Professional Documents
Culture Documents
64-0726e صهاريج مشققة Vgr-Ara
64-0726e صهاريج مشققة Vgr-Ara
O
ƱDZ# !Ǹƾǯǫ' 'džǴ ǰǜ + QDžǁƷ# ƶNjǫ Q D QǶǁƸƷ *'HƱǯNjǫ'
ƱDZ#!ؼƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǪǨH Q FHLJƷ
AƱǗƸǃƭǫ' ǰǜ + QDžǁƷ#
!ƱǯNJ# ƵƺƱǬƺ ƶǁƷ ǷƷ# DžǦǫ !Ǹƾǯǫ' ǰǮ Ǫǀ'LJǮ ƵƺƱǬƺ džǣDz Q Oǹ AǶNJ dzDZQ s FHLJƷ# ad
Q
dzNjǣDZ ƿǺNjǯǫ' ǶǴ ǧǫ0 ǪǨ ǸǢ FHLJƷ# 3Džǥ -H1 ǰƳs (" +ǶǫƱƻƳ M ǷƷ# DžǦǫ ǰƳȫǬǫ
ƵǯǝDZ DƱǯǜ#
P Q
ƵƺƱǬƺ !'LJƽǿ ǸƷƫǹ AǶNJ dzDZƫƳ ǭǬǝDZ ǰǁDZ Fƪǫ'H ƶǥǶǫ' D'Ƕǖ dzNjǣDZ dzǫƭǫ'
O
ƵƺƱǬƺ ǸǢ ǪǯƸǩǹ Q ǸǢ ƱǮ ǪǩǢ
dzǬǫ' Q 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ'
Q Ƶ Qǹ/ǶǯǝǮH ljǹDžǦƷ LJǹLJƴƷ
džǃƫǺǫ AƱǗƸǃƱǫ' ǸǢ ƵǺDZƱƺK ǸƷƫǹ AǶNJH dzNJHLJǜ !'Džǣǫ ƱǫK H#
Q !Ʊƽ F0s ǶǵǢ ae
C'0 ǸǢ džƯDžǝƳH
M ƵǩǬǯǫ'H ǧǬǯǫ' dzNJHLJǜ ƵǦǢLJƳ ƵƻǫƱƺ )K LJǮQ ǸƷƫǹ ǭƺ ȥ ǰǮH dzNJHLJǜ
)/Ƕǝǫ' GdžǴ 1ƱǚƸDZƱƳ FǶDZǶǩǹ AǶNJ LJǎƴǫ' ǰǮ LJǺƴǨL L/Džǜ ƶǥǶǫ'
K
ǰǹLJǚƸDzǯǫ' IǶNJ ƱƴǹLJǦƷ Džǀ#
M ǰǮ ƱǮ /Ƕǝǹ ƱǮDžDzǜ )LJǯǫ'
Q GdžǴ ǸǢ ǰǩǫH
5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' ǰǮ /Džǜ ǧǫƱDzǴ FǶǩǹ AǶNJH dzưǺƾǮ DžǜǶǮ ǭǬǝǹ AǶNJ ǰǹ QDžǝƸNjǯǫ'H
Q 'ǶǣǗP OƸǃ' DžǦǫ ǭǴLJǺǑǮ ALJN ʹǝ Oǹ ǰǫH FH/ǶǦǣǮ ǭǵDZQ # ǷǬǜ FǶDzNǬǝ Oǹ AǶNJ ǰǹdžǫ'Q
ǪǩƳ
ǸǢ Ƶǚǁǫ ǸǢ FHLJǺǠƸǹ Q ـ1ƱǚDZƫǫ' ǰǜ FǶǣƸDŽǹ AǶNJ 'džǩǴH Ƶǚǁǫ ǸǢ ƵǖƱNjƳ
K
DžǦǣ Oǹ F# ƱƴǺǴ1 K
'LJǮ# FǶǩǹ AǶNJ + NDžǁǫ' N 'džǵǫ ǰǹ QDžǝƸNjǮ 'ǶDZǶǨ 'džǫ ـǰǺǜ ƵǢLJǖ
KƱǣNJƬǮ ljǺǫ# dzǺǬǜ 1Ƕƻǝǫ' ǰǮ LDžǀ# ǰQǩǯƸǹ Ʊǫ#H Q !'LjQ ǜƫǫ'
P /'LJǢƫǫ' Džǀ# -Ʊƴǐ *'0
ǸǢ 1'LJǯƸNJƱƳ
M F0s 'ǶǦƳ# ǭǩƷƱǢ Džǥ dz Q
DZ ƫƳH ǭǩDzǜ LJƴǜ Džǥ +Džǁǫ' 'džǴ QFƫƳ 'ǶǨ1DžƷO F#
Q LJǔǁǮ
dzǬǫ'
9ǶƴNJƫǫ' ǰǮ ǰǺDzƺǿ' EǶǹ E/ƱǦǫ' ǰǺDzƺǿ' (LJǫ'Q /'1# '0s E/ƱǦǫ' 9ǶƴNJƫǫ' ǸǢ Fƪǫ' af
K
FǶƴǴdžǺNJ ƹǺǀ ƱDZHLjǹ1# Ƿǫ' '/ QDžƾǮ ƵǬƯƱǝǫ' ƲǁǗǐ# AǶNJ (LJǫ' Q ƵưǺǎǯƳ E/ƱǦǫ'
/Ƕǜ## džƯDžǝƳH
M ƵNJ1Džǯǫ' Ƿǫ'
K
ƱƴǹLJǦƷ Džƽ'ǶƷ# Ʊǫ CƱDzǴ *ƱǜƱǯƸƽs Ƶ Qǹ# DžǦǜ# Ʊǫ ƱDZƫǢؼCƱDzǴ ,LJǃ# Ʊǫ ǸQDzDZ# LJǺǟ ag
AǶNJ ǪƴǦǯǫ' ǰǺDzƺǿ' 1ƱǵDZ LJǃ" FƱǩǮ Ƿǫ' ƲǴ0# AǶNJ ƱDZƫǢ ƱDZHLjǹ1# ǸǢ 'DžƳ# K
M
ƱǺƴǮǶǫǶǨ Ƿǫ' džƯDžǝƳ
M 1/Ʊǟ# AǶNJ ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' /Ƕǜ# ǭȥ ƺN ǰǮH CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ǸƸƽH2 ƲǁǗǐ#
K
ǸǢ '/ QDžƾǮ FǶǨ# AǶNJ /ƱǬǺǯǫ' DžǺǜ ǪǺƴǥH H/'1ǶǫǶǨ Ƿǫ' /Ƕǜ# ƱǴDžǝƳH ƵǺDZƱǗǹLJƴǫ'Q
/Ƕǜ#H ƵǬƯƱǝǫ' Ǜǯƽƫǫ ƵƺƱǬƺ H# ǰǺǮǶǹ ƱǯƳ1ؼǪƽ# ǰǮ ǕǦǢ *Ʊǚǁǫ Ǜǔƴǫ ƱDZHLjǹ1#
DƱǬǃ ƱDzǴ *ƱǜƱǯƸƽ'
M N
ƵǬNjǬNJ ǭǺǥ#H (LJǫ'Q !ƱǍ '0' ƱDzǴ /ƱǬǺǯǫ' ƵǬǗǜ ǸǔǮ# Ǹǩǫ
DžǹDžƾǫ' EƱǝǫ' 9ǶƴNJ#
FǶǨ# ƱǯǮ LJƻǨ# *'LJǮ Q LJǎǜ ƱDzǴ /ǶƽǶǮ ǸDZQ ƱǢ LJƻǨ# ƱDzǴ Džƽ'ǶƷ# ƱK ǺǬǯǜ
Q ƱDZƫǢ 'džǫ ah
ƱǯǺǢ CƱDzǴ !ǸǍ J# ƱDzǹDžǫ ljǺǫ CƱDzǴ *ƱǜƱǯƸƽs ƱǫH ljƯƱDzǨ ƱDzǹDžǫ ljǺǫ 0s CƱDzǴ
ǪNJ1# F# ǛǺǗƸNJ# FƱǩǮ J# K
Q DžƽǶǹ Ʊǫ ƱǮ ƱǜǶDZ !ǸNJ
L !ǸǍ
L 'džǴH ƵNjǺDzǩǫ' ƵǮDžǃ Ǐǃ Q
LJǦƸǣDZ ƱǮ 'džǴHH ƱDzǴ ǭǨ/ƱǫH# ƱǵǝǯNjǹ ƱǮ ǶǁDZ P ǷǬǜ ǪƯƱNJ LJǫ'
Q GdžǴ 9ƱǯNjǫ dzǺǫ' ǸǫƱǣǖ#
ljǦǖ 1ƱǀQ AƱƽ ljǦǗǫ' Q QFs )DžǺƽQ ƵǁǑƳ Q FǶǝ QƸǯƸǹ ǭǵǝǺǯƽ ǰǩǫH CƱDzǴ dzǺǫ'
CƱDzǴ ǷǦƳ# ǰǫ ǸDZQ ȫǢ ƱDZ# ǸƸǵƽ ǰǮ )DžǺƽ Q Ƶ M ǁǑƳ
Q FHDžƴǹ ǭǵǝǺǯƽ DƱǣǖƫǫ' ƱǯDZQ ' AƱƽ
Q
ƵǨLJǀ ǸǢ ǸDzDZ'ؽǸDzDZ' ǸǁǐQ Q LJǺǟ E# ƱǺǁǐ K Q FƱǨ '0s ƱǮ ǭǬǜ# Ǹǩǫ ƵǺǢƱǩǫ' ) QDžǯǫ'
K LJǎƸǮ
'/ Q *O ʹDžPǫ OH Džǥ ǸDzDZQ ƫƳ DžǦƸǜ# ƱDZ# ƱDZ# ƱDZ' )LJǯƸNjǮ
Q
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' d
9ƱǯƸƽƱǫ' DžǝƳ ƱǵDzǮ ǛǯNJ#H /Ƕǜ# AǶNjǢ ƱDzǴ ƱǵDZQ ƫƳ ǭǬǜ#ؼǸƳ ǪǑƸƷ Q ǸƸƽH2 ai
Q
ƵƳLJǗǔǮ -Ʊǹ1 H# )LJǺǠƸǮ
Q -Ʊǹ1 !Ǹǎǫ' Q 'džǴ ǸǯNj Q
Q DZO '0ƱǮ ǭǩǬǨ 'džǴ FǶǢLJǝƷ ǭƸDZƫǢ
LJǯƸNjǮ
Q Q Q
ǪǦDzƷ ǸǢ ǸDzDZ' LJǃ" ǷDzǝǯƳ H' )LJǺǠƸǮ Q -Ʊǹ1 FǶǢLJǝƷ ǰǩǹ ƱK Qǹ#ؽǰǩǹ ƱK Qǹ# H#
ƲƴNjƳ DLjDzǯǫ' ǸǢ ƲǹLJǟ L K
ǸDzDZQ ƫǨH ƱDZƱǺǀ# LJǝǍ#H ƵDzNJ M ǰǹLJǎǜH ǸƸDzƺ' džDzǮ ,HLjƸǮ Q ƱDZ#
)LJǯƸNjǮ
Q )1ǶǑƳ
M )1/ƱǠǯǫ' Ƿǫ' J1'LJǗǓs
K
ǰǖǶǫ' 61# ǷǬǜ ƱǮ ƱǮǶǹ dzǺǢ LJǦƸNJ# Q Q
Jdžǫ' ƶǥǶǫ' Ƿǫ' BǶǎƳ ǛǬǗƷ# Q ǸQDzDzǩǫH
)ƱǬǐ ǸǢ ǰǩDzǫ 'džǫ )LJǯƸNjǮ
Q Q ƶǥǶǫ' ǸǢ ƱǯDZQ '
ƵǨLJǝǯǫ' ǰǴ'LJǫ'
Q ǭǨƱǓLJǮ 'HLJǔP ǀ#
ǰǺƳdžQ Nǝ Oǯǫ' ǪǨH ʹ (LJǫ' Q !ƱǍ '0s E/ƱǦǫ' Džǀƫǫ' -ƱƴǑǢ 'ǶNjDzƷ Ʊǫ b`
3ƱQDzǫ' ǰǮ ƵǜǶǯƾǮ ƿƽ1ƫǫ' ǷǬǜ CƱDzǴ FǶǩǹ AǶNjǢ ǭǩDzǨƱǮ# 'HLjƾǀs 'LJǨƱƳ K 'ǶǫƱǝƷ
ǧǫƱDzǴ ǰǩǹ ǭǫ DƱǀ ǸǣǢ )ƱǬǑǬǫ Q *ƱǥƱǗƳ Ǜǹ2ǶƸǫ LJǗǔDZ Q AǶNJH )ƱǬǑǬǫ ǰǺƽƱƸǁǯǫ'
Ǹǣǩǹ ƱǮ CƱDzǴ FƱǨ '0ƱǢ )ƱǬǐ *ƱǥƱǗƳ 92ǶDZ Q ǰǫ ƱDzDZQ ȫǢ 5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' ǰǮ ǸǢƱǩǫ' /Džǝǫ'
ƱǯQƳ1 ǰǩǫH ǪǺƴǦǫ' N 'džǴ ǰǮ !ǸǍ H# +ƱǬƺ H# ǰǺƸDzǹ2/ ƱǬƻǮ K K
'LJǺǠǐ ƱK ǣǐ
Q ǪǺǩǎƸǫ
Ǫƴǥ Ǜǹ2Ƕ QƸǫ' 'džǵƳ EǶǦDZ F# F0s ƿƽLJǯǫ' Q ǰǮH )ƱǬǑǫ' *ƱǥƱǗƳ 92ǶDZ AǶNJAǶNJ Q
ƵDzǮƱƻǫ' ƵǜƱNjǫ' Q DžDzǜ FǶǩƷ AǶNJؼ#DžƴƷ AǶNJ ƱǵDZQ ƫƳ DžǦƸǜ# ǸƸǫ'HQ !ƱǦǬǫ' Q ǰǮ ƵǜƱNJ
ƵNjǺDzǩǫ' FǶǁƸǣǺNJ )ƱǬǑǫ' Q
Q *ƱǥƱǗƳ FǶǜ2Ƕǹ AǶNJ ǡǑQDzǫ'H ƵDzǮƱƻǫ'H# ƵDzǮƱƻǫ' Q
ǰǮ ƱDzǴ 'ǶDZǶǩƷ F# ǷǬǜ F0' 'ǶǐLJǀƱǢ ǪƴǦǯǫ' Džǀƫǫ' -Ʊƴǐ )ƱǬǑǫ' Q *ƱǥƱǗƳ ǭǺǬNjƸǫ
ƵNjǺDzǩǫ' Ǫǃ'/ Ƕƾǫ' FǶǩǹ AǶNJ ǡQ Ǒǫ' Q ǸǢ ǭǴH1 ȧLJǮN ǭǨ!Ʊƴǀ# Q 'HLJǔǀ#ؼǪƽ#
ǭǵǬƽ# ǰǮ )ƱǬǑǬǫ ƱDzǝNJHP ǸǢ ƱǮ ǪǩƳ Q EǶǦDZ AǶNjǢ ǷǓLJǮ 'ǶDZƱǨ '0'Ʊǎ K ǝDz K
P OǮH ƱǣǺǗǫ
ƵƴQ ǁǯǫ' ƵǮDžǦƷ Ǫƽ# ǰǮ '/ K QDžƾǮ ǭǨLJǩǍ# ba
G1Ƕǔǀ J# +Džǁǫ' 'džǵǫ '/'DžǝƸNJs K !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ dzǬǫ' Q ƵǯǬǨ ǸǢ #LJǦDZ AǶNJ Fƪǫ'H bb
K
QF# LJǺǟ ƱǮ ƱǑDZ K
Q #LJǦDZ F# ƱDzDZƱǩǮƱƳ dzDZQ ƫƳ C1P ʹDžDZO ǰǁDZ ƱDzNjǀ dzƸǯǬǨ ƱDzǁDzǯǹ Ǹǩǫ DžǹDžƽ ǰǮ
ǶǴ dzǬǫ' QF# LJǺǟ ǏQDzǫ' 1ƱǺƸǃ' ƱDzDZƱǩǮȫƳ FHLJƷ FǶǯǔǯǫ' ǰǜ ǰǬP ǝ Oǹ AǶNJ Jdžǫ'Q ǶǴ dzǬǫ'
Q Q
ǸDZƱƻǫ'Q -Ʊǁǐǿ' ƱǺǮ1s (ƱƸǨ Fƪǫ' FǶǁƸǣƷ ƱǯDzǺƳH FǶǯǔǯǫ' ǰǜ ǰǬǝ Oǹ F# Ʋƾǹ ǰǮN
Q
(LJǫ'Q ǸǢ ǸǫƱǠǫ' .ƫǫ' ƱDzǝǮ ǪǹƱǢ Ǹǫ P .ƫǫ' /ǶƽǶƳ 'Džƽ LDžǺǝNJ ǸDzDZƱƳ DǶǦǫ' Džǹ1#
bc
K
ƱǯǨ Ljǹ'LJǨ /1ƱǬǹH .ƫǫ' dzǯNJs LJQǨdžƷ# F# ǛǺǗƸNJ# Ʊǫ .ƫǫ' Ʊǔǹ# ƱDzǴ DžƽǶǹ dzDZQ ƫƳ DžǦƸǜ#H
.ƫǫ'H AƱǬƳ 1ƱǬƳǶƳ Ǹǀ'ǶDZ ǰǮ ǰǹLJǃ"H FǶƽ .ƫǫ' 3ƱNjDzǨ1# ǰǮ )ǶǃƱǫ' I1# ǸDzDZQ #
ǸDzƸǺǫؼǛǺǗƸNJ# Ʊǫ ƱǬǝǢ K ƱDZ#ؽƱDZ# ǰǯǮ Q ǰǹLJǺƻǩǫ'H D/'1 .#H FǶNjǨƱƽ .ƫǫ' G"HN LJǺǬƳ
ǭƸDZ#H LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ ǪǝǢ J1HDžǦǯƳ ljǺǫ ƱǬǝǢ K ǸDzQDzǩǫH ǭǵƯƱǯNJƫƳ ǛǺǯƾǫ' LJǨ P0 ǛǺǗƸNJ#
1DžǑǯǫ ǰOǨLJǫ' K K
Q )K /Ʊǜ ǶǴH Ʊǔǹ# ƱDzǴ ƱNjǫƱƽ G'1# ǸDZQ s ƶʹDzǹ'P LJʹN Ƴ ǰʹ ƳP .ƫǫ' ǧǫ0 FǶǯǵǣƷ
ǭǝDZ GH# dzƷP Ƕǐ DƱǬǃ ǰǮ ǰʹ ƳP ALJǝǹ ǛǺǯƾǫ'!ؼƱDzƺ# ǰǺǮƪǫ'
J/'Ƕǫ' ǸǢ ǰǺǺDZ'Džǯǝǯǫ'
Q Ƿǫ' ƵǫƱNJLJƳ
M 2O LJǨ#
P ƶDzǨ Q *'0ؼƱDzDZQ s bd
O ƱǺDZ1ǶǣǺǫƱǨ ǸǢ )LJǮ
K
ƱǮ ƱǜǶDZ ǰǺǺǖ'LJǦƸNJ1ƫǫ'
Q K K K K
ǰǺǺDZ'Džǯǝǯǫ' ǰǮ 'LJǺƴǨ '/DžǜH )LJǺƴǨ ƵǯǺǃ CƱDzǴ FƱǨ DžǦǫ
!ƱNjQDzǫ' ǒǝƴǢ FǶǢLJǝƷ FƱǨ ƵM NǵƽP Ƶ Qǹ# ǰǮ )Džǀ'H ـǰǺǮ" ـƵǯǬǨ 9ƱǯNJN ǰǮ ǰQǩǯƷ# ǭǫ
'džǵƳ ǰǺƷLJǺƴǩǫ' ǰǺǬƽ ȧLJǫ' ǰǮ ƱƽH2K ƶǹ#1 )K ƫƾǢH ǰǵǴǶƽH
Q K
,ƱǺǨƱǮ /ƱNjǢs ǰǮ ƱǢǶǃ
ǶǴH )K LJNj OǹH ƵDzǯ K
K Oǹ LjƸǵǹ '/ǶNJ# K
'LJǝǍH ǰǺƷLJǺƴǨ ǰǹDžǹH !'Ƕǵǫ' ǸǢ ǰǺƸǜǶǢLJǮ ǭƾǁǫ'
e ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
(Ȧ LJǫ'
ȥ DǶO ǦO Nǹ ' ȤDžƽP JLJǺȥ ǁN ƷN HN J ȧLJ PǝǎN ǥ'
ʹ HN 'džǴ
N ǰʹ ǮP *'O HƱ ȥ Ʊ Nǵ OƸ ȥǹ'Ȝ Ǹ PƸ NǵƳʹ 'P
N ǯN Njǫ'
P
P ǺN ǯP ǫ'ʹ 9Ƕ
ǭʹ ǵP NjP ǣO DZʹ ƱǫȜ 'H OLJǦʹO DzǺN ǫP ƵP Ǻȥ ǁN ǫ'ʹ GƱ N ƴO Dzʹ Nǹ ƱDZN 'Ȝ ǸDZP ǶOǨLJN ƷN ǰP ʹǹLJȥ ǍN ǪN ǯP Nǜ ǸƴP ʹǝǍN ȥFƱǫȜ
K ǮN ǕO ƴO ǔʹ ƷN ƱǫN ƵK ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ '1K ƪʹƳ'Ȝ ؞EE *ƱDZ'Ljǃ؟
!Ʊ Q '1K ƪʹƳ'Ȝ
Fƪǫ' ƱDzNJH$1 ǸDzǁDZ ƱDZǶǜ/
F#H ƵǯǬǩǫ' GdžǴ ELJǩ Q
Q ƷO FƫƳ ǸǬǑDZ ǰǁDZH ǧƸǯǬǨ ƶƯN LJP ǥO DžǦǫ ƲǺƴǁǫ' ƱDzǵǫs Ʊǹ bh
ǸǢ )LJƳƱǠǫ' EƱǹƫǫ' (Ƕǐ ǛǬǗƸDZ Q ƱǯǺǢ Ʊǵǫ Ƶǹ2'Ƕǯǫ' )LJƴʹ ǝǫ'
P H# JLjǮLJǫ' Q Ǫ Nƻǯǫ'
N ƱDzǁDzǯƷ
Q
)DžǴƱǎǮ ƱDzDZƱǩǮȫƳ dzDZQ # ƱDzǯǬǝǹ 3 QDžǦǯǫ' (ƱƸǩǫƱǢ ƱDzǫ ƵǬƻǮ# ƵƳƱƻǯƳ ƶDZƱǨ ǸƸǫ'H Q ǪǺƯ'LJNJ'
ǰǺǀ ǭǵǬǮƱǝƷ
P ƶDzǨ ǡǺǨ Ʊǔǹ# K ILJDZH ƵǯǬǩǫ' FǶǝǺǗǹ ƱǮDžDzǜ ǭǵǝǮ ǧǬǮƱǝƷ ƵǦǹLJǖ
ǧDzǮ ǶƽLJDZ ǰǁDzǢ 'džǫ dzƳ EƱǺǦǫ' ƱDzǺǬǜ ǰǺǝƸ Q Nǹ ƱǮ ƵǢLJǝǮ ǸǫƱ QƸǫƱƳH ƵǯǬǩǫ' FǶǑǝ Nǹ
ǸǢ ALJǑƸDZ
Q ǡǺǨ ALJǝDZ ƱǯǺǩǫ )Lj M ǺǯǮ
Q ƵǦǹLJǗƳM !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ ǸǢ ƱDzǺǫs + QDžǁƸƷ F#
ǭNJȫƳ 'džǴ ƲǬǗDZ 0s Fƪǫ' dzǎǺǝDZ O ƱDzDZQ ƫƳ -ƱƴǑǫ'
Q 'džǴ ǸǢ ƱDzǨ1/# ƹǺǀ EǶǺǫ' 'džǴ
ǰǺǮ" 9ǶNjǹ
3ǶǬƾǫ' ǭǩDzǩǯǹ
ǰǜ ǕǦǢ )LjǺƽH
M )LJƸǣǫ@ǫ
M 9ǶǓǶǯǫ' ǰǜ !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ + QDžǁƷ# F# Q/H# bi
ʹ Ƴƪǫ'ʹ
ƵǦN Ǧȥ ǎN Oǯǫ' 1ƱN
Q DƱǥ ǰǺƷLJǺƴǨ ǰǺƸưǺǗǃ ALJƸǥ' Džǥ ǪǺƯ'LJNJs c`
9ǶƴDzǹ ǶǴ GǶǨLJƷ ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ dzǬǫ'
!ؼǸǍ 'džǴ ƱǯDZQ ' ƱǵDzǮ 'ǶƳLJǎǺǫ '1K ƱƳ" ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ 'HLJǦDZH )ƱǺǁǫ'
ǛǮ 2'ǶƸǮ
M ȧ
ǕDŽƳ LJǺNjǹ dzDZQ # ǶǴ 9ǶǓǶǯǫ' 'džǵƳ LJǺǩǣ QƸǫ' Ƿǫ' ǸDzǝǢ/ Jdžǫ'Q ƲƴNjǫ'Q ca
Q
ǸƸǫ' ƵǺǔǦǫ' Q Q
ǰǜH ƱǵǎǺǝDZ ǸƸǫ' ƵǺDZƪǫ'Q ƵǜƱNjǫ'
Q ǰǜ -ƱƴǑǫ'Q 'džǴ dzǫǶǥ# ƶDzǨ Jdžǫ'Q
ƱǵǬƽ# ǰǮ ǪƷƱǦDZ
K
ƱǯƯ'/ ǷǦƴǹ AǶNJ dzǬǫ' Q QFƫƳ DǶǦǬǫ DƱƻǮP ƵƳƱƻǯƳ ƱǴdžǃƫDZ ǸƸǫ'Q ǪǺƯ'LJNJs LJƴƸǝDZH cb
Q Q
ƱǴLJǢH ǸƸǫ' ƵǬǺNJǶǫ' IǶNJ dzǬǫ' Q dzǮLJǩǹ Q Džǥ !ǸǍ
M J#
Q ǧǫƱDzǴ ljǺǫH C'džDZ" FƱǨ ƱǯǨ
džƯDžDzǜ
M Q
dzǬǫ' ƵDZƱǴs ƱǵƸƾǺƸDZ ƶDZƱǨ ƵǬǺNJǶǫ' ǧǬƷ ǰǜ 'ǶǢLJǁDZ' ƱǮDžDzǜH ǭǫƱǝǬǫ dzNjǣDZ ǶǴ
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' f
Q
*ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ'@ǫ' ǛDzǐ Ƿǫ' FHDžǯN ʹǝ Nǹ ǭǵDZQ ƱǢ 1ƱƳƪǬǫ 3ƱQDzǫ' LJǦƸǣǹ ƱǮDžDzǜ LJưƴǫ' ǪǁǮ ǪǁǺǫ Q Q
ǸǢ FƱNjDZǿ' GLJǣǁǹ LJǎƴǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ LJưƳ L H# ƼǹLJǵǐ
L ǶǴ ǸǓ1ƫǫ' F'LjDŽǫ' Q LJǃ" LJǺƴǝƸƳ
M
DƱNjƸǟȫǬǫ GƱǺǯǨM ƱǵǮDžDŽƸNjǹ ǒǝƴǫƱǢ DƱǯǝƸNJƱǬǫ@ؽǬǫ GƱǺǯǫ' ǛǺǯƾƷ Ǫƽ# ǰǮ 61ƫǫ'
DžǺǝƴǫ' ǸǓƱǯǫ' ǸǢ ƱǯQƳ1 ILJǃ# 6'LJǟƫǫH M (LJǎǬǫ GƱǺǯǨ
M ƱǵǮDžDŽƸNjǹ AǶNJ ǭǵǔǝƳH
ƱǵǩǹLJǁƷ 6LJƸǣ Oǹ ƵǯǹDžǥ M Ƶǫ"
M Ƶǯƺ Q ƱDzǹDžǫ FƱǨ DžǦǫ GƱǺǯǬǫ DžǺǀǶǫ'1DžǑǯǫ' ǶǴ F'LjDŽǫ' Q FƱǨ
FƱǨH ǷǬǜƫǫ# Ƿǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' (ǶNjDzǮ ǛǣƷLJǹ F# Ƿǫs JLJƯ'/ JLJƯ'/ JLJƯ'/ JLJƯ'/ ǪǩǎƳ M
F'LjDŽǫ' Q ǰǮ GƱǺǯǫ' ƲǁNjǫ P Ƶǫƪǫ' GdžǵƳ Ƶ N
Ǧ ȥ
Ǭ Nǝ Oǯǫ' )LJǺǠ Ǒǫ'
Q !Ʊǫ ȧ
Džǫ' ǒǝƳ DžƽǶǹ
LJưƴǫ' ǰǜ GLjǺǯǹ Q Jdžǫ'H Q ǸǓ1ƫǫ' F'LjDŽǫ' Q 5ǶǑDŽƳ ƱǮ ƱưǺǍ K K
ǘǀƱǬDZ ƱDzDZQ s ƱDzNjǀ cf
Q
!ƱǦǬƷ ǰǮ GƱǺǯǫƱƳ ƮǬƸǯǹ Ʊǫ F'LjDŽǫ'@ǫ'@ؽǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' ǰǮ :LJN ǣ Nǹ AǶNJ ǸǓ1ƫǫ' F'LjDŽǫƱǢ ʹ Q
ǶǵǢ ǸǓ1# ȣ F'M Ljǃ Q ǷǬǜ /ƱǯƸǜǿ' ƱDzDzǩǯǹ Ʊǫ dzǺǬǜ /ƱǯƸǜǿ' ǰǩǯǹ ƱǫؼǶǵǢؽǶǵǢ dzPƷ'0
Q
AHLJǚǫ' ƲNjǀ !ƱƸǎǫ' Q H# ǡǺǑǫ' Q ǸǬǑǢ DƱǬǃ ǪǗǵƷ ǸƸǫ' 1ƱǗǮƫǫ' ǷǬǜ /ƱǯƸǜƱǫ' dzǺǬǜ
