WITH CLEAN MUD
RECYCLES THE
MUD & DUMPS
THE CRUD
MP255-100
Pick up and clean up to 500 gpm
@ 200 psi, with a 250 Pump
and 118 Pump—Chrome with
enhanced Mechanical Seal. The MudPuppy® was designed to
efficiently remove rocks and sand
from drill mud, making the mud and
jobsite cleaner. With clean mud the
problems of wear and tear on the
mud pump, drill string, and other
parts are reduced dramatically. The
hole is cleaner with less wall cake,
making for a more productive well.
MP170-2SC MP255-2SC
Pick up and clean up to 350 GPM. Pick up and clean up to 500 GPM. Each MudPuppy® is outfitted with
Built with with a 118 Pump— Built with with a 118 Pump—Chrome a high wear CHROME centrifugal
Chrome with Mechanical Seal. with enhanced Mechanical Seal. pump. Chrome ensures a longer life
with higher RPM.
Groundwater Week
442.242.7507 | craigh@mudpuppyinc.com | Tibban.com. Booth #319
Water pressure measurement
should never compromise how
clean the water is...
For over 90 years, Telemecanique Sensors has provided control solutions which help monitor and
automate proper reactions to pressure levels. Our Square D brand water pressure switch is consistently
recognized as the #1 switch in the industry and our recent innovations in pressure monitoring incorporate
the latest, cutting-edge technology. Using a Telemecanique Sensors or Square D brand pressure solution
not only contributes a long history of reliability and effectiveness to your water system, but ensures that
your solution complies with NSF / ANSI 61 health effects criteria for water system components.
So if you want a time-tested, proven water pressure solution that is NSF certified for potable drinking
water, make the easy jump to Telemecanique Sensors and industry-standard Square D brand water
pressure switches. While our competitors may claim to match the same level of service provided by a
Telemecanique Sensor or Square D pressure switch, time has shown those claims to be quite...fishy...
Who should you trust for all your pressure monitoring and pressure switch solutions?
Simply easy!
61 tesensors.com/pressuresensors
July 2018
Vol. 72, No. 7
Featured ARTICLES
23 Well Forensics
By Roger Miller
Difficult well problems may require a more
detailed approach of investigation.
29 Maximizing Your ROI
By William Wagner
Downhole cameras can be a great tool
for any company. But make sure you
know these five factors before lowering
one in a well.
About the cover: A view from the back of a rig from Rottman
Drilling Co. at a jobsite at a ranch in Santa Clarita, California.
The well replacement was drilled 610 feet and marked the last well
for Rottman as it ceased operation and began selling its equip-
ment after the job. In addition to irrigating the ranch, the well
supplies water for Los Angeles County fire-fighting crews in times
of need—like earlier this summer. Rottman, which was located
in Lancaster, California, was in business for nearly 90 years and
three generations. Rottman did well drilling and pump installation,
well maintenance, well rehabilitation, and more. Photo submitted
by Edd Scofield of Johnson Screens, Aqseptence Group, in Laguna
Hills, California.
2 July 2018 WWJ waterwelljournal.com
Featured COLUMNISTS
29 32 Safety Matters
By Alexandra Walsh
WWJ DEPARTMENTS Eye Safety on the Job
Having an eye and face protection program prevents injuries.
4 First Up
Some Like It Hot 34 Drawing from the Well
6 Editor’s Note By Gary Shawver, MGWC
Treat Your Customers Like Ambassadors No Man Is an Island
If the groundwater industry is going to survive, we must be
8 In This Issue willing to help others.
10 WWJ Closeup 36 Engineering Your Business
Steve Chisholm, CPI
By Ed Butts, PE
12 Industry Newsline Preventive Well and Pump Maintenance
Revised lead and copper rule delayed again Program
18 The Log Part 1: Setting up the program and its parameters
NGWA files comments on EPA’s groundwater/
44 People at Work
surface water interaction request
By Alexandra Walsh
20 Now on Water Well Journal.com
Outsourcing HR for Small Businesses
51 Newsmakers Whether you outsource everything or just some tasks, there are
2M Co. Inc. celebrates 40th anniversary options for your company.
L
ester Johnson, a certified welder for 30 years, works
on 24-inch ps 316 stainless steel well screen featuring First Up is a page of Water Well Journal that showcases—
weld rings and collars. The photo was taken at Johnson you! Please send in photos and brief descriptions and you just
Screens’ Bakersfield, California, facility. When completed, may be “first up” in an issue of WWJ ! And remember, if your
the screen went to an aquifer storage and recovery project photo is selected for the cover of WWJ, you’ll receive $250. If
in Monterey, California. Johnson is wearing proper personal your photos are selected, you will be asked to fill out a photo
protective equipment for welding. Read the Safety Matters disclaimer form that grants the National Ground Water Asso-
column on eye protection on page 32. Photo submitted by ciation the royalty-free right to display the photos. Please send
Edd T. Scofield of Johnson Well Screens, Aqseptence Group. high resolution digital photos to tplumley@ngwa.org.
franklinwater.com
T
his is an editorial on customer service. It is not an editorial NGWA President
on designer purses, although it may seem like one at times. David Henrich, CWD/PI, CVCLD
And let’s admit—if this was about purses, at least we
Director of Information Products/Editor
could all say we were witness to a first in Water Well Journal’s
Thad Plumley tplumley@ngwa.org
77-year history!
My wife had a designer purse she used for years, basically Water Well Journal Editorial Review Board
carrying it until it wore out. Meeting the manufacturer at a Art Becker, MGWC, CPG; Tom Christopherson;
show, she mentioned it and was told to send it in for repair. Dan Milan; Roger Renner, MGWC;
She eagerly did so, excited to see it come back looking like John Schnieders, Ph.D., and Robert Sterrett, Ph.D.
new again. Senior Editor
And then nothing happened. Mike Price mprice@ngwa.org
She called to no response. Emails went unanswered. Copy Editor
Finally, she posted a question on one of the manufacturer’s social media channels. Wayne Beatty wbeatty@ngwa.org
That got a response. “Oh my goodness,” she was told. “You sent it to the wrong
Production and Design
place. Ask the postal service to send it back to you and then mail to the correct
Deirdre Stevens dstevens@ngwa.org
address so we can repair it right away.”
She did just that—and then nothing happened. Advertising
She called to no response. Emails went unanswered. Brooke Smith
Worried, my wife looked online for complaints about the company. Unfortu- Kelli Nilsson
nately, she found stories looking eerily like her own. Her heart sank. Mark Mohanna
To say my wife had been an ambassador for this purse manufacturer for years Matthew Thomasson
is an understatement. She would show off their products to friends and tell anyone To inquire, contact sales@ngwa.org
who would listen all about them. I told her on more than one occasion she should Circulation Coordinator
have a marketing title and salary with the company. Denise Bierkortte dbierkortte@ngwa.org
And then something occurred to her. “I wonder if they lost it and are afraid to Contributing Writers
admit it,” she asked me one day. She wrote again and asked if picking out a new Ed Butts, PE; Donald W. Gregory;
purse would “be easier than making the repair.” An immediate reply told her to pick William J. Lynott; Julie Hansen;
something out. Michael J. Schnieders, PG, PH-GW;
She did so. And then—I know you can see where this is going by now—nothing Gary Shawver, MGWC; Lana Straub;
happened. Raymond L. Straub Jr., PG; Jennifer Strawn;
We’re at eight months and counting now. The company’s name no longer elicits Alexandra Walsh; and William Wagner.
phrases that sound like a commercial; they’re more like rants I am not allowed to
Editorial, Advertising, & Publishing Offices
print.
601 Dempsey Rd., Westerville, OH 43081
You don’t always know the ambassadors for your company, which is why treating
(800) 551-7379 Fax: (614) 898-7786
every customer with respect has to be the rule. So, what do you think the average
customer would say about you? Would it be a commercial worthy of running on Selected content from Water Well Journal is
television? Would you be proud of what you heard? indexed on Ground Water On-Line™ at
There is major competition for every business today. This means quality customer www.NGWA.org/gwonline
service is more critical than ever. Make sure you treat every customer like they’re ©Copyright 2018 by the National Ground Water
your best one and they may just repay you by becoming your ambassador. Association. All rights reserved.
I can assure you that beats the alternative.
The Water Well Journal (ISSN #0043-1443) is published
monthly by the National Ground Water Association,
601 Dempsey Rd., Westerville, OH 43081.
Printed and mailed at Beaver Dam, Wisconsin, and additional
mailing offices. Postal acceptance: Periodical (requester
subscription circulation) postage paid at Westerville, Ohio,
Thad Plumley is the editor of WWJ and director of information products at the National Ground Water and at additional mailing offices.
