Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract- Increasing implementation of renewable energy sources to be stored for use during periods of peak system
sources within power systems means that the use of energy demand [2].
storage technologies will be ever more important for system
stability and power quality purposes. A range of energy storage
technologies currently exist, ranging from low-power, short term B. Reducing the Risk of Power Blackouts
technologies such as capacitors to long-term high power systems Energy Storage Technologies are also employed for the
such as Pumped Hydro. Future developments such as the use of purpose of power fluctuation smoothing caused by sudden
Carbon Nanotube technology within super-capacitors look set to interruptions to supply or a sudden load change. In addition,
bring improvements in power density, efficiency and lifetime.
employment of energy storage technologies for provision of
Index Terms—Battery, Compressed Air Energy Storage long term back up power in the event of a large power outage
(CAES), Energy Storage, Flow Battery, Flywheel, Power or failure, such as the loss of a large conventional power
System, Pumped Hydro, Renewables, Supercapacitor,
generating unit or transmission line allows system security to
Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage (SMES).
be improved [3].
I. INTRODUCTION
C. Supply & Demand Matching
The drive to constantly increase the amount of electricity During periods when the power supply is greater than the
produced using natural & renewable sources (Wind etc.) system demand, energy storage technologies can be used to
which cannot be controlled in a way akin to traditional fossil store surplus electricity (ideally purchased at a low cost)
generation methods means that generation and grid control is which can then be released when power consumption exceeds
becoming ever more difficult and unpredictable to manage. the available supply (provided there is cost benefit) [3]. This
Energy Storage enables some of the control lost through the enables conventional base-load generating plants (coal, gas &
use of renewables to be recovered, allowing generation and oil etc.) which may not be designed to run at part-load or vary
demand requirements, along with grid performance to be their output in response to system demand fluctuations, to be
aligned and controlled more closely. set to run more-or-less continually at a level which provides
Within this paper, a review of a range of currently existing the greatest efficiency and cost benefit [4].
energy storage technologies will be presented. An insight into
to the importance of energy storage will be provided, before
III. COMPOSITION AND CLASSIFICATION OF ENERGY
an overview of a number of existing energy storage STORAGE SYSTEMS
technologies are detailed. A technical comparison between
different energy storage technologies will then be made, after Energy Storage Systems allow power to be taken from a
which, a discussion on the applications of energy storage source (such as the power grid), stored and then released back
technologies within power systems will be given. into the system as and when required [5]. The method used
for energy storage will differ depending on the technology
II. THE IMPORTANCE OF ENERGY STORAGE
being used; however, most energy storage systems will
Efficient and effective implementation of energy storage include the following four main components [5];
systems can provide numerous environmental, economic and Storage Medium (the device which will store the energy
technical benefits to energy supply systems. These include; until it is required)
Charging System: the method of allowing energy flow
A. Enabling of Renewable Power Generation from the external system into the storage medium
Renewable power generation technologies such as wind Discharging System: the method used to release stored
turbines provide a source of clean power. Their power supply energy back into the power system
is, however, highly erratic and very intermittent. An ever Control: Governing the operation of the storage system
increasing call by governments and world leaders to increase According to [3], energy storage systems can be broadly
renewable energy generation means this problem is likely to classified into three groups based upon their response
become ever more prevalent in the future [1]. Energy storage characteristics as follows; short term energy storage (seconds
technologies enable smoothing of the intermittent power to minutes) – used for power quality applications; long term
input associated with renewable energy sources, allowing energy storage (minutes to hours) – used for grid congestion
energy which is surplus at the time of supply from renewable management and frequency response; and real long term
VII. APPLICATIONS OF ENERGY STORAGE WITHIN POWER explains that connection of a supercapacitor energy storage
SYSTEMS system to the DC-link of a DFIG through a two quadrant
DC/DC converter (with additional control elements)
Energy Storage technologies such as those described provides a solution to achieve high levels of wind turbine
above can provide great benefit to electrical power integration into electical grids.