DLjDzƷ
P AǶNJ džưDzǺǀ
M !ƱƸ Q
ǎǫ' ǪǑǢ ǸǢ 1ƱǗǮƫǫ'H ,ǶǬƻǫ' ǕǥƱNjƸƷ ƱǮDžDzǜ )K /ƱǝǢؼǸǩǫ
Q Q
ǰǫ ǭǩDZȫǢؽǭǩDZȫǢ GƱǺǯǫ' ǧǬƷ ǪƴǦƸNjǹ P ǭǫ ǶǴ DƱǀ ǸǢH F'LjDŽǫ' Ǫǃ'/ Ƿǫ' GƱǺǯǫ'
G/LJǣǯƳ dzNjǣDZ ƫǬǯǹ F# dzDzǩǯǹ Ʊǫ ǡƾǹؼǪǮƱǩǫƱƳ dzDZQ sؽǪǮƱǩǫƱƳ ǶǵǢ !Ʊǯǫ' ǷǬǜ 'ǶǬǑǁƷ
g ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
@ؽǫ' ǪǔǣƳ ƮǬƸǯǹ dzDZQ ƱǢ dzNjǣDZ !ƱǦǬƷ ǰǮ ƮǬƸǯǹ F# ǛǺǗƸNjǹ Ʊǫ ǭǹDžǦǫ' ǸǓ1ƫǫ' F'LjDŽǫƱǢ
ǕǥƱNjƸƷ ǸƸǫ'Q 1ƱǗǮƫǫ'
)K /ƱǝǢ ǸǓ1ƫǫ' F'LjDŽǫ' Q 9ǶǓǶǮ ǸǢ LJǃ" !ǸǍ Ƿǫ' ǭǩǴƱƴƸDZ' ƶǣǫ# F# Q/H#H cg
)LJǺǚǁǫ' ƵǀƱNjǮ FǶǩƷ )K /ƱǜؼF'LjDŽǫ' Q ƱDZDžDzǜ ǪǐƱǀ L FƱǨ ƱǮ 'džǴ dzǬǥ# Q FHDžƾƷ
DƱǬǃ ǰǮ F'LjDŽǫ' Q Ƿǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' FǶǬǐǶǹ )K /Ʊǜ 'ǶDZƱǨ DžǦǬǢ DLjDzǯǫ' ƵǀƱNjǮ ǡǝǓ
ƱǮDžDzǜؼƱDzǹDžǫ FƱǨ ƱǮDžDzǜ CƱDzǴ F'LjDŽǫ' Q ǧǫ0 'Dž K ǺƽQ LJQǨdžƷ# ǸDzDZQ s )LJǺǚǁǫ' ǰǮ ƱǵǖƱǦNJs
ǰǮ ǕǦNjǹ FƱǨ ƱǮ ǪǨ F'LjDŽǫ' Q Q Ǫǃ'/ Ƿǫ' ǧǫ0 ǪǨ Q ALJƾƷ ALJǑǫ' Q ƲǺƳƱDZ# ƶDZƱǨ
)LJǺǚǁǫ' ǰǮ ǪǺNjǹ FƱǨ ƱǯǮ Q
Q ƮǬƸǯǹ F'LjDŽǫ' FƱǩǢ )LJǺǚǁǫ'
Q
3HDžƷ *ƱDZ'ǶǺǁǫ' ǪǨ ƹǺǀ )LJǺǚǁǫ' ƿǗNJ ǰǮ ƵǺƷƪǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' ƶDZƱǨ 'džǩǴH
ƿǗNJ ǷǬǜ LJǦƸNjƷ ǸƸǫ'Q !ƱDzǣǫ' .ƱNJH#H )LJǺǚǁǫ' ƵǀƱNJ !Ʊƽ1# ƵǢƱǨ Q ǸǢ ƱǵǬƽ1ƫƳ
ǰǮ ƿǗNjǫ' O Q
Q ǰǮ dzǗǦP Njʹ ƷH dzǬǨ 'džǴ GƱǺǯǫ' ALJƾƷ ǭȥ ƺ ǰǮH AƱǣƾǫ' ƶǥH ǸǢ )LJǺǚǁǫ' N
DžǺƳ
M K
Ʊǔǹ# ǶǴ 9ǶDzǑǯǫ' F'LjDŽǫ' Q Ǫǃ'/ Ƿǫ' CƱDzǴ ǰǮH FƱNjDZƱǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ ǪǗNjǥ DƱǬǃ
M
FǶǩǬƸǯƷ ƱǮDžDzǜ dzDZǶǎǺǝƷ Jdžǫ' ƱǮ J1/# ƶNjǬǢ Q O ǷǓǶǣǫ' ǸǢ 'ǶNjǯǠDzƷ P ǭǫ FȫǢ ʹ Ƶ QǹLJǎƳ
ƵǹƱǣǩǫ' dzǺǢ ƱǯƳ )1džǥ ǸǴH FƱNjDZǿ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ ƱǵǬǨ Q JDžǺNJ ǭǝDZ ƱK ǺǓ1# Q K Ljǃ
ƱDZ' Q
ǪǴF'LjDŽǫ' Q ǷǬǜ LJƸǬǺǣ N Ǩ E NDžDŽ NƸNjʹ ƷO ƵǥLJ K ǃP ƱDzǹDžǫ FƱǨؼǤPǬǗʹ DZO ƱDzǨ DžǦǫ ƱưǺǍ K FǶǯǬǝƷ# ch
M
ǛDzǯǫ )ƱǣǑǮ H#LJƸǬǺǢ ƵƳƱƻǯƳ dzƸǴǶǢ ǷǬǜ ƵK ǥLJǃ ǛǓH ELjǬǹ FƱǨ ǧǫdžƳ ǭǬǜ N M ǷǬǜ ǭƸDzǨ
Q
ƱǮ ǪǨH ƱƴǹLJǦƷ FƱǩǮ K Q
ǪǨ ǰǮH )LJǺǚǁǫ'@ؽǫ' ƿǗNJ ǰǮ DLjDzǹ FƱǨ ƱǮ ǪǨH *'LJǎǁǫ' Q
M
ƵƳƱƻǯƳ
P 4Ʊǯ M ǥO ƵǝǗǥ ǛǓǶǹ N FƱǩǢ F'LjDŽǫ' Q ǸǢ ǷǮLJʹ Oǹ FƱǨ CƱDzǴ ǰǮH ƱDzǴ ǰǮ LJǯǹ Q FƱǨ
Q
ƱǵDZ# ƿǓ'Ƕǫ' ǰǮ dzǖƱǦƸǫs ƱDzDzǩǯ Q
P Oǹ ƱǮ ǪǨH .ƱNJHƫǫ' ǪǨ ǕǦƸǬƷ Ǹǩǫ F'LjDŽǫ' ǷǬǜ LJƸǬǺǢ Q Q M
,LJǀDžƸƷ ƶDZƱǨ ǸƸǫ'Q ǧǬƷ ǕǦǢ )LJǺƴǩǫ' EƱNjƽƫǫ' ƱǯDZQ s ƵǺǦǺǦǁǫ' Q )1'džǦǫ' ǧNjP ǯʹ ƷO ǰǫ
*'LJǎǁǫ' LJǺǑǜ ƱǯDZQ s 4ƱǯǦǫ' ƵǝǗǥ ǸǢ LJǦƸNjƷ Q Džǥ *'LJǎǁǫƱǢ dzǬǃ'/ ǸǢ ǕǦNjƷN H
ƱǮDžDzǜ ǷǓǶǣǫƱƳ ƱǦǀ Q FǶǚǁƷN ǭƸDZ# ؽǭƸDZ# F0s !Ʊǯǫ' ǸǢ DLjDzǺǫ dzǦǹLJǖ ǛƳƱƸ Oǹ AǶNJ
K džǥ
'1 K
P ƱǯǹDžǥ K
ƱDZ'Ljǃ FǶǩǬƸǯƷ
ǕǦǢ EƱǹ# M ƵǝǔƳ DƱǬǃ )DžǨ'1 ƿƴǑƷ AǶNjǢ F'LjDŽǫ' Q Ǫǃ'/ GƱǺǯǫ' CLJƸDZ ƱǮDžDzǜ ci
ƼǝƷ Q AǶNJ ƱǴDžDzǜH /ǶǨ1 ƵǫƱǀ ǸǢ ƿƴǑƷ AǶNJH F'LjDŽǫ' Q Ǫǃ'/ !Ʊǯǫ' 'ǶǨLJƷ'Ȟ
K
ǭǬǜ# Ʊǫ 'ؼQDžƽ )LJǺǠǐ ǸǴ ـAǶǟLJǍ ـƱǵǺǯNjDZ Q
Q ƱDzDZs ǸǜƱǢƫǫ'H *ƱǺǬǁ Q NjǫƱƳ Q 9/ƱǣǔǫƱƳ Q
ǶǴ ƱǯDZQ s ƱǵDZǶǯNj Q ƷO '0ƱǮ ǭǬǜ# Ʊǫ ǛǺǗƸNJ# ƱǫؼƱǵDZQ s *ƱǺǬǺǣ Q ǖO ƶNjǺǫ ǸǴؼƶDZƱǨ ƱǮ '0'
ǭǩDzǮ Džǀ'H M ǭǨ ǸǴ ƱǮ FǶǢLJǝƷ AǶǟLJǍ dzǺǯNjDZ Jdžǫ'ؽJdžǫ'Q !Ʊǯǫ' ǸǢ /ǶƽǶǮ !ǸǍ Q
/ǶǨLJǫ' Q DžǺǨƫƸǫƱƳ 'džǴ FǶǢLJǝƷ ǭǩǝǺǯƽ FǶ QǹHLJǦǫ' ǭƸDZƫǢ ǭǝDZG" + QDžǁƷ# Ʊǯǜ Q ALJǝǹ
ǸǢ ǶǴ /ǶǨLJǫ' K
Q QFs ƱǯƯ'/ dzDZǶǦǢ'LJǹ /ǶǨLJǫ' BƱǎ OǜH dzǓLJǜH F'LjDŽǫ' DǶǖ ǷǬǜ QDžƸǯǹ Q Q
F'ǶǺǁǫ' ('džƾDZ' !'1H ƲƴNjǫ' Q ǶǴ /ǶǨLJǫƱǢ Q CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ǭǵƳ ǷƷ# Jdžǫ'Q !Ǹǎǫ' Ǜǥ'Ƕǫ'
F'LjDŽǫ' Q Ǫǃ'/ Ƿǫ' )DžǨ'LJǫ' Q *ƱǁǗQ NjN Oǯǫ' IǶǵ Nǹ Jdžǫ'Q
ؼƱDzǺǬDŽƷ Q ƱDzDZQ ƫƳ DžǦƸǜ# EǶǺǫ' ƱDzNjƯƱDzǨ DƱǀ DžǺǝƳ Džǀ ȣ Ƿǫ' dzƴǎ P Oǹ ǛǓǶǫ' 'džǴ QFs d`
ǪǺƯ'LJNJs ƵǺǗǃ Q ǪƻǮ ǕƴǔǫƱƳ Q ǸǴ EǶǺǫ' ƵNjǺDzǩǫ' ƱǵƸǢLJƸǥ' ǸƸǫ'Q ƱǹƱǗDŽǫ' ǭǚǜ# IDžǀs
ǛDzǐ ǰǮ *ƱDZ'Ljǃ ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ 'HLJǦDZH ƵǺǁǫ' Q Q GƱǺǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ ǶǴ GǶǨLJƷ DžǦǬǢ ƱǵDzǮ2 ǸǢ
GƱǺǯǫ' ǰǮ 9ǶQDzǫ' 'džǴ Ʋǁǹ Q ǰǮ Q
Ǫǩǫ K
ƱDzǩNj Ǯ N *ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' ǧǬƷ ƶǁƴǐƫǢ FƱNjDZƱǫ' JDžǹ#
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' h
Q
Ƽǹ1Ʊǵǐ ƱǵDZQ ƫǫ ƱǵǬǃ'/ ǸǢ njǺǝƷ )1džǦǫ' ǭǺƺ'LJƾǫ' 9'ǶDZ# ƵǢƱǨH 9/Ʊǣǔǫ' *ƱǺǬǁ Q Njǫ'
Q
KƱǫƱƻǮ ǶǴ ƼǹLJǵǑǫ' Q
Q 'džǴ Ǫǃ'/ !ƱǺǍƫǫ' ǧǬƷ ǪǨ FƱǗǺƸNJ'H LJǎƴǫ' JDžǹƫƳ ƵǜǶDzǑǮ
K
EǶǺǫ' ƱDzƴǴ'džǮH ƱDzǣƯ'ǶǗǫ Ʊǃ1Ʊǐ
)ـȥDžǁǫ'
P GdžǵƳ 5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' !ƱǫƬǴ ǭƽƱǵƷ '0Ʊǯǫ EƱǵDZ'LJƳ .# Fƪǫ' ـFǶǫǶǦƷ Džǥ da
AƱǗǯǫ' ƵǹƱǵDZ ǸǢ ƱǵDZQ ƫǫ ƱǵDzǮ 'ǶƳLJǴ# 'ǶǯƽƱǵN Oǹ F# ǸǠƴDzǹ ǭǵǯƽƱǵDZ F# ƱDzƳ 6O LJN NƸǣʹ Oǹ
FǶǩƷ AǶNJ ǸǴ ƵǦǺǦǁǫ' ǸǴ GdžǴ 'HLJQǨdžƷ njǀǶǫ' ƵǯN NJP ǪQǩǎƷ AǶNJ ǰʹ ǮN ǸǴ
ǤǺǦǁƸǫ Fƪǫ' ƱǵǦǹLJǖ ǸǢ ƱǵDZQ s ƵǯNjǫ' Q Ƿǫ' )K LJǍƱƴǮ /ǶǦƷ ǡƯ'ǶǗǫ'
Q QFs njǀǶǫ' ƵǯNJP
ƵǗǬNjǫ'
Q DƱǬǃ ǰǮ ) QǶǦǫƱƳ ADžǵǫ' 'džǴ
Q Q
I Q/# Jdžǫ' ǕƴǔǫƱƳ ǶǴ 'džǵǢ ƵǯǹDžǦǫ' ƵǺDZƱǮHLJǫ' Ƶ Qǹ1Ƕǖ'LJƴǮƫǫ' ǂǹ1ƱƷ ǸǢ 'ǶƻǁƳs db
Q ǷǬǜ '1/Ʊǥ
H# !'LJǎǫ' K FƱǨ Džǀ# ǰǮ ƱǮ dzDZQ ƫƳ ǭƸǹ#1 DžǦǫH ǧǬƷ /'DžƷ1ǿ' ƵǮƱǬǜ Ƿǫ' ǭǵƳ
Q ǛǺƴǫ'
ƱǵƳ Ƿǚǁʹ Nǹ F# dzǺǬǜ ǸǠƴDzǹ FƱǨ njǀǶǫ' ƵǯN NJP dzNǫ ǰǮN Ʊǫs
ǭ ʹƸǃN ǭǵǹDžǫ ǰǹdžǫ'Q ǧưǫH' 61ƫǫ' ǷǬǜ LJǎƴǫ' ǰǮ FƱƸưǢ CƱDzǴ FǶǩǹ AǶNJ dc
F0s ǭǩǹDžǫ FǶǩǹ F# ǸǠƴDzǺǢ ǕǦǢ FƱƸưǢ njǀǶǫ' ƵǯNJP ǭǵǹDžǫ ǰǹdžǫ'Q ǧưǫH'H dzǬǫ' Q
/'DžƷ1ǿ' ƵDZƱǹ/ ƱǮ ƵDZƱǹ/
M N
ƵǮƱǬǜ ƵǮƱǬǜ /'DžƷ1ȫǫ' CƱDzǴ FǶǩǹ AǶNJ ILJǃƫǫ' H# )Džǀ'Ƕǫ'
ƱǮH1 QFƫƳ DžƾDZ ƱDzƸNJ'1/ DƱǬǃ ǰǮ njǀǶǬǫ )1Ƕǐ Ʊǔǹ# K CƱDzǴ FǶǩǹ AǶNJH dd
ƵǬǺNJH
M K K
ǰǮ ƱǮ ƱǮƱǯƷ njǀǶǫ' H#ؼEƱǬǜ ǸǴ ƱǯƯ'/ ǷǦƴƷ AǶNJH Fƪǫ' ǸǴH ƶDZƱǨ
ƱǮH1 ǧǫ0 AƱǬǃ ǭǵǣDZ Fƫǫ ILJǃ#
*ƫǎDZ#H Ƶ QǹǶƳƱƴǫ' ƱǮH1 Ƿǫ' ƵǺDzƺǶǫ'
Q ƱǮH1 ǰǮ ƶǫ QǶǁƷ DžǦǫ ƱǮH1 ƶǬǝǢ '0ƱǮH de
QƱǫsH ƵDZƱǹDžǫ' ǧǬƷ Ƿǫ' EƱǯǔDZƱǫ' ǷǬǜ ) QǶǦǫƱƳ ǛǺǯƾǫ' LJƴƽ#
P DžǥH ƱK ǺDZQ ǶǨ K
ʹ ƱǮƱǚDZ K
ƱǮƱǚDZ
ǭǵƴǺǑDZ FǶǩǹ *ǶǯǫƱǢ
ǪǯN ǁǫ'
N ǪƻǮ ǸǴH ƵǀƱNjǫ' Q ǷǬǜ )Džǁ QƸǯǫ' *ƱǹƱǫǶǫ' 1ǶǵǙ ǶǴ ƲǹLJǠǫ' LJǮƫǫ'H df
)LjǺƽH )LJƸǢ M DžǝƳH ƵǺNjDzǨ Q BǶǦǀH ƵǺDZDžǮ Q BǶǦǀ F'LJǺǠǐ FƱDZLJǥ dzǹDžǫ ǪǯN ǁǫ'H N
Q
FƱǨ ǸƸǫ' ǰǺDz QƸǫ' ƵǗǬNJ ǪǮƱǨ 31ƱǯǹH ǰǺQDzƷ ǪƻǮ ǭǬǩƸǹ Q K
GDžƾDZ ƱǬǯǀ FǶǩǹ ƱǯDzǺǀ
)K 1Ƕǐ ǛDzǑDZ ǭǬǴـ ȥ 'ǶǫƱǥ ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ ƱDZLJƴDŽǹ 3 QDžǦǯǫ' (ƱƸǩǫ'H dzǬƴǥ LJǺǃƫǫ' 'džǴ ƱǵƳ Ǜ QƸǯƸǹ
ǛǮ Fƪǫ' dzƸǹ$1 ƱDzDzǩǯǹ LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴH LJǃ" ƱưǺǍ K dzƴǎǹ ƱǮ !ǸǍ ǸǴ )1ǶǑǫ' Q ـnjǀǶǬǫ
ǪƻǯǹQ Jdžǫ'H Q ǸǯǫƱǝǫ' ljƯƱDzǩǫ' ljǬƾǮ ǪǺǩǎƷ Ƿǫ' ǷǝNjƷ ǸƸǫ'Q ) QDžƷLJ Oǯǫ' ƵNjǺDzǩǫ' ƵǫƱǀ
ƶDZƱǨ Jdžǫ'Q dzNjǣDZ ǕǠǔǫ' Q (Ƕǝǎǫ' Q ǷǬǜ 31ƱǯƷ AǶNJ ǸǵǢ ƱǮH1 ƵǗǬNjǫ )K 1Ƕǐ
ǰǮ ƱǮ F0s ILJǃ# ƵǬǺNJH ǰǮ ƱǯǢ Ƶ QǹǶƳƱƴǫ' ƱǮH1 H#ؼǪƴǥ ǰǮ ƵǺDzƺǶǫ' Q ƱǮH1 dzNJ1ƱǯƷ
ƵǦǺǦǁǫ' ǸǴ GdžǴ ƱǯDZQ s LJǃ" !ǸǍ M
ǸDzǮ2 ǸǢ 'džǴ ǸǫƱǁǫ' JLJǑǜ ǸǢ !Ǹǎǫ' Q 'džǴ ǭƽƱǴ# ƱDZ# ƲƴNjǫ' Q 'džǵǫH dg
Ǹ PǢ 'ǶOǨLJP NƸǎʹ ƷN ƱǬNȥ ưǫP ǸƴP ʹǝǍN Ʊ Nǹ Ʊ NǵʹDzǮP 'ǶƽO OLJǃ#ـ
ʹ !'DžQDzǫ' ǤPN Ǭǖʹ 'Ȟ DžǦǫ ǭƽƱǵ
N Oǹ F' ǸǠƴDzǹ dzDZQ ƫǫ
ـƱNǴƱ NǹƱǗN ǃN
dzDZQ s )ƱǺǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ dzDZQ s ـƵƺ ȥǶǬ Oǯǫ'H )1džǦǫ' *ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' Q Ȟ
ǧǬƷ Ƿǫ' F0s Ʊǵ Oǵƴȧ ǍN 'ƱDZƫǢ dh
N Q
IǶNJ JǶǁƷ Ʊǫ *ƱDZ'Ljǃ ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ 'HLJǦDzǺǫ GǶǨLJƷ Džǥ 3ƱQDzǫ' QFȫǢ 'džǴ ǛǮH ـƵǺǁǫ' Q GƱǺǯǫ'
dzDZQ s ǸǣƯƱǗǫ' Q EƱǚQDzǫ' dzǬǝǣǹ ƱǮ 'džǴH dzǺǬǜ JǶƸǁƷ Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ' !Ǹǎǫ' Q dzDZQ s *'1'džǦǫ'
i ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
ƱǯǫƱǖ dzǫƱƴǦƸNJƱǫ FH QDžǝƸNjǮ ǭǵDZQ ' ƱǵǺǫs EƱǯǔDZǿ' ǸǠƴ NǹH ƱǵDzǮ E QDžǦƸǹ ǰǮ ǪǨ Q ǕǦƸǬǹ
ǰǮ H# FǶDZǶǩǹ ǰǮ ǭ Oǵǹ ƱǯǬǥ ƵDzǺǝǮ Q Q ƵǦǹLJǗƳ M K
ƱƳƱǺƺ JDžƷLJǹ dzDZQ # H# DƱǯǫ' ǒǝƳ dzǹDžǫ
D'Ƕǀƫǫ' ǪǨ Q ǸǢ ǭǵDZǶǬƴǦǹ ǭǵDZQ ȫǢ FǶƷƫǹ ǰǹ#
ǶǴ ƱǨLJǺǮ# ǭǥ1ؼƱDzǴ ƶNǬQǩǎƷ ǸƸǫ'Q GdžǴ njǀǶǫ' ƵǮƱǬǜ Ʊǔǹ# Fƪǫ' DžƾDZ ǰǁDZ di
)LJǎǜ +ƱǬƺ N Ǫǯǁǹ ƱǵǯNǬ Nǜ FƱǨ DžǦǫ )LJǯǝƸNjǮ )LJǎǜ +ƱǬƺ ǛǮ * NDžPǫ OH DžǦǬǢ LJǎǜ ƵƺƱǬƺ
Ʊǹ$LJǫ' LJǣNJ ǰǮ LJǎǜ ƹǫƱƻǫ' Q ǪǑǣǫ' ǸǢ LJǵǚƷ ƱǵDZQ # Ƿ QƸǀ ƱǗǃ K LJǎǜ ƵƺƱǬƺ N K
ƵǯƾDZ
JDžDzǵǫ' 3#LJǫ' Q QF# ǷƸǀ ƵǺǨLJǺǮƫǫ'
Q DžǦQDzǫ' ǛǗǥ ǷǬǜ ƱǯƯ'/ ǪƻǯƸƷ K Q )#LJǯǫ' )1Ƕǐ QF# ƱǯǨ
LJǮƫǫ' 'džǵƳ ǭǬǜ ǷǬǜ ƱDzDZQ s )#LJǮǿ M ƵǺƴDZƱƽ
Q )1Ƕǐ ǶǴ 4LJǥ Ƶưǯǫ' ƵǝǗǥ ǷǬǜ /ǶƽǶǯǫ'
ƵǹLJǁǫ' Q DƱƻǯƷؼƵ QǹLJǁǫ' ǸǥƱƴǫ' ǪǨH ƵǹLJǁǫ' Q 3LJƽ
N !ǸǍ
M ȥ
ǪǨ ƱǵDŽǹ1ƱƷ ALJǝDZ ǰǁDzǢ
ǪǨ ILJDZ F# DžǺƽ Q !ǸǍ 'džǴ'ؽdžǴ Ʊǯ DZ Q s FHLJƷ# )LJǎǜ +ƱǬƺ ǭǥLJǫ' )#LJǮs )#LJǮs dzDZQ s
1ǶǮƫǫ' ǧǬƷ
GdžǴ QFƫƳ Ʊǹ$1 DƱǬǃ ǰǮ H# dzǬǫ' Q ǰǮ FƱǬǜsH ǸǀǶƳ aicc EƱǝǫ' ǸǢ *ƫ O ƴQ DzƷ DžǦǫH e`
M M
Q
Jdžǫ' ـǸDzǺǫǶNJǶǮ ـQF# ǸǴH ƱǵDzǮ )Džǀ'HH FƱǮLjǫ' ƵǹƱǵDZ Ǫƴǥ ǪǑǁƷ AǶNJ !ƱǺǍƫǫ' Q
dzƸM Qǹ1ǶƷƱƸǩǹDžǫ ljNJƬǹ Q FƱǨ DžǦǫ ـdzƸ Qǹ1ǶƷƱƸǩǹ/ ƵǮƱǥȫǫ ljNJƬǹ Q ƶǥǶǫ' ǧǫ0 ǸǢ FƱǨ
-HLJǫ'H ƱǺƳǶǺƺ' ǷǬǜ ǸǫǶƸNjǹH CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' dzƽǶƸǺNJ Q FƱǨH ƱǺƳǶǺƺ' HLjǠǫ P ǕǗDŽǹ Q FƱǨH
قـǧǬƷ dzƷǶǗǃO ǸǢ ǤǣDŽǹ AǶNJ ƿǬǣǹ ǰǫ فDƱǥ
FHLJQǨdžƸǹ ǰǯǮ Q ƱDzǴ ƵǯǺDŽǫ' ǸǢ ǷǮ'DžǦǫ' ǒǝƳ DžƽǶǹ D'2 ƱǮ ǪǴ D!ƱNjƷ# O ǸDzDZQ s ea
džDzǮ CƱDzǴ ǘǝP DZN ƱDzǨ ƱǮDžDzǜ ـFƱǮ/1ـ P ƵǫƱǐ ǸǢ 9ǶǓǶǯǫ' 'džǴ ǰǜ ƶƺ O QDžǁƷ Džǥ ǸDZQ ƫƳ
Q Q
'ǶDZƱǨ ǰǹdžǫ' ǧưǫH# ǰǮ ƵǬǺǬǫ' ƱDzǵǴ ǷDzƴǯǫ' ǸǢ ƱǮ LDžǀ# DžƽǶǹ ǪǴ ǰǺDzNJ ) QDžǜ ) QDžǜ
ؑؕ @Ƴ ǷǯQ NjN Oǹ ƱǮ ƫǎDZ ǰǺǀ 'džǵƳ *2LJǨ O ƱǮDžDzǜ ƵǯǹDžǦǫ' ـFƱǮ/1ـ P ƵǫƱǐ ǸǢ CƱDzǴ
ƱǮ ǷǬǜ ƱDzǴ LDžǀ# DžƽǶǹ Ʊǫ DHƫǫ' GDžǵ Nǜ FƱQ N Ƴs ƶǬǢ2H1 ǭǩǀ DƱǬǃ DžǺǝƳ M ǰǮ2 džDzǮ
)DžǺQ Njǫ' Q ǭǝDZ ƱDzǴ ǏDŽǍ
M Ƶ ǯƺQ ƱDzǴ ǏDŽǍL DžƽǶǹ ǭǝDZ ǭǝDZ ƱǮ LDžǀ# CƱDzǴ ǪǴ DžǦƸǜ#
Q
FƱǑDŽǍ CƱDzǴ D'Ljǹ Ʊǫ )LJǃƬǯǫ' ǸǢ CƱDzǴ ƵNjǫƱƽ ǸƸƽH2 ƱǴLJǨdžƷ# ǸDZ' FǶNjǬǹH Q Q
ƵƴǦǁǫ' ǧǬƷ ǸǢ CƱDzǴ 'ǶDZƱǨ ǰǯǮ Q ǭǹDžǦǫ' ǪǺƾǫ' ǰǮ
ƱǵDzǺǀ DǶǥ# ƶDzǨH njǀǶǫ' ƵǮƱǬǜ ǸǴ GdžǴ ؑؕ @ǫ' QFƫƳ FǶǫǶǦǹ 'ǶDZƱǨ ƱǮDžDzǜ
ƱǵDzǩǯǹ Ʊǫ ƱǮH1 ǰǮ ǸƷƫƷ ǪƳ ƱDzǴ ǰǮ ǸƷƫƷ Ʊǫ njǀǶǫ' ƵǯNjǢ P BƱǬǖƱǫ' ǷǬǜ Ʊǵǫ ƵǥƱǬǜ Ʊǫـ
ـnjǀǶǫ' ƵǮƱǬǜ FǶǩƷ F#
AǶNJ LJǬƸǴ ǡǫH/# ـQFƫƳ ƶǬǥ O DžǦǫ ƶǬǺǥ Džǥ !ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǪǨ Q QFƫƳ 'HLJQǨdžƷ Fƪǫ'H eb
AǶNJ ǭǵDZQ # ƱǯǨ )Džǁ QƸǯǫ' *ƱǹƱǫǶǫ' ǷǬǜ (LJǁǫ' ǰǬP ǝ Oǹ AǶNJ dzDZQ ƫƳH ƵǔǮƱǟ ƵǹƱǵDZ ǷǦǬǹ
ƱDzǴH dzǺǢ FǶǎǺǝǹ AǶNJ ǭǵDZQ # Ƿ QƸǀH FǶǖƱƴǫ' ǰǮ ƱǯDŽǓ K !ƱDzƳؽ
K K
ƱǯDŽǓ K
ƱưǺǍ FǶDzƴ Nǹ
Q
ǤǬǝƸǹ LJǮƫǫ' FƱǨ DžǦǫ ـƵǗǦQDzǫ' GdžǴ DžDzǜ ƵNJ'LJǎƳ FǶǬƷƱǦǹ ǰǺǺǨLJǺǮƫǫ' DžƾDZ AǶNJ