Association. He can be reached at tplumley@ngwa.org and on Twitter @WaterWellJournl. Postmaster: Send address changes to Water Well Journal,
601 Dempsey Rd., Westerville, OH 43081.
Canada Post/ Publications Mail Agreement #40739533.
Return address: 4960-2 Walker Rd., Windsor, ON N9A 6J3.
8. 5 x 11
Whether you’re in the field or at the office, experience knowledge at your fingertips with A.Y. McDonald University (AYU).
Sign up for this free e-learning platform at aymcdonaldu.com and experience our knowledge in the water works and gas industry!
Visit AYMcDonald.com or call 1.800.292.2737 to learn how our E-Series Jet Pumps can work for you.
Look to us to make water work for the plumbing, pumps, and water works industry.
In this ISSUE Disclaimer
Water Well Journal and the National Ground
T he July issue of Water Well Journal focuses on well rehabilitation and features
two feature articles on the subject.
Author Roger Miller covers how to assess well systems that
Water Association provide information for guidance
and information purposes only. This publication is
not intended to provide investment, tax, or legal
are proving difficult because common assessment practices are not advice.
solving the problem. In the cover story, “Well Forensics” on page The issues addressed in Water Well Journal have
23, Miller points out some wells from time to time require more been identified by NGWA as being pertinent to its
mission, but the decision to address any particular
detailed investigations and then shares case studies that show how
issue should not be interpreted as an indication
to do so. that such an issue is more or less important to the
He provides four case studies of well systems that needed extra industry than other issues.
research from his company. The studies represent wells having Water Well Journal and NGWA cannot
problems relating to a well construction-related issue, water quality Roger Miller guarantee as to its accuracy, completeness,
issue, deposited materials not responding to conventional treatments, and validity of the information contained herein
and an operational issue within the water chemistry realm. and cannot be held liable for any errors or
omissions. All information contained herein
Using a downhole camera is the subject of freelance writer William Wagner’s fea-
should be independently verified and confirmed.
ture story. Titled “Maximizing Your ROI” and starting on page 29, he lists five fac- Water Well Journal and NGWA do not accept
tors to consider when using a downhole camera, and why the tool can be an important any liability for any loss or damage howsoever
part of your work. caused in reliance upon such information.
The tips mentioned are: A camera doesn’t lie. View the camera’s footage like a Readers agree to assume all risk resulting from
doctor. Don’t hesitate asking for a second opinion. Have a plan. You get what you pay the application of any of the information provided
for. While cameras come with associated costs, Wagner’s article explains they can be by Water Well Journal and NGWA.
The NGWA is funded in large parts by member
quite useful and help justify the fees you charge to customers.
dues, advertising, and donations and is not finan-
The monthly Safety Matters column looks at the important topic cially able to full explore all issues impacting the
of protecting your eyes when on the jobsite. In “Eye Safety on the groundwater industry. The NGWA assumes no duty
Job” on page 32, columnist Alexandra Walsh begins with some to its members or any party to investigate, evaluate,
sobering statistics: 2000 workers suffer eye injuries each day; 33% or disseminate information regarding any issue
of eye injuries are treated in emergency rooms; and eye injuries cost within the industry.
more than $300 million per year in lost time, medical expenses, and Trademarks and copyrights mentioned within
Water Well Journal are the ownership of their
workers’ compensation.
respective companies. The names of products and
Walsh then highlights OSHA standards covering eye protection; services presented are used only in an education
Alexandra Walsh how eye injuries can occur; selecting proper personal equipment fashion and to the benefit of the trademark and
protecting the eyes; providing a written eye safety plan that features copyright owner, with no intention of infringing on
training; and handling eye emergencies. An accompanying sidebar features a checklist trademarks or copyrights.
of five key steps to take for eye safety. No endorsement of any third-party products
Walsh also authors the People at Work column titled “Outsourcing HR for Small or services is expressed or implied by any
information, material, or content referred to
Businesses” which begins on page 44. In it, she agrees administrative functions related
in the Water Well Journal.
to human resources can be costly for small businesses, but are also very critical.
One suggestion she makes to help offset the costs is outsourcing some or all of those Advertising Disclaimer
Advertisers and advertising agencies assume
responsibilities to professional human resource firms. These firms can do everything
liability for all content (including text, repre-
from payroll outsourcing, employee screenings and background checks, employee sentation, and illustrations) of advertisements
recruitment, new employee training, immigration compliance if that is needed for your printed and also assume responsibility for any
firm, and more. claims arising therefrom made against the
Walsh also mentions too how some companies are turning to software-based publisher. The publisher reserves the right to
solutions for tasks such as payroll, keeping track of job applicants, and record keeping reject any advertising that is believes is not in
and reporting. keeping with the publication’s standards or is
deemed unsuitable or misleading.
Columnist Gary Shawver, MGWC, discusses mentorship in the
latest installment of Drawing from the Well. In “No Man Is an Subscriptions/Back Issues
Island” on page 34, he writes he has learned solving problems For questions, changes or problems with your
is often best accomplished by getting advice from people who’ve subscription call Denise Bierkortte. Subscriptions:
Water well contractors and other qualified
already had those experiences—mentors. groundwater industry personnel in U.S. and
He said he reached out and learned a lot from mentors early in Canada — free; others in U.S. and Canada
his career, and adds it is important to give back and be a mentor to — $115 per year; $15 per copy. International:
people coming into the industry now. Shawver admits he used to not $150 per year; $35 per copy. Subscriptions
Gary Shawver,
want to share tips or techniques, but realized doing so is critical to available through NGWA offices only. We reserve
MGWC the right to refuse subscriptions to anyone not
the success of the groundwater industry.
directly engaged in the groundwater industry.
Claims for missing issues must be made in writing
within three months of publication and will be
subject to the availability of back issues.
Revised Lead and Copper Rule costs for manufacturers who may need Springs, Colorado, died recently when
Delayed Again to modify their products. their rig struck overhead power lines,
Lead is a naturally occurring metal fatally electrocuting them.
T he wait on a revised Lead and Copper
rule is going to last a little longer.
Revisions to the Lead and Copper
that does not alter the taste, odor, or
color of water. The presence of lead in
The rig’s derrick hit a 12,500-volt
power line—killing the subcontractors,
groundwater tends to be small and al- both of whom were in their 20’s. A third
Rule (www.epa.gov/dwreginfo/lead- most undetectable. A greater concern is coworker who was far away from the rig
and-copper-rule) were expected early the presence of lead in galvanized steel at the time was uninjured.
in 2019. However, the draft revision is pipes, certain brass used in plumbing The tragedy is a sobering reminder
now expected in August 2019, which is fixtures or well components, and certain to “Look Up and Live”—a motto every
a delay of six months from the timetable solder used to connect pipes and joints. contractor should do every day at every
that was announced last fall. Although the lead content allowed jobsite.
The date of the final publication has in these plumbing and well components Related to the topic, NGWA Press
not changed; it is scheduled for February has been greatly reduced—most recently publishes Safety Meetings for the Ground-
2020. in 2014—it can still be a health risk for water Industry, a set of 52 sheets designed
This marks the third time the draft’s well systems that predate federally man- to aid weekly safety meetings. Among
publication has been delayed by the dated lead content reductions. the safety topics are two related to derrick
Trump administration. The revisions NGWA has an information brief on safety: electrical safety with drilling rigs
were also scheduled to be released in the lead (www.ngwa.org/Media-Center/ and safety when raising a derrick. Ground-
summer of 2017, January 2018, and briefs/Documents/Lead-Presence-in- water contractors are encouraged to cover
August 2018. Well-Systems.pdf), providing informa- these important topics with their col-
NGWA serves on the National tion on sources and corrosion. It also leagues on a regular basis—and especially
Drinking Water Advisory Council, has information on lead for homeowners with any subcontractors they work with.
which has weighed in on possible revi- with well systems on its website at Safety Meetings for the Groundwater
sions throughout their development. wellowner.org/lead. Industry, and other items related to safety,
Because the revisions are unknown, can be found in the NGWA Bookstore at
the impacts to groundwater industry
professionals are unclear. However, if
Fatalities Remind Importance of www.NGWA.org/Bookstore.
stricter limits on lead and copper con- Overhead Power Line Safety Two recent articles in Water Well
Journal focus on safety and electricity as
tent are contained in the revisions, com-
pliance costs could result in increased T wo employees of a drilling crew col-
lecting soil samples near Colorado NEWS continues on page 14
H E A D WAT E R C O . C O M
NEWS from page 12 (waterwelljournal.com/preventing-slips- layed during the George W. Bush admin-
trips-falls) as well. istration for further assessment.
well. “Safety Around Power Lines” Atrazine can be found in shallow
(waterwelljournal.com/safety-around-
power-lines) and “Working Safely
EPA Cancels Groundwater and wells in regions of the country that have
Around Electricity” (waterwelljournal. Pesticide Rule several farms. Because of its potential
and the other four chemicals to impact
com/working-safely-around-electricity)
can be viewed on Water Well Journal’s
website.
