Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—Ornithopters are flying aerial vehicles capable of [9]. Tracking of UAV’s is a challenge since they offer very low
flying at a low altitude and low speed.These aerial vehicles offers RCS and their trajectories consists of abrupt changes.They can
a very low Radar cross section and often escape detection by move forward ,backward hover at a point,make a coordinated
tracking systems.These aerial vehicles trace a rabbit path which
consists of frequent and abrupt changes. Non linear tracking turn or take any abrupt direction of motion at will.Considering
of ornithopters is important from army point of view.This these challenges there is a need to develop a good tracking
algorithm can be used to track the ornithopters being used by the algorithm to track these low RCS targets [10].
adversaries and note down or evaluate the pattern.The processing
of this information will yield a meaningful data.These tracking C. Significance of non linear tracking
system once developed in the hardware can be incorporated in
the fire control system and can be used to bring down the enemy Non linear tracking of ornithopters is important from army
surveillance aerial vehicles flying at a low altitude and a low point of view.This algorithm can be used to track the or-
speed.The radar cross section offered by these ornithopters is nithopters being used by the adversaries and note down or
very low of the order of few square meters.Hence non linear evaluate the pattern [11], [12].The processing of this infor-
tracking is modeled using an Extended Kalman filter in this mation will yield a meaningful data.These tracking system
work in which a vehicle is made to follow a circular trajectory
and plotted for true, observed and estimated positions. once developed in the hardware can be incorporated in the
Index Terms—Ornithopters , Kalman Filter , Conflict detection fire control system and can be used to bring down the enemy
and resolution , Radar Cross Section , Continuous Wave Radar surveillance aerial vehicles flying at a low altitude and a low
speed [13].The RCS offered by these ornithopters is very low
I. I NTRODUCTION of the order of few square meters.
UAV’s and ornithopter’s have found an extensive usability
D. Literature Survey
in today’s scenario.There are combat UAV’s that carry aircraft
ordinances such as missiles and bombs used for deep strikes • In 2018 Amin razmi etal carried out his research work
[1], [2]. These UAV’s are usually under real-time human indicating detection of low RCS target in multi static con-
control, with varying levels of controls.The history of UAV’s figuration. The detection of geometrically-based stealth
dates back to Yom Kippur War of 1973 in which Israel lured targets in a reliable and befitting manner by employing
Saudi Arabia to fire their entire arsenal of anti-aircraft missiles a conventional single sensor radar system may be quite
on their unmanned aircrafts [3]. difficult [15], [16]. This is because the small radar cross-
section (RCS) results in a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR)
A. Conventional Radar systems and their usability at certain angles. In the main work, the multi-target
The radar systems available in the environment are basically tracking configuration of secret targets is investigated in a
developed in a manner to detect the supersonic targets.These multi-static radar with passive receivers. The direction of
aerial targets usually fly at a high altitude with a high speed arrival (DOA) of the targets is estimated by the receivers
which makes it possible to separate the target echo and without knowing the number of targets, and their position
ground/sea noise in the area(domain) of frequency [4], [5]. is obtained based on the direction of the transmission
radius [17], [18]. The Bomber B2 model was used as a
B. Maintaining the Radar operation for the detection of low stealth target
Radar Cross Section (RCS) objects • The RCS of the target is simulated for all variations of
Over the years there have evolved aerial vehicles such as angles of incidence and reflected angles of an oblique
paragliders, ornithopters etc. These airborne vehicles generally plane wave. The detection probability is formulated using
fly at a low altitude of few thousand meters with a speed of the a Toeplitz-based method for various signal to noise ratio
order of 225 kilometer per hour and offers a RCS as small as corresponding to different RCS patterns and applied to
2m2 [6], [7].Over the years UAV has assumed a lot of impor- an iterated corrected probability hypothesis density (IC-
tance and are extensively being used by defence forces over PHD) filter [19]. Despite the fact that when generating
the world for svl operations. Hence it has become important to our input data we take into account the resolution of the
track their trajectories and subsequently neutralize them [8], sender and receiver, the proposed algorithm can track the
At xt− 1 + Bt ut + ϵt (1)
s[n] = A[n−1]s[n−1]+Bu[n]+(a(ŝ[n−1|−1]))−A[n−1]ŝ[n−1|n−1]
x[n] = H[n]s[n] + w[n] + (h(ŝ[n|n − 1]) − H([n]ŝ[n|n − 1]) Fig. 3. Flow diagram of Kalman Filter
hence the modified equation for non linear Kalman Filter are
,where
A. MATLAB design
Fig. 6. The azimuth is plotted for display of variation in true ,observed and
estimated values
A. Discussion
• The EKF for this problem relies on linearisation in
order to propagate the mean and covariance of the state.