ǪǑǹ AǶNJ ـƶǬǥ O ǭȥ ƺN ǰǮH dzƯƱDzƴƳ )LJǍƱƴǯǫ' Ǫƴǥ ƱǮƱǜK LJǎN Nǜ NDžǀ#
N DžǹLJǣǠǺNJ ǕDŽƳQ
(ـLJǁǫ' ƿƳLJƷ AǶNJ )Džǁ QƸǯǫ' *ƱǹƱǫǶǫ'H dzƸǹƱǵDZ Ƿǫ'
O
ƶǬǥH ـƵǺǜǶǺǍH
Q ƵǺǍƱǢ
Q Ƶ QǹLJǬƸǴ ـƵ QǹP' ـƵƺƱǬƺ ǧǫƱDzǴ ـQFƫƳ ƶǬǥ ǧǫ0 DžǝƳH ec
ـƵǺǜǶǺ
Q ǎǫ' Q
Q ǸǢ ǭǵǬǨ ǭǵǑƸǯƷ
Q AǶNJ ƱǺNJHLJǢ Q ƵǺǜǶǺ
Q Q DžDzǜ ǭǵǬǨ
ǎǫ' Q FǶǵƸDzǹ AǶNJـ
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' a`
AǶNJ FƱNjDZƱǫƱǢ 'K QDžƽ )LJǺƴǨ ƵǦǹLJǗƳ ǭǬǝǫ'1 QǶǗƸǹ AǶNJ ǭȥ ƺN ǰǮH ـƱǔǹ#
K O
ƶǬǥH ed
ؽH ǸǑǜ
ȣ O
!'Ljƽ# IǶNJ LJǚQDzǫ' QDžǮ ǷǬǜ 1N # ǭǫH LJƾǣDZ' Džǥ ǭǫƱǝǫ' QFƫǨH ƶǹ#1 Q
ƵǚǁǬǫ'
ȧ
ـ1ƱƾǣDZǿ' ǕǠǓ ƶǁƷ 61ƫǫ' ƱǵƸǚǣǫ Džǥ ƵDzǃ NDž OǮ 1ǶDŽǐH
Ǫǐ# ǰǮ 1ǶǮ# ƵNjǯǃ QFs ǭǫƱǝǫ' ƵǹƱǵDZ Ǫƴǥ ǪǑǁƷ AǶNJ !ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǪǨHQ
P M
K QDžƾǮ ǰǁDZ ƱǴH ǰǺƺƱǬƻǫ'H +ƱǬƻǫ'
dzDZQ s '/ Q *'ǶDzNjǫ'
Q 1'DžǮ Q
ǷǬǜ ƶǦǦǁƷ Džǥ ƵǝƴNJ
P
ƵǹƱǵQDzǫ' ƶǥH
Q EƱǚQDzǫ' QDžǓ ǭǬǩƷ#
GdžǴH ǸǣƯƱǗǫ' Q ƵƴǦN ǁǫ'
N ǧǬƷ ǪǨ Q DƱǬǃH ǰǺǁǫ' C'džǮ Q ƱDZ#H eh
ǛǺǗƸNJ# Ʊǫ *'1'džǦǫ' 3 QDžǩƸƷ ƹǺǀ ǛǦDzƸNjǮ /LJƾǮ Q dzDZQ ƫƳ ǰǮ$# ƶǫ2 Q
O ƱǮ ƱDZ# Ʊǔǹ# ƵǬǺǬǫ'
NDžǫǶǹ F# ǸǠƴDzǹ dzDZQ ƫǫ dzƸNjǺDzǨ Ƿǫ' dzǯǔǹH
Q N Q
!Ǹǎǫ' 'džǴ ǪƻǮ džǃƫǹ dzǬǫ' QFƫƳ ǤǹDžǑ QƸǫ'
ǪǃDžDZ ǰǁDZ JLJNjǫ'
Q Q -H1 ǰǮ
ƿǺNjǯǫ' DžNjƾǢ dzNǩǬ OǮ ƿƴǑ Oǹ F# Ǫƴǥ LJ ȥǵǗN Oǹ F#H dzǬǫ'
3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ'Q Ƶ Qǹ/ǶǯǝǮ Ƶ Qǹ/Ƕǯǝǯǫ' DƱǬǃ ǰǮ dzDzǯǓ
ǷǬǜ ǸǠƴDzǹ ƵǺǣƯƱǗǬǫ
Q K
'2ƱƸǯǮ K
ƱǫƱƻǮ DžǺǨƫ QƸǫƱƳ ǶǴ 'džǴ *ƱDZ' Q
P LjDŽǫ' EƱǚDZ QFs ǭǝDZ ei
N
ƶƴƺ# Q QFƫǫ EƱǚQDzǫ' 'džǴ ǰǯǓ ǪǃDžǹ ƱǬǢ 'LJǺǑƳ
Džǥ dzǬǫ' K FǶǩǹ F# ǭǺǩǁǫ' FƱNjDZƱǫ'
LǪƽ1 ǸƷƫǹ FƱǨ )M LJǮ ȧ N
Q ǪǨ ǸǢ ǕQʹ ǥ dzǝǮ ǪǮƱǝƸǹ ǭǫ ǶǴH G QDžǓ dzDZQ ƫƳ DƱǺƽƫǫ' IDžǮ ǷǬǜ
ǰʹ ǩǫH
P ǭǴLJǺǟH ǰǺǣǫƱǨH ƹǺǯNJH 'LJƽ Q ǭǬǴHQ K
ǸǬNjǹH LJƺǶǫ ǪƻǮ ƱǮ ƵǫƱNJ1 K
ƱǬǮƱǀ
JƫƳ
Q ƱǴDžǦƸǣǹ /Ƕǝǹ ƱǫH ALJǫ' Q
Q ǷǬǜ dzǬǫ' ƱǵDzǨLJǹ džƯDžDzǜ
M Q
*ƱǯǚDzǯǫ' !ƱǎDZƱƳ 'ǶǜLJǎǹ Fs ƱǮ
*ƱǔǵDzǫ' ǰǮ
N 9ǶDZM
aa ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
EDžDŽƸNJ'
N Džǥ dzǬǫ' Q QFƫƳ *ƱǥHƫǫ' ǰǮ ƶǥH M J# K LJʹ N Ǩdž Oǹ ǭǫ ǂǹ1Ʊ QƸǫ' 'Ƕǝƽ'1 f`
Q ǸǢ ƱǫH 'DžƳ#
ǰǨƱǮƫǫ' ǰǮ FƱǩǮ M J# ǸǢ ƱǮ ƵǔǵDZ
M Ƶ Qǹ# )1Ʊƺs Ǫƽ' ǰǮ ƵǺǣƯƱ Q ƵǯǚDZƫǫ' GdžǴ IDžǀ%
Q Ǘǫ'
K
!Ǹǎǫ' 'džǴ QFƫƳ Ʊǔǹ# 3 QDžǦǯǫ' (ƱƸǩǫ' ƲNjǁƳH ǂǹ1Ʊ QƸǫ' IDžǮ ǷǬǜ ǰǴLJƴƷ Džǥ 0s
ǷǝNJ#H ƱǴ QDžǓ ƱDZ# ƲƴNjǫ' Q 'džǵǫH ƱǵǝǮ Ǹǫ FƫǍ N Q ǸDzǺǜ ǸǢ LJǴƱǖ LJǺǟ LJǮ#
ƱǫH dzǬǫ' L ǶǴ
Q M
CƱDzǴ ǰǮ 3ƱDzǫ' ,'LJǃȫǫ 'DžǴƱƽ K
Ƿǫ' LJǚQDzǬǫ EǶǺǫ' ǪǑǁǹ ƱǯƳ dzǺƴǍ ǪǺƯ'LJNJ' ǛǮ ILJƽ JdžǫƱǢ Q ؽFH QǶǜDžǮ ƱDzDZQ s fa
ǰǺǺǬǺƯ'LJNJǿ'
Q !ƱǫƬǴ ƵǮƱǥs ) QDžǮ D'ǶǗǢN LJƴN Pǝǫ' džǃ#H ʹ ƵǬƻǮ# /Ʊƾǹs Ǫƽ# P ǰǮ ǪǺƯ'LJNJs
ǰʹ ǩǫH
P E'LJ Oǹ ƱǮ ǰNjǀ# ǷǬǜ LJǺNjǹ ǭǵǺǫs ƵƴNjQDzǫƱƳ !ǸǍ ǪǨ FƱǨ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' ǧǫ0 ǛǮ
ǸǢ dzǬǫ' Q ǭǵNǨLJN ƷN džƯDžDzǜ
M LJǎƴǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ ƵǯǚDZ# K ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ *ƱDZ' M Ljǃ Q LJǣǁƳ 'ǶǜLJN ǍN ƱǮDžDzǜ
P
K
GƱǺǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ ǶǴ GǶǨLJƷ ـƱDzǝǮ Ʊǔǹ# dzNjǣDZ !Ǹǎǫ' Q Ǫǝǣǹ AǶNJ ǶǴH ǭǵǬǺƴNJ DƱǀ
ILJƷ ǪǴ dzDzǜ FǶǫǶǦǹ Džǥ ƱưǺǍ K 'ǶǝDzǑǹ F# ـǭǴ QDžǓ dzǬǫ' Q IǶǩǍ ƶDZƱǨ ǧǬƷ ـƵǺǁǫ' Q
ـGƱDzǝDzǐ Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ
K
Ʊǔǹ# ǭǴƱǗǜ# dzDZQ # ƱǯǨ ǸƴDzƳ ȣ ǭǵǺǬǜ dzǬǫ' Q ǭǝDZ# N DžǦǫ ǷNJǶǮ ƵǬǀ1ƵǬǀ1 !ƱDzƺ# Fƪǫ'H fb
ǸǴ ƵǯǝQDzǫ' QFs ƲƯƱƾǜH *ƱǹƪƳ ƱǵƸƴQ ƺ Džǥ ǶǴH ǭǵƷLJǺNjǮ D'ǶǖN ǭ Oǵ OǮ QDžǦN NƸ Nǹ 1ƱDZ M N/Ƕǯǜ
FǶǯƸǵǹQ ǭǵQ
Dz ǩǫH ǰǺƴǟ'1 'Ƕǫ'2 ƱǮ FǶ ǺǬǺƯ'LJNJȫǫƱǢ
Q !ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǪǨQ ǭǵǫ *LJ Q ǸƸǫ'Q
ǢH
ƵǝǹLJǎǫƱƳ Q 'ǶǩNjP ǯʹ ǺǫO ƵǯǝQDzǫ' 'ǶǔǢ1 DžǦǫ ƵǝǹLJǎǬǫ Q
ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ 'HdžDŽ QƸǺǫ ƵǯǬǩǫ' FǶǔǢLJǹ ǭǵDZQ s EǶǺǫ' 3ƱQDzǫ' dzǬǝǣǹ ƱǮ ǕƴǔǫƱƳ Q 'džǴH
Q
ǶǬǁ Nǹ ƱǮ ǪǨ 'ǶǬǝǣǹ F# ǭǵDzǩǯǹ ƵǮǶǚDzǯǫ' GdžǴ Ǫǃ'/ ǭǵDZƫǫ ƱǺƴǴdžǮH Q K Q ƱK ǺǣƯƱǖ
Q K
ƱǮƱǚDZ
ƿǺNjǯǫ' ǸǢ ǭƸDZ#H ǧǫ0 'ǶǬǝǣƷ F# FǶǝǺǗƸNjƷ Ʊǫ ǭǩQDzǩǫH (ƱNjǁǫ' P ǰǮ 'ǶƸPǬǣʹ OǹH ǭǵǫ
Q
ƿǺNjǯǫ' ǸǢ 'ǶDZǶǩƷ Ǹǩǫ 1ǶǮƫǫ' GdžǴ ǪǨ ǰǜ 'ǶǝǗǦDzƷH 'ǶǦNDz NƸƷN F# ǭǩǫ ǸǠƴDzǹ 0s Q ʹ
Q ǷǬǜ H# EƱǚDZ Q
ǛDzǐ ǰǮ F' M Ljǃ M ǷǬǜ DǶǑǁǫ' Ǫƽ# ǰǮ Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1# LJưƳ M ǰǜ ǸǬDŽ QƸǫ' fc
ǭDzǩǯǹ# ǪƺP ƱǯǮ ǪǯǝƳ K
EƱǺǦǫ' dzDZƱǩǮȫƳ ƱǮ ƱǑDŽǍ QFƫƳ 1 QǶǑ QƸǫ' ǭǨ1HDžǦǯƳ ǪǴ LJǎƴǫ'
M
LJưƳ
M ǰǮ ƵƳdžǜ GƱǺǮ P ʹ O ǷǬǜ )1DžǦǫ'H ƵǺǀƱǬ
( LJ Ǎ Q Ǒǫ' Q ǧǬƸǯǹ FƱNjDZǿM ƵǺǬǦǝǫ'
Q ƵǫƱǁǫ'1 QǶǑƷ
Q
9/ƱǣǔǫƱƳ G$ƱǮ ƼǝƷ Q FƱNjDZƱǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ F' Q (ƱNj Q
P ǁPP ǫ ƱǵDzǜ ǷǬDŽƸǹ OdzDZ# LJǺǟ Q
M Ljǃ N Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1#
ƱǴLJǺǟH *ƱǺǬǺǣ Q Q
Ǘǫ'H *ƱǺǬǁ
Q Njǫ'H
Q
Q Q
ǰǜ 'ǶǬDŽƷ DžǦǫ LJǎƴǫ' dzƳ EƱǥ ƱǮ 'džǴ ƱǯDZs BƱǬǖȫǫ' ǷǬǜ ƱǺǦǗDzǮ K Q LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ HDžƴǹ Ʊǫ
*ƱDZ'
M LjǃQ ǛDzǑǫH *ƱDZ'
M Q
Ljǃ ǰǮ ǪǵQDzǬǫ Ƶ ǺǦǺǦǁǫ'
Q dzƷ1DžǥH ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' dzǬǫ'Q 9ǶƴDzǹ ƵǯǬǩǫ'
P P
K
ؼFǶǫǶǦǹ Ʊǔǹ# EǶǺǫ' dzƳ 'ǶǮƱǥ ƵǺǓƱǯǫ' 1ǶǑǝǫ' ǸǢ GǶǬǯǜ JdžǫƱǢ Ʊǔǹ# ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ Q
ǶǵǢ ac ILJǀƫǫƱƳ H# adb ƱǺǮ1s ǸǢ ƱDzǴ ƱDzǴ DǶǦǹ dzDZQ s ـƱDZ# ǸDZǶǨLJƷ( ـLJǫ' Q DƱǥ
ʹ
ـƵP Ǻȥ ǁN ǫ' GƱ ʹ
P ǺN ǯP ǫ' 9Ƕ N Ȝ
N ƴO Dzʹ Nǹ ƱDZ' ǸDZP ǶOǨLJN ƷN ـDǶǦǹ
Q
ǭǬǝDZH F'LjDŽǫ' 'džǴ dzǺǬǜ
P JǶƸǁǹ Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ ILJDZH F'LjDŽǫ' Q ǶǴ ƱǮ Fƪǫ' ǭǬǝDZ ƱDzDZQ s fd
GƱǺǯǫƱǢ 1dž N L dzDZQ s ǷDzƴʹ Oǹ ǡǺǨ Ʊǔǹ# K
M ǥ ǡǦNJ
M ǰǮ ǸƷƫǹH FƱNjDZƱǫ' DžǺƳ P 9ǶDzǑǮ !ǸǍ
L
ƿǗNjǫ'Q 'džǴ ǷǬǜ DžƽǶǹ ƱǮ ǪǨ Q ƱǵǝǮ ALJƾƷH 1džǥ ƿǗNJ ǷǬǜ ǕǦNj O ƷN DLjDzƷ Q
P M M P ǸƸǫ'
FƱNjDZƱǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ ƼǹLJǵǐ K
ǸǢ 'LJǺǃ# ǸǵƸDzƸǫ LJǎƴǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ ǪǗNj N
ǥ LJƴ Nǜ G1LJǯ O
Q Ʒ ǭƺ Q
M P M
AƱDzǐ#H 9/Ʊǣǔǫ' Q *ƱǺǬǁ
Q Q Njǫ' ǭǺƺ'LJƾǫ' N
ǪƻǮ Ǫǃ' QDžǫ' ǸǢ 3 QDžǩƸƷ *'1'džǦǫ' Q
ǪǨH
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' ab
ƵǣǺǚDZ LJǺǟ )1džǥ *ƱDZ'ǶǺǀ ƱǵDZQ s 'džǴ 'ǶǚǀƱǫ ƵǦǗDzǯǫ' ǸǢ )/ǶƽǶǮ ƵǵƳƱǎǮ ILJǃ#
ǸǢ DžƽP OH DƱǀ
P ǸǢH ƵǣǺǚDZ GƱǺǮ
M Ȧ 'džǵǢ /ǶǨ O1 ǡǟ'LJǍ
ǸǢ njǺʹ Nǝǫ' dzDzǩǯǹ Ʊǫ AǶǟLJʹ ǎǫ' P
؞EE /ǶǨLJǫ'
Q ǸǢ) ؟DžǨ'1 GƱǺǮ Odz N
M ǸǢ njǺǝǹ F# Ʋƾǹ ǣ ʹƸǀN ǷǦǬǹ AǶNjǢ ƵǣǺǚDZ M GƱǺǮ
M
ǸǢ njǺǝǫ' ǭǩDzǩǯǹ Ʊǫ EǶǺǫ' *ƱǺǬǺǣQ Ǘǫ'Ȧ GdžǴ ǰǮ DžǹDžǝǫ' ǛǮ DƱǁǫ' ǸǴ GdžǴ fe
FǶǫǶǦǹH ƵǯǬǩǫ' DžǓ ƵǮ'LJǑƳ ǭǵǢǶǥH ƲƴNJ ǶǴ 'džǴ ƵǎǝDz Oǯǫ' 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ' Q GƱǺǮ
Q K P ƷO ƱǵDZQ sـ
GƱǺǯǫ' *ƱDZ'Ljǃ ǰǮ 9ǶDzǫ' C'džǫ ƵƽƱǁƳ ǭǵDZƫǫ 'džǴ ـƱưǺǍ JHƱNjƷ ƱǫH ƱǵNjǣDZ ǒǥƱDz
KƱǬǝǢ ƵǦǺǦǁǫ' ǸǴ GdžǴ ƱǵǺǢ 'ǶǁƴNjǹ F# ǭǵǫ ǷQDzNjƸǹ Ǹǩǫ )DžǨ'LJǫ' Q
ILJǃ# *ƱDzƯƱǨH
M Q
ǡǟ'LJǎǫ'H *ƱǺǬǁ
Q Njǫ'H
Q Q ǷǬǜ ǤƴǗDzƷ ƱǵNjǣDZ ƵǫƱǁǫ'H
9/Ʊǣǔǫ'
F' Q
M LjDŽǫ H# ǛǦDzƸNjǯǫ
M ƵƽƱǁƳ ǸǴ )ƱǺǁǫ' DžǺǥ ǷǬǜ !ƱǦƴǫ' Ǫƽ# ǰǯǢ ƱǵNjǣDZ ƵǬǺǑǣǫ'
P ǰǮ
LJǺǺǠƷ ƱDzODzǩǯǹ ƱǫH ƱǵǺǢ 'ǶǎǺǝǹ FƫƳ ǸǔƸǦƷ Ʊǵ NƸǝǺƴǖ QFƫǫ )DžǨ'1 GƱǺǮ
M ǷǬǜ JǶƸǁǹ
dzƸǝǺƴǖ LJǺǠDZ
Q ǭǫ Fs
ʹ F'ǶǺǁǫ'
Q ƵǯǬǨ Ƿǫ' ǭǴDžǀƫƳ 'ǶƷƫƷ F# ǭǩDzǩǯǹ ƱǫH
dzƸǝǺƴǖ QF# ƱǯǫƱǖ ƱǵǬƴǦǹ GǶǬǝƾƷH dzǬǫ'
Q
dzǺǢ ǪǃDžǹ C'džDZ" dzǬǫ ǰƳs Q dzƸǝǺƴǖ D QDžƴƸƷ ƱǮDžDzǜH LJǺǠƸǹ
M ƿN ƴǑ
P ǺǫO dzǺǬǜ ƶDZƱǨ ƱǯǮ Q ǭǫ
Q
dzǬǫ' ƵǯǬǨ ƲƸǨ ǰʹ ǮN ǶǴ 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ'
Q QFs 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ'
Q
ǸǢ ƱDzǴ LJǓƱǁǫ' ǪǹƱǢ Ǹǫ 1ǶƸǨ/ LjǹLjǝǫ' ǸǦǹDžǐ ǛǮ EǶǺǫ' + QDžǁƷ# ƶDzǨ DžǦǫ ff
)DžǺǯǁǫ' *ƱǎǥƱDzǯǫ' ǒǝƳؽǒǝƳ 1HDžƷ ƱǮ ƱƴǫƱǠǢ K Q GdžǴ
ǧǫdžǫ ǸƷǶǴƱǫ dzDZQ s ƵǚǁǬǫ'
K'Džƽ ǰL ǗP ǢN ƵNJ QDžǦǯǫ' ƲƸǩǫ' DǶǀ ƱDzDzǺƳ ƱǯǺǢ
O Q Q Q O Q O
ǭǩ OƸǯǬǜ ǸƸǫ' !ƱǺǍƫǫ' ǪǩƳ ǭǨ OLJǨdž Oǹ AǶNJ ǶǴ 'džǴ 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ' ǭʹ ǩǺƷƫǹ ƱǮDžDzǜـف
ـƵǺƷ" 1ǶǮƫƳ
M ǭOǨ OLJƴP DŽʹ OǹH ƱǴƱ Qǹs
ac ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
ǸDZLJʹ ƴP DŽʹ Oǹ ǭǫ ǶǴH 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ' Q ǭ OƸǬʹ DZP ǭǩDZQ # ǷǬǜ ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' ǪǺǫ QDžǫ' F0s ʹ ǶǴ 'džǴ
C'0 ـǶǴ 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ' Q ƱDzƯƱDzƸǥ' ǷǬǜ FƱǴLJƴǫ' F0s ǶǴ 'džǴ ƮǖƱǃ !ǸǍ M JƫƳ
Q ƱǮǶǹ K
ƱǵǺǬǜ DǶǑǁǫ' ǭǩDZƱǩǮȫƳ FƱǨ Fs ـƵǯǬǩǫ' ǤǹDžǑƷ ǛǺǗƸNjǹ Jdžǫ'Q
ǶǴH ـƵDzNjǫƫƳ FǶǯǬǩƸƷ Q AǶNJ 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ' Q ǸƷƫǹ ƱǮDžDzǜ' ـDžƳ# K ǪǦǹ ʹ ǭǫ 9ǶNjǺǢ
!ƱǺǍƫǫ' ǧǬƷ ǰǮ JƫƳ ȧ FǶǮǶǦƷ AǶNJ 3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ' Q DǶǬǀ IDžǫ ǭǩDZQ ƫƳ 'DžƳ# K Ǫʹ ǦO Nǹ ǭǫ
F0s ƱDzǹDžǬǢ ـƵM ǺPN Ʒ" 1Ƕ Ȟ O ȟ ȥ Ȝ
M OǮƱƳP ǭʹ OǨ OLJƴP DŽʹ OǹHN ǭʹ OǨ OLJƴP DŽʹ OǹHN ǸPǫ Ʊǯȥ ǮP džǃO Ʊ Nǹ OdzDZƱǫ ـDƱǥ dzQDzǩǫH ƵK ƴN ǖƱǥP
3DžǦǫ' -HLJǫ'1Ƕǔǀ Q ǷǬǜ DžǺǨƫǫ'H ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' FƱǴLJƴǫ' dzNjǣDZ 9ǶNjǺǫ K
ƱǦ ʹ
Ǣ HP HN
Q
FHdžǠƸǹ 'Ƕǫ'2 ƱǮ ǸƸǫ'H Q 3ƱQDzǫ' !ƱǫƬǴ IDžǫ ǸƸǫ'Q !ƱǺǍƫǫ'H ljǺNJƱǀƫǫ' GdžǴ ǪǩǢ Q fi
H# ƵǣƯƱǖ Ƿǫ' D QǶǁƷ DžǦǫ FHLJƷ# 'džǴ ǭǵǢLJǑƷ Q ƲƴNJ FǶǢLJǝƷ ǭƸǁƴǐ# Fƪǫ'H ƱǵDzǮ
Q
)2ƱƸǯǯǫ' dzǬǫ' ƵǯǬǨؼƿP NƸNjʹ Oǯǫ' ǷǬǜ ƱǮ ƵǣƯƱǖ ljǺNJƫƷ ǰO Pǩǯʹ Oǹ ƱǫH )DžǨ'1 GƱǺǮ F' Q Ƿǫ'
M M M P Ljǃ
JDžǺNJ Q Q
Q Ʊǹ ƱǬǨ dzƸǺǯNjƷ H# dzǬǫ' ǰǺǺǝƷ ǰǩǯǯǫ' LJǺǟ ǰǮ dzDZQ ƫǫ ǪǺǁƸNj OǮ
ƵǯǬǩǫ' ǤǹDžǑƷ ǷǬǜ ǰǹ1/ƱǦǫ' ƱǬƻǮ K 5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' ǰǮ ƵǜƱǯƽ K džʹ ǃƫDz
O ǫP ƲƴNjǫ' Q ǭO OǨƱǴ g`
ǶǴ ƱǵNjǺNJƫƷ ǷǬǜ EƱǜ M 1HLJǮ DžǝƳ ƱǵDzǜ OdzǝǯNjƷ LJM ƴN ǃN DH#H Q ƱǮ ƵK ǯN ǚNȥ Dz OǮ FǶǦǬP Ǘʹ Oǹ ǭǴǶǜ N/
ǰʹ ǮN ǭǴ !ƱǫƬǵǢ ǭǵǝǮ !ǸǍ
M J# Q
Ȧ ǛǣDzǹ Ʊǫ ǰǹdžǫ' CƱDzǴ ـLjǺǩǹLJǫ'ـ Q ǰǮ ƵǜǶǯƾǮ /ǶƽH
Q dzǬǫ'
ƱǬǨ Q (ǶǬNJ# ljǺǫ 'džǵǢ ǧǫ0 DƱǺǀP ƱưǺǍ K FǶǝǺǗƸNjƷ ƱǫH 1ǶǮƫǫ' EƱǮLjƳ FǶǩNjǯ P Oǹ
K
ƹǺǀ ƱDZƱǩǮ ƿƴǐ#H F' Q Q
L 'džǵǢ dzǬǫ' (ǶǬNJ# ljǺǫ dzDZQ '
M Ljǃ Ƿǫ' D QǶǁƷ DžǦǫ /1'H LJǺǟ LJǮ#
ƼP Ǯʹ N/ ǪǺƴNJ ǸǢ LJǃ" LJǮ# ǭǵDzǮ /M LJʹ ǢN ǪǨQ
M J# Q ǷǬǜ H# C'0 ǷǬǜ H# LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ ǷǬǜ EHƱNjǹ P
ǭǵǺǫ' EƱǯǔDZǿ'
P ǰǮ 3ƱQDzǫ' ǰQǩǯƸǺǫ H# !Ʊǔǜƫǫ' ǒǝƳ
FǶǺǬǺƯ'LJNJƱǫ'
Q LJǣǀ EǶǹ N ƵNM DzǺȥ Nǝ OǮ Ƶǚǁǫ M ǸǢ ǤǬǗDZ' Džǥ EƱǚQDzǫ' 'džǴ QFƫƳ DžƾDZ ǰǁDZ ga
