Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SPECPOL
A Quick Note
Kashmir is still in a state of conflict at the time of this writing, so the dais
urges you to stay updated by reading recent news from the region. Note
that Indian and Pakistani sources will reflect the policy of each country and
therefore will provide very different narratives. While some may have
strong personal opinions on the issue, remember that your country policy
should guide your research and your statements!
Introduction
Koreas, the Kashmir conflict has become a defining element of Indian and
Pakistani military and cultural policy (less so of China’s). As a result, even
though Kashmiris are an ethnic minority in the subcontinent, the Kashmir
conflict is now central to the political identities of all of India and Pakistan.
For many other reasons, however, Kashmir is unique.
Firstly, India and Pakistan both have nuclear arsenals, but neither of them
have joined the non-proliferation treaty, and neither of them have close
ties to an NPT member as the DPRK is to China and South Korea to the US.
Secondly, Kashmir’s legal status during partition was left uncertain , due to
the delay caused by Maharaja Hari Singh who wanted Kashmir to be
independent. As a result , this led to war and complicated matter. India
continues to treat the Kashmir insurgency as a domestic issue. This has
resulted in humanitarian aid being hindered and allowed human rights
violations to take place. Lastly, though Indian-administered Kashmir (where
the current conflict is centered) is a Muslim-majority region within a
Muslim-minority country, ISIS, the Taliban, and other well-known Islamic
extremist groups do not significantly influence political dynamics in the
region. There are smaller terrorist cells (including Lashkar-e-Taiba, which
carried out the 2008 Mumbai attacks), but their appeal is limited.
Compared to much of the Middle East, popular support for the Kashmir
insurgency is more political and less religious.
2
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
History
The ambiguous political status of Kashmir dates to the time of the British
colonial occupation. The British did not control all of India directly; in many
cases, they chose to secure guarantees of loyalty from existing “princely
states,” which were still run by kings.
1947: Maharaja Hari Singh flees to Jammu , due to the insurgency of the
kasmiri people and requests military aid from India. He also signs the
Instrument of accession to India ,agreeing to accede to the Dominion of
India. War breaks out over the region
1948: India raises the issue in the UN , which in resolution 47 calls for a
referendum, it also calls for Pakistan to removes it troops and for India to
cut down its military presence , a ceasefire is arranged and Kashmir is
partitioned.
3
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
1965: A brief war between Indian and Pakistan over Kashmir ends in a
ceasefire and a return to the previous positions.
1984: Indian army seizes control of the Siachen glacier , an area where the
border isn't demarcated due to very harsh conditions. Pakistan attempts to
capture it back in the following decades
1990: the insurgency increases rapidly when India kills about 100
demonstrators at Gawakadal Bridge. India imposes Armed Forces Special
Powers Act ( AFSPA) in Jammu and Kashmir.
1990s: the insurgency continues with militant training in Pakistan and India
increasing its military presence by a large amount, as a result violence
increases against civilians.
1999: Another war breaks out as number of Pakistani soldiers and Kashmiri
militants infiltrated the Indian side of the Line of Control. After the
4
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
2011: Chief Minister Omar Abdullah announces amnesty for the 1200
young protesters who threw stones at the security forces previous year.
The India state Human Rights Commission confirms the presence of more
than 2000 unidentified bodies in unmarked graves near the line of control.
Three Pakistani soldiers killed in armed conflict with India along the line of
control.
Prime minister of Pakistan and India meet to try and limit the violence along
their borders in Kashmir
2014: India cancels talks with Pakistan, accusing Pakistan for interfering in
its internal affairs. Prime Minister Modi accuses Pakistan of waging a proxy
war against India. After a rise in violence along the borders in October,
Pakistan and India exchange strongly-worded warnings
2016: Burhan Mavi , a popular militant and top commander is killed by the
security forces , sparking violent protest. In July Authorities impose an
indefinite curfew in most parts of indian-admnistred Kashmir. During the
curfew 68 civilians and two security officials were killed, and more than
9000 people injured, the curfew was lifted in August after 50 days of
violence.
2019: Indian government strips Kashmir of its special status that gave it
extensive autonomy. Kashmir is currently placed under curfew, with no
internet or telecommunication services , and many political leaders have
been arrested, and thousands of people are being detained , and many are
missing.
Current Situation
6
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
restrictions imposed by India for the past about five months. Besides other
sectors of life, the nearly five-month-long Internet gag has critically hit the
ambulance service in dealing with emergencies and ferrying referral
patients from one place to another in occupied Kashmir.
The civilians in Pakistan administered Kashmir were anguished, and the JKLf
organized mass protests which intended to cross the de facto border in
order to provide humanitarian aid , but they were prevented from crossing
the LoC.
More than 4000 people have been arrested and 1000 of them remain under
custody since August 5.on September 29 , thousands rally for human rights
in Kashmir in New York. Prime Minister Imran Khan warns the international
committee of bloodbath in Kashmir, mentioning about the presence of
900,000 soldiers in the region. India’s Modi dodges mention of Kashmir in
UN speech. The US has also said that it wants India to quickly ease
restrictions imposed in Kashmir.