Fig. 4. Main functional block design Propagating the mean and covariance of the state based on
Jacobian linearisation can be a crude approximation. This
the EKF may track well in this problem for a short period
of time. This is shown in the zoomed plots of the Range
and the Azimuth. In those plots, the estimate is shown as
a black dotted line and actual true trajectory of the state is
shown in blue. The red trace is the noisy observations. On
the other hand, if the initial conditions of the underlying
state dynamics are not known well then the EKF will not
have desirable performance.
V. C ONCLUSION
It is shown that traditional Kalman Filter fails in esti-
Fig. 7. The range is plotted for display of variation in true ,observed and
estimated values mating non-linear trajectories of the targets. The non-linear
Kalman filter or extended Kalman filter has been successfully
researched and implemented and shows the results of target
modeling in various scenarios. The accuracy of the extended
Kalman filter is promising, but it has a slight disadvantage due
to increased noise that can lead to inaccuracies in the trajectory
estimation. To further improve accuracy, many sophisticated
scoring methods exist, such as the Unscented Kalman filter,
which uses odorless transform to construct scores around a
target mean. Particulate filters can be installed in more difficult
paths.
We have range of UAV’s capable of flying at low altitude
and low speed to combat UAV’s which can even be used to
Fig. 8. The trajactories is plotted for display of variation in true ,observed
and estimated values destroy logistic dumps and static locations which are strategic
in nature.There have been instances where our adversaries
have used UAV’s to deliver weapons and ammunition to non-
is because the Jacobian of the original nonlinear dynamics state players.Building a robust algorithm will assist the field
discards the higher order terms of the nonlinear dynamics. army in successful execution of operations.Once the trajectory
In addition to this approximation, Kalman Filter theory of aerial targets is modeled using Extended kalman filter it may
is abound by Gaussian statistical assumptions. In other lead to future scope of developing a hardware system which
words, Kalman Filters of almost all varieties assume can implement the above mentioned algorithm. The tracking
that the noise distributions are Gaussian therefore they algorithm worked out in this paper can be implemented in
propagate the first and second moments through some hardware form and incorporated in fire control systems to
version of the dynamics (in this case of the EKF, its the bring down the target.The tracking algorithm requires con-
Jacobian of the nonlinear dynamics). This can lead to tinuous supply of measurement data which can be provided
unpleasant estimation errors if the underlying true sta- in the form of range and bearing from the radar.Since the rcs
tistical distribution has dominant higher order moments possessed by the ornithopters is of the order of few square
(i.e. a great deal of the distribution is characterized by meters the radar should have sufficient sensitivity to capture
its Skewness or Kurtosis). Since reality is not always it.
Gaussian,this problem is real and must be acknowledged.
• For highly nonlinear systems with non-Gaussian noise, R EFERENCES
more refined techniques can be used to improve the [1] Nezah Balal,Yael Balal,Yair Richter and Yosef Pinhasi(2020). Detection
estimator performance. For instance, one may consider of Low RCS Supersonic Flying Targets with a High-Resolution MMW
a Particle Filter implementation or, if one is familiar Radar.Sensors by MDPIIsrael.