'ǶǝDzǐ ǰǹdžǫ'Q Ʊǔǹ# K ǰǺǺNjǹ Q LJǣǫ' Q ǰǮ ƵǜǶǯƾǮH L Ǫƽ1L CƱDzǴ FƱǨH *ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' Q ǧǬƷ
Q
ƵǹƱǫǶǫ' ǭǨƱǀH ǭǬǝǯǫ' 3H/HLJǺǴ Ƿǜ ʹDž Oǹ Ǫƽ1 ǭǴDžDzǜ FƱǨ *ƱDZ' Q
M Ljǃ
ǸƴDZ K Q FƱǨ DžǦǫ ǡƯ'ǶǗǫ' Q ǛǮ Odz NƸǥH ǛǺȧ ǔN Oǹ Ʊǫ Ǫƽ1
Ȣ LJN Oǹ ǭǫH ƱǺƴDZ M Ƿǫ' NǛǯP NƸNjǺǫ !Ʊƽ ǶǴH
ǶǵǢ ljǩǝǫ' ǷǬǜ ǪƳ ǡƯ'ǶǗǫ' Q ǧǬƷ IDžǀs Ƿǫ' EƱǹƫǫ' ǰǮ EǶǹ M J# ȧ ǸǢ ǭȥ ǔDZ' N Džǥ ǕQʹ ǥN
ƱKƳ'Ȝ ǭǺ P LJʹN Ƴ'ȡ ƱNDzNǫ ǭʹ OǩNjP ǣO DZʹ 'Ȝ Ǹ PǢ FǶ
O Ǵ' O
N ǫǶǦO ƷN 'ǶƯO PDž NƸƴʹ ƷN ƱǫH ـDǶǦǹ ǸƴQN
Ȧ Dzǫ' 'džǴ -'LJǢ Ʊǵǔ PǠƴʹ Oǹ FƱǨ
ـǭǺ
N Ǵ' N Ȝ
P LJʹN ƳƱȡ ǫ ' K/ƱǫHʹ ' )P 1N ƱƾN ǁP ǫ' GP džǴ ʹ P ǰʹ ǮP ǭǺ N ǦP Oǹ Fʹ ' 1L /ƱȜ P ǥN NdzǬǫ' Q ȥF'ȡ ǭʹ OǩNǫ DǶO ǥO 'Ȝ ǸDZȧ ƱǫȜ
FƱǨ C'0 EƱǦǯǫ' N ǸǫƱǝǫ'H dzǺǫs P ǸǠǑǹ Ǹǩǫ EƱǦǯǫ' ǛǺǢ1N ƱǬƽ1 K dzǺǫ'
P 'ǶǬNJN 1ƫǢ ʹ gb
Džǥ dzƽǶǫP ƱǵƽH K N
Odzǫ DǶǦǺǫ !Ʊƽ '0ƱǮ 'H1Ljǀ'H ʹ Ʊǵƽȥ HLjƷH Q Odz NƸƽH2 dzǺǃƫǫ Ʋ N NǬNJN Džǥ
ǪǔǢ# ǧN ǫ LJʹ NƸǃsN ʹ JDžǺNJ Ʊǹ ǪǔǣƷـ ʹ ȥ DǶǦǹH ǤQ ǁǫ' N ǷǬǜ OEHƱNjǹ AǶNJ OdzDZQ ƫƳ ODžǦƸǝDZ
ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' EǶǺǫ' ǧN ǮHDžǦƳ P K
' QDžƽ LDžǺǝNJ ƱDZ#ؼǧǺǬǜ ǸǠƴDzǹ FƱǨH ƱDzǴ 3ǶǬƾǬǫ ƵDzǩǮƫǫ'
ـǸǫ'
ȥ 9ƱǯƸNJȫǬǫ
ـǧǺ N ǃP 'Ȝ )O 'Ȝ LJN Ǯ' ʹ ǧN Nǫ FǶ N OǩƷN Fʹ 'Ȝ ǪȦ ǁP Nǹ Ʊǫـ K
N ƱǬƯƱǥ Odz Nǵƽ'HH N GǶǁDZ )K LJǍƱƴǮ ƱDzǀǶǹ E QDžǦƷ
dzƸưǺǗǃ ǷǬǜ OdzDŽȥ Q
N ƳHN dzDZ# BƱǬǖƱǫ' ǷǬǜ dzǫ dzǫƱǥ !ǸǍ M DO H# Q FƱǩǢ
!ƱNjDZ
M ǛǮ FǶǎǺǝǹ DƱƽLJǫ' Q ƹǺǀ O ) NDžǨ'1
P !ƱǮ M 6'Ƕǀ# N ƼO ƸʹP DzƷO ǡƯ'ǶǗǫ' Q QFs FHLJƷ# N gc
ljǺǫ ƵǚN ǦN Ǻǫ' N ƵǔǵDZ ǷǬǜ 'ǶǬǑǁƷ Ǹǩǫ ǂǔǫ' Q Ƿǫ' ƵƽƱǁƳ ǭƸNjǫ ـO1ǶNjȦO Dzǫ' OǛǯP NƸƾʹ ƷN NCƱNDz OǵǢN
Q
dzƳ EƱǺǦǫ' ǭǩǺǬǜ Jdžǫ' DžǺǀǶǫ' !Ǹǎǫ' Q FƱǨ !ǸǍ M J#
Q ,ƱƸDZȫǫ Q 'ǶǮǶǦƷ F# ǭǩǺǬǜ
ǂǔǫƱƳ
P
)DžǺƾǫ'HQ ƵƳdžǝǫ' Ƶƽ2ƱǗǫ' Q GƱǺǯǫƱƳ !ǶǬǯǮ ǶǵǢ ƲNjǁǢ ʹ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' Ƿǫ' 'ǶƷƫƷ F# ǶǴ
Q
1'LJǯƸNJƱƳ ǸǬǠƷ ƱǵDZs Ʊǵǫ ƵǹƱǵDZ ƱǫH E'H QDžǫ' ǷǬǜ
K
OLJǗP ǯʹ ƷO ƱǵƸǺǫ Ʊǹ ƱDzNjǀـ CƱDzǴ 'H/ Q/LJN ƷO FƫƳH F'LjDŽǫ' Q Ƿǫ' (ƱǴdžǬǫ Q ƵƽƱǁƳ ǭƸNjǫ ǭƸDZ# gh
FHLJƷ# (ـLJǎǬǫ Ȧ ƱǮ !ǸǎƳ M Ƿǚǁʹ DZN džPM ƯDžDzǜH )LJǺǚǁǫ' BǶǢ ƵǗN PǥƱNj NƸ Oǯǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' FLjȧ DŽO N DzǢ
)DžǺƽ Q L !ƱǮ ƱǵDzǮ Ǥ Q
ǢDžƸƷ Ƶ Qǹ2'Ƕ O
Ʒ 1ƫǫ' LJưƴǫ' GdžǵǢ ƵǫƱǁǫ' GdžǴ ǸǢ ljǺǫ Ʊǯ Q
DZ s Ǹǵǫ' Ʊǹ G"
KƱDzNjǀ ـDǶǦǬǫ ǰǹLJQ ǗǔǮ N ǭƸNjǫ ʹ ƱǵǺǬǜ N/ƱǯƸǜǿ' ǭǩODzǩP ǯʹ Oǹ ƵǜƱNjǫ' Q 1'DžǮ ǷǬǜ )/1ƱƳH
P
ƵǣǥǶ Q NƸ OǮ 1ƱǗǮƫǫ' ǰǩǫHQ dzDzǮ ǪO NǵDzDZ Ƿǔ Ǯ
N ƱǯǺǢ ƱQDz Ǩ DžǦǫ ǭǹDžǦǫ' F' Q
LjDŽǫ' C'0 DžǑP ǦDZ ʹ AǶNJ
Q ʹ
ـƵǢƱƽ ƿƴǑƷ Džǥ ǸǵǢ N ǭǩǫ Odz OƸǬǥ ƱǮ 'džǴ ƵǬǹǶǖ )LJƸǢ M džDzǮ
DǶǃ QDžǫ' ǭǩDzǩǯǹ LJǎƴǫ' JDžǹƫƳ ƵǜǶDzǑǯǫ' ƵǯǚDZƫǫ' GdžǴ ǒǝƳ dzǺǬǜ ǸǴ ƱǮ 'džǴ gi
J#
Q H#ؽH# !ƱǺǍƫǫ' ǒǝƳ ǛǺƴǫ )LJǺƴǨ ƵƳƱǑǜP 1ǶǮƫǫ' ǒǝƳ ǭǩǹDžǫ FƱǨ '0% CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ'
Q ǸǢ *ƱǬǣǁǫ' ǭǺǚDzƷH ǶƷǶǬǫ'
ǤƳƱǗǫ' Q ƲP PǝNǬNǨ ILJǃ# '1ǶǮ#H
K K )K LJǺƴǨ '/ƱǺǜ#
ƱǬƻǮ K ƱǮ +M NDžǀN
Q ʹǩ OǮ ƵǢLJǠǫ' FHDžƾƷ AǶNJ CƱDzǴH ƱǴLJǺǟH ǸǬǣNjǫ'
3ƱDzǫƱƳ ƵǚƸ Q
CƱDzǵǢ FƱǺNǬǠǫ'
N ǭƯ' QDžǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 DžƽǶǹ ƹǺǀ FƱǩǯǫ' Ƿǫ' FǶƴǴdžƷ ƱǮDžDzǜ ƱǯDZQ %
ƱǵǺǬǜ /ƱǯƸǜƱǫ' ǭǩDzǩǯǹ )DžǺƾǫ'
Q )/1Ʊƴǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' ǰǮ FHǶƷLJǹ M 5ƱDŽǍƫƳ FǶǦƸǬƷ AǶNJ
'džǴ ƲDZƱƾƳ ǭƸǎǜ '0' ـƵǔǵDZ Ƶ QǹƫƳ 'Ƕǚǁǹ ǭǫ *'ǶDzNJ LJǎǜ džDzǮ ـFǶǫǶǦƷ ǭƸDZ#
)LJǯƸNjǮ
Q ƵǔǵDZ
M ǸǢ ǶǵǢ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ'
LjǬǹǶǫ' /ƱǬƳ ƶǬǑǀ ƱǮDžDzǜ )LJǮ Q *'0 H# LjǬǹǶǫ' ǰǮ 1 QDžǁN NƸ Oǯǫ' ǪƽLJǫ'
Q C'0 DƱǥ ƱǯǨ h`
K
ƱǔǝƳ QFs )Džǁ QƸǯǫ' *ƱǹƱǫǶǫ' ǰǮ *ƱǺǑDŽ Q Q 1ƱƴǨ ǰǮ ǒǝƳ
ǎǫ' L ƱǵǺǫ' NdzƽǶƷ
Q ƱǵƸǔǵDZ ǷǬǜ
ƱǯǜH
Q FƱǩǯǫ' ǰǜ JLJǁ N
Q QƸǬǫ LjǬǹǶǫ' /ƱǬƳ 'HDžǑN ǥ !ƱǫƬǴ EƱǚǝǫ' P *ǶǴƱǬǫ' )LJƷƱǨ/
P ǰǮ
ǡǬDŽǫ' Ƿǫ' ƵǢǶǣǬǯǫ' ǭǵƷƱǥƱǺƳ ǰǺǦDZƫƸǮ 91'Ƕǎǫ' Q ǸǢ FǶǬ ȥƸǣN NƸǹ 'ǶDZƱǨ DžǦǫ CƱDzǴ JLJƾǹ
)ƫǢDžǯǫ'
P ƲǺƳƱDZƫƳ ƵǵǺƴǎǫ' Q ǭǵƷƱǝƴQ ǥ ǰǹLJǯ NƸ ʹǝ OǮH
ƲǺǬǑǫ' N NǵƳ - ȧǶNǬǹ ǶǴH ǪǑǹ LJǺǠǐ ƵǖLJǍ Ǫƽ1 '0ǶǴH
Q ǷǬǜ ـOLJǣȧ ǑN OǹH dzPP ƷH'LJ N
QǪǨ dzP ǯNJǿ
P K Ǘȥ ǁN OǮ dzǺǫ'
ǸƴǬǥ LJN ȥǵǖ CƱDzǴ Odz OǮ/ ǭǫƫǫ' ǰǮ Ʊǯ P ƶưƽO ǸǑǬDŽȧ OǮ *ƱǮ ƹǺǀ
Q ǸǢ ǷǎQ ǯN NƸ Nǹ ǶǴH ـDžƾǯǫ'
91Ʊǎǫ'
O
Q Ʊǵ Qǹ#' ـǶǫƱǦǢ ـOdzǫƫNjDZ
ـDžǺQ Njǫ' O ƱDz
ǭȥ ǬǴ K QǹDžƸ OǮ ƱǬƽ1
K HDžƴǹ dzDZQ s 'ـǶǫƱǥ džưDzǺǀ
M
ـJDžǺNJ ǭǝDZ( ـƱƽ#
ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ƱDzǺƷ# DžǦǫ 'DžǢH K ǪQǩǎDZ ǰǁDZ
O )Džǁ QƸǯǫ' *ƱǹƱǫǶǫ' ǰǮ ƱDzưƽ ǰǁDZ ـDƱǥ
ƱDzưƽ DžǥH *ǶǴƱǫ )LJƷƱǨ/ ǰǁDzǢLjǬǹǶǫ' /ƱǬƳ ǸǢ ƵǮǶǜLjǯǫ' ƵǔǵQDzǫ' DǶǀ ǤǺǦǁƸƳ EƱǺǦǬǫ
ODžǦN ʹǝƷO ǰǹ#H ƵǔǵQDzǫ' GdžǴ ǸǴ ǰǹ# ALJǝDZ F# Ȧ/ǶN DZN ـAƱǓ# ǭƺ Q ـLJǮƫǫ' ƱǮ ILJDzǫ ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ'
*ـƱǜƱǯƸƽǿ'
ǸǴ LjǬǹǶǫ' ƵǔǵDZ ـǰǺǮ" ـLjǬǹǶǫ' ƵǔǵDZ ǶǴ ƱDZ# DžǺNjǫ' N Ǭʹ ǐN HN DžǦǫ( ـƱƽ#
Q Ʊǵ Qǹ# ƶ
ـFǶǩƷ F# Ʋƾǹ ƹǺǀ ƱDzǵǴ ƱǵDZQ s ǸǬǃ'/ ǸǢ
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' af
)ƱǺǁǫ' !ƱǮ 9ǶƴDzǹ ǰǮ (LJǦǫƱƳ njǺǝDZ ƱǮDžDzǜ ƱǵǺǬǜ FǶǩDZ ǸƸǫ'Q ƵǫƱǁǫ' ǸǴ GdžǴ ha
dzDZQ % ƵǹƱǵDZ dzǫ ljǺǫ ǸǬǠǹH ǸǬǠǹH ǸǬǠǹH ǸǬǠǹ ǶǵǢ ƶǥǶǫ' D'Ƕǖ Ǹǀ Ȣ dzDZQ s 'džǴ
K ȥ N
ـLJǗǯǫ' ǒǝƴƳ 'LJǃƬǮ ƱDzǯ PǝDZ Džǥ ƱQDzǨ F% !Ʊǯǫ' ǒǝƳ ǧǫƱDzǴ FƱǨ F% ILJDzPǫ ƱDzƳ ǭǬǴـ Q ljǺǫ
K
ƱDZƱƾǮ O Nǹ dzDZQ % DǶǥ# ƶDzǨ
G!ƱǮ ƿDzǯ O ƱǯǨH C'0 Ǹǁǫ' !Ʊǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ dz Q
DZ % 'džǩǴ ljǺǫ Ʊǫ
Q
dzǫƱNJ1% Ǫƴǥ ƵǺǯǺǬǝ
Q P ǒǝƳ )!'LJǦǫ dzǺǬǜ ǛǥN OLJǫ' ǛǓǶǫ FǶƽƱƸǁƷ Ʊǫ ǭǩDZQ s hb
QƸǫ' BLJN DŽǫ'
ǪǩǎƳ
M ƱǵǚǣǬǹ FƱǨ ƱǮ '0% Ʋƾǹ ƱǯǨ *ƱǯǬǩǫ' ƲƸǩǹ FƱǨ '0% ƱǮ ƵǢLJǝǮH LJǺǎƴƸǬǫ
ǰǮ DžǹDžǝǫƱǢ *ƱǣǑǫ'HQ ƱǴLJǺǟH LJƯƱǯǔǫ'H Q !ƱǯNJƫǫ' EDžDŽƸNjǹ FƱǨ ƱǮ '0' ƿǺǁǐ
9ǶƴDzǺǫ' DžDzǜ njǺǝǹ D'2 ƱǮ ǶǴ D'Ƕǀƫǫ' ǪǨ Q ǸǢ dzQDzǩǫH LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ FǶǬǵƾǹ ǭǵDzǺƳ
D'Ƕǀƫǫ' ǪǨ Q ǸǢ FHLJƷ#
Q
*ƱǔǵQDzǫ' Ƿǫ' ƱǫH ƮǬƸǯǹ Ǹǩǫ ƵǺQ Ǭǁǯǫ' 1ƱǗǮƫǫ' ǷǬǜ /ƱǯƸǜȫǬǫ 'K LJQ ǗǔǮ
N ljǺǫ dzDZQ s hc
Q
CƱDzǴ dzǺǢH dzDzǮ ƱǯǴ dzƷ1ƱǵǖH dzƷ1Džǥ QFƫǫ 'džǴ Ǫǩǫ ƵƽƱǁƳ ljǺǫ dzDZQ s ƵǺQ Ǭǁǯǫ' Q
dzƴǬǥ ǸǢ ƱǵǫƱƴǦƸNJ' ǰǮ ƱǮ ǏDŽǍ
L ǰO QǩǯƸǹ ƱǮDžDzǜ ƵǐƱDŽǫ' Q ƱǵƷ1Džǥ ƱǵDZQ s ƵǯǬǩǫ' DžƽǶƷ N
Q K O
LJǐƱDzǝǫ' GdžǴ ǪǨ ǸǴ ƱǵƷ'0 ǸǢ Ʊǔǹ# ƱǵƷ1DžǥH ƱǵƴǬP ǐO ǸǢ ƵDzƯƱǨ ǸǴ ƱǵƷ1ƱǵǗǢ
)ƱǺǁǫ' ǤǢQ NDžƸƷ ƱǵDzǮH ƱǵƷ'0 QDžǁƳ ƵǯǬǩǫ' ǸǢ ƵNǬǐƫƸǮ P
ƲǜƱƸǯǫ' FǶǵƽ'Ƕǹ 'ǶDZƱǨ džưƸǥH
M dzDzǜ FHDžǝƸƴǹ FǶǺǬǺƯ'LJNJƱǫ'
Q FƱǨ ƱǮDžDzǜ hd
ǪǨƱǎǯǫ' ǭǵǓLJ NƸǝƷN ƶDZƱǨ dzDzǜ ǭǵǵƽǶƳ FǶǁǺǎ Oǹ 'ǶDZƱǨ )M LJǮ ȧ ǸǢ ƲǜƱǑǯǫ'
Q ǪǨ
'džǴ ǛǮ Ǫǐ'ǶƷ O ǷǬǜ ƵǔǵQDzǫ' FǶǩƷ Ʊǫ ƱǮDžDzǜ EǶǺǫ' ƱDzǝǮ ǪǑǁǹ dzNjǣDZ !Ǹǎǫ'H Q
Q O
GƱǺǮ *ƱDZ'LjǃH 1ƱƳƪǫ' ƱǵNjǣDzǫ LJǣǁƷ ƵǔǵQDzǫƱǢ F0s ƱǵDzǮ ǷƽLJʹ Ʒ )DžƯƱǢ ǰǮ ƱǯǢ LJǮƫǫ'
ǸǵƸDzƷ ǸǴ ƱǴH )DžǨ'1
ƱǮDžDzǜ džƯDžǝƳ
M CƱDzǴ LJǯǀƫǫ' LJǁƴǫ' DžDzǜ *ƱǍǶǍǶǫƱǢ ƱǯƯ'/K ǭǴDžǜƱNjǹ FƱǨ dzQDzǩǫH he
K Q
FƱǨ DžǦǫ ǭǵǫ 'DžǜH ƫǎDZ# DžǦǫ ǭǴDžǜH Džǥ ǶǵǢ dzǬǨ 'džǴ ǛǮH ƱǯDZQ sؼFHLJǮdžƸǹ Q 'ǶDZƱǨ
Q K
NDžǜHN Džǥ FƱǨ dzDZ# LJǺǟ LJǮƫǬǫ ǰǁDZ ƱDzƷLJǚDZ ƲNjǁƳ CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ƵǺDZƱƺ ǭǴ NDžǺǝ Oǹ F# ǸǠƴDzǹ
ILJǃƫǫ' ƵǣQ ǔǫ'
Q Ƿǫ' ǭǵǫƱǑǹȫƳ
ǭǵǺƴDZQ FƱǴLJƳH *ƱƴƺȫǨ GLJǺǟH 1ƱQDzǫ' N/Ƕǯǜ ǪǺƯ'LJNJ% !ƱDzƳƫǫ LJǢȥ HN DžǦǫ ǪǝǢ N '0ƱǮ
LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ ƲǜƱƸǯǫ' 6LJƸǝƷ ƱǮ ƱƴǫƱǟH K LJǯǀƫǫ' LJǁƴǫ' Ƿǫs CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ǭǴH/Ʊǥ ǭǴH
Q
F'LjDŽǫ' ǧǫ0 ƿƸǢ DžǦǫ dzǬǫ' ǪǝǢ '0ƱǮ FH1DžƷN ǪǴH dzǍǶǺƽ ǛǮ FǶǜLJǣǫ' ǪǐH ƱDzǴH
Q
)DžǨ'LJǫ'
Q GƱǺǯǫ' ǰǮ LJǯǀƫǫ'
ƵǫƱǀ ǸǢ ǶǴH ƱǬǝǢ K ƶǺǮ K
Q dzDZQ s ǭǫƱǝǫ' ǸǢ ƱƷǶǮ Q ǶǴ ƶǺǯǫ'
LJƻǨƫǫ' !Ǹǎǫ' Q LJǁƴǫ'
dzǺǢ njǺǝǫ' OdzODzǩP ǯʹ Oǹ !ǸǍ
M ǰǮ ƱǮ /ǶǨ1
O
F# ǭǵǺǬǜ ljǺǫ ƹǺǀ Ƿǫ' ǭǵNǬǦN DZN DžǦǫ ILJǃƫǫ' Ƶǵƾǫ' ǰǮ ǭǴ1LJȥ ǀH N dzǁƸǢ
N DžǦǫ
ǪƺƱǯ
M M ǶƳ
OǮ BƱƺ P ǰǺǥǶƺǶǮ 'ǶDZǶǩǹ
Q
*ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' ǧǬƷ ǷǬǜ /ƱǯƸǜǿ' FǶǝǺǗƸNjǹ Ʊǫ ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ 'ǶǣǎƸǨs CƱDzǴ !'LJǁǑǫ'
Q ǸǣǢ hf
ǸǢH LJǃ" Ƿǫ' ǛǦDzƸNjǮ Q
ǰǮ FǶƴǴdžǹ 'ǶDZƱǩǢ FǶƻǁƴǹ 'Ƕǀ'1 ƵǢƱƽ ƶDZƱǨ ƱǵDZQ ƫǫ
M
C'0 Ƿǫ' 'ǶǵƽǶƷ
Q )Džǀ'H !ƱǮ
M ƵǗǦDzǫ
P FǶǥǶƸǹH Ʊț ǯN ǚǫ'
N ǰǮ FǶƷǶǯǹ 'ǶDZƱǨ !'LJǁǑǫ'
Q
ag ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
K
DžǦǫ Ʊǔǹ# ƱK ǢƱƽ
Q dzP ƳP '0sH LJǃ" FƱǩǮ Ƿǫ' 'ǶǬǦƸDZƱǢ ƱK ǢƱƽ
Q FƱǨ DžǦǫ ǛǦDzƸNjǯǫ' F'LjDŽǫ'Q
M
Q GƱǺǮ
(LJǎǬǫ M K
ǷǬǜ ƱǮ ƱǮǶǹ 1Ƕƻǝǫ' ƵǺDZƱǩǮs
Q ǰǮ ǪǮƫǫ' 'HDžǦǢ
ǷǬǜ 'HLJƻǜ CƱDzǴ !'LJǁǑǫ' Q ǸǢ 1ǶȦ ǑN QƸǫ' ǰǜ FǶǩǹ ƱǮ DžǝƳƫǫ' FƱǩǯǫ'
M ǸǢH džƯDžǝƳH
M
ȥ
ǷǬǜ ǛǥǶN NƸ OǮ LJǺǠǫ' FƱǩǯǫ' ǸǢ )LJDŽǐ
M ǸǢ FƱǨ CƱDzǴ )LJDŽǐ
M ƲǬǥ
P ǸǢ FƱǨ DžǦǫ !Ʊǯǫ'
)LJDŽǐ
M ǸǢ )Džǀ'H !ƱǮ ƵǗǦDZ dzǺǢ Džƾǹ F# FƱNjDZǿ' ǷǬǜ ǪǺǁƸNjǹ ƹǺǀ BƱǬǖƱǫ'
Q
FƱǩǯǫ' ǸǢ GdžǴ ǪƻǮ !ƱǺǍ# ǛDzǑǹ dzǬǫ' QF% FHLJƷ# ǰǩǫH !'LJǁǑǫ' Q ǕP NJN HN ǸǢ ƵǢƱƽQ
K
ƱǯƯ'/ K
ǪǑǁǹ FƱǨ ƱǮ 'džǴ Ƶ Qǹ/ƱǺƸǜ% LJǺǠǫ' ƵǬǺNJǶǫ'H ƱǫƱǯƸǀ' Q
Ǫǥƫǫ'
ǡƯ'ǶǗǫ'H Q ƲǴ'džǯǫ' ǰǮ ǭDŽǓ LǛǯQ ƾN ƷN ƱDzǹDžǫ FǶǩǹ F# ǸǠƴDzǹ dzDZQ ƫƳ ǒǝƴǫ' DžǦƸǝǹ hg
ǛǮ ǭǵǔǝƳ AƱǫƪǫƱƳ 'ǶDZHƱǝƸǹH 3ƱQDzǫƱƳ FƱǩǯǫ' Ƽǝǹ Q FƫƳH ƱǝǮ K ǭǵǬǨ Q 'ǶǝǯƸƾǹ FƫƳH
ƵǔǵDZ ǷǬǜ DǶǑǁǫƱƳ ǭǵDzǮ Ƶƴǟ1 LJǮƫǫ' 'džǵƳ ǛǺǯƾǫ' ƲǀLJǺǢ K Q ǒǝƳ
ǷƸǀ dzƸ QǹDžƾƳ# ALJǝǹ Ʊǫ Jdžǫ' ǕǺNjƴǫ' ǪƽLJǫ' Q Q
Q dzǬǫ' EDžDŽƸNjǹ FƱǺǀƫǫ' ǒǝƳ ǸǣǢ
ǭǵDzǺǯǹ ǰǮ ǭǵǫƱǯǍ FǶǢLJǝǹ /ƱǩǫƱƳ ǰǹdžǫ' ǰǺǺǮ Q Q Ʊǫ' Ȟ 5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' ǰǮ ƵǜƱǯƽ M ǕP NJH ʹ ǸǢH
ƱDzǀǶǹ EƱ Qǹ# ǸǢ dzǬǝǢ ƱǮ ǕƴǔǫƱƳ Q 'džǴ ǭǫƱǝǫ' LjǵƷ Q F# ƱǵDZƫǍ ǰǮ ƵǔǵDZ M )1ƱƺȫƳ dzǬǫ' Q EǶǦǹ
J#
ȧ ǷǬǜ 'LjƯƱǀ K FƱǨ !ƱǫƬǴ ǰǺƳ ǰǮ Džǀ# M ǰǮ ƱǯǢ !ƱǺƴDZƫǫ' EƱ Qǹ# ǸǢ dzNjǣDZ !Ǹǎǫ'H Q
ǭǵƸǗNJ'ǶƳ LjN ƾDZ#H N ǭǵǮDžDŽƸNJ' Džǥ dzǬǫ' ǰǩǫH Q Q ǭǵƳ ƱDzƸǢLJǝǮ ƲP Njǁ N ƳP ƵǢƱǦƻǫ' ǰǮ 9ǶDZ M
Ƶǯƽ Q !ƱǺǍ# N
Ƿǫ' LJǮƫǫ' 1Džǐ# ǰʹ ǮN ǶǴH )LJDŽǑǫ' Q FƱǨ ǶǴ GƱǺǯǫ' ƶP ƽLJ N ǃN P)LJDŽǑǫ' Q GdžǴ ǰǮP hh
ƱǵǁDzǮH
N ƵǣǺǚQDzǫ'H Ƶƽ2ƱǗǫ' Q ƵǺǦQ Q Dzǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' 6ƱǢ#H N (LJN ǔʹ ƷO F# Ʋƾǹ )LJDŽǑǫ' Q GdžǴ
L
ǤƳƱǗ ƷN ƱǵǴƱǺǮ ǰǮ !'ǶƷ1ǿƱƳ ǰǺƴǟ'LJǫ' Q Q
Q ǪǨ ǏǬǃN DžǦǫ (LJǎǫƱƳ Q Ʋ ȧ
N ǟP 1N ǰʹ ǮN ǪǨ Ƿǫ' )1'LjǠƳ
afc ƱQDzǀǶǹ ǛǮ ƵǬǮƱǍ )L '2'ǶǮH ǪL ǮƱǩ P NƸ OǮ
ǰO ǮP Ƭʹ Oǹ ǰʹ ǮN ǪȦ OǨ ǧN ǬP ʹǵ Nǹ ƱǬǢؼ N NDžǺǀP ǶN ǫ'ʹ OdzNDzƳʹ ' DN džNN Ƴ Ƿ ȥƸǀN ǭN NǫƱ Nǝǫ'ʹ OdzǬǫ' Q Ʋȥ ǀN 'Ȝ 'džN N ǩǴؼ
