Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE PEOPLE'S
UNIVERSITY Environmental
Indira Gandhi National Open University
School of Interdisciplinary and Toxicology
Trans-disciplinary Studies
ENVIRONMENTAL CYTOTOXICITY
AND GENOTOXICITY 4
MEV-004
Environmental Toxicology
Indira Gandhi National Open University
School of Interdisciplinary and
Trans-disciplinary Studies
Block
4
ENVIRONMENTAL CYTOTOXICITYAND
GENOTOXICITY
UNIT 1
Carcinogenicity 5
UNIT 2
Mutagenicity 20
UNIT 3
Teratogenesis 33
UNIT 4
Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity Prevention 45
PROGRAMME COORDINATORS
Dr. B. Rupini Dr. Sushmitha Baskar Prof. Ruchika Kuba
Environmental Studies, School of Interdisciplinary Environmental Studies, School of Interdisciplinary School of Health Sciences, Indira
and Trans-disciplinary Studies, Indira Gandhi and Trans-disciplinary Studies, Indira Gandhi Gandhi National Open University,
National Open University, New Delhi National Open University, New Delhi New Delhi
FORMAT EDITORS
Dr. B. Rupini Dr. Sushmitha Baskar
Environmental Studies, School of Interdisciplinary and Environmental Studies, School of Interdisciplinary and Trans-
Trans-disciplinary Studies, Indira Gandhi National Open disciplinary Studies, Indira Gandhi National Open University,
University, New Delhi New Delhi
Secretarial/Technical Assistance: Ms. Sonali, SOITS, IGNOU, New Delhi; Mr. Vikram, SOITS, IGNOU, New Delhi
PRINT PRODUCTION
Mr. S. Burman Mr. Sudhir
Mr. Y. N. Sharma
Deputy Registrar (P), IGNOU, New Delhi Asst. Registrar (P), IGNOU, New Delhi Section Officer (P) IGNOU, New Delhi
February, 2019
Indira Gandhi National Open University, 2019
ISBN: 987-88-88498-90-6
All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form, by mimeograph or any other means, without permission in writing from the
Copyright holder.
Further information on the IGNOU courses may be obtained from the University’s office at Maidan Garhi, New Delhi or the official website of IGNOU
at www.ignou.ac.in
Printed and published on behalf of IGNOU, New Delhi by Registrar, MPDD, IGNOU, New Delhi.
Laser Typeset by Tessa Media & Computers, C-206, A.F.E.-II, Okhla, New Delhi.
Printed at:
INTRODUCTION TO BLOCK 4
This block focuses on the environmental cytoxicity and genotoxicity. Cytotoxicity
and genotoxicity develops as a function of age, environment and genetic makeup
of the host. They can be caused by viruses, radiation and by chemicals. Mutagens
and teratogens are also associated with lifestyle, diet and environment. The block
describes in detail carcinogens, mutagens, teratogens, their classes and mode of
action. Finally the block focuses on the prevention of the same and screening for
cyto and genotoxicity.
Unit 2 deals mutagenecity. Mutagens are agents that bring about changes in the
DNA and they are genotoxic in nature. The unit discusses that mutagens affect
the transcription and replication of the DNA and also lead to cellular death. It
also explains that certain mutagenic agents exert their mutagenic effect through
their metabolites and that powerful mutagens may result in chromosomal
instability, causing chromosomal breakages and rearrangement of the
chromosomes such as translocation, deletion, and inversion.
Unit 3 deals with teratogenecity. The unit explains that certain toxic substances
can penetrate the placental barrier and bring about birth defects with
malformations in the developing embryo and foetus causing teratogeneic effects.
The unit describes the effects of teratogens that cause mental retardation, paralysis
of the limbs, congenital heart defects, cleft palate, visual and auditory disturbances.
Finally the unit summarizes the teratogenic drugs and mechanisms of action.
Unit 4 deals with the cytotoxicity and genotoxicity prevention. The unit discusses
the screening methods like in vitro and in vivo toxicology testing, bioassay,
biomarkers, biosensors, bacterial mutagenesis, gene mutation chromosome
damage and DNA damage and repair assays and their usefulness in prevention
of cytotoxicity and genotoxicity.
Environmental Cytotoxicity
and Genotoxicity
4
Carcinogenicity
UNIT 1 CARCINOGENICITY
Structure
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Objectives
1.2 Carcinogens
1.3 Classes of Carcinogens
1.3.1 Physical Carcinogens
1.3.2 Biological Carcinogens
1.4 Carcinogenesis
1.4.1 Chemical Carcinogenicity
1.4.2 Etiology
1.4.3 Mechanism of Action
1.5 Let Us Sum Up
1.6 Key Words
1.7 References and Suggested Further Readings
1.8 Answers to Check Your Progress
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Cancer is a major cause of suffering and death. It is the second most fatal disease
next after cardiovascular diseases. Cancer develops as a function of age,
environment and genetic makeup of the host. According to an estimate 5% of
human cancers are caused by viruses, 5% by radiation and rest 90% by chemicals.
Of these, an estimated 30% are caused due to the use of tobacco products and
rest by chemicals associated with lifestyle, diet and environment.
In this unit you will study about carcinogens and carcinogenesis. Agents/chemicals
which can induce tumors are known as carcinogens while carcinogenesis is the
process of development of cancer. A cancerous cell possesses the ability of
uncontrolled cell proliferation. It is a multi-step process where suddenly a normal
cell turns into a rogue cell and starts dividing continuously leading to the
development of tumours (solid lumps) or dispersed cells (blood cells). You will
study in detail the etiology of cancer as well as the mechanism how carcinogens
work to induce cancer. In the preceding sections you will learn about various
classes of carcinogens.
Marginal Remarks: Around one-third of deaths from cancer: high body mass
index, low fruit and vegetable intake, lack of physical activity, tobacco and alcohol
use.
5
Environmental Cytotoxicity
and Genotoxicity 1.1 OBJECTIVES
After studying this unit you should be able to:
define cancer and carcinogens;
classify carcinogens;
identify carcinogens;
explain the etiology of cancer; and
discuss the mechanism of action of chemical carcinogens.
1.2 CARCINOGENS
Any chemical substance or mixture of chemical substances which induce cancer
or increase its incidence are termed as “carcinogens”. Inhalation, ingestion,
application or injection of these carcinogens induce malignant tumours or increase
their incidence or shorten the time of tumor occurrence. Cancer is also known to
be caused due to changes in cell’s DNA. Some of these changes may be hereditary.
Others may be caused due to environmental factors like wide range of exposures
to our lifestyle (nutrition, tobacco, physical activity), naturally occurring exposures
(ultra violet light, radon gas, infectious agents), medical treatments (radiations,
chemotherapy, hormonal drugs, immumo suppressive drugs), workplace
exposures (occupational hazards), pollution and household exposures.
2) Procarcinogens
Procarcinogens includes the majority of chemical carcinogens which are
initially non-carcinogenic but become active after metabolic processes i.e.
become active only when it is metabolized in an organism. Some of the
known procarcinogens are aminozoic colorants, aromatic hydrocarbons,
aflatoxins, aromatic amines and urethane.
6
3) Co-carcinogens Carcinogenicity
Now you know the difference between a carcinogen, pro-carcinogen and co-
carcinogen is known. In the next section you will study about various classes of
carcinogens.
The IARC Monographs identify environmental factors that can increase the
risk of human cancer. These include chemicals, complex mixtures,
occupational exposures, physical agents, biological agents, and lifestyle
factors. Some of the Group I potential carcinogens are:
Alcoholic beverages, Asbestos (all forms, including actinolite, amosite,
anthophyllite, chrysotile, crocidolite, tremolite), Aflatoxins, Areca nut,
Beryllium and beryllium compounds, Cadmium and cadmium compounds,
Coal-tar distillation, Cyclosporine, Benzene, Ethylene oxide, Betel quid with
tobacco, Betel quid without tobacco, Coal gasification, Coal (indoor
emissions from household combustion), Coke production, Engine exhaust
(diesel), Ethanol in alcoholic beverages, Estrogen therapy (postmenopausal),
Estrogen-progestogen oral contraceptives (combined), Helicobacter
pylori (infection with), Hepatitis B virus (chronic infection with), Hepatitis
C virus (chronic infection with), Human papillomavirus types 16, 18, 31,
33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, Ionizing radiation (all types), Leather
dust, lindane, Mineral oils, untreated or mildly treated, Outdoor air pollution
(particulate matter in), Painter (occupational exposure as a), Phenacetin,
analgesic mixtures containing, Polychlorinated biphenyls, Processed meat
(consumption of), Rubber manufacturing industry, Processed meat
(consumption of), Soot (as found in occupational exposure of chimney
sweeps), Ultraviolet radiation (wavelengths 100-400 nm, encompassing
UVA, UVB, and UVC), Wood dust, X- and Gamma-Radiation and many
more.
