This document compares three parameters used to analyze water quality: chemical oxygen demand (COD), biochemical oxygen demand (BOD5), and total organic carbon (TOC). COD uses strong chemical oxidants to measure organic compounds, providing rapid results but potential interference. BOD5 uses microorganisms to model natural degradation over 5 days, but requires proper conditions and is time-consuming. TOC directly measures total carbon and is fast, but does not indicate treatability and may overestimate load. Each method has advantages and disadvantages for different monitoring needs.
This document compares three parameters used to analyze water quality: chemical oxygen demand (COD), biochemical oxygen demand (BOD5), and total organic carbon (TOC). COD uses strong chemical oxidants to measure organic compounds, providing rapid results but potential interference. BOD5 uses microorganisms to model natural degradation over 5 days, but requires proper conditions and is time-consuming. TOC directly measures total carbon and is fast, but does not indicate treatability and may overestimate load. Each method has advantages and disadvantages for different monitoring needs.
This document compares three parameters used to analyze water quality: chemical oxygen demand (COD), biochemical oxygen demand (BOD5), and total organic carbon (TOC). COD uses strong chemical oxidants to measure organic compounds, providing rapid results but potential interference. BOD5 uses microorganisms to model natural degradation over 5 days, but requires proper conditions and is time-consuming. TOC directly measures total carbon and is fast, but does not indicate treatability and may overestimate load. Each method has advantages and disadvantages for different monitoring needs.
Oxidant Used K2Cr2O7 Oxidation by microorganisms O2
Mn2(SO4)3 K2S2O8 Heat Combination of the above with various catalysts Most Suitable Use Rapid and frequent monitoring of Modeling treatment plant process Measures amount of total of organic treatment plant efficiency and water and the effects organic compounds carbon in samples quality on the dissolved oxygen content of receiving waters Test Completion Time 1-1/2 to 3 hours 5 days (for standard BOD test) Several minutes to hours Advantages • Correlates with BOD on waste • Most closely models the natural • Correlates with BOD on waste with constant composition environment when used with the with constant composition, but not • Toxic materials do not affect proper “seed” as closely as COD oxidant • Short analysis time • Changes in the COD value between influent and effluent may parallel BOD content and supplement BOD results • Short analysis time Disadvantages • Interference from chloride ions • Toxic materials kill • Requires expensive equipment • Some organic compounds are not microorganisms • Some organic compounds are not oxidized completely • Microorganisms do not oxidize all oxidized completely materials present in waste • Measures Total Organic Carbon • Inaccuracies when used with and not oxygen demand improper “seed” • Lengthy test period
Source: Hach, “The Science of Chemical Oxygen Demand” Technical Information Series, Booklet No. 9, by Wayne Boyles.