Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Springer is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to GeoJournal
Land Reclam
Macau
ABSTRACT: The spatial and temporal significance of land reclamation from the sea in
relation to the development of the three SE Asian small coastal territories of Singapore,
Hong Kong and Macau are examined and compared. In all three territories the rate of
reclamation has been an index of the rate of economic development. Four phases of land
reclamation are identified: (1) pre-1900: involved relatively unplanned and uncostly projects
in shallow water and swamplands around the main focus of settlement; (2) 1900-1945:
involved military projects outside the main settlement core; (3) 1945-1980: this phase of
large-scale projects unconstrained by natural conditions because of advances in technology
and high rate of reclamation was driven by rapid industrial and population growth; (4) 1980
to date: a period marked by large infrastructure projects designed to maintain and extend
the status of the territories as world economic and commercial centres. Currently 10%, 5%
and 33% of the total land surfaces of Singapore, Hong Kong and Macau respectively
comprise land reclaimed from the sea and these proportions will continue to rise.
Paradise" (Heineberg domain. In this respect at least the extent 1986, of further p
Singapore, which reclamation is beingnow set. In the knowledge
has of thesethe h
Asia. The scale absoluteof land
limits, the government has for areclama
long time been
be understood as
considering a
a meaningful response
optimal land-use strategy. to
population growth Since 1961, a total
andof around 5400 theha new land has
associ
activity thereby been reclaimed at set in
a total cost of around motion
4.25 m Singapore
correlations (at Dollars. By 1991 around
the 99 10% of its
% land surface
significwill
the terms of constitutetrade reclaimed land and (Wong 1985).the In the near size
hand and thefuture, area the governmentreclaimed
is planning to increase the land o
time, the World area of Singapore by a further 15%. Ifclassifie
Bank and when this
aspiring threshold new program is completed,
lands. the total area of Singapore
During the 1980swill be around 25% the greater than inpace 1967. The new of d
considerably.project In will for recent years,
the first time involve the infilling of sea
the north coast areas 15 m have
deep, while previous reclamation work has
been dyk
initate land-infilling been confined to areas lessprocesses.
than 10 m deep. The total T
of shallow coastal waters
surface area of Singapore reached 626 km2 by 1989. and This s
Ris and Jalan Kayu will be completed by 1992 (Hoe expansion in the land area mirrors, in later times at least,
1988). These measures have, however, led to ecological economic development. Singapore ranks today amongst
damage, which has had consequences in the political the world's top five commercial centres and top ten world
Fig 2
Land reclamation history of northern
Hong Kong island, the Kowloon
peninsula and the southern New
Territories up to 1990
centres, if one bases the calculation on the number of Victoria Harbour (Fig 2). By 1855 they had doubled the
multinational concerns, the banking importance and theland area of their companies' sites in this way. The
number of international organizations (Helle 1989, p. Ordinance of 1842, which prohibited such reclamation, in
165). fact constituted no barrier to it. After reclamation, the
owners commenced construction of warehouses. The
coast at Victoria, the core settlement of the colony,
Land Reclamation in Hong Kong (Fig 2) underwent significant change within a very short time-
span: by 1855 the shallow water zone had almost
A major reason for reclamation of land from the sea disappeared, the coastline had advanced by an average of
in Hong Kong throughout its history has been its 100 m and exhibited a sharply irregular plan-form. At the
mountainous topography. Both Victoria, the capital onsame time, the first measures to drain the swampland
Hong Kong Island, and Kowloon on the mainland are areas W and E of Victoria (at West Point and Happy
hemmed in by hills reaching over 900 m in altitude andValley respectively) were also carried out for disease and
Hong Kong has only been able to expand into the sea hygiene reasons. The first government infilling operations
(Hong Kong Government 1964). Although the commenced in 1852 on Bonham Strand in the W part of
acquisition of the New Territories in 1898 included some Victoria. In doing this they used the debris produced by
significant stretches of flatter land close to the Chinesea fire as infill material.
border, until the last two decades the leasehold nature of The accelerated growth of the town's population as a
the land and Chinese political uncertainties largely ruledresult of migration from the Chinese mainland resulted in
out this land for largescale industrial, commercial and the second land reclamation phase. In 1868, a 825 m long
urban development. embankment was built between Bonham Strand West and
As in Singapore, the first phase of land reclamation Wilmer Street in the W part of Victoria and the area
began shortly after the founding of Hong Kong in 1841. landward of it was filled in. These measures was carried
The bodies responsible were the various trading out by both the Public Works Department and private
companies which extended their land abutting the concerns. By 1873 the coastline lay along what is now
coastline northwards across the shallow water zone into Des Voeux Road. Further infilling followed around the
commercial centres and as a consequece co-operation what extent land changes and land reclamation measures
with the neighbouring industrial and commercial can be included as an indicator of economic growth in
hinterland assumed greater importance. economic geography studies. In the opinion of the
Land development and reclamation measures are a authors, inclusion of the indicator must in very great
very clear indication of the dynamic development of thesemeasure take into consideration a genetic and strategic
three small territories. This fact has surprisingly notmeaning. The smallness of territories cannot in every case
previously been given attention in "spatial and hence also be considered a development problem, in contrast to
land-orientated" geographical science. It remains open to what Buchholz (1987) has suggested.