T he U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency announced in the Federal
Register on May 7 it was withdrawing a
groundwater, the EPA had determined
the pesticides may contaminate the
environment if management was not
rule to restrict the sale of five pesticides provided.
Fatalities from Work-Related which had previously been labeled possi- If the proposed rule had passed, la-
Falls Increase ble or probable carcinogens. bels of the pesticides would have been
The most common fertilizer in the
R eleased data from the Bureau of changed so their use was in accordance
group is atrazine, which has seen its use with an EPA-approved state management
Labor Statistics shows work-related decline in the last 10 years. The others
falls from a higher to a lower level re- plan after a period of time allowed for
included are alachlor, cyanazine, meto- development of the plans. The proposed
sulting in fatalities increased from 2011 lachlor, and simazine.
to 2016. rule also contained a revision to pesticide
The EPA said it was withdrawing the labeling regulations.
The number rose 26% with a total of rule because, as stated in the Federal
697 fall fatalities in 2016, a sharp increase Register, the “EPA determined that all
from 553 in 2011. Over the entire six-year five of the chemicals identified in the
Drought in Certain Regions of
period, there were 3723 fatal falls to a (state management plan) proposal met Country Impacting Crops
R
lower level. the ‘no unreasonable adverse effects on eports showed wheat crops in the
The Bureau stated most falls occurred the environment’ standard” and “the rule southern and central Great Plains
in the private construction industry. In is unnecessary to prevent unreasonable were in poor condition after a dry winter
fact, falls in private construction rose 45% adverse effects on the environment.” was followed by a cold spring.
from 2011 to 2016 (from 255 to 370). This ends a long process for the rule. The USDA World Agricultural Outlook
A recent article in Water Well Journal It was first proposed in 1999 and was de- Board reported 50% of the Kansas wheat
focuses on preventing slips, trips, and falls
A n April decision by the Michigan requested withdrawal,” Nestle wrote in Nestle also recently announced its
Department of Environmental Qual- a statement published on April 2. “We water plant in Sacramento, California, is
ity to allow Nestle Waters North America will need time to carefully review the now powered entirely by clean energy, a
to increase its water collection in Osceola specifics but will comply with all permit move that will reduce its carbon footprint
County, Michigan, will be challenged by requirements. We appreciate the MDEQ’s by more than 21,279 metric tons of car-
a conservation group. careful review and consideration of our bon dioxide over the next three years.
Michigan Citizens for Water Conserva- application, in what it has called its most
tion has said it will contest the new permit thorough review ever, and we look for-
SANITARY
®
Y34
IOWA
YARD HYDRANT
■ Reliable and durable
■ Freezeless—won’t
freeze when hose
is detached
■ Repairable from top
of hydrant
■ Parts always available S3
Y2 YARD
YARD HYDRANT
HYDRANT ■ Sealed to
prevent cross-
■ Freezeless and contamination
automatic (ground water
draining—won’t entering reservoir
freeze, even with or service line)
hose attached ■ For use where
■ Dual check vacuum required by code
breaker protects ■ Fully serviceable
water supply from above ground
■ Dual check vacuum
WOODFORD MANUFACTURING COMPANY breaker protects
Excellence. Always. water supply
800.621.6032
www.woodfordmfg.com
The LOG
NGWA Files Comments on EPA’s NGWA worked with a group of volunteers to prepare the com-
Groundwater/Surface Water ments, which can be read in their entirety at www.regulations.gov/
document?D=EPA-HQ-OW-2018-0063-0448.
Interaction Request
NGWA responded on May 21 to the U.S. Environmental NGWA Foundation Merges with
Protection Agency’s request for comment on the “Clean Water Groundwater Foundation
Act Coverage of ‘Discharges of Pollutants’ via a Direct
Hydrologic Connection to Surface Water.”
The request for comment asked for feedback on the EPA’s
previous statements on the National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination System (NPDES), following multiple court cases
with differing opinions.
Nearly 60,000 comments at press time had been submitted The NGWA Foundation for Groundwater and the Ground-
to the EPA on this issue, demonstrating the need for the water Foundation announced the organizations have merged,
EPA to provide clarity. NGWA’s comments centered on the establishing the foremost Foundation dedicated to protecting
importance of groundwater protection and the role states groundwater and enhancing professional practices in the
play in regulating groundwater quality. Because of the vari- industry. Under the agreement, the combined entity will
ability across the states in the use and value of groundwater carry the Groundwater Foundation name and will leverage
resources, states are best equipped to regulate groundwater administrative and operational support from NGWA.
quality—empowering those with expertise in local environ- The organizations believe this merger is important as it
mental conditions. creates a hub of information and charitable outreach for
In addition, NGWA pointed out no definition of “direct groundwater professionals and the public alike. Folks in the
hydrologic connection” exists in previous EPA statements on industry will have a strengthened resource for education, net-
the issue or in the Clean Water Act, and provided a definition working, and professional development. The public will have
for its consideration. access to the latest science, research, field work, scholarships,
Rather than asking for a rulemaking or revision of all previous breaking news, and comment from proven leaders in the
statements, NGWA asked the EPA to issue clarifying memoranda. groundwater industry.
DUAL ROTARY
CRANE LEAD SYSTEM DUAL ROTARY
The Dual Rotary Crane Lead System utilizes DECK KITS
Foremost DR drill components installed and All the versatility of the Foremost Dual Rotary Drill can
mounted onto crane leads. Drilling operations can be mounted on virtually any nonstandard North American
be controlled from auxiliary hydraulics on the crane, Chassis. The DR Deck Kit is designed for many types of on-road
or an independent hydraulic power unit (HPU). and off-road conditions and the shipping frame is included with
the drill purchase.
Free
CEO of NGWA.
Jane Griffin, executive director of the Groundwater Founda-
tion, says the merger will provide a robust platform to effectively
deliver various community programs and initiatives.
“NGWA and the Groundwater Foundation have been part- Online, self-paced course covers the selection and operation
ners for several years and we have complementary strengths, of meters for safe and successful electrical troubleshooting
experiences, and industry knowledge,” Griffin says. “While the of water well pump systems in “Selection and Operation of
Groundwater Foundation has a national presence, our mission is Meters for Safe and Successful Electrical Troubleshooting
to boost groundwater awareness at the local level, and merging for Water Well Pump Systems.” This course should be able
with NGWA’s Foundation allows us to extend this mission, to be completed in 30 minutes and is made possible by a
address issues, and educate at every level.” grant from Franklin Electric. Learn more at
The Groundwater Foundation will remain in Lincoln, www.NGWA.org/Events-Education.
Nebraska, and staff will be retained. The group will be sup-
ported by NGWA. As Foundation executive director, Griffin
will report to Morse. NGWA staff and operations will remain
unchanged.
16
“One of our key messages to our diverse membership is
Certification exams administered by the National Ground
that we truly are ‘better together’ in our collective efforts
Water Association in April—6 passed the exam. Also
to advance the groundwater industry,” Morse says. “We’re
administered were 46 licensing exams—19 passed the exam.
excited to merge with a fantastic organization that allows us
3
to expand this message to its members, to individuals, and to
local communities alike.”
FROM FACEBOOK
The Groundwater
Association
MEMBER
EXCLUSIVE Water Well Journal
Another delay for the Lead and Copper Rule
revision. Stay tuned: https://waterwelljournal.
com/revised-lead-and-copper-rule-delayed-again.
Water Well Journal
Via the Occupational Safety and Health Authority
and Agency, Implementing #Safety and Health
Program Protects Employees, Saves Money:
http://ow.ly/62pU30jNntd.
#PPE, #drilling, #groundwater, #water
You can learn about the issue theme of well rehabilitation on Water Well Journal’s ON TWITTER
website too. A pair of full-length articles by industry veterans are available for National
Ground Water Association members at WaterWellJornal.com. The articles focus on the Water Well Journal
importance of understanding the chemistry of well water when using chemicals #TipTuesday: It’s important your #safety meetings
and acids in rehabilitation procedures and responding to corrosive water. always discuss “look up and live” as this sad story
shows: https://waterwelljournal.com/fatalities-
www.WaterWellJournal.com/web-only remind-importance-of-overhead-power-line-
safety/.