Ionizing radiations (X-rays, alpha, beta, and gamma rays, radioactive isotopes,
protons and neutrons) may directly alter cellular DNA resulting in mutagenesis,
8
may cause chromosomal breakage, translocation or point mutations. It may also Carcinogenicity
dislodge ions of water and other molecules of cell resulting into formation of
reactive free radicals that may bring about damage. It can frequently cause
leukemia and cancers of thyroid, skin, breast, ovary, uterus, lung, and salivary
glands.
Aspergillus flavus and Aspergillus parasiticus, fungus best known for its
colonization of cereal grains and legumes liberate significant quantities of toxic
compounds generally termed as mycotoxins (Example Aflatoxin. Aflatoxins are
poisonous and carcinogenic. Consumption of aflatoxins is associated with
development of hepatocellular carcinoma.
Many bacteria have also been reported as causal organism for cancer. Helicobacter
pylori (H pylori) can cause ulcers and lead to stomach cancer. Salmonella typhi
is associated with gall bladder cancer, Streptococcus bovis with colorectal cancer,
Chlamydia pneumoniae with lung cancer and so on. However Salmonella
typhi has also been found useful in delivering chemotherapeutic agents for the
treatment of melanoma, colon and bladder cancer.
Viruses as cancer causing agents have been divided into two groups: DNA
oncogenic viruses and RNA oncogenic viruses. Both these viruses may induce
mutation in the target host cell. RNA viruses (e.g. HIV, HCV) generally have
very high mutation rate than DNA viruses. However, viral infection alone is not
responsible for oncogenesis, yet it is one of the steps of a multi step process of
cancer development. Viral infections may be a primary viral infection in which
the infection lasts for few days to few weeks and are generally cleared by host
immune system or persistent/ latent viral infection which may occur by acquiring
mutation in viruses which resist host’s immune attack or virus itself induces
immune-suppression in the host such as HIV. Table 1.1 gives an overview of
various causal agents categorized into different sub groups.
9
Environmental Cytotoxicity Table 2.1: Various types of Carcinogens
and Genotoxicity
Radiation Infectious Chemicals Dietary/ Lifestyle
UVlight Virus Occupational Fat
X-ray HPV Arsenic Calorie
Gamma-ray HIV Asbestos Low fiber
Nuclear HCV Coal tars
EBV Soot
KSHV Benzene
HEP B/C Vinyl chloride
Bacteria Alcohol
H. pylori
C. psittaci
Fungus Tobacco
A. flavus Parasite
Schistosoma
Clonorchis
MR: Three common routes for most of the viral infections including oncogenic
viruses: direct contact with one another, inoculation from animals/insects to
humans and transmission of infection from parents to offsprings (oncogenic
viruses and retro-viruses).
Apart from these biological agents, there are many other factors that also
contribute to carcinogenesis. For example, age, hormonal status, family history,
diet and lifestyle. Generally prostate cancer occurs at the age of 50-55 years.
Females in their peri- and post – menopausal ages are prone to the cervix cancer.
Although no age group is immune to this disease yet hormonal factors play a
significant role in gender specific cancers. Also, having a family history adds to
the risk of developing cancers. It has been found that females run about 3 time
higher risk of developing breast cancer if either of their relatives like mother,
sister, grandmother or maternal aunt has suffered. Similar is the case with cervix
and prostate cancer.
Individuals who are more into deep-fried and preserved foods (high salt) are
prone to the incidence of gastric cancer. Similarly, regular consumption of diet
low in fiber content and high in animal fat increases the risk of stomach and
oesophageal cancer. It has also been reported that high fat diet and obesity has
positive correlation with breast cancer.
10
Check Your Progress 1 Carcinogenicity
1.4 CARCINOGENESIS
In the previous section you studied about various ways of classifying carcinogens vis-
à-vis potency, state or mode of action; let us now study about the mechanisms behind
carcinogenesis. Firstlywe will deal with chemical carcinogens and their mode of action.
Carcinogenesis is a process of development of cancer. During the cancer development
unlimited and uncontrolled cell division occur which leads to the formation of malignant 11
Environmental Cytotoxicity tumor. Uncontrolled cell division may occur due to mutation of DNAin cells or may
and Genotoxicity
be due to imbalance between cell proliferation and cell death resulting into cancer.
Earlier it was believed that all cancers arose from viral genes that are contained in
normalcells. These viralgeneswhen get activatedbychemicalcarcinogens andradiation
result in cancer. It was believed that many cells harbor latent retroviruses and that
these viruses are activated by carcinogens. However, it may be the case for some
cancers but after many years of trying to prove this hypothesis, strong support has
never been obtained.
Manycarcinogens are proved mutagens which suggest that a carcinogen might act by
causing a mutation in a proto-oncogene, thereby converting it to an oncogene. Basic
mechanism of chemical carcinogenesis is by induction of mutation in the proto-
oncogene and/or anti-oncogene (tumor suppressor gene).
In the previous section while studying classification, you have read that carcinogens
are classified according to their mode of action as genotoxic or non-genotoxic
carcinogens. Genotoxic carcinogens exert their carcinogenicity by direct interaction
with DNA, resulting in DNA damage or chromosomal aberrations. Non-genotoxic
carcinogens do not directly interact with DNA and are believed to enhance tumor
development byaffecting gene expression, signal transduction, and/or cell proliferation
i.e. they act by indirect or epigenetic mechanisms.
Genotoxic Carcinogens
Direct action
Pro-carcinogen
Inorganic Carcinogen
Non-Genotoxic Carcinogens
Solid state carcinogen
Hormones
Immunosuppression
Depending upon the mode of action chemical carcinogenicity can be divided into two
broad categories: chemical carcinogens as initiators and chemical carcinogens as
promoters.
Initiator Carcinogens: Chemical carcinogens which initiate the process of neoplastic
transformation are further divided into two subgroups:
i) Direct acting carcinogens/ pro-carcinogens: These do not require metabolic
activation and include:
12
a) Alkylating agents: These are mainly anti-cancer drugs (busulfan, Carcinogenicity
chlorambucil, cyclophosphamide, melphalan, nitroso urea etc.), beta-
propiolactone and epoxides. They are weakly carcinogenic and are
implicated in the etiologyof Leukemias and Lymphomas in humans;
Chemicals like insecticides, fungicides, saccharin and cyclomates are known to induce
cancer in the experimental animals.
13
Environmental Cytotoxicity oestrogen) in promotion of endometrium and breast cancer, prolonged administration
and Genotoxicity
of diethylstilbestrol in the etiology of postmenopausal endometrial carcinoma and in
vaginal cancer in younggirls born to mothers exposed to this hormone duringpregnancy.
Sometimes, dietary fats can also cause colon cancer. Even cigarette smoke, phenols,
certain drugs and viral infections can act as promoter carcinogens. Let us have look at
table 1.2 to understand some of the contrasting characteristics of initiator and promoter
carcinogens.
1.4.2 Etiology
You studied about various chemical carcinogens and their carcinogenic effects.
In this section let us study the etiology of cancer. Cancer is a pathologic condition
where clonally expanded cells derived from a common precursor cell get
accumulated. It may occur due to genetic damage or may be acquired as well.
Although each theory has its own merits, yet in many cases combination of two
or many processes work in cooperation leading to neoplastic cell transformation
and also facilitate promotional changes.
16
..................................................................................................................... Carcinogenicity
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
3) What are the various steps involved in transforming ‘the target cell’ into the
‘initiated cell’
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
19
Environmental Cytotoxicity
and Genotoxicity UNIT 2 MUTAGENICITY
Structure
2.0 Introduction
2.1 Objectives
2.2 Effects of Mutagens
2.3 Types of Mutations
2.4 Origins of Spontaneous Mutations
2.5 Mutagens
2.6 DNA Repair Systems
2.7 Let Us Sum Up
2.8 Key Words
2.9 References and Suggested Further Readings
2.10 Answers to Check Your Progress
2.0 INTRODUCTION
Mutation is any heritable change in the genetic material. It is significant in higher
organisms where mutations can occur both in the gametes (germline mutations)
and in body cells (somatic mutations). Mutations are important in several ways.