systems, enabling increased renewable source integration
and increased supply security and stability to be achieved B. Load Shifting
[14]. Some typical applications of energy storage systems Because renewable sources cannot be controlled with
to power systems are described in this section of the paper. the same level of accuracy or predictability of generation
methods such as fossil or nuclear power, their output does
A. Integration of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) not always coincide with the times of peak energy demand
One of the main uses for energy storage systems is to of the grid. This presents grid operators with numerous
increase the integration of RES such as wind and solar difficulties in terms of matching generation requirements
[14]. The intermittent nature of inputs from renewable with those of demand, and means that in some cases,
power sources can result in voltage and frequency generation can either exceed or fall short of consumer
fluctuations occurring within the grid, negatively affecting demand. Load shifting allows delivery of renewable
system stability [14]. As such voltage and frequency energy to be delayed from periods of non-peak demand to
fluctuations can occur very quickly and frequently, it is those of peak demand. Energy storage systems can store
necessary to employ energy storage technologies with high the renewable energy output during low demand periods
cycling lifetimes and short response times. and then release it into the grid at times of peak demand.
Supercapacitors, batteries (excluding conventional lead This helps to smooth excess grid demand and increase the
acid) and SMES are therefore particularly suited for this value of renewable energy sources. Energy storage
purpose [7]. According to [7], a widely accepted method technologies suitable for this purpose must be able to
for mitigation of the power fluctuations associated with operate and react in the region of several minutes and
DFIG wind turbines is to incorporate an energy storage several hours, therefore technologies such as CAES,
system within the DC link of the back-to-back converters Pumped Hydro and Flow batteries are considered to be
of the machine. This storage system will have a controller suitable for this purpose [8].
which interacts with the control system of the wind turbine
to optimize the overall net power flow to the grid. [23]
C. Transmission & Distribution Upgrade Deferral VIII. FUTURE ADVANCES AND DEVELOPMENTS IN
Transmission and Distribution (T&D) upgrade deferral ENERGY STORAGE TECHNOLOGY
refers to the delaying or deferring of upgrades to existing Since the earliest developments in energy storage
T&D infrastructure within a power system by installation technology, there have been numerous advances in the
of either a temporary or permanent EES downstream of the technology available for the storage of energy. Generally
overloaded T&D node [17]. T&D deferral allows the speaking, the effectiveness of an energy storage system
annual carrying charges for capital investment to be can be evaluated in terms of factors such as [25];
avoided, thus reducing the overall cost to ratepayers, Energy Density (Wh/kg)
improving asset utilisation and releasing capital for other Power Density (W/kg)
infrastructure projects [17]. Cycle Efficiency (%)
Self-Discharge Characteristics
D. Grid Black Start
Cycle lifespan (number of cycles)
In the event of a total grid power loss, it may be
Chronological lifecycle
necessary to restore power using a process known as black
Future developments in the technology associated with
start [12]. Energy storage systems can be used for this
energy storage systems will therefore be aimed at
purpose. For example, in power generating facilities,
improving such characteristics. Already, developments in
batteries can be used to provide a source of power to start a
the field of energy storage technology are producing very
diesel generator or similar device, which can then be used
promising results with respect to such characteristics.
to generate electrical power to supply auxiliary systems for
Advances in the development of carbon nanotubes are
a major generating unit, which can then supply power back
enabling a new generation of supercapacitors to be
to the grid.
developed. Using carbon nanotubes, it is predicted that a
supercapacitor having a one square centimetre conductive
E. Energy Arbitrage
plate will have a surface area of approximately 50000
Energy Arbitrage refers to the process of charging
square centimetres, compared with 2000 square
energy storage systems when energy demand and therefore
centimetres for a standard carbon based supercapacitor,
cost is low, before then discharging the energy storage
enhancing both the lifespan and storage capability of the
system back into the grid during periods of high demand
supercapacitor, with specific energies as high as an Ni-Cd
and cost, thus making a profit. Typically, Pumped Hydro
battery (60Wh/kg) being anticipated [26].
Storage (PHS) is used for this purpose due to the fact that
In the field of flywheel energy storage, the development
it can be built for large scale energy storage (+100MW)
of low-loss, high performance bearings and high
and used for discharge over a relatively long period of time
performance composite fibres is being investigated in
(up to several days). Compressed Air Energy Storage
order to bring improvements to factors such as device
(CAES) is another technology which can be implemented
reliability, manufacturing costs, storage capacity and
for this purpose, again due to the large capacities and
power density, making FES a more desirable EST [25].
relatively long discharge times which are possible [14].
