You are on page 1of 6

ARTICLE IN PRESS

Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies (2008) 12, 185–190

Journal of
Bodywork and
Movement Therapies
www.intl.elsevierhealth.com/journals/jbmt

FASCIA RESEARCH

Epi-perineurial anatomy, innervation, and axonal


nociceptive mechanisms
Geoffrey M. Bove

Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 01907, USA

Received 3 March 2008; received in revised form 26 March 2008; accepted 30 March 2008

KEYWORDS Abstract Nerves are usually viewed as simple conduits of electrical signals to make
Fascia; muscles move and enable sensation. However, recent data have shown that the
Nervi nervorum; axons within nerves are capable of responding to their environment. Nerves have a
Pain mechanisms very specialized anatomy and physiology, and are capable of mediating certain types
of pain. This synopsis introduces the reader to these concepts, which can be
incorporated into clinical decision-making.
& 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Introduction the surrounding structures constitute but one


mechanical stimulus that nerves are susceptible
Body workers from all disciplines appreciate that to. Nerves are also bent around various structures,
maneuvers that move nerves often reproduce and indented by external pressures. Nerves have
radiating pain. This symptom reproduction has many anatomical features that allow them to
important implications for the diagnosis and man- accommodate such movements and mechanical
agement of radiating pain symptoms. stimuli. The reader is directed to books by
In the presentation at Fascia 2007 from which Shacklock (2005) and Butler (2000) for full descrip-
this manuscript is derived, two videos that were tions of nerve biomechanics.1
obtained with high-resolution diagnostic ultrasound
were presented that clearly showed median nerve
gliding during normal finger and wrist movements.
Nerve fascial anatomy
The movements were independent of the move-
Nerves possess a complicated, 3-layer fascial struc-
ments of the other surrounding structures. Such
ture (Figure 1). Axons are covered by endoneurium,
movements of the interface between the nerve and
1
Readers are cautioned regarding abnormal nerve movements,
Corresponding author. Present address: Department of or nerve tethering, as contributory to nerve-related pain. Such
Anesthesia, Critical Care, and Pain Medicine, Beth Israel aberrant biomechanics have yet to be documented, and, in fact,
Deaconess Medical Center, 330 Brookline Ave, Dana 721, Boston, substantial evidence exists that refutes the presence of adverse
MA 02215, USA. Tel.: +1 617 667 0641; fax: +1 617 667 1500. nerve movements during disease states such as carpal tunnel
E-mail address: gbove@bidmc.harvard.edu syndrome and other repetitive motion disorders.

1360-8592/$ - see front matter & 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jbmt.2008.03.004
ARTICLE IN PRESS
186 G.M. Bove

Figure 1 Peripheral nerve anatomy. A: Endoneurium-covered axons (end) are bundled by perineurium (p) into fascicles.
These fascicles are in turn covered by epineurium (epi). B, C: Specializations of the Schwann cells that surround
unmyelinated (B) and myelinated (C) axons. Numerous unmyelinated axons (ax) are embedded by invagination into the
cytoplasm of a single Schwann cell (Sch). Each myelinated axon has multiple layers of Schwann cell membrane wrapped
around it, forming myelin (my), interrupted at regular intervals by nodes of Ranvier (nR) (from Lundborg, 1988, used
with permission).