Ƶ QǹDžƳƫǫ' )ƱO ǺN ǁN ǫ'ʹ OdzNǫ OFǶOǩƷN ǪNʹ Ƴ dzP ƳP
ƱǯǺǩǫ dzǺǬǜ ƱDzƸDZǶDzǹ/ ƱDz OǯʹǩǀO ǛǥHH N ƵƻƾǬƾǫ' ǷǬǜ )LJDŽǑǫ' Q ǧǬƷ (LJǓ dzǬǫ' Q QFs hi
K
dzDZQ s Ƶ QǹDžƳƫǫ' )ƱǺǁǫ' Ʊǔǹ# ƱDZ# Ǹǫ ǸDzǁDzǯǹH ǭǩǁNO Dzǯʹ ǺNJ Q
N Jdžǫ' )ƱǺǁǫ' -H1 ǸƷƫǹ dzDzǮ
ƱDzǵǴ ƵǹLJƴǫ' Q GdžǴ ǸǢ ƱǵDzǜ ǪǮƱǩƸǮH L LJL ƴȧ Nǝ OǮ ǪL NƻǮN
ƱǯDZQ s dzǬǨ Q 'džǴ ǰǮ !ǸǍ Ʊǫ ǂQ ǔǬǫ Q ƱǫH LJǣǁǬǫ ƱǫH Ʋǁʹ NjǬǫ Q Ʊǫ 'DžƳ# K 'HLJQ ǗN ǔʹ Oǹ ǭǫ ǭǵDZQ s i`
!Ʊǯǫ' ƲP ǁʹ Njǫ N ƵƽƱǁƳ 'ǶDZǶǩǹ ǭǫ ƱDZƱ K ƾǮ Q ǭǵǫ ƱǵǮ QDžǥ ǸƸǫ'Q ƵǬǺNJǶǫ' ǧǬƸƳ C'LJƸǍǿ' ǕǦǢ
'ǶƽƱƸǁǹ ǭǫ Ƕǫ P QDžǫ' ƵǗNJ'ǶƳ !ƱǮ K 'ǶǦƸNjǹ Fƫǫ ǰǹLJQ ǗN ǔʹ OǮ 'ǶDZǶǩǹ ǭǫ ƱǮ ǛM ǦDz N NƸNjʹ OǮ ǰǮ
ǭǵǫ FǶǩǹ F# IǶNJ !ǸǍ M JƫƳ
ȧ EƱǺǦǫ' ǭǵǺǬǜ ǰǩǹ ǭǫ dzǺǬǜ DǶǑǁǫ' Ǫƽ# ǰǮ njM DZʹ Ƕǫ P
dzǺǢ ƵK Ǒǀ Q
ǭǨ2O ǶP ʹǝ Oǹ Ʊǫ !ǸǍ Jƫǫ Q 'ǶǯǔDzƷ Q Fƫǫ ƵƽƱǁƳ ǭƸNjǫ Fƪǫ' dzǬǝǢ ƱDzǺǬǜ ƱǮ ǪǨ Q 'džǴH
K Q O N
ǭƸNjǫ ƱǮ ƱưǺǍ 'ǶDŽǔƷ F# H# ƱǮ ƱưǺǍ 'ǶǝDzǑƷ F# ƱǫH ƿƳdžǯǫ' EƱǮ# /ǶƾNjǫ'H K Q 9ǶǨLJǫ' Q
ǭǩ OƸǠǫ ƿN ƴǑ P O
Ʒ F# Ƿǫ' *'
M LJǮ
Q )N QDžǜH ) N QDžǜH ) N QDžǜ ƱǵNjǣDZ ƵǯǬǩǫ' 'H/ ȧ
/LJ O
Ʒ Fƫǫ ƵƽƱǁƳ
ƵǬǺNJǶǫ' dzDZQ % ƱDZƱ K ƾǮ Q dzǺǢ ƵǨ1Ʊǎǯǫ' ǶǴ dzƳ EƱǺǦǫ' ǭǩǺǬǜ Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ' !Ǹǎǫ' ƵK ǍN ȥǶǎN OǮ
ljǺǫ ƲNjǀH ʹ K
ƱDZƱƾǮ dzDzǮ 'HdžǃO ǪƳ 'džǴ ǰǮ !ǸǍ Ʊǫ ǛǢʹ N/ ƱǫH ǂǓ Q Ʊǫ dzǬǫ' Q ǰǮ ƵǮN ȥDžǦN Oǯǫ'
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' ah
ǰǺưǺNjǫ' ȧ K
Q 5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' ǏǬDŽǺǫ !Ʊƽ Džǥ ǪƳ ǰǺǁǫƱǐ ƱǐƱDŽǍ# ǏǬDŽ Oǹ ǸǩPǫ *ƫǹ ȧ N P ǭǫ dzDZQ s
ـǰǺưǺNJ Q ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ ǭǵNjǣDZ# FǶǢLJǝǹ ǰǹdžǫ'Q ǧưǫH#H
ؼـƱDzNjǀـK DƱǦǢ
Q
ـǧǫdžǨ ljǺǫ# ǭQDzǵƽO Ƿǫ' (ƱǴdžǫ' DžǹLJƷ Ʊǫ ƶDZ# N ʹǛǯNJ% ـƶǬǥ O
ـƱǬǨ ـDƱǥ
Q 'K LJǗǔǮ
ƲǴdžƷ Ʊǫ Ǹǩǫ *ƱǮ Džǥ ǶǵǢ CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' (ƱǴdžǬǫ Q N
ƶNjǫ ƶDZ# K
N ƱDzNjǀـ O
ƶǬǥ id
ـCƱDzǴ Ƿǫ'
ـǪǝǢ# F# Ʋƾǹ '0ƱǮ ـDƫNjǢ
N ƷN ƱǯǮ
ـ1 QǶǑƸ O
Q ǪǵNJ# LJǮƫǫƱǢ !ǸǍ Ʊǫ ـƶǬǥ
ؼـǛǺǗƸNJ# ǸDzƸǺǫ Ʊǹ EǶǹ *'0 ǰǩǫH( ـƱƽ#
)1ƱƾǺNjǫƱƳ LJǺǩǣ QƸǫ' ǰǜ ǡQ OǨ ǰǺǃDž QƸǫ' ƵǑǥ Q Ƿǫ' '/ K ȥDžƾN OǮ /ǶǝƷ ƶDZ# N ƱǴ ـƶǬǥ O ie
!ǸNJ N N Q
N ƱǯƳ Ʊǫ dzǺǬǜ ǶǴ ƱǯƳ OdzǬǝǢ JdžǫƱƳ ǕǦǢ ǶǴ dzP ƳP LJQǩǢ 'džǴ LJQǨdžƷ N
Q ƶDZƫǢ dzǺǬǜ ƶDZ#
EƱǹƫǫ' ǰǮ EǶǹ M J# K
ȧ ǸǢ ƱưǺǍ JHƱNjƷ ǰǫH ƱưǺǍ K JHƱNjƷ ƱǮǶǹ K K
ǰǩƷ ǭǫH ƱưǺǍ JHƱNjƷ Ʊǫ
!ǸǎǫƱǢـ Q ƶǬǥ Q
O ǭN ƺO !ـǸǍ ǪǨ JHƱNjǹ Jdžǫ' Džǀ'Ƕǫ' Q P ǶǴ ǶǴ dzDZQ ƱǢ dzǺǬǜ ǶǴ ƱǮ ǰǩǫH
F# IǶNJ F0' ǧǺǬǜ N ƱǯǢ CƱDzǴ ǧDZƱǩǮN džǃ# dzDZQ # ƱǯƳ ǶǴ dzƳ EƱǺǦǫ' ǧǺǬǜ N Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ'
N O Q Q
N OdzǬƴN ǦƷ F# ǶǴ OdzǬ ʹǝ PǢ ǧǺǬǜ ƱǮ ǪǨ dzƳ EƱǥ Jdžǫ' Ǫǯǝǫ' Ʊǜ
ـƲʹ Njʹ ǀH K Ƕʹ ǖN ǪN ƴN ǦƷN
ـǧǫ0 ǪǝǢ# AǶNJ 'Džƽ K ǕǺNjƳ L ʹ dzDZQ s ـDƱǥ ـƱǯDZQ sـ
LJL Ǯ#
OdzƷO ʹDžǯǜH
ȥ ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' F0s OdzƷO LJʹ ǔN ǀ# ʹ FHLJƷ ـƵǺǥƱNJ Ƶǯȥ ƺN ƱDzǴ '0ǶǴ ـƶǬǥ O džƯDžDzǜ
M if
O
ƶǬǝǢ ƱǯǮ P Džǥ ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ ǭǬǜ# ƱDZ#ؽƱDZ#H ƱDzǴ FǶNjǬƾǹ dzƸǬƯƱǜ ǰǮ /'LJǢ# Ƶǯȥ ƺN
Q 'HLJDŽNJ
O
IDžǫ QFƫƳ ƶǚǀƱǫ O
DžǦǫ OdzǬǝǢ# Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ ƱǮƱǯƷ
K K 1 ʹDž OǮ ƶDzǨ
ƱǨ O ǸDzQDzǩǫH ƱǩK ǁP ǔʹ OǮ GHDžƽHH
P
ǸǝǮ Odz OƸƴʹ ǁǗǐƱǢ
ʹ dzǹDžǫ !Ǹǎǫ' Q 'džǴ ljP ǯʹ Nǫ ǰǮ ƶDz O QǩǯƷ DžǥH ƱK ǺǦǺǦǀ
Q K
ƱưǺǍ ǪƽLJǫ'
Q 'džǴ
ƿǺNjǯǫ' 9ǶNjǹ ǭNJȫƳ OdzƷO ʹDžǯǜHQ
)LJƾǍ
M ʹ
ǰǜ Ʊǹ$1 ǷǬǜ ƱDzǬǑǀ DžǦǫ dzPDzƳ% DLjDzǮ Ƿǫ' ƶO ʹǵƽQ ǶƷ
N )LJǺǑǥ
M )LJƸǣƳ
M 'džǴ DžǝƳH
G N/Ƕǯǜ ǭǗN ǁǹ
N /ƱǩǹH OǛǦǹ ǪP ƽO LJǫƱƳ
Q '0sH ǰǨƱǮƫǫ' Džǀ# ǸǢ )/ǶƽǶǮ ƶDZƱǨ )1ǶNjǩǮ
Džǥ ǰǺǃDž QƸǫ' QFƫƳ (LJǫ'
Q Ǹǫ ǰ
N Q ǧǬƷ ǸǢH ǷǣǎƸNjǯǫ' Ƿǫ' Odz OƸǬʹ ǦNN DzǢ JLJ
NǬ ʹǜ# ƵǬǺǬǫ' Q ǦN ǣǫ'
P
N
K
ǸǓƱǯǫ' ǰǮ ƱưǺǍ ƿƴǐ#
ƫǥHDžDzǐ dzǫ JLJƸǍ# AǶNJ ـƶǬǦǢ O LJƯƱƾNjǫ'
Q ǒǝƴƳ Ʋ N ǟ1P ǸǫƱ QƸǫ' EǶǺǫ' ǸǢH
ǰǮ2 QFs ǪǑǁǹ AǶNJ ƱǮ 'DžǺƽ K Q 'Ƕƴǥ'1 GƱ Qǹ% dzǺǗǜ#H LJƯƱƾNjǫ' Q ǰǮ ƲǬǜ LJǎǜ JǶǁǹ
)K 1ƱƾǺNJ Ǫ Pǝǎʹ Oǹ ǭǫ ƶǥǶǫ' C'džQ OǮH ـƵǝ ƽ1
M ʹ P LJǺǟ Ƿǫ' Ƿ Q
ǫ HN Džǥ P DzǫƱƳ ǰǺǃDž QƸǫ'
dzǺǫ' ƵƴNjQ
Q K K P ʹDž Oǝ Nǹ ǭǫ dzDZQ # ƱǯǨ ǕQʹ ǥN )K Džǀ'H
dzǬǫ' ǶǴ 'džǴ 'DžƳ# ƱǵƳ Ʊƴǟ'1
9ǶƴDzǺǫ' 'džǴ Ƿǫ' 'ǶƷƫƷ F# ǸǴ ƱǵƳ EƱǺǦǫ' ǭǩǺǬǜ ǸƸǫ'Q ǷǫHƫǫ' )ǶǗDŽǫ' FHʹ LJƷ# N ig
K FǶǝǺǗƸNjƷ Ʊǫ ǭǩDZQ ƫƳ 'ǶǨ1Dž
ǪǯǝǫƱǢ ƱưǺǍ P ƷO F#H GƱǺǯǫ' GdžǴ Ƿǫ' !Ǹƾǯǫ' ǭǩǺǬǜ ǸǠƴDzǹ
O Fƫǫ ƵƽƱǁƳ ǭƸNjǫ 'HLJǣǁƷ F# ǭǩǺǬǜ ljǺǫ ǭQ Oǵ Nǹ Jdžǫ'Q '0ǶN ǴO ǶǴ dzƳ EƱǥ Jdžǫ'Q
'ǶDŽQ ǔƷ
ǭǩǺǬǜ Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ' LJǮƫǫƱǢ C'0 H# !Ǹǎǫ' 'džǴ ǰǜ ǸǬDŽ Q QƸǬǫ ǭǩǫ ƵƽƱǀ Ʊǫ ƱǮ ƱưǺǍ
K
'ǶƳLJǍ% ǭƸǎǗǜ Fsʹ LJƻǨ# Ʊǫ !Ʊǯǫ' C'0 ǰǮ (LJǎǫ'HQ CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' dzƽȦ ǶN QƸǫ' ǶǴ dzƳ EƱǺǦǫ'
ǡǺǚQDzǫ'H ǸǦQDzǫ' !Ʊǯǫ' ǷǗǜ#H ƱDzǬƽ# ǰǮ dzǬǫ' Q dzƳLJǓ DžǦǫ )LJDŽǑǫ'Q FƱǨ ǶǴ F0ȫǢ ih
FH Q/ǶN Nǹ ǰǹdžǫ'Q ǪǨ
Q Ƿǫs !Ʊǯǫ' 'džǴ ǰǮ ǸǗǝǹ Jdžǫ'Q dzNjǣDZ ǶǴ EǶǺǫ' Ƿǫ' D'2 ƱǮH )1'LjǠƳ
K
dzƴǝǍ ǰǁDZ ƱDzǫ ƵǀǶDzǯǯǫ' dzƸǯǝDZ Ʊǝƴǖ ǸǴ GdžǴ 'ǶDzǮƬ Oǹ F#
Fƫǫ /'DžǝƸNJ' ǷǬǜ ǭǵDZQ s EǶǺǫ' 3ƱDZ K
P ƱƳȞ ƱǵǺƴǍ K
ƱǬƺƱǯǮ K
ƱưǺǍ CƱDzǴ FƱǨ DžǦǫ ii
ǪƳƱǦ OǯǫƱƳ ƵǮDžǃ Ƶ Qǹ# ǭǹDžǦƷ FǶǔǢLJǹ ǭǵQDzǩǫH dzǺǬǜ DǶǑǁǫ' ǭǵDzǩǯǹ ƱǮ ǪǨ Q 'Hdžǃƫǹ
Q Q
'HDžǹLJǹ ǭǫ ǭǵDZ# Ʊǫ% CƱDzǴ )LJDŽǑǫ' Q ǧǬƷ ǰǮ (LJǎǬǫ@ؽǫ Q ǰǹ QDžǝƸNjǮ 'ǶDZƱǨ FǶǺǬǺƯ'LJNJǿƱǢ
Q
Q GƱƾƷ Ƶƴƽ'Ƕǫ'
dzǬǫ' P ƵǮDžDŽǫ' ǭǹDžǦƷ
ǰǜ ǷƸǀ FHLjƽƱǜ ƱDzDZQ s FǶǢLJǝƷ ǪǴ ǡǥǶƷ Ȧ ƱǯDZH/ *ƱǮ NDžDŽǫ' ƱDzǫ JDžNjʹ Oǹ ǶǴH a``
Q
Ƶƽ1N QDžǫ' Gdžǵǫ ƵǮDžDŽǫ' GdžǴ dzǬǫ' ƱDzǁDzǯǹ ǭǫ Fs ljǣDzƸDZ Q F# ƱDzDzǩǯ Oǹ Ʊǫ dzDZHDžƳ ljǣDz QƸǫ'
K
ǸǢ ƱƴǹLJǦƷ ǰǺǣǑDZ Ƿǫ' BLjǯƸDZQ ƱDzDZQ ƫǨH LJǝǎDZ ƱDzDZQ ƱǢ ǧǫ0 ǛǮH dzǺǬǜ FHDžǯP NƸ ʹǝ OǮ ǰǁDZ
Q
ƱDzǫƫNjǹ dzDZƱǢ dzǫ ƵǮDžǃ
M Ƶǹ/ƫƷ Ƿǫ' ƱDZ1ʹ LJP ǗǓ'O ƱǮ '0' H# dzǬƽ# ǰǮ !ǸǍ M JƫƳ
ȧ ƱDzǮƱǺǥ P DƱǀ
P
)DžǜƱNjǮ H# ƱǮ ǏDŽǍ M Ǫƽ# ǰǮ )ƱǬǑǫ' Q H# ǭǴDžǀ# ƵǬƳƱǦǯǫ (ƱǴdžǫ' Q ƱǮ LJǮƫƳ
M EƱǺǦǫ'
ǭǹDžǦƸƳ ƲǟLJDZ N Ʊǫ ƱDzQDzǩǫH Ǫǃ' QDžǫ' ǰǮ BLjǯƸDZ Q ƱDzDZQ ƫǨH LJǝǎDZ *ƱƴǬǗǫ' Q GdžǴ !'2ȫǢ ƱǮ Džǀ# M
dzǫ ƵǮDžǃM Ƶ Qǹ#
K ƱǦ
ƱǫDžƳ K ǦQ ǎN OǮ ƱDZ'Ljǃ
K N ƵǯǬǩǫ' ƱDZ# ǸDZǶǨLJƷ ـǭǵDZQ ƫǫ ǭǵDzǮ ǷǩƸǍ'H ǭ OǵǮƱǫ
'ǶǬƴP ǥH N DžǦǫ a`a
ȥ N
'ǶǬǔǢH 'ǶǵƸǍ'H Ǹǁǫ' !Ʊǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ )ƱǺǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ ƱDZ# ǸDZǶǨLJƷ DžǦǫؼǪƴP ǥN ǸDzǮ
Q
Ǫǯǝǫ' 'džǴ 1 QǶǑƷ ǭǩDzǩǯ Oǹ# ـDžǨ'1
P F' Q ǰǮ (LJǎǫ'
M Ljǃ Q
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' b`
NdzƽǶƷ
Q ƱǮ '0sؼǏDŽǍ '0Ʊǯǫ )Dž PǨ'1 GƱǺǮ F' Q ǰǮ ƱƳdžK Nǜ !ƱǮ
L M P Ljǃ K FǶƳLJǎƷ ǡǺǨ a`d
DǶǐ OǶǫ' dzODzǩǯǹ ǰǺǀ
P ǸǢ dzDzǮ (LJǎǺǫ
N )DžǨ'1 GƱǺǮ
M ǷǬǜ JǶƸǁǹ F' Q Ƿǫ' ƱǮ ǏDŽǍ
P Ljǃ L
ـFƱNjDZƱǫ' 'džǴ :ƱǮ/ ǸǢ Ʋ L N
L ǗN NǜH ǪǬǃN ƵǯQ ƺN QFs ـFǶǫǶǦƷ AǶNjǢ J2'ǶƷ1# LJưƳ
ȣ M Ƿǫ'
Ƶǀ'LJǫ' K
Q ǰǜ ƱƻǁƳ ƵǬƺƱǯǮ ǰǨƱǮ# DƱƽLJǫ' Q Džǀ# H# !ƱNjDzǫ' IDžǀs *DžǑǥ DƱǀ ǸǢH
QDDž Nǹ 'džǵǢ ƵǯǬǩǫ' FHDžǹLJǹ Ʊǫ ǭǵDZQ s ƱK ǺǀH1
Q ƱK NǬǬǃN ǏDŽǎǫ'
Q 'džǴ IDžǫ QF# DžQǨƬǯǫ' ǰǯǢ
KƱưǺǍ H# ƿǺǁǐ ǭǝDZ GLJǺǟ H# AǶǟLJǎǫ' Ȧ H# 9Džǣǔǫ' Q ƵǝǺƴǖ FǶǬǯǁǹ 'Ƕǫ'2 Ʊǫ ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ
GdžǴ QFƫǫ ǧǬƷ )DžǨ'LJǫ'Q GƱǺǯǫ' *ƱDZ'Ljǃ FǶƴQ ǁǹ ǰǹdžǫ'Q ǧưǫH' ƵǝǺƴǗǫ' K
Q Gdžǵǫ 'DžƯƱǜ ƱǮ
Q ʹ
Ʊǫ ƵƳdžǜ GL ƱǺǮ ǸǵǢ ǧǫ0 FǶǝǺǗƸNjǹ Ʊǫ ǭǵDZs ƵNƳdž Nǝǫ' GƱǺǯǫ' ǸǢ njǺǝƷ Ʊǫ *ƱǥǶǬDŽǯǫ'
ǧǫ0 ǭǵDzǩǯP Oǹ
Q FǶǬǝǣǹ EǶǺǫ' ǭǴ ƱǴH ـƱDZ# ǸDZǶǨLJƷ ـF0s IǶǩǎǫ'
dzNjǣDZ !Ǹǎǫ' Q ƶDZƱǨ DžǦǫ a`e
ƶDZƱǨH (ǶǦǝǹ F'Ljǃ Q Ƿǫ' *!Ʊƽ DžǦǫ ƱDzNjǀ K LJưƴǫ'' DžDzǜ )#LJǯǫ' Ƿǫ' 'HLJǚDZ# Fƪǫ'H
Q Q
AǶNJ ƵǣƯƱǖ ǶǴ (ǶǦǝǹ F'Ljǃ ƱǯDZs 'džǴ (ǶǦǝǹ F'Ljǃ Q ǰǮ E'H QDžǫ' ǷǬǜ ǸǦƸNjƷ
K
ǰǺƳ ǰǮ 'Džǀ'H FƱǨ Fƪǫ' ƱDzǜǶǓǶǮ F'LjDŽǫ' Q 'džǴH ƱǵDzǮ ƵƺƱǬƺ K LJǣǀ dzDZQ ƫǫ 'džǩǴ dzǺǯNjDZ
Q
K N Q
ƱDZǶƳ# ƱDzNjǀ ـƶǫƱǥ dzǫǶǦƸǫ LJǺƻǩǫ' !Ǹǎǫ' ƱǵǹDžǫ FƱǨ )#LJǯǫ' GdžǴH ƱǴLJǣǀ ǸƸǫ' ǧǬƷ Q
K
ـƱǺǢƱǨ ljǺǫ#
N dzǺ P ǶN ǮN HN GO ǶODzƳN HN ǶN ǴO Ʊ NǵʹDzǮP (N LJP ǍN HN (ǶǦǝǹ LJưƴǫ' GdžǴ LJǣǀ
P Ǎ'
ba ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
K
ƵǺDZƱƺ ǰǹ/ǶǝƷH ƱǔK ʹǹ'Ȝ ǰǺǎǗǝƷ AǶNJ ƱDzǵǴ ǰʹ ǮN dzDzǺƴǁN Njʹ ƷN Jdžǫ'Q !Ʊǯǫ' ƱǯDZQ ' ـDƱǦǢ a`f
1ƱǀMQ !ƱǮ OǛƴDZ dzDZQ s 9ǶƴDzǹ ǶǴ dzǺǗǜ# ƱDZ# Jdžǫ'Q ǰǩǫH ـAƱǓ'H dzDzǮ JdžǃƫƸǫ ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ'
P ƱDzǴ dzDZQ ' dzDzǮ JdžǃƫƸǫ ƱDzǵNǴ Ƿǫ' ǸƷƫƷ ǰǫH Ǫǃ'Džǫ' ǰǮ ǤǢDžƸǹ
ـǧǝǮ Q
DƱǬǃ ǰǮ ƱǵǺǫ% + QDžǁƷ Džǥ ƱK ǺƳƱƸǨ Q K
ƱǜǶƴDzǹ QFƫƳ ƶǣǎƸǨ' ƱǮDžDzǜ ǰǩǫH 'ǶǚǀƱǫ a`g
Q K
ƱǵDZƫǫ 'DžƳ# dzǺǫ' ʹDž OǝƷ ǭǫH 'džǴ ǸǣƯƱǗǫ' Q (ǶǦǝǹ EƱǚDZ ƶǨLJƷ ƱǴLJǚƸDzƷ ƶDZƱǨ ƵǺƳƱƸǨ Q Ƶ Nǹ"
ƵưǺǗDŽǫƱǢ ƵDzǹDžǯǫ' Ƿǫ' ƵǜLJNjǮ K ƶʹ ǔN ǮN DžǦǫ FHLJƷ ǪǴ ƵǺǦǺǦǁǫ' Q )LJDŽ Ǒǫ'
Q ʹ
*DžƽH
DžǦǫ ƱǴDžP Ǎʹ OLJPǫ )K DžǥƱǢ )#LJǮ% ʹDž OǝƷ ǭǫ ƵNjN ƾP DZN )#LJǮ% ʹDž OǝƷN ǭǫ ƶǵƸDZ' Džǥ ƱǵǺǫ% ƵƴNjQ P DzǫƱƳ
ؼƱǵDZQ % ـƿǺ N Ǫȥ NǝNǫ'Ȝ ƶO Ǭʹ NǝǢN ƱǮN Ǫȥ OǨ ǸǫP DƱ
O NjP ǯN ǫ'ʹ ǶN ǴO 'džǴ N ǥN ƱDZK ƱNjN DZʹ 'ȡ 'H OLJǚO DZʹ ' 'ǶǯȦ ǬNO Ǵ ـƶǫƱǥ
EƱǮ# Fƪǫ' Ƶǣǥ'H ǸǴH dz QƸǯǵǮ džǣDZ Q DžǦǫ 'K QDžƽ DžǺƽ Q FƱǨ F'LjDŽǫ' Q 'džǴ QF# LjƯƱƾǫ' ǰǮ
ƱǮDžDzǝǢ ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' ƿN ƸP ǢO F# Ƿǫ' E'LJ Oǹ ƱǮ ǷǬǜ F'LjDŽǫ' Q FƱǨ DžǦǫ ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ'
LFƱǩǮ DžƽǶǹ dzDZQ ƫƳ ƶǣǎƸǨ' )#LJǯǫ' ǧǬƸǢ dzƷ QǶǥ ǪǨ Q F'LjDŽǫ'
Q NDžǦN ǢN ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' ǪǐH
(LJǎǬǫ ǪǔǢ#
chH cgg ƱDzǀǶǹ ǸǢ ƿǺNjǯǫ' ǸǢ ǶǴH ǪǔǢ# FƱǩǮ ǧǫƱDzǴ ǪǔǢ# FƱǩǮ CƱDzǴH a`h
Q ǯǫ'
ʹ(ـLJN ǎʹ NǹHN Ǹȥ Nǫ'ȡ Ǫʹ ƴP Ǧʹ ǺO Ǭʹ ǢN LDžǀN 'Ȝ njN ǗP Nǜ Fʹ 'ȡ ـDƱǚ N DžǺǜ ǰǮ LJǺǃƫǫ' EǶǺǫ' ǸǢ 9ǶNjǹ DƱǥ
ƿƳdžǯǫ' ƶǁƷ ǰǮ JLJƾǹ ǕǺNjƳ !ƱǮ M ǤL ǢȦ NDžƷN ǭǵǹDžǫ FƱǨ DžǦǢ 'ǶƾǵƸƳ' Džǥ ǭǵǝǺǯƽ
FǶƳLJǎǹ ƱDZ$ƱƳ" FƱǨ ـFǶǫǶǦǹ 'ǶDZƱǨH DžǺǝǫƱƳ@ǫƱƳ DƱǣƸǀȫǬǫ ƱǝǺǯƽ K 'ǶƳLJǍ CƱDzǴHؽH
KƱǴƱǺǮ 'ǶDŽǓH Q K
ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ ƱDZ'Ljǃ 'HLJǦDZ DžǦǫ FHLJƷ# '!ـLJǁǑǫ' Q ǸǢ ƵM ǺǀH1
Q )LJDŽǐ
M ǰǮ
DǶǀ ǭǵǬǨ Q 'ǶǝǯƾƷH Q CƱDzǴ ƿƳdžǯǫ' ƶǁƷ ǰǮ JLJƾƷ ƱǴǶǬǝƽH ƱǮ FƱǩǮ ǰǮ )DžǨ'1
M
dzDzǮ 'ǶƳLJǍH !Ʊǯǫ' C'0
ـFǶƳLJǎǹ !'LJǁǑǫ'Q ǸǢ ƱDZ$ƱƳ" FƱǨ )DžǹDžǜ ǰǺDzNJ džDzǮ' ـǶǫƱǥH
ـdzǬNJ1# Jdžǫ'Q ǶǴ dzǬǫ'
Q !ƱǯNjǫ'
Q ǰǮ D2ƱQDzǫ' ǰȥ ǯǫ'
N ƱDzǬǨ# DžǦǫ' ـǶǫƱǥ
QFs ǭǵǗNJʹ HN ǸǢ FƱǨ DžǦǫ ǶǴ FƱǨ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 ـǰQ ǯǫ'