2 4
Industry veteran shares tips on well rehabilitation Water Well Journal
in video interview Are there reports of PFAS contamination near you?
Neil Mansuy, vice president of technical
services for Subsurface Technologies Inc.
NGWA ®
The Groundwater
Association
@ngwatweets set to participate in EPA conference
on PFAS with nation’s governors.
in Rock Tavern, New York, discussed all MEMBER 2 5
things well rehabilitation in the video EXCLUSIVE
interview titled “Catching Up.” Mansuy
has nearly 40 years of experience in well rehabilitation ON THE SITE
and has volunteered on numerous NGWA committees.
He is also a regular workshop presenter at NGWA’s WWJ NEWS
Groundwater Week. Salary Survey Pinpoints Value of Certifications
www.WaterWellJournal.com/web-only for Safety and Health Professionals
The median base salary for full-time professionals
was $97,000, with 22% of respondents earning
$125,000 or more.
NGWA ®
Fatalities from Work-Related Falls Increase
Recently released data from the Bureau of Labor
The Groundwater
Association
Join NGWA Log in Statistics shows work-related falls to a lower level
resulting in fatalities increased from 2011 to 2016.
Drought in Certain Regions of Country
Make sure you’re a member of the National Ground Water Association. Impacting Crops
It’s not just great content from WWJ; there are a host of benefits important to Reports show wheat crops in the southern and
you and your business. Go to www.NGWA.org today to check them all out! central Great Plains are in poor condition after a
dry winter was followed by a cold spring.
© 2018 Flint & Walling, Inc. All rights reserved. Flint and Walling Inc. asserts trademark and copyright rights in “Trust Runs Deep,” the Flint & Walling logo and the silhouette image device.
Star Iron Works
257 Caroline St.
Punxsutawney, PA 15767
Phone: 814.427.2555
Fax: 814.427.5164
Toll-free: 1.800.927.0560
www.starironworks.com
(COVER STORY)
Well Forensics
Difficult well problems may require a more detailed approach of investigation.
By Roger Miller
F
orensic science is considered a careful and detailed common problems encountered in groundwater wells are scale
search and examination beyond what is considered accumulation, biomass buildup, sediment infiltration, corrosion,
common or normal. and coliform occurrences.
And while all well assessment activities are investigative in In the assessment of common types of potential mineral
nature, periodically we encounter an issue not easily identified deposits, water sample analysis can identify chemical concen-
through common assessment practices and requiring a more trations that can point to precipitation. These carbonate, sulfate,
detailed process. A review of the more common problems in and oxide scales can easily foul the well, blocking flow and
a well and how they are evaluated will emphasize how the reducing capacity.
more difficult problems require the detailed efforts of well Additionally, the oxidation potential of the system water
forensics. can identify the potential for system corrosion along with the
buildup of metal oxides into the scale mass. This information
Common Well Problems is beneficial not only for structuring a rehabilitation process
Well fouling can cover a multitude of problems involving for the effective removal of these deposits, but can potentially
any change that impacts operation or water quality. The most WELL FORENSICS continues on page 24
WELL FORENSICS from page 23 cell is established under deposited material, such as scale or
identify the source of corrosion that may allow for some biofilm buildup, on the metal surfaces. This type of corrosion
change to prevent corrosion damage to the system. is the leading cause of well component degradation within the
Biomass, referring to the accumulation of biofilm in a well, groundwater industry.
can cause quality declines, capacity losses, corrosion damage, Additionally, microbial influenced corrosion is common as
and of course, unsafe water conditions. Not only the bacteria many types of bacteria in groundwater either produce acids or
themselves, but the exopolymer slime they secrete, can cause enzymes that will pit metal or they are natural iron-oxidizing
quality issues along with capacity losses as the biofilm mass species that oxidize and degrade iron in their metabolic process.
can block flow in conjunction with dislodging into the flowing The bacterial issue in groundwater of greatest concern, and
water and provide organic masses creating taste and odor issues. one which is controlled by regulatory rules, is the presence of
Specific bacteria, identifiable through laboratory analysis, pathogens, predominantly the coliform group.
can be the cause of microbial influenced corrosion, and the Although many members of the coliform group are not
bacterial load of the sample analyzed can evaluate the severity pathogens, the presence of any member raises the potential.
of the biofilm buildup, guiding the selection of the proper Therefore, the regulations require periodic testing and required
resolution process. actions if various levels are found.
Formation materials can block flow if not effectively Most of the coliform group are anaerobic bacteria and
developed during well construction or if the well is operated through monitoring the anaerobic activity within the well, we
improperly, creating turbulent flow and mobilizing them into can predict the increased potential of a positive total coliform
the well, plugging flow paths. Microscopic analysis of system test result. This information can guide us in problem identifi-
water can identify common formation materials such as sands, cation and resolution even prior to required reaction of regula-
silts, and clays. tory controls, avoiding emergency conditions.
Formation clays can also be separated from processed
clays (drilling muds) under the microscope to determine if
Difficult Well Problems
ineffective development is the potential problem or if the natural As stated earlier, all well assessment activities are investiga-
clays from the formation are potentially being mobilized into tive in nature and the investigator operates at various levels of
the well by improper operation. detail in the process of problem identification and resolution.
Water well corrosion can come from a multitude of The investigation is often dependent on the customer,
sources. Water chemistry is the first step in an evaluation the role the well plays, and the level of failure or impaction
process, generally looking at the calculation of the Langelier occurring. For example, a single well supplying a home will
Saturation Index developed through a series of water chemistry require a simplified and faster response to return service,
parameters. while a well that is part of a larger wellfield may offer time
The results of the LSI will indicate if the water itself is for a more academic approach.
corrosive. In 2016, the U.S. Geological Survey reported the The following projects are examples where the common
corrosion potential of U.S. groundwater sources was higher assessment steps have been taken without satisfactory reso-
than expected, with most of the country having moderately lution to the particular problem. Therefore, the investigator
aggressive groundwater. has gone beyond, and in some cases considerably beyond, the
One of the most common types of corrosion in groundwater normal steps in order to identify the source of the problem
supplies is “concentration cell”—also referred to as “under and effectively develop a resolution to the particular issue.
deposit” corrosion. The typical electrochemical corrosion The following examples of well forensics will involve a
well construction-related issue, water quality issues, deposited
Case Study II
A finding of an oily film and black deposits forming in the
well was reported to our laboratory.
Samples were requested and received of both the deposited
material and water from the well. Laboratory analysis identified
the oily material to be a form of coal tar. Coal tar is a compli-
cated hydrocarbon derived from the thermal destruction of coal
with hundreds of potential chemical structures.
One of the more common coal tar structures is creosote,
used as a sealer in road construction, and to a lesser known
structure with analgesic properties used in acetaminophen or
Tylenol.
An emulsified oily substance deposited on well casing and screen. The end result of this assessment was we were dealing
with a complicated hydrocarbon and would need an effective
degreaser chemical to remove it from the well. Further com-
plicating these efforts, most effective degreasers for this type
materials not responding to conventional treatments, and
of hydrocarbon material are petroleum distillates with strong
operational issues within the water chemistry realm.
butyl or alkali components, which are toxic and not acceptable
for potable water use.
Case Study I
However, previous work had been performed in our labo-
In the northern United States, a dual-rotary drilled well was ratory on similar material from the oil industry with success,
not responding to standard well development procedures using using a citrus-based chemical known as D’Limonene. This
both physical and chemical processes. chemical is nontoxic, biodegradable, and currently carries
A sample of what was presumed to be plugging the NSF certification for several formulas.
screened interval of the well was secured and sent to our lab- After identifying the most appropriate D’Limonene formula
oratory. The material was noted to be a “mud-like substance” for the water chemistry of the particular aquifer, the product
and when observed under the microscope, was predominantly was recommended for rehabilitating the well using standard
clay particulate. chemical procedures. The project resulted in an effective
As clays can be from either processed drilling muds or cleanup of the well with no signs of oil film or deposits.
natural-formation materials and react differently to various Note: The actual source of the coal tar material was never
chemical reactions, further assessments were performed to identified by the client.
make this determination.
Closer observation under the microscope showed the particles Case Study III
to be of random structure with sharp defined edges. This
Although this case was not directly related to the source
pointed to the source being natural-formation clays as
water well, it is an excellent reference to the delicacies of
processed drilling muds are more uniform and rounded.
water chemistry and deposit formation that can adversely
Additionally, a settling study was performed as the pro-
affect well operation.
cessed clays will settle slower than natural-formation clays.