Nearly all of Pakistani Kashmir’s 3.5 million residents are Muslim, and
Chinese-controlled Aksai Chin is essentially uninhabited. Indian
administered Kashmir can be split into three main regions. The Kashmir
valley has 4 million residents, of which 95% are Muslim. However, 66% of
the 3 million residents of the southern region of Jammu are actually Hindu,
and in the less populated eastern region of Ladakh, 40% of the population is
Muslim while 40% is Buddhist. In proposing solutions to the conflict,
delegates must take into account the significant presence of non-Muslims
7
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
outside the Kashmir valley. They still play a significant role since the Indian
state of Jammu and Kashmir is one political entity.
Issues to Consider
The above information was necessary to frame the conflict, but since this is
not a war committee, we will not be debating the details of culpability for
this summers’ conflict. The following section details a few of the issues that
are within the scope of the UN and other international bodies. Successful
resolutions will address these issues creatively and effectively.
8
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
autonomy for the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir. Depending on the
interpretation of Article 370, there is scope for a broad devolution of
powers from the Indian central government to the Jammu and Kashmir
state authorities. In addition, many powers—for instance, of policing—
remain with the army in light of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act.
There is precedent for devolution of powers to autonomous regions in
other parts of the world, and delegates are urged to find inspiration there
for successful solutions.
Nuclear Weapons
9
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
One longtime sticking point, and one that the international community
continues to be interested in, is the question of what constitutes an
“acceptable” use of force by the Indian Army. India, for instance, accepts
10
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
pellet guns as a necessary peacekeeping tool because they do not kill but
only result in injury as a side effect of keeping the peace. However, many
inside and outside Kashmir are critical of the guns because they cause
permanent physical damage (particularly eye damage) and have been used
repeatedly on civilians. The Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) has
also been a longtime target of criticism because it essentially grants Indian
soldiers impunity. Amnesty International released a report in 2015 that
highlighted cases in which soldiers had not been prosecuted despite
accusations of murder, kidnapping, or rape. The report laid out several
recommendations, including that the AFSPA be repealed, that the Indian
military and civilian justice systems swiftly hold trials for the accused, that
information be made available to families on those who have disappeared,
and that India ratify and respect relevant international treaties. Depending
on country policy, delegates will likely support some combination of these
and should come up with creative ways to enable collaboration on this
issue with the Indian government.
Freedom of the press has been repeatedly curtailed during the insurgency.
During the summer 2016 unrest, security forces raided the main
newspapers in the valley and forced them to temporarily close.
Communication is also severely restricted in the valley from time to time—
during the recent unrest the Army suspended all mobile phone services in
the valley in an effort to prevent anti-government demonstrations. Both of
these actions are sources of severe criticism internationally, as international
law generally protects freedom of the press and assembly. In addition, most
Indian citizens can and do fully exercise these rights—India has a strong
tradition of a free and critical press, and mobile services are a core part of
11
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
Country Policy
12
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
India
In terms of the immediate border conflict with Pakistan, India declares that
the entire state of Jammu and Kashmir is a part of India. In response to
international calls for a plebiscite to decide the fate of the region, India
maintains that the continued participation of Kashmiri people in Indian
national elections amounts to recognition of Indian sovereignty. As a result,
any unrest in the region is considered an internal issue, so India is unlikely
to accept much international intervention (military, economic, or
otherwise) in the region. India also emphasizes that Chinese-controlled
Aksai Chin is part of India, and has long asked for negotiations with China to
establish a Line of Actual Control (de facto border) and prevent future
conflict.
Pakistan
China
Because of its conflict with India over Aksai Chin, China has generally
quietly sided with Pakistan in the border conflict—China and Pakistan
signed a deal that settled their own border dispute long ago. However,
China has long resisted agreeing to a Line of Actual Control (de facto
13
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
Russia and its allies also refrain from expressing an official policy on the
issue. However, Russia is a longtime military ally of India, and many of the
weapons and strategies in place on the Line of Control are originally
Russian. Given that Russia and its allies are generally more protective of
national sovereignty and give less legitimacy to international intervention
on the basis of human rights, they are also less likely to support active
intervention in Kashmir.
14
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
This region is primarily Muslim, and therefore is likely to support the rights
of Muslim Kashmiris. Most will advocate for a political solution such as the
long awaited referendum. Some may tacitly approve covert action—for
instance, it is suspected that some of the militant groups active on the
border are funded by citizens of the oil-rich Gulf States (UAE, Saudi Arabia,
Qatar, etc.).While support for Kashmiri independence is not as prominent a
cause across the Muslim world as, for instance, the fate of Palestine, it is
likely that in the case of a larger flare-up these countries would come to the
protestors’ aid.