N 'džǴ ǶǴ ƱDZ# ـƿǺNjǯǫ' DƱǥ a`i
ǭǵǗNJH ǸǢ FƱǨ 'džǴ )ƱǺǁǫ' Ljƴǃ
FƱNjDZǿƱǢ ǭǵƳ 5ƱDŽǫ'
Q Q ǭǵǫ FǶǩǹ F# 'ǶǬǔǢ
ǭǵDZ'Ljǃ Q DžǦǫ GǶǔǢ1 ǭǵDZQ ƱǢ 'džǴ ǛǮH
Q
'HLJǦDZ DžǦǫ ǰǺDzƺƱǫ' ǰǺƳ BLJǣǫ' ǕƴǔǫƱƳ ǶǴ 'džǴ C'0 ǪNJ1# (LJǫ'H Q F'LjDŽǫ' Q 'džǴ ǷDzƳ Džǥ
*ƱDZM LjǃQ ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ
O C'0 ǶǴ dzDZQ s ʹ(ـLJN ǎʹ NǹHN Ǹȥ Nǫ'ȡ Ǫʹ ƴP Ǧʹ ǺO Ǭʹ ǢN LDžǀN 'Ȝ njN ǗP Nǜ Fʹ 'ȡ ـDƱǥ ǶǴ aa`
9ǶƴDzǺǫ'
M ǮN O1Ʊ NǵDZʹ 'Ȝ dzP DzP ǗNʹ Ƴ ǰʹ ǮP JLJP ƾʹ ƷN ( ـƱƸǩǫ' DƱǥ ƱǯǨH
Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1ƫǫ' LJưƴǫ' ǧǬƷ dzDZQ s G" ـǸȣ ǀN !Ʊ
ـǸǀ !ƱǮ 1ƱǵDZ# ǒǺǣƷ AǶNJ dzP DZP ƱǺǨ BƱǯǜ# ǰǮ H# dzP DzP ǗƳ ǰǮـ
ȧ ƶǥH
) ȥDžǎǫ' P N )LJDŽǐ ƶDZƱǨ ǧǬƷؼǸǢ ƶDZƱǨ ǸƸǫ'Q )LJDŽǑǫ'
ǸǢ LJƽƱǴ Q ǧǬƷ dzDZQ s aaa
N
CƱDzǴ ƶDZƱǨ ƱǮDžDzǜH ǭǺȥ DŽ Oǯǫ' ,1Ʊǃ * N/LJP ǖO DžǥH *Ƕǯǫ' ƵǢƱǀ ǷǬǜ ƱǵǬǣǖ FƱǨ ƱǮDžDzǜ Q
Džǥ ƱǵƷP 2Ƕʹ ǀN ǸǢ FƱǨ Jdžǫ'Q F'LjDŽǫ' Q ǸǢ GƱǺǯǫ' ǸǖƱǺƸǀs QFs ǪǺǜƱǯNJs LJǺǠǑǫ'' Q ǛǮ
K
ƵǢƱNjǮ Ƿǫ' *DžǝƸƳ'H ƱǓ1# ǪǺǜƱǯNJ' ǪǣǗǫ' ƶʹ ǀN LJN ǖN F# Ʊǫs LJƽƱǴ ǰǮ FƱǨ ƱǯǢ Ʋ Q N ǔN DZN
)K ƫƾǢH *Ƕǯǹ ƱǵǬǣǖ Ƶǹ$1 ǸǢ Ʋʹ ǟN LJʹ ƷN ǭǫ ǸǵǢ G" ǸǩƴƷ ƶǀ'1H 3Ƕǥ M ǷǮLJǮ ǷǬǜ
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' bb
Q
ƱǮH CƱDzǴ ǤǢDžƸƷ ǸƸǫ'Q LJưƴǫ' @ ؽǫ' ǛƴNJ LJưƳؽؼ
N K
'LJưƳ *DžƽǶǢ (LJǫ' Q
Q CƱǬǮ ǭǬǩƷ
)LJDŽǑǫ' Q
Q LJƽƱǵPǫ ƵǀǶDzǯǯǫ' ǛƴNJ LJưƳؽLJưƴǫ' ǧǬƷ FƱǨ ǶǴ 'džǴ ƱDzǮǶǹ Ƿǫ' ǤǢDžƸƷ ƶǫ'2
Ƶ QǹLJƴǫ'
Q ǸǢ CƱDzǴ )/ǶƽǶǯǫ'
K
ƶDZƱǨ DžǦǫ 1ƱǵQDzǫ' C'0 ǸǢ ƱǮ/ !ǶǬǯǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' ǸǢ ƱDzǴ ƶDZƱǨ )LJDŽǑǫ' Q ǧǬƷ aab
ǸǣǢ ƵǣǐƱǝǫ' ƶǥH؞ؼEE ؽǕǹLJǎǫ' Q ǷǬǜ ƵNǬƾNjǮ
Q LJǺǟ ƵǀƱNjǮ ؟ǪǩǺǵǫ' ǸǢ CƱDzǴ
LJǺǵǗ QƸǬǫ /H'/ ƶǺƳ ǸǢ -ǶƸǣǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 ǶǴ FƱǨ LJǎǜ ƹǫƱƻǫ' -Ʊǁǐȫǫ' Ʊ QǹLJǨ2
FƱǨ ǶǴ icf 1ǶǮLjǯǫ' ǸǢH 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 FƱǨ ǶǴ ƵưǺǗDŽǫ' ǰǮ LJǺǵǗ QƸǬǫ ƵưǺǗDŽǬǫH
/H'/ ƶǺƳ ǸǢ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 D'Ljǹ Ʊǫ ǶǴH /H'/ )ƱǺǀ 9ǶƴDzǹ
Q DƱǥ DžǦǫ CƱDzǴ LJǜƱǎǫ'
LJǜƱǎǫ' Q ƲǬǥ ǸǢ /ǶƽǶǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' ǶǴH
ȧ K
ǤǢ NDž NƸ Oǯǫ' E QDžǫƱƳ ƱưǺǬǮ K
ƱǜǶƴDzǹ CƱDzǴ
ǪǺƯǶDZƱǯǜ
Q BHLJǜ ǰǮ
ǭQ Ǻǫ'
N 'džǴ ǸǢ ljǯǠDzǹ Q
ƮǖƱǃ ǪǩǢ
ʹ Q
ǭƺ% ǪǨ ǰǮ LJ ȥǵǗƸǹN
Q
dzǬǫ' ƵǯǬǨ dzDZQ s 'džǴ !Ʊǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ )ƱǺǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ dzDZQ s
)ƱǺǁǫ' !ƱǮ ƵǺǦǺǦǁǫ' Q ƵǯǬǩǫ' ǶǴ GǶǨLJƷ Džǥ GdžǴ )LJǺǃƫǫ' EƱǹƫǫ' (ǶǝǍ QF% aac
'HLJǣǀ 'HLJǦDZ DžǹDžƽ ǰǮ ILJǃ# )K LJQ ǮH N ƵǺǣƯƱǖ
Q *ƱDZ'LjǃQ ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ 'HLJǦDZH
ǭǺƺ'LJƾƳ !ǶǬǯǮ F'LjDŽǫ' Q 'džǴH ƵǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ *ƱDZ'Ljǃ Q ǭǵǹDžǫ FƱǨ dzDZQ ƫƳ EǶǺǫ' ǡǎƸǩDZH aad
Q Q Q
ǭǵDZ% dzǬǫ' /Ƕǜ OǶǫ Ƶǔ PǥƱDzǯǫ' 1ǶǮƫǫ' ǧǬƷ ǪǨH Ƶ QǹǶƳLJ QƸǫ' ƼǮ'LJƴǫ'H LJǣǩǫ' ƿƾȦ ƴN ƸƳ LJǣOǩǫ'
N
ƵǯǬǩǫƱƳ FǶǩQǩǎN Oǹ
LF'Ljǃ Q ǶǴ ǤǦȥ ǎN Oǯǫ' F'LjDŽǫ' Q ƵǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1ʹ ƱNN Ƴ" ƱǵDZQ ƱƳ (ƱƸǩǫ' DǶǦǹ ǧǬƷ ǭǵƷƱDZ'Ljǃ Q ƱǯDZQ % aae
ǸDzǹ/ ǛǦDzƸ M Njʹ OǮ ǸǢ (LJNjƸƷ Q Q
ƱǵDZs Ǫǝǣǹ '0ƱǮ !ƱǮ (LJNj Q
Q Oǹ dzDZ% !ـƱǮ K ( ȧLJNjǹ N njDz Q Nǹـ
ljǬƾǯǫ' C'0 Ƿǫ' ǭǴ/ǶǦǹ 'džǴ ǤǦȥ ǎN Oǯǫ' F'LjDŽǫƱǢ Q ǸǯǫƱǝǫ' ljƯƱDzǩǫ' ljPǬƾǮ ǷǯQ NjN Oǹ
*ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' Q GdžǴ 'ǶǝDzǐH ƵǺǁǫ' ȥ GƱǺǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹؼDžǥH ǶǴ GǶǨLJƷ ǭǵDZQ ƫǫ
ƵǢLJǝǯǫ'H ǭǺǬǝ QƸǬǫ ƵǯDŽǓ *'LJǯƷƬǮH M *'HDžDZ
M N
ƵǯǚDZ# ǭǵNjǣDZƫǫ FHLJǣǁǹ ǭǵDZQ s aaf
)2'LJ PǩǬǫ ,1ƱDŽǫ' ǪƽLJǫ' Q ǷǬǜ ǸǠƴDzǺǢ ƱǵDZHLJǣǁǹ ǸƸǫ' *ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' Q 9ǶDZ ǶǴ 'džǴ GLJǺǟH
)2Ʊƽs H# BǶǦǁǫ' ǸǢ )'1ǶƸǨ/ H# ƵǣNjǬǣǫ' ǸǢ )'1ǶƸǨ/ )/ƱǵǍ ǷǬǜ 'LjƯƱǀ K FǶǩǹ F#
*ǶǴƱǬƳ
M N
ƵǬǢƱǀ Q
P *ƱDZ'Ljǃ ƱǵDZ' LJǺǎƴ QƸǫ' ƵǬǀ1Q P ǸǢ ǤǬP ǗDzǹ F# ǪƴǢ dzƳƱǍ ƱǮH ('/ƪǫ' ǸǢ
CƱDzǴH ǸǫƱǝǫ' ǭǺǬǝ QƸǫƱƳ ƵǑN Ǒȧ DŽN NƸǯǫ' DžǴƱǝǯǫ' ǧǬƷ Ƿǫ' ǭǵDZǶǬǃP ʹDžǺǢ O LJǎƴǫ' ǛDzǐ ǰǮ
ȥ N
Ʊǹ ǭǺǬǝ QƸǫ' 'džǵƳ ǰǺǁǬNjN OǮ ǭȥ ƺ ǰǮ ǭǴǶǬNJP LJʹ OǹH ǭǴP DžP ǺN ƳP 9ǶDzǑǯǫ' ǭǵƷP ǶǴƱǬƳ ǭǴǶDzǦǁǹ
K Ljǁʹ OǮ 'LJǮ'
ƱDZ P
K ljǺǫ# FƱNjDZǿ' DžǺƳ ƵǜǶDzǑǮ *ƱDZ'Ljǃ Q Fƪǫ' dzǺǢ njǺǝDZ Jdžǫ'Q EǶǺǫ' 'džǵǫ
3ƱQDzǫ' QFƫǫ DǶǵǬǫ ʹ Ʊǹ G" ƵDZN ƱƸDZN ؽǷǫ' !Ǹǎǫ' Q 'džǴ D QǶǁƸǹ F# ǸǢ ƲƾN Nǜ ƱǫؼF#
dzDzǮ FǶƳLJǎǹ
DǶƴǥN ǰǮ ƱǫDžƴǢ K -LJǣǫ' ǷǬǜ DǶǑǁǫ' FHDžǹLJǹ ƱǮDžDzǜ EǶǺǫ' 3ƱQDzǫ' Ǫǝǣǹ '0ƱǮH aag
ljƯƱDzǩǫ' /'HQ OLJǢ -LJǣǫ' !'1H ƱǺǝNJ K ƵưǺǗDŽǫ' FƱǔǀ# ǸǢ FǶǦǬƸNjǹ ǭǴ'LJDZ (LJǫ' Q -LJǢ
ƱǮDžDzǜ )1ƱƾǺNjǫ' Q DƱǝǍs Ƿǫ' FǶǜ LJ
P ʹ Nj Oǹ ǭǴ'LJƷ ( LJǫ'
Q E' QDžǃ O ǭǵ Q
DZ ƫƳ FǶǜ QDž Nǹ ǰǹdžǫ'Q
bc ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
ƵǯǎƸǁ
P OǮ LJǺǠǫ' ǰQ OǵƳƱǺƺ ǰǹDžƷLJǹ ǰǵ Q @ǫƱƳ ǰƴǟLJ Nǹ ƱǮDžDzǜH LJƷQ Ƕ QƸǫƱƳ FHLJǝǎǹ
Q DZQ ȫǢ ǶǵǬǫƱƳ
Q DZQ ' ǰǵƳ
ǰǵ K
Q ƱƳƱƾǜs ǰǵǫ Q
Q FHLJǣǑǹH DƱƽLJǫ' Q ƹǺǀ CƱDzǴ Ʋǎǝǫ' LjQ ƾN ǫP ǰN ƽʹ OLJDŽǹH
Q LJǯǹ ʹ
'džǵǢ ƱǯDzǺNjǫ' *ƱǯƾDzƳ dzƴQ ǎ NƸǬǫ ǰN Ǻʹ NǝNj NǹH *ƱƳǶƴǁǮ ǰǁʹ ƴǑ P Oǹ Ǹǩǫ !ǸǍ JƫƳ ǰǯ N ǦǹO
ǰǵǀLJǢ
Q ǶǴ
ǰǮ (LJǎǫ' Q ǰǜ ǭǵ OǝȦDzǯN ƷN ǶǴ 1ǶǮƫǫ' GdžǴ !'1H ǸǝNjǬǫQ ǭǵƳ ǛǢDžǹ Jdžǫ'Q ƲƴNjǫƱǢ
Q
Ƿǫ' FǶǯǔDzǹ
Q ǭǵDZQ ' dzƯƱǮ ǰǮ ǪǵQDzǫ' FHDžǹLJǹ Ʊǫ GǶǔǢ1H dzDzǜ 'ǶǬDŽƷQ DžǦǢ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0
Q
9'ǶDZ# Ƿ QƸǎƳ ƵDZƪǬǯǫ' *ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' ǰǮ 9ǶDZ
M Ƿǫ' LJǎƴǫ' JDžǹƫƳ ƵǜǶDzǑǯǫ' ƵǯǚDZƫǫ' ǰǮ 9ǶDZ M
ǶǁQDzǫ' 'džǴ ǷǬǜ )LJǺNjǯǫ' DƱǯǨs ǭǵDzǩǯ Oǹ ƹǺǀ /ǶǨLJǫ'
Q
K
ƱǀƱƴǐ ƶƴNjǫ'Q EǶǹ FƱǨ dzDZQ ƫƳ DžǦƸǜ# ƵǺǥƱNjǫ' Q Ƿǫ' /ƱǫHƫǫ' ƱDzƴǁǗǐs ljǮƫǫƱƳ aah
JDžǺǣǀ /ƱǫHƫǫ' ƱDzǦǢ'1H (1ƱǦǫ' P ǰP ʹƸǮN ǷǬǜ DžǺǑǬǫ Q ǸǬǺƳ ƲǴ0 CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ƱDzƴǴ0 DžǦǫ
ǭǫ (1ƱǦǫ' ǸǢ GLjDz Ȧ QƸǬǫ@ؽǬǫ ƵǺǥƱNjǫ' Q Ƿǫ' ƱDzƴǴ0H LJǺǠǑǫ'Q ǸDzƳsH ǸƸDzƳs ǰǹLJǃƪǫ'H
5ƱDŽǍ#
L ƵǺǥƱNjǫ'Q DžDzǜ CƱDzǴ DžƽǶǹ N FƱǨ ƱǮ )LJ P ʹƻNǩǫP (1ƱǦǫ' ǸǢ GLjDzƸDZ Q F# ǛǗƸNjDZ
P
(LJǦǫƱƳ (1Ʊǥ L LJǮ
Q !ǸǍ J# Q FǶǬǝǣǹ 'ǶDZƱǨH )'LJ Oǜ ǡǑDZH FǶƺ QǶǬ OǮH FH1džǥ FǶNj ƾP DZN
)LJǎǜ +ƱǬƻǫ'H Q ǸDzƺǿ' ǰǺƳ ƱǮ ǭǴ1Ʊǯǜ# -H'LJƸƷ FƱƴQ ǎǫ' Ȧ ǰǮ ƵǜǶǯƾǮ dzP DzP ƸǮ ǷǬǜ ƱDzǮ
DǶʹ NǵǬǫʹ Ʊǹ G" 'ـǶ
K ʹǵǫ' ـdžǴ FǶǯQ NjN Oǹ )1ƱƾǺNJH )LJǺƳ )N Ƕƴʹ Oǜ ǭǵDzǮ Džǀ'H M Q Džǹ ǸǢH ƵDzNJ
ǪǨ
'džǵǨ ǪM ƺP Ʊǯ OǮ EƱǚDZ
M ǛǮ EHDžǹ F# ǭǫƱǝǫ' 'džǵǫ ǰǩ O ǯʹ Oǹ ƶǥǶǫ' ǰǮ ǭǨ
Q ǸǩǫH ǭȥ ƺN ǰǮH aai
Ƿǫ' *Ƕǯǫ' DžǝƳ ǭǵƳƱǴ0 FƫǎƳ ǭǴ O/H'LJ P ƷO ǸƸǫ'1ƱǩǢƫǫ' ǰǮ 'H1LJǁƸǹ Q
DžǺƳ Q
P ƵǜǶDzǑǯǫ' *ƱDZ'LjDŽǫ' GdžǴ IDžǀs Ƿǫs FǶǯǔDzǹ Q ǭǵDZs dzDZǶǬǝǣǹ Jdžǫ'Q ƱǯǢ ǭQDzǵƽ
Q
IǶNJ 'ǶNjǺǫ ǭǴ F'LjDŽǫ' Q Q
'džǴ Ƿǫ' FǶǯƸDzǹ ǰǹdžǫ' LJǎƴǫ' 9ǶDZ F0s ǶǴ 'džǵǢ FƱNjDZƱǫ'
ƱǯǨ dzDZƫǫ dzǺǫ' FǶƴNjƸDzǹ ǭǵDZQ ' ƵƺN ȥǶNǬ Oǯǫ' ƵNjN ƾQP Dzǫ' )LJǺǠǑǫ'
Q Q ǭNǫƱǝǫ' 9/ƱǣǓQ ǰǮ ƵDzǣǀ
FǶNʹ Ƴƫǹ ǭǴ ـǛǦƷ ƱǵǫƱǩǍ# ǷǬǜ 1ǶǺǗǫ'ـ Q DǶǦƷ ǷǔǮ ƱǯǺǢ 2Ƕƾǝǫ' ǸƷDžǫ'H ƶDZƱǨ
Q
CƱDzǴ njǺ Nǝǫ' FHDžǹLJǹ ǭǵDZs GdžǴ ƵưǺǗDŽǫ' )ƱǺǀ ǰǮ 'HLJ QǵǗƸǺǫ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' Ƿǫ' !Ǹƾǯǫ'
ǶǴ dzDzǜ 'Ƕǫ ȥǶǁƷ DžǦǫ '0Ʊǯǫ FǶǺǁǺNjǮ Q ǭǵDZQ ƫƳ !Ʊǜ Q/ǿƱƳ 1'LJǯƸNJȫǫ' ǛǮ Ǫǃ' QDžǫ' ǸǢ
Q
Jdžǫ' ƲƴNjǫ' N
Q ǶǴ 'džǴ ǰǺʹ ǬǮƱǨ !ƱǣƸǨ'H
M )ƱǺǀ
M N
9ǶƴDzǹ )ƱǺǁǫ' ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' -LJǣǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ
Q
ǰǹdžǫ' Ǫǃ' QDžǫ' ǸǢ !ƱǫƬǴ ǪƻǮ 5ƱDŽǍ# L ǧǫƱDzǴ F'LjDŽǫ'Q 'džǵƳ BƱǁƸǫǿ' Ƿǫ' ǭǵƳ 'DžǀN
!ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǵƳ FǶDzǮƬǹ
Džǥ ƱQDzǮ ƵǜǶǯƾǮ EǶǖ .ƫǫ'H ؉ أؤرDžǹLJǢ .ƫǫ'H ƶDzǨ O ǪǹǶǗƳP ljǺǫ ǰǮ2 M džDzǮ
ab`
K ǮN H# '1DžǑǮ
ƱǝƴDz K ALJǜ# Ʊǫ ƱDZƫǢ Ǫǝǣǹ '0ƱǮ I1#H Ǫǯǝǫ' ǸǢ GDžǹ Ʋǥ'1# F# ǶǴ dzǬǮƫƷ#
Q
GLJǺǟ LJǃ"
L ƺN ǶǴ ǭǨ G"
N ǰǺǯ
ǒǺʹ ǣǫ'
Q ǒǺƳ# ǸDzǬǝƾǹ Jdžǫ'Q
ƼǬƻǫƱǨ
LJǃ" 1DžǑǮ
M J#
Q ALJǜ# Ʊǫ
9ǶNjǹ E/ IǶNJ LJǃ" !ǸǍ Ʊǫ
E QDžǫƱƳ !ǸǬǮ
L LǛƴDZ ǧǫƱDzǴ
ǪǺƯǶDZƱǯǜ Q BHLJǜ ǰǮ ǪǺNjǹ O
ǭQ ǔN DŽǫ'
P 'džǴ ǸǢ ǏƯƱǟ M ƮǖƱǃ Ȧ
ǪǨ
M
ƵưǺǗǃ
M Q O
ǪǨ ǰǮ ǪNjƸǠǹ P
K NJP HN ƶDzǨ
ƱDŽ O ƱǮDžDzǜ ǸDZLJ Qǵǖ DžǦǫ ǛƴQDzǫ' C'0 IǶNJ LJǃ" ƱǝƴDZ K ALJǜ# Ʊǫ ǭǩǫ DǶǥ# ǸDZQ s abf
ʹ ǸǠʹƳ# ǸDzDZQ ƫǫ 'LJǴƱǖ K K
GƱǺǯǫ' GdžǴ ǰǮ ǪǵQ P Dzǫ'H dzƴDZƱƽ Ƿǫ' njN Ǻǝǫ' ƱǣǺǚDZ ǸDzǚǣǁ Nǹ ǶǴ
-LJǣǫƱƳ ǸǀH1 ƫǬǯƷ ǸƸǫ'Q ƵƳdžǝǫ'
ǷǬǜ '1/Ʊǥ K ʹDžǜ# ǭǫ ǸDZQ ƫƳ ƱK ǺǬǯǜLJǝǍ#H Q /HDžǁǫ' DžǝƳ# Ƿǫ' ƱǗ K ƴN ǁʹ OǮ FǶǨ# Džǥ
ǛǺǗƸNJ# džƯDžDzǜ M LJǃ" FƱǩǮ M J# Q
Q Ƿǫ' (ƱǴdžǫ' ǸDzDzǩǯ Oǹ ƱǫH ILJǃ# ƵǫǶƾǫؼ1'LJǯƸNJƱǫ' M
N
ƶDZ#ǸƷ QǶǥ ƶDZ# N dzǫǿ' ( LJǫ'
Q Ʊǵ Qǹ#ـ DǶǥƫǢ K
'Dž ʹǜH ǛǗǥ# CƱDzǴH ǸƸƴǨ1 ǷǬǜ 9ǶǥǶǫ'
Q
ǸƸǮ2# ǰǮ ,LJǃ# džƯDžDzǜ M ǸǬǃ'/ ǸǢ ƱDzǴ ǸǬǠǹ ƱǮ !ǸǎƳ M LJǝǍƫǢ ـǪǩǫ' ǸǢ Ǫǩǫ' Q Q Ǹǫ
FǶǯǬǝƷ ǘǦǺƸNJ# ƱǮDžDzǜ -ƱƴǑǫ' Q ǸǣǢ JLJǯǜ ǰǮ ǰǺNjǯDŽǫ' ƵƴƸǜ N *O 2HƱƾƷʹ DžǦǫ abg
Q
ǰǩǯƸDZ Ʊǫ ƱǺǬǯǜ K Q ǰǁDzǢ G" LJǹLJNjǫ' Q ǰǮ DLjDZ# F# ǛǺǗƸNJ# /ƱǩǫƱƳ ǸDZȫǢ LJǮƫǫ' FǶǩǹ ǡǺǨ Q
ǷǬǜ ǸDzǝǬP Ǘʹ ǺǫO ǸƷƫǹ ǸǬǺƳ 'džǴ H# (Ʊƴǫ' BLJǗǹ ƱǮ LDžǀ# CƱDzǴH LJǹLJNjǫ' Q ǰǮ 6ǶǵQDzǫ' ǰǮ
ǡǺǨ ـǸNjǣDZ ǸǢ DǶǥƫǢ ƱǮ FƱǩǮ N
ǸǢ ƵƯ1Ʊǖ ƵǫƱǀ ƵǯQ ƺ /Ƕƽ OǶǫ '1ǶǢ ,HLJDŽǫ' (ǶƽH K
M
LJǹLJNjǫ' Q ,1Ʊǃ ǸǬƽ1 ƲǁNJ DHƱǀ# ـ,HLJDŽǫ' ǰǮ ǰQǩǯƷƫNJ
(LJǫ' Q DžDzǜ ǰǮ FƱǺƷƫƷ ƵDZǶǝǯǫ'H N ) QǶǦǫ' ǰǺǮ" ǸƷ QǶǥ 1DžǑǮ ǛƴQDzǫ' ǶǴ ƶDZ# ـLJQǩǢ#H
FǶ N
N OǝǢLJʹ Nǹ )K ȥǶǥ FH O N O/Džȧ ƾN Oǹ (ȧ LJǫ' ȥ H OLJǚP NƸʹDz OǯǢ فǸƳƱƴǍ ǶǴ ƶDZ# Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1ƫǫ' JLJưƳ ǶǴ ƶDZ#
'džǴ Ǹǵǫ' (LJǫ' Q Ʊǵǹ# قFǶ N ǺO ʹǝ Oǹ ƱǫN HN FǶ N ǎO ǯʹ Nǹ FǶ N ƴO Nǝ ʹƸ Nǹ ƱǫN HN FǶ N ǔO OǨLJʹ Nǹ 1Ƕ P NjȦO DzǫƱNǨ ƵK ǁN DzP ƽʹ 'Ȝ
)K ƫƾǢ ـǸƴƽ'H J Q/$#H JLjǨLJǮN ǸǢ FǶǨ# Ǹǩǫ ǸDzDZǶǜDžǹ ǭǵDZQ % ƲǴ0# F# ǸǬǜ ȥ Ǹƴƽ'H
ǸǬǃ'/ ǸǢ OLJǨLJǩ Oǹ #Džƴǹ ƱǮ !ǸǍ L
FƱǨH 3ƱNjDzǨ ƱǩǺƳǶƷ ǸǢ ƱDzǴ LJǺǠǐ ǷDzƴǮ ǸǢ ƱǜƱǯƸƽ% DžǦǜ# ƶDzǨ K O EǶǹ *'0 abh
ƱDzǴ ljǫƱƾǫ' JH1 .ƫǫ' QF% ǪƯ'Hƫǫ' ǸƯƱǬǣOǨ ǰǮ LDžǀ'H (ƱǍ L LJL ǎƴ ȧ OǮ (ƱǍ L L
Ǫƽ1 CƱDzǴ
E/ƱDŽǫ' 'džǵǢؼDžǀ#Džǀ# CƱDzǴ FƱǨ ǭDŽǔǫ' Q FƱǩǯǫ' C'0 ǸǢ 'džǴ ǸǢ FƱǩǯǫ' LJQǨdžƸǹ
ƶǁƷ ǤǁNjDZ'H N ǸƴDZƱƾǫ' 1'Džƾǫ' P 1ƱǵDZƱǢ ƱǮ FƱǩǮ
M ǸǢ H# ǡǦNjǫ' Q ƶǁƷ AǶǥǶǬǫ dzƽǶƷ Q
dzDZƱǩǮ ǰǮ dzǫƱǁǖO -LjǀLjƷH N OG ODžƴP N Ǩ Ʋ O
N ǦP ƺ DžǦǢ *Ƕǯǫ' ƵǢƱǀ ǷǬǜ (Ʊǎǫ' Q Q FƱǨ DžǦǫ EƱǨLJǫ' Ȧ
dzǺǬǜ *1ƱǵDZ' Džǥ ) QDžǜP LFƱDzǖƫǢ dzǺǬǜ ǛǥH Jdžǫ'Q EƱǨLJǫ' Q LJǺƺƫƷ Ǫ ʹǝ ǣP ƳP