Heavy scale formation was reported within the piping and
This test again pointed toward the source being formation
storage system adjacent to a client’s water treatment plant
material.
facility. A site visit was performed and samples of the scale
Based on this determination and the knowledge that normal
material were secured and taken to our lab for analysis.
well development chemistry (phosphates) provides the reaction
Laboratory results indicated the material to be 99% calcium
of sequestration, the formation of a more water-soluble
carbonate, a common water mineral precipitate.
complex, it was apparent the phosphates were not effectively
From the review of operations during the site visit, there
sequestering the natural-formation clays.
was noted an intermittent discoloration in the finished water,
From these factors, the investigator looked into the uncom-
and a consultant had recommended an adjustment of the
mon chemical reaction for well development of dispersion
finished water pH value to a maximum of 9.0 to alleviate the
chemistry. The dispersion chemical reaction actually inter-
corrosion potential.
feres with the positively charged particles, destabilizing the
Further evaluating the information provided, we noted the
clay structures and breaking up the bonding, allowing them to
majority of the piping system was constructed of PVC mate-
be washed from the well.
rial and only a few valves were of metal components. We also
In order to confirm this process and formulate the proper
observed 30% of the raw well water bypassed the treatment
dosage, a bench test study was performed using multiple
chemical combinations. From this study a final dispersion WELL FORENSICS continues on page 26
For more than 50 years, the Goulds “Declaration of Independents” has been bedrock
for our unwavering commitment to the independent dealers who are the engine of
our industry. It’s our pledge to maintain the highest quality products, invest in the latest
technologies, and provide unmatched support and service. See just what we can do
for you at goulds.com/independents.
goulds.com/independents
©2018 Xylem Inc. Goulds is a registered trademark of Goulds Pumps, Inc. and is used under license.
SEMCO INC.
P.O. Box 1216 ● 7595 U.S. Hwy 50 ● Lamar, Colorado 81052
800-541-1562
719-336-9006 ● Fax 719-336-2402 ● semcopumphoist@yahoo.com
www.SEMCOoflamar.com
SEMCO HYDRORENCH
By William Wagner
T
he technology involving downhole cameras has evolved Although downhole cameras are cheaper than they used
dramatically over the past several decades. to be, more simple to use, and portable enough for a driller
Just consider: or pump installer to own and operate himself, Christopher S.
“We built the world’s first downhole camera over 70 years Johnson, PG, Chg, of Aegis Groundwater Consulting LLC in
ago,” says Eric Hadden, vice president of sales and marketing Fresno, California, isn’t averse to farming out the work.
at Laval Underground Surveys in Fresno, California. “It was a Says Johnson, “I recommend that you find local contractors
still camera that was put into the casing of a World War II–era who specialize in downhole video cameras.”
bomb. It weighed over 200 pounds and was about 9 feet long. Whether you do it yourself or hire someone, you’ll want to
So miniaturization certainly has come a long way.” make the most of that camera’s long journey down a well and
That’s putting it mildly. Some models now measure about back. Here are five key factors to consider when using a down-
1.5 inches in diameter and 16 inches in length. hole camera, and why this high-tech tool can be such an import-
The prices of downhole cameras also have come down con- ant part of your work:
siderably, especially over the past 10 years. Hadden says Laval
Underground Surveys manufactures a model that costs about 1. The camera doesn’t lie.
$14,000, which is small potatoes compared with what you There’s no substitute for the intel you’ll gather from a camera,
would have forked over in the past. whether you’re drilling a well or doing maintenance on one.
“Ten years ago, you were looking at a system (that was “Don’t pass up an opportunity to run a camera down the
operated) from a vehicle or a trailer,” Hadden says. “And the well,” Johnson urges. “It provides an objective process for
camera itself was in excess of $25,000. The winch was another establishing a wide variety of things. Wells are 12 to 20 inches
$10,000, and the cable was maybe $5000 or $7000. All told,
you were looking at a system that could easily cost $100,000.” MAXIMIZE ROI WITH CAMERAS continues on page 30
CERTIFIED
national ground water association
in your market.
The Groundwater
Association
ALEXANDRA WALSH
E
ach year, thousands of people are blinded from work- Industrial chemicals and cleaning products are common
related eye injuries. causes of chemical burns to a person’s eyes. Thermal burns
Each day alone, about 2000 U.S. workers sustain a to the eye can also occur—often among welders. These burns
job-related eye injury requiring medical treatment. About one- routinely damage workers’ eyes and surrounding tissue.
third of the injuries are serious enough to be treated in hospi-
tal emergency rooms. More than 100 of these injuries result in
Preventing Eye Injuries
one or more days away from work. Eye protection must be worn when working at a water well
Eye injuries cost more than $300 million per year in lost construction site!
production time, medical expenses, and worker compensation. The protection chosen depends on the nature and extent
Many could have been prevented with the proper selection of the hazard at the site, the circumstances of exposure, other
and use of eye and face protection. protective equipment being used, and personal vision needs.
Eye protection should be fitted to an individual or adjustable
Standards to provide appropriate coverage. It should be comfortable and
The Occupational Safety and Health Administration re- allow for good peripheral vision.
quires employers to ensure the safety of all employees in the Employers can prevent eye injuries to workers by seeing to
work environment. It follows that eye and face protection must it controls are in place and are used to reduce eye injuries and
be provided whenever necessary to protect workers against protect against exposures to eye infections. Employers can
chemical, environmental, radiological, or mechanical irritants also conduct a hazard assessment to determine the appropriate
and hazards. type of protective eyewear suitable for a given task.
Selecting Personal Protective
Eye injuries cost more than Equipment
OSHA’s eye and face protection standard requires that
$300 million per year in lost employers must provide eye protection whenever employees
are exposed to the possibility of eye injuries while working,
production time, medical expenses, especially if current work practices or controls don’t eliminate
the risk of injury.
and worker compensation. Eye and face personal protective equipment includes spec-
tacles, goggles, face shields, or welding shields designed to
protect the wearer against a variety of hazards.
The corresponding OSHA standard for eye and face pro- Personal protective equipment for the eyes and face is
tection is 29 CFR 1910.133. This standard requires employers designed to prevent or lessen the severity of injuries. The em-
ensure each affected employee uses appropriate eye or face ployer must assess the workplace ahead of time and determine
protection when exposed to hazards to their eyes or face from if hazards are present—making it necessary to use eye and
flying particles, molten metal, liquid chemicals, acids or caustic face protection.
liquids, chemical gases or vapors, or injurious light radiation. A hazard assessment can determine the risk of exposure to
eye and face hazards, including those that may be encountered
How Eyes Get Hurt in an emergency. Employers should be aware of the possibil-
The majority of eye injuries result from small particles ity of many hazard exposures happening at the same time and
or objects striking or scraping the eye—dust, cement chips, be prepared to protect against the highest level of each hazard
metal slivers, wood chips. These are often ejected by tools, (29 CFR 1910 Subpart I App B).
blown by the wind, or fall onto a worker. Larger objects may
also strike the eye or face, or a worker may run into an object Training for Use of PPE
causing blunt-force trauma to their eyeball or eye socket. Training must be provided to employees who are required
Objects like nails, staples, or slivers of wood or metal can to use eye and face protection. The training must be compre-
puncture the eyeball and result in a permanent loss of vision. hensive, understandable, and repeated annually. All training
Written Protection Prepare for eye injuries and first aid needs
OSHA requires a number of written elements for all PPE • Have an eyewash or sterile solution on hand.
protection programs. As a result, employers must have a writ- Source: National Institute for Occupational Safety and
ten eye and face protection program with worksite-specific Health (NIOSH)
procedures and elements for required eye and face protective
equipment use. The program includes procedures for selecting,
medically evaluating, fit testing, training, using, and taking care
of eye and face protection. A formally established eye and face protection program
certainly increases the chances of using personal protective
Handling Emergencies equipment correctly. And everyone should remember eye and
If an injury to the eye occurs, quick action can prevent a face protection will only protect when used correctly. WWJ
permanent disability. For this reason, emergency eyewashes
should be placed in all hazardous areas. First aid instructions
should be posted close to potential danger spots. Employees Alexandra Walsh is the vice president of Association Vision, a
must know where the closest eyewash station is, and how to get Washington, D.C.–area communications company. She has extensive
experience in management positions with a range of organizations.
there if and when their vision is restricted.
NO MAN IS AN ISLAND
If the groundwater industry is going to survive,
we must be willing to help others.