They are important to geneticists as the genetic variants possess mutant alleles
of the genes. They are also important in genetic variation which fuels evolutionary
change. Mutations are some changes that take place in our DNA sequence. This
may be due to some mistakes when the DNA is copied or due to certain factors
in the environment. These factors may be UV light, chemicals, food additives,
cigarette smoke and so on. The changes that occur in our DNA are in the sequence
of bases of adenine (A), cytosine (C), guanine (G) and thymine (T). These changes
can alter the protein formation in our systems. Mutations can also be inherited
through generations. One example is that of sickle cell anaemia. It is caused due
to a mutation in the gene that directs the protein formation of haemoglobin. It
causes the red blood cells to become abnormal and sickle shaped. It has been
observed that this mutation among the Africans helps them tide over malaria. In
this way mutations have advantages as well as disadvantages. This unit introduces
you to mutations, mutagens and their effects especially on the human systems.
2.1 OBJECTIVES
After studying this unit you should be able to:
define mutations;
classify the various types of mutagens;
explain the effects of mutagens on living systems; and
describe the DNA repair systems
20
Mutation
2.2 EFFECTS OF MUTAGENS
As mutagens bring about changes in the DNA, they are genotoxic agents. They can
affect the transcription and replication of the DNA. In some cases this can lead to
cellular death. Deleterious mutation can result in aberrant, impaired or loss of function
for a particular gene, and accumulation of mutations may lead to cancer. Mutagens
may therefore be also carcinogens. Certain mutagenic agents exert their mutagenic
effect through their metabolites. So such mutagens actually become carcinogenic
dependending on the metabolic processes of an organism. Also a compound shown
to be mutagenic in one organism may not necessarily be carcinogenic in another.
Different types of mutagens act on the DNAdifferently. Powerful mutagens mayresult
in chromosomal instability, causing chromosomal breakages and rearrangement of the
chromosomes such as translocation, deletion, and inversion. Such mutagens are called
clastogens.
Mutagens may also modify the DNA sequence. This means the changes in nucleic
acid sequences by mutations. This includes substitution of nucleotide base-pairs
and insertions and deletions of one or more nucleotides in DNA sequences. Some
of these mutations are lethal and some cause minor effects. Many mutations are
silent mutations. They are termed so as they cause no visible effects. This may
be because they occur in non-coding or non-functional sequences, or they do not
change the amino-acid sequence due to the redundancy of codons. Some mutagens
change the number of chromosomes in the cell and cause aneuploidy. In Ames
test, where the varying concentrations of the chemical are used in the test, the
dose response curve obtained is nearly always linear, suggesting that there is no
threshold for mutagenesis. Similar results are also obtained in studies with
radiations, indicating that there may be no safe threshold for mutagens. However,
some proposed that low level of some mutagens may stimulate the DNA repair
processes and therefore may not necessarily be harmful.
Check Your Progress 1
Note: a) Write your answer in about 50 words.
b) Check your progress with possible answers given at the end of the
unit.
1) Define mutation.
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
Hereditary mutations: They are inherited from a parent and are genetic. They
are present throughout a person’s life in all cells in the body. These mutations are
also known as germline mutations. This is due to their presence in the parent’s
egg or sperm cells known as germ cells. When an egg and a sperm cell unite a
fertilized zygote is produced. This receives DNA from both parents. When this
DNA has a mutation, then the embryo/ foetus will have the mutation in each of
his/her cells.
Somatic mutations: They occur in the somatic or body cells and not in the germ
cells. So they are not inherited from the parents. They take place at some time
during a person’s life time. These changes can be caused byenvironmental factors
such as ultraviolet radiation from the sun. It can also occur when certain errors
are made when DNA copies itself during cell division. They are also known as
acquired mutations. These mutations are not passed to the next generation.
Now let us learn about small changes in DNA, of the point mutation type.
22
B) Frameshift Mutations Mutation
Frameshifts are the result of “slipped mispairing” between the template DNA
strand and the newly synthesized strand during DNA replication. In the
sequence above, a likely spot for frameshift mutations to occur would be in
the stretch of 6 A:T base pairs. Subsequent studies with genes from other
organisms, including humans, have shown that runs of repeated nucleotides
are hotspots for frameshift mutations.
2.5 MUTAGENS
A mutagen is a natural or human-made agent (physical or chemical) which can
alter the structure or sequence of DNA.
A) Chemical Mutagens
The first report of mutagenic action of a chemical was in 1942 by Charlotte
Auerbach, who showed that nitrogen mustard (component of poisonous
mustard gas used in World Wars I and II) could cause mutations in cells.
Since that time, many other mutagenic chemicals have been identified and
there is a huge industry and government bureaucracy dedicated to finding
them in food additives, industrial wastes, etc.
1) Base Analogs
aminopurine adenine analog which can pair with T or (less well) with
C; causes A:T to G:C or G:C to A:T transitions. Base analogs cause
transitions, as do spontaneous tautomerization events.
3) Imntercalating Agents
Acridine Orange, Proflavin, Ethidium Bromide (used in labs as dyes
and mutagens)
All are flat, multiple ring molecules which interact with bases of DNA and
insert between them. This insertion causes a “stretching” of the DNA duplex
and the DNA polymerase is “fooled” into inserting an extra base opposite
an intercalated molecule. The result is that intercalating agents cause
frameshifts.
Table 2.2: Commonly used physical mutagens, their properties and mode
of action
26
Mutation
4. Beta Rays S.I., particulate, more Act by ionization and
Particles penetrating than alpha excitation. Cause
particles and negatively chromosomal and gene
charged. mutations.
5. Fast and D.I., particulate, neutral Cause chromosomal breakage
Thermal particles, highly penetrating and gene mutations.
Neutrons
6. Ultra Violet Non- ionizing, low Cause chromosomal breakage
Rays penetrating and gene mutations.
1) Electromagnetic Spectrum
Visible light and other forms of radiation are all types of electromagnetic
radiation (consists of electric and magnetic waves). The wavelength varies
widely and is inversely proportional to the energy they contain. The longest
waves (AM radio) have the least energy while successively shorter waves
and increasing energy are seen with FM radio, TV, microwaves, infrared,
visible, ultraviolet (UV), X and gamma radiation. The portion which is
biologically significant is UV and higher energy radiation.
2) Ionizing Radiation
X- and gamma-rays are energetic. They produce reactive ions (charged atoms
or molecules) when they react with biological molecules; thus they are
referred to as ionizing radiation. This term also includes corpuscular
radiation. They include atomic and subatomic particles emitted by radioactive
elements. They are of two types, alpha- and beta-particles. UV radiation is
not ionizing but can react with DNA and other biological molecules and is
also important as a mutagen. The units for ionizing radiation of all types are
rems (roentgen equivalent man). 1 rem of any ionizing radiation produces
similar biological effects. The effects of different types of radiation differ. 1
rem of alpha particles has a much greater damaging effect than one rem of
gamma rays. Further, the energy type and total dose of radiation are also
important factors.
3) Sources of Radiation
Natural sources of radiation produce so-called background radiation. These
include cosmic rays from the sun and outer space, radioactive elements in
soil and terrestrial products (wood, stone) and in the atmosphere (radon).
One’s exposure due to background radiation varies with geographic location.
In addition diagnostic X-rays, radiations from nuclear testing and power
plants, and various other sources such as TV’s, smoke detectors, are also
mutagenic.
Sublethal dose (100-250 rems): nausea and vomiting early; 1-2 week latent
period followed by malaise, anorexia, diarrhea, hair loss.
Lethal dose (350-450 rems): nausea and vomiting early; 1 week latent period
followed byabove with more severe symptoms including internal bleeding; a
50% chance of death. Death is due to blood cell or gastrointestinal failure.
Supralethal dose (>650 rems): nausea and vomiting early, followed byshock,
abdominal pain, diarrhea, fever and death within hours or days. Death is due
to heart or CNS damage.
For the affected tissues and organs, the number of destroyed cells and the
likelihood of their replacement determines the survival chances. The long
term effects include increased cancer risk and increased risk of mutations in
one’s offspring.
6) UV (Ultraviolet)
UV radiation is less energetic, and therefore non-ionizing, but its wavelengths
are preferentially absorbed by bases of DNA and by aromatic amino acids
of proteins, so it, too, has important biological and genetic effects. UV is
normally classified in terms of its wavelength: UV-C (180-290 nm) is
germicidal, most energetic and lethal. It is absorbed by the ozone layer. UV-
B (290-320 nm) is a major lethal/mutagenic fraction of sunlight. UV-A (320
nm—visible) has deleterious effects. The major lethal lesions are pyrimidine
dimers in DNA (produced by UV-B and UV-C). These are due to the
formation of a covalent bond between adjacent pyrimidines in one strand.