ǸƸƽH2 Ʊǹ ǰǺǢLJǝƷ ǪǴ ـƶǬǥ O ǸƸƽH2 Ƿǫ' + QDžǁƷ# ƱNjǫƱƽ K ƶDzǨ O 1ǶǗǣǫ' N DžDzǜ abi
ǰǮ$# ƱDZ# فǪǹǶǯ QƸǫ' Ǹǫ EN QDžǥ ƱǮDžDzǜ ـdzǬǝǣǺNJ ƱǮ ǰǺǢLJǝƷ# ƱDzǴ '/ǶƽǶǮ K 9ǶNjǹ FƱǨ Ƕǫ
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' bf
ـFƱǗǺǎǫ' L
Q ǰǮ ƵǬǺǀ GdžǴ ـƶǬǥ O ǭƺ Q ƿǺNjǯǬǫ ǪǹǶǯ QƸǫ' E QDžǦǹ FƱǨ DžǦǢ قƵǯǬǩǫ' GdžǵƳ
N
'džǴ QFs dzǺǬǜ ǰǺƸNJ QDžǦ Oǯǫ' dzǹDžǹ ǛǓHH ƲǴ0 FƱǩNǫ ƱDzǴ /ǶƽǶǮ 9ǶNjǹ FƱǨ Ƕǫ ـƶǬǥ O
9ǶNjǹ QFƫǫ ǷǢƱǝƸǹ AǶNJ ǶǵǢ ǭǵǹ Q Ʊǫ B ȥ
Lj ǯǮ
N M DƱǁǖ ǛǮ Ƿ QƸǀ ǷǢƱǝƸǹ AǶNJ (Ʊ Q
ǎǫ'
K
ǷǬǜ (ƱƸǩǫ' QF% dzƷǶǜ/ ǭǬǝǹ FƱǨ DžǦǫ ǶǴ ǰǮ ǕƴǔǫƱƳ ƱǯǫƱǜ CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' dzƽǶƸǺNJ Q FƱǨ
ȣ J#ؼFHDžƳH FǶǩǹ ǰǮN J# dzƸǹ QǶǵƳ dzP ǯP Ǭǜ
ǪǙ ʹ DƱǬǃ ǰǮ ǶǴ dzǺǢ FƱǨ FƱǴLJƴǫƱǢ Ǥǀ
Q
O ـdzƽ'1/#
ǪǴ ـƶǬǥ N /ǶǝǹH ǷǢƱǝ OǮ ǰʹ OǨ ǸDzƳ% Ʊǹ DǶǦǹH dzǺǬǜ dzǹDžǹ Ǜǔǹ AǶNJ ǧǎǬǫ Q
ـFƱƸNJN ȥDžǦN Oǯǫ' dzǬǫ'Q 'Džǹ 9ǶNjǹ FƱǨ ǶǵǢ ǸƸƴǺƴǀ Ʊǹ ƶǹ#1
P
ƱǯǴƱǬǨ ǸǮ'H
Q ǸƳƫǢ ƵǺNjDzƽ
Q )/ƱǫH DƱǬǃ ǰǮ *O ʹDžPǫ OH DžǦǫ ƮǖƱǃ LFƱNjDZ' ƱDZ# ـƶǬǥ
O
L Q K
ـǏǥƱDZ Ǫƽ1 ǸDZ% ƱưǺǍ JHƱNJ# Ʊǫ ƱDZ#H ǰǺưǖƱǃ ƱDZƱǨ
AǶNjǢ CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ǸDzǬNJ1#H Ʊǹ$1 (LJǫ' Q ǸDZƱǗǜ# DƱǀ ǸǢ ǰǺǢLJǝƷ ǪǴ ـƶǬǥH O
DƱǀ ǸǢ LJǹLJNjǫ'Q CLJƸǺǢ dzǺǬǜ JDžǹ Q ǛǓ#H ƲǴ0# AǶNJ ـƶǬǥ K
O ـƱǣǬƸDŽǮ LJǮƫǫ' FǶǩǹ
ـƱǹ$LJǫ'
Q ǧǬƷ (LJǫ'
Q ǸDZƱǗǜ#
Jdžǫ'Q ƱǯǢ ǪǝǣǫƱƳ Ʊǹ$1 CƱDzǴ FƱǨ dzDZQ # Ƕǫ Ƿ QƸǀ DƱǀ J#
Q ǷǬǜ ـLJȧǩǢ# ƶǀ1
O 'džǫ ac`
ǭǝDZ G" dzǺǬǜ ǷǦǬʹ ƷO AǶNJ ǸƸǫ'Q ƱǵNjǣDZ ƵDŽNJǶǫ' JDžǹƫǫ' FǶǩƸNJ ƶDZƱǨ ǪǑǁǺNJ ʹ FƱǨ
Q Q
ـƱǵNjǣDZ )1džǦǫ' JDžǹƫǫ' dzǬƽ# ǰǮ ǷǬǐ Jdžǫ' dzNjǣDZ ǪƽLJǫ' Q
L
9ǶǓǶǮ Q QFƱǢ 'džǫP OdzǬO ƻȧ ǯN OǮ ƱDZ# ـLJQǩǢ# ƶǀ1
1Ʊƴǫ' C'0 OE NDžǢ ƱDZ# ǸDZ'LJǹ Ʊǫ dzǬǫ' O džƯDžDzǜ
M
dzDZQ % ǸƷƱǬǐ ǶǴ ǸƸǹƱǣǨP dzDZQ % ǸǬƽ# ǰǮ ǕNJǶƸǹ Q Q
Jdžǫ' ǶǴ ƿƳdžǯǫ' ǷǬǜ CƱDzǴ
ǰǮ$# ǸDzDZQ # ǶǴ dzǺǬǜ JDžǹ Q ǛǓH Ƿǫ' ǸDzǝǢDžǹ Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ' !Ǹǎǫ'ـ Q ƶǬǥ
O ـǸƷƱǺǀ
F# ǸDzDzǩǯǺǢ O dzNjǣDZ !Ǹǎǫ' Q Ǫǝǣǹ AǶNJ dzNjǣDZ FƱǯǹǿƱǢ Ƿ QƸǀ Ʊǹ$LJǫ' Q FHDžƳH Ʊǹ$LJǫƱƳ
Q
Q Q Q Q Q K
dzDZ% Ǫǩǫ' ǸǢ Ǫǩǫ' Ǹǫ ǶǴ dzDZƫƳ LJƴƸǜ# ƱDZ# ƱǯDZ% ƱưǺǍ JHƱNJ# Ʊǫ ǸDZƫƳ F0% ǸNjǣDZ LJƴƸǜ# Q
Jdžǫ'Q ǶǴ ǪƳ ǸDzƸǬNJ1# ƵǣƯƱǖ ǰǮ ƱǮ ƵǮDžDŽǫ' ǸDzǬǨH#H ǸDzDzǺǜ Q Jdžǫ'Q ǶǵǢ ǸƷƱǺǀ
CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ƶƴǴdžǢO ـdzǺǬǜ JDžǹ Q ǛǓ# AǶNJ dzǯNJȫƳ ǤǬǗDZ# AǶNJ ƱǹǶǬǬǴ Q ǸDzǬNJ1#
K
ǷǢƱǝƷN DžǥH 9ƱǯƸƽƱǫ' ǸǢ '/ǶƽǶǮ FƱǨ !ƱNjǯǫ' C'0 ǸǢH (Ʊǎǫ' Q 'džǴ ǷǬǜ JDžǹ Q ǛǓƫǫ
K
ǰǺǮ" ƱǮƱǯƷ
!ǸǍ Ʊǫ LJǃ" 1DžǑǮ M J#
Q ALJǜ# Ʊǫ ƱDZ# ـ1DžǑǯǫ'H ǛƴQDzǫ' C'0 ǶǴ '0ǶǴ ǭǝDZ G" aca
Q
ƱDzQDzǩǫH ƱDzǬǨ dzǺǬǜ ǰǁDZ ƱǮ 'džǴH LDžǟH ǸDzDZQ % LJǺǦǀ ǏDŽǍ L ƱDZ# ـ9ǶNjǹ E/ IǶNJ LJǃ"
*'
P HƱ ȥ Ǹ PǢ J Pdžǫ'ȥ ǭO OǨƱNƳ'Ȝ ȥF'Ȝ ƱǯN N Ǩ ǰǺP
N ǯN Njǫ' N ǬǮƱ N
P N Ǩ ǭʹ OƸDZʹ 'Ȝ 'ǶDZO ǶOǩǢؼـǶNjǹ Q EƱǮ#
ǰǺǬǮƱǨ ǰǁDZ dzǬǫ'
K
ǛƴQDzǫ' 'džǴ CƱDzǴ ƱDzǬƻȧ ǯN Oǹ ƱǬǮƱǨ K
'Džǀ'H QFƫǫ ǰǺǬǮƱǨ 'ǶDZǶǩƷ F# ǭǩDzǩǯ Oǹ ǡǺǨ ـǪL ǮƱ P N Ǩ ǶN ǴO
K K K
IDžǮ ǷǬǜ ƱƳdžǜ ƱǝƴDZ ƱǯDZQ % /ǶǨ1 ƵǫƱǀ ǸǢ ƱưǺǍ ljǺǫ ǶǵǢ E'H QDžǫ' ǷǬǜ (džǜǶǴ L CƱDzǴ
Q Q
ǛƴQDzǫ' C'0 ǶǴ dzDZs ǸƳǶDZ0 ǪǨ ǶǁǯǹH EƱǹƫǫ'
ƵǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ *ƱDZ'Ljǃ
Q ǸǴ 'džǴ ǰǜ ǡǬƸDŽǮ M !ǸǍ
M J#
Q 'džǴ DǶǥ# EƱƸDŽǫ' ǸǢ Fƪǫ'H acb
Q
ǭǩǫƱǮ" ǪǨ ǭƸǝǓH ƱǮ '0s ƱǵǬǃ'/ ǸǢ dzDZǶǝǔƷ ƱǮ ǪǨ Q (LJNjQ ƷO F# ƱǵDZƫǍ ǰǮ ǸƸǫ'Q ǧǬƷ
9ǶNjǹ DƱǥ DžǦǫ ǧǬƷ )DžǨ'LJǫ' Q ǰǮ )Džǀ'H ǸǢ ǭǩǹDžǫ ƱǮ ǪǨH
Q GƱǺǯǫ' *ƱDZ'Ljǃ Q ǭǩƸǥH ǪǨ Q
dzDZǶǝǔƷ !ǸǍ M Q O N ȥ Q K Q N ȥ Q
ǪǨ (LJQ NjN Ʒ AǶNJH ƵǦǦǎN OǮ ƱǵDZs ـƱǔǹ# dzǬǫ' DƱǥH ƵǦǦǎN OǮ *ƱDZLjǃ ƱǵDZƫƳ Q
ǸǵǢ ƱưǺǍ K ǕƴǔƷ Ʊǫ ƱǵDZQ ƫǫ ƱǵǝǮ ƵƾǺƸDZ
M Ƶ Qǹ# Ƿǫ' 'ǶǬǑƷ K
P ǰǫH ƱưǺǍ ǭǨDžǺǣƷ ǰǫ ـƱǵǺǢ
bg ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
ƵǦǺǦǁǫ' Ƿǫ' DǶǐǶǬǫ )DžǺǀǶǫ' ƵǬǺNJǶǫ' ǶǴ dzDZQ s Ǜǥ'Ƕǫ' ǸǢ ƱǴ'ǶƸǁʹ OǮ ǪǨ Q (LJNjQ ƷO
)DžǺǀǶǫ' ƵǬǺNJǶǫ'H DžǺǀǶǫ' ǶǴ dzDZQ s JDžƳƫǫ' EƱǬNjǫ'H
Q JDžƳƫǫ' -LJǣǫ' Ƿǫ' )ƱǺǁǫ' Ƿǫ'
Ȧ QƸǬǫ
ƵƾǵƴǬǫ Ʊǹ G" ƱǵǺǫ' ǪǐǶ
ǶǴ ǰǮH '0Ʊǯǫ ƿǺNjǯǫ' 9ǶNjǹ ǶǴ Ʋǔʹ N Dz Nǹ Ʊǫ Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ' )ƱǺǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ QFs acc
K
Ƿǫ'H EǶǺǫ' ƱNjǮ# dzNjǣDZ ǶǴ ـ1DžǑǯǫ' 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' O )ƱǺǁǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' dzNjǣDZ ǶǴ ƵǯǬǩǫ' dzDZQ s
ǷǯNJƫǫ' GO ƱǓ1H Q dzƷƱǺǀ ǷǯNJƫǫ' dzǀLJǢ dzDZQ s ǸǦǺǦǁǫ' ǰǮƬǯǬǫ ƵƴNjQDzǫƱƳ ـDžƳƫǫ'
P ƵǺǮƱNjǫ'
ƱǫH EƱǯǔDZȫǬǫ ƱǫH LJN ƾǫ'H#
N ƲǁNjǬǫQ ƱǫH ǂǔǬǫ Q ƵƽƱǀ Ʊǫ ƿǺNjǯǫ' ǸǢ /ǶƽǶǮ ǶǴ
ǰǮƬǯǬǫ ƵƴNjQDzǫƱƳ dzǺǬǜ ǶǴ ƱǮ 'džǴ ƿǹLJƸNjDZH ǰǮƬDZ Fƫǫ ƵƽƱǁƳ ǰǁDZ ƱǯDZQ % ǞǹLJǣ QƸǬǫ
ǭǫH ƲǁNjǫ' Q H# LJƾǫ'
Q ƵǺǬǯǜ
Q K
Ƿǫ' 'DžƳ# K
ƫƾǬǹ ǭǫ ǶǵǢ ǭǺǴ'LJƳ' ƱDzǺƳ# ǪƻǮ ƱǮƱǯƷ acd
ǷǬǜ ǷǦǬʹ NƸNJ' dzDZQ s ƵǯǬǩǫ' GDžDzǜ FƱǨ DžǦǫ dzƷƱǺǀ ǸǢ )LJǮ Q ƱǫH AǶDŽǫ' H# ǤǬǦǫ' GP LJƸǝǹ
P
N
LJN NǵǙ PGLJǯǜ ǰǮ Ƶưǯǫ' ƵDzNjǫ' Q ǸǢ ǭǺǴ'LJƳ' FƱǨ ƱǮDžDzǜ ؞EE ؟LJǹDžǦǫ' J' QDžǍN Ǫǹ% JP ʹDžƺN
ƱǮ ـJ' QDžǍ Ǫǹ' ـǸǴ Ƶ QǹLJƴǝǫ' ƵǠǬǫ' Q ǸǢ ƵǯǬǩǫ' ـLJǹDžǦǫ' dzǬǫ' Q ƱDZ# ـdzǫ DƱǥH dzǬǫ'
Q dzǫ
ǷǬǜ ǕǦǢ ǤP ǬƸNJ% ʹ Q
ʹ ƱǯDZQ % ) QǶǦǫ' ǧǹDžǫ ʹDž Oǝ Nǹ ǭǫH 2Ƕƾǜ ƶDZ# ـǰǺ Nǹ ʹDžƺ Odzǫ Jdžǫ' ـGƱDzǝǮ
ǰǮ dzǺǬǜ ǪǑǀ Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ ǰǺǮ" ؞EE ؟1DžǑǯǫ' ǛƴQDzǫ' 'džǴ ǰǮ ǧƷ N QǶǥ QDžǯ NƸNJ'H
ʹ Ǹȥ NǹDžƺ
K K K
)1ƱNJ ǰǮ ƱǬǣǖ dzǹDžǫ ƿƴǐ# 'DžǹDžƽ 'DžNjƽ 1DžǑǯǫ' 1DžǑǫ' Q 'džǴ ǰǮ dzNjǣDZ ƵǹdžǠƷ !'LJƽ Q
ILJǃ# )#LJǮ%M ǰǮ /ƱǫH# ƵǝƴNJ dzǹDžǫ ƿƴǐ# ƵDzNJ ǰǺNjǯǃ 1HLJǮ DžǝƳH
Q OdzNǬ NǝǢN Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ ǰǺȧ ƴN Oǹ ǭǹDžǦǫ' Džǵǝǫ' QFs J' QDžǍ Ǫǹ' G" ace
ǰǬP ʹǝ Oǹ DžǹDžƾǫ' Džǵǝǫ'H dzǬǫ'
ؼǭǹDžǦǫ' Džǵǝǫ' ǸǢ ǰǺǮ" Ǫǝǣǹ AǶNJ '0ƱǮ
Ȟ 9LJP NJ#
ƵǗǦQDzǫ' GdžǴ DžDzǜ 9ǶǓǶǯǫ' ǸǵDZʹ 'H Q DžǦǫ acf
ʹ AǶNJ 'džǫ Fƪǫ' !'Ƕǵǫ' ǡǺȧ N ǩ OǮ ǡN ǥǶƷ
ƵǬǺǬǥ *Ʊǚǁǫ DžǝƳ
DžǦǫ LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ ǰǮ )K LJƴʹ ǜP *O džǃ# ʹ )M LJȥ ǮN *'džǢ ǸǵDZ'Ȟ F# Ǫƴǥ !Ǹǎǫ' Q 'džǴ DǶǥ# F# Ȧ/HN 'Ȝ
,1Ƕƽ ـǸǀ'ǶDZ ǸǣǢؼƱDzǵǴ 3ƱQDzǫ' ǰǮ DžǹDžǝǫ'H ǸƸǫǶƾƳ EǶǥ# ƶDzǨ O 'Dž K Ǻƽ K
Q ƱǫƱƻǮ FƱǨ
Q
DžǦǫ ǤǢDžƸǹ !ƱǮ O
M 9ǶƴDzǹ DƱǬ QƸǫ' DžDzǜ DžǺǝƴǫ' ǸǢ CƱDzǴ FƱǨ ـFHƱƷ ǪǺǮ ـǸǢ ـFHƱƷ
H ƵǝƳ1# ǰǺƳ -H'LJƸƷ ƵǢƱNjǮ Ƿǫ' )1ǶǢƱDZ DƱǬǃ ǰǮ GƱǺǯǫ' @ǫ' AdžǦƷ ƵK Qǹ2'ǶƷ1# 'LJưƳ K ƶDZƱǨ
ȣ
ƱǵǺǫ'Ƕǀ FƱǨH LJǯƸNjǮ Ȧ K
ǤM Ǣ NDžƷN ǸǢ ƶDZƱǨH ؞EE ؽLJƸǮ ae` H# ab` ؟ƱƴǹLJǦƷ E'Džǥ# ƵNjǯǃ
)LJǺƻǨ ILJǃ# *ƱƷƱƴDZ FǶǢLJǝƷH 9ƱDzǝDzǫ' ƵƸƴDZ O ƱǵǺǫ'Ƕǀ ǰǮ LJƻǩǹ FƱǨH LJǺƴǨ ǛƴDZ CƱDzǴ
K
GH" CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' DǶǐǶǬǫ ƱǎǗQ Nǝ NƸ OǮ ƶDzǨ O ǭǨ G" ǭN ƺN ǰǮ 9ƱDzǝQDzǫ' ǰǮ ǡDzǑǫ' K
Q C'0H Ʊǔǹ#
'džǩǴ (LJǍ#H (LJǍ#H dzƴDZƱƽ Ƿǫ' / QDžǯƷ# ƶDzǨH O ǛƴQDzǫ' C'0 Ƿǫ' DǶǐǶǬǫ BǶǎǫ' Q 'džǵǫ Ʊǹ
LJǚƸDZ#H !Ʊǯǫ' 'džǴ ǰǮ ǪǵQDzǫ' /HƱǜ#H ljǬƽ# ƶDzǨ O ǭȥ ƺN ǰǮH
P ƵǖƱNjƴƳ
Q
ǡǥǶƸǹ ǭǫ ǶǵǢ dzNjǣDZ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 Ƿǫ' 1'LJǯƸNJƱƳ /Ƕǜ# ƶDzǨO ƵDzNJ M DžǝƳ ƵDzNJH
O Q K
'HDžǯQ ƾN Ʒ F# FǶǝǺǗƸNjƷ Ʊǫ GDžǺǯƾƷ ǰǮ 'ǶDzǩǯƸǹ ǭǫ ƱǣǺǐH !ƱƸǍ K FƱǹLJN ƾǫ' K
N ǰǜ 'DžƳ#
)/HLJƴǫ' ) ȥDžǍP ǰǜ LJǚQN Dzǫ' ǒQ ǠƳؽǰǜLJ
N ǚQN Dzǫ' ǒǠƳ
Q Ʊǫ G" Ʊǫ ǛƴǗǫƱƳ K
Q ƵK Qǹ2'ǶƷ1# 'LJưƳ
ǸǣǩƷ ǛǺǦǑǫ' Q ǰǮ ƵǬǺǬǥ ƵǺǯǨ K Q O K
Q ƱDZ'Ljǃ 'HDžǯQ ƾN Ʒ F# ǭǩDzǩǯǹ 'DžƳ# DžǯƾƸǹ Q Ʊǫ dzDZQ ȫǢ
FHLJƷ# ƱǴDžǺǯƾƸǫ
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' bh
Q
Ʊǫ ǪǦDzƸǹH CLJǁƸǹ
Q dzDZQ ȫǢ dzǬǃ'/ ǸǢ )ƱǺǀ dzǺǢ FǶǩǹH CLJǁƸǹ Q !ǸǍ
M Q ƱǯDZQ s
J#
K Q
ƱǮ ƱDZƱǩǮ ƲǺǑǹ Jdžǫ' ǸNjǣQDzǫ' (ƱưƸǨȫǫ' Ƶƽ1/ ǭǵƷ Q N
Q ƱǯǬǥ Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1ƫǫ' LJưƴǫ' DžǺǯƾƷ ƱDzDzǩǯ Oǹ
LJưƴǫ' GdžǴ DžDzǜ 'ǶǎǺǜ ƵK Ǻǀȥ LJǯƸNjƷ
Q LJưƴǫ' GdžǵǢ
ƵǜHLJǬǫQ ƱǹؼH ƱǵƯƱǮ ǰǮ (LJǍ#H O CƱDzǴ ǰǮ LJǮ#
Ȧ ƶDzǨ K
O DžǦǢ CƱDzǴ Ʊǔǹ# ƶǚǀƱǫH O acg
K Ǹǜ'/ Ʊǫ ƵƳdžǜH Ƶƽ2Ʊǖ ƱǴƱǺǮ ƱǦǀ
ƲǴ0# ǸDZQ # ǶǬǢ D!ƱNjƷ# ǸDzDZQ s' ـǶǦǬǦƷ Fƫǫ 'DžƳ# K ƱǵDZQ '
ؼƵǹ1Ʊƽ ƶǫ'2 ƱǮ ƱǵDZQ s ـFƱǹLJN ƾǫ' Q
N ǰǜ ƶǣN ǥǶƷ Džǥ ILJƷO Ʊǹ ǪǵǢ CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' Fƪǫ'
P ǭǫ ƱǵDZQ s ـDƱǥ ǭƺ
DžǦǣƷ Q ـƱǵDzǮ (LJǎǹ J QDžƽ FƱǨ ـDƱǥ 2L Ƕƾǜ 91'LjǮ L ǸDZLJƴǃ# DžǦǫ ach
ƱǵǴƱǺǮ ƲǑƷH
Q Q
ǤǢDžƸƷ ƱǵDZQ s LJưƴǫ' ljǣDZ ƶǫ'2 ƱǮ ǸǵǢ LJǃ" !ǸǍ
M J# K
Q ƱǫH ƱǵP ǯP ǃʹ 2N ǰǮ ƱưǺǍ
ـCƱDzǴ B12ƫǫ' LJǵQDzǫ' ǸǢ
DžǦǫ ـdzDzǮ (LJǎǬǫQ ǸǫƱƻǯǫ'H ǛƯ'LJǫ'
Q FƱǩǯǫ' 'džǵǫ Ʊǹ Ǹǵǫ' Ʊǹ G" ـǸNjǣDZ ǸǢ ƶǬǦǢ O aci
K
E'Džǥƫǫ' ǷǬǜ 'LJǺNJ K
ƱƴǹLJǦƷ ؞EE ǭǬǨ af` ؟ǪǺǮ O
M ƵǢƱNjǯǫ ǤǹLJǗǫ' ǰǮ ƵǢƱǣƸǫȫƳ
M EǶǥ# ƶDzǨ
Q ǸǫƱƻǯǫ'H
ƶDZƱǨ ǭǨ G" (LJǎǬǫ P LjǺQ ǯǯǫ' K
N FƱǩǯǫ' ƱǬǝǢ FƱǨ dzDZQ ƫǫ FƱǩǯǫ' C'0 Ƿǫ' DǶǐǶǬǫ
ǛƯ'1 'džǴ ǭǨ Ǹǵǫ' Ʊǹ G" GƱǺǯǫ' ǧǬƷ )džǹdžǫ
LJưƴǫ' GdžǴ ـLJǩƸǢ# ƶǫ2 O ƱǫH CƱDzǴ ƱDZHLjǹ1# ǸǢ !'LJǁǑǫ' Q ǸǢ ǸNjǣDZ Džƽ# ƱDZ#ؽƱDZ#
ـƲNjǀH ʹ ƱǵƴDZƱƾƳ ǸǦǬƸNJ# F# ǛǺǗƸNJ# ǸDZ# Ƕǫ CƱDzǴ ƵǝƯ'LJǫ' Q
ǰǮ ILJǃ# )LJǮ K Q (LJǎǫ'Q ǛǺǗƸNJ# ǸDzƸǺǫ Ʊǹ G"'* ـLJǯǫ' Q IDžǀs ǸǢ /H'/ DƱǥ ƱǯǨ
CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' DǶǐǶǫ' 9ƱǗƸNJ' dzDZQ # Ƕǫ ـLJưƴǫ' GdžǴ
ǧǬǝƾǹ
P Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ ـƶǬǥ K
O ƱǩǁǔǮ K
ƱưǺǍ ǸǝǮ +DžǀH ƱNjǫƱƽ K O
ƶDzǨ EǶǹ *'0H ad`
K
ƵDzǹLjǀ CP 1N # ǭǫ '0Ʊǯǫ ǰǩǫH 'džǩǴ 'DžǺǝNJ K FǶǨ# F# ǷQDzǯƷ# ƱDZ# ƶǥǶǫ' D'Ƕǖ )K 1HLJNjǮ
ƶDZ#ـP O
ƶǬǦǢ ـFLjǁǫ' ǰǮ )10 Q Ƶ Qǹ# ǧǺǢ P ljǺǫ ƱDzǵǴ Ƿǫ' !Ǹƾǯǫ' *O ʹDžƸǜ' F# džDzǮ ǕQ ǥN
ƱǯǨ !ƱƸǎǫ' Q ǸǢ 4ƱǝƸDZƱǫ' ƵO ǯƯ'/H N ǰǺǬǠƷH ǰǹLjǣǦƷ ǧP DZQ ' E'H QDžǫ' ǷǬǜ -LJǣǫƱƳ Ƶǯ L Nǝǣʹ OǮ
Q L
Jdžǫ' ƱǮ 1'LJǯƸNJƱƳ -LJǣǫƱƳ ƵǯN Nǝǣ OǮ ƶDZƫǢ ʹ P ǰǩǹ K
ʹ Ʊ Qǹ# LJQ ǁǫ'
N ǸǢ H# /LJƴǫ' ǸǢ ǡǺǑǫ' Q ǸǢ
ǧǴƱǺǮ
P ǰǮ (LJǍ#
O ǸDzDZQ ƫǫ# ƲƴNjǫ' Q ǶǴ ƱǮ ǶǴ ƱǮ ؼ ǧǬǝƾǹ
P
Q
ـƱǬǨـ
ـLJǮƫǫ' 'džǵƳ ǰǺǝƸǯƸNjƷ ƶDZ#H
P ǧǴƱǺǮ
P K
ǰǮ (LJǎƷ ƲDZ'1ƫǫ' QF# ƱǯQƳLJNǫ ƱDzNjǀـ O
ƶǬǦǢ
Q
ـƱǬǨـ
Gdžǵǫ )K DžǺǝNJ ǧǬǝƾǹ
P Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ Ǫǩǎǫ'
Q 'džǵƳ ǸǬǠƷ ǧǬǝƾǹ
P Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ ƱDzNjǀـ
K O
ƶǬǥ
O
Q QFƫǫ QFƫǫ ǪǴ ـƶǣǓ#H
1ǶǺǗǫ' K K
ـƱǯƯ'/ -LJǣǫƱƳ )1ǶǯǠǮ 'džǩǴ ǧǬǝƾǹ
P Q
Jdžǫ' ƱǮ Ƶƽ1 QDžǫ'
ـǧǴƱǺǮ
P ǰǮ (LJǎƷ
Q
ـƱǬǨـ
ـǧƯƱǮ
P ǰǮ (LJǍ#
O ƱDZ# ǸDZQ ƫǫ ǪǴـ
Q
ـƱǬǨـ
O
ـƵƽ1 QDžǫ' Gdžǵǫ -LJǣǫƱƳ ƵǯN Nǝǣʹ OǮ ǧP Ǭǝƾǹ Jdžǫ'Q ƱǮ F0s ƱDzNjǀـ
K O
ƶǬǥ