GARY SHAWVER, MGWC
I
had a young water well contractor seek my advice on a So where does one find these mentors? By networking and
project he was undertaking he had little expertise in. going to conventions, taking in seminars—in essence, pulling
He needed to borrow a stabilizer from my former com- yourself from the jobsite and putting yourself out there.
pany and the general manager was kind enough to loan him Early in my career, I listened to a lot of motivational
the tool. He then sought my input. He was going to fluid drill speakers on cassette tapes in my vehicle on my way to see a
a hole and didn’t quite have a large enough mud pump on his customer. One of those speakers was Tony Robbins, a well-
rig to easily get the project done. I suggested he seek expertise known motivational speaker still giving talks today.
from a drilling fluids product company that could provide the On one of his early tapes, Robbins made the statement he
right fluid to drill the well successfully. wanted to become successful, so he decided he would start
Early in my career I had faced the same dilemma and going to all kinds of seminars given by successful people. He
sought such expertise. This young contractor did just that and stated some were not as good as others, but if he picked up
the project was a complete success. just one thing that helped him, it was worth his time.
Over the years I’ve learned that solving problems, be it
Being a Mentor
drilling or otherwise, is often best accomplished by getting
One of my mentors, who was successful, used to lead a
advice from people who’ve had those experiences. I call them
lot of sessions at national water well conventions and state
mentors.
shows. It wasn’t long, though, that I began seeing him less
I had many mentors in my time in business, and without and less. I asked him one day why he didn’t speak as often
them it would have been difficult to get to the next level of and he told me, “The people who need to hear what I have
professionalism. Time and again, one mentor was able to lift to say don’t come to the conventions. They think they know
me up through their experiences and expertise and help me everything and don’t think they can learn anything, so why
solve problems I was facing at the time. waste my time?”
The ability to get started in a business today is difficult
and finding young people wanting to get started in any given
business is even more difficult. If the groundwater industry is
going to survive, we must be willing to help others who are
I’ve learned that solving problems,
seeking help or having problems. This industry is loaded with be it drilling or otherwise, is often best
people with experience and great ideas that will make this
industry easier to navigate. accomplished by getting advice from
Finding Mentors people who’ve had those experiences.
We take history in school not only to teach us about our
past, but in theory, help us learn what didn’t work and what
did work so we can get to the next level without having to
navigate those pitfalls. Often though, we don’t learn the hard Frankly, his words are pretty true. But we must keep going.
lessons of history without enduring those lessons ourselves. Conventions, shows, and other professional development op-
That’s part of human nature. portunities are where one finds mentors and tips to make their
As I went through the years in the industry and began find- journey through the industry successful.
ing some new techniques that were either highly efficient or Early on, I was too busy and we had lots of work and little
solved a difficult problem, I often hesitated to share a particu- time to go to many conventions. Then the recession of the
lar technique in fear of helping a competitor. 1980s hit and I had all kinds of time. In fact, that is when I
But as time went on, it was easier to share as I looked back first heard that speaker who later became one of my mentors.
and remembered the mentors who had shared with me and He impacted me the first time I heard him—saying something
helped my career. And yes, there are those who will appreci- that really stuck and kept me focused my whole career.
ate it and be a good competitor and there are those who won’t. He stated (and, remember this was in the early ’80s): “I did
But as time goes along, gaining this perception of people is a study on the efficiency of the water well drilling aspect of
also another experience one will learn. our industry and found we spend 30% of our time drilling and
800-552-8800
www.efficiencyproduction.com
685 Hull Rd., Mason, MI 48854
Build-A-Box™ Modular Shoring System
I
wrote a series of columns last year somewhat sluggish in the local irriga- ably handle, but those years were instru-
and into January this year on well and tion business. Diversifying and expand- mental as they allowed me to learn new
pump rehabilitation and methods to ing into the municipal and commercial techniques, expand my troubleshooting
improve the operating efficiency in both. water systems market not only provided skills, and increase my knowledge of
This month, as a start to a two-part series badly needed revenue, but allowed us to water wells, pumps, and electrical and
and a logical continuation to the topic, I’ll keep current personnel who might other- hydraulic theory.
expand the discussion outlining my concept wise have been laid off or assigned reduced
of a well and pump preventive maintenance hours during long winter periods. Setting Up the Program
program with suggested procedures and Since we were already a long- Before actually embarking on a new
recommended intervals. established water systems firm, moving preventive maintenance (PM) program,
into this larger and slightly different we first had to decide how often to
Beginnings of a Preventive market did not require substantial retrain- recommend individual site visits and
Maintenance Program ing or expansion of our service staff. We develop some type of database to rou-
During the final months of 1978, my were also able to use our existing equip- tinely document each individual client
employer at Stettler Supply Co. agreed ment and rolling stock, particularly our and their water system facilities, as well
to expand the company by developing a service vehicles and pump hoists. as track each PM and service procedure
new municipal, water district, and com- As we moved cautiously into devel- conducted at each site and for each unit.
mercial division for the 30-year-old oping a preventive maintenance program A careful appraisal and balance of
firm that had primarily focused on for the various clients, one thing became the estimated cost for each inspection,
agricultural irrigation and domestic rapidly apparent. The program was combined with what we felt to be the
water systems. going to have to be customized and optimum frequency and need—not to
As we launched this new enterprise, tailored for each client and the specific mention the potential disruption to our
we decided to offer a preventive main- needs and number of pumps for each service staff during our normal summer
tenance program on a trial basis. This water purveyor. For systems with multiple peak periods—resulted in a general
would be our way of introducing and well and pump stations, this meant we recommendation of seasonal (every
acquainting ourselves to a previously had to individualize the program for three to four months) inspections for
unknown base of new clients, intro- each client. most clients at each facility.
ducing our new division to our existing Although I was in charge and responsi- Some opted for every six months
clients, and as a way of gaining a full ble for this new division—which included or even yearly inspections; a few even
understanding of each water system’s my cultivating new clients, submitting asked for monthly visits. The seasonal
particular needs. bids and proposals, and performing en- inspections were accepted by most clients
After obtaining mailing lists from gineering and design—I was still young as a compromise between excessive
state water utility organizations and and didn’t wish to simply come out of the costs and ensuring adequate and timely
sending a form letter as an invitation, field and into the office to assign the main- PM procedures were being conducted to
we awaited the reaction. The response tenance and troubleshooting to the other make the program worthwhile.
was, in a word, overwhelming. employees. So, for the first four years of As far as building a database, after
Many of these newly discovered this new enterprise I alternated between considering various methods of record
clients, especially local smaller water field work and office work. keeping I settled on using a single master
districts and cities, informed me they had This not only helped me expand my file for each client. Each file included
wanted to implement some type of pre- skills in field work and troubleshooting, information on each separate well and
ventive maintenance program for their but allowed me the opportunity to visit pump station. Each was assigned a
facility, but didn’t know where to start. and work with many of the new and unique identification code with the spe-
The new preventive maintenance diverse water system clients we gained cific details of each facility recorded on
program was more than a method of throughout western Oregon. Eventually, “master data sheets” (Figures 1, 2, 3).
gaining new business for our firm, the time and effort required to split my The original master data sheets re-
especially since the late 1970s were also duties became more than I could reason- mained at the office in the master file
Well Data—Original Date/Year Drilled: ____________ Updated-1) Date: ___________ 2) Date: _________
Well Diameter: ______” Well Depth (Total): ________’ Original SWL: _______’ Date: _______________
Casing Size(s): ____” from _____’ to ______’-Type: _______ Thickness: ______” Ga/Inches-Hgt______”
“ “ ____” from _____’ to ______’-Type: _______ Thickness: ______” Ga/Inches-Elev______’
Seal Borehole: Dia. ______” from ________’ to ________’---Dia. _______” from ________’ to _________’
Seal Material: _____________________________________________ Seal Qty.: ______ Bags ________ lbs.