While most other countries do not have a direct stake in the conflict, their
policy is likely to be influenced directly by the diplomatic and economic
relationships they have with India and Pakistan. As Indian economic growth
continues to impress, its diplomatic sway will increase as well. Given past
experiences with colonialism, most of this group of countries will likely be
wary of intrusive military interventions but should support peacekeeping
and diplomatic efforts. Important Terms, Documents, and Groups
· National sovereignty: The concept that ultimate power rests with the
sovereign state, and not with any region within it or with any international
body. India’s claim that the international community should not intervene
15
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
· Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA): Indian law that allows for
extensive military activities in Kashmir and bypasses many of the safeguards
and limitations that military forces are otherwise accountable for. Has been
criticized by the UN Human Rights Commission.
Still active in Pakistan; perhaps the only group capable of attacking India
directly.
· Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front (JKLF): One of the oldest and most
popular groups in Kashmir. Made up of Kashmiri Muslims, but uniquely
advocates a secular solution to the conflict. Supports an independent
Kashmir and opposes accession to Pakistan.
5. is there scope for greater Kashmiri autonomy within India, and if so, what
powers would be devolved to the state level?
17
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
Bibliography
2.
https://www.amnesty.org.in/images/uploads/articles/Kashmir_Report_We
b_version_(1).pdf.
4. "Who are the Kashmir militants?" BBC News. Last modified August 1,
2012. Accessed August 30, 2016. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-
18738906.
7. Times News Network. "What is Article 370? Three key points." Times
of India. Last modified May 28, 2014. Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/What-is-Article-
370Article370/articleshow/35678708.cms.
8. Lidarev, Ivan. "History's Hostage: China, India and the War of 1962."
The Diplomat. Last modified August 21, 2012. Accessed August 30, 2016.
18
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
http://thediplomat.com/2012/08/historys-hostage-china-indiaand-the-war-
of-1962/.
12. Pandita, Rahul. "Why the Return of Kashmiri Pandits Is Still a Distant
Dream." New York Times, June 3, 2013. Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/06/03/why-the-return-of-
kashmiripandits-is-still-a-distant-dream/?login=email&_r=0
15. Rafiq, Zahid. "Macchil fake encounter: life term for 5 Army men." The
Hindu, November 14, 2014.
http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/machil-fake-
encounter-seven-soldiers-sentenced-tolife-for-killing-three-kashmiri-
civilians/article6594347.ece?homepage=true.
19
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
16. Peer, Basharat. "Kashmir, and the Inheritance of Loss." Editorial. New
York Times, July 25, 2016. Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/25/opinion/kashmir-and-the-
inheritance-ofloss.html.
18. BBC News. "Kashmir clashes over militant Burhan Wani leave 30
dead." July 11, 2016. Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-36761527.
19. Tamin, Baba. "Pellet guns cause severe eye injuries in Kashmir." Al
Jazeera, July 13, 2016. Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/inpictures/2016/07/pellet-guns-
blinding-eye-injurieskashmir-160713083300883.html.
20. Dawn. "Waiting for the day Kashmir becomes Pakistan: Nawaz." July
22, 2016. http://www.dawn.com/news/1272477.
21. Lahore Agencies. "Hafiz Saeed leads Kashmir Caravan, vows to march
towards J&K." Hindustan Times, July 20, 2016. Accessed August 30, 2016.
22. "Pakistan." Geohive. Last modified 2016. Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://www.geohive.com/cntry/pakistan.aspx.
20
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
27. Krepon, Michael. "LOOKING BACK: The 1998 Indian and Pakistani
Nuclear Tests." Arms Control Association. Last modified June 11, 2008.
Accessed August 30, 2016.
https://www.armscontrol.org/act/2008_05/lookingback.
28. Weiss, Leonard. "India and the NPT." Strategic Analysis 34, no. 2
(March 2010). Accessed August 30, 2016.
https://fsi.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/Weiss_India_and_the_NPT.pdf.
29. "Who are the Kashmir militants?" BBC News. Last modified August 1,
2012. Accessed August 30, 2016. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-
18738906.
37. Humanitarian aid for the most vulnerable people of India affected by
the conflict in Jammu and Kashmir. 2004. Accessed August 30, 2016.
https://ec.europa.eu/echo/files/funding/decisions/2004/dec_india_01000.
pdf.
22
BVSMUNVI-SPECPOL STUDY GUIDE
38. de Jong, Kaz. "Conflict in the Indian Kashmir Valley II: psychosocial
impact." Conflict and Health 2, no. 11 (2008). Accessed August 30, 2016.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2577626/.
41. PTI. "Funds from Gulf Being Used for Radicalisation of Youths in
Kashmir: Officials." New Indian Express, April 24, 2016. Accessed August 30,
2016. http://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/Funds-From-GulfBeing-
Used-for-Radicalisation-of-Youths-in-Kashmir-
Officials/2016/04/24/article3397759.ece.
42.https://www.hofstra.edu/home/news/ur/modelun/modelun-
committee-specpol.html
43.https://www.bbc.com/news/world-south-asia-16069078
44. https://kmsnews.org/news/2019/12/24/iok-one-of-saddest-places-in-
world-report/
45. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/08/india-revokes-kashmir-
special-status-latest-updates-190806134011673.html
46. irc.princeton.edu/pmunc/docs/SPECPOL_FinalBG-1.pdf
23