bi ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
(LJǎƷ ǧN DZQ ƫǫ ljǺǫ EƱǵDZ'LJƳ .# ـƶǫƱǦʹ Nǫ ǸDzƴǺƾƷ F# LJưƴǫ' ǧǬƷ ƵǜƱǗƸNJƱƳ FƱǨ ǶǫH ada
F# FHDžǹLJǹ ǰǹdžǫ' ǪǨ JdžǟQ Q Q 'Ȟ ƱDZ# LJǺǢƱǑǝǫ' EƱǝǖs ʹ ǛǺǗƸNJ# ǸDZQ ƫǫH'ؽdžǴ 1 QDžǥ# N ǸDZQ s
ǪǵDzƷH ƱDzǵNǴ Ƿǫ' ǸƷƫƷ F# ǶǴ dzƳ EƱǺǦǫ' ǧǺǬǜ Jdžǫ'Q DžǺǀǶǫ' !ǸǎǫƱǢ Q ǸQDzǮ 'ǶƳLJǎǹ
ǸǢ ƱǮ !ǸǍ
L dzDZQ s ǸNjǣDZ ǰǮ ǸǬǟ# ʹ ƶNjǫ
O ǸDZQ # ǶǴ )DžǺǝNJ ǸDzǬǝƾǹ Jdžǫ'Q ǰǩǫH ǸDzǮ
ـǸǬǃ'/ ǸǢ ǸǬǠǹ ƱǮ !ǸǍ L dzDZQ s ǸDzǝǢDžǹ Jdžǫ'Q ǶǴ Ǫǃ'Džǫ'
ؼǸǢ FƱǨ ǶǴ 9ǶNjǹ DƱǥ ƱǯǨ -HLJǫƱƳ Q ƵM ǯN Nǝǣʹ OǮ )ƱǺǁǫ M ƵƴNjQ
P DzǫƱƳ DƱǁǫ' ǸǴ 'džǩǴH adb
ǒǺǣƷH ǤǢQ NDž NƸƷ Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1# 'LJưƳ K Ƶ QǹDžƳ# )ƱǺǀ M Ƿǫ' ǛƴDzƷ !ƱǮ M 1N ƱǵDZ# ǭǨƱǗǜ# ǶǵǢ FHLJƷ#
ǭƸDZƫǢ ǭǵƷƱǥƱǣǃsH ǭǵƷƱǀƱƾDZ ƵNjǺDzǩǫ' !Ʊǔǜ# ǸǥƱƴǫ FƱǨ FȫǢ ʹ 1'LJǯƸNJƱƳ JLJƾƷ ǸǴH
LJưƴǫ' GdžǴ DžDzǜ FǶǫ'LjƷ Ʊǫ ǭƸDZ#
ƱǴLJǺǟH *ƱǺǬǺǣ K
Q ƱưǺǬǮ ƱDZ'Ljǃ
Q ǗǫƱƳ K K
Q ƱǯǹDžǥ ƱǺǣƯƱǖ K Q K
ƱǮƱǚDZ ǭǩNjǣDZƫǫ FHdžDŽP QƸƷ '0Ʊǯǫ
9ǶƴDzǹ
M Ƿǫ' 1ǶǔǁǬǫ FH QǶǜDžǮ ǭǩ Q
DZ # ǰǺǀ
P ǸǢ )DžǨ' LJǫ'
Q !ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǰǮ 'ǶƳLJǎƷ Ǹǩǫ
Ƶ Qǹ2'ǶƷ1# LJưƳ
M Ƿǫ'
ƲO PƻƷN H LjǣǦƷH -LJǣƷH ǧǁǔƷH LJǃLJDŽƷ H#ؽH# ƲO Ǭȥ ǦƸƷH N OǛǢDžƷ ƱǴ'1# ƶǫ2 O ƱǮ ǸDZQ s adc
/ƱǬƴǫ' ǸǥƱƳ ǷǬǜ AƱǣƾǫ' LJǗǺNjǹ ƱǯDzǺǀH AƱƾǫ' 1Ʊǁǫ' Q Q LJǗP ǯʹ Oǯǫ' /1Ʊƴǫ' ljǦ P Ǘǫ'Q ǸǢ
ǤP ǯʹ Oǜ ǸǢ LJǦƸNjƷH
Ȧ ȦDžƸǯƷ ƱǴ1HdžƽH ƵǦǺǯǜ Ʊǵ Q
DZ ƫǫ ƱǵƷ/ƱǝǨ FƱǺ N ǬǟN ƵǫƱǀ ǸǢ ǸǴ ǷǦƴƷ
M
LJƾQ ǣƸƷ N ƹǺǀ O FƱǩǯǫ' C'0 ǰǮP CƱDzǴ 1ǶDŽǑǫ'P Q BƱǯǜ#
ƵǯǚDZƫǫ' ƵǢƱǨ Q ǭǩNjǣDZƫǫ 'Hdžǃ ǸǬǠƷ ǸƸǫ'Q LJưƴǫ' P GdžǴ ǰǮ (LJǦǫƱƳ P njǺǜ# ǸDZǶǜ/ G" add
Q
GƱǺǯǫ' ǷǬǜ Ƶ NǹǶƸǁ Oǯǫ' ƵǯǹDžǦǫ' ǭǨ1ƱƳ" ƵǢƱǨ ƱǵDZHDžǹLJƷ ǸƸǫ' LJǎƴǫ' JDžǹƫƳ ƵǜǶDzǑǯǫ' Q
C'0 Ƿǫ' ǸƷ" ǸDZǶǜ N/ ƱǯDZQ % )DžǨ'LJǫ' Q GƱǺǯǫ' *ƱDZ'Ljǃ Q H#ؼǷǫ' ǸƷ" ǸDZǶǜ N/ ƱǯDZQ % )DžǨ'LJǫ' Q
N Q
ǸǀLJN Ǣ dzDZ% Ʋʹ Njʹ ǀH N ƮPǬƸǯʹ OǮ ǶǴ ƹǺǀ Ƿǫ' CƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ǸƷ" F# Ǹǫ 'ǶǁǯNJ'H 9ǶƴDzǺǫ'
ǸǩǬP ǮN dzDZQ % ǸǑǬȧ DŽN OǮ dzDZQ % ǸǢƱǍH
ȥ ǸƴǺƴǖ ǶǴ ǸƷƱǺǀ dzDZQ % ǸƷ QǶǥ dzDZQ %dzDZQ % J1ǶDZ ǶǴH
GLJǺǟ LJǃ" !ǸǍ J# Q Ƿǫ' dzƽǶƷ# Q '0ƱǯǬǢ dzǺǢ P L/ǶƽǶǮ dzǺǫ% ƵƽƱǁƳ M ƱDZ# ƱǮ ǪǨQ
ǸǢH FHDžǹLJƷ Ʊǫ# ƵǬǺǬǫ'Q 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' 'džǴ Ƿǫ' !Ǹƾǯǫ' FHDžǹLJƷ Ʊǫ# ǸƷ'Ƕǃ# N ǸƷǶǃ% ade
Q
ǰǁDZ ƱǯǺǢ ƵǬǺǬǫ' GdžǴ ǸǢ GǶǬƴǦƷH GǶǬƴǦƸNjƷ F# FH Q/ǶN Ʒ Ʊǫ# dzǺǫ% 'DžƳ# 'ǶƷƫƷ ǭǫ DƱǀ N K
3H$LJǫ' Q ǰǺDZƱǀ
*'1'džǥ ǛǮ dzP ǬP ǃ'/ Ƿǫ' (LJȥ NjN NƸ Nǹ ǭǫƱǝǫƱǢ (LJQ NǵƷO njQ DzP ƷN (LJQ NjN ƷO ƵǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1ʹ ƱNN Ƴ" adf
+Ƕǩ Oǯǫ' !ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǛǺǗƸNjƷ Ʊǫ ƹǺǀ O LJưƴǫ' GdžǴ ljǺǫ ǭN ǫP ILJǃƫǫ' EƱ Qǹƫǫ'H LJƯƱǚǁǫ' N
ȧ O
Q BHLJǜ ǰǮ ǤǢ NDž NƸ Oǯǫ' E QDžǫƱƳ !ǶǬǯǯǫ' ǭDŽǔǫ'
Ʊǫ ǭN ǫP ǪǺƯǶDZƱǯǜ Q 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' 'džǴ dzǺǢ
Q
ƵǢƱƽH ƵNjƳƱǹ !ƱƳ ʹDžƽN 61#
M ǸǢ !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ dzǬǫ' Q ƱDZ ʹDžǜƱNj
P ǺO Ǭʹ ǢN !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ dzDZǶǬƴǦƸNjƷ
Q N
FHDžǹLJƷ Ʊǫ# 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 dzDZ% )ـLJN ƾP Ǔ ƵNjƳƱǹ 61# M ǸǢ )LJDŽǑǫ' Q dzDZQ % ـǸƴQDzǫ' DƱǥ ƱǯǨ
ǸǬǑDZQ ƱǯDzǺƳ !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ ǸǢ ǭǩƳǶǬǥ ǸǢ dzǺǫ% 'ǶƷƫƷ F#
ǰǮ ƱǮ ـǷǦǺNJǶǯǫ' ALjʹ NǝǨ LJǃ" ƱǜǶƴDzǹ K CƱDzǴ ljǺǫ ƲǺƴǁǫ' JHƱǯNjǫ' Q ƱDZƱƳ# Ʊǹ adg
O
ƱDZ#H ƶǜLJǜLJƷ CƱDzǴH CƱDzǴ *O ʹDžPǫ OH DžǦǫ ـ9ǶNjǹ E/ IǶNJ !ǸǍ Ʊǫ OdzǢLJǜ# O LJǃ"
M 9ǶƴDzǹ
M
N
CƱDzǴ GLJǔǁǮ ǸǢ Ʊǔǹ# *'ǶǮƫǫ' ǰǮ ƵǮƱǺǦǫ' ǭȥ ƺ ǰǮH dzǺǢ *Ƕǯǫ'H CƱDzǴ njǺʹ Nǝǫ' Ȧ/H#
)DžǺǦǜ ƱǬǢ GLJǺǟLJǃ" FƱǩǮ J#
Q ALJǜ# ƶNjǬǢ O K
ƱǯƯ'/ dzƷLJǔǀ ǸǢ FǶǨ# (1 Ʊǹ ǸDz ʹǜ N/
M
ƵǥǶǗDzǯǫ' ƵǯǬǩǫ' c`
ƿǺNjǯǫ' IǶNJ ILJǃ# )DžǺǦǜ CƱDzǴ ljǺǫ ƿǺNjǯǫ' IǶNJ LJǃ" Ʋǀ ȧ ǰǮ ƱǮ Ʋǀ Q ƱǫH
C'0 IǶNJ LJǃ" -LJǢ
M ǰǮ ƱǮ GLJǺǟ !ǸǍ Ʊǫ 3 ȥDž N
Ǧǯǫ' (ƱƸǩǫ' IǶNJ LJǃ" (ƱƸǨM ǰǮ ƱǮ
ǸǢ ǸƷƱǺDzƸǦǮ ǭƾǀ ǶǴ ǭǨ ǸDzǯǵǹ Q Ʊǫ ƱDZƫǢ Ǹǵǫ' Ʊǹ dzDzǮ ǸDZǶǮLJǀN FȫǢʹ dzǺǢ G ODžƾDZ Jdžǫ'Q
ADžǴ
M ƱǯDZH/ ǸǵƽH ǷǬǜ ǭǺǴ#
O AǶNJ ǸDZQ ȫǢ 1'LJǯƸNJƱƳ *ǶǮ ǶǴؽǶǴ 0s ǭǫƱǝǫ' 'džǴ
ǰǩNjǹ ʹǜ N/ ǰǩǫH (1 Ʊǹ ǸǵƸDZ# AǶNJ ǸDzǮ GǶǜLjN DZʹ N '0ȫǢ ǸNJ#1 BǶǢ JDžǹ
Odz Ȥ K
ƱǝǓ'H
ljǺǬǢ 1Ʊǹ# LJǵǍ ǪƻǮ dzǬƻǮ Ǹǫ ƵƴNjQ
P DzǫƱƳ DHƫǫ'
Q FǶDZƱǨ LJǵǍ ƿƴǑǹ džƯDžDzǜH M ǸǬǃ'/ ǸǢ
ʹ Q
Ʊǹ ǶǴ dzǺǬǜ ǪǑǁDzǬǢ ƿƾDzǹ Ʊǫ dzNjǣDZ *ǶǯǫƱǢ ƵǢƱƽ ǰǨƱǮ# ƱǫH )1Ʊǀ Q ǰǨƱǮ# CƱDzǴ
Q ƱDzǴ ǰǺDzǮƬǯǫ' ǛǺǯƽ Ƿǫ' ǒǺǢH
GdžǴ ǸǢ FH/ǶƽǶǮ ǭǵDZƫǫ ƵǬǺǬǫ' M )1'LjǠƳ
M OdzǁDzǮsʹ ǸƸƳ#
dzǺǬǜ DǶǑǁǫ' 1ƱǚƸDZƱƳ ƱDzǴ ƵǫƱ P Ǒǫ'
Q
ǭǵǫ2ƱDzǮ Ƿǫ' )/ǶǝǬǫ
P !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ ǸǢ ǭǵƷ'1ƱǺNJ FH/ǶǦǹ AǶNJ ǭǵDzǺƳ ǰǮ FHLJǺƻǨ adh
CƱDzǴ njǺǜ# ǸDzDZQ s 9ǶƴDzǺǫ' 'džǴ DžDzǜ njǺǜ# ƱDZ# ـǭǴ1ƱǩǢ# 1ǶǁǮ
N ǶǴ LJǮƫǫ' 'džǴ ǰOǩǺN Ǭʹ ǢN
K K
ـƵǜƱNJ DžǝƳ ƵǜƱNJ ƱƳdžǜ !ƱǮ
K (LJǍ#
O
FƱǩǯǫ' 'džǴ 'H1/ƱǠǹ Ǹǩǫ Fƪǫ' dzǺǬǜ 'ǶǬǑN ǁǺ ʹ DžǝƳ dzƳ 'Ƕǚǁǹ ǭǫ DƱǀ ǸǢH adi
ʹ ǬǢ
ـǭǫƱǝǫ' ƵǹƱǵDZ Ƿǫ' ǭǩǝǮ FǶǨ# AǶNJ ǭǩǦǢ'1# AǶNJ ـ9ǶƴDzǺǫ' 'džǴ ǭǵǝǮ ǰǺǬǮƱǀ
!ƱǺǍƫǫ' GdžǴ ǸƸƳ# Ʊǹ ƲN ʹ Ǵ
ǭǨ DǶǥ# Džǥ H# !ƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ ǸǢ ƱDzǴ LDžǀ# DžƽǶǹ# ƱDzNJH$1 ǰǺDZƱǀ ǰǁDZH Fƪǫ'H ae`
9ǶƴDzǺǫ' C'0 Ƿǫ' ƵǚǁǬǫ' Q GdžǴ ǸǢ Fƪǫ' ǸDZdžǃ (LJǫ' Q Ʊǵ Qǹ# ـDǶǦǹ AǶNJ ǭǩDzǮ Džǀ'H
O
ƶưƽ K
DžǦǫ ƱǮ ƱưǺǍ Džƽ# Ǹǩǫ ƶưƽ O Q
ƱǯDZs ǕǦǢ 9ƱǯƸNJȫǬǫ ljǺǫ ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ' ƶưƽ O DžǦǫ CƱDzǴ
Fƪǫ' ǸƴǬǥ Ƿǫs DƱǝƷ N ƵǬǺǬǫ' Q GdžǴ ǧǺǫs ƵƽƱǁƳ M Ǹ Q
DZ s JDž ǺNJ
Q Ʊǹ ƶDZ# NCƱǦǫ# Ǹǩǫ ƱDzǴ Ƿǫ'
ǭǩDzǮ Džǀ'H
M Q
ǪǨ (LJǫ' ʹ N Q
Q C1ƱƴǺO ǬǢ dzǬǫ' ǭOǩOǨ1ƱƴǺPO ǫ (ـ1 Ʊǹ 'džǴ ǪǝǣƸNJ ǪǴ O
*ƱǫƱǑǫ' Q ǸǢH F'1Džƾǫ' O ǷǬǜ ǸƸǫ'H Q ƵǜǶǢLJǯǫ' J/Ʊǹƫǫ' ILJƷ ǧN DZQ s (ƪǫ' Ʊǵ Qǹ# aea
N
ǪǨ QDžNjO Ʒ F# ǧǫƫNJ#ؽǸ N Q
DZs (ƪǫ' Ʊǵ Qǹ# ǭǵƸǹ#1 Džǥ ƶDZ#ƶDZ# N K
Ʊǔǹ# K
Ʊƽ1Ʊǃ ILJǃƫǫ'
ǸǢ ǡM ǥǶƷ Ȧ /LJƾQ OǮ FǶǩǹ Džǥ JDžǺNJ Q Ʊǹ ǭǹDžǥM F'Ljǃ ǰǮ 'ǶƳLJǍ Džǥ ƱǯQ Ƴ LJ N ǫ ǭǵƷƱƽƱǺƸǀ'
M
DžƯƱǦǝǫ' 9'ǶDZ# ǪǩƳ Q ƶƺN ȥǶNǬƷH ƱǮ ƱDZ'Ljǃ K LJǣǀ 5ƱDŽǍƫǫ' Džǀ# ƹǺǀ ǤǹLJǗǫ' Q ǡǑƸDzǮ
C'0 ǶǴ dzDZQ # ƱǯƳ ǶǴ dzǺǫ' 'ǶƷƫǹ FƫƳ ƶƳ# P Ʊǹ ǸǬǐ# Q ǸDZQ s ƵǯǬǩǫ' LJ PǩʹDzƷO ǸƸǫ'Q ƵƴǹLJǠǫ'
9ǶNjǹ ǭNJȫƳ Fƪǫ' ǧǺǫ' N ǭ OǵǬO ǨH# P ǸDZQ s ǸƸƳ# Ʊǹ ǭǵǺǬǜ dzƳ ǭǝP DZʹ # )ƱǺǁǫ' 9ǶƴDzǹ 9ǶƴDzǺǫ'
'džǴ ƶƴǬǖO O ƱǮ ǸDzDZQ # Ʊǫ%
ƶDzǨ Q ـOdzǬO NǝǢʹ 'Ȝ ǧP N ǫdžǢN ǸǯP NJƱ ʹ ƳP ƶ N ǫʹ ƱȜ NJN ƱǯN ʹǵǮN Hـ
N Ǹǫ ƶǬǥ N ƶDZ#H N aeb
N Dzǫ' ǰǯǫ'
D2ƱQ ȥ ǪǨƫDZH ǰǺǮ" ƵƳHLJǔǯǫ' )LJDŽǑǫ'
Q ǧǬƷ 9ǶNjǹ (LJǫ' Q ǛǮ ǤǹLJǗǫ' Q ǸǢ LJǺNjDZ
ǰǺǮ")LJDŽ Q ǰǮ JǶƷLJDZH ƵǩƯƱǬǯǫ' !'džǟP ǰǮ ǪǨƫDZ ƱQDzDZ% (LJǎDZH BǶǢ ǰǮ
P Ǒǫ'
K
ǕQ ǥN LJǃ" ƱǜǶƴDzǹ ALJǜ# Ʊǫ ƱDZ#
9ǶNjǹ E/ IǶNJ LJǃ" !ǸǍ Ʊǫ G"
Fƪǫ' 3#LJǫ' ǸDzǁDZ ƱDZǶǜ/
dzƸǯǀ1H dzƸǯǝDZ ǰǩƸǫ ǭǩDzǮ Džǀ'H M Q
ǪǨ ǒǺǣ Q
M ƳP dzǬǫ' ǭǩǨ1Ʊƴǹ Ǹǩǫ ǸǬǐ# Q ǸDZQ % aeh
Ƶǵ
P ƾǫ'
P Ƿǫ' ǭǨDžǀ# ǪǦƸDZ' ƱǮ '0% !ǸǍ M J# N
Q +Džǀ ƱǮ '0%H 9ǶƴNJƫǫ' 1'Dž P ǮN ǷǬǜ ǭǩǝǮ
EǶQDzǫ' ǰǮ *ƱǜƱNJ M ǛǔƳ IǶNJ ƶNjǺǫ ƱǵDZQ ƫƳ 'Dž K Ǻƽ
Q 'HLJ Q Ǩ džƷ CƱDzǴ (Ʊƾǁǫ' ǰǮ ILJǃƫǫ'
Q K
ǰǺǯƯƱQDzǫ' 'ǶǦǺǝ Oǹ ǰǫ ǰǺǥƱƴǫ' !ƱǺǀƫǫ' ـQFƫƳ 'HLJǨdžƷ '/ QDžƾ OǮ ǸǦƸǬDZ F# Ƿǫ' Ƶǀ'LJǫ'H Q
BǶƴǫ'H QǶ QƸǬǫ dzƷǶǐ ǤN NǬǖ# Džǥ 3/ƱNjǫ' Q BǶƴǫƱǢ 'ؼـdžǴ LJǺǃƫǫ' BǶƴǫ' dzǬǫ' Q BǶƳ QFƫǫ
*' Ȝ Hـ
O ǶN Ǯʹ Ʊǫ' N B ȧǶƴN Oǹ AǶNJ (LJǫ'
Q !ǸƾǮ FǶǩǹ AǶNJ LJǺǃƫǫ' ǭ ʹƸDŽǫ' N ƱǯǨ 'džǴ LJǺǃƫǫ'
Q
ƵǚǁǬǫ' ǧǬƷ ǸƷƫƷ F# Ƿǫ' ƲNjʹ ǀH N FǶǁǹLJƸNjǹ ǭǵDZQ % ـƱǫHȥ 'Ȝ FǶ K N OǮǶǦO ǺN NJN ƿǺ ʹ
P NjP ǯN ǫ' ǸǢP
'HLJQǨdžƷ ǭǴDžǀ# ǰǮ )!ƱNJȫǬǫ ǭƸǓLJǝƷ Q ƱǮ '0%H aei
9ǶNjǹ ǭNJs ljʹ ƴP ǫsʹ
JǶǥ
ȣ 9M 1ʹ DžP N Ǩ
ǧǫǶǀ
N ǰǮ (1Ʊƾ QƸǫ' ǛǯƸƾƷ ƱǮDžDzǜH
Q
ǰǺǖƱǺǎǫ' ƲNjʹ ǀH N 3 QDžǦ Oǯǫ' ǭNJǿ' C'0 )ƱǬǐ M ǸǢ ljʹ ǯǴs P
1'LJǣǫƱƳ 0ǶǬƷ AǶNJ
ǷǓLJǯǫ' ǭǩǝǮ 'ǶƴǁǗǐs E/ƱǦǫ' Džǀƫǫ' EǶǹ ƱDzǴ ǭǩƸǹ$1 ǪǮƫDZ 'HLJQǨdžƷ af`
Q
'ǶǫǶǥ FǶǬǑƸNJ K
ǪǴ Fƪǫ' ǸǬƽƫǫ Ʊǔǹ# Q ǭǩǬƽ# ǰǮ ǸǬǐƫNJ
ǭƸDZ# 'ǶǬǐ Q ǰǺǯǫƫȧ NƸ Oǯǫ'H
Q ǭǩǨ1ƱƴǺǫP ǭǩǬƽ# ǰǮ ǸǬǐƫNJ
dzǬǫ' Q ؞EE ـ ؽǰǺǮ" ـDǶǦƷ ƵǜƱǯƾǫ'ـ ؟ǰǺǮ"ـ
)ƱǬǑǫ'
Q ǸǢ ǭNJsؼ
L
dzƸƳHdžǝǫ Ʊǹ G" ǰǺǯƺL ǭNJs
L ǰǺǯƺ L ǭNJs
L
!ƱǯNjǫ' Q -LJǢ
O 61ƫǫ'
P !Ʊƽ1
O
dzƸƳHdžǝǫ Ʊǹ G" ǰǺǯƺ L ǭNJs
L
!ƱǯNjǫ'
Q -LJǢ
O 61ƫǫ'
P !Ʊƽ1
O
9ǶNjǹ ǭNJǿP ǸDzǁDzDZ
dzǺǮDžǥ DžDzǜ DžƾNjDZ
!ƱǯNjǫ'
Q ǸǢ , ȥǶ NƸ Oǹ AǶNJ CǶǬǯǫ'
P ǧǬǮ
O
ƱDzƸǬǀ1P EƱƸǃP IDžNǫ
ǰǺǯƺH (džǜ ljǺǫ# ǰǺǯƺ L ǭNJs
L ǰǺǯƺ L ǭNJs
L
!ƱǯNjǫ'
Q -LJǢ
O 61ƫǫ'
P !Ʊƽ1
O
dzƸƳHdžǝǫ Ʊǹ G" ǰǺǯƺ L ǭNJs
L ǰǺǯƺ L ǭNJs
L
!ƱǯNjǫ' Q -LJǢ
O 61ƫǫ'
P !Ʊƽ1
O
cc ƵL ǦN Ǧȥ ǎN OǮ 1L ƱNƳ"
ǭǨ ALJǜ# ǸDzDZQ # ǰǮ ǭǟLJǫ' Q ǷǬǜ ǭǩǨLJƷ# F# 'K QDžƽ ƲǝǑǫ' Q ǰǮ )/ƱǝǫƱǨ dzDZQ s afa
K
FǶƴǟLJƷ ǪǴ LJǃ" ƱǝǗǦǮؼAǶNJ ƱDzDZQ sؼǪǝǣǫƱƳ ƱǮ !ǸǍ L CƱDzǴ ƱǯDZQ s FǶǥLJȥ ǁN NƸƷ
ǭǩDzǺƳ Džǀ'H
M ǭǨ ǸƸǃ# ǕƳ'LJǫ' Q LCN1Ʊƴ OǮ FHDžǹLJƷ# ؞EE ـ ؽǰǺǮ" ـDǶǦƷ ƵǜƱǯƾǫ'؟
)DžǹDžǜ *'ǶDzNj
M ȧ ƱQDzǨ DžǦǫ ƵǯǹDžǦǫ' ƵǯǺDZLJ QƸǫ' GdžǴ ALJǝǹ
ǫP Ʊǵ OǯDZLJDZ
ƱǮDžDzǜ *ـƱưǯǫ' ǰǺƳ ǰǮ ǷǦQ ƴN ƷN ƱǮ 'džǴ FƱƸDzƺs F'Džǹ! ـƱNjǯǫ' 'džǴ ǸǢ LJQǩǢ# ƶDzǨH afb
ƱDzǔǝƳ JDžǹƫƳ ƱDzǹDžǹ# ǰǺǩNjǯ P OǮ ǰǁDZH ƵǯǺDŽǫ' !ƱǁDZ# ǪǨ Q ǸǢ ƵǯǺDZLJ QƸǫ' GdžǴ ǭDZQ LJDZ ƱQDzǨ
FHLJǚƸDzǹ ǭǵDZQ s ƱDzǴ )LJƴǦǯǫ'
P K
ǸǢ ǭǵDzǮ 'LJǺƴǨ K
'/Džǜ O DzǢN N/ DžǦǫ ǕƳ'LJǫ'
ƶʹ Q LC1Ʊƴ OǮؼǒǝƴǫ'
Ƶǵƾǫ' Ƿǫ' LJǚDZ# ƱǮDžDzǜ I$ O1 ǸǢ LJǃƪǫ ƶǥH M Q K
ǰǮ ǭǴ'1# ǸDZs '/ ȥDžƾN OǮ ǭǴ'1# AǶNJH
ƱDzǴ ǭǵDZQ s (Ʊƾǁǫ'
P ǰǮ ILJǃƫǫ'
ǭDZQ LJDZ ƱǯDzǺƳ Fƪǫ' ƱDzNJH$1 ǸDzǁDZ ƱDZǶǜ/
ǕƳ'P LJǫ'
Q LC1Ʊƴ OǮ
ƿǺNjǯǫ' ǸǢ ƱDz Oǝǯƾ N Nǹ Jdžǫ'Q
ؼƱDzƳǶǬǥ ǸǢ 3 ȥDžǦN Oǯǫ' ƲQ ǁǫ' K
-HLJǫ'
Q ƱDzǺǢ Ʋǩ O ʹ Nj Nǹ Jdž ǫ'Q
ؼǰǁDZ
LJǃƪǫ' DžǺƳ
P ǭǩDzǮ Džǀ'H
M Q ǧNjP ǯʹ ǺO ǫH
ǪǨ ʹ Fƪǫ' ǭǩǹDžǹ# 'ǶǗNjʹO Ƴ#
K
ƱƴǹLJǥؼ
Fƪǫ' ǭǩNJH$1
N 'ǶDzǀ#
ƱDzǬǃ'/ ǸǢ ǭǫƫǫƱƳ ƱDZ OLJǝǎ P Oǹ
ƲǬǦǫƱƳ ǰǹDžǁ ȥƸ OǮ ǷǦƴDZ ƱǯDZQ s
ƱDZ$ƱǦǫ ƲǹLJǥ
L dzDZQ ƫƳ ƱDZ$Ʊƽ1H
ك @ؼƳ ǭ OƸDŽʹ ǺǫH Q Ƿǫ' ƵǮDžDŽǫ' ǭǬȧ NJ#
N Ǹǜ'LJǫ' N Fƪǫ'H ƵK ǺPN Dzǁʹ
N Dz OǮ ƱDzNJ$$1 ǤP ƴʹ DzO ǫP afc
ؕחדטבוח؈ ƵL ǦN Ǧȡ ǎN OǮ L1ƱNƳ"
حؤتخر؆زحرؤسزب
9ƱǯƸƽ' ƵǯǺǃ ǸǢ ñifd 2ǶǯƷ òf Džǀƫǫ' EǶǹ !ƱNjǮ )1/ƱǑǫ' Q GdžǴ ƵǺǬǐƫǫ'
Q EƱǵDZ'LJƳ FǶǹ1ƱǮ EƱǺǫH .ƫǫ' ƵǫƱNJ1 QF%
ǪǺƾNjƸǫ' ǕǹLJǍ ǰǮ ƵǺǴƱDzƸǮ ƵǥDžƳH ƱǺǢLJǀ
Ȥ ƶNǬ PǦDZO Džǥ ƵǺǨLJǺǮƫǫ' )DžǁƸǯǫ' *ƱǹƱǫǶǫ' ƱDZƱǹDžDZ% ǪǺǣDZǶNJLJǣǺƽ ǸǢ EƱǵDZ'LJƳ
Q *Ƕǐ *ƱǬǺƾNjƷ Ǫƴǥ ǰǮ ƶǜ2HH
dzǬǫ' ȧ ƶǝƴǖ Džǥ ƵǺƳLJǝǫ' ƵǯƽLJƸǫ' GdžǴ ƵǺƳLJǝǫ' Q Q ƶ NǝƴP ǖH
ƵǠǬǫƱƳ O ǕDzǠǯǯǫ'
"3"#*$