[2] Chin E. Lin,Hyondong Oh(2018). UAV Path Prediction for CD and
with the Unscented Transformation, the UKF may be an R to Manned Aircraft in a Confined Airspace for Cooperative Mis-
option. Note that with the UKF, one is still constrained sion.International Journal of AerospaceEngg,Taiwan
by the Gaussian assumptions on the noise distributions, [3] Chin E. Lin and Ya-Hsien Lai(2015). Department of Aeronautics and
Astronautics, National Cheng Kung University, Tainan 701,Taiwan.
but the actual nonlinear dynamics are used to propagate [4] Andrew Gadsden, Saeid Habibi, T. Kirubarajan(2012). NonlinearEsti-
key points through the system dynamics. Despite its mation Techniques Applied on Target Tracking Problems.Journal of
shortcomings for this nonlinear/non-Gaussian problem, Dynamic Ssystem,Measurement andControl.
[5] Xiaofei Jing, Jiarui Cui, Hongtai He, Yue Yang(2017). Attitude Estima-
we have been able to obtain simulation results to discuss. tion forUAV Using Extended Kalman Filter.29th CCDCChina.
When the initial conditions of the states are known [6] Chunbo Luo, McClean, Luke Teacy and Renzo De Nardi(2013).
perfectly by the EKF then the covariance propagation UAV Position Estimation and Collision Avoidance Using the Extended
Kalman Filter.IEEE Transaction on vehiculartechnology.
matrix initial conditions become zeros. [7] Marion Plite,Silvere Bonnabel,Fredric Livernet(2018).USRI Workshop
• In this case, depending on the noise covariance intensities, France.
[8] Kumawat, Harish C., and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Extraction of Doppler tional Conference on Communication and Electronics Systems (ICCES),
signature of micro-to-macro rotations/motions using continuous wave pp. 136-141. IEEE, 2020.
radar-assisted measurement system.” IET Science, Measurement & [27] A. P. Lakshminarayanan, H. C. Kumawat and A. B. Raj, ”Moving
Technology 14.7 (2020): 772-785 Target Detection in Foliage Environment using FMCW Radar,” 2020 5th
[9] Raj, A. ArockiaBazil. ”Mono-pulse tracking system for active free space International Conference on Communication and Electronics Systems
optical communication.” Optik 127.19 (2016): 7752-7761. (ICCES), 2020, pp. 418-421.
[10] Anthonisamy, ArockiaBazil Raj, Padmavathi Durairaj, and Lancelot [28] Behera, Dinesh Kumar, and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Drone Detection and
James Paul. ”Performance analysis of free space optical communica- Classification using Deep Learning.” In 2020 4th International Con-
tion in open-atmospheric turbulence conditions with beam wandering ference on Intelligent Computing and Control Systems (ICICCS), pp.
compensation control.” IET Communications 10.9 (2016): 1096-1103. 1012-1016. IEEE, 2020.
[11] Raj ,A. ArockiaBazil, J. Arputha Vijaya Selvi, D. Kumar, and S. Ragha- [29] Anju, P., AA Bazil Raj, and Chandra Shekhar. ”Pulse Doppler
van. ”Design of cognitive decision making controller for autonomous Processing-A Novel Digital Technique.” In 2020 4th International Con-
online adaptive beam steering in free space optical communication ference on Intelligent Computing and Control Systems (ICICCS), pp.
system.” Wireless Personal Communications 84, no. 1 (2015): 765-799. 1089-1095. IEEE, 2020.