These dimmers block transcription and DNA replication and are lethal if
unrepaired. They can stimulate mutation and chromosome rearrangement
as well.
28
Mutation
2.6 DNA REPAIR SYSTEMS
DNA damage occurs spontaneously and as a result of certain environmental agents.
Most organisms have the ability to repair their DNA. The repair mechanisms are
given below.
Damage Reversal: They are simple and enzymatic action restores normal
structure without breaking the backbone.
Damage Removal: It involves cutting out and replacing a damaged or
inappropriate base or section of nucleotides.
Damage Tolerance: It is a a way of coping with damage so that life can go
on.
Let us now see some examples of each type of repair, the mechanisms, the
consequences of mutations in each, in both model organisms and in humans.
A) Damage Reversal
1) Photoreactivation
This is one of the simplest and perhaps oldest repair systems: it consists of
a single enzyme which can split pyrimidine dimers (break the covalent bond)
in presence of light. The photolyase enzyme catalyzes this reaction; it is
found in many bacteria, lower eukaryotes, insects, and plants. It seems to be
absent in mammals (including humans). The gene is present in mammals
but may code for a protein with an accessory function in another type of
repair.
B) Damage Removal
1) Base Excision Repair
The damaged or inappropriate base is removed from its sugar linkage and
replaced. These are glycosylase enzymes which cut the base-sugar bond.
For example: uracil glycosylase is an enzyme that removes uracil from DNA.
Uracil is not present in the DNA. It can occur when RNA primers are not
removed in DNA replication or if cytosine is deaminated. The enzyme
recognizes uracil and cuts the glyscosyl linkage to deoxyribose. The sugar
is then cleaved and a new base put in by DNA polymerase using the other
strand as a template. Mutants lacking uracil glycosylase have elevated
spontaneous mutation levels and are hyper-sensitive to killing and mutation
by nitrous acid.
29
Environmental Cytotoxicity 2) Mismatch Repair
and Genotoxicity
This process occurs after DNA replication as a last “spellcheck” on its
accuracy. In E. coli, it adds another 100-1000-fold accuracy to replication.
It is carried out by a group of proteins which can scan DNA and look for
incorrectly paired bases which will have aberrant dimensions in the double
helix. The incorrect nucleotide is removed as part of a short stretch and then
the DNA polymerase gets a second try to get the right sequence. In humans
mutations are found to be passed in the germline of families with some
types of inherited colon cancer.
“It was a very good year for DNA repair”, J. E. Cleaver, Cell 76: 1-4, 1994.
J. F. Crow, “How much do we know about spontaneous human mutation rates?”,
Environmental and Molecular Mutagenesis 21: 122-129, 1993
Mismatch repair, genetic stability, and cancer”, P. Modrich, Science 266: 1959-
1960, 1994.
31
Environmental Cytotoxicity “Molecule of the year: the DNA repair enzyme”, D. E. Koshland, Science 266: 1925,
and Genotoxicity
1994.
New colon cancer gene discovered”, J. Marx, Science 260: 751-752, 1993.
S. Buratowski, “DNA repair and transcription: the helicase connection”, Science 260:
37-38, 1993.
P. C. Hanawalt, “Transcription-coupled repair and human disease”, Science 266:
1957-1958, 1994.
32
Mutation
UNIT 3 TERATOGENESIS
Structure
3.0 Introduction
3.1 Objectives
3.2 Definition and Concepts
3.2.1 Definition
3.2.2 Principles in Teratology
3.2.3 Stage of Exposure to Teratogens
3.3 Sources of Teratogens and their Effects
3.4 Teratogenesis
3.4.1 Basic Principles in Teratogenesis
3.4.2 Mechanism of Action
3.5 Let Us Sum Up
3.6 Key Words
3.7 References and Suggested Further Readings
3.8 Answers to Check Your Progress
3.0 INTRODUCTION
We have learnt about toxicants and toxins in the previous units and how they
exert deleterious effects on the organs. Some toxic substances can penetrate the
placental barrier and bring about birth defects with malformations in the
developing embryo and foetus. They can cause mental retardation, paralysis of
the limbs, congenital heart defects, cleft palate, visual and auditory disturbances.
There have been numerous reports which have shown that the drug Thalidomide
used to treat morning sickness in women caused teratogeny and birth defects in
the children born to these women. Bhopal gas tragedy and endosulfan pesticide
poisoning induced teratogeny among the human population. Let us now learn
about teratogens, some concepts in teratogeny and their mechanism of action.
3.1 OBJECTIVES
After reading this unit, you should be able to:
define teratogens and teratogenesis;
understand the principles underlying teratogenic effects;
explain the various sources of teratogens and their effects; and
describe the mechanism of teratogenesis.
33
Environmental Cytotoxicity 3.2.1 Definitions
and Genotoxicity
Let us now learn about some definitions and terms commonly used in teratogeny.
a) Developmental toxicity: It is caused due to any morphological or functional
alteration caused by chemical or physical insult that interferes with normal
growth, homeostasis, development, differentiation, and/or behavior.
b) Teratology: It is a specialized area of embryology that focuses on the study
of the etiology of abnormal development. It is otherwise known as the study
of birth defects.
c) Teratogens: They are toxic agents, xenobiotics that cause malformations in
the developing foetus.
d) Malformation: This is referred to a primary structural defect resulting from
a localized error of morphogenesis.
e) Disruption: It is a particular abnormality that arises from disruption of normal
developmental processes. This is dependent on time and not on an agent.
f) Deformation: This refers to an alteration in shape or structure of previously
normally formed part.
g) Syndrome: It is a recognized pattern of malformations with a given etiology.
h) Congenital malformation: These are structural defects present at birth. They
may be gross or microscopic, on the surface of the body or within it, familiar
or sporadic, hereditary or nonhereditary, single or multiple. (Warkany, 1947)
1) Therapeutic Drugs
a) Thalidomide: This is a sedative drug that was used in Europe from
1957 to 1961. The drug was actually used for insomnia (sleeping
disorders), nausea, vomiting and morning sickness associated with
pregnancy. It was widely used by women in Europe, Australia, Asia,
Africa, and America. Later on it was observed that the women who had
consumed this drug in the first trimester gave birth to children who had
abnormalities. The birth defects were amelia (absence of limbs),
phocomelia (severe shortening of limbs), absence of the auricles,
35
Environmental Cytotoxicity deafness, muscular defects of eye and face, malformations of the heart, bowel,
and Genotoxicity
uterus, and the gallbladder. The effect was disastrous with more than 10,000
affects. So finally the compound was withdrawn from the market in 1961.
2) Alcohol
Women who consume alcohol during pregnancy give birth to children with
mental and physical retardation. The foetal alcohol syndrome is also observed
when the foetus is exposed to alcohol in utero. The most critical period for
this defect is the first trimester. The babies born have small body size, low
birth weight, craniofacial defects, psychomotor defects, microcephaly (small
head), scoliosis, small eye openings, and other neurological problems. They
may also have visceral defects associated with the heart and kidney. Learning
disabilities may also be present.
4) Physical Agents
Some physical agents induce teratogenecity. They include: ionizing
radiations, hyperthermia and so on. Ionizing radiation can harm the growing
embryo. It results in cellular death and injury to chromosomes. Some women
exposed to the radiations in the Hiroshima atomic bombing during 10 – 18 weeks
36
of gestation had children with brain defects. In the same way x-rays can also Teratogenesis
cause risk to the developing foetus.
5) Environmental Toxicants
Some environmental toxicants like organic mercury compounds,
polychlorinated biphenyl, agricultural herbicides and industrial solvents are
reported to cause teratogenic effects. People affected by consumption of
organic methyl mercury contaminated fishes in Japan had children born with
birth defects.
7) Drugs of Abuse
Drugs used for abuse are highly risky to the developing embryo.
a) Cocaine: Cocaine or benzoylmethylecgonine is a teratogen. It is an
alkaloid extracted from the plant Erythroxylum coca. Expsoure to this
drug causes gastrointestinal anomalies, cardiac problems, craniofacial
anomalies, tissue death due to disruption in blood supply to the
developing embryo. It can also cause limb anomalies.
c) Cannabis: This drug can cause low birth weight children and shorter
gestation periods.
