Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Insurance benefits
Katrien Antonio
policyholder’s beneficiaries
death benefit
life insurance
contract
premium(s)
I We value traditional life insurance benefits, including the whole life, term and endowment
insurance.
I We introduce the random variables (r.v.’s) representing the present values of the benefits,
and express their moments.
• Tx
• Kx
(m)
• Kx , the number of complete periods of length 1/m years lived by (x).
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Learning outcomes 4 / 73
Learning outcomes
I We cover Sections 4.1 - 4.4 and 4.6 from the book (DHW, third edition).
I We mention the essential findings from Section 4.5 (‘Relating Āx , Ax and A(m)
x ’) but will
not cover the derivations in this Section.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Learning outcomes 5 / 73
Introduction
I We combine:
and obtain the distribution of the present value (PV) of an uncertain, life contingent future
benefit.
I The basis is the set of assumptions used in life insurance or pension calculations.
µx = A + B · cx ,
• a constant and fixed interest rate (see DataCamp Chapter 1 for other term structures)
1+i = eδ
v = (1 + i)−1 = e −δ .
I What if we split the one year time period in m equal intervals (e.g., m = 12)?
I Thus,
?
im = (1 + i)1/m − 1
i (m)
= (1 + i)1/m − 1,
m
with
• i (m) = m · im? .
• benefit of 1 EUR
I Payment date is unknown, and thus present value of benefit is also unknown.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 10 / 73
Whole life insurance
Continuous case, Āx , time-line
x x +s x + s + ds age
0 s s + ds time
s px µx+s ds
(x) survives s years (x) dies
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 11 / 73
Whole life insurance
Continuous case, Āx , PV as r.v.
I The present value of the 1 EUR benefit payable immediately on death is a r.v.,
Z = v Tx = e −δ·Tx .
E [Z ] = E [e −δ·Tx ],
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 12 / 73
Whole life insurance
Continuous case, Āx , PV as r.v.
fx (t) = t px · µx+t ,
then
Āx = E [e −δ·Tx ]
Z ∞
= e −δ·t · t px · µx+t dt.
0
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 13 / 73
Whole life insurance
Continuous case, Āx , PV as r.v.
I Variance of the PV
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 14 / 73
Whole life insurance
Continuous case, Āx , PV as r.v.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 15 / 73
Whole life insurance
Annual case, Ax
• benefit of 1 EUR
I Payment date is unknown, and thus present value of benefit is also unknown.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 16 / 73
Whole life insurance
Annual case, Ax , time-line
x x +k −1 x +k x + k + 1 age
0 k −1 k k +1 time
k px qx+k
I The present value of the 1 EUR benefit payable at the end of the year of death is a r.v.,
Z = v Kx +1 .
E [Z ] = E [v Kx +1 ],
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 18 / 73
Whole life insurance
Annual case, Ax , PV as r.v.
then
Ax = E [v Kx +1 ]
+∞
X
= v k+1 k| qx = v · qx + v 2 · 1| qx + v3 · 2| qx + ...
k=0
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 19 / 73
Whole life insurance
Annual case, Ax , PV as r.v.
Then, the variance of the present value of a benefit of 1 EUR payable at the end of the
year of death is
2
Ax − (Ax )2 .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 20 / 73
Whole life insurance
(m)
The 1/mthly case, Ax
I Let Kx(m) be the 1/mthly curtate future lifetime r.v., where m > 1 is an integer (e.g. 2, 4
or 12).
Kx = 23,
(2) (4) (12) 8
Kx = 23.5, Kx = 23.5, Kx = 23 .
12
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 21 / 73
Whole life insurance
(m)
The 1/mthly case, Ax
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 22 / 73
Whole life insurance
(m)
The 1/mthly case, Ax , time-line
1
Pay 1 EUR at time k + m
1
discount with v (0, k + m
)
1
x x +k x +k + m age
0 k k+ 1 time
m
k px 1 qx+k
m
(m) 1
1 2
If Kx = k (with k = 0, m , m , . . .) then the present value r.v. takes value v k+ m .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 23 / 73
Whole life insurance
(m)
The 1/mthly case, Ax , PV as r.v.