Battery technology is also predicted to be the subject of
F. Voltage/VAR Support significant technical developments in the coming years.
Voltage/VAR support is an ancillary function provided Advanced lead-acid batteries, created by adding upto 40%
by system operators in order to assist in the maintaining of activated carbon to the negative electrode composition
grid system stability. Voltage/VAR support requires the will benefit from an increased cycling life (upto 2000 extra
supply or absorption of reactive power (VAR’s) in order to cycles) compared with exisiting designs. Coupled with low
maintain grid voltage within a specified range [17]. This costs, it is envisaged that this will again make lead-acid a
process has typically been carried out by power generators; realistic choice for battery storage systems [26]. Lithium
however the fact that reactive power cannot be effectively based cells are expected to benefit from improvements to
transmitted over long distances means that distributed electrodes, plates, current collectors and seals in the future,
energy storage systems could provide a realistic alternative complemented by improvements to processing and
[17]. Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) is a fabrication techniques [25]. Developments in technologies
technology which could potentially be used for this such as lithium-sulphur and lithium-sulphide cells are,
purpose. An example of BESS usage for Voltage support however, currently only being investigated by a small
is the experimental storage system produced by A123 number of organisations and will only be commercially
Corporation in California, having a capacity of possible provided the technology can compete in terms of
8MW/32MWh using Lithium-Ion Technology. This life cycle and expected cost considerations [25].
installation has been developed to provide improved Alongisde refinements to existing technology, new
renewable energy integration, alongside provision for technologies such as Gravity Power Module Energy
ancillary capabilities such as voltage support [24]. Storage (GPMES) are also predicted to play an increasing
role in future energy storage systems. GPMES uses two
water filled shafts, one wider than the other, connected at [6] X. Luo, J. Wang, M. Dooner and J. Clarke, “Overview of current
development in electrical energy storage technologies and the
both ends. Water is pumped through the smaller shaft, application potential in power system operation,” Applied Energy,
which in turn raises a high-weight piston situated in the vol. 137, pp. 511-536, 2015.
larger shaft - the reversal of this process allows the piston [7] F. Diaz-Gonzalez, A. Sumper, O. Gomis-Bellmunt and R.
Villafafila-Robles, “A review of energy storage technologies for
to force water to flow back through a pump and generate wind power applications,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy
power [18]. Additionally, the development of new Reviews, vol. 16, pp. 2154-2171, 2012.
technologies such as Mini-CAES and above ground CAES [8] T. Kousksou, P. Bruel, A. Jamil, T. E. Rhafiki and Y. Zeraouli,
“Energy Storage: Applications and Challenges,” Solar Energy
which have evolved from existing Compressed Air Energy Materials & Solar Cells, vol. 120, pp. 59-80, 2014.
Storage (CAES) are likely to allow increased usage of [9] P. J. Grbović, Ultra-Capacitors in Power Conversion Systems:
such technology, enabling some of the disadvantages of Applications, Analysis and Design from Theory to Practice,
exisitng CAES such as obtaining suitable operational sites Chichester: John Wiley and Sons, 2014.
[10] G. Ren, G. Ma and N. Cong, “Review of electrical energy storage
to be overcome [26]. system for vehicular applications,” Renewable and Sustainable
Energy Reviews, vol. 41, pp. 225-236, 2015.
IX. CONCLUSION [11] A. Chauhan and R. P. Saini, “A review on Integrated Renewable
Energy System based power generation for stand-alone
Numerous energy storage technologies are currently in applications: Configurations, storage options, sizing methodologies
existence. Some are now highly developed, with others and control,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 38,
still in their infancy. Existing energy storage technologies pp. 99-120, 2014.
[12] F. A. Bhuiyan and A. Yazdani, “Energy Storage Technologies for
allow energy to be stored in a variety of forms, for a Grid-Connected and Off-Grid Power System Applications,” in
variety of timescales, and with varying capacities. Electrical Power and Engineering Conference (EPEC), London,
Application of specific technologies differs, with ON, 2012.
technologies such as Supercapacitors and SMES being [13] H. Chen, T. N. Cong, W. Yang, C. Tan, Y. Li and Y. Ding,
“Progress in electrical energy storage system: A critical review,”
suitable for short-period, fast response applications, and Progress in Natural Science, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 291-312, 2009.
technologies including CAES and PHS being more suited [14] S. Vazquez, S. M. Lukic, E. Galvan , L. G. Franquelo and J. M.
to long term, long discharge applications. Increased use of Carrasco, “Energy Storage Systems for Transport and Grid
Applications,” IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL
intermittent energy sources such as wind and solar will act ELECTRONICS, vol. 57, no. 12, pp. 3881-3895, 2010.
as a stimulus for increased energy storage implementation [15] A. Castillo and D. F. Gayme, “Grid-scale energy storage
within power systems. The correct application of energy applications in renewable energy integration: A Survey,” Energy
Conversion and Management, vol. 87, pp. 885-894, 2014.
storage technologies within power systems allows the [16] R. B. Schainker, “Executive Overview: energy storage options for a
potential of renewable energy sources to be realised to a sustainable energy future,” in Power Engineering Society General
greater extent, enabling disadvantages such as voltage and Meeting, Denver, CO, 2004.
