You are on page 1of 68

ISSUE FREE PLAN: RUBBER POWERED COMPER SWIFT

1027Est. 1935

December 2022.
No. 1027. (109) £6.99
www.aeromodeller.com

b scribe Tod
Su
GE
ay

SEE PA
e Today

54
Subscrib
rib

Tod c
a y S ubs

COMPER
WOHM 5C C
FF
D I ES
INDOOR FF N
TECH - BMK
EL R EVIEW
ATS
GPS
SWIFT
1930’S CLASSIC BY DENNIS RATTLE

O NATS CL – F2D, VINTAGE COMBAT & TEAM RACE O FF SCALE O OLD WARDEN O BOOK REVIEWS O MORE…
Contents
AEROMODELLER 1027 December 2022 – Next issue published on 15 December 2022.

04 HEARD AT THE 42 CL NATS:


HANGAR DOORS TEAM RACE
EDITORIAL, NEWS AND VIEWS. SIMON MOLYNEUX REPORTS FROM THE
RESCHEDULED CL NATIONALS AT BUCKMINSTER.
07 UP & COMING
CALENDAR OF EVENTS. 48 CL NATS:
VINTAGE COMBAT
08 POWER TRIP – DENIS MURPHY REPORTS ON THE VINTAGE COMBAT. Issue 1027 December 2022
WOHM 5 (Issue 109 since relaunch)
A NEW 5CC DIESEL FROM CRE8TIONWORX IS 53 CL NATS: How to contact us:
TESTED BY MARIS DISLERS. F2D COMBAT Tel: 01525 222573
A PRECIS OF THE FAI COMBAT EVENT BY GORDON Email: enquiries@doolittlemedia.com
14 GPS LOCATOR PRICE. Editorial:
REVIEW Editor: Andrew Boddington
Email: editor@aeromodeller.com
THE LATEST TECHNOLOGY FROM BMK OFFERS COST 56 OLD WARDEN Publisher: Alan Harman
EFFECTIVE GPS ENABLED RETRIEVAL FOR YOUR THE LAST EVENT OF THE SEASON IS COVERED BY Administration: Gordon Angus
Editorial Design: Peter Hutchinson
MODEL. ANDY BROUGH AND ANDREW BODDINGTON.
Advertisement and circulation:
22 SCALE MATTERS 60 INDOOR NATIONALS Aeromodeller, Doolittle Media,
The Granary, Doolittle Lane,
BILL DENNIS ON THE LATEST FF SCALE ACTIVITIES. THE INDOOR PERFORMANCE NATIONALS REPORT BY Totternhoe, Beds, LU6 1QX
MEREDITH EVANS.
Tel: 01525 222573
28 FREE PLAN – E-mail: enquiries@doolittlemedia.com
COMPER SWIFT 66 TAIL END CHARLIE
DENNIS RATTLES PLEASING RUBBER POWERED
Newstrade:
THE THOUGHTS OF CHRIS OTTEWELL. Select Publisher Services, 3 East Avenue,
SCALE DESIGN IS BUILT BY RICHARD FALCONER. Bournemouth, BH3 7BW
Tel: 01202 586848
E-mail: tim@selectps.com
38 COVER TO COVER
THE LATEST AVIATION BOOKS ARE REVIEWED BY Subscriptions:
Aeromodeller, Doolittle Media,
CHRIS OTTEWELL. The Granary, Doolittle Lane,
Totternhoe, Beds, LU6 1QX
Tel: 01525 222573
Subscribe: 12 issues - UK £75, Europe £100,
Worldwide £115

Website: www.doolittlemedia.com

AeroModeller is published monthly by


Doolittle Media, The Granary, Doolittle
Lane, Totternhoe, Bedfordshire, LU6
1QX. Entire Contents © 2022 Doolittle
Media Reproduction in part or whole
of any text, photograph or illustration
without written permission from the
publisher is strictly prohibited. While due
care is taken to ensure the content of
AeroModeller is accurate, the publishers
and printers cannot accept liability for
errors and omissions. Advertisements
are accepted for publication in
AeroModeller only upon Doolittle Media’s
standard terms of acceptance of
advertising, copies of which are available
from the advertising sales department of
AeroModeller.

Richard Falconer’s
pretty rendition of the
Comper Swift.
NEWS, VIEWS AND EDITORIAL

HANGAR DOORS
HEARD AT THE

COVER INCREASE…

I
could have started this editorial with the same statement in the price we pay for commercial mailing, and as you are no
as the last, that a month can seem like a long time between doubt aware other prices for services have also increased.
issues of AeroModeller, this time given the rate of change of To ensure the long-term survival of AeroModeller the
British Prime Ministers… but this is not my area of expertise! publisher has reluctantly had to increase the price. We’ve done
However, the current political and economic uncertainties our best to hold the cover price unchanged for nearly 5 years,
have not helped with the costs associated with producing a but we believe that the new price still o ers good value for
magazine. money for a specialist magazine. I hope you will stick with us at
There has been a substantial increase in the costs of paper what I know is a difficult time for many.
stock used by our printers, and we’ve been told a further
increase is coming in January. Royal Mail typically increase the Regards, Andrew Boddington
cost of postage annually and are introducing another increase editor@aeromodeller.com

IN THE AIR TONIGHT CROSSLEY NEW BUILD


The popular BMFA online Zoom presentations are Richard Crossley has been in touch, pleased with the
restarting on 22nd November with our very own Chris response from AeroModeller readers.
Edge presenting on the BMK range of technology, I just thought I’d let you know that within a week of the
including the GPS Locator system reviewed in this issue. September issue of AeroModeller coming out with the
The range of devices from BMK is not just applicable to article about the sale of some of my competition winning
FF models but has possible uses by drone and space scale models I had sold three-quarters of them. One guy
model flyers. even flew up from Harwich to a local aerodrome to pick up
For more information and to subscribe to receive some models in his aircraft!
updates on the presentations go to the In the Air Tonight I now have plenty of room for new builds including a
website www.itat.bmfa.uk biplane Grumman Duck.

Chris Edge will be presenting online about the BMK range of Richard Crossley is well advanced with his build of the Grumman J2F
technology products for the BMFA In the Air Tonight series. Duck an American amphibious biplane.

4 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


DESIGN A LOGO
FOR SCALE WORLD
CHAMPIONSHIPS BID
Do you fancy a £100 gift voucher for modelling
supplies Do you have artistic flair The BMFA
Scale Technical Committee (STC) may have the
answer.
The STC is planning a bid to host the 2026 Scale
World Championships. They have already raised
almost 11k but need an identity, a logo, to help
raise more funds. So, this is your chance to help
and possibly win yourself some goodies.
Design some artwork that combines visuals
synonymous with Great Britain, it doesn’t have to
be as blatant as a Spitfire flying across a Union
Jack, but it could be. Something imaginative and
original, is what the team are looking for.
So, get sketching and send your entries to
EnquiriesBMFAScale yahoo.com or if you prefer
send to BMFA BUC MI STER (Attn STC Logo
Comp) Sewstern, Grantham G 5RW
Entry closes on January 1st 202

MODELAIR DATES FOR 2023


You’ll see from the coverage of the September ld Warden Shuttleworth management for model events in 202
in this issue that en and Sheila Sheppard have stepped Festival of Flight - 1 -14 May 202
down from the running of ModelAir and future aeromodelling Scale Weekend - 16-1 September 202
events at the Shuttleworth Collection site at ld Warden. I’m
pleased to say that James Gordon and Emma Chase have Please see the ModelAir website for more information on
taken over the organisation having both come to ld Warden flying at ld Warden as well as camping, entry etc.
for many years. They have already agreed the dates with the www.modelair.info

Emma Chase and James Gordon are the new organisers behind the ModelAir events at Old Warden for 2023.

AeroModeller 1027 - 5
NEWS, VIEWS AND EDITORIAL

Thanks to Chris Edge for this update on the FF Team Trials.


2023 WORLD FF CHAMPIONSHIP The GB Team for the next Free Flight World Championships, due to be
TEAM SELECTION TRIALS held in Moncontour, Loire Valley, France in August 2023, has now been
chosen, pending the usual ratification process by the BMFA (i.e. D A
testing and waterboarding…) The event was not without incident with a
protest even before the first flight was flown, and one after we thought
we’d finished – both protests were upheld. A challenging weekend’s
weather at the massive RAF Sculthorpe in orfolk saw good flying but by a
sadly reduced number of competitors this year. nly four fliers managed a
perfect score, the top three in F1B Wakefield and the winner of F1C Power.
Particular mention to Mark Benns who made his first F1B Wakefield
team after literally being let-out of the salt mines only a few weeks before,
and with a change to the rules now allowing a lady flier to make up a team
of four, ris Best takes up her first place in F1A Glider. Well done to all.

Results
F1A Glider 1st John Carter, 2nd Chris Edge, rd Stuart Darmon, Top Lady
Kris Best
F1B Wakefield Equal 1st Peter Brown, Mark Benns, Mike Woolner
F1C Power 1st eil Allen, 2nd en Faux, rd Simon Dixon

Of course, AeroModeller will be there at the FF World Champs in the


form of Chris Edge and Stuart Darmon, this organ’s senior FF hacks who
The GB F1A Glider Team of George Clooney, Tom Cruise and Ron-
will endeavour to bring you the hot news whilst doing their all for King and
nie Biggs – shurely shome mishtake?! – Editor (Photo by SEE) Country!

INDOOR SEASON AT PETERBOROUGH


Peterborough Model Flying Club have been in contact
about their winter season of Indoor Flying at the eracity –
Bushfield Leisure Centre, rton, Peterborough, PE2 5R
– which has on site car parking. The sessions are for small
and light FF models - rubber, electric or C 2 powered. o
RC, drones or shockies.
Contacts Brian Waterland 07717461000 or
Martin Skinner 07774863008 and see the website
peterboroughmfc.org
The next sessions are Saturday 26/11/2022, and
7/1/2023 starting at 10:00 am.

The editor has finished his ini Beam a future Free Plan in esigner
An interesting indoor flyer from across the Atlantic is Adrian Culf’s E e Tissue. Can you send us photos of your model finished with this
capacitor electric Flying Canoe a Chasse Galerie which to graphic tissue trim for the chance to win a pri e
everyone’s surprise turned out to be a superb performer o send in
other unorthodo flying creations to editor aeromodeller.com

DESIGNER EZE TISSUE PHOTO


COMPETITION
Just a quick reminder that the competition announced in
the last issue for photos of models covered in Designer E e
Tissue from Deluxe Materials is running until the 8th January
202 . Send us two clear photos of your Designer E e Tissue
finished model together with up to a 100 word description of
what you’ve done to have a chance of winning £100 worth
of Deluxe Materials aeromodelling products, and a 12 issue
subscription to AeroModeller.
Your submission must be via email to be considered
for winning a pri e. Please also include your name and a
postal address in case you are lucky enough to win. Multiple
entries are allowed if you have more than one model
finished in Designer E e Tissue but they must be in separate
emails.
email editor aeromodeller.com Subject Designer Tissue

6 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


EVENTS

UP & COMING
Please note that the events listed are compiled weeks in advance of publication, so please check in case of change - specifically M D venues
such as Barkston Heath can be cancelled at short notice. For inclusion of your event, please send an email with date and details in a format similar
to those shown below to editor@aeromodeller.com

NOVEMBER Gavin Manion gavin.manion84@gmail.com 14:00. FF (rubber, electric, CO2), no RC.


01543 422509 or Stuart Darmon Brian Waterland 07717 461000
16 November stuartdarmonf1a@yahoo.com 01858 882057 Martin Skinner 07774 863008
Flitehook Indoor FF, West Totton Community www.peterboroughmfc.org
Centre, Southampton SO40 8WU. 12:00 to 4 December
16:00. Flyers £8. Spectators & Juniors Free. Scale FF Flying nly Contest, M D 8 January
Cafe, Parking. rogerknewman@yahoo.com Lu enham. OFMAC Indoor Flying, Abbey Centre, Furlong
Mike Smith michaeldocsmith@gmail.com Green, Berinsfield 10 R. 09 00 to 15 00.
20 November 07516410905 scale.bmfa.org Indoor FF, FunFly & Scale.
BMFA SW Area Indoor Flying, Birds Of Prey Ian Melville OFMAC@redkite.aero
Centre, Winnard’s Perch, St Columb TR9 6DH. 18 December
1200 to 1600, FF, micro RC & electric CL. BMFA SW Area Indoor Flying, Birds Of Prey 14 January
Ron Marking ron.marking@btinternet.com Centre, Winnard’s Perch, St Columb TR9 6DH. Tonbridge Gassers & Rubber Fanciers Indoor,
1200 to 1600, FF, micro RC & electric CL. Kings Sport Centre, 601 Maidstone Rd,
22 November Ron Marking ron.marking@btinternet.com Rochester ME1 3QJ. 18.30 to 22.00. FF, LW
In the Air Tonight, BMFA Online Zoom RC, & 3D RC timed sessions.
Presentation. Chris Edge on BMK and the 18 December Steve 0208 942 5000 or Eric 07763 398416
GPS system reviewed in this issue. BMFA W Area Rochdale Indoor, ingsway
www.itat.bmfa.uk Park High School, Turf Hill Rd, Rochdale OL16 15 January
4 A. 1100 to 1600. All indoor inc FF with BMFA W Area Rochdale Indoor, ingsway
26 November slots. Park High School, Turf Hill Rd, Rochdale OL16
Peterborough MFC Indoor, eracity, Bushfield Martyn Kinder 079890 25198 4 A. 1100 to 1600. All indoor inc FF with
Leisure Centre, Orton PE2 5RQ. 10:00 to bmfa.nw@gmail.com slots.
13:00. FF (rubber, electric, CO2), no RC. Martyn Kinder 079890 25198
Brian Waterland 07717 461000 21 December bmfa.nw@gmail.com
Martin Skinner 07774 863008 Flitehook Indoor FF, West Totton Community
www.peterboroughmfc.org Centre, Southampton SO40 8WU. 12:00 to 18 January
16:00. Flyers £8. Spectators & Juniors Free. Flitehook Indoor FF, West Totton Community
DECEMBER Cafe, Parking. rogerknewman@yahoo.com Centre, Southampton SO40 8WU. 12:00 to
16:00. Flyers £8. Spectators & Juniors Free.
4 December 28 December Cafe, Parking. rogerknewman@yahoo.com
OFMAC Indoor Flying, Abbey Centre, Furlong ‘Cold Turkey’, Barton M30 7RL. CL Comps:
Green, Berinsfield 10 R. 09 00 to 15 00. BGY, Barton B, Club Speed. 29 January
Indoor FF, FunFly & Scale. Malcolm Ross 01925 766610 BMFA SW Area Indoor Flying, Birds Of Prey
Ian Melville OFMAC@redkite.aero www.controlline.org.uk Centre, Winnard’s Perch, St Columb TR9 6DH.
1200 to 1600, FF, micro RC & electric CL.
4 December 2023 Ron Marking ron.marking@btinternet.com
8th Grande Coupe de Birmingham, MOD JANUARY
Lu enham. 10 00 onwards. F1G for
AeroModeller Trophy. Pre 1970 Coupe and 7 January
intage Coupe events. Fly-o s as required Peterborough MFC Indoor, eracity, Bushfield
( ot DT ) Leisure Centre, Orton PE2 5RQ. 10:00 to

Full details of BMFA events can be found at: www.bmfa.org

AeroModeller 1027 - 7
POWER TRIP

WOHM 5 TBR Diesel


Maris Dislers reviews this crisply finished 5cc diesel from Cre8tionworx the manufacturers of the
WOHM and CLAMO branded single and multi-cylinder engines, as well as replica engines.

D
ean Clarke’s one-man Adrian Duncan’s WOHM 5 TBR single,
enterprise in Cambridge, while en route to him in Canada.
New Zealand resembles Generous of Duncan, or perhaps a
those of Ronald Valentine canny way of having someone else
or Derek Giles. Handcrafted do the running in?
model engines in very small batches The WOHM 5 TBR is
following a distinct theme. So that from the short-stroke
customers won’t very often su er development line, unlike
someone else “wearing the same frock”. the earlier 3.5cc/5cc
Dean’s forte is multi-cylinder types – long-stroke WOHMs. It
diesel and glowplug – right through to would not have been out
the gorgeous V-12 Wraith. He can also of place on a hobby shop
repair/restore your treasured model shelf circa 1960. Classic
engine. Oliver Tiger inspired cylinder
Starting out by restoring engines in porting, front rotary induction,
his own collection, Dean’s first home- crankshaft riding in two ball
build was an in-line twin 15 years ago, races. ot so di erent
continuing to design and build others, to a variety of 2.5cc
forming the CLAMO (Clarke Motor) diesels, only at twice
range of boxer and V-form engines. the swept volume.
All made the old-fashioned way with Unlike quantity-
basic machine tools – no computer produced engines
driven stu . He also makes a range of using crankcase
single and three-cylinder radial engines castings,
(by arrangement) under the WOHM the WOHM
(Wolfgang Otto Höpfner Motor) brand. crankcase is
Herr Höpfner continues to produce his machined
own engines from time to time, while from solid
Dean has retained the basic concept,
redesigning his range to be lighter, more
compact, and more powerful. All can
be admired at the Cre8tionworx
website (cre8tionworx.co.nz)
although not all are
available at one time.
Not so exotic but
is still out of the
rut, we tested

OH 5 TBR is the latest offering from a line


of single and multi cylinder model engines,
handcrafted by ean Clarke of Cre8tionwor .

8 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


Following classic-
era design lines,
performance and
handling are as good
as its looks.

Dean Clarke of Cre8tionworx is producing


finely finished diesel and glow engines from his
workshop in New ealand.

aluminium billet. Which can look


lumpish but is done well here. Narrow
lugs probably best mounted to a metal
surface, rather than direct onto wooden
bearers. Overall weight and size are
quite reasonable. Cylinder fins and
spinner anodized a pleasing green colour
(perhaps inspired by the Bavarian Forest, inclined ports cut into external, lower Starts are straightforward with finger
or Robin Hood’s doublet and hose?) cylinder wall. Exhausts sawn through choking alone. Too generous and it can
adding distinction to the well-finished the mounting flange. Upper and lower start backwards and run out the excess.
exterior for a bodacious overall look. sections precision ground to fit closely Two or three choked turns from cold. For
Propeller driver has a 9mm spigot for into the crankcase and cooling fins. warm starts one choke turn only, then
centring the propeller. Spinner nut is Flat-top cast iron piston is extensively turn over until a bump is felt and it will
cross-drilled 3mm for tightening. lightened internally and has a pressed in start in one or two flips.
The crankshaft has counterbalanced gudgeon pin. Compression setting for starts is not
web with 6mm crankpin, 12mm main critical. That can be left at optimum
journal diameter, stepping down to On the Bench position for restarting without the
10mm for the front bearing and threaded The WOHM 5 comes in an attractive tendency to “bite” with lighter loads,
M6 for the propeller retaining stud. box, but without instructions (those were although an energetic flip will be needed
6.5mm diameter rotary intake port not yet ready.) Uneventful running in, to bring it smartly over compression.
and passage. Machined high tensile progressively approaching peak settings Contra piston adjustment is remarkably
aluminium connecting rod is unbushed. over a series of two-minute runs for light to the touch, holding the setting
Cast iron cylinder with four equally around one hour total. Then a further and backing o perfectly when required;
spaced transfer bypasses and upwardly 30 minutes before performance tests. to a slow tick-over around 3,000 RPM if
desired. Mixture adjustment is very fine,
OH 5 is not that with running position around 5 –6 turns
much larger for double open. Optimum running comes with
the swept volume of
similar icron 2.5cc mixture set just rich enough to prevent
engine. arger engine an over-lean “white smoke” misfire. Fuel
offers higher torque,
operates at moderate economy is then quite acceptable. Low
RP , for different vibration up to around 12,000 RPM, then
applications, such as
classic stunt models increasing significantly around 1 ,000
originally powered RPM, which is usual for engines of this
by 29 5 si e glow
engines. size and type.
We used a typical fuel formula of 25%
castor oil, 30% ether, 45% kerosene,
with 1.5% added ignition improver
(Amsoil Cetane Boost). Well suited to
running in the peak horsepower zone
but showing signs of over-advanced

AeroModeller 1027 - 9
POWER TRIP
Sturdy crankshaft design allows this one to turn large propellers
in comfort. ecent counterbalancing keeps vibration low at
higher speeds.

Crankcase is machined from solid billet stronger than equivalent casting. Care is
taken to minimise bulk, while keeping it sturdy.

ignition with heavy loads. The WOHM internal loads. Best you can do is back
5 was much happier swinging large o and richen mixture to a compromise
propellers with fuel containing only setting.
.75% ignition improver. That mix good Diesel ignition improvers (a.k.a.
through to 11,000 RPM without RPM Cetane Boosters) are the tincture of
loss, indicating it is not very fussy about tenderness for solving the problem. amount added – up to a point- as shown
fuel in the midrange zone. Nothing new Alkyl nitrates with fancy names, such in the accompanying chart taken from an
in that approach. Peter Chinn used as iso-propyl nitrate, iso-amyl nitrate, old issue of Circle Torque. Disregard the
three di erent fuel mixes when testing 2-ethyl-hexyl nitrate or octyl nitrate. numbers on the RPM and Compression
the ED Super Racer, to put it in its best Choice between them is mostly price Ratio scales, as they’ll be significantly
light. And a good excuse to digress and or availability because the di erences di erent for other engines. Look at the
expand on the phenomenon. in their e ectiveness are minimal. trends versus ignition improver content.
Small amounts in diesel fuel modify Power eventually drops due to reduced
Diesel Ignition Improvers the way it burns and how its energy is combustion expansion pressure in the
Almost all model diesels have a rough released, better harmonising that with cylinder at lower operating compression
exhaust note when pushed to highest the optimum power portion of the cycle ratio.
RPM on a basic ether plus lubricant at higher speeds. That goes a long way Unless run under-compressed and
(base fuel such as kerosene/paraffin toward overcoming the ether detonation well short of peak, all diesels need
optional) mix. Screw down compression problem. The result is higher power warm-up time to stable operating
(to clear the apparent misfire) and the output, better fuel economy and slightly temperature before final settings can
problem only gets worse. Some of the improved cold starting. Think of it as a be established. That warm-up time and
ether detonates well ahead of the piston modifier, unlike nitromethane in glow fuel, tendency to overheat increases with
reaching top dead centre. Black exhaust which adds its own “chemical power”. greater ignition improver content. Go
oil is the tell-tale sign of excessive This e ect is proportional to the too far and compression setting must be

E ample Effect of Adding iesel gnition mprover

10 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


PERFORMANCE PERFORMANCE
Bore: 18.86 mm (. 42 in) Propeller RPM
Stroke: 18.14 mm (. 14 in) APC 9 x 4 1 200
Swept Volume: 4.90 cc (.299 cu in) Super/Graupner 10 x 12540
Weight: 2 8 g ( 8.40 o ) Super/Graupner 9 x 5 11900
Height (mount face to cylinder top): 61 mm (2.4 in) APC 9 x 6 11850
Length (to prop driver face): mm (2.8 in) APC 10 x 4 11500
Mounting screw pattern: 18 x 8 mm (0. 1 x 1.5 in) APC 10 x 6 9800
Exhaust duration: 158 degrees APC 11 x 6 8800
Transfer duration: 110 degrees APC 12 x 6 600
Sub-piston induction: 20 degrees APC 12 x 100
Intake open/close: 60 ABDC – 0 ATDC APC 12 x 8 6650
Intake duration: 150 degrees APC 1 x 6 6950
ecti e cho e re 8.54 sq. mm APC 1 x 6600
APC 14 x 6 5900

increased for cold starts, the engine runs and choose the one closest to your
hot despite backing o the compression needs. r mix your own – it can be worth
setting or overheats easily when the e ort.
unexpected load in flight occurs and
won’t recover when the going get easier. Performance Appraisal
Air temperature and ether/kerosene/ The W HM 5 has no nasty traits that
oil proportions in the mix have some would deter someone used to running
e ect, but it mostly comes down to much smaller capacity diesels. ot
engine type and cylinder porting. A few critical on settings, it does its best
slow-revving engines work well without work in the moderate speed running
ignition improver. Some engines give range and with notable capability when
their best with as much as 4 improver, turning large propellers. The modest
perhaps because the lower operating e ective choke area works particularly
compression ratio reduces internal well at the lowest operating speeds. Classic cylinder porting. n this instance,
friction losses, such as from crankshaft Suspecting it might hold back higher bypasses are entirely formed in lower cylinder
portion. Special grade of cast iron used for
flex. Around 0.5 – 1 improver works speed performance, we tried a slimmer cylinder and piston shows only light contact after
well for old-style 1940’s diesels and spraybar - no RPM gain, but irregular our tests, suggesting a long operating life, if kept
away from dust.
many others swinging large propellers running when not tuned correctly. Dean
up to around 10,000 RPM. Higher speed had it just right all along.
engines run best in the 1.5 – 2.5 range. Putting it into numbers, maximum maintained to 9,000 RPM, at which
Commercial fuels can’t get it right for all torque a little over 45 o -in torque is . 8 BHP is realised. The power curve
engines or uses, so follow their advice indicated at the lower end. Almost all then climbs quite gently, peaking at .42
BHP broadly around 11,500 RPM and
dropping o as vibration levels rise. ot
many published test reports for 5cc
diesels, but this one easily outperforms
the first-generation Wildcats and Drones.
More on par with the Miles 5cc “special”
or PAW 29. While the exotic multis from
Cre8tionworx are more likely to impress
the crowd gathered around a test bench,
the W HM 5 TBR really belongs in a
Classic Stunt CL model or suitable ld
Timer RC type. ■

CONTACT:
Contact Dean Clarke for CLAM and W HM
model engines at
Website cre8tionworx.co.n
Phone 021 05 9 8
The secret to keeping spinner nut pristine is choosing close- Email the eng hotmail.com
fitting bar for tightening. Anything undersi e or not round Facebook Instagram CLAM Engines
causes damage. e used the smooth end of a mm drill bit.
POWER TRIP

The OH Three Cylinder ong Stroke


Radial is one of the production models
available in Diesel and Glow versions from
Cre8tionwor . ith such specialised engines
you may not be able to buy everything
‘straight off the shelf’.

Cre8tionworx Engines The C A O multi cylinder range has


Any lover of exotic engines will enjoy looking over Dean Clarke’s Cre8tionworx
included both flat and configuration
website (cre8tionworx.co.nz) to see the CLAMO and WOHM range of engines as well engines. At the time of writing BaMoPro in
as other specials and experimental proof of concept multi-cylinder. the U had a new in bo Shadow 4 Glow
and Phantom 4 cylinder flat diesel in stock.
Website bamopro.co.uk

The impressive looking CLAMO Wraith V12 Glow has a 4-6 month lead time Currently in development is this Si Cylinder ouble Row Radial Glow
and is limited to a production run of five units of which two have already engine. o look at the Cre8tionwor website for other interesting prototypes.
been sold. Price is NZD $6,500…

12 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


SQUADRON BOoKS
39008 B-25 MITCHELl 10268 F-111 AaRDVARK 10267 F-14 TOMCAT ALSO AVAILABLE
AIRCRAFT IN ACTION - SOFT COVER

NEW
1201 C-5 Galaxy in Action
1205 P-40 Warhawk in Action

ONLINE NOW 1213 P-80 Shooting Star in Action


10228 B-24 Liberator in Action
10221 B-25 Mitchell in Action
10222 P-38 Lightning in Action
10223 F-22 Raptor in Action
10238 A-20 Havoc in Action
10244 F-104 Starfighter in Action
10245 SR-71 Blackbird in Action
10265 F-111 Aardvark in Action
10239 B-58 Hustler in Action

AIRCRAFT IN ACTION - HARD COVER


50227 B-29 Superfortress in Action
50229 F3D Skyknight in Action

NEW
ONLINE NO
W
50207
50230
50231
B-52G/H Stratofortress in action
S-3 Viking in Action
C-17 Globemaster III in action

AT THE GATE SERIES - SOFT COVER


5801 Douglas DC-9/MD-80 At the Gate
28002 Boeing 737 At the Gate

WALK AROUND SERIES - SOFT COVER


25054 B-29 Superfortress Walk Around
25066 KC-135 Stratotanker Walk Around
25043 Messerschmitt Bf 109 G Walk Around

NEW
WALK AROUND SERIES - HARD COVER
65054 B-29 Superfortress Walk Around

ONLINE NOW
65070 Heinkel HE 111 Walk Around
65068 F9F Cougar Walk Around

WWW.DOOLITTLEMEDIA.COM
E. enquiries@doolittlemedia.com T. +44 (0) 1525 222573
Doolittle Media Ltd., Doolittle Mill, Doolittle Lane, Totternhoe, Bedfordshire, LU6 1QX, Great Britain
FREE FLIGHT TECHNOLOGY

BMK GPS
Locator System
CAN THIS DEVICE FROM MELIH AT BMK OFFER GPS ENABLED TRACKING AT AN AFFORDABLE PRICE? CHRIS EDGE
TESTS THE LATEST FROM THIS INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGY MANUFACTURER. ADDITIONAL PHOTOS BY SUSAN EDGE

o a few years back to be replaced

G
oodness, even the commercial stand-alone GPS tracker
packaging is perfection. for free-flight models called iCare2 (see by a much more expensive system
How you get a label on AM ovember 2015). To me it was a called FlyingNeuron, but what was
a box with mill-metric game-changer as now you could add a really needed was a cheaper, simpler
precision I don't know, but relatively small package to your model system with good functionality and
the latest box containing THE product to be able to locate it in 3-D space to an customer support to fill the void; I give
that many have been waiting for is just accuracy of 5m and at a distance of you (trumpets please) the BM Locator
spot on; I may have to frame it. But first many tens of kilometers. I've used mine System, comprising the FlexiDisplay
let's go back a bit. ever since and helped others retrieve (hand unit) and Alti-Loc GPS Beacon
models quickly from many difficult (model unit). This is a big move for
In The Beginning scenarios using both iCare2 and Pyxis BM which has been largely producing
Way back when, I reviewed the first competitor systems. iCare2 was killed small, cheap timers and associated kit

14 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


The Alti-Loc Beacon Transmitters come with
mounting lugs which can be removed.

Beautifully packaged: 'Starter Pack' of two Alti-Loc Transmitters and FlexiDisplay Receiver.

The new BMK system is smaller and lighter


than Chris’ existing system from iCare on (13mm wide with the 'ears' removed) charge lead for the FlexiDisplay, all for
right. with a power socket on the bottom, a around £300; additional Alti-Locs are
small push switch on one face and whip £60. Should you want to wire in the Alti-
aerial out the top. It contains small bits Loc to an existing model battery then
of exotic stu that provide, via a FM suitable leads are supplied as well, so if
radio link, a model's 3D position, altitude, you wanted to you could fire everything
and other useful information back to the up and sling the model straight way,
FlexiDisplay. It s the smallest/lightest right? Well it's always worth reading the
GPS tracker on the market – nu said. manual first and BM have produced
To switch it on you connect a 1S LiPo or a good online edition which at the
other battery source up to 15v and let it time of writing was here https //tinyurl.
acquire a satellite lock; that's all. com/2p85jv 5
The FlexiDisplay is a handheld unit Unlike the iCare2 system I've been
‘Kissing’ the antenna of the Alti-Loc you
want to track is the quickest way to select it. smaller than, say, an FM radio used for using for ~8 years now, the BMK
traditional tracking. It has two buttons, system has a pressure altimeter in the
an aerial and monochrome display model part, the Alti-Loc. This allows
(see reviews in AM issues 1014 and originally designed for a mobile phone. accurate data on model altitude, and by
1018), but this is a 'big-boy's-toy' with To turn it on you press the front red calculation, climb/sink rates (variometer),
application not just for free-flight but button for a few seconds, after which with maximums being shown in a simple
space modelling, drone racing and the it will acquire its own GPS position and table on the FlexiDisplay. What s more,
like. give information on the last selected Alti- the altitude/time data can be exported
And again, for full disclosure I've had Loc's position. It will also act as a radio- for the last ten flights, so you compare
a small input to the specification and a controlled DT (RCDT) transmitter if you model trims and things like rubber or
larger input to the testing of this system have suitable BMK equipped models. propeller e ects easily. The altimeter is
and received one of each item from BMK As purchased, all Alti-Locs will be not certified to FAI standards so can t be
free-of-charge, i.e. there was no party shipped set to a particular frequency in used as alternative scoring data – not yet
and I didn't inhale. But given how good conjunction with the FlexiDisplay so that at least.
I've found it I've now ordered more using when you switch everything on, you will When booted up, the Red Button on
cold hard Scottish Spondoolies (the get full functionality from the o . the front operates a RCDT transmitter
official currency in these parts) and am I suspect that most customers that can be coded and thence operates
fitting it to most of my models. will plump for the package of one any other BMK RCDT B1 and B2 receiver
FlexiDisplay and two Alti-Locs as shown you may have. So already you've saved
What you got, Mister? in the photo. This also comes with two some arm real-estate by needing one
Alti-Loc (Altimeter-Locator transmitter suitable Alti-Loc batteries (40mAh) with less item to carry around.
beacon) is a 1.5grm unit, ~20x20x5mm dedicated USB charger and a USB So in summary, here you have a GPS

AeroModeller 1027 - 15
FREE FLIGHT TECHNOLOGY

locator, altimeter, flight summary respectively (left to right); this


database, with in-built RCDT line is also duplicated on Screen
transmitter; it s small light and 2. The GPS label will show if the
relatively cheap against the GPS is acquired or not, or of poor
competition - unbelievable accuracy. There are three GPS
Did I mentioned the WiFi and lock states a flashing GPS
BlueTooth capability Best not, so means the unit is still acquiring
as to not fry the reader s brain. a satellite lock, a flashing L W
GPS means there is a satellite
Kissing with Confidence lock but it s quality is not too
An issue with any GPS system good, maybe in the order of 10s
is selecting the transmitter in the of meters of accuracy, (It s still
model you want to track. ften it usable in this state but it may
FlexiDisplay Default Screen 1 on switching on. (This and other requires multiple button presses, take a little longer to locate the
emulated screen images from BMK.) binding of the transmitter (Tx) to model) and a fixed GPS means
receiver (Rx) and the like; none of the highest accuracy, of the order
that here. First, the BM Locator of +-5m.
System doesn t require any The second line shows an Alti-
Alti-Loc Tx to be bound to the Loc signal strength (left) which
FlexiDisplay Rx. The advantage is will be in the range of 20 to 120,
reduced set-up time but also the the higher number being closer
ability to track any other Alti-Loc to it of course. To the right are
on the same frequency channel, values for GPS accuracy; the
which is useful if you want to help higher number the lower error in
a friend find their model. Second, positioning noting that the best
to select any of your Alti-Locs, accuracy you ll get is +-5m with
just kiss (touch) the receiver and a value of 5.
transmitter antennae for a few Line is the Alti-Loc ID. As
Holding the FlexiDisplay level ensures the compass direction is seconds (i.e. one transmit period) purchased this will have a 6-digit
accurate. and the FlexiDisplay will switch random hexadecimal value but it
to that. Some wag (i.e. me) has can be changed to anything you
dubbed this Antenna iss (TM) want in a settings file – more on
and it s a huge advantage in the that later. Below that (Line 4) is
heat of a contest. the current di erence in altitude
It is also possible to select an between the Alti-Loc and its
Alti-Loc from a list of known calibration height (i.e. the height
ones and I describe that later. when powered up); there is a
With a selected Alti-Loc you up or down arrow to show if it s
now get lots of information climbing or not. Finally, the bottom
on the Flexi-Display screen, line is the distance to the Alti-Loc
originally designed as a okia at the last received transmission
monochromatic pixel display, with next to it an arrow showing
which is easy to read in low light. its direction. As you move, the
The supplied battery provides a tidy 3.1grm airborne package. distance and arrow will change
Screen Idols of course noting that keeping
The FlexiDisplay has a number the FlexiDisplay flat in your hand
of screen and menus that display will provide the most accurate
information and allow changes to direction to the model (or chicken
the unit s set-up. When booted up if you re so inclined; noted for a
from cold the FlexiDisplay shows friend).
a default screen (Screen 1) which An Alti-Loc will transmit roughly
for most of the time is the one every second when gliding, 0.5s
you ll probably use. Let s assume period when climbing and, if
you have a Alti-Loc powered up, not moving, about once every
kissed and thence selected on 8s; in the latter case the display
the FlexiDisplay. will show a LA DED tag. The
The top line describes the altitude data is updated via the
Rear of Alti-Loc showing pressure altimeter and channel select
GPS status and battery voltage pressure transducer on the Alti-
button. for the Alti-Loc and FlexiDisplay Loc, it doesn t take its height data

16 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


from GPS which tends to be much less each new flight is started when the Alti-
accurate. Loc's altimeter records a climb above
Other screens are selected using the 20m at greater than 1m/s – I've tested
button on the edge of the FlexiDisplay, this with an E30 and it works very well
hence called the Edge Button (or maybe although it can be triggered by a strong
after the bod who suggested it, but he's blow on the Alti-Loc, so positioning in a
too shy to admit that…) So from the model's fuselage is important. My E30
default screen, press the Edge Button to has the Alti-Loc in the pylon and flights
get to Screen 2 etc. are recorded correctly. Also note that
Screen 2 gives the data from the the flight time (bottom line) is based on
pressure altimeter in the Alti-Loc, so an arbitrary but consistent criterion and Screen 2 on the FlexiDisplay includes data
from the pressure altimeter in the Alti-Loc.
relative and max. height, climb or sink must not be used for timing purposes.
rate but also a small bearing arrow and The flight data from the pressure
distance (LOS, or Line Of Sight) to the altimeter can be downloaded from the
model. Both this and the default screens FlexiDisplay but best read the manual for
have their merits, and the user will have how to do that – it s in .CS format for
a preference. For instance, if you're those that understand this sort of thing.
trimming a power model and want to
do short flights with di erent props to FlexiDisplay Settings
assess climb rate and maximum altitude, Screen 5 allows you to go to a 'Settings'
then this is the puppy for you. The data page. Press the Red Button and you'll
is saved to a file which can be accessed see the Settings options, scrolling down
Screen 3 on the FlexiDisplay has a QR code
so no need to write anything down; the to see them all. which can be scanned to show last position
method to enable this will be described Use the Edge Button to scroll down of model on GoogleMaps.

later. and the Red Button to select the option,


Note that currently the height is both at the top level (i.e. this) screen
calculated relative to the 'zero' height of or individual settings screens. I will go
the Alti-Loc, i.e. absolute height when through the important ones in detail.
powered up. I learn that the FlexiDisplay 'Beacon Select' is an alternative way
also has a pressure transducer so of, err, selecting Alti-Locs. Once this
relative height between the two units option selected, the FlexiDisplay will
could also be calculated (yes please!). scan the current frequency channel for
Another press of the Edge Button any operational Alti-Locs and list them to
gives you Screen 3 and provides a Quick the screen. Use the Edge Button to scroll
Screen 4 gives a flight summary ma imum
Response (QR) code that you can scan down and then the Red Button to select height, sink and climb rates, and distance.
with a phone or tablet that links to the the one you want, and the main screens
last transmitted position of the model will now track that Alti-Loc. Note that the
shown on GoogleMaps; this clearly is the ID displayed will be the hexadecimal one
work of the devil! unless you've changed it to your own
This screen (3) includes the Alti-Loc designation in an initiation (.I I) file.
ID (top line) and the day/time of the 'WiFi' switches on the FlexiDisplay
positional data (bottom line). This is WiFi operation which allows you to
important as it possible to select an download data or change other settings
alternative Alti-Loc from a previous flight via an .I I file shown on a phone or
and display its position (via Screen 1) tablet browser. The reason you will need
and QR code to allow tracking at a later to use it is to set your RCDT code if you Screen 5 allows access to Settings.
time. have one, or to change the Alti-Loc IDs
As an aside, it's fun to watch the QR to something sensible like CHE01 or
code change when the model is in flight. Cheryl . If this sounds complicated, it s
The pixels obviously mean something to not – it s no di erent to say adding an
the experts but I'm sure I saw the face of app to your phone, and the advantage
Nigella Lawson at one point... is that when BMK come up with new
Screen 4 gives a flight summary, so features or updates for the FlexiDisplay
maximum height, sink and climb rates, unit, so changing the start tune to your
distance, based on the data from Screen 2. favourite Caduceus ditty for example
Each flight has a sequential number ( a popular beat-combo m Laud), then
and the FlexiDisplay saves the last 10, it doesn't need to be returned to BMK. The Settings Screen. Use the Edge button
which you can scroll through using the Note that the Alti-Loc software can only to scroll down and the Red Button to select
the option.
Red Button. So, what s a flight Currently be modified by returning it to BM but

AeroModeller 1027 - 17
FREE FLIGHT TECHNOLOGY

need to worry about it unless you have


initials like CHE or JvdP.

Beam me down, Scotty


In addition to the location and altitude
function, there is another trick up the
sleeve of the FlexiDisplay and that is a
competition-standard RCDT transmitter.
When booted up and not in the 'Settings'
menu the Red Button acts as the RCDT
button for BMK RCDT receivers and
BMK RCDT equipped timers like the
E36+ and E20+. If you already have a
BMK B1 or B2 transmitter then you can
program the FlexiDisplay with its 6-digit
hexadecimal code and thence use it to
DT your model as well! This gives a very
complete system that e ectively removes
the need for an extra unit to be taken out
to the flight-line/downwind.
The RCDT code is set via the WiFi
page described earlier. If you don't own
a B1 or B2 then you can set your own
Access to flight data and user variables in the . N file is via the Fle i isplay iFi connection. code of course, and 'bind' the RCDT
receivers in the usual BMK way. Range
this is considered extremely unlikely. you're really keen, you can view the has been tested by me as being better
'Compass Cal.' will calibrate the 'RAW DATA' that the unit is receiving/ than 1km on the ground.
FlexiDisplay's internal digital compass measuring. To switch o the unit just
and it is suggested you do this on press the Edge Button for 3s, or for a Installation Tips
receipt. If you notice an error on the hard reset press the Red Button for 6s. The Alti-Loc should ideally be positioned
compass arrow's direction to the model Way too much information, right? Well vertically within a fuselage with the top 6
(Screens 1 & 2) then it maybe you're the nice thing is that after initial set-up to 7mm clear of any conducting material
in an area of magnetic anomaly which to select an Alti-Loc you don't have to such as carbon fiber, or else GPS
can a ect the compass accuracy and do anything other than switch both units performance is compromised. To ensure
it will be prudent to calibrate it again. on and use it. For others (no names you do this whilst providing a mounting
Note that when searching, the compass mentioned, let s just called them Chris surface and additional weatherproofing
direction shouldn t be a ected by small and Jules) the other information can for the Alti-Loc and fuselage innards,
inclinations of the FlexiDisplay from be rather useful; now if only the Lagina why not use the Edge Hat (TM); these are
horizontal as it has a doobrey inside that Brothers had a few of these that Oak now being 3D printed by alumni such as
corrects for that. But, Top Tip: hold the Island treasure would already be theirs. Mark Benns (.STL file available soon).
FlexiDisplay in the palm of your hand for
it to be as level as possible to check the The .INI File, Innit? The Proof is in the Pudding
compass direction. Many of the user variables and other “But enough of the functions Chris, how
Using the 'Channel Scan' and 'Channel neat stu is configured on boot-up of do you use it in practice?”
Set' options allows you to select an the FlexiDisplay in a .I I (initiation) file Fair comment, let's look at a practical
alternative channel for the FlexiDisplay. that you can modify using the WiFi link. scenario. You are on a perfect flying field
You might want to do this to help a fellow In fact once visible on your browser, the covered with eil raft Trimming Grass,
flier find their model if on a di erent .I I file is directly editable, so it s easy the sky is blue, the wind is light (Get on
channel to the one you use, or in the to set new Alti-Loc IDs, the RCDT code, with it! - Ed).
extreme case of too many users on Alti-Loc channel number, and to enable Fire up your Alti-Locs by connecting
your preferred channel. Don't forget pressure-time recordings, etc. I must them to a battery; let's say you have two
you would need to change all your Tx check if it has the 'Strictly' results as models ready. Fire up the FlexiDisplay
channels as well (with the small button well... - there is an amount of LED flashing as
on the Alti-Loc) so not a trivial task and I see the .I I file being very powerful it boots up and acquires satellite lock –
something that the manual will explain in time, so perhaps the option to this can take some time if you have total
better than I can. change flight data from vertical speed cloud cover. Antenna Kiss to the model
There are a other options that allow to horizontal speed for example – useful you want to use and check GPS has
a 'RETURN' to the main screen, a for drones. But if this sort of thing brings acquired on both units and the battery
'REBOOT' of the FlexiDisplay and, if you out in a rash, don't worry, you won't voltages are good. By now you should

18 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


see that the signal strength is near 100; manner as an FM beacon. With iCare2
time to sling it into that stonking thermal! the transmit period when stationary was
Model 1 is flown but ends up in the long, in my case 50s to save battery life,
Haggis Farm – drat and double-drat, so triangulating took a long time, but the
you ll have to retrieve it later. Antenna BM system transmits at 8s intervals
Kiss Model 2 and check the Tx ID has even when stationary so it will speed up
changed and the distance and direction finding the model. h, and don t forget
Typical Alti-Loc fuselage installation.
to that model makes sense. You fly that you have the R code which will show
and make two more maxes and you re you on a map where the model is which
in the flyo . But with no time to retrieve can be very useful as well. And no, I
Model 1, you fly Model 2 in the flyo , haven t tested flying into a tree... yet..
glide over the Haggis Farm (Phew - Ed) Let s add a little detail to these
and in to open land beyond. Using the scenarios and cover the generic case. In
R code option and selecting each flight Screen 1 will show an increasing
Tx in turn via Beacon Set , you get model distance, altitude and the bearing
GoogleMap positions for both models. to the model. The human body s in-built
Model 1 is still in the farm, so select genetic code will want you to state loudly
Model 2 again and cycle o to collect. what distance you model is, but fight this
nce picked up, select Model 1 and urge if you can as it is very annoying to
approach the farm – rats, the gate is other fliers. ote that it s important to
locked and you ll have to come back hold the FlexiDisplay flat in the palm of
D printed ‘Edge Hat’ for the Alti-Loc tomorrow. your hand to get an accurate bearing,
provides extra protection. (Photo by Mark
Benns) ext day after a restless night, you fire otherwise there s nothing else to do until
up the FlexiDisplay again knowing that the model lands.
the last Tx you selected was for Model For the vast majority of flights you will
1 and all the data from the last received have seen the model down and have a
transmission has been saved. You go good idea where it is, but in some cases
to the farm and find a slightly di erent the model s landing point may not been
position to the night before as Truss, the seen or else you re Phil Ball and you ve
local farmhand, has found the model and just done a hour flight to the next
moved it to the office. You track the model county. ( ther nationally recognised
to the right building and engage Truss in aeromodelling heroes are also available.)
erudite conversation about the advantages This is where the R code on
of GPS model tracking. Job done. Screen is particularly useful as it
The FlexiDisplay operates all BMK RCDT Let s now consider the tree scenario as allows transferring the last transmitted
Receivers – just be careful where you leave landing a model in a tree is often quoted GPS data to GoogleMaps on your
smartphone. As noted before, scan
it.
as a scenario where an FM beacon can
perform better. In such circumstances the code and a link will appear that
you reduce the FM receiver aerial to just you click to bring up the GoogleMaps
a short length of wire to significantly app; in some cases the app is loaded
attenuate the signal and identify the automatically. A pin is shown at the
tree – I ve done this myself to good model s last transmission point and, if
e ect. But now we have more data to you re clever like people called Jules,
use, so let s see how that helps. First you can use the GoogleMaps Directions
you know the height of the Alti-Loc from option to help navigate you to the pin s
the starting position. ext you have position. Even if you re only a few fields
the signal strength meter on Screen 1 out the R code link will show you the
which really comes in to its own at short pin position relative to field boundaries,
Use wire plastic insulation tube to reinforce distances. The GPS distance/direction obstacles like trees, the local Haggis
the exit of aerials and allow threading in
compact pylons. data will get you close, within the typical Farm, etc., all of which can help you
GPS tolerance but yes, closer to the make good decisions on how to navigate
model and especially if it s up a tree down wind.
the data can be confusing. So switch
to using the signal strength, walking a This is my generic prescription,
square to triangulate the strongest signal published a few times now, when
and that will get you within a few meters. retrieving with GPS
If you wish you could still replace the
FlexiDisplay aerial with a short length of 1) Stay put. Each transmission is giving
wire as it is working in exactly the same you the model’s position in D space

AeroModeller 1027 - 19
Tape used to space RCDT and GPS aerials
on Chris’ E30 - annotation helpful for aging
brains.
FREE FLIGHT TECHNOLOGY

to within ~5m, so as long as you get a


transmission you know exactly where it
is and you can navigate to it. Chasing
risks loosing the transmission (i.e. it
suddenly DTs as you start driving/
riding o and the transmission ceases).

2) Watch the numbers. Rather than


just a beep from which you can only
get direction and a poor estimate of
distance, the numbers are very useful.
They tell you how far it is and, more
importantly, if it is still going up or
not. If still going up then relax, just
enjoy the ride, if coming down then do
). ote that testing shows typically
20kms range at 80m altitude, likely
more if the model is higher but there
will be a limit on range based on the
power of the transmitter, this could be
30, 40 kms however; experience will
eventually show what is achievable.

3) Hold the receiver above your head.


Like a FM tracker receiver, every extra
foot in height is a benefit in keeping
the data coming. As with a traditional
bug, as the model gets closer to the
ground you will eventually loose line-
of-sight to the transmitter and the data
will cease. Review the numbers after
each transmission, is it coming down
or not?

4) The last transmission will likely be at


some finite altitude. If the model was
descending quickly (you’ve followed
2) right ) then it will have landed close
to the position shown on the receiver.
In this case plot the last transmission
position on a map (you carry a paper
map of the site with you, right ) and
navigate to it. If the last transmission
showed the model was still high,
say a few hundred meters, and was
descending slowly then you need to
extrapolate a landing position/area.
If your receiver has a ‘sight and go’
function then use that to plot a line
through the last transmitted position to
aid this, and/or use a map to achieve
the same.

5) You’re now downwind at the last


transmitted position. If the model

Chris ‘Antenna Kisses’ the FlexiDisplay


against the Alti-Loc aerial to pair the device
fitted in his glider.

20 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


is within 500m or so then you’ll get as you can receive the information, so one from the last flight.
another transmission and you’ll know what s the range and battery life like The Alti-Loc will continue to transmit
where the model is to within 5m - I tested the BMK system against at voltages down to . v at which point,
go and get it! If you are at the last iCare2 using transmitters on a assuming you have no battery protection
transmitted position and don’t get calibrated table in the garden. I put circuit, it will switch o the GPS receiver
a signal then you need to get one. both transmitters side-by side in similar BUT continue to transmit its last position
Clearly the model is further along its models and cycled o down the drive. until the battery voltage is 1.8v. At this
flight line (as per the sight-and-go and/ Both hand units have indicators that point the battery will be totally du but
or map heading) so head downwind show when the signal has been lost, in at least it s dying coulomb may just
in 500ms steps, trying to gain height the case of the FlexiDisplay the top line allow you to pick up your errant model s
to increase transmission range to the of Screens 1 and 2 will show a GPS position.
model. You’ll eventually get to a point flashing tag, and a small chirp that also
where you’ll get another transmission indicates a received signal will no longer The Known Unknowns…
and hence you know where the model be heard. I got to the local village at Is this all I hear you say? Well for the
is. If you still don’t get a transmission 1. kms and could just get a signal from time-being yes, but there is a steady
after heading downwind in steps, then both systems, so I see them as having stream of new functions that are being
frankly I’m in uncharted territory. I equivalent ground range. Given that s a considered and I m told it s intended to
would likely plot the flight on a paper worst case, I expect airborne range to set up an online user wish list in due
map and extrapolate more accurately be in the iCare2 s tested value of ten s of course. For example, I do know that the
the likely landing position from the kilometers – more than enough. FlexiDisplay has BlueTooth connectivity
altitude/direction data. The only In terms of battery life, The FlexiDisplay which opens up possibilities to send the
positive is that, assuming it hasn’t has an in-built 1S LiPo which can be GPS and altimeter data to, say, a phone
been picked up, you know where it charged via a USB port on the side with app. at some point in the future; Rocket
isn’t so maybe at this point you start a stated battery life of 20 hours; better Locator is a good example. Is SkipYogi
phoning landowners. than iCare and more than sufficient. Top enabled Frankly I don t know but
Tip always take out to the field one of wouldn t it be good if it was
6) If you’ve got a signal and the model those USB power bricks so if necessary The good news is that updates
is in a tree you have a slightly di erent you can plug it in to the GPS receiver. will be available to load via WiFi, so
issue. Here the GPS accuracy can be After all you don t want to have a low no requirement for a return to BMK;
insufficient to spot the model, but you battery warning just as you ve launched any firmware changes to the Alti-
now use the signal strength meter on your model in to a big flyo thermal, Loc transmitters will require a return,
the receiver. This displays the Tx s er not that I ve ever had that happen however, but that is much less likely.
signal strength with the maximum (remember the injunction, kids). What I find with BM is that they are
typically being within inches of the You can connect the Alti-Loc to an very positive about users ideas and I
transmitter; it’s best to do some testing existing model s battery or a dedicated can visualise updates appearing with
beforehand to get used to what the one via the small connector. I tend to some regularity. For example, during
numbers mean; you can use body use the battery installed for an electronic testing I suggested a few extra functions
shielding for direction if you wish. The timer and find those sufficient for a day s that were available with the next firmware
one occasion I had to use this method flying; the added advantage is that the update – I ve never had that before with
was when my model landed in a tree voltage is displayed on the FlexiDisplay any other supplier of model electronics.
but was not immediately visible from so you know the status of it at any time
ground level. It took a few minutes and can re-charge if needed. I currently Summary
but I eventually saw it using the signal prefer batteries of 500mAh for multi- I ve been a strong advocate for GPS
strength information - note that you servo timers + GPS and that allows a retrieval for some years now, it saves
can use the altitude value to tell how good trimming session, or a contest plus a lot of time when going to collect you
high it is, very useful. F . model especially for those long flights.
If you want lightest possible installation Having used most of the GPS products
The Power and the Glory then use the supplied 40mAh LiPo. It has on o er I can honestly say that the BM
All these capabilities are great as long a stated tested life of 1 hour updating system is accurate, has good range, is
the GPS, followed by a longer period phenomenally good value for money
transmitting the last position as noted and gives you additional functions, such
LINKS: below. This will be sufficient for many as the flight summary information, that
BMK shop - bmks.co.uk
shorter contest flights and trimming; you will use on a regular basis. If you re
BMK GPS system manual : https://cdn. don t forget that the retrieval will often considering upgrading from a free-flight
shopify.com/s/files/1/0594/0959/662 /files/ be significantly quicker, with a swap-out FM tracking system or want a high-
BM FlexiDisplay User Manual v1 DRAFT. of the battery (or recharge) once back at quality GPS for your space model or
pdf v 16644452 9
base. If I was using these batteries then drone, then this will delight you. Highly
BMK Facebook page www.facebook.com
Group bmkfreeflight
I d have do en all charged up ready, recommended. ■
with the supplied charger topping up the

AeroModeller 1027 - 21
FREE FLIGHT SCALE

SCALE MATTERS
BILL DENNIS ON THE OXFORD SCALEFEST TOGETHER WITH HIS AND OTHERS LATEST BUILDS.
ADDITIONAL PHOTOS BY ANDY BLACKBURN
DANKOK where it went by the name of Dankok. a Mills 5 equivalent but with a shorter
We’ll kick o this month with another Twelve were made and remarkably one intake, which fits. The structure makes
striking model by Richard Hewitt. The still exists. The model is 2” span and use of carbon spars and thread bracing,
Hawker Danecock was a version of the weighs 15o , giving a loading of 6.5o / combined with the more traditional tail
Woodcock built for the Danish Airforce, sq ft. Power is an MPJet 040 which is and wingtip structures. The model has a
striking air of realism.

OXFORD SCALEFEST
September saw a welcome return for the
xford Scalefest meeting, particularly as
Dreaming Spires was blown out earlier
in the year. Charlie ewman took the
unusual step of running the event on
a Thursday as an experiment because
of the increasingly-difficult weekend
parking at Port Meadow. I had my
doubts, but I was wrong; the turnout was
good and apart from one regular, most
of the usual suspects were there and a
good time was had by all in very clement
conditions. However, the fact that so
many were free to attend, unencumbered
by work, was revealing about the

Two views of Richard Hewitt’s Hawker Dankok, showing an impressive air of realism. (Photos by Richard Hewitt)

22 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


Steve Glass’s Chipmunk would have been an impossible project before the advent of the gyro. (Photo by Andy Blackburn)

demographic for ‘real’ aeromodelling! very long bungee would not detach and f Simon’s diesel models I particularly
Again, power was the most well- the model wing-overed into the ground hoped to see him try the Flycatcher from
supported and we were able to contrast beyond our encampment. The resultant the AeroModeller plan. I built one a few
the flying style of gyro and non-gyro impact released the tight bungee which years ago and it was hopeless, lacking
models. The gyro model is very steady whizzed at high speed through the in all directional stability. Walking back
and predictable, never deviating from its assembled flyers and models, luckily with the bits one day at Port Meadow I
circular path. Steve Glass’s Chipmunk without picking anything up on the way. met a chap who had built one with the
was very impressive in the way you
could see it reacting to aileron inputs
almost instantaneously. Ivan Taylor’s
beautiful FW190 also impressed but
was hampered by a variable engine run.
Best flight was Mike Smith’s DH4 which
wandered about the field before coming
back almost to land in the tent. In rubber
one of my favourites was Ivan’s Mig but
it flew as if the wings were very pointy,
which they are, and sustained some
damage.
Simon Rogers had a fleet of diesel
models but only flew his Hotspur in the
glider competition. n one flight the

van Taylor’s fabulous Fw190 was going well, aided by its gyro, but the ills was getting a little hot and
bothered. (Flying photo by Andy Blackburn)

AeroModeller 1027 - 23
Steve Glass’s electric Saab Tunnan was a
fine flyer and featured in September 2014
AeroModeller.
FREE FLIGHT SCALE

Avro 560 Simon Rogers’ Avro 560 appears


to be Dart-powered. Is there a simpler
scale subject?

Heinkel He5 Hansa The Heinkel Hansa


featured in the 1955 Aeromodeller Annual
Pete Fardell’s atmospheric Bleriot passes overhead with just the right degree of translucency. but is woefully inaccurate. Nevertheless it
Interestingly, all the Shuttleworth pioneer machines appear to have just been re-covered in very clean does fly well this one by Simon Rogers.
linen! (Photo by Andy Blackburn)

same lack of success. Furthermore, he getting perilously close to trying again. Anyway, the new Swallow has flown
said he had been in the same club as I had with me the Coasby BA Swallow about fifteen times without mishap,
designer Stan Perry who said his never that I revisited recently to see if that which must be some kind of record for a
flew either, despite the encouraging extreme pendulum rudder really worked. low-winger.
blurb accompanying the plan. This kind ne thing I realised is that the pendulum
of thing was apparently quite common weight needs to be quite substantial STATIC JUDGING
in the magazines, but what could be because I could see that even on hand The xford Scalefest and the FF Scale
wrong with the Flycatcher? Yes it is glides the rudder was being blown Nationals a few weeks earlier both
a slightly odd-looking thing with the straight by the slipstream when it should featured static judging to the BMFA
extreme stagger, virtually no nose and an have been heeled over. That is another schedule and on each occasion it turned
oddly-shaped and low fin, but nothing reason for scepticism over the Flycatcher into a chore for all concerned. Most of
to suggest it would be an anvil. I did which also features a pendulum rudder; our meetings are Flying Only, where we
experiment with increasing the fin si e an inch of cored solder as the weight is just turn up and get on with flying. When
but to no avail. Any ideas? Because I am not even going to balance the rudder. the Nationals were held at Barkston it

Ivan Taylor’s big Mig 3 gets away before coming to grief – could it be the pointy wings? (Photo by Andy Blackburn)
One of the few glider entries was this attractive Hotspur – yet another Simon Rogers model. (Photo by Andy Blackburn)

mattered less that judging took all day doubt whether there would be much LYSANDER
because we could wander o and watch di erence and it certainly dramatically A few months ago I embarked on a
the combat or try to find something to reduces the time spent. With two judges double-size KK Lysander for either
buy in the trade stands that wasn’t made one falls into a routine of searching for, electric or diesel power. I lost impetus
of foam. However, here the process and discussing, errors but on your own, but this week just a few hours work
became tedious and it was clear that we you very quickly get a feel for the overall got me back on track and the model
need to find a way of speeding things up shape. If a fault cannot be seen within 20 is now finished. I made a front cowling
in one-day meetings. seconds, then it can’t be very important incorporating an ED Baby, which is the
The easiest way to streamline the and doesn’t matter anyway. least powerful of my engines because
process is to have just one static judge, The existing static section is largely in retrospect the Lysander is too small. I
rather than two discussing every point. unchanged since its inception in the didn’t even measure the thing, which is
Provided the judge is experienced, I late sixties, although thankfully the why the cylinder needs a hole. However
requirement to provide long rulers with there is a limit to how much you can
which to measure things was long-since enlarge before more ribs, formers and
rescinded I think it is still fit for purpose stringers are called for.
and should not be simplified significantly I double covered the fuselage with
because paradoxically, having fewer polyester tissue (two pieces) and
aspects against which to assess does Modelspan; the remainder in tissue only.
not make judging easier or quicker. Markings were printed on paper, given
two coats of dope to seal and then stuck

Mike Stuart gets his Fleetster away at Port Meadow.


Simon Rogers had built a Stan Perry
Flycatcher of ill-repute, unless you know
differently A very attractive sub ect from AeroModeller 1027 - 25
May 1955 AM that somebody needs to get
to fly
FREE FLIGHT SCALE

The double si e ysander is finished in odelspan and enamel, with The E Baby in the ysander is fed by a home made tank from a small spray
paper markings stuck on with canopy glue. bottle lid.

on with thinned canopy glue. the experiment has worked apart from mountings (like in the Lysander) is the
The wing area is 1sq ft and the weight the choice of subject. Any of the high tank because it has to sit on a solid
8oz, although I suspect tail weight, wing designs will have a lot more wing surface. The commonly-available tanks
unusually, will be needed. Even I can area, enabling the loading to be brought are tall and thin and the pipe exits straight
do that sum and the loading is a little down to around 6oz/sq ft. The Guillows down, and while this makes it easier to
more than I had hoped but nothing can designs would also be worth looking at. judge the length of run, it complicates
be done about the weight of the engine, installation and gives a big change in fuel
prop and mounting. It should fly well; FUEL TANKS head. This can be a problem with front
it’s the landings I worry about. I think The problem with certain engine induction engines. In the case of the

our columnist’s models at


O ford Scalefest. Note the
position of the pendulum
rudder on the Swallow
which persists throughout
flight. The ysander can be
a good it Scale model
it’s vestigial wings cause it
to fall out of the sky usually
after 0 seconds, but not
today
Lysander the pipe has nowhere to go. I the KK Piper Super Cruiser from the
have occasionally made my own tanks Superscale range. Of the three, the Piper
but now I’ve found a very easy solution. has the most wing area and a fabric-
Lots of little squirty bottles as found in covered structure more appropriate to
chemists, or lens cleaning liquid have a our building techniques. The full-size
clear plastic lid of just the right size. Drill Luscombe Silvaire fuselage, by contrast,
it straight through at the bottom from one is assembled from aluminium cones
side to the other. Cut a piece of suitable and not represented well by stringers.
brass tube to length and crimp and solder The Piper also has all the attributes for
one end to seal it. Find the place where a fine-flying model, equally suitable
the tube lies halfway across the tank and for conversion to rubber or electric,
file a groove to let the fuel in. Finally seal whichever is your favoured power
the tube in with proper Araldite. Passing source.
the tube all the way through the tank For Flying Only, the only improvements
anchors it securely. There is nothing new for practical use are to separate the
Many Guillow’s kits are available as laser in adapting plastic objects as tanks; PE wing panels from a fixed centre section
cut kits from www.guillow.com , but
not the Pfalz and some earlier Guillow’s Norman used the cases for toothbrushes and to sheet the LE for strength. For the
designs which can be found on Outerzone. in his ducted fan jets. Open classes, the biggest improvement
odel flies with ero dihedral, if a little
oddly! is to reduce the size of the tailplane – it
PFALZ is unnecessarily huge. If you really want
Another abandoned project was this to go to town, add the missing fuselage
Guillows Pfalz. I like the Guillows designs, stringer but after that it’s up to you.
especially the ones where the vertical keel The important thing is to get out and fly
structure used by all of them makes sense while you can. If you want to be kept
and this one looks remarkably accurate, up to date with what’s going on with FF
even down to the flat top wing and the Scale, send an email to Mike Smith at
Ron Marking’s Puss Moth is beautifully small tail. It did not take long to finish it michaeldocsmith@gmail.com
decorated; the blue centres of the fuselage o and spray it silver. I have just done a
lettering are still to be added. (Photo by
Ron Marking) few test flights and it certainly flies but TWO PUSS MOTHS
there are quirks. Noseweight has almost Always a popular design, this month we
cured a stall on glide but it flies right with have two versions. The first is by Ron
adverse bank. No doubt some dihedral Marking and is essentially an enlarged
would cure that but for me that is not an Westwings kit and so is very light at
acceptable option. 9.5oz. The motor is an inverted Dart,
which I hope behaves itself. Initial tests
CONTESTS look very promising. Enlarging a rubber
A conversation at Old Warden touched model for diesel seems a very good way
on what models might be suitable for of getting a light model. Ron is mainly a
Dave Causer’s AeroModeller DH80a Puss
Moth from the Belair kit. Thankfully Dave
Flying Only contests. Currently we have duration flyer but is also one of very few
has modified the fictitious cabin roofing of two main types of outdoor contest; who also have some interest in scale. It
the original. (Photo by Dave Causer)
Flying Only and the Open classes where has always puzzled me why there is so
static judging takes place. The former little crossover but there isn’t. I fly scale
is more popular than the latter, which when it is nice and duration when it isn’t.
is perceived as more difficult and much The other Puss Moth is the Longbon
more work but it need not be. There design, built from a Belair kit by Dave
are ways, with minimal e ort, to be Causer and fitted with a Mills 1. . I
competitive in both with the same model have built a couple of these models
and thus increase your flying time. and it is certainly one of the best-flying
In an Open contest you need to models I have had. Dave has chosen the
provide some documentation so that challenging scheme worn by G-ABLS
the judges can compare your model and described how he did the fuselage
with the full-si e, while you go o and fly pinstriping. The first stage is to paint
something else. That’s the only di erence the gold in the general area of the stripe
as far as the competitor is concerned. and then apply narrow tape of the
Most of the marks awarded are for the appropriate width before spraying the
accuracy of the outlines and it takes no whole thing black. Then peel o and
The nose of Fred Longbon’s Puss Moth is longer to build a model that is the correct admire.
too wide but does make fitting the ills shape than otherwise. That’s a lot of new models for us to see
easier. (Photo by Dave Causer)
An ideal model for this approach is next year. ■

AeroModeller 1027 - 27
FREE PLAN

Comper
Swift BY DENNIS RATTLE
RICHARD FALCONER BUILDS THE 24” SPAN RUBBER POWERED COMPER SWIFT ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED IN
MODEL AIRCRAFT MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 1963

28 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


The Comper Swift has distinct out-of-the-rut lines and Richard Falconer’s build
shows what a charming model it makes. The plan shows adaption to Cox TD 010, or
with a slight enlargement modern micro RC and electric or IC power would make a
fine small flyer.

L
ike a lot of 1950’s kids sticking plasters as I dripped
I spent my pocket blood on the kitchen floor. The
money and a great great Doug McHard contributed
deal of time building regularly to the AeroModeller but
Keil Kraft 3/9 scale in the 60’s he was a sta writer
kits. These would have been for Model Aircraft. This design by
three shillings and six pence Dennis Rattle from Cheltenham
but the government of the time accompanied one of Doug’s
decided that model aircraft were articles about improving small
not educational and imposed scale kits. To me the Comper was
purchase tax! The manufacturer’s a revelation. Lightweight, easy to
business plan was essentially build and a sensible si e, it flew
short term in that the inevitable beautifully.
failure of most of these models There is no need for me to add
was enough to direct disillusioned to the building instructions, but
builders to some other hobby. I would make a few points. No
Exceptionally a Hurricane built dihedral is shown on the plan and
when I was eight gave me it may well fly without it but I’ve
sufficiently inspiring flights to added 18mm to each tip and this
hook me for life. As all were cut seems to tie in with the length of
with a broken razor blade my the struts. It’s up to you whether
mother was adept with prompt to make the wing detachable: I

AeroModeller 1027 - 29
FREE PLAN

tend to pile on the turns which makes


this feature desirable! The undercarriage
should be improved by terminating the
radius arms on the centre of the fuselage
not the sides: leave them free to move to
avoid damage to the structure. Raise the
tailplane 2.5mm as it never sat directly
on top of the stringers. A removeable tail
will make the model virtually crash proof.
This is easily e ected with a cocktail
stick pin at the front and a rubber band
attached to ‘small hooks’ simulating
the struts. More interestingly I have
It is worth taking the time to make the dummy Pobjoy engine as it is such a prominent feature.
experimented and found that the model
flies better with a smaller tailplane. The
Pobjoy drawing is fair but you will find
better drawings on the internet. Like
Dennis, spare yourself the exhaust. Make
the cylinder fins by wrapping the barrels
with thin string and then smothering with
cyano. As with the wheels I turned all of
the engine components in the chuck of
my battery drill. I double sleeve these
with aluminium tube holding the wheel
to the axle with a further ring of tube.
This means that the wheel can be held
on its inner side with a drop of epoxy.
Faring the undercarriage legs with balsa
is easy, just groove the wood and attach
with more epoxy. Also reduce the nose
profile of the fuselage so that it’s about
crankcase diameter and leaves a free
airflow to the Pobjoy cylinders no need
to change the drawing just look at the
various images on the internet. Finally
o build a bit of ‘fle movement’ in to the undercarriage as it will save shocks to the fuselage. add a pilot: he’s a big feature in a tiny
aeroplane.
Nick Comper was the son of Sir Ninian
Comper the distinguished ecclesiastical
architect. He too was hugely talented but
given to alcohol and practical jokes. His
company went into receivership in 1935
and a few years later he was killed in a
street altercation after he had decided
to pose as a terrorist while holding a
lighted firework. A concerned passer-
by knocked him to the ground and he
died. A sad postscript was the use of the
Swift’s plan image on the dust jacket of
an edition of Rachel Carson’s pioneering
ecological work ‘Silent Spring’, the
innocent little Swift being depicted in the
unlikely role of an evil crop sprayer.
If you go on the internet you will find
various other small free-flight Swifts. I
suggest none are better than this except

Before flight trimming check the balance is on or slightly in front of the main wing spar and there are
no warps.

30 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


The outline of the Comper Swift is
undeservedly featured on the cover of the
early environmental catastrophe warning
book ‘Silent Spring’.

Charlie Newman’s 30” span 130g Comper


Swift won a Bronze Medal at the Model
Engineer Exhibition and was on the cover of
March 1992 AM.

Eddie J Riding’s
Comper Swift three- Richard Falconer really likes Comper Swifts!
view from August 1945 Having built several Rattle Comper Swifts he
gives information on is now building the simpler Ron Warring 18
scale sizes. inch design from April 1957 Model Aircraft.

for Andrew Moorhouse’s 13inch Peanut kits Westwings was obviously brilliant plan. These flew reasonably even if the
version – clumsy fingers meant mine but I’m lukewarm about the popular 2 ,000 rpm scream was a singularly
was never finished but Andrew himself eron o ering which was distinctly inappropriate sound accompaniment.
constructed a much larger version which non-scale. I also made several Cox Tee- These days we have electrics.
I recall flew beautifully. There were other Dee 010 powered versions as Dennis’s

AeroModeller 1027 - 31
FREE PLAN – COMPER SWIFT BY DENNIS RATTLE
PLAN 714 IN AEROMODELLER 1027 DECEMBER 2022
FREE PLAN

Original September 1963 Model Aircraft Article

Humbrol. Decorate as indicated on

FULL SIZE PLANS! drawing and I suggest the use of stencils


for registration markings.

COMPER SWIFT Colour Scheme


Fuselage, fin, and rudder scarlet, white
registration and trim lines. Name The
AN ATTRACTIVE SCALE RUBBER MODEL, WITH POWER CONVERSION DETAILS,
Scarlet Angel in white on nose. Wings
FOR THIS ATTRACTIVE PRE-WAR LIGHT PLANE. DESIGNED BY DENNIS RATTLE and tail-plane—white, scarlet registration

L
OOKING for a subject requiring R/C equipment now on the market. This and trim line (trim line on underside wing
the minimum possible building particular machine, The Scarlet Angel, only). Struts white with scarlet trim.
time, but with good flying (VT-ADO) featured in a book of the same
capabilities, I chose the Comper name and provided the decor of the Wheels and Engine
Swift as my entry for the model. The only deviations from true The aircraft owes much of its character to
Blackbourn Trophy, a club competition of scale are a slight increase in dihedral these two items and time spent thereon
the Glevum M.A.C., which is held in two angle and tailplane area. will be well rewarded in the finished
parts— Concours and Duration R.T.P. It model. The more experienced modeller
took first place in the event, but flying is Construction might wish to improve the performance
not restricted to R.T.P., it flies equally well This is straightforward, the basic by incorporating a gearbox in the dummy
FF and conversion to an engine powered fuselage sides being built one on top engine. For this purpose the gearboxes
version is included on the plan. of the other for "sameness." Cement supplied with the ready-to-fly Frog Mk.
The actual aircraft was a popular formers to one side, join second side, V or Buccaneer, being obtainable as a
sport 'plane in the 1930's and to the add decking, sand nose laminations and separate "spares" item, are ideal.
best of my knowledge one still exists. nose formers to shape in situ.
(Correct GA-BUS regularly appears at air The wing and tail are also quite Trimming
displays, etc., cockpit close-up is of this straightforward and constructed over Ballast with Plasticine inside the nose
machine and photo was taken in 1958— the plan in the usual way, but to ensure (most probable) or tail, to balance at
Editor.) Three di erent engines were used a good flying performance a warp-free indicated position and check glide. When
at various times, but I have chosen the structure is essential. satisfactory, apply some 200- 00 turns
Pobjoy version as possessing the most on the motor and trim out any power stall
character. Covering tendency with downthrust packing, or
At 1 in. to 1 ft. scale, the span is 24 Use lightweight tissue throughout, water undue turning characteristics with side
in., scaled up to twice this size, the shrink, apply two coats of thinned clear thrust. For the Tee Dee powered model,
model would be ideal for the smaller dope, colour with two coats of thinned obtain running shoes! ■

Dennis Rattle’s original The Scarlet Angel from September 1963 Model Aircraft. Cockpit close up of GA-BUS instrument panel in
1958. I’m sure a quick search online will produce
something clearer.

AeroModeller 1027 - 33
FREE PLAN – COMPER SWIFT BY DENNIS RATTLE
PLAN 714 IN AEROMODELLER 1027 DECEMBER 2022
FREE PLAN – COMPER SWIFT BY DENNIS RATTLE
PLAN 714 IN AEROMODELLER 1027 DECEMBER 2022
COVER TO COVER

BRILLIANT BOOK
BONANZA!
CHRIS OTTEWELL SURVEYS THE LATEST FULL-SIZE AVIATION PUBLICATIONS

Christmas is coming and choosing gifts can be tricky! However, anyone (or more) of these great books would make an
excellent gift for any aircraft or flying enthusiast.

Dilip Sakar is a well-respected Historian who


writes books rather than a journalist or general
writer who has turned his hand to writing about
air warfare. This means that he has done all
the research in an academically sound way,
going to primary sources wherever possible
and consulting those who were there if they are
still living. He is also an excellent writer who
presents the facts in a clear and concise but
compelling way. As a result, his books are both
readable and valuable as history text books.
The “Big Wing” controversy has raged for
years; even though most people concluded
many years ago that Dowding was right to
fight the Battle of Britain the way he did.
Nevertheless, he was removed from his
position and replaced by those very people
who might have cost us that battle and
hence the war. Dilip has carefully collected
all the facts and pieced together what really
happened, then worked out and explained
better than anyone else “why”.
I found the book fascinating and thoroughly
commend it to you all.
I am delighted to discover that a sequel,
“Bader’s Spitfire Wing, Tangmere 1941” is in
Bader’s Big Wing Controversy preparation and may well be published by the
Dilip Sarkar MBE, FRHistS time you read this. I look forward to reviewing
that in due course.
Published by Pen and Sword
ISBN 978 1 39901 715 2 Air ice arshal Trafford eigh allory worked
Price UK £25.00 USA $49.95 with ouglas Bader who was an Acting Squadron
eader to develop the Big ing concept.

Douglas Bader
Dilip Sarkar MBE, FRHistS/Published by Amberley Books/ISBN 978-1-4456-1276-8/Price UK £25 USA $39.95

Although this is not a newly published book it Dilip uses 50 pages to give us a much
is “THE” definitive biography of probably the more complete and certainly more balanced
most “Marmite” of the RAF heroes of WWII. picture of this man – courageous but a bully.
I’ve included it in the review article as reading A total snob who felt that ALL pilots should be
it in conjunction with Dilip’s new “Big Wing” officers and all officers should be ex-public-
book covered above makes both books even school boys. An excellent pilot but perhaps
more interesting and informative. less excellent than he thought he was At
Most of us probably first read of Bader and times apparently lacking in empathy and yet
his exploits in Paul Brickhill’s hagiography who worked tirelessly for the disabled in the
“Reach for the Sky” and the subsequent film later stages of his life.
of the same title. However, even those works Some of his comrades in arms hated
make it clear that for dramatic purposes, him and even refused to attend post-war
“things have been simplified”. And to be fair, events if they saw he was on the guest list;
apart from the other usual considerations many others hero worshipped him. This
Bader was far too complex a character to book explains and resolves some of these
understand from a slim paperback or a 90 dichotomies. Furthermore it’s a great read
minute film.

38 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


trove for the scale modeller looking for an much clearer – for example there’s a great one
authentic alternative to all those “Ferocious of the wing guns being loaded which clearly
Frankie” and “Big Beautiful Doll “ paint shows the hatches and doors involved.
schemes we see repeated on the scale flying This book also includes a quite a few
scene. orean war pictures which give yet another
A lot of the other pictures make the fine dimension to the range of illustrations and yet
details needed for a top class scale model more options for the keen scale model builder.

Images of War - P51 Mustang


Martin W Bowman
Published by Pen and Sword
ISBN 978 1 52674 639 9
Price UK £14.99 USA $26.95

This is quite a di erent book to the others


reviewed here. It contains a very brief history
of the P51 and its extended family but is
mostly an album of excellent black and white
photos of Mustangs of all types in service
Plenty of photographs of different marks of ustang with detail for adding realistic weathering of
around the world. It’s an absolute treasure service aircraft.

This is a fascinating book Even the foreword, often ignored by the reader, is interesting and
intriguing being written by one Brigadier General Elliot Roosevelt USAF (Ret). And yes, that IS
FDR’s son; a pilot and a keen proponent of the Mosquito especially in the reconnaissance role.
US pilots either loved or hated the Mossie. It appears that many, perhaps the majority, of US
pilots were unused to twin engined “tail draggers” and many others had difficulty coping with
the torque e ect of twin Merlins both rotating in the same direction. However, for some tasks the
aircraft was unbeatable so served in US reconnaissance squadrons in specialist roles, where for
the most part it was greatly loved.
Lots of great pictures in the book for model builders looking for an unusual colour scheme and
a good and informative read all round.
In addition this book raises a question. It refers to one US squadron exchanging its
Beaufighter night fighters for Mosquitos; I was previously unaware of the Beaufighter in US
service and would love to know more. Whilst there is a little more information on this in the book,
I wonder if Tony Fairburn would like to make this the main topic of his next book

The Mosquito in the USAAF


Tony Fairburn
Published by Pen and Sword
ISBN 978 1 39901 733 6
Price UK £25.00 USA $ 42.95
A H osquito model in USAAF markings would make an interesting change.

AeroModeller 1027 - 39
COVER TO COVER
Christopher Shores is a prolific writer on familiar aircraft in unfamiliar markings and
aviation history who with Giovanni Massimello colour schemes, and also unusual aircraft.
has assembled a small multi-national team For example, I was surprised to find a picture
to document the air war in the Mediterranean of two USAF YP80A Shooting Star jets being
from 1940 to 1945. This is a huge task and operated experimentally in Italy in April 1945.
this 500+ page book is the fifth in a planned They did not encounter let alone engage any
set of six volumes. enemy aircraft.
It is however very much a reference book, At the other extreme is a lovely air to
covering the claims of all participants for each air shot of a German He 46E parasol wing
day documented, along with the actual losses; monoplane apparently used in anti-partisan
the discrepancies are often just as great as operations in the Yugoslav mountains. That
you might imagine. Well written narrative for would make an excellent scale model subject.
each day is also included which brings the There are also more “action” photographs
events to life aided by the many illustrations. than seen in most air warfare books. For
Although in black and white, the illustrations example, there’s a great air to air photograph
will be of most interest to model builders as of a Heinkel 111H trying to avoid being shot
once again we find good photographs of both down by an RAF Beaufighter; he failed.

A History of the Mediterranean


Air War 1940 – 1945 (Vol 5)
Written by Christopher Shores and Giovanni
Massimello with Russel Guest, Frank Olynyk,
Winifred Bock and Andrew Thomas
Published by Grubb Street
ISBN 978-1-911621-97-3
Price UK £50.00 USA & Canada $75.95 Beaufighter X NT895 ‘H’, 252 squadron flown by Heinkel He 46E ‘R’ reconnaissance aircraft over
Plt Off Underwood on 21 September 1944. Croatia in July 1944 has the making of a stable FF
scale model.

Prototype Hawker P.1040 which would become the Sea Hawk.

aircraft design from the 1940’s onwards.


In addition to the copious illustrations (both photographs and drawings) the book included
a detailed table briefly describing each test flight made by the prototype aircraft up to and
including the Hunter. The “Remarks” against many of the flights make interesting reading and
show some of the dangers of test flying in that era – for example the P1040 fighter –
“04/04/1949 Eric Brown – Cat Launches. Rear fuselage ripped open by hold back extension
puller.”
Many of the projects of the 1950’s were sadly never built. Some because a competitor’s
proposal was preferred and others in the misguided “cull” of jet fighter projects led by Duncan
Sandys. All however are sufficiently covered to allow a pretty accurate model to be built.
Some other companies’ aircraft are also covered including one that I have never heard of –
The Gloster GA2 “Ace” which was built and flown with quite impressive results. A good subject
for a small rocket powered model I suspect.

Hawker’s Early Jets


Christopher Budgen
Published by Pen and Sword
ISBN 1526792176
Price UK £25.00 USA$49.95

This excellent and very readable book will be


a great resource for all those fans of Rapier
rocket motors, Jetex and TSP their modern
equivalents, not to mention those of you
building EDF and even turbine models. It is
a detailed and well written account of the
Hawker company’s evolving thinking on jet The Gloster GA.2 “Ace”.

40 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


This is an absolutely fascinating book. Although the author died in 1956, it has only now been
published. Frank Warren Merriam was a flying instructor from before the First World War who
taught many better-known pilots how to fly. He also knew virtually ALL the early pioneers. In his
later years he tried to collect stories from his former pupils, peers and those pioneers who had
survived until then.
The result is an ama ing book that every real aviation enthusiast should have in their library.
Imagine speaking to someone who when asked “Who taught you to fly” can answer “Wilbur” –
being one of the Wright brothers of course r alternatively “Bleriot” Reading this book is as
close as you can come to this today and for these things alone it is worth buying. Add to this the
ama ing period photographs; for example the author and Harold Barnwell (brother of the famous
Frank Barnwell, Chief Designer at Bristol’s) together with a bulldog in (or perhaps “on” ) a Bristol
Boxkite, this apparently being the first bulldog to fly This was taken on or about Sept 25th 1912
and published in The Sunday Pictorial newspaper.
Anyone interested in the early days of aviation simply must buy this book.

Echo’s From Dawn Skies


Frederick Warren Merriam AFC FRAeS
Published by Pen and Sword
ISBN 1526726203
UK £20 USA $34.95 Book author Captain Frederick Warren Merriam Alec Ogilvie (left) at Eastchurch in 1911 preparing
at the controls of a Bristol Boxkite in 1911. for the Gordon Bennet Race watched by Wilbur
Wright.

Qantas and the Empire


Flying Boat
David Crotty
Published by Key Books
ISBN 978-1-913870-37-9
Price UK £17-99

Here’s a final treat for you. A well-illustrated Carpentaria ready to be towed up the slipway at Rose Bay.
account of the Shorts C Class or Empire flying
boats in antas service. Each of their do en
boats, their individual history and eventual
fate is covered in some detail along with many
excellent period photographs and posters.
I have long been fascinated by these aircraft
and must confess to a personal connection
as Dad flew on their successors, operating
out of Rose Bay in the late 1940s and always
remarks on the superb engineering operation
they had there. As well as the flying boats
themselves, this book illustrates some of the
difficulties associated with their operation as
well as some of the outstanding flights carried
out by their crews. These were perhaps the
outstanding British airliners of the pre-war
period and deserve more attention than they
usually get.

Coolangatta comes in to land.

AeroModeller 1027 - 41
CL NATIONALS

TEAM RACE 2022 SIMON MOLYNEUX REPORTS FROM THE RESCHEDULED


NATS RACING ON THE 23-25 AUGUST.

the superb campsite and shower block

D
ue to the unavailability on venue selection this year, some members
Barkston Heath this year, and, most importantly to the Team Race may have taken exception. This would
the race was on to find an competitors, very efficient organisation. be a very sad indictment of the current
alternative venue to host the Whilst Combat and Stunt enjoyed state of Team Race in the U , this writer
2022 Control Line Nats. As buoyant entry levels, Team Race su ered certainly hopes it was not the case.
luck would have it our ational Flying from a lower than usual entry due to An extra bonus for attendees was
Centre was booked for a cancelled World several no-shows. The mid-week time- the BMFA Centenary Exhibition, with a
Cup event, albeit midweek, just before slot proved none too popular with some. stunning display of our aeromodelling
the traditional August Bank Holiday Some people conveniently overlooked heritage with models from British, World
slot. The bonus for the competitors was the fact that for many years, those of us and European Champions. A particular
that Stunt, Combat and Team Race that work non-regular hours have had highlight for me was to see 1984 F2C
could all compete at the same venue. to take leave each and every year to World Champions Steve Smith and Colin
Everyone that attended was rewarded support the BMFA in competing at the Browns iconic F2C model. We were also
with a superb multi-disciplined venue, ats. Unfortunately, it is possible that as privileged to have Steve and Colin in
a truly world-class Team Race circle, the Barton Club were overlooked in the attendance; Steve was competing very

Sion Burns releases his British Goodyear racer. He travelled from


Menorca to take part in the Team Race Nationals.

42 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


The BMFA Centenary Exhibition was the perfect backdrop to the CL 1984 F2C Team Race World Champions Colin Brown and Steve Smith were
Nationals and prizegiving. (Photo by Andrew Boddington) present and involved in the Nats. (Photo by Andrew Boddington)

e ectively in intage Combat and F2B, attending the French and Dutch GP’s.
with Colin doing sterling work in the Would their recent experience show in
Team Race judges tower. their performances this time out
With the superb facilities on site, Due to having just one hard circle
the BMFA Centenary display in the available, CD Chris Barker drew up a
Goldsmith Hangar, and the multiple schedule of flying one round in each
control line events to be flown there was class alternating between vintage and
a really nice, relaxed atmosphere building modern classes. This meant a rapid
on the Monday afternoon. Even the turnaround of equipment and certainly
weather forecast was good . kept us on our toes
f those that did turn up, Sion Burns
travelled all the way from Menorca with Heats
a selection of very competitive racing We were blessed with a nice bright
models and once again deserves the start to the first day, lovely conditions
gong for biggest e ort made’. Sion for model aircraft racing, day two again
is a formidable competitor and builds dawned bright but a little bree y. A little
John Broadhead had returned from racing on beautiful and very quick racing models. trickier but eminently raceable. Finals
the continent to take part. His well-used Classic 15 model powered day was a whole other matter though
by a Rothwell R250 seems to win every
time out, with just about anyone holding Vintage A
the handle. Could he take the trophy With minimal entries we were set for
once again some chilled racing. intage event
F2C teams Barker/Tricker and Waters/ CD John Mealing added to this with
Broadhead were fresh back from his charming manner ensuring racing
International duties in France after was carried out efficiently and in

Sion Burns with one of the many Argander


like British Goodyear racers.

With only one hard circle in operation there was an appreciative audience to watch Toogood, Hill and
Cannon compete.
The Toogood/Lewis/Toogood pit crew prepare
their Barton B model.

AeroModeller 1027 - 43
CL NATIONALS

alcolm Ross pitting Alan Hill’s nicely finished model. Happy band of Barton B finalists.

excellent humour. First up was Vintage with their excellent minimalist and very standards to which we all ascribe. Alan
A. Toogood/Lewis had good airspeed skinny carbon fuselage model. has a mass of competitive experience in
and stops to record a 3:39.0, Cannon/ Molyneux/Thorpe led the way after a all classes and his models demonstrate a
Pinkerton had a time of 4:51.9. With just smooth run to a 4 48 in the first three very detailed approach. They are usually
two entries present Vintage A was over up heat, Barker/Tricker weren’t running very fast and very reliable. His pit crew
very quickly at all consistently with a 6:36 and the Ross/Robinson were doing a good job
vastly experienced team of Fitzgerald/ but due to a timing error no time was
British Goodyear Greenwood were having a few teething recorded. Cannon/Pinkerton were not
After many years of being dominated by issues including a fuel line falling o and too far o with a 54.84. This was a
Ol’ Blue models it appears that this year a missed catch finishing at 56 laps. very pleasant race to observe, the big
the pretty Argander was the model of The second heat was a 2 up with glow powered models growling round
choice in British Goodyear. Sion Burns Waters/Burns recording 4:53 with a harsh impressively, we were all looking forward
had a very nicely finished brand new sounding model, possibly a vibration to the Final.
model to ‘shake down’ on the Monday issue, and Cannon/Pinkerton with a 5:52 The favourites in the Final had to be
with PAW power. The motor had some On day two Molyneux/Thorpe
engraving on the crankcase implying that improved by a tiny 0.7 secs, Waters/
it may well be a Macclesfield Special’. Burns did a 4:50.3 and Fitzgerald/
Also in the Argander club were Greenwood got their ducks in a row to
Molyneux/Thorpe with a Technohobby record 5:01.6, these three teams making
K12 powered fully-painted rarity, it through to Thursday s final.
aspiring to actually look like a full size
racing plane, and Fitzgerald/Greenwood Barton B
brought along an as yet unflown model An excellent heat was flown for the first
built by the late Team Race stalwart round of Barton B. Toogood/Lewis/
Jim Holland. Cannon/Pinkerton flew an Toogood recorded a very respectable
Argander-a-like, built from an unknown 40. 5 for the 80 laps. Alan Hill flew
plan. Also in the club were Barker/Tricker his beautifully prepared model, made to
Sion Burns readies his Rothwell R250
powered Classic 15 for Charlie aters to fly.

Not everything went smoothly for team


aters Newbold in intage 1 2A.
Neil Tricker releasing a F2CN model for Chris Barker.

44 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


Hill/Ross, with Alan Hill dominating Toogood/Lewis/Toogood romped home
the class in terms of airspeed for in 7:33.0 with Cannon/Pinkerton/Leeman
many years. This has been to the trailing in 9:55.7.
consternation of other competitors, Pat eeman produces some finely crafted
ini Goodyear models. Powered by 1.5cc
but inspection of Alan's beautifully F2CN plain bearing engines the class is flown over
prepared models and his enormous The profile version of F2C, ’ was fairly grass and is a great introduction to Team
Racing.
experience leaves little doubt that sheer well subscribed with 5 entries. In round
hard work and understanding have one Fit gerald/Greenwood su ered a
led to superb performance. Also in DQ, Cannon/Pinkerton did 4:51 with an
the mix were Toogood/Lewis, showing inconsistent run, Barker/Tricker su ered
ballpark airspeed, could they emulate a loose spray bar and a horrible engine
the reliability and stops? Cannon / run enabling only a 5 minute heat time.
Pinkerton were down on airspeed but up Molyneux/Thorpe were looking good for
on enthusiasm, and once racing starts a really quick time, and gliding in for their
anything can happen... The models second and final pitstop, the model 0.5m
got away well and coming into the first o the ground they somehow went under
stop Hill seemed to get the timing of his the lines of Waters/Waters who were
landing out of sync and left Malcolm supposed to be pitting! Such a shame as
Ross little chance of making a catch estimations put the time around an easy
Pat eeman warming the engine on his ini
leaving just two horses in the race. 3:50, this was to prove very costly later. Goodyear model prior to the final.
And then the unthinkable occurred, the Waters was D ’d, and a refly awarded. A
model of Toogood/Lewis retired leaving reluctant engine resulted in a dodgy too-
Cannon/Pinkerton a free solo run to the cool engine run and a pedestrian 4:05.3 Day two saw a three-up race with
end, to great cheer from onlookers. A for Molyneux/Thorpe. Bizarrely Sion Cannon/Pinkerton having good starts
thoroughly well-deserved win for these Burns su ered a similarly poor run in his and reasonable airspeed with very low
two stalwarts of control line racing. heat to record exactly the same 4:05.3 range. This resulted in a 6:21.4, their
time with his Trigger’s Broom’ model. first time on the board with the ex-
F2C This truly excellent model flies beautifully Ed eedham 12 powered model. I
The Blue Riband event F2C attracted and is very quick, despite having been estimated six stops, but actually lost
four entries. The models are the lightest, crashed many times. Some say it’s on count! Waters/Burns dropped to a 4:51
fastest accelerating, and most economic its second new fuselage and third new and Toogood/Lewis having a D F with
of all the racing classes. wing, but when it was going it was pretty an unreliable shut o .
It looked to be a close-run a air much the fastest model there. The wing
with all teams running a similar pace in is a patchwork balsa-quilt, obviously very Open Goodyear
practice. Fit gerald/Greenwood su ered e ectively repaired as the model has lost A 2.5cc glow, running at peak revs
a DQ, landing their model outside the none of its speed. with an open exhaust usually grabs the
pitting line. This was due to the pilots’ On day two Fitzgerald/Greenwood attention. Sadly the only heat produced
circle being denoted by white paint on jumped to the top of the timesheets just one competitive time for Fitzgerald/
bleached concrete, proving just about with a very respectable 3:54.2. This was Greenwood/Thorpe of 4:24.8.
invisible in peripheral vision. This was of great credit to Mark Greenwood in
repainted overnight to better e ect. particular who was battling a series of Vintage 1/2A
Waters/Broadhead were at the top of the health issues throughout the competition. With just two entries Toogood/Lewis
timesheets with a 3:28.00 for the 100 lap Waters/Waters were a little o the pace looked to be going quite nicely with their
heat, Molyneux/Thorpe second fastest in with 4:16, no one else threatened to delightful model recording 4:10.8. It was
3:29.3 and Barker/Tricker third with 3:34. change the qualification order. decided to run the final on the second
Day 2 saw some very blustery weather day with Toogood/Lewis coming through
early that was a factor for the F2C Classic 15 to win in 9 0.0 with Waters/ ewbold
fliers. Biggest improvement was Barker/ This class is flown to a very British’ runners up in 11:30.2 with a variety of
Tricker jumping up to second qualifiers specification favouring liver style model handling issues.
by 0.2 secs with a 3.29.1. Fitzgerald/ engines. Sadly, as usual, UK rules are at
Greenwood put in their only time of odds with what happens Internationally Mini Goodyear
3:50.0, cementing 4th place. Molyneux/ so we operate very much in our own This traditional beginner’s event is run
Thorpe flu ed a take-o which saw the bubble. The virtually unobtainable over grass and attracted three entries.
model run in, and Waters/Broadhead Rothwell R250 used by Sion Burns Pat Leeman had a couple of very nicely
also failed to improve. continued to run well in his beautiful own presented own design models on show.
design model, with a first heat time of Pat is obviously extremely fond of this
Vintage B 4:36.9. Toogood/Lewis were next up in delightful class and has produced some
Due to their being just two viable entries 5:10.6 with Cannon/Pinkerton unable to very attractive models with which to
it was decided to run a straight final. record a time. compete.

AeroModeller 1027 - 45
CL NATIONALS

Combat or Team Race The first attempt at the ini Goodyear final was The eventual two up final which was won by Cannon Pinkerton.
chaotic...

It was decided to run a final on a Thursday. Disappointingly it dawned qualifiers Molyneux/Thorpe took their
Wednesday afternoon with the three grey and dri ly. The forecast was for rain 12 Argander into the circle where it
entries, after a bit of practice. What clearing but in reality the weather was steadfastly refused to run cleanly. After 5
followed was highly entertaining if a set for the day with just a couple of small minutes of messing around they had no
little unconventional. Chaos would also gaps to enable some F2C practice and setting and not much chance. Waters/
describe the first running, with some the British Goodyear Final to be run. Burns and Fit gerald/Greenwood did
spirited flying contravening just about (Postscript - The poor weather initially seem much happier with their models.
every rule in the book. This led to some caused the postponement of the F2C n ,2,1 Go ’ all models got away
fearing for the vocal cords of CD Pete Final, with the expectation that it would well, it was immediately apparent
Jephcott when issuing many warnings, be held later in the season. This was later Molyneux/Thorpe were in trouble with
none of which were heeded Eventually changed so that the F2C results were what seemed to be dirt in the fuel
common sense prevailed and the team based on the heat times. So, 1st Waters/ line. Waters/Burns were going well
of Waterland /Lever D ’d. This left a Broadhead, 2nd Barker/Tricker, rd but not quite on song with Fit gerald/
two up final to be flown, which Cannon/ Molyneux/Thorpe.) Greenwood having similar airspeed.
Pinkerton won in 10 11. , and Barker/ Then, inexplicably, the 12 Argander
Leeman completed 122 racing laps. British Goodyear Final model coughed and bingo - fuel line
An individual warm up period of 5 cleared. The race was on The 12 had
Finals Day minutes is allowed for each team superior airspeed and great stops with
Unusually for the ats Finals Day was on to find their race setting. Fastest around 180 laps to go there was plenty

Nigel Thorpe and Simon olyneu wait for F2C practice time. Unfortunately Off she goes, but no F2C final race today. Nigel Thorpe is more usually seen
the weather got worse and postponed the conclusion. at intage Combat events with the Feltham team.

46 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


British Goodyear finalists. From left, anny illiamson anager of the B FA National Centre who presented the awards, ark Greenwood, ike Fit gerald,
Nigel Thorpe, Simon olyneu , Charlie aters, and Sion Burns.

of time to catch up. The race was the


usual lively a air with a few interesting
‘moments’. At one stage Mike Fitzgerald
was cutting o as Waters overflew rather
high leaving Molyneux performing a near
wing over to avoid catastrophe. Very
sadly Mark Greenwood s model su ered
a significant break in the fuselage after a
fast landing. They kept going, but looking
at it after it was a wonder it hadn’t
failed completely. Molyneux/Thorpe
were su ering with sti ening controls,
resulting is some interesting laps towards
the end of the final.
But the orange Argander of Molyneux/
Thorpe had now got ahead, the yellow
The F2CN finalists of olyneu Thorpe, winners Fit gerald Greenwood, and aters Burns.
model of Waters/Burns had a rough
sounding PAW tailing o slightly and
Fit gerald /Greenwood inevitably running
slowly with their airframe issue. ■

RESULTS:

2022 NATIONAL TEAM RACE CHAMPIONS


F2CN - Fitzgerald / Greenwood
British Goodyear - Molyneux / Thorpe
Open Goodyear - Fitzgerald / Greenwood
Mini Goodyear - Cannon / Pinkerton
Vintage A - Toogood / Lewis
Vintage B - Toogood / Lewis / Toogood
Vintage 1/2A - Toogood / Lewis
Classic 15 - Waters / Burns
Barton B - Cannon / Pinkerton / Leeman

The Classic 15 was decided by the Round times, with Cannon Pinkerton third, aters Burns the F2C - Waters/Broadhead (Decided on heat time)
winners, and Toogood ewis second.

AeroModeller 1024 - 47
CL NATIONALS

BRITISH NATIONALS VINTAGE


COMBAT COMPETITION DENIS MURPHY REPORTS FROM BMFA BUCKMINSTER ON THE NATS COMPETITION
HELD ON 24TH AND 25TH AUGUST

V
intage Combat started event the previous day (see last month’s remaining rounds. F2E and ½ A would be
at around 10.30am on issue), warm but with slightly more wind. flown in the second circle after intage
Wednesday. Engines were With an entry of 33 competitors, the had completed on Thursday.
allowed to be started at Combat circles were again placed on the
10.00am giving 30 mins to main runway with two dedicated circles. First Round
obtain a good engine setting prior to the The idea being that the first round and The first round always springs some
competition starting. Conditions were losers’ rounds would be flown in two surprises whereby some of the more
pretty much the same as for the Oliver circles, with one circle being used for the established names come a cropper.

Lionel Smith launches for


Steve Smith while Roger Fisher
releases the streamer during
the British Nationals Vintage
Combat held at Buckminster on
Wednesday 24th and Thursday
25th August 2022.

48 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


Richard Evans and Tony Frost were the pit
crew for ave ood flying against an ever
improving artin Johnson in green shirt.
espite ma or outboard damage this armonger X 68 kept flying.

Notable this time was Chris Fisher, who with Simon Molyneux, v Willie Wallace.
won Oliver Combat the previous day, ick Stowe was given a bye due to the
being beaten by Martin Kiszel who has odd number of competitors.
been flying his “goofy” left-handed style
particularly well since his return to the Losers’ Round
combat scene this season. Sometimes called the “Last Chance
Possibly THE bout of the First Round Saloon”, the Losers’ Round enables
was between Richard (Legend) Evans those knocked out in Round ne to fly
and Gordon (Mine’s a Scotch) Price. o in order to get to the next round. It
Four minutes of close-following combat also ensures that all competitors get to
ensued and ended in a draw. Both fly a minimum of two bouts each. First
pilots on their knees with the e ort and up in Circle ne was Richard (The Shoe)
applause from the watching crowd. The Stitson v Peter (Pylon) Harvey, Richard
re-fly was also a nip and tuck a air, winning through. Chris Fisher redeemed
this time Richard just getting the upper himself v Tim Hobbins, Moggs Morris
hand. Some of the main contenders won won against an improving Chris Davy
through as expected, Richard Herbert v and Roger Fisher, runner up in liver
Peter Harvey, Tony Frost v Alan Bunker, Combat the previous day, won against
Dave Riley v Denis Murphy, and igel Richard Berry.
Thorpe, fresh from his team race exploits In Circle Two, ick Stowe beat Willie

Tony Frost and ick ewis launch a model


for Richard Evans during what was possibly
the closest First Round bout when he flew
against Gordon Price foreground .

Previous day’s Oliver Combat winner Chris Fisher was in the osers’ Round against Tim Hobbins right
Roger Fisher had a First Round win against and managed a win.
Johnathon Crabtree left .

AeroModeller 1027 - 49
CL NATIONALS

Johnathon Crabtree launches during the intage bout involving F2 flyers ave Riley left v ave iseman.

Wallace, Dave Wiseman beat Dave bout was hard fought as per their Oliver himself between being a mechanic in
Wood, Alan Bunker beat Dave Chalk, and bout the previous day. At the end of the the Team Racing and being a pilot in the
Gordon Price beat Denis Nosher Murphy. bout Lionel was declared the winner, Vintage Combat. For whatever reason,
Chris complained that some dark arts Nigel stepped out of the circle and was
Eliminator Round had happened during the bout although disqualified. Frank Marshall v Tony Frost
Due to the number of entries it was the Centre Marshall hadn’t signalled was a bit untidy, Tony managing to take
necessary to have an Eliminator round. anything untoward. After some heated the winning cut late on. Dave (The Grey
Martin Kiszel v Richard Herbert discussions, a re-fly was ordered, and Fox) Harrison v Richard Evans was won
resulted in a win for Richard. The bout yes you guessed it, Chris won! by Richard. Dave’s pit crew took a long
between Chris Fisher and Lionel Smith Simon Miller v Nigel Thorpe was an time to start his engine and when finally
was not without some controversy. The interesting bout. Nigel was spreading started and launched had a bad setting.
Dave Riley v Dave Wiseman, both
seasoned F2D flyers, was a terrific bout
to watch, Dave Riley winning through.

Chris avy and Alan Bunker launch their respective models for the Eliminator of Johnathon Crabtree Richard Evans launches for Tony Frost left
right v Gordon Price. who won his bout against Frank arshall.

50 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


First Semi Final saw Steve Smith (left) losing
against Dave Riley on ground time after two
cuts each.

The final two Eliminator bouts were


Johnathon Crabtree v Gordon Price.
Johnathon, double ationals winner last
year in both liver and intage, had no
such luck against Gordon and exited
the competition. Eamonn Fosdike v Alan
Bunker resulted in a win for Alan.

Second Round
The second round took place on
Thursday. The start was delayed
somewhat by heavy rain showers and
a fierce wind. Due to the delay, the F2E
and A were looking very unlikely to
happen as a large number of competitors
in those classes were still in the intage
competition. John Leggott vs Martin
Johnson were up first. Martin seemed to
improve as the competition went on and avid Riley and Gordon Price pitted for artin Johnson in the second Semi Final when he flew against
was a deserved winner. How far could Simon Miller (left).
he go
Simon Miller v Sam Hobbins was the whole circle and flying inverted. Try Semi Finals
an interesting contrast in styles. The as he may, Tony was unable to get a cut The first Semi Final was between Steve
younger Sam moved around the circle, and Dave was declared the winner after Smith and Dave Riley. With so much at
often flying low inverted, Simon flying a a full 4mins of combat with no ground stake, it was a frantic bout with lots of
more traditional style flying downwind. time Ian Perkins v Chris Fisher brought tight following by both pilots. Dave was
n this occasion the young pretender the second round to a climax, Ian’s in the lead by 2 cuts to one before there
was outdone and Simon progressed. model was hit in a mid-air and could not was a line tangle, Steve took a cut in the
Richard (HRH) Herbert v Richard (The continue. A win for Chris. tangle and then crashed. With the score
Shoe) Stitson was a fairly routine a air, 2-2 on cuts, Dave won on ground time.
Richard winning through. Moggs Morris v Quarter Finals The second Semi Final between
Gordon Price (F2D 2022 at’s Champion) Martin Johnson v Chris Fisher started Martin Johnson and Simon Miller looked
produced possibly the shock result of the the uarter Finals, resulting in a win pretty even for a couple of minutes.
round with Moggs getting the better of for Martin who continued to impress. Unfortunately Simon, whilst flying directly
Gordon. Was it the it ats Possibly the most eagerly awaited bout overhead, lost his balance and stepped
Alan Bunker v Richard Evans promised was that of Dave Riley v Richard Herbert. out of the circle and was automatically
to be a great bout. Richard took two cuts After a line tangle, Richard took the D ’d. Unlucky Simon, but fair play to
to Alan’s one. Then with only 10 seconds whole of Dave’s streamer before crashing Martin.
of the bout remaining, disaster struck vertically and broke his prop. Dave
for Richard as he was judged to have managed to stay airborne while Richard’s hird l ce l
stepped outside the circle, resulting in pit crew changed his prop and got him Fly o for third and fourth place saw
an immediate D . Lively conversations back up in less than a minute. Dave Simon (The Whippet) Miller v Steve
ensued ick Stowe who had showed then managed to get the cut he needed (Steady) Smith. Simon looked down on
some good form, then went out against for the win. This just proves that HRH airspeed compared to Steve, probably
the ever-consistent Steve Smith. is human after all Alan Bunker v Simon due to a wet soggy model. After a couple
Tony Frost v Dave Riley was an Miller ended rather disappointingly. of minutes into the bout with the scores
excellent bout. Dave was 2-1 up with Alan’s model was launched at the start level, there was a mid-air. Steve got
about 1m of streamer left. Tony had and went into an inverted manoeuvre back up, but on landing had no streamer
no streamer left so was desperately before levelling out straight and level. attached and was D ’d Third place to
attacking Dave for all he was worth. The result an instant D for Alan and a Simon, with Steve picking up Fourth.
Dave defended magnificently by using win for Simon.

AeroModeller 1027 - 51
Gordon Price launches
the model of Dave
Riley (blue) during his
Vintage Combat Final
CL NATIONALS win against Martin
Johnson.

The Final Buckminster for hosting the event. If lack of awareness where pilots are in
So to the Final of Dave Riley v Martin we are unable to get a FULL Nationals the circle, and possibly the speed of
Johnson. Dave’s model appeared to be at Barkston Heath or elsewhere in the the models. All pilots are getting older
quite a bit quicker and tighter turning future, Buckminster is the perfect venue after all. The slower Oliver class did not
than Martin’s giving him an instant for CL only events. It was unfortunate seem to be a ected in the same way.
advantage. Dave followed Martin for that due to the weather conditions on The rule is quite specific, if you step out
a minute or so, taking two cuts and the Thursday intage finished late, and with two feet you are D ’d. Perhaps the
then defended extremely well for the therefore F2E and 1/2A events were way forward is for Centre Marshalls to
remainder of the bout. The bout ended unable to be run. be more vocal, and possibly physical
2-0 to Dave giving him his first intage in order to prevent these D ’s from
Combat competition win in 30 years of is lific tion les happening? No pilot wants to travel
trying! Well done both. In the intage competition, there were hundreds of miles at great expense just
Thanks must go to the members of several disqualifications (D ) over the to get D ’d. This particular issue was
the CFA Committee (Combat Flyers two days, mainly for pilots stepping brought up at the CFA AGM and caused
Association www.combatflyers.co.uk) out of the circle with two feet. Why a lot of debate. I’m sure we have not
for their hard work in organising and people are doing it is anyone’s guess. heard the last of it! ■
running the events, together with BMFA Dizziness could be a factor along with

Winner of the Final, Dave Riley (right) with pit crew Gordon Price and Alan Bron e fly off Simon iller right took third place and Steve Smith fourth
Bunker and runner up Martin Johnson with pit crew Jonathon Crabtree and place with their respective pit crews.
Lionel Smith.

52 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


CL NATIONALS

BRITISH NATIONALS
so Alan was very close.
After three rounds three pilots
remained: Harry Walker (2019 champ),
Dave Riley (2021 reigning champ) both
on 1 life and Gordon still with 2 lifes left.

F2D COMBAT
In round 4 Harry was unlucky to have
a single model F2D ‘Helicopter’ after a
collision, where the model does a flat
spin, while leading 1-0. Harry’s model
did not cut its own streamer so the pit
crew had an huge mess to untangle
GORDON PRICE REPORTS FROM BMFA BUCKMINSTER ON THE resulting in more than a cut’s worth of
NATS FAI COMBAT COMPETITION. PHOTOS BY DENIS MURPHY ground time and a loss for Harry. In
round 5 Gordon took three cuts of Dave

T
he 2022 F2D National Johnson started the action at 12 noon. and then kept trying to dump his full
Championships was held With 6 entries the F2D two lives system, streamer on Dave’s model. Eventually he
on Tuesday 23rd August where you have to lose twice to be out of succeeded and removed Dave’s wingtip
as part of the Control Line the competition, suggested 11 bouts to in the process which then got tangled in
Nationals held at the BMFA leave one winner with one life left. the string and around Dave’s elevator,
Buckminster NFC. With only 6 entries, In the first few rounds notable were which was not clear from the middle until
and run alongside the Oliver Combat to Alan Bunker losing by 9 seconds to it finally fell o .
avoid pilots needing to fly in both comps, Gordon Price (2 cuts all) and by 6 So Gordon Price finally won the F2D
a short competition was expected. seconds to Dave Riley (1 – 0 to Alan in Nationals after 14 odd previous attempts,
Centre Marshal Vernon Hunt assisted by cuts). For reference any score closer than with 2 lives intact and having beaten
scorers Lex Scurfield, Ben and Martin 5 seconds or 10 points in F2D is a re-fly each of the other 5 opponents.■

Centre Marshall Vernon Hunt signals to scorers that the bout between Dave Riley and eventual F2D
Nationals Combat winner Gordon Price (red shirt) has ended.

Dave Wiseman and Harry Walker prepare a


model for launching.

Harry Walker (black shirt) in a bout with


Gordon Price during the British Nationals
F2D Combat.

Winner of F2D Combat Gordon Price AeroModeller 1027 - 53


(centre), Dave Riley second (left) and
Harry Walker third.
LIMITED TIME
AEROMODELLER
SUBSCRIPTION OFFER!
SUBSCRIBE TODAY AND RECEIVE A VERY SPECIAL GIFT
WORTH OVER £35 INCLUDING POSTAGE
F
We have teamed up with our friends at Deluxe Materials to offer you a very special gift.
For subscribing with us for 2 years, you will receive a bottle of Roket Hot, Roket Max,
!
Roket Odourless, SuperPhatic and Roket Glue Tips.

This offer is available to both NEW and EXISTING subscribers. If you are an existing
subscriber, we will simply extend your current subscription for a further 2 years, so do
not wait until your subscription runs out, RENEW TODAY while stocks last!

* Terms and conditions


You must be aged 18 and over to be eligible for the Deluxe offer. While stocks last.
Customers attempting to take out this offer after all stock is gone will be contacted before any money is taken.
Subscriptions taken out with this offer will not be refunded if cancelled.
F R E E
I F
G £ 33!T WO R T H O V E R
*

ONLINE AT WWW.DOOLITTLEMEDIA.COM OR CALL 01525 222573


24 ISSUE AEROMODELLER 2 year subscription:- UK; £150, Europe; £200, Worldwide; £230

SUBSCRIPTION Renewal/Extension New Subscription Starting with issue No..........................

First name ........................................................................................................................................... Please debit my credit/debit card for £................................. Please be aware that all
credit/debit cards are
processed through PayPal
Surname............................................................................................................................................... Visa Mastercard Maestro Cheque and this may appear on your
bank statement
Payable to
Address................................................................................................................................................. Card number:,0 Doolittle Media Ltd.

.................................................................................................................................................................... ■■
Maestro only
....................................................................................................................................................................
Expiry date.................... Valid from.................... CCV Code.................... Issue No...........
.................................................................................................................................................................... 3 digits on the signature strip If applicable

Country...............................................................Post/zip code ..................................................


Telephone Number........................................................................................................................ Signature .................................................................................Date............................................

Email ....................................................................................................................................................... Please call our subscription line or mail this form, or a copy, to;
Doolittle Media, The Granary, Doolittle Lane, Totternhoe, Beds, LU6 1QX
Please tick to confirm that you are aged 18 or over Tel; +44(0)1525 222573 Online; www.doolittlemedia.com
(Photocopies of this form are acceptable)

IF THIS OFFER ISN’T FOR YOU REGULAR 1 YEAR SUBSCRIPTIONS ARE STILL AVAILABLE - ONLINE AT WWW.DOOLITTLEMEDIA.COM OR CALL 01525 222573
EVENT REPORT

OLD WARDEN SCALE WEEKEND


ANDY BROUGH AND ANDREW BODDINGTON REPORT ON THE LAST MODELAIR EVENT OF THE
SEASON THAT SAW THE REINS HANDED OVER BY KEN AND SHEILA SHEPPARD TO A NEW TEAM

W
ith somewhat Many will have attended the could meet your heroes!
blustery conditions model flying meetings at ld Warden For the last 23 years it has been the
at the Shuttleworth Aerodrome over the years; often they ModelAir Team firstly Mike and Joan
Collection site on the have become the highlight of the year’s Reynolds assisted by Ken and Shelia
weekend of 17-18th events calendar. No other venue can Sheppard and then in more recent
September - wind speeds often well provide the ambience of the airfield, with years it has been their responsibility to
over 10 mph - I think some of the FF its unrivalled collection of historic planes, stage these events. To those attending
scale flyers were put o from attending the parkland setting and the occasional it all seems to just to flow along with
on what was a new date for the Scale comings and goings of the museum ease which shows just how e ective
Weekend. There was however plenty of planes. The ability to fly models by free their leadership is. To organise and run
sports FF flying taking place, and on the flight, or with radio assist, control line these meetings there has to be a strong
Sunday competitions run by SAM 35 for or full house radio control also makes team especially in the modern era of
Precision Rubber Powered models (AKA the venue di erent. That this happens tick boxes, overreaching legislation
the Rubber Bowden) and small single every year is down to the hard work of and demands of insurance companies.
channel models. This Old Warden was a dedicated group of modellers. Several However, it takes clear focus, enthusiasm
particularly significant as it marked the groups have run these meetings over the and leadership to pull it all together. en
retirement of Ken and Sheila Sheppard decades, who can forget Ron Moulton and Shelia have done that magnificently.
from ModelAir and their organisation of with his laid-back style and ability to The Scale Weekend just gone was the
the Model Events at this venue. attract famous aeromodellers so you last to be organised by the duo. Both

ark Pedwell flew by single


channel Noel Shennan’s Cricket
from ay 1964 odel Aircraft.

56 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


Do not fear, model aircraft events are
continuing at Old Warden with two dates for
2023 organised by James Gordon and Emma
Chase. www.modelair.info

Chris Chapman had an interesting array of


FF EDF (Electric Ducted Fan) jets powered by
LiPo battery or SuperCapacitors to his own
design in moulded foam, inspired by the Jetex
Tailored series of kits of the 1950’s which had After 23 years involvement with ModelAir and the running of aeromodelling events at Old Warden,
moulded balsa fuselages. The orange model Sheila and Ken Sheppard are retiring. Ian Lever of SAM 35 presents them with tokens of appreciation
is the Avro 707, forerunner of the Vulcan. for all their hard work. Your editor would also like to publicly thank Ken and Sheila for all
they have done to make Old Warden such a special place for
aeromodellers. (Photo by Penny Housden)

Brothers Mark and Lance Pedwell


were continuing their family’s
aeromodelling tradition. Mark has
a Frog 45 (he had been looking for
one for years as their father flew
one) that he found as a wreck at
a swap meet for a £5; he stripped
the tissue, remade the joints, and
recovered. As he couldn’t find any
black tissue for the fuselage, he
ended up using tissue from around
oranges bought in Aldi! Lance has
his original Vespa from 1972 with the
addition of some 1/16” square balsa
on the wing underside to straighten
out warps.

Chris uses vacuum forming techniques to


produce the airframe shells with what was
called Graupner Vector Board and is now
produced by Pichler as Super Board (Steve
Webb Models can supply). Method is to carve
a solid half side mould of the fuselage less
the thickness of the board used. The foam
board is reasonably stretchy so the vacuum
and a bit of prodding will mould it cold around
the form. He then uses a heat gun over the
surface to relax the foam and then this sets
into shape when cold. Model shown is the
Paul also had with him his scale XP 6 ‘ oonbat’ first seen a couple of years ago in A as work in
Hawker Hunter inspired by the Jetex kit, with
progress and now nearly finished but unflown. The model was designed by ick Howard and published
the under trough now serving as an air duct
in May 1988 AM.
to the EDF unit which is from Drone spares.

AeroModeller 1027 - 57
EVENT REPORT

The gentlemen flyers of SA 5 prepare their single channel models for a precision competition.

Paul Briggs enjoyed his weekend at Old


Warden despite the weather. On one of the
many trade and enthusiast stands he found
the parts for this ‘jet’ engine which anyone
reading US model aircraft magazines of
the 1950’s will recognise from the MEW
(Minnesota Engine Works) adverts. This new
MEW 601 engine was supposedly easy to
run and worked by vapourising ethanol or
gasoline fuel from a heat source in the steel
tray below the main jet cylinder which then John Ashmole was back running the Rubber Bowden on the Sunday with his usual enthusiasm and
sprayed through into the tube at the rear diligence. Here he sets the target time of 0 seconds flight for ave Banks who flew another of his fleet
where combustion took place – not for the of quirky small own designs.
faint hearted and definitely not to be tried at
home!
It was great to bump in to
three generations of family
flying together. From left,
Alan Bird with icroRC
RTF Sonik ustang with
stabilising giro, Lyndon
Bird, Sarah Rowse, friend
Thomas Boyd with Sonik
Corsair, and Rowan Bird.
This was their first time
back at Old Warden in
three years because of
Covid, and they were
thoroughly enjoying
it. Small RC electric
stabilised RTFs have
their place as an easier
introduction to what we
do, and they’re fun!

Catching the editor’s eye, Doug Campbell


had a ills 1. powered Tyro which was not
only designed by his father David Boddington
but finished in classic B marking scheme
but with a different colour palette.
Edward Gautrey was struggling first to start and then trim his FF twin rotor autogyro. The Contra
Gyro is an old A design by aurie Ellis and the plan U644 still available from Sarik Hobbies.

the SAM 35 and ModelAir committee


members planned to present awards
for their service. They coordinated the
presentations to happen at 9.30 am on
the Sunday before the start of play, firstly
SAM 35 followed by ModelAir. They
were very moved especially as it was
also Sheila’s birthday! We all sang happy
birthday at the end which brought Shelia
to tears…
ModelAir continues with Emma Chase
and James Gordon heading up the team.
There are two dates booked for next
year: Festival of Flight 13-14 May, and
Scale Weekend 16-17 September 2023.
www.modelair.info ■
Richard alby often has a stand at Old
arden and you can be sure of seeing
engines there which you won’t see anywhere
else. These talian ena diesels are at the top
a rear induction k and below a later FR
Front Rotary alve version.

,
much patched Sirocco
ave Rumball and his
ea with a elie onocoupe, and en
Bryan in
Cousins Braydon ileson and alin Hall were ior Tomtit competing
Bates with a FROG Sen run by SA 5.
flying all weekend under the watchful eyes of the Rubber Bowden
Shaun ileson. The Junior Glider competition was held both
days, with gliders built and decorated in one
of the hangars before flying. Photo by Stuart
arsden

A healthy turn out of 12 flyers in the Rubber Bowden given the flying conditions for the small models.
inner of the ow ing Biplane category was Ron Johnson with his O flying wing, while Bert
hitehead won the High ing category.
Classics all, ready for the ourney home
Graham inch had filled his GB GT boot
with some lovely models including a Nat nee
and ercury Tiger oth.
FF Contest

INDOOR FREE FLIGHT


PERFORMANCE NATS
MEREDITH EVANS REPORTS ON THE

T
his year, the usual indoor Unlike TVAC, a model which hung up on
INDOOR NATS HELD ON 16TH TO performance venue at the these obstructions was easily retrieved
18TH SEPTEMBER 2022 Thames Valley Athletics and not one model was lost during the
Centre (TVAC) was not contest.
available due to re-surfacing n Friday, the absence of both Tony
of the floor. Therefore, the Indoor Free Hebb and Mark Benns meant that
Flight Performance ationals had to Hans Staartjes and Mike Colling were
be held at yet another new venue. left to fill in as joint Contest Director.
Fortunately, Tony Hebb the Indoor Tech The decision was taken to split the hall
Committee chairman was able to secure virtually between relatively light and
the use of his local leisure centre at heavy classes; the light classes getting
Daventry. In May, this had been used for the better air at the entrance door end.
one of the U F1D Team Trials events Most people obeyed this demarcation
and was found to be ideal. This venue and there was never the perception that
has a large single open space with a the hall was too small for our needs.
ceiling of 9.2 metres, defined by support
The outside breeze being channelled through
ventilation and heating ducts had a detrimental rails for cricket nets, along with other Friday 16th September
effect on Tom Goodwin s Gyminnie Cricket. lighting services and structural members. With the first day of the contest falling on

Tom Goodwin’s Limited Penny Plane (LPP) at the Daventry leisure centre Indoor FF Performance Nats.

60 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


avid Goodwin’s Catapult glider on a trimming flight. Roy Sellwood’s pretty Airacobra No-Cal.

a Friday, there were only five contestants at an angle towards the floor. utside,
present at the start of the first morning. it was quite bree y and cold, so air was
This low turnout led to the CD forcing its way in through the wall vents,
authorising self timing; an arrangement as indicated by the fans rotating slowly.
which then persisted for the rest of the It was never clear whether the air coming
championship. At this early stage, the out of the heating vents was actual
flying mainly consisted of trimming flights heating air, or air forcing its way into the
with the heavier models. Ian Pearce and system from outside as its e ects were
Roy Sellwood were mixing the Gyminnie quite intermittent. Either way, it was
Cricket (GC) and Limited Penny Plane quite powerful enough to stall a model,
(LPP) classes, while I started with or dash it towards the floor making
LPP and o-Cal scale. In the lighter accurate trimming difficult.
half of the hall, solitary F1D flyer Hans Later in the morning David and Tom
Staartjes was assembling his model and Goodwin arrived, along with Bob Bailey,
checking its glide. These check flights, who all made a start on Gyminnie Cricket
performed with the propeller replaced and LPP. I spent the morning setting up Tom Goodwin launching his Catapult glider.
by a ballasted dummy hub, are a useful my LPP and doing some quick flights
part of F1D flight preparation and are in o-Cal scale. This was using my
used to get the tail setting angle exactly old Dornier 5 model, which is rather some initial Catapult glider trimming,
right. An experienced flyer will know warped and overweight now, so no great even though conditions were not
how many seconds of glide they will get performance was achieved. With their good, with the turbulence a ecting the
from a hand launch and adjustments are relatively short tail arm and limited tail transition to glide.
made until the expected performance is area, LPP models can struggle for pitch When rubber powered flying resumed,
achieved. stability, and in the prevailing conditions Roy Sellwood spent the afternoon flying
From the start of the flying session, this was certainly the case. My model his P 9 Airacobra o-Cal, which looked
it was immediately apparent that air struggled and couldn’t realise its hoped- very attractive in its yellow and green
conditions were not good. The exterior for potential. civilian racer colour scheme. Generally,
sidewall of the hall was equipped with At lunchtime, propeller powered during the afternoon conditions improved
two extraction fans, which clearly flying was stopped for a half hour Hand and this allowed flights of the lighter
connected to the outside. In addition to Launched Glider (HLG or F1 ) and classes such as Rob Funnel’s Living
this there was a ceiling mounted heating Catapult glider slot. Bob Bailey and the Room Stick (LRS) and Ian Pearce’s
duct with four vents blowing air down Goodwins made use of this time for 5cm Challenge. Hans was also getting

Ian Pearce’s 35cm Challenge model. He went on Ian Pearce steering his F1L model. Tim Chant’s Legal Eagle winner.
to win the class.

AeroModeller 1027 - 61
Free Flight Scale

ark Benns’ large H G glider went on to win the class.

Mark Harper has returned to indoor


competition and was flying this Bob Bailey good times in F1D, as was experienced made the required take o something
designed PP. during the Team Trials at this site. I spent of a lottery, but we were able to make
the afternoon trying to get the best out some very good flights. As lunchtime
of my LPP, which was not pitch stable approached and we ran out of time, Tim
enough to recover sharply from a roof was in the lead by one second and that
beam hit. The Goodwins spent the was how it remained as we moved on to
afternoon making progress in GC and other classes.
LPP. Towards the end of the afternoon, At the start of the lunch break, we
Tim Chant arrived and began some all stopped flying and held a minute’s
setup flights with his Legal Eagle and silence to commemorate the passing
LPP. Unfortunately, we had to pack up of Her Majesty the late ueen Eli abeth
at 16:30 in order to be out of the hall by II. nce the finish of the silence was
17:00 for another activity. This led to a announced by Mark, it was time for the
rushed pack-up as people tried to make half hour glider slot. This was rather
And this is Bob Bailey’s PP. the most of the good conditions at the busy, with many of the competitors
end of the afternoon. In my case, this led taking part, although mostly in Catapult.
to a spectacular folding table collapse Mark Benns was supreme with his
which completely destroyed my LPP familiar, large HLG model, but there were
model. also good flights from Tom and David
Goodwin.
Saturday 17th September In what would turn out to be the best
Weather conditions on Saturday were conditions of the championship, it was
much more favourable, with warm very busy on Saturday afternoon. Many
sunshine and almost no wind. Inside the people were trying to get their best
hall, the extractor fans were stationary flights in LPP, which is traditionally the
and flying conditions were very much class with the most entrants and hence
improved. There was still the occasional is the most competitive. Bob Bailey was
bump, but the air stabilised very nicely continuing with his unusual own design,
Tom Goodwin made the most of the good
conditions on the Saturday with his F1R. during the day. The weekend brought which has been kitted by Bob and other
new arrivals including Mark Benns as members of the Indoor Tech Committee.
Contest Director, Dave Whitehouse and This has proven to be very popular
Mark Harper, who was returning after and two of the kits had been built and
some time away from the hobby. were flown by Roy Sellwood and Mark
The better conditions brought out the Harper alongside Bob’s original. The
lighter models and soon the lighter end design is unusual in that it doesn’t use
of the hall was busy with Living Rooms all the available wing chord or propeller
Stick and 35cm challenge models, F1Ls diameter. This gives a longer tail arm
and the usual F1Ds. There was also and less pitch de-stabilisation from the
a surprise visit from former UK Team propeller, improving the overall pitch
member Derek Richards, along with stability, which can be a problem for
some local flyers from Birmingham. They LPP designs. This was not, however,
were not taking part in the contest, but a one-design contest, with Tim Chant
Tim Chant’s winning PP
it was great to see Derek once more flying his carbon-sparred Gowan LPP
engaged with the indoor free flight model. David Goodwin and Rob Funnel
performance scene. As for myself, I was were also performing well with their more
involved in a close battle with Tim Chant conventional LPP models.
in Legal Eagle. Turbulence near the floor In the good air conditions, Tom

62 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


Goodwin was making a start in F1R with As I had expected Sunday to have the equipped with a motor stick section
a 0.6gram fixed-pitch propeller model. best conditions, this was the time I had made from a specially moulded carbon
He had initial problems with hang-ups reserved for my F1R flying. My model fibre tube. This was obviously very sti
on the ceiling structure, but was soon weighs 0.5 gram without rubber and and, at this stage, rather heavy when
making good flights. With the absence of has a fixed pitch prop. At this weight, compared to the balsa tube version.
Tony Hebb, this class was unusually wide the model is pretty rigid; the converse of There was also discussion as to whether
open. My afternoon was spent battling which can be a problem with F1R models the necessary stick bow due to the motor
Dave Whitehouse in F1M. This class is obsessively built to an arbitrary weight tension would be achieved with this
intended as an entry into F1D and has target. In the early stages of my indoor construction. This is an essential feature
seen some great multi-way battles over performance career, it was continually of a modern F1D, where the motor
recent years. It is also possible to fly a dinged into me by the old hands’ that tension bows the motor stick against
LPP as an F1M, as it meets the rules if a given model must be rigid enough to the resistance of the wire bracing. This
you use a 0. 5gram half motor with a hold its shape in flight and be able to provides downthrust which avoids a
0. 5gram ballast stick. Tim Chant chose survive handling. A model with these power stall just after launch, an e ect
to do this with his Gowan, but the result properties, even if it’s overweight, will which dissipates as the torque drops o .
was some way behind the dedicated fly and will teach you something. You Having competed in five other classes,
F1M models. Fortunately at the end of can then look at ways of progressively I hadn’t spent the time required by my
Saturday’s session, there was no-one getting the weight down. F1D to get the most out of it. I’d had to
else using the hall so we were able to Having found the torque level required adjust the pitch trim to provide more stall
leave some of our equipment in place for my F1R to reach the ceiling, I then margin in the slightly lumpy air and this
and make best use of the excellent put up two timed flights as a benchmark required considerable readjustment of
conditions. before moving on to F1D. Tom Goodwin the P setup to compensate. The model
had spent the morning finishing o is still 10 overweight and flies correctly,
Sunday 18th September his flights in Living Room Stick and if not very competitively in its current
Sunday Morning’s weather was once Gyminnie Cricket. Then, having seen my state, so I left things as they were and
again sunny, but with a slight bree e. F1R times, he was inspired to try and prepared for some nominal flights after
Inside the hall, the ventilation fans better them. He tried very hard and got the lunch break.
were turning, but only very slowly, so closer by adding a minute to his times Sunday’s lunchtime glider slot saw
conditions were not quite as good as from Saturday, but it was not enough. Mark Benns flying Catapult, having
for Saturday, but still quite adequate. Having put the time in on F1D, finished with HLG on Saturday. His
Sunday usually presents the opportunity Hans Staartjes spent the morning best model was destroyed when the
to get in those final flights and really experimenting with a F1D model wing came o during the launch and
push things in the classes that matter
to you. Tim Chant, Bob Bailey and Mark
Harper were finishing o their flights in
LPP, while Ian Pearce and Roy Sellwood
were completing 5cm Challenge. I had
found myself a few seconds behind Dave
Whitehouse in F1M and as he was not
present on Sunday, I decided to try and
catch him unopposed. My first flight
was a slight improvement, but my final
flight ended in a hang-up in the ceiling
structure, with critical damage during the
retrieval.
Having completed LPP, Tim Chant
moved on to o-Cal scale with his
Cassutt Racer alongside David Goodwin,
who was also putting in some final o-
Cal flights with his Heinkel. Tim had a
few problems this year, but the addition
of a big aileron trim tab and some ballast
rectified things enough for him to take
the win over David. Based upon our
experiences this year, I would conclude
that o-Cal models don’t have a long
shelf life. It seems they are particularly
prone to warping with their minimal
structure and tissue covering. Hans Staartjes is experimenting with a carbon motor tube on his F1D model.

AeroModeller 1027 - 63
RESULTS:
Free Flight Scale
F1D ½ MOTOR (3 ENTRIES)
1. M. Benns 11 25 + 11 2 22 48
2. H. Staartjes 11 15 + 11 09 22 24
. M. Evans 0 5 + 08 1 16 28

F1L ½ MOTOR (2 ENTRIES)


1. I. Pearce 0 4 + 0 54 15 28
2. T. Goodwin 06 20 + 0 05 1 25

F1R ½ MOTOR (2 ENTRIES)


1. M. Evans 0 49 + 08 00 15 49
2. T. Goodwin 0 5+0 1 15 06

F1M ½ MOTOR (3 ENTRIES)


1. D. Whitehouse 06 0 + 05 59 12 06
2. M. Evans 05 50 + 05 52 11 42
. T. Chant 0 06 0 06

F1N (HAND LAUNCHED GLIDER) (3 ENTRIES)


Hans Staartjes steers his more traditional F1D Bob Bailey launches his Catapult glider. 1. M. Benns 41.80 + 9.20 + 42. 0 12 . 0
model with balsa tube. 2. T. Goodwin 25.00 + 2 .00 + 28.00 80.00
. D. Goodwin 2 .00 + 2 .00 + 2 .00 69.00

the violent, unrestrained acceleration year, the gap while the final scores were LIMITED PENNY PLANE (LPP) (10 ENTRIES)
shredded the tail surfaces. He then compiled was filled by a mass launch 1. T. Chant 06 52 + 0 00 1 52
2. D. Goodwin 06 29 + 06 8 1 0
moved on to a fleet of smaller models, contest for LPP models; last one down is . R. Funnel 06 5 + 05 45 12 8
but was unable to challenge Tom the winner. Seven competitors took part,
NO-CAL SCALE (4 ENTRIES)
Goodwin whose model performed some but the almost inevitable mid-air collision 1. T. Chant 02 1 + 01 5 04 06 Cassutt
perfect glides from a transition just below took out two of them almost immediately. 2. D. Goodwin 01 4 + 01 50 0 Heinkel
. R. Sellwood 01 + 01 42 0 19 Airacobra
the e ective ceiling. Bob Bailey also ne by one the models landed leaving
had an ama ing Catapult flight when Tim Chant victorious with a slightly 35CM CHALLENGE (2 ENTRIES)
1. I. Pearce 06 44 + 06 1 1
his small model successfully threaded conservative 6 45 to go with his LPP win 2. M. Harper 04 1 + 04 45 09 16
its way through the roof structure in the Championship.
GYMINNIE CRICKET (GC) (5 ENTRIES)
without touching anything following an With the mass launch complete, it was 1. T. Goodwin 05 01 + 05 05 10 06
overenthusiastic launch. time for the presentations. Gwynedd 2. R. Bailey 04 29 + 05 16 09 45
. D. Goodwin 04 21 + 04 45 09 06
The final session of the ationals is and Mike deserve our special thanks for
quite short as flying is stopped at 15 00 their dutiful e orts over the three days LIVING ROOM STICK (LRS) (5 ENTRIES)
1. D. Goodwin 05 08 + 05 1 10 9
to allow Gwynedd and Mike Colling in keeping track of 196 competition 2. R. Funnel 04 2 + 04 2 08 59
time to compile the final scores. I put flights in the eleven classes from twelve . M. Harper 04 8 + 04 20 08 58

up my two flights in F1D which were competitors and for publishing the final LEGAL EAGLE (4 ENTRIES)
nothing special, but Mark Benns was all results so quickly. The verall Points 1. T. Chant 0 5 + 0 21 06 56
2. M. Evans 0 29 + 0 26 06 55
for readjusting the VP to get the most Championship and our congratulations . D. Goodwin 02 51 + 02 49 05 40
out of the model. Unfortunately, there this year go to David Goodwin, with a
CATAPULT GLIDER (5 ENTRIES)
was not time for this and it wouldn’t score of 0 points built upon his victory 1. T. Goodwin 5.00 + .00 + 6.00 108.00
have changed the positions, but merely in Living Room Stick and the consistency 2. D. Goodwin 28.00 + 2 .00 + 29.00 90.00
. M. Benns 25.00 + 0.00 + 0. 0 85. 0
improved my scores. Having had the full of placing in all seven classes he
three days this year, there didn’t seem to entered.
be such a mad rush to get flights in just This year, the return to the three-day would always welcome new competitors.
before the close and so things settled format allowed more classes to be flown It’s more accessible than you might think
down in preparation for the Limited by each competitor, ensuring the survival The BMFA Indoor Duration Technical
Penny Plane Mass Launch. of the lesser’ classes which su ered last Committee website is indoorduration.
As there was no auction of donated year. Competitor numbers appear to be bmfa.uk ■
indoor equipment and materials this recovering slowly after Covid, but we

The winning Catapult glider of Tom Goodwin makes the most of the roof height. Mass launch of LPP models gave time for the results to be collated.

64 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


EST.
200
ALWAYS IN STOCK: Huge range of miniature Fast m
ai
3
fasteners, including our socket servo screws ser vi l order
ce
● Taps, Dies & Drills ● Miniature Bearings ● Adhesives & Tools
● Circlips ● E-Clips ● Starlocks ● Shim Washers ● O Rings

Tel: +44 (0)115 854 8791 Email: info@modelfixings.com

Traditional and Electric CL/FF/RC

Years
70
ears Super-Nylon
Since 1952 the bestselling and
Cox 049 engines and spares…ECL kits….CL & FF Electronic most successful propellers worldwide
w
Timers……Motors & ESC’s…….CL accessories….UK agent for Heisbok
laser cut FF and RC Kits The complete range of or propellers, spinners and boat propellers
pr
are available Shop.
vailable from the Specialized retailer or in our Shop
On Line shop at www.densmodelsupplies.co.uk
Or phone Den on 01983 294182
for traditional service

Modelling propeller Peter Schulze


Kunststofttechnik GmbH
Made in Germany
Model Accessories, Adhesive, Birch & Lite Ply, Veneer. Bildstock 23
All Types
Online of Covering, Prolux Covering Irons, SC Engines, Overlander Products, and much more.
Shop
Balsa Cabin Kits, Flair Kits & Cloud Model Kits. Agents for J. Perkins (Distribution) Ltd
88085 Langenargen
Tradition since 1952 Germany

Attractive dealer conditions +49(0)7543-1701

Exclusive to Balsa Cabin Modelling Pins £3.08


Protect-A-Plan 10ft x 41” £2.00

www.schulze-luftschrauben.de
Visit Our Website For Show Dates www.balsacabin.co.uk • Email: balsacabin@hotmail.com
The Balsa Cabin, Unit 15, Heybridge House Ind. Est. The Causeway, Maldon, Essex. CM9 4XL

Buyers Guide

FLITEHOOK TO ADVERTISE
PB MODELSHERE
www.flitehook.net sales@pbmodels.co.uk
Kits, Engines, Glues, Balsa, Coverings and
Call Alan on:
Accessories. Mostly for free flight but we also 01525
RETRO MODELS 222573
FROM THE 70’S and 80’s
carry a range of RC kits and bits.
Tel:
Tel:02380779836
445 Romsey
42 Players
02380 861 541
Road, Southampton,
Crescent, Hampshire,
Totton, Southampton, SO16 9AZ
Hants, SO40 9GJ www.pbmodels.co.uk
alan@doolittlemedia.com
TO FINISH

Tail End Charlie


Another pot pourri of aeromodelling miscellany…

Roger Cooper 1951 Aeromodeller plan, a and the Curtiss ‘Ascender’ reports and Scale Matters
1936 – 2022 RIP pusher canard of 40” span inspired me to attempt a column) and recommends
I was very sorry to hear from powered by a Redfin reed semi-scale prototype for a company called Silkcraft.
Roger Cooper’s wife Joan valve 1cc diesel. Roger was a canard lightplane. Two Mike says “The Silk Chi on
that he had passed away also the first participant in our di erent designs were built they sell is very good and the
towards the end of October “Fly the World” event. before the ‘Bee’ version, cost is very reasonable. See
after a short illness. Whilst On a personal note, he not which has been lost in a creek www.silkcraft.co.uk/white-
I hadn’t known Roger for a only collected a nearly mint for some months, placed silk-per-metre Weight is 3.5
great length of time, he was ETA29 from Gildings auction second at our Nationals.” m/m a little heavier than Esaki
the sort of person who could for me, but on hearing I was Who agrees that this would tissue but well usable. They
(and did) become a firm friend awaiting major surgery, arrived be a great choice for a historic sell it per metre or by the roll if
very quickly. on my doorstep with his wife plan article? you have deep pockets.”
Regular readers will Joan to deliver it, even though As Jim goes on to explain So that’s not only another
remember his article on he knew that Covid restrictions that the model needs nose month but another year
his Northwick Park club would limit our meeting to a weight roughly equivalent to under the bridge. Please do
(March 2021 AM) and more few minutes shouting across the engine weight. So it seems let me have your comments,
recently the excellent job my drive. He was a true friend to me that a modern variation complaints, suggestions,
he did refurbishing George who will be sorely missed. Our with electric power would be memories and anecdotes
Sayell’s 1955 KK Ranger thoughts remain with Joan and ideal, as the battery can be either direct to chrisottewell@
whilst retaining the patina. his family. placed to get the correct G anworld.com or by post via the
The last time we met was of G with no need to carry editorial offices.
at Old Warden in May when The Ascender otherwise useless weight! Now Email Note – There is no
Richard Evans took a break When I saw pictures of to convince the Editor...! dot “.” between “chris” and
from combat to perform the Roger’s Ascender model “ottewell” neither is there an
honours as Ranger test pilot. I took a quick look on line Silky Smooth “r” in my name! Sometimes
In his earlier years he had and discovered that it was Mike Smith wrote about people make those mistakes in
designed his own models and designed by Australian expert his recent experiences with typing my e-mail address and
been a keen Jetex rocketeer. Jim Fullarton. He wrote in the silk covering, favouring silk wonder why I don’t reply… ■
More recently he was a keen original build article that “This layered over tissue. He uses
user of Redfin engines and design started back in 1944, silk covering over tissue on
liked the unusual; for example when the disclosure of such his Free Flight Scale models
By Chris Ottewell
his “Ascender” from a July types as the Miles ‘Libellula’ (see the DH4 in past scale

1 2 3 4

1: The late Roger Cooper starting the engine in the Ranger prior to its first post renovation flight at O in ay 2022. 2 Roger Cooper and his 1954 own
design Arrow with Jete 50. 3: Roger ready to “Fly the orld” 4: Roger Cooper recently built the Jim Fullarton designed Ascender canard from July 1951 A .

66 AeroModeller 1027 - December 2022


PLANS AND PARTS
BE READY TO START BUILDING AS SOON AS YOU UNFOLD THE PLANS!

ALL CURRENTLY IN STOCK!!!


NAME CUT Moska MB Bis 45” CUT504
Grosswing Monopole CUT073 Martinsyde F.4 Buzzard CUT506
Westland Lysander Mk3 CUT109 Sopwith Pup CUT507
Morane Salunier Type N 108 CUT124 Comper Swift CUT516
Bleriot Monopole CUT16 Bellanca Skyrocket CUT518
Woodbury Gorse Basher 52.5” CUT214 NIEUPORT 17 1/6th scale CUT525
English Electric Canberra CUT262 Cessna 165 18” CUT526
BE12A 24.5” CUT310 Besson MD 411 CUT527
Mini Madcap CUT316 Brequet LE CUT528
Cessna 120/140 CUT468 Ponnier 1913 Racer 50” CUT532
FE8 CUT471 Pfalz E1 Eindekker CUT534
Ruffian CUT472 Cessna 165 18” CUT539
3FT Ruler 36” CUT473 Verville Air Coach CUT540
Nieuport 17” CUT474 Twinster CUT648
Lepton 14” CUT475 Heinkel He 162 16.75” CUTMF290
Sweet Lil ‘Sister 16” CUT476 Panic Attack 46” CUTMF291
Fokker D.VII CUT489 Vikers Gunbus 22” CUTMF297
Heinkel He-51 54” CUT499 Hansa Brandenburg C1 CUTMF8

CHECK OUT OUR WEBSITE FOR 100s MORE!!!


WWW.DOOLITTLEMEDIA.COM
E. enquiries@doolittlemedia.com T. +44 (0) 1525 222573
Doolittle Media Ltd., The Granary, Doolittle Lane, Totternhoe, Bedfordshire, LU6 1QX, Great Britain
Some of our kits now available through
Micron Radio Control
Baby Biwinger
13” span, float kit available separately

50” Dallaire Sportster


54” span 1/2A or electric Texaco

1913 Eastborn Monoplane


1:12 scale, 28” span fine scale model for electric or CO2
dummy engine kit available separately
The Limey
20” span RC Ebenezer
Offering over 90 original retro & vintage RC and FF model
airplane kits plus many unique laser cut accessories, building
jigs, tools organisers and glue caddies

Benny Howard DGA3 “Pete”


1:12 scale, 20” span “foamy” great for indoor pylon racing The Hun
19” span RC Ebenezer

You might also like