Screens/Perf./Liners: _______________________________________________________________________
Screens/Perf./Liners: _______________________________________________________________________
Gravel/Filter Pack: Y__ N ___ Size/Details: ____________________________________________________
Well Test Data: _______ GPM from _____’ PWL (_____ MSL) after ________ Hours (Primary/Orig. COS)
Test Pump _______ GPM from _____’ PWL (______MSL) after ________ Hours (Alternate COS #1)
Airlift—Bail _______ GPM from _____’ PWL (_______MSL) after ________ Hours (Alternate COS #2)
Test Date: ___________ By:_________________________ Water Level Meas. Device:_________________
Well Recovery Data:_________________________________ Alignment Results:______________________
Driller Firm/Name: ______________________________State Lic.#:___________Driller Well #:__________
Well Comments/Recommendations:___________________________________________________________
Figure 1. Master data sheet for inspection of a well and well pump. ENGINEERING continues on page 38
Date:____________________Details: ________________________________________________________
Unit # ___ Pump/Motor--Unit # ___ Pump/Motor--Unit # __ Pump/Motor--Unit # ____Pump/Motor
Red Flags to Client (By): ______________ Date: ___________ Ack.: ______________Date: ___________
Date:____________________Details:________________________________________________________
Unit # ___ Pump/Motor--Unit # ___ Pump/Motor--Unit # __ Pump/Motor--Unit # ____Pump/Motor
Red Flags to Client (By): ______________ Date: ___________ Ack.: ______________Date: ___________
Date:____________________Details:________________________________________________________
Unit # ___ Pump/Motor--Unit # ___ Pump/Motor--Unit # __ Pump/Motor--Unit # ____Pump/Motor
Red Flags to Client (By): ______________ Date: ___________ Ack.: ______________Date: ___________
Figure 3. Master data sheet for inspection of drivers. ENGINEERING continues on page 40
Twitter @WaterWellJournl WWJ July 2018 39
ENGINEERING from page 39
Field Data Form—Well/Booster Pump Station WO #:________________
Tech: Date: Time-Start: Stop:
Client: Facility Name:
Client ID: Water Sample to Lab? Yes: ___ No:___ System/ID #:
OUTSOURCING HR FOR
SMALL BUSINESSES
Whether you outsource everything or just some tasks,
ALEXANDRA WALSH there are options for your company.
ED BUTTS, PE
A
lthough the majority of vertical turbine and submersible angle in between. For purposes of this column, the common
pumps are used for deep well applications, they can also terms applied to a centrifugal, vertical turbine, or submersible
be used and are often preferred as booster pumps for many pump will all be referred to simply as “booster pumps.”
applications including parallel and series service as outlined in the
last two columns of The Water Works.
Open Sumps: Submergence
When suction problems arise in pump cans or sumps ex-
This month, we’ll examine this specific use along with the
posed only to atmospheric pressure, more often than not the
related design process and pitfalls for open sumps, that is, sumps
issues are associated with the configuration and design of the
open and exposed to atmospheric pressure.
sump or the need to maintain adequate pump submergence as
As with most water system applications, there are usually
often as with the pump itself—especially if the pump region is
different approaches that can be used to accomplish the same goal.
circular and operates with minimal submergence.
The following information and design criteria, although based
It is important to remember the pressure exerted by atmo-
largely on my personal experience and past project success, is not
spheric pressure results from the weight of the atmosphere
intended to demonstrate the only method available for the application
at the appropriate elevation above or below sea level—
and design of a well pump for use as a booster pump.
disregarding all potential frictional losses, vapor pressure, and
As always, for any questionable or difficult projects, I suggest
any additional energy losses generated from the flow of fluid
you enlist experienced and qualified individuals or firms to assist
within the pump can or open sump.
you with your specific application. Please note the following
Depending on the type, specific gravity, and viscosity of
guidelines are intended for informational purposes only and to
the fluid being pumped—and potential interference caused
help you gain an understanding of general sump arrangement,
by the number and spacing of pumping units along with the
configuration, and dimensions. Therefore, I cannot guarantee the
geometry and layout of the sump and pumps—these losses
success or adequacy of any sump design, layout, or configuration
can be minor, insignificant, or severe enough to accumulate
based on any use of this information.
and generate a sufficient loss of inlet head or flow disruption,
Well Pump vs. Booster Pump resulting in a negative impact to the operating pump.
Besides their most common uses as well pumps, vertical In addition, even if the loss of inlet head within the pump
turbine pumps and submersible deep well pumps, as well as can or sump is not excessive, there may not be an adequate
ordinary centrifugal pumps, are also used as booster pumps. depth of water maintained over the pump’s inlet to prevent a
Generally, this is done for singular or series/parallel perfor- cyclonic action of the water leading to the pump inlet during
mance in both inline pressurized applications using a direct pumping conditions—creating a vortex or whirlpool, similar
inline feed for centrifugal pumps or pump sumps, cans, or to the draining of a bathtub or basin.
barrels for subs and VTP types—using an open or atmo- Vortexes have been known to form in pumping applications
spheric pressure fed source from a nearby reservoir, lake, over vertical distances of 20 feet or more. Therefore, it is vital
or river that is directly fed into an open sump, commonly to recognize the potential for a vortex to form and methods to
referred to as a “wetwell.” prevent or dissipate their formation.
I have used centrifugal, vertical turbine, and submersible This required operational factor, known as submergence, is
pumps numerous times as booster pumps. Once you accept also a critical design element and must be included over and
and work around the issues and limitations associated with above NPSH concerns as a separate and independent consid-
NPSH, submergence, and clearance design requirements, eration in every open and some closed sump arrangements.
proper sealing of the discharge or electrical cable when using Open Sumps: Hydraulic Configuration
a pump can under pressurized service, proper grounding of and Pump Spacing
electric motors, and observing the appropriate approach and Where multiple pumps are used, and in addition to submer-
annular velocity for either application, you’ll see they make gence, the proper geometry and configuration of the sump and
excellent and efficient booster pumps. the inlet pipe are also important. If the appropriate spacing
Whereas a vertical turbine pump is limited to operation in a and baffling between pumping units or sump walls or barriers
vertical orientation only, a submersible pump can safely func- is not observed in an open sump arrangement, severe prob-
tion in a vertical or horizontal position and at virtually any
Protecting groundwater
protects your livelihood.
4, 2018
cons
ASR ˜ ow control valves
rigs t
boring machines computer software — modeling drills, caisson ˜oa ts
floats
auger drill tools
rs a nd drilling , product,
breakout tools conditioning, water treatment drills, core ˜ ow measurement equipment
flow
to n
contrac , ÿnd the perso he
augers, bailers brushes-rehabilitation controls drills, direct push/probe ˜umes & weirs
flumes
augers, hollow stem bushings, drive controls, constant pressure drills, directional
augers, sand pumps
n t t
bushings, rotary deck controls, variable speed pumping drills, down-the-hole
or ser
core boxes drills, rotary
B
bailers
cable tools
Nwire,
ecable
A
GtiesW& guards
core drilling tools
couplings, compressor
drills, tieback
drills, topdrive
Buyers Guide
banking/ÿnancing
o nl in cameras, down-the-hole .
cable, submersible pump/motor couplings, PVC drinking water systems
Guide
bearings cranes drives, bushings G
bentonite pellets/tablets
bit dressers and tools
Buyers cameras, video (not dth)
carousels
cylinders drives, caps
drives, couplings
gaskets
gauges
bit grinders carriers D drives, pulling heads gears
bits, button casing cutter-downhole data logging equipment drives, right angle generators
bits, cable guards casing tools, spiders and slips deaeration and degasification
degasiÿcation drives, shoes geophysical equipment & testing
bits, cable tool, friction wheels casings, fabricated steel decontamination and environmental drives, variable frequency services
bits, cable tool, jars casings, Fiberglass equipment and services geotechnical instrumentation
bits, cable tool, sockets casings, plastic deionization E geothermal equipment
bits, cable tool, stems casings, PVC depth indicators education & training geothermal pipe
bits, carbide casings, shoe derricks electric motor controls gravels
bits, diamond casings, stainless steel desalination systems electromagnetic water treatment groundwater pumping equipment
bits, down-the-hole casings, Te˜on desanders elevators, casing groundwater sampling equipment
bits, drag casings, threaded PVC desilters elevators, pipe grout, bentonite
bits, drill catheads dies and inserts engines, diesel grouters
bits, horizontal centralizers direct push tools environmental supplies grouts/sealants
TO LEARN MORE,
CALL 800.457.2096
3.475 x 4.75
Twitter @WaterWellJournl WWJ July 2018 53
Featured PRODUCTS
Weil Pump Announces Solinst Designs AquaVent Laval Underground Surveys
New Line of Booster Systems Water Level Datalogger Provides Portable Borehole
Weil Pump, a Wilo The Solinst Camera System
Company, announces AquaVent uses Laval
it now offers a full line a vented pres- Under-
of vertical multistage sure transducer ground
booster pumps and for reliable, accurate (0.05%FS) data- Surveys’
systems. logging of water levels that are auto- SC-166
The new booster matically barometrically compensated. downhole
systems combine Weil’s Programmable The AquaVent combines pressure and camera is designed for water wells,
Logic Controller (PLC) panels with temperature sensors, and a datalogger boreholes, and vertical shafts as small
Wilo-Helix V pumps and are available for up to 120,000 data sets, within a as 2 inches in diameter. This camera
in 2-, 3-, or 4-pump configurations. ⅞-inch × 7-inch stainless steel housing. has effective survey capabilities for
The multi-pump systems offer real- The AquaVent features a robust, low 2-inch to 10-inch well diameters.