[17] N. Bhatnagar and B. Venkatesh, “Energy Storage and Power
frequency fluctuation and mismatching of supply and Systems,” in IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and
demand peaks to be reduced, with grid stability being Computer Engineering (CCECE), Montreal, QC, 2012.
increased as a result. Future developments in energy [18] P. Medina, A. W. Bizuayehu, J. P. S. Catalao, E. M. G. Rodrigues
and J. Contreras, “Electrical Energy Storage Systems: Technologies'
storage technology such as the application of Carbon State-of-the-Art, Techno-economic Benefits and Applications
Nanotube technology to Supercapacitor design and the Analysis,” in 47th Hawaii International Conference on System
introduction of low-loss bearings for flywheel systems Sciences (HICSS), Waikoloa, HI, 2014.
[19] B. R. Alamri and A. R. Alamri, “Technical review of energy storage
look set to bring further improvements in terms of device technologies when integrated with intermittent renewable energy,”
efficiency, energy density and extended component in International Conference on Sustainable Power Generation and
lifecycles. Supply (SUPERGEN), Nanjing, 2009.
[20] A. Poullikkas, “A Comparative Overview of Large-Scale battery
REFERENCES systems for electricity storage,” Renewable and Sustainable energy
reviews, vol. 27, pp. 778-788, 2013.
[1] T. M. Mahlia, T. J. Saktisahdan, A. Jannifar, M. H. Hasan and H. S. [21] Z. Zhou, M. Benbouzid, J. F. Charpentier, F. Scuiller and T. Tang,
Matseelar, “A review of available methods and development on “A review of energy storage technologies for marine current energy
energy storage; technology update,” Renewable and Sustainable systems,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 18, pp.
Energy Reviews, vol. 33, pp. 532-545, 2014. 390-400, 2013.
[2] G. Coppez, S. Chowdhury and S. P. Chowdhury, “The Importance [22] H. Liu and J. Jiang, “Flywheel Energy Storage - An upswing
of Energy Storage in Renewable Power Generation: A Review,” in technology for energy sustainability,” Energy and Buildings, vol.
45th International Universities Power Engineering Conference 39, pp. 599-604, 2007.
(UPEC), Cardiff, 2010. [23] L. Qu and W. Qiao, “Constant Power Control of DFIG Wind
[3] T. M. Masaud, K. Lee and P. K. Sen, “An Overview of Energy Turbines With Supercapacitor Energy Storage,” IEEE Transactions
Storage Technologies in Electric Power Systems: What is the on Industry Applications, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. 359-367, 2011.
future?,” in North American Power Symposium (NAPS), Arlington, [24] A. Saez-de-Ibarra, A. Milo, H. Gaztanaga, I. Etxeberria-Otadui, P.
TX, 2010. Rodriguez, S. Bacha and V. Debusschere, “Analysis and
[4] E. M. G. Rodrigues, R. Godina, S. F. Santos, A. W. Bizuayehu and comparison of battery energy storage technologies for grid
J. Contreras, “Energy storage systems supporting increased applications,” in IEEE Grenoble PowerTech (POWERTECH),
penetration of renewables in islanded systems,” Energy, vol. 75, pp. Grenoble, 2013.
265-280, 2014. [25] J. Baker, “New technology and possible advances in energy
[5] D. O. Akinyele and R. K. Rayudu, “Review of energy storage storage,” Energy Policy, vol. 36, no. 12, pp. 4368-4373, 2008.
technologies for sustainable power networks,” Sustainable Energy [26] X. Tan, Q. LI and H. Wang, “Advances and trends of energy
Technologies and Assessments, vol. 8, pp. 74-91, 2014. storage technology in Microgrid,” Electrical Energy and Power
Systems, vol. 44, pp. 179-191, 2013.