[12] Raj, Arockia A. Bazil, Arputha J. Vijaya Selvi, Kumar D. Durai, and [30] Mohan, Anurag, and AA Bazil Raj. ”Array Thinning of Beamformers
Raghavan S. Singaravelu. ”Intensity feedback-based beam wandering using Simple Genetic Algorithm.” In 2020 International Conference on
mitigation in free-space optical communication using neural control Computational Intelligence for Smart Power System and Sustainable
technique.” EURASIP Journal on Wireless Communications and Net- Energy (CISPSSE), pp. 1-4. IEEE, 2020.
working 2014, no. 1 (2014): 1-18. [31] Phanindra, Bhavana Ram, R. N. Pralhad, and AA Bazil Raj. ”Machine
[13] Raj, A. ArockiaBazil, J. Arputha Vijaya Selvi, D. Kumar, and S. Learning Based Classification of Ducted and Non-Ducted Propeller
Raghavan. ”A direct and neural controller performance study with beam Type Quadcopter.” In 2020 6th International Conference on Advanced
wandering mitigation control in free space optical link.” Optical Memory Computing and Communication Systems (ICACCS), pp. 1296-1301.
and Neural Networks 23, no. 3 (2014): 111-129. IEEE, 2020.
[14] Raj, A. ArockiaBazil, J. Arputha Vijaya Selvi, D. Kumar, and N. [32] Kumawat, Harish Chandra, and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Data acquisition
Sivakumaran. ”Mitigation of beam fluctuation due to atmospheric turbu- and signal processing system for CW radar.” In 2019 5th International
lence and prediction of control quality using intelligent decision-making Conference On Computing, Communication, Control And Automation
tools.” Applied optics 53, no. 17 (2014): 3796-3806. (ICCUBEA), pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2019.
[15] Upadhyay, Madhusudan, Somanchi Krishna Murthy, and AA Bazil Raj. [33] Thiruvoth, DaliyaVelandi, AA Bazil Raj, B. Pavan Kumar, V. Senthil
”Intelligent System for Real time detection and classification of Aerial Kumar, and Ravi Dutt Gupta. ”Dual-Band Shared-Aperture Reflectarray
Targets using CNN.” 2021 5th International Conference on Intelligent Antenna Element at Ku-Band for the TT&C Application of a Geostation-
Computing and Control Systems (ICICCS). IEEE, 2021. ary Satellite.” In 2019 4th International Conference on Recent Trends
[16] Akella, Aditya Srinivas, and AA Bazil Raj. ”DCNN Based Activity on Electronics, Information, Communication & Technology (RTEICT),
Classification of Ornithopter using Radar micro-Doppler Images.” In pp. 361-364. IEEE, 2019.
2021 5th International Conference on Intelligent Computing and Control [34] Gupta, Anupama, and AA Bazil Rai. ”Feature Extraction of Intra-Pulse
Systems (ICICCS), pp. 780-784. IEEE, 2021. Modulated LPI Waveforms Using STFT.” In 2019 4th International Con-
[17] Sharma, Gaurav, and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Effects of Antenna Radiation ference on Recent Trends on Electronics, Information, Communication
Pattern on Airborne SAR Imaging with Sufficient Cyclic Prefix-OFDM.” & Technology (RTEICT), pp. 742-746. IEEE, 2019.
In 2020 IEEE 4th Conference on Information & Communication Tech- [35] Vaishnavi, Ravi, G. Unnikrishnan, and AA Bazil Raj. ”Implementation
nology (CICT), pp. 1-6. IEEE, 2020. of algorithms for Point target detection and tracking in Infrared image
[18] Sharma, Gaurav, and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Spotlight SAR Imaging with sequences.” In 2019 4th International Conference on Recent Trends on
Sufficient Cyclic Prefix-OFDM Waveform.” In 2020 International Con- Electronics, Information, Communication & Technology (RTEICT), pp.
ference on Smart Electronics and Communication (ICOSEC), pp. 625- 904-909. IEEE, 2019.
630. IEEE, 2020. [36] Shakya, Priyanka, and AA Bazil Raj. ”Inverse Synthetic Aperture Radar
[19] Maddegalla, Maheeja, A. ArockiaBazil Raj, and GurugubelliSyamala Imaging Using Fourier Transform Technique.” In 2019 1st International
Rao. ”Beam Steering and Control Algorithm for 5-18GHz Trans- Conference on Innovations in Information and Communication Technol-
mit/Receive Module Based Active Planar Array.” In 2020 International ogy (ICIICT), pp. 1-4. IEEE, 2019.
