Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PHARMA
SUPPLY
CHAIN
HEALTH CHECK
SM
B
BULKING UP
TO COMPETE
S
SP EC IA L RE PO RT
FLORIDA
CLEAR SAILING FOR LOGISTICS
INCENTIVES
POWERING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
END-TO-END
VISIBILITY,
DELIVERED.
Get up-to-the-second insights
to boost your supply chain.
Anytime. Anywhere.
Hub Group puts the power of
industry-leading technology
in your hands, enabling you
to drive smarter business
decisions.
hubgroup.com/visibility
Info SNACKS
BITE-SIZED SUPPLY CHAIN / LOGISTICS INFORMATION
E ARLY-STAGE TURNOVER
IN OV ERDRIV E
4.2%
Supply chain professionals’ average base salary
increase in 2018, up from a reported 3% pay raise
75%
in 2017.
OF CONSUMERS
18% higher
Median salaries of supply chain professionals
expect same-day delivery who hold one certification over those who are
from all retail brands in the not certified.
next 12 months.
– 2019 Supply Chain Salary and Career Survey Report,
– ElasticPath, The SciFi Association for Supply Chain Management
Shopper report
50
CPG brands tackle
e-commerce
38 54 Rx for pharma
fulfillment
SMBs AND E-COMMERCE: SPONSORED
INCENTIVES POWER
DEVELOPING THE MUSCLE
TO SUCCEED ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Energy, tax, and land incentives
60
SPONSORED
Smaller retailers have a tough time
competing with the giants. But by juice logistics projects. Here’s how FLORIDA: CLEAR SAILING
pumping up their supply chains, they spark site selection decisions
In the Sunshine State, it’s the water
pint-sized businesses can take on and drive economic development.
that really counts for logistics
the behemoths. providers. Find out how Florida’s
44
waterway advantages and other
assets combine to make the state’s
logistics forecast perennially sunny.
CPG BRANDS FIND
THEIR PLACE ONLINE
Consumer-packaged goods (CPG)
brands large and small get creative
to meet the needs of evolving
customers who crave product
information, access, and near-
instant gratification.
Energizing
logistics
projects
54
With Old Dominion, your time-sensitive shipments will arrive on time and in full to meet shrinking
retail delivery windows. Our Must Arrive By Date (MABD) service is supported by our industry-
leading on-time record and low claims ratio. Let us help strengthen your retail partnerships, protect
your vendor scorecard and deliver value in every shipment. OD provides 100% door-to-door visibility
with a Customer Service Representative as your single point of contact.
Old Dominion Freight Line, the Old Dominion logo, OD Household Services, and Helping The World Keep Promises
are registered service marks of Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc. ©2019 Old Dominion Freight Line, Inc.
CONTENTS
AUGUST 2019 | VOL. 39 | NO. 8
10
GOOD QUESTION
INFOCUS How can brick-and- INPRACTICE
1 INFO SNACKS
mortar retailers 18 LEADERSHIP
16 VERTICAL FOCUS: Michelle Dilley, COO of DSC
APPAREL compete with Amazon? Logistics, energizes her company
23 NOTED by challenging the status quo,
standing her ground, and
26 TAKEAWAYS allowing her team to make
74 PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT: mistakes.
FULFILLMENT INNOVATIONS
32 SPONSORED
76 IN BRIEF
80 LAST MILE
INSIGHT THOUGHT LEADERS
M&A: what you need to know...32
Back-to-school supply chain 8 CHECKING IN EFW’s net promoter score
I was a shipment at Disney. program measures customer
satisfaction...33
12 DIALOG
The ongoing conversation 34 3PL LINE
Choosing a 3PL: How to make a
14 10 TIPS mature decision
Selecting a TMS
36 IT MATTERS
30 SPONSORED Blockchain-as-a-service: building
KNOWLEDGE BASE transparent supply chains for all
The top three logistics
challenges for the rest of
2019...30
Carrier relationships: core INFO
carrier, long term, or bid?...31
68 WEB_CITE CITY
72 SUPPLY CHAIN INSIGHTS
78 SUPPLY CHAIN
SOLUTIONS 20 READER PROFILE
74
79 RESOURCE CENTER Debbie Lentz, president
of global supply chain for
Fulfillment Electrocomponents plc, reveals
dynamos why you should leave your ego
at the door, be transparent with
your team members, and go with
the flow.
School
supplies in
peak demand
80
Inbound Logistics (ISSN 0888-8493, USPS 703990) is mailed monthly to approximately 60,000 business professionals who buy, specify, or recommend logistics technology, transportation, and related
services, by Thomas Publishing Company LLC, 5 Penn Plaza, NY, NY 10001. José E. Andrade, co-chairman; Carl T. Holst-Knudsen, co-chairman. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY, and additional mailing
offices. All rights reserved. The publisher accepts no responsibility for the validity of claims of any products or services described. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by
any electronic means, or stored in any information retrieval system, without permission from the publisher. POSTMASTER SEND ADDRESS CHANGES TO: Inbound Logistics, 5 Penn Plaza, New York, NY 10001
D C A S
O
DECISION SUPPORT
P
TOOLS
CITY shipments. Find out how your supply chain stands to benefit.