I The present value of the 1 EUR benefit payable at the end of the month of death is a r.v.,
(12)
Z = v Kx +1/12
,
where m = 12.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 24 / 73
Whole life insurance
(m)
The 1/mthly case, Ax , PV as r.v.
The EPV of the 1 EUR benefit discrete, 1/mthly whole-life insurance product.
(m)
Recall the pf of Kx ,
(m)
Pr (Kx = k) = k px − 1 px
k+ m = k px · 1 qx+k = 1 qx ,
k| m
m
then
(m)
Ax = v 1/m 1 qx + v 2/m 1 1
| qx + v 3/m 2 1
| qx + . . .
m m m m m
1
Cfr. the time-line: let k run from 0 to ∞ (or: ω − x) in steps of m.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 25 / 73
Whole life insurance
(m)
The 1/mthly case, Ax , PV as r.v.
I Then, the variance of the present value of a benefit of 1 EUR payable at the end of the
month of death is
2 (12) (12) 2
Ax − (Ax ) .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 26 / 73
Recursions
I Using the annual life table in a spreadsheet, calculate Ax using backwards recursion.
Aω−1 = E [v Kω−1 +1 ] = v .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 27 / 73
Recursions
= v · qx + v · px · Ax+1 .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 28 / 73
Recursions
v · qx ,
• value at age x + 1 of all subsequent benefits, discounted to time 0 using survival probability
and the discount factor!
v · px · Ax+1 .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 29 / 73
Term insurance
Continuous
I Death benefit is payable at the moment of death, but only if policyholder dies within fixed
term of, say, n years.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 30 / 73
Term insurance
Continuous
I Using a similar reasoning as before (with the continuous whole-life insurance), the EPV is
Z n
Ā 1 = e −δ·t t px · µx+t dt.
x:n 0
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 31 / 73
Term insurance
Annual
I Death benefit is payable at the end of the year of death, if death occurs within fixed term
of, say, n years.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 32 / 73
Term insurance
mthly case
I Death benefit is payable at the end of the 1/mth year of death, if death occurs within fixed
term of, say, n years.
k 1
[Check: if k = m · n − 1, then m =n− m .]
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 33 / 73
Pure endowment
I Pure endowment benefits are conditional on the survival of the policyholder at a policy
maturity date.
I The present value r.v. Z , with benefit of 1 EUR and term of n years, is
(
0 if Tx < n,
Z =
v n if Tx ≥ n.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 34 / 73
Pure endowment
I Rewriting Z we find,
(
0 with probability 1 − n px ,
Z =
vn with probability n px .
A 1 = n Ex = vn · n px .
x: n
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 35 / 73
Endowment insurance
Continuous
I The endowment insurance combines: (i) a term insurance and (ii) a pure endowment.
I The present value r.v. Z , with benefit of 1 EUR and term of n years, is
(
v Tx = e −δ·Tx if Tx < n,
Z =
vn if Tx ≥ n.
= v min(Tx ,n) = e −δ·min (Tx ,n) .
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 36 / 73
Endowment insurance
Continuous
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 37 / 73
Endowment insurance
Annual
I When the death benefit is payable at the end of the year of death,
(
v Kx +1 if Kx ≤ n − 1,
Z =
vn if Kx ≥ n
= v min(Kx +1,n) = e −δ·min (Kx +1,n) .
I With EPV
n−1
X
v k+1 · k px · qx+k + v n · Pr [Kx ≥ n] = A 1 + v n ·n px .
x:n
k=0
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 38 / 73
Endowment insurance
mthly
I When the death benefit is payable at the end of the 1/mth year of death,
(m)
( 1 (m)
v Kx + m if Kx ≤ n − m1 ,
Z = (m)
vn if Kx ≥ n.
(m) 1
= v min(Kx +m ,n)
.
I With EPV
m·n−1
(m) (m)
X
v (k+1)/m · k px · qx+ k + v n · Pr [Kx ≥ n] = A 1 + v n ·n px .
m m x:n
k=0
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 39 / 73
Deferred insurance benefits
Continuous
I Deferred insurance refers to insurance which does not begin to offer death benefit cover
until the end of a deferred period.
I Consider a benefit of 1 EUR payable immediately on death of (x) provided (x) dies
between ages x + u and x + u + n.
I The PV r.v. is
(
0 if Tx < u or Tx ≥ u + n,
Z =
e −δ·Tx if u ≤ Tx < u + n.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 40 / 73
Deferred insurance benefits
Continuous
I Calculate the EPV
Z u+n
u| Ā 1 = e −δ·t t px · µx+t dt
x:n u
Z n
= e −δ·(s+u) s+u px · µx+s+u ds
0
Z n
−δ·u
= e p
u x e −δ·s s px+u · µx+s+u ds
0
= e −δ·u u px · Ā 1
x+u:n
= vu · u px · Ā 1
x+u:n
= u Ex · Ā 1 .
x+u:n
Hence,
u| Ā 1 = Ā 1 − Ā 1 .
x:n x:u+n x:u
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 42 / 73
Deferred insurance benefits
(As a recap) Let’s take a closer look at the following identity:
u| Ā 1 = Ā 1 − Ā 1 ,
x:n x:u+n x:u
Ā 1 = Ā 1 + u| Ā 1 ,
x:u+n x:u x:n
i.e. the EPV of term insurance with duration u + n issued to (x) equals the EPV of a term
insurance with duration u years issued to (x) plus the EPV of a term insurance with duration n,
deferred over u years, issued to (x). This is also equal to
Ā 1 = Ā 1 + u Ex · Ā 1 ,
x:u+n x:u x+u:n
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Valuation of insurance benefits 44 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax : the essentials
I This is useful when we only have a life table with integer age functions.
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 45 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using UDD - the essentials
You will sometimes use this approximation in exercises (cfr., formula sheet). Derivation
on next slides is FYI.
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 46 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using UDD - FYI
d d
s qx = s · qx
ds ds
= qx .
The lhs is the derivative of the cdf of Tx , hence the pdf, thus
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 47 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using UDD - FYI
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 48 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using UDD - FYI
Eventually,
eδ − 1
Āx ≈ Ax ·
δ
1+i=e δ i
= · Ax .
δ
Similar approximations hold for other products.
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 49 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using claims acceleration
I For example,
• insured (x) dies in [x + Kx , x + Kx + 1), now split the year into quarters
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 50 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using claims acceleration
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 51 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using claims acceleration - the essentials
and when m → ∞
Āx ≈ (1 + i)1/2 · Ax .
You will sometimes use this approximation in exercises (cfr., formula sheet). Derivation
on next slides is FYI.
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 52 / 73
(m)
Relating Āx , Ax and Ax
Using claims acceleration - FYI
I This leads to the following approximation,
(m) m+1 m+1
Ax ≈ qx · v 2m + px · qx+1 · v 1+ 2m
m+1
+ 2 px · qx+2 · v 2+ 2m + ...
∞
X m+1
= k px · qx+k · v k+ 2m
k=0
∞
− m−1 +k+1= m+1 +k m−1 X
2m 2m
= (1 + i) 2m · k px · qx+k · v k+1
k=0
m−1
= (1 + i) 2m · Ax .
When m → ∞, we retrieve
Āx ≈ (1 + i)1/2 Ax .
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 53 / 73
Variable insurance benefits
DIY
(m)
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven Relating Āx , Ax and Ax 54 / 73
That’s a wrap!
I You can define the present value r.v. of a death benefit, payable in continuous or discrete
time.
I You relate mthly and continuous time products to their annual counterparts.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a wrap! 55 / 73
That’s a wrap!
Timelines
b0 b1 b2 b3 b4 b5 benefit
0 1 2 3 4 5
... time
discount factors
qx 1| qx 2| qx 3| qx 4| qx ...
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a wrap! 56 / 73
That’s a wrap!
Timelines
discount factors
qx 1| qx ... n−2| qx n−1| qx ...
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a wrap! 57 / 73
That’s a wrap!
Timelines
0 0 0 ... 0 d0 d1 benefit
0 1 2
...
u−1 u u+1
... time
discount factors
qx 1| qx ... u−2| qx u−1| qx u| qx ...
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a wrap! 58 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2020
For a cohort of individuals all age x consisting of non-smokers (ns) and smokers (sm) are
given:
• mortality is based on the following:
k ns
qx+k sm
qx+k
0 0.01 0.08
1 0.03 0.12
• i = 0.05
• A1 = 0.0616 for a randomly chosen individual from this cohort.
x:2
Determine the proportion of non-smokers and smokers in this cohort at age x.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 60 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2020
We reason as follows:
ns
A1 = v · qxns + v 2 · pxns · qx+1
ns
x:2
= 0.03646259
sm
A1 = v · qxsm + v 2 · pxsm · qx+1
sm
x:2
= 0.1763265.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 61 / 73
Mentimeter Challenge
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 62 / 73
Challenge - resit exam 2018-2019
For a special, fully discrete whole life insurance on (40) the following is given:
• the death benefit is 1 000 during the first 20 years, 5 000 during the next 5 years
and 1 000 afterwards,
• i = 0.06.
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 63 / 73
Challenge - resit exam 2018-2019
Thus, we consider
19
X 24
X
EPV = 1 000 · v k+1 · k p40 · q40+k + 5 000 · v k+1 · k p40 · q40+k
k=0 k=20
∞
X
+1 000 · v k+1 · k p40 · q40+k
k=25
∞
X 24
X
= 1 000 · v k+1 · k p40 · q40+k + 4 000 · v k+1 · k p40 · q40+k
k=0 k=20
4
X
= 1 000 · A40 + 4 000 · v 20 · 20 p40 · v k+1 · k p40+20 · q40+20+k
k=0
= 1 000 · A40 + 4 000 · 20 E40 ·A1 .
60:5
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 64 / 73
Challenge - resit exam 2018-2019
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 65 / 73
Challenge - resit exam 2018-2019
A40
20 E40
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 66 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2013-2014, Q3
Given
• qx+10 = 0.0083
• Ax+10 = 0.5148
• 10 Ex = 0.7055
• i = 3%.
If qx+10 is increased with 0.001 and all other assumptions stay the same, then how much
does Ax increase?
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 67 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2013-2014, Q3
I It follows:
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 68 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2013-2014, Q3
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 69 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2013-2014, Q3
P9
I We know A?1 = A1 = k=0 v (k + 1) · k px · qx+k .
x:10 x:10
I We put focus on
+∞
X
A?x+10 = v (k + 1) · ?
k px+10 · qx+10+k
k=0
+∞
X
?
= v · qx+10 + v k+1 · ?
k px+10 · qx+10+k .
k=1
Thus,
+∞
" #
X
A?x = A 1 + 10 Ex
?
· v · qx+10 + v k+1 · ?
k px+10 · qx+10+k .
x:10
k=1
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 70 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2013-2014, Q3
I Now use:
+∞
X
v k+1 · ?
k px+10 · qx+10+k
k=1
∞
X
?
= v · px+10 · vk · k−1 px+10+1 · qx+10+1+(k−1)
k=1
+∞
X
?
= v · px+10 · v l+1 · l px+11 · qx+11+l (use l := k − 1)
l=0
?
= v · px+10 · Ax+11 .
As such we find:
A?x = A 1 ? ?
+10 Ex · v · qx+10 + v · px+10 · Ax+11 .
x:10
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 71 / 73
Challenge - midterm 2013-2014, Q3
?
I Replace qx+10 = qx+10 + 0.0001 then
Life Insurance Mathematics 2022, K. Antonio, UvA & KU Leuven That’s a challenge! 73 / 73