which offers little mechanical support. Groups of by nociceptors. A good example is the immediate
endoneurium-covered axons are bundled by peri- pain that is felt when one stubs a toe. In this
neurium, which is a thin but dense epithelium. The type of pain, the mechanical stimuli are transduced
perineurium offers strength in tension, and also by the normal neural elements into electrical
maintains the so-called blood–nerve barrier (if the impulses that then are conducted to the central
perineurium is cut into, the axons herniate because nervous system for perception. However, there
of the positive pressure inside the nerve). The are types of pain that do not rely on normal
perineurium is covered by the thicker epineurium, transduction. Two major categories are nerve trunk
an areolar tissue that acts as a cushion for the pain and dysesthetic pain (Asbury and Fields,
nerves. The epineurium is highly vascular, making it 1984). A simple exercise can often potentially
difficult to render any part of a peripheral nerve reveal the difference between these pain types.
ischemic. The blood vessels are slightly coiled to The ulnar nerve is located just posterior to
adapt to excursion of the nerves. Feeder vessels the medial humeral condyle (the so-called ‘‘funny
from the epineurial blood vessels course to all inner bone’’). Here it can be easily manually stimulated.
parts of the nerve. Importantly, to the discussion to If the reader presses on the nerve, he/she may
follow, all layers of the nerve are innervated, and feel local sensations, and/or they may feel sensa-
have a thin but potentially important plexus of tions in the medial hand and fingers (the distal
nociceptors. innervation territory of the ulnar nerve). Local
sensations, if painful, are properly considered
nerve trunk pain. Such pain requires local
Nerve trunk pain and dysesthetic pain transductive elements on the nerve that allow
perception of pain coming from the area being
Nociceptive pain is considered to be pain mediated stimulated. This is a form of nociceptive pain.
by noxious stimuli to a structure that is innervated Distal sensations, if painful, are called dysesthetic
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Epi-perineurial anatomy, innervation, and axonal nociceptive mechanisms 187

Figure 2 Peripherin-like immunostaining in nervi nervorum and vasa nervorum of rat sciatic nerve (whole mount). a:
Montage demonstrating nerves following a blood vessel (BV, outlined by the fibers flanking the label) and leaving it to
terminate in epineurium (arrows) and associated with adipose tissue (A). Note extensive branching. b: Enlargement of
area marked in a, detailing adipose innervation. M ¼ mast cell, A ¼ adipocyte. Scale bars in a ¼ 50 mm, b ¼ 20 mm
(from Bove and Light, 1995a, used with permission).

pain.2 To perceive any sensation distal to such a neural elements. While characterizing paraspinal
stimulus, there must be local transductive ele- nociceptors, we observed nociceptor receptive
ments in addition to the normal transductive fields located on neurovascular bundles and often
elements found more distally. A perfect clinical extending to muscles or tendon (Bove and Light,
example of this phenomenon is the pain that is 1995b). Using immunohistochemistry, we revealed
reproduced by the straight leg raising test in a peptidergic fine-caliber axons in the epineurium
patient with radicular pain. This test primarily and perineurium, consistent with nociceptive func-
moves the sciatic nerve and contributing roots, tion (Bove and Light, 1995a; Figure 2). We also
thus mechanically stimulating them. The nerve performed in vitro electrical and noxious chemical
is stimulated in a place that normally does not stimuli of nerves, nerve sheaths, and isolated
evoke sensations, but the distal symptoms are axons, and documented that nervi nervorum can
reproduced. evoke neurogenic inflammation (Sauer et al.,
1999). Collectively, these data support that nervi
nervorum are nociceptive and also nocifensive,
The basis of nerve trunk pain: the nervi meaning that they are responsive to damaging
nervorum stimuli by contributing to local inflammation, thus
helping to defend and maintain the nerve’s local
Nerve trunk pain is mediated by nervi nervorum, a environment (Lembeck, 1983; Light, 2004).
term that means ‘‘the nerve of the nerve’’.
Although recognized as an entity for more than a
century (Horsley, 1884; Sappey, 1867), a good The basis of mechanically evoked
anatomical description did not appear in the dysesthetic pain: ectopic axonal
literature until 1963 (Hromada, 1963). In the mechanical sensitivity
1990s, we performed a series of experiments that
documented the functional properties of these Mechanically evoked dysesthetic pain seems more
2 difficult to understand, because neural impulses
Other commonly used terms for this type of pain include
radiating pain and radicular pain. Radiating pain is not specific, have to be generated in a structure not normally
and radicular pain is used when the structure affected is the capable of initiating action potentials. We have
nerve root, or radix. reported that normal axons are not mechanically
ARTICLE IN PRESS
188 G.M. Bove