8) Inhalants
They include industrial solvents, such as toluene; fuels; anesthetics; nitrous
oxide; and alkyl nitrites. Women may be exposed to these substances at the
industrial workplaces. Toluene causes preterm labor, intrauterine growth
retardation, microcephaly, craniofacial abnormalities, wide nasal bridge,
blunt fingertips and abnormal palmar creases.
These are some sources and effects of teratogens. You can see how much
damage they can do to the developing embryo. So during pregnancy utmost
care has to be taken by the mother and she should avoid drugs (both therapeutic
37
Environmental Cytotoxicity as well as of abuse) and non chemical agents. She should be careful about the
and Genotoxicity
food she eats, the water she drinks and the air she breathes as environmental
toxicants are also detrimental.
Check Your Progress 2
Note: a) Write your answer in about 50 words.
b) Check your progress with possible answers given at the end of the unit.
1) List the different sources of teratogens.
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
2) Describe the effects caused by therapeutic drugs.
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
3) Describe the effects caused by drugs of abuse and non chemical teratogens.
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
3.4 TERATOGENESIS
We have seen the sources of teratogens and the effects caused by them. They are
present even in the environment as toxicants. These can induce embryotoxicity.
Teratogenicity refers to the manifestation of developmental toxicity representing
a particular case of embryo/foetotoxicity by inducing structural disorders in the
foetus.
38
3.4.1 Basic Principles in Teratogenesis Teratogenesis
2) Extracellular Matrix
Teratogens can also affect the function of a tissue by interfering with the
production or maturation of this extracellular material.
3) Fetal Environment
Embryogenesis and foetal development is controlled by various factors. They
include maternal, placental and autogenous factors. They are the hormonal
factors, immune mechasisms and nutritional factors. Teratogens can cause
changes in the foetal environment even without crossing the placenta. These
agents can block the supply of nutrition or vital necessities to the growing
foetus. Thus they bring about birth anomalies.
40
Teratogenesis
3.6 KEY WORDS
Teratology : It is a specialized area of embryology that focuses on the
study of the etiology of abnormal development. It is
otherwise known as the study of birth defects.
Klaassen, C. D., ed. Casarett and Doull’s Toxicology: The Basic Science of
Poisons, 6th ed., New York: McGraw-Hill, 2001.
42
Answers to Check Your Progress 2 Teratogenesis
Drugs of Abuse
Drugs used for abuse are highly risky to the developing embryo.
Cannabis: This drug can cause low birth weight children and shorter
gestation periods.
44
Teratogenesis
UNIT 4 CYTOTOXICITY AND
GENOTOXICITY PREVENTION
Structure
4.0 Introduction
4.1 Objectives
4.2 Cytotoxicity (Tissue Culture)
4.2.1 Qualitative Cytotoxicity Tests
4.2.2 Quantitative Cytotoxicity - MTT Assay
4.3 Genotoxicity
4.3.1 Prevention of Genotoxicity
4.4 In Vitro Toxicology Testing
4.5 In Vivo Testing
4.6 Bioassays
4.6.1 Principles of Bioassay
4.6.2 Purposes of Bioassay
4.6.3 Types of Bioassays
4.7 Biomarkers
4.7.1 Use of Biomarkers in Oncology
4.7.2 Types of Biomarkers
4.7.3 Use of Biomarkers in Drug Discovery
4.7.4 Biomarkers at Various Organizational Levels
4.7.5 Challenges in Biomarker Research
4.8 Biosensors
4.8.1 Applications of Biosensors
4.8.2 Why Biosensors for Environmental Monitoring?
4.8.3 Biosensors for Environmental Monitoring
4.8.4 Endocrine-effect Biosensors
4.8.5 Biochemical Oxygen Demand
4.9 Microorganisms
4.10 Molecular Strategies
4.11 Fluorescence Strategies
4.12 Chemiluminescence Strategies
4.13 Analytical Strategies
4.14 Electrochemical Methods
4.15 Let Us Sum Up
4.16 Key Words
4.17 References and Suggested Further Readings
4.18 Answers to Check Your Progress 45
Environmental Cytotoxicity
and Genotoxicity 4.0 INTRODUCTION
In this unit we will discuss about the basic concepts surrounding cytotoxicity and
genotoxicty, how to access cytotoxic and genotoxic potential with the help of some
screening methods like in vitro and in vivo toxicology testing, bioassay, biomarkers,
biosensors, bacterial mutagenesis, gene mutation chromosome damage and DNA
damage and repair assays. The different screening methods have been discussed in an
elaborative manner explaining their purpose, principle, types, methods, advantages
and some of their limitations.
4.1 OBJECTIVES
After reading this unit you should be able to:
define cytotoxicity and genotoxicity
understand the basic concepts in cytotoxicity and genotoxicity, and
explain assessment of cytotoxic and genotoxic potential using toxicologytesting.
The Agar Diffusion assay is appropriate for high density materials, such as
elastomeric closures. In this method, a thin layer of nutrient-supplemented agar
is placed over the cultured cells. The test material (or an extract of the test material
dried on filter paper) is placed on top of the agar layer, and the cells are incubated.
A zone of malformed, degenerative or lysed cells under and around the test
material indicates cytotoxicity.
The MEM Elution assay uses different extracting media and extraction conditions
to test devices according to actual use conditions or to exaggerate those
conditions. Extracts can be titrated to yield a semi-quantitative measurement of
cytotoxicity. After preparation, the extracts are transferred onto a layer of cells
and incubated. Following incubation, the cells are examined microscopically
for malformation, degeneration and lysis of the cells. At least one type of
cytotoxicity test should be performed on each component of any device.
46
4.2.2 Quantitative Cytotoxicity - MTT Assay Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
Recent regulatory additions (ANSI/AAMI/ISO 10993-5:2009) on biocompatibility
for devices state that the qualitative cytotoxicity tests (direct contact, mem elution,
agar diffusion) are appropriate for screening purposes, but that quantitative evaluation
is preferable.
Annex C of ISO 10993-5:2009 refers to the MTT cytotoxicity assay, which can
accurately quantify as few as 950 cells. The MTT is a colorimetric method that
measures the reduction of yellow 3-(4, 5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)- 2,5-diphenyl
tetrazolium bromide by mitochondrial succinate dehydrogenase. Because the
cellular reduction is only catalyzed by living cells, it is possible to quantify the
percentage of living cells in a solution.
The MTT can be used to evaluate the cytotoxicity of:
Extractable materials of medical devices
Toxic compounds
Toxins and environmental pollutants
Potential anti-cancer drugs
Antibodies to examine growth inhibiting potential
The major advantages of the MTT are its quantitative ability, that it can be done
on either extracts or by direct contact, and that the results are not subject to
analyst interpretation. Additionally, the MTT can be performed on 96-well
microplates in a standard reader allowing for fast screening of multiple samples.
MTT assay does not discriminate a specific cellular death mechanism - such as
apopotosis vs. induced cell death. Additionally, it may underestimate cellular
damage and only detect death at the last stages of the cellular dying process.
4.3 GENOTOXICITY
Genotoxicity is a very broad term and it means a test material that can damage
DNA and can in fact affect the integrity of the genome such as a test material
affecting the spindle apparatus or DNA chimeras or DNA repair. In some cases
this genotoxic damage is repaired by our onset systems. However in some cases
genotoxic damage means permanent changes in the DNA which we know as
mutations and then some of these mutations can lead to cancer to occur. Genotoxic
damage can be of multiple different types. It can affect the DNA directly or
indirectly. There are single and double stranded breaks in the DNA which can
lead to mutations and inversions of the chromosomes.
Cross linking of nucleotides can occur which results in DNA replication being
locked. In addition, DNA damage can lead to cancerous events such as in silent
(synonymous) mutation. Here C gets replaced by T but that doesn’t replace the
amino acid being translated. But nothing occurs in terms of mutation because of
protein. Missense (substitution), nonsense (termination) and frame shift do affect
the protein translation. Missense affects one amino acid base pair, nonsense
(termination) creates a STOP codon and that don’t keeps the protein so the protein
will not have the same function as it was previously before the mutation. A
frame shift point mutation adds a nucleotide and this has many downstream
effects on the protein translation so the protein would be severely affected with
frame shift mutation. 47
Environmental Cytotoxicity Cells in our cases can repair these types of damages but they are not 100% effective
and Genotoxicity
and when DNA damage becomes permanent it is a mutation. Damage occurring
from genotoxic events can be on the chromosomal level or aneuploidal level so
that is the gain or addition of chromosomes. Not all genotoxic substances are
mutagenic and not all mutagenic substances are carcinogenic. However if the
test material is genotoxic or mutagenic, there is a greater chance that it will be a
carcinogenic test material. Most regulatory agencies require mutagenicity testing.