bit.ly/geocodingSC
The most comprehensive
online directory of
supply chain websites— HOW SMB WAREHOUSES FIND A
organized by category,
cross-referenced, and CAN RAMP UP AGILITY TRUCKING COMPANY
fully searchable. bit.ly/truck-DST
Warehouses need to be more
bit.ly/IL_WCC
configurable and adaptive to respond to
e-commerce demands. Here’s how small
and mid-sized businesses can make
their warehouse operations more agile.
bit.ly/speedupyourDC
FIND A LOGISTICS IT
PROVIDER
Walt Disney World.” The technology tracks you from origin to destination. It also DIGITAL DESIGN Amy Palmisano
MANAGER apalmisano@inboundlogistics.com
keeps all your data from this visit so you can enjoy all the benefits IoT and big PUBLICATION MANAGER Sonia Casiano
data can deliver for your future visits. sonia@inboundlogistics.com
MARKETING & SALES Ivana Thomson
Given the crowds, I know Disney designed this technology to offer the best ASSISTANT ithomson@inboundlogistics.com
experience possible. But from a logistics perspective, I kept comparing each of CIRCULATION DIRECTOR Carolyn Smolin
my touch points to what a shipment in today’s supply chain might “experience.” EDITOR AT LARGE Rena Behar
Visibility. With the app, wait times at all the attractions are available real time. SALES OFFICES
Real-time tracking. The long-range RFID allows attractions you visit to PUBLISHER: Keith Biondo
welcome you by name. The kids I was with thought seeing their names on the 212-629-1560 • FAX: 212-629-1565
attraction was “awesome,” but I felt a little weird. Using big data, the Disney folks publisher@inboundlogistics.com
know in advance where people are heading so they can staff accordingly. WEST/MIDWEST/SOUTHWEST: Harold L. Leddy
847-446-8764 • FAX: 847-305-5890
Routing. The smartphone app, which it seemed everyone was using, displays haroldleddy@inboundlogistics.com
your location and routing on an interactive map. The mission? To quickly get you Marshall Leddy
to the attraction you want in a massively expanded and crowded venue. 612-234-7436 • FAX: 847-305-5890
marshall@inboundlogistics.com
TMS. The FastPass routes visitors to a special entrance, skipping long attraction
SOUTHEAST: Gordon H. Harper
lines. Can’t do that without the app! And the MagicBand clears you for entry. 404-229-9691 • FAX: 404-355-2036
Merge in transit. If everyone opens the app on their smartphone, you can south@inboundlogistics.com
see your location and so can others in your party, letting your group identify the MIDWEST/ECO DEV: Joseph Biondo
SIMPLE SORTING
CUSTOM FILTERS Sort your shipments by
Filter your search shipper, consignee, status,
results by date received, or Lynden company.
consignee, or shipper.
VIEW DOCUMENTS
View and email documents
STAY ALERT
like bills of lading, delivery Receive shipment status
receipts, and invoices. updates via email by
clicking on the alerts icon.
@ILMagazine inboundlogistics.com/cms/podcast
DROP US A LINE:
editorial@inboundlogistics.com
Fast
TAKE The subject of a driver shortage has been discussed for years. Yet I cannot remember
a time when I could not move product from point A to B for a sustained amount of
time. A day or two? Perhaps. Even then, if I really wanted to move something, I could get it moved but at
a very high cost. If the demand is there, the supply will be. The price of cargo transport will—and has—
gone up when we collectively pump out more product. Trucks will eventually drive autonomously, taking
away driver jobs and turning the driver shortage discussion upside down.
When all is said and done, we will continue to move product, mark my words.
—Lee Milton
Global Account Executive
Crane Worldwide LLC
Re. Good Question: Re. 10 Tips: Leveraging IoT in the Supply Chain
What’s the quickest way to bit.ly/leveraging_IoT
improve return logistics?
bit.ly/returnlogisticstips Dynamic flexibility and agility of the network will
be key in shipping goods as many distribution hubs
Successful companies will be those that can are now running near capacity and becoming more
deliver relevance at scale by improving the sensitive to disruptions.
quality of consumer insights. If products While new software tools and technologies,
don’t meet shoppers’ expectations, they’ll be including Internet of Things (IoT) sensors, machine
returned instantly. learning, artificial intelligence, and new techniques of
—Mohammed (Mo) Hajibashi optimization under uncertainty (OUU) are now available,
Managing Director and Supply Chain
Global Consulting Lead, Accenture
these models have no concept of causation and only look at correlations present in
vast amounts of historical data.
What is required is a holistic solution, using IoT data infrastructure, computer
On average, retail returns are high, hovering
vision sensors, and package scan data to better observe and estimate the current
anywhere from 20% to more than 30%.
system state, and new kinds of optimization models that can provide rolling
Managing these returns is expensive but by
adjustments in response to early signals. The solution should provide rolling
investing in a good returns management
forecasts of demand, disruption, weather, resource availability, asset failure
system, operations costs can be kept down.
prediction, etc.
The system can also help route and determine
The next generation of logistics technology will give retailers and manufacturers
what goods should be discarded or destroyed,
the ability to design and operate networks with an optimal tradeoff between cost
can be resold in stores, online, or to a
efficiency and robustness to disruption by leveraging IoT and building networks
third party.
that can adjust proactively.
—Paul Steiner
—Amit Shah
Vice President, Strategic Analysis
Vice President, Enterