Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Summary

    Uploaded by

    nabil
    6 views4 pages
    The document shows the results of 5 algorithms (A1-A5) on 5 datasets (DC1-DC5) for 3 evaluation metrics (F1, F2, F3). Algorithm A1 (MEMETIC with a state-of-the-art approach) generally performed best or second best across the datasets and metrics, followed by Algorithm A2 (a threshold approach). Algorithm A3 (MEMETIC with a clever approach) performed best for metric F3. The ant colony optimization approaches (A4 and A5) tended to rank lower.

    Original Description:

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document shows the results of 5 algorithms (A1-A5) on 5 datasets (DC1-DC5) for 3 evaluation metrics (F1, F2, F3). Algorithm A1 (MEMETIC with a state-of-the-art approach) generally performed best or second best across the datasets and metrics, followed by Algorithm A2 (a threshold approach). Algorithm A3 (MEMETIC with a clever approach) performed best for metric F3. The ant colony optimization approaches (A4 and A5) tended to rank lower.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    6 views4 pages

    Summary

    Uploaded by

    nabil
    The document shows the results of 5 algorithms (A1-A5) on 5 datasets (DC1-DC5) for 3 evaluation metrics (F1, F2, F3). Algorithm A1 (MEMETIC with a state-of-the-art approach) generally performed best or second best across the datasets and metrics, followed by Algorithm A2 (a threshold approach). Algorithm A3 (MEMETIC with a clever approach) performed best for metric F3. The ant colony optimization approaches (A4 and A5) tended to rank lower.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 4

    DC1 DC2 DC3

    A1 (MEMETIC+state of art) 0.839 0.944 1.003


    A2 (threshold) 0.841 0.946 1.002
    F1 A3 (MEMETIC+clever) 0.779 0.866 0.926
    A4 (ACO+state of art) 0.773 0.956 1.029
    A5 (ACO+clever) 0.769 0.946 1.024

    A1 (MEMETIC+state of art) 1.029 1.138 1.208


    A2 (threshold) 1.036 1.143 1.214
    F2 A3 (MEMETIC+clever) 1.006 1.102 1.163
    A4 (ACO+state of art) 0.936 1.280 1.552
    A5 (ACO+clever) 0.938 1.307 1.496

    A1 (MEMETIC+state of art) 0.691 0.798 0.830


    A2 (threshold) 0.690 0.763 0.808
    F3 A3 (MEMETIC+clever) 0.546 0.613 0.653
    A4 (ACO+state of art) 0.633 0.809 0.848
    A5 (ACO+clever) 0.645 0.809 0.842
    DC4 DC5 Ranking
    1.007 1.039 2nd
    1.003 1.037 3rd
    0.918 0.963 1st F1
    1.034 1.111 5th
    1.031 1.096 4th

    1.224 1.252 2nd


    1.226 1.256 3rd
    1.183 1.205 1st F2
    1.568 1.771 5th
    1.508 1.658 4th

    0.806 0.839 3rd


    0.785 0.820 2nd
    0.586 0.648 1st F3
    0.861 0.894 5th
    0.855 0.853 4th
    DC1 DC2 DC3 DC4
    A1 (MEMETIC+state of art) 8.34326579261 8.26271186441 7.67696909272 8.83813306852
    A2 (threshold) 8.56123662307 8.45665961945 7.58483033932 8.47457627119
    A3 (MEMETIC+clever) 1.2836970475 0 0 0
    A4 (ACO+state of art) 0.51746442432 9.41422594142 10.009718173 11.2185686654
    A5 (ACO+clever) 0 8.45665961945 9.5703125 10.9602327837

    A1 (MEMETIC+state of art) 9.03790087464 3.16344463972 3.725165562914 3.34967320261


    A2 (threshold) 9.65250965251 3.58705161855 4.200988467875 3.50734094617
    A3 (MEMETIC+clever) 6.95825049702 0 0 0
    A4 (ACO+state of art) 0 13.90625 25.06443298969 24.5535714286
    A5 (ACO+clever) 0.2132196162 15.6847742923 22.25935828877 21.5517241379

    A1 (MEMETIC+state of art) 20.984081042 23.1829573935 ### 27.2952853598


    A2 (threshold) 20.8695652174 19.6592398427 ### 25.3503184713
    A3 (MEMETIC+clever) 0 0 0 0
    A4 (ACO+state of art) 13.7440758294 24.2274412855 ### 31.9396051103
    A5 (ACO+clever) 15.3488372093 24.2274412855 ### 31.4619883041
    DC5 Ranking
    7.31472569779 2nd
    7.13596914176 3rd
    0 1st
    13.3213321332 5th
    12.1350364964 4th

    3.75399361022 2nd
    4.06050955414 3rd
    0 1st
    31.9593450028 5th
    27.3220747889 4th

    22.7651966627 3rd
    20.9756097561 2nd
    0 1st
    27.5167785235 5th
    24.0328253224 4th

    You might also like