Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GROUPS: 47 – 48
ID Number: 405099M
SUBMISSION METHOD/MODE:
Personnel management had a very hard approach, as it were very authoritarian and
assumed that employees were easily replaceable company assets. (McGregor, 1957) This
approach was found to be inadequate on the workplace, as it was found that it slowed down
company growth due to a lack of employee longevity and evolved skillset in the available
workforce. In 1911, Mechanical Engineer Dr.Frederick Taylor had suggested in his book “The
Principles of Scientific Management” that by applying scientific management principles on the
workplace, the employee has to be developed to his maximum state of efficiency with adequate
training. Moreover, work must be divided and specific amongst different groups of employees,
in order to improve the overall operating efficiency of the company. Moreover, rewarding
personnel with wage increases will promote employee longevity and will also incentivise
employees to work harder and be ‘loyal’ to their manager and workplace. (Taylor, 1911)
In 1943, Abraham Maslow theorised that people are motivated if their five categories
of needs (physiological needs, security needs, social needs, esteem needs, and self-
actualisation) are satisfied. The first four needs are deficiency needs and self-actualisation is
the need to grow. Individual self-growth will allow the employee to achieve maximum
potential on the workplace, driving company growth. (Maslow, 1943) People who have
developed theories like Maslow include Herzberg with the ‘motivation-hygiene’ theory.
Hygiene factors (company policy, supervision, working conditions, salary, status, job security,
personal life etc.) are things associated with the four deficiency needs in Maslow’s hierarchy
of needs, while motivation (achievement, recognition, advancement, growth, etc.) is self-
actualisation on the workplace (Pardee, 1990).
Over the years models were developed which contributed to the development of
personnel management on the workplace. In the 1980s, Beer et al. developed the discipline of
human resources management (HRM). HRM looks at employees as capital and the only
resource in the company, which can generate value, for long term organisational success.
Having a strategic HRM (SHRM) is a cost-effective way to ensure company growth when
combined with company strategy. Moreover, it was highlighted that to ensure organisational
success, strategic HRM must be implemented all throughout the organisation.
The Harvard model is an analytical approach which studies the determinants and
consequences of HRM polices. The Harvard model recognises the importance of strategic
HRM in a company and the importance of employee needs, as much as customers and
shareholders. Using the Harvard model, managers’ choices greatly effective through the polices
they create. Using the 4C Harvard model, the manager and company policies (culture) can
affect the overall employee commitment and employee competence on the place of work, the
congruence between employee and company goals, and the overall cost effectiveness of the
company (four Cs of Harvard’s model of HRM). By aiming to strive the four Cs and other
factors, the company can take care of the overall well-being of the company and employees,
maintain environmental effectiveness (Beer M., 2015)
There are many more models that are used widely amongst HR peers which were
derived from the Harvard model. Such models include the 8-box model by Paul Boselie which
focuses on the external market context of HR, meaning how do external factors influence the
way one does HR (tailoring recruitment and hiring according to skill shortage, impact of
legislation on employee welfare policies, cultural effect on HR policy etc.). The HR value chain
by Paauwe and Richardson considers day to day HRM activities such as the cost-effectiveness
of hiring and training processes, and measure their outcomes (satisfaction, motivation,
retention and presence). This model enables an employer to take the best outcome of his own
actions, such as spending more time to hire an employee to ensure that he/she hires the right
employee for the job. (Hans, 2021)
Due to the CoVid-19 pandemic, there had to be a complete re-structuring of core HR-
activities. This is to strategically acquire the maximum amount of financial value out of the
business while still safe-guarding employees’ jobs. One such HR re-structuring includes the
use of HR information systems and implementation of digital tools on the workplace to
safeguard employee health and maximise employee productivity. EY have devised an HR
model in 2021 as a result of the pandemic which they called the ‘People Value Chain’ which
is based on three aspects: digital people team, people consultants, and virtual global business
services. (Vasey, 2021)
Using such theories and models, a PESTEL analysis (CIPD, 2021) can be carried out
to further determine the external factors which have shaped HR practice in organisations in the
past two years due to the CoVid-19 Pandemic:
External Factors to Consider Impact of factors on industry of choice Organisational
Importance
Political Government Policy The CoVid-19 Pandemic has had profound High
Political Stability consequences on global trade due to lesser sales, and
Tax logistical problems that resulted in a decrease in
Industry regulations shipments over the course of the pandemic.
Global trade agreements and/or
restrictions There have been sharp increases in shipment prices
ever since the start of the pandemic. Moreover, a Medium
shortage of production parts from China (PCBs) due
to factory lockdowns have delayed shipments
further. These issues have slowed down sales and
reduced profit margins greatly.