time diagnostics and remote monitor- maintenance design. Hydrophobic fil- The SC-166 well camera system
ing with variable speed control and ters and permanent desiccants provide comes equipped with a protective carry
balanced runtime for each pump. moisture protection for the lifetime of case provided for storage, adjustable
The booster packages are suitable the instrument. Batteries are user- centering bands, and cable head
for many applications—water supply, replaceable and conveniently located protector.
pressure boosting, agriculture, wash- in the wellhead at surface. Durable, The SC-166 will work with all R-Cam
ing/sprinkling systems, cooling circuits, custom-designed vented cables are 1000 and R-Cam 1300 systems. Simply
and condensate return. available to 500 feet. disconnect the existing camera and use
The systems have a maximum head The AquaVent datalogger communi- the SC-166 for smaller-diameter holes or
of 780 feet, maximum flow of 550 GPM, cates with Solinst Levelogger Software monitor wells. The robust 304 stainless
rated pressure of 232 PSI, and a liquid and accessories or uses SDI-12 or steel housing is designed for rugged
temperature range of –4°F to 248°F. MODBUS protocols. applications.
weilpump.com/#findrep www.solinst.com www.lavalunderground.com
®
Exhibits · Workshops · Summit
Las Vegas, Nevada • December 3-6, 2018
Make your plans today to join thousands of professionals from all sectors of the industry — and
across the globe — at Groundwater Week 2018, the one event that truly encompasses being
BETTER TOGETHER!
From workshops and hands-on skill activities to an unparalleled lineup of exhibitors and networking
events, it’s here at Groundwater Week where you will find everything you need to succeed.
REGISTER TODAY!
THIS IS BIG
NGWA Offers Best-in-Class
Insurance Program, HR Services
for ALL Groundwater Professionals
Preferred Programs & Preferred Pricing
7791 NGWA.org/Bookstore
(800) 551-7379 • (614) 898-7791
Name __________________________________________________________________________
Company name __________________________________________________________________
Address ________________________________________________________________________
City, State, Zip ___________________________________________________________________
Phone __________________________________________________________________________
Fax ____________________________________________________________________________
Email __________________________________________________________________________
Enclosed you’ll find ______ photos for Water Well Journal. I understand that these photos become
the property of the Water Well Journal, and will not be returned. If any photo is selected for use on
a WWJ cover, I further understand that I will be paid $250 and my photo credit will appear on the
issue’s contents page.
Signed _________________________________________________________________________
NGWA
Date ___________________________________________________________________________ SM
18 BREAKOUT TOOLS
BREAKOUT TOOLS
SEMCO Inc.
All Hydraulic Hydrorench
S110H In Stock
1-10 Four Rollers 65 DRILL PIPE
Breaks Pipe
Make Pipe to Torque Specs
800-541-1562
50 CORE DRILLING
135 RIGS
Award-Winning
Patented Technology
SONIC DRILL CORPORATION
Suite 190#120, 119 N. Commercial St.
Bellingham, WA 98225
www.sonic-drill.com 1-604-588-6081
4510 E Market,
New rigs—custom
Quality designs
rig repair service We Buy, Sell & Trade
! !
Enid, OK Quality
New and rigused
repair service needs
equipment
!
73701
USA New and used
“Transfer equipment needs
of Technology” - the Used Drilling Equipment
“Transfer
must haveofbook
Technology” - the
for all drillers!
must have book for all drillers!
SWITCH EVERYTHING
FLOW
Flow Level LEVEL
CONTROLLERS
Ideal 7 1/4x15 Duplex Pump..$38K
Browse Our Entire Inventory
HARWIL
®
BeemanEquipmentSales.com
est 1956
WIRELESS
HARWIL.COM (805) 988-6800 sales@harwil.com
Sand
Guzzler • Custom Built Packers
Building & Gaining Trust by Manufacturing For Any Application
Quality Flattanks, Serving the Water Well
Drilling, Mining, Mineral Explorations,
PRODUCTS • Competitive Prices
Inflatable
Geothermal, Directional Boring, and Sonic
TetraGrene
Drilling Industries, we offer your company the
satisfaction of a job well done. Check out our
Well P ackers
website for more information on our products.
442.242.7507 | sales@tibban.com
Call (406) 466-2146 or
MudPuppyInfo.com
(406) 544-5914
2012 367 Peterbilt 550HP Cum-
mings ISX15, 62,033 miles 18 speed
1-800-452-4902 • www.lansas.com
Manufactured by Vanderlans & Sons 1320 S. Sacramento St. • Lodi, CA 95240 • 209-334-4115 • Fax 209-339-8260
transmission, 20k front 46k rears,
79,500GVW-New Flattanks 22 long
deck space, 2800 gallons-New IMT 178 WATER TREATMENT
178 WATER TREATMENT
7500 wireless radio remote crane.
The Bree[e
for sulfur and iron problems
• No Pressure Switch Wiring
• No Flow Switch
• No Over or Under-Aerating
2006 International 7600-422,322 • No Leaky Vents
miles. 18k front 46k rears. Cat C13 • Outstanding Value
Acert 430hp. RTO 16908LL 10-spd.
4 way lockers, Chalmers rubber The BreezeAeration
spring suspension. New 2100 gallons Made Simpler!
Flattanks 21 long deck space.
3 RIG PARTS
rigused
nd repair service needs
equipment
!
www.northwestflattanks.com
d used
fer equipment needs
of Technology” - the
er ofbook
ave Technology” - the
for all drillers!
ave book for all drillers!
62 July 2018 WWJ waterwelljournal.com
186 WELL SCREENS
Made in
Hydrofracture Packers
ASR Flow Control Valves
Manufactured in Denver CO USA
+1-303-789-1200
1-800-55Baski
www.baski.com info@baski.com
35 sizes of Packers/Frackers™ in stock
Custom sizes for all applications
Field tested for long term use
www.aquapump.com
Aqua Pump is proud to carry
a line of Life: H2O Required
apparel. $5.00 of every item sold
will be donated to the cause.
Thank you,
The Nigro Family
106
106 INSTALLATION
INSTALLATION ACCESSORIES
ACCESSORIES
Heat Shrink
from B&B Wholesale
“We are the heat shrink people”
- Heat shrink kits for #14 to 4/0 wire
- Volume pricing
- Custom kits made to order
- Private labeling available
- Quick shipping
- Four types of heat shrink tubing
Jubilee booth #1707 in stock
- Large selection of installation
accessories including pressure
139 SLOTTING MACHINES 160 TRUCKS gauges, tapes, valves and tank
fittings packages
J&K Tool Company, Inc. 30-Freightliner Trucks 66, Supplying “Made in USA” heat
We design & manufacture: 60 Series Detroit, HT740, shrink tubing to pump and well
PVC Screen Slotting Machines Allison Trans., Rockwell Axle, installers since 1994.
PVC Pipe Threading Machines 68KGVW, 315/80 R22.5 Michelin, 315-622-5957
Vertical Slotting Machines
Low Miles
Perforating/Hole Drilling Machines
Made in USA.
SEMCO, Inc.
High quality, affordable, easy to Phone (800) 541-1562 75 ELECTRIC MOTORS
operate automated machines.
www.jktool.com EQUIPMENT WANTED: Electric mo-
320-563-4967 · sales@jktool.com tors wanted. Vertical hollow shaft pump
motors. 20 to 500 hp good or bad, will pick
up. PH: (800) 541-1562.
NGWA.org/CareerCenter
Employers:
• Quickly and easily post job openings
• Search resumes of qualiÿed candidates
• Receive a discount if you’re an NGWA member.
Job seekers:
• Post your resume anonymously
• Access hundreds of job openings and sign up
for job alerts
• Take advantage of a host of resources.
NGWA
The Groundwater
Association
®
Most well problems can be somewhat easily Recruiting and training the
assessed and resolved using common testing next generation of employees
and evaluation practices. However, the more in this information technology
difficult issues require a more detailed search world is critical. Our success
and examination—well forensics. is dictated by the trained
Alexandra Walsh
in “Eye Safety on the Job”, page 32
Wolf Pumps • PO Box 490, 18014 N. I-27 Hwy • Abernathy, TX 79311 • WolfPumps.com
© 2018 Wolf Customized Pumps. All rights reserved. Wolf Customized Pumps asserts trademark and copyright rights in “Right Pump. Right Now.” the Wolf logo and the silhouette image device.