They have their preferred methodology to access genotoxicity and mutagenicity.
4.6 BIOASSAYS
The goal of ecotoxicity is to understand how is to understand how chemicals
produce a damage in some organisms, in some organisms, which organisms will
be which organisms will be affected, and how this affected, and how this affects
the whole receptor environment the whole receptor environment Toxicity can be
defined as the degree to which a Toxicity can be defined as the degree to which
a chemical substance elicits a deleterious or adverse chemical substance elicits a
50
deleterious or adverse effect upon the biological system of an organism stem of an Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
organism exposed to the substance over a designated time exposed to the substance
over a designated time period Aquatic toxicity, genotoxicity and estrogenicity are
different expressions of toxicity.
Bioassays are procedures that can determine the concentration or purity or biological
activityof a substance such as vitamin, human or plant growth by measuring the effect
on organisms, tissue, cells, enzyme or receptor.
Bioassays may be qualitative and quantitative. Qualitative bioassays can be used for
accessing the physical effects of a substance that may not be quantified such as seeds
fail to germinate or develop up normally. One such famous example is on castrated
chickens. This analysis found that by removing the testicles of a chicken, it would not
develop into a rooster because the endocrine signals necessary for this process were
not available.
51
Environmental Cytotoxicity Bioassays can be performed in-vivo as well as in-vitro. In-vivo involves working on
and Genotoxicity
the intact animal whereas in-vitro involves experiment on an isolated tissue.
The standard drug is added at fixed intervals but alternating with the test so
that each response produced by a dose of test substance is bracketed by
responses produced by the dose of standard. The response of test substance
is bracketed between two responses of the standard. Close bracketing gives
more accurate results.
5) Three Point Bioassay- In three point bioassay, the DRC of standard & test
samples is first obtained from the responses due to graded doses. From the
DRC of standard, two standard doses are selected in such a way that they
have produced 25% & 50% of the maximal response respectively & are
designated as S1 & S2. The responses of these doses lie on the steepest &
straightest part (linear) of the curve. From the DRC of test sample one test
is selected such that it gives a response which lies in between the two standard
52
responses that is it gives a greater response than S1 & a smaller response than Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
S2 & is designated as T.
After selecting the standard & test doses, the bioassay is performed by recording
the standard & test responses in randomized fashion as per Latin square design.
The pattern of addition of doses is S1, S2, T; S2, T, S1 & T, S1, S2 in 3
successive cycles. The mean values of height of contraction for all the 3 doses
are calculated and are used in plotting the graph so as to estimate the potency of
the test sample.
The precision and reliability of this method is much better than matching and
bracketing methods of bioassay& the sensitivityof the isolated tissue preparation
is assessed prior to testing the unknown sample.
Advantages: Quick and with more precision than a matching assay. There is a
possibilityof usingcertainstatisticalprocedures althoughnotwith muchconfidence.
6) Four Point Bioassay- The classic 2X2 parallel assay involves being able to
measure parallelism where drugs acting through the same mechanism are
expected to produce parallel dose-response curves.
7) Seed Bioassay- Seeds are living organisms that may be harmed by chemicals.
The seed bioassay technology has been implied as decisive and lab scale
and method to assess the toxicity of any substance on profitable crops.
Historically many of the new antibiotics were isolated from natural sources
like soil microbes and plants. Many more were later synthesized and
introduced in clinical practices. Unfortunately human struggle against
pathogenic microbes is far from over due to many reasons. Most important
of them time to time discovery of new pathogens and remarkable abilities
of microbes to develop resistance against used antibiotic. The discovery
and development of new antimicrobial agent is therefore an ongoing process.
Remarkable diversity of chemicals present in biological samples has
tremendous potential in search of new antimicrobial agents.
53
Environmental Cytotoxicity 9) Antifungal Assay- Fungal infections have been reported to have dramatically
and Genotoxicity
increased in the past decade, and these often occur as systemic infections or
as co-infections with other diseases, such as AIDS or cancer, or in patients
who are immuno-compromised. There is considerable need to discover new
fungi-toxic compounds in view of the many plant and human fungal diseases.
Some of the common plant fungal diseases are potato late blight, tobacco
blue mould, hop downy mildew, Dutch elm disease, ergot of rye, cereal
rusts, corn blight and grape downy mildew. The human fungal diseases
include athlete’s foot, Aspergillosis, Actinomycosis, Histoplasmosis and
Corcidiomycosis. The rapid increase in fungal infections and the growing
number of new antifungal agents indicate an increasing need for rapid and
accurate methods for antifungal screening and susceptibility testing.
Some fungi can be beneficial to man since they attack harmful insects. The
two main methods includes
1) Cylinder Plate Method
2) Paper-disc Method
10) Antimitotic Assay- Antimitotic agents are defined as any applied stimulus
which produces a consistent change/deviation in the mitotic cycle. Inhibition
of cell division is a measure of the antimitotic activity of chemical
compounds. Antimitotic chemical compounds such as vinblastine and
podophyllotoxin have been shown to inhibit cell division of fertilized sea
urchin eggs and starfish oocytes. Normally the reaction should be reversible
with time, removal of stimulus or on the addition of an antagonist.
54
An ideal bioassay should be: Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
Reliable and reproducible; Economical of time and resources;Able to yield statistically
robust data; Relevant, practicable and readily understood by the layman; Able to
utilize test organisms froma reliable stock; Simple to emulate; Regularlyintercalibrated;
With a clearly defined end-point; Sensitive to a wide range of pollutants.
Check Your Progress 2
Note: a) Write your answer in about 50 words.
b) Check your progress with possible answers given at the end of the
unit.
1) Write short notes on Types of Bioassays.
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................
4.7 BIOMARKERS
Definition
A biomarker is anything that can be measured as an indicator of biological process.
A biological process is something that can be normally happening in the body or
during the development of a disease or in our spines to a particular medicine in
a patient undergoing treatment.
4.7.1 Use of Biomarkers in Oncology
In oncology, biomarkers are used to provide information about a person’s risk of
developing cancer and to determine the prognosis once the cancer is diagnosed
and in some cases to predict how some patients may respond to particular
medications. For eg. Mutations in the so called PRCA genes are known to increase
a women’s risk of hereditary breast or ovarian cancer.
55
Environmental Cytotoxicity 4.7.2 Types of Biomarkers
and Genotoxicity
There are many different types of biomarkers which include things that are simple to
measure such as high blood pressure as an indicator of increased risk of stroke to
more complex genetic changes or mutations in the genes of tumour cells that can help
to identify a patient’s particular type of cancer.
In relation to the treatment of cancer, biomarkers fall into two main classes:
Finding new biomarkers can be of great value in our efforts to determine which
pathways are important to target with new investigation or agents. For eg. work
on the Hedgehog signaling pathway has revealed that this pathway is activated
in basal cell carcinoma, a type of skin cancer.
56 5) Behavioural
4.7.5 Challenges in Biomarker Research Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
Most cancers have common characteristics. There is no “one size fit all” solution
to biomarker discovery. Each drug and disease is different and unique. In order
to determine which patients should or should not receive a particular treatment,
biomarkers must be rigorously tested and validated in clinical studies. In a typically
sized clinical trial, it is easier to see statistically significant differences and how
a drug works in patients who do respond well compared to those who do not
respond there at all. However, for medicines that work well across different
patient’s subtypes, a much larger number of patients are required to reveal a
statistically significant finding if one even exists.
Currently there are no standard criteria’s to establish to identify those who should
be tested for PRCA mutations and additional studies are underway to determine
how the better use of these biomarkers can be done to access the risk for
developing these cancers. As always it is important to exercise caution when
interpreting research as applied to cancer treatment.
Despite the various challenges associated with discovering biomarkers and testing
their utility regarding clinical studies, biomarkers are currently a critical
component of cancer research. They are more important if they help us to improve
the care that the patients receive. Biomarkers possess the potential to develop
new medicines for cancer patients. The goal should be to match those patients
with the best possible treatments for their specific cancer.
4.8 BIOSENSORS
A biosensor is defined by IUPAC as a self-contained integrated device that is
capable of providing specific quantitative or semi quantitative analytical
information using a biological recognition element (biochemical receptor), which
is retained in direct spatial contact with a transduction element.
57
Environmental Cytotoxicity Monitoring glucose level in diabetes patients
and Genotoxicity
Food analysis
Environmental applications
Protein engineering and drug discoveryapplications
Wastewater treatment
The need for disposable systems or tools for environmental monitoring has encouraged
the development of new technologies and more suitable methodologies, the ability to
monitor the increasing number of analytes of environmental relevance as quickly and
as cheaplyas possible, and even the possibilityof allowing on-site field monitoring. In
this respect, biosensors have demonstrated a great potential in recent years and thus
arise as proposed analytical tools for effective monitoring in these programs.
BOD biosensor systems still present a series of limitations that restrict their
applications: the lack of standardisation and legislation in most countries,
complicated maintenance requirements, and insufficient resistance to various
toxic compounds.
Other BOD biosensors recently reported are those based on the photocatalysis of
the sample and on a novel microbial membrane.
4.9 MICROORGANISMS
DNA biosensors can be more specific than immunologically based detection
59
Environmental Cytotoxicity systems, and the sensitivity can be improved by combination with polymerase chain
and Genotoxicity
reaction (PCR) methods. Gene probes are alreadyfinding application in the detection
of disease-causing microorganisms in water supplies, food, or in plants, animal or
human tissues.
Organic Compounds
Pesticides
Concern about toxicity, ubiquityand persistence of pesticides in the environment
has led the European Community to set limits on the concentration of pesticides
in different environmental waters. Enzymatic sensors, based on the inhibition of a
selected enzyme are the most extensively used biosensors for the determination
of these compounds. Based on the inhibition of acetyl cholinesterase (AChE)
and colin oxidase, various biosensors have been developed for the detection of
organophosphorous and carbamate pesticides. Diazinon and dichlorvos have
been detected at limits around 5 and 75 ìM, respectively, using a tyrosinase-
based oxygen sensor.
Hormones
Estrone, progesterone and testosterone, along with other organic pollutants,
have been determined with a fully automated optical immunosensor in water
samples, reaching limits of detection up to sub-ng/L.
Dioxins
Dioxins are polychlorinated compounds released as by products in a number
of chemical processes involving chlorine. They are considered carcinogenic
and a potential threat to human health. The DRESSA biosensor based on
the binding of the dioxins to an aryl hydrocarbon receptor has been developed
in hepatome cells. The SPR biosensor for the determination of PCBs was
also employed in the determination of the dioxin 2,3,7,8- TCDD.
60
Phenols Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
Phenolic compounds, and especially chlorophenols, are significant
environmental pollutants because of their high toxicity and possible
accumulation in the environment. Chlorophenols have been detected with a flow-
injection chemiluminescence fibre-optic biosensor.
Bisphenol A
Bisphenol A is a typical product of industrial societies produced in large
quantities worldwide. Although only weakly estrogenic, the determination
of bisphenol A in the environment is very important due to its extensive use
and environmental ubiquity. However, the first biosensors focused on
bisphenol A determination have only recently appeared. Some examples
are immunosensors based on bacterial magnetic particles, on surface plasmon
resonance and on total internal reflection fluorescence. Based on a tyrosinase-
carbon paste electrode, an optical biosensor for phenolic EDCs, including
bisphenol A, nonylphenol and diethylstilbestrol, has also been reported.
Surfactants
An amperometric biosensor for detection of anionic surfactants was
constructed with Pseudomonas rathonis T (bearing a plasmid for surfactant
degradation) as the biological element. The limit of detection achieved for
sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) was 0.25–0.75 mg/L.
Alkylphenol Ethoxylates
Alkylphenol ethoxylates (APEs) belong to the group of non-ionic surfactants
whose detection has become more important due to their endocrine-
disrupting properties. In wastewater treatment processes and in the
environment, APEs degrade to alkylphenols (APs), which tend to be more
toxic and show greater estrogenic activity. An amperometric immunosensor
based on a carbon screen-printed electrode has been developed recently for
the determination of nonylphenol with a detection limit of 10 ìg/L.
Antibiotics
Medical substances have been released into the environment with very little
attention so far. The presence of antibiotics in the environment is worrying
since they promote antibiotic resistance. The commercial biosensor
BIACORE 3000 was used to study the cross reactivity between two
sulphonamides: sulfamethazine and furosemide.
Toxins
A great number of specific sensors for bacterial toxins and mycotoxins have
been developed for food and environmental control. A light-addressable
potentiometric immunosensor based on the commercial device (Threshold)
is developed for the analysis of saxitoxin and ricin. A portable fibre-optic
biosensor and an impedance-based immunosensor have been prepared to
determine staphylococcal enterotoxin B.
Inorganic Phosphate
Inorganic phosphate in surface waters can be used as a measure of
eutrophication status of different water bodies, such as surface and sea waters.
Various enzymatic biosensors for phosphate determination have appeared
in the literature in recent years.
Nitrate
Urban wastewater treatment regulations aim at reducing pollution, including
nitrate pollution, from sewage treatment works and industry. A biosensor
containing immobilized denitrifying bacteria was applied to the
62
determination of NO3 in tap water. Through the reduction of NO3 in a reaction Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
chamber, N2O was formed and determined by a N2O microelectrode, which
was the sensing element of the biosensor. A whole-cell fluorescence biosensor
based on recombinant Escherichia coli allowed the determination of nitrate without
the interference of phosphate, chloride and nitrite. A conductimetric biosensor
for nitrate was developed using nitrate reductase immobilized on a thin film
electrode, reaching detection limits of 5 ìM.
Despite the huge number of biosensors developed so far, there is still a lack of
biosensing systems for an important group of emerging contaminants such as
phtalates and polybrominated compounds (used as flame retardants), veterinary
and human medicines and personal care products (pharmaceuticals, synthetic
fragrances, sunscreen agents). However, as the world becomes more concerned
about the impact that environmental contamination may have on public health
and ecosystems, the demand for rapid-detection biosensors will only increase,
and new applications of biosensor systems based on new technologies or targeting
new emerging contaminants are appearing constantly.
Biosensors
Main Advantages
Rapid and continuous measurement
High specificity
Very less usage of reagents required for calibration
Cost effective
Fast response time
Ability to measure non-polar molecules that cannot be estimated by
other conventional devices
Biosensor Limitation
Heat sterilization is not possible because of denaturation of biological
material
Stability of biological material (such as enzyme, cell, antibody, tissue, etc.),
depends on the natural properties of the molecule that can be denaturalized
under environmental conditions (pH, temperature or ions)
The cells in the biosensor can become intoxicated by other molecules that
are capable of diffusing through the membrane
Bacterial Mutagenesis Assays
Bacterial mutagenicity tests, specifically the Salmonella and E. coli reverse
mutation (Ames) test, are widely used and are usually required before a chemical,
drug, pesticide, or food additive can be registered for use. The tests are also
widely used for environmental monitoring to detect mutagens in air or water.
Their use is based on the showing that a positive result in the test was highlypredictive
for carcinogenesis.
TheAmes test is a widely employed method that uses bacteria to test whether a given
chemical can cause mutations in the DNAof the test organism. More formally, it is a
biological assay to access the mutagenic potential of chemical compounds.Apositive
test indicates that the chemical is mutagenic and therefore may act as a carcinogen
63
Environmental Cytotoxicity because cancer is often linked to mutation. The test serves as a quick and convenient
and Genotoxicity
assay to estimate the carcinogenic potential of a compound because standard
carcinogenic assays on mice and rats are time consuming and expensive. In this process,
a pathogenic mutant strain of Salmonella i.e. Salmonella typhimurium is used in which
Histidine has been mutated so also known as His- strain. These types of strain do not
have the ability to produce Hystidine amino acid on their own. Histidine deficient
media is taken for the strain growth and the chemical agent to be tested for
carcinogenicityis poured on the media alongwithSalmonella typhimuriumHis deficient
strain. Most of the chemical agents become more mutagenic when they are processed
in the liver so as to check the mutagenic effect of chemical agents on liver, liver extract
from mice is also added into the plate along with media. The culture plate is then
streaked and is kept at 37°C for 2 days. If the chemical agent is mutagenic, it can turn
the Hystidine gene into its active position which is His+. Now the bacteria are capable
of producing its own Histidine and they can grow easily in the plate. If the chemical
agent is not mutagenic, it will not convert the His- gene into His+ gene.