The recruitment process at MEM for non-entry level jobs starts off as a departmental
in-house type of recruitment. Departmental managers are expected to identify and coach a
handful individuals using a SMART approach on leadership and management on the place of
work (a SHRM strategy). The employee with the best combination of technical and leadership
qualities will be the next contender for a promotion to a managerial position within the
section/company. This continuous employee training will ensure that there are always trained
employees available take-up vacant managerial/leadership positions within the company. This
strategically helps employees to fulfil themselves on the workplace, eliminate aspects of the
glass ceiling effect between manager and employee, and maintain a healthy psychological
contract between the employee, management and HR.
If no one is internally available to take up the required role, an open call for Job Vacancy
will be issued on the MEM web portal (an online database protected via Okta Network Security
Solutions). The advert will consist of a job title and description, responsibilities, needed skills
and qualifications and the deadline to apply. In the case that no one within the company is
available or qualified enough to take on the role, job recruitment websites such as LinkedIn)
are used by HR recruitment officers to selectively look up for ideal candidates and approach
them for an interview. At MEM, it is very uncommon to issue an advert for work unless it is
unless it is for a very rare skillset resource such as a toolmaker.
HR will ensure that the employee receives the necessary onboarding training upon
selection. Topics covered during training range from employee health and safety,
environmental awareness on the workplace and disciplinary behaviour workplace (including
sexual harassment policies, company fraud policies, environmental policies) are discussed. A
year-long training program is strategically issued by the line manager so that new employees
are fully coached on their job, and to ensure that employee achieves maximum work output for
their current job at MEM. Moreover, several courses on anger management, negotiation skills
time management on the workplace are offered by HR and made compulsory for workers, to
improve social interaction and work-flow efficiency on the job. Last not least, specific training
on the handling of specialised equipment is given to a select number of workers for themselves
and their team’s health and safety on the premises. Examples include health and safety courses
on the handling compressed gases. Lastly, online training using Thomson Reuters platforms
are used to give cyber-security training courses.
Line managers are expected to routinely give feedback to employees on their job
performance and criticise them when needed. Officially, HR routinely interviews employees
and asks them for feedback on their place work, wage, job satisfaction, attitude towards
company policy culture (Kaizen system, 5S, etc.) and relationships with their colleagues and
superiors on the workplace. All this data is recorded on excel files and stored on the MEM
drive, so that they are easily accessible in the need of a job promotion, wage increase and
rewarding of individual for increased performance. Shopfloor employees are represented by
the Maltese General Workers Union which together with MEM have a guideline which outlines
worker rights, health and safety on the workplace, yearly wage guidelines and guides towards
constructive employee appraisals on the workplace.
CoVid-19 has significantly boosted the use of Human Resources Information systems
to track employee data: employee skillset, employee wages (Using Shireburn indigo), booking
leave and employee punching-in and punching out (using Work Attend mobile phone
application). HR has tried its utmost to protect the most venerable, mothers and pregnant
individuals to work from home. Due to the constant communication between shopfloor
employees and staff, it was very difficult to allow most people to work from home. due to the
To retain staff and crucial shopfloor personnel from manufacturing, a 4-day working week was
proposed to reduce staff attrition and to protect jobs. Meetings were shifted to Microsoft Teams
which nowadays became a popular convenience to hold meetings within the company and
schedule appointments for day-to-day discussions and developments on the workspace.
Transitioning towards industry 4.0 isn’t easy, as it involves a lot of training to staff and
shop floor employees on manufacturing data information systems and efficient way to
manipulate and process data in order to better analyse the overall efficiency of the workplace,
hence employee productivity. This type of data has allowed management to take easier
decisions on employee retention, selective employee coaching, improvement of standard
operating procedures and efficient budgeting dependant on operational needs.
Unfortunately, this data driven approach has fuelled hard HRM practices on the
workplace. Shopfloor employees are excessively driven to keep up with production demands.
Moreover, a data driven approach has made managers more stringent on expecting immediate
explanations to production downtime or reasons for decreased efficiency (reduced cycle time)
during production. This is putting shopfloor employees under excessive pressure which if not
dealt with in the right manner, could lead to catastrophic damage to employee morale on the
workplace. As a result, this attitude has resulted in an increased employee attrition over the
course of the pandemic, meaning that employees with years of experience on different fields
injection moulding, toolmaking, electrical technicians were lost as a result of this managerial
shift.
Health and Safety on the workplace was very much looked after, by providing weekly
testing to staff to safeguard the protection of employees, providing free PPEs and sanitizers on
the workplace and ensuring that there is enough desk space and social distancing present on
site. As a result, worker rights to stay home was still behind when compared to other business,
resulting in a lack of flexibility on the workplace. Meaning, that workers were still expected to
come to work regardless of the situation of the pandemic, as top management felt that worker
productivity decreased if staff were to work from home. This is another example of needless
Hard HRM on the workplace with staff.