sensitive (Bove et al., 2003). This is good, because performed a time course of this change (Dilley
axons are mechanically stimulated during most and Bove, 2008a). We have reported that the peak
movements. We also know that when diseased or AMS occurs at 4–7 days post-initiation, and then
broken, axons can become mechanically sensitive decreases to insignificance or ‘‘heals’’ within 2
(Chen and Devor, 1998). However, if substantial months of the initial insult. We have characterized
damage is done, there will be areas of sensory loss, the inflammatory response using the presence and
a potentially important diagnostic metric. Demye- numbers of macrophages and T-cells. We have
lination also causes spurious activity in axons, but found that the inflammatory response is limited to
this does not necessarily affect nociceptors, which the epi- and perineurium, and outlasts the AMS by
are not myelinated. Moreover, clinical observations months (unpublished data). We hypothesize, but
support that dysesthetic pain in the absence of have not investigated fully, that the perineurial
apparent or overt nerve injury can often resolve diffusion barrier is disrupted by inflammation, and
rapidly (faster than possible by regeneration). heals faster than the immune system can clear the
Again, for intact axons to become mechanically pro-inflammatory debris. This will be a subject of
sensitive there must be a transductive element further study.
present.
We have modeled dysesthetic pain using a nerve
inflammation model (Bove et al., 2003). In this
model, the sciatic nerve of a rat is inflamed using The role of axoplasmic transport
complete Freund’s adjuvant (CFA), which induces a
robust immune mediated inflammation without We also questioned the mechanism of induced
leading to axonal breakage or other overt nerve ectopic AMS. It seems reasonable that the mechan-
injury (Bove et al., 2003; Eliav et al., 1999). ical–electrical transductive elements normally pre-
We have recorded from nociceptors with axons sent at nociceptor terminals become functional on
passing through such inflamed areas, and have the axons during inflammation. Unfortunately, the
reported that at least a subpopulation of inflamed transductive element of nociceptors has eluded
axons with intact nociceptive receptive fields detection, making the search for the inflammation-
becomes mechanically sensitive at the inflamed induced element difficult. We do know that nerve
site (Bove et al., 2003; Figure 3). Put otherwise, inflammation interferes with normal fast axoplas-
after a few days of inflammation, the axons became mic transport (Armstrong et al., 2004), and that the
capable of generating action potentials with similar mechanical transductive elements are likely trans-
mechanical forces that also caused their terminal ported from the cell body to the terminal
receptive fields to generate action potentials. This (Koschorke et al., 1994). Therefore, we hypothe-
axonal mechanical sensitivity (AMS) is referred to sized that if axoplasmic transport was blocked
as ‘‘ectopic electrogenesis’’. We subsequently in the absence of inflammation, we should still

Figure 3 Axonal mechanical sensitivity is induced by nerve inflammation. The sciatic nerve is depicted in the middle of
the image, with the shaded oval area indicating CFA-induced inflammation. The individual neurons lead to receptive
fields in muscle or skin (right and top), and centrally to dorsal roots (left) for recording. When inflamed, the normally
insensitive axons become mechanically sensitive. DRG, dorsal root ganglion (from Bove et al., 2003, used with
permission).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Epi-perineurial anatomy, innervation, and axonal nociceptive mechanisms 189

Figure 4 A: Components required for mechanical sensitivity are transported from the cell body of a single C-fiber
neuron to the periphery for insertion at the terminals. B: Blocking axoplasmic transport leads to the accumulation and
insertion of mechanosensitive components proximal to the site of axoplasmic blockade. Mechanical stimulation of the
axon membrane therefore becomes an effective stimulus to generate action potentials that pass in both directions
along the axon (denoted by arrows) (from Dilley and Bove, 2008b, used with permission).