The disadvantage of this test is false positive results which can occur due to spontaneous
mutation. This can cause His- to change into His+ which will give a false impression
that the induced chemical agent is mutagenic. The way to differentiate between
spontaneous and chemical agent mutation is by checking the formation of colonies in
both the cases. In case of spontaneous mutation, the colonies are wide apart from
each other i.e. scattered which conveys that no mutation is involved in such a case
while in case of mutagenicitydue to chemical agent, the colonies thus formed are well
aggregated. If the plate does not show anycolonyand is clear it shows that the chemical
agent is not mutagenic.
The capacity of the different assays to detect relevant genetic changes, and specially
those associated with the risk of cancer, is controversial. Gene mutations and
chromosome damage are considered more relevant than primary DNA damage, and
it is generally accepted that only gene mutation and chromosome damage assays can
establish a genotoxic mode of action.
For ethical reasons, animal testing of the latter products is mainly recommended (i) if
in vitro genetic toxicity tests are positive, or (2) in case of “high” or “moderate and
sustained” human exposure, or (3) when large amounts of the product are to be released
on the market and, potentially, in the environment. In this regulatory context, in vivo
genetic toxicity assays contribute to genotoxic hazard identification and to human risk
assessment, bypredicting carcinogenic activity and inheritable genetic changes.
One or more in vivo genetic toxicology assays maybe necessary when positive results
are obtained in vitro, in order to increase the weight of evidence and to better evaluate
the human risk. A major advantage of in vivo genetic toxicology assays over in vitro
tests is that they take into account not only intrinsic genotoxic potential, but also
toxicokinetic parameters such as bioavailability, absorption, tissue distribution,
metabolism (activation, detoxification, and excretion), and other factors that onlyexist
in vivo. Individually, theyare generallyconsidered less sensitive (more false-negatives)
but more specific (fewer false-positives) than in vitro assays. They are also thought to
be more relevant to human exposure, being less prone to experimental artifacts,
confounding factors, and irrelevant results. Consequently, a positive result in an in vivo
genetic toxicology assays are helpful for understanding and interpreting the results of
carcinogenicitystudies.
In the case of genotoxic carcinogens, gene mutations and chromosome damage are
generallynecessarybut not sufficient for carcinogenesis, because additional keyevents
such as cell proliferation are required for tumour formation. In other words, most
genotoxic compounds are carcinogens, especially those showing genotoxicityactivity
in vivo, but not all carcinogens exhibit genotoxic activity: some have other mechanisms
of action (e.g. hormone imbalance, enzymatic induction, cell proliferation, andinhibition
of apoptosis).
For example, effects on components of the mitotic apparatus are responsible for
chromosome gain or loss (aneuploidy) as a result of mechanisms such as improper
attachment of chromosomes to the mitotic spindle, failed cytokinesis and an
abnormal number of mitotic spindle poles. In this case, the primary target is
generally not DNA but instead multiprotein complexes involved in chromosome
65
Environmental Cytotoxicity segregation. Thus, a no-effect level can be determined and a safety margin can be
and Genotoxicity
estimated compared with actual human exposure. Consequently, understanding the
mode of action is essential for risk assessment.
Numerous in vivo genotoxicity assays have been developed for research purposes.
The duration of treatment and the dose levels are the most important factors to
be considered because the doses evaluated during long-term treatment are
frequently lower because of more pronounced toxicity. When DNA lesions,
mutations, and damaged cells do not accumulate over time (because of efficient damage
repair or elimination of damaged cells by apoptosis or cell turnover), longer treatment
might result in lower sensitivity. When DNAlesions accumulate over time and damaged
cells are not eliminated (e.g., transgenic gene mutation assays in slowly proliferating
tissues), multiple administrations mayimprove assaysensitivity.
In vivo genetic toxicity end points can be evaluated after multiple administrations in
other toxicology studies- for example, 14 or 28 day general toxicity studies. After
more than 28 days (e.g., 3-month studies), confounding effects such as oxidative
stress, enzymatic induction, and preneoplastic lesions might be expected, leading to
the measurement of secondary rather than primary effects on DNA. Genotoxicity
findings obtained after long-termexposure should therefore be interpreted with caution.
DNA lesions and the repair mechanisms that maintain the integrity of genomic
DNA are important in preventing carcinogenesis and its progression. Notably,
mutations in DNA repair mechanisms are associated with cancer predisposition
syndromes.Additionally, these mechanisms maintain the genomic integrity of cancer
cells. The majority of therapies established to treat cancer are genotoxic agents that
induce DNA damage, promoting cancer cells to undergo apoptotic death. Effective
methods currently exist to evaluate the diverse effects of genotoxic agents and the
underlying molecular mechanisms that repair DNA lesions.
There are a number of strategies that allow the investigation of these underlying
mechanisms and highlight their importance. These techniques may be separated
into two perspectives: Techniques for detecting DNA damage and techniques
for evaluating the underlying repair mechanisms.
The comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis) is a simple method for measuring
deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) strand breaks in eukaryotic cells. Cells embedded in
66
agarose on a microscope slide are lysed with detergent and high salt to form nucleoids Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
containing supercoiled loops of DNA linked to the nuclear matrix. Electrophoresis at
high pH results in structures resembling comets, observed byfluorescence microscopy;
the intensity of the comet tail relative to the head reflects the number of DNA breaks.
The likely basis for this is that loops containing a break lose their supercoiling and
become free to extend toward the anode.
The assay has applications in testing novel chemicals for genotoxicity, monitoring
environmental contamination with genotoxins, human biomonitoring and molecular
epidemiology, and fundamental research in DNA damage and repair. The sensitivity
and specificity of the assay are greatly enhanced if the nucleoids are incubated with
bacterial repair endonucleases that recognize specific kinds of damage in the DNA
and convert lesions to DNA breaks, increasing the amount of DNA in the comet tail.
DNA repair can be monitored byincubating cells after treatment with damaging agent
and measuring the damage remaining at intervals.Alternatively, the repair activity in a
cell extract can be measured byincubating it with nucleoids containing specific damage.
This technique identifies the head of the comet as a spherical mass of undamaged
DNA, and the damaged DNA (DNA loops around strand breaks) streams out
from the head as a tail. In the most frequently performed type of comet assay,
cells are embedded in agarose to immobilize the DNA and a lysis process is
performed usinga detergent and high salt. The comet assayhas a limited resolution
of 10-800 kb using standard conditions. Other variants of the comet assay are
also used to assess DNA damage and its detection.
Alkaline Single Cell Gel Electrophoresis: This version of the comet assay
uses alkaline denaturation surrounding a DNA break to reveal the break
(single or double). This method enhances comet tails and extends the range
of DNA damage that is detected, but sensitivity has not been increased
compared to the use of lesion specific enzymes.
4.13 ANALYTICALSTRATEGIES
High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) Electro SprayTandem
Mass Spectrometry (MS): Oxidative stress and absorption of UV light by
nucleic acids has been established to be one of the causes of oxidative DNA
damage, which may promote cancer development. It is also possible to detect
tandemDNA lesions as dinucleoside monophosphates, and in addition to detecting
the type of DNA damage, HPLC-MS mayalso provide information on the location
and quantity of DNAdamage. Despite the advantage of accuracy, this assay has
the limitations of a high cost and the large amount of experience that is required
to accuratelyuse the technique to monitor the formation of low levels of oxidized
bases within cellular DNA. However, it remains the method of choice for
measuring modified DNA bases.
The electrochemical method, electrocatalysis, has provided the basis for novel assays
to detect low levels of lesions and possible for use as an earlydiagnostic tool.Although
70 this is a method that provides sensitive, selective and low cost detection of DNA
damage, it has the limitation of not being able to recognize thymidine dimer lesions Cytotoxicity and Genotoxicity
Prevention
until they are connected with the distortion of DNA double helix.
The importance of the study of DNA damages and how damage may be restored
requires further study, as it has clinical implications in multifactorial diseases,
including cancer and diabetes. There are a number of methods available for the
detection, analysis and quantification of DNA lesions and it is important to identify
the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. The combination of these
methodologies may provide an overview of DNA lesion analysis and other
complementary information.
https://www.azosensors.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=402
71
Environmental Cytotoxicity https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/f661/70f74da25527ba8ea91319b
and Genotoxicity
98913738f4a72.pdf
https://people.ifm.liu.se/frewi/Agora/Environmental%20biosensors.pdf
http://www.profpdhansen.de/Biosensors%20and%20Ecotoxicology%20-
%20Final.pdf
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-19018-1_4
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15004294
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5452911/pdf/ol-13-06-3982.pdf
73