Running a manufacturing facility as a line manager is no easy job, especially due to the
constant pressure from superiors to keep up with production demands. Yet, this should not alter
one’s behaviour on the workplace, specifically shopfloor employees. Firstly, for effective
employee response, the line manager should always maintain a healthy psychological contract
with his/her employees. This will boost the employee’s confidence on the workplace and will
allow the employee to look at the job from a more positive outlook. Having a positive mindset
will unknowingly make the employee loyal to the job, and always strive to do better. Doing
better means, aiming to reach production goals and surpassing by taking initiative on the job.
Using a slight soft HRM approach (Theory Y) can be beneficial on the workplace and
can make things easier when it comes to integrating new concepts on the workplace such as
data management systems. Time is key, and time should be allocated for the training and
coaching of employees so as to ensure that employees are fulfilling their job without risking
their welfare and without missing any crucial steps that need to be done on the job. Such
checks/steps include produced part quality checks and 5S checks (maintaining order on the
workplace; Japanese culture [Theory Z]) on the workspace.
Hence, having employees permanently employed to the company can give room for
fast tracked continuous improvement in production outputs and the continuous technical
development of employees on the workplace. Continuous improvement allows line managers
to recruit ideal employees to grow within the company. This will help employees to develop
themselves as tomorrow’s leaders. Argyris in his book of organisational learning has
emphasised, that using such an approach on the workplace will ensure an increased employee
satisfaction in the long run.
The Human resources department need to try to use Human Resources Information
Systems more effectively and train all employees on how such systems are used for their own
benefit. Keeping these information systems up to date are of great benefit to the company to
keep track of the available skills of employees on the workplace. This is an essential tool for
managers, to know what skill sets and expertise are available on the workplace in order to
assign staff specifically to positions on different projects. Moreover, the department should be
more open to change management procedures and push for change management in different
departments, ensuring continuous improvement in every department and never allowing the
‘freezing’ of ongoing procedures on the workplace.
Conclusion
Human Resource Management has come a long way and it will take to come back on
its two feet, especially after going through a pandemic of this sort. The economic repercussions
are great and need time for them to be restored. As a result, the biggest challenge of human
resources throughout the pandemic was to stay grounded and keep on pushing towards the
protection and welfare of the employee on the workplace. Methode electronics Malta might be
on the right path in doing so (policy wise) yet there is still a long way to go to achieve optimal
HR performance on the workplace, especially when it comes to the implementation of Human
Resources Information Systems on the workplace.
References
Beer M., B. B. (2015, May-June). Back to the future: Implications for the field of HRM of
the multitaskholder perspective proposed 30 years ago. Human Resource
Management (Wiley Periodicals), pp. 427-438.
Beer, M. S. (1984). Human resource management: A general manager’s perspective. New
York: Free Press.
Bendix, G. W. (2000). The "Hawthorne effect" — what did the original Hawthorne studies
actually show? Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health, 363-367.
CIPD. (2021, December 06). PESTLE Analysis. Retrieved from CIPD:
https://www.cipd.co.uk/knowledge/strategy/organisational-development/pestle-
analysis-factsheet#gref
Hans, I. (2021, December 28). Top 10 HR Models Every Human Resources Professional
Should Know. Retrieved from Select Software Reviews:
https://www.selectsoftwarereviews.com/blog/top-10-hr-models
Maslow, A. H. (1943). A Theory of Human Motivation. Psychological Review, 370-396.
McGregor, D. (1957). The Human Side of Enterprise. Management Review, 22-28.
Mcgregor, M. D. (1960). The Human Side of Enterprise. New York: McGraw-Hill.
McLelland, D. C. (1988). Human Motivation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Oress.
Micallef, P. (2022, February). Methode Malta Celebrates 25 Years of Success. The Methode
Insider Monthly Newsletter, pp. 2-8.
Ouchi, W. (1981). Theory Z: How can american business meet the japanese challenge.
Pardee, R. L. (1990). Motivation theories of Maslow, Herzberg, McGregor & McClelland.
Literature review of selected theories dealing with job satisfaction and motivation.
Romford, J. (2021, December 06). Hard and Soft HRM. Retrieved from Agility Portal:
https://agilityportal.io/blog/hard-and-soft-hrm
Sarthak, S. J. (2019). Human Resource Management in Japan. Advances In Management, 48-
53.
Sethi, N. K. (1962). Mary Parker Follett: Pioneer in Management Theory. The Journal of the
Academy of Management, 214-221.
Shireburn. (2021). Indigo Suite. Retrieved from Shireburn Software:
https://www.shireburn.com/indigo
Taylor, F. (1911). The Principles of Scientific Management. New Yorl: Harper & Brothers
Publishers.
Vasey, K. (2021, Jan 28). Reimagining HR: where is your organization in the People Value
Chain? Retrieved from EY: Building a better world together:
https://www.ey.com/en_ch/workforce/reimagining-hr-where-is-your-organization-in-
the-people-value-ch
Workday. (2021). An HCM system that adapts to what comes next. Retrieved from Workday:
https://www.workday.com/en-us/products/human-capital-management/overview.html