detect AMS. Thus, we applied the axoplasmic a palpated spot leads to symptoms in a more distal
transport blockers colchicine and vinblastine to region. Most peripheral nerves can be directly
nerves, and tested for AMS. We found that such moved or palpated, and nerve courses are well
treatment evoked AMS in a majority of tested axons described anatomically. Nerves and their fascia
(Dilley and Bove, 2008b; Figure 4). We thus deserve full diagnostic attention.
concluded that the mechanical–electrical trans-
ductive element is transported by fast axoplasmic
flow. The ion channel(s) responsible for AMS have
yet to be determined. References
Armstrong, B.D., et al., 2004. Induction of neuropeptide gene
expression and blockade of retrograde transport in facial
motor neurons following local peripheral nerve inflammation
Conclusion in severe combined immunodeficiency and BALB/C mice.
Neuroscience 129, 93–99.
In conclusion, we have shown that nerves possess Asbury, A.K., Fields, H.L., 1984. Pain due to peripheral nerve
an intrinsic innervation of their fascial layers, and damage: an hypothesis. Neurology 34, 1587–1590.
Bove, G.M., Light, A.R., 1995a. Calcitonin gene-related peptide
that this innervation is nociceptive and likely and peripherin immunoreactivity in nerve sheaths. Somato-
responsible for nerve trunk pain. We have also sensory and Motor Research 12, 49–57.
shown that inflammation changes axons by making Bove, G.M., Light, A.R., 1995b. Unmyelinated nociceptors of rat
them sensitive to mechanical stimuli. This latter paraspinal tissues. Journal of Neurophysiology 73, 1752–1762.
Bove, G.M., et al., 2003. Inflammation induces ectopic mechan-
effect heals with inflammation resolution. We
ical sensitivity in axons of nociceptors innervating deep
feel that these findings have immediate clinical tissues. Journal of Neurophysiology 90, 1949–1955.
implications, although we caution that these data Butler, D.S., 2000. The Sensitive Nervous System. Noigroup
were gathered using rats in a very controlled Publications, Adelaide.
environment. It is, however, possible that patients Chen, Y., Devor, M., 1998. Ectopic mechanosensitivity in injured
with nerve trunk or dysesthetic pain have a sensory axons arises from the site of spontaneous electro-
genesis. European Journal of Pain 2, 165–178.
persistent source of inflammation that is affecting Dilley, A., Bove, G.M., 2008a. Resolution of inflammation
a nerve. Symptoms can appear as local tenderness induced axonal mechanical sensitivity and conduction slow-
of a nerve, or a ‘‘doorbell’’ type of response, where ing in C-fiber nociceptors. Journal of Pain 9, 185–192.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
190 G.M. Bove

Dilley, A., Bove, G.M., 2008b. Disruption of axoplasmic trans- Lembeck, F., 1983. Sir Thomas Lewis’s nocifensor system,
port induces mechanical sensitivity in intact rat histamine and substance-P-containing primary afferent
C-fibre nociceptor axons. Journal of Physiology 586, nerves. Trends in Neurosciences 6, 106–108.
593–604. Light, A.R., 2004. ‘‘Nocifensor’’ system re-revisited. Focus on
Eliav, E., et al., 1999. Neuropathic pain from an experimental ‘‘Two types of C nociceptor in human skin and their behavior
neuritis of the rat sciatic nerve. Pain 83, 168–182. in areas of capaicin-induced secondary hyperalgesia’’.
Horsley, V., 1884. Preliminary communication on the existence of Journal of Neurophysiology 91, 2401–2403.
sensory nerves in nerve-trunks, true ‘‘nervi nervorum’’. Lundborg, G., 1988. Nerve Injuries and Repair. Churchill
British Medical Journal 1, 196–198. Livingstone, Edinburgh.
Hromada, J., 1963. On the nerve supply of the connective tissue Sappey, M.C., 1867. Recherches sur les nerfsdu névrilème ou
of some peripheral nervous tissue system components. Acta nervi nervorum. C. R. Acad. Sci. 65, 761–762.
Anatomica 55, 343–351. Sauer, S.K., et al., 1999. Rat peripheral nerve components
Koschorke, G.M., et al., 1994. Cellular components necessary for release calcitonin gene-related peptide and prostaglandin
mechanoelectrical transduction are conveyed to primary E-2 in response to noxious stimuli: evidence that nervi
afferent terminals by fast axonal transport. Brain Research nervorum are nociceptors. Neuroscience 92, 319–325.
641, 99–104. Shacklock, M., 2005. Clinical Neurodynamics. Elsevier, Edinburgh.

You might also like