Conference on System, Computation, Automation and Networking (IC- [37] Garg, Upasana, AA Bazil Raj, and K. P. Ray. ”Cognitive Radar Assisted
SCAN), pp. 1-6. IEEE, 2020. Target Tracking: A Study.” In 2018 3rd International Conference on
[20] Singh, Neha, and AA Bazil Raj. ”Estimation of Heart Rate and Communication and Electronics Systems (ICCES), pp. 427-430. IEEE,
Respiratory Rate using Imaging Photoplethysmography Technique.” In 2018.
2020 International Conference on System, Computation, Automation [38] Gupta, Deeksha, AA Bazil Raj, and Abhijit Kulkarni. ”Multi-Bit Digital
and Networking (ICSCAN), pp. 1-5. IEEE, 2020. Receiver Design For Radar Signature Estimation.” In 2018 3rd IEEE
[21] De, Sampurna, and AA Bazil Raj. ”Angle Estimation using Modified International Conference on Recent Trends in Electronics, Information
Monopulse Ratio Algorithm and S-curve in Adaptive Subarray Level.” & Communication Technology (RTEICT), pp. 1072-1075. IEEE, 2018.
In IEEE Inter., Conf.,“Systems Inventive Research in Computing Appli- [39] Majumdar, A., Z. Ghassemlooy, and A. Raj. ”Principles and applications
cations (ICIRCA 2020), pp. 1-7. 2020. of free space optical (FSO) communication.” IET, UK (2019).
[22] Deepshikha, A. Raut and A. A. Bazil Raj, ”Signal Processing for Digital [40] Raj, A. ArockiaBazil. FPGA-based embedded system developer’s guide.
Beamforming on Transmit in MIMO Radar,” 2020 Second Interna- CRC Press, 2018.
tional Conference on Inventive Research in Computing Applications [41] Raj, A. ArockiaBazil. Free space optical communication: system de-
(ICIRCA), 2020, pp. 1106-1111. sign, modeling, characterization and dealing with turbulence. Walter de
[23] Singh, Urvasi, and AA Bazil Raj. ”A Comparison Study of Multiple Gruyter GmbH & Co KG, 2015.
Radar Waveform Design Techniques” Customized floating-point algo- [42] Ch, Mary Latha, AA Bazil Raj, and L. Abhikshit. ”Design and Imple-
rithm for the ranging systems.” In IEEE Inter., Conf.,“Systems Inventive mentation of a Secure Physical Unclonable Function In FPGA.” In 2020
Research in Computing Applications (ICIRCA 2020), pp. 1-7. 2020. Second International Conference on Inventive Research in Computing
[24] Gunjal, Mayur M., and AA Bazil Raj. ”Improved Direction of Arrival Applications (ICIRCA), pp. 1083-1089. IEEE, 2020.
Estimation Using Modified Music Algorithm.” In 2020 5th International [43] Kumar, Rohit, and A. ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Customized Floating Point
Conference on Communication and Electronics Systems (ICCES), pp. Algorithm for the Ranging System.” In 2020 International Conference
249-254. IEEE, 2020. on System, Computation, Automation and Networking (ICSCAN), pp.
[25] Mazumder, Joydeep, and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Detection and Classifi- 1-7. IEEE, 2020.
cation of UAV Using Propeller Doppler Profiles for Counter UAV
Systems.” In 2020 5th International Conference on Communication and
Electronics Systems (ICCES), pp. 221-227. IEEE, 2020.
[26] Kumawat, Harish Chandra, and ArockiaBazil Raj. ”Approach-
ing/Receding Target Detection using CW Radar.” In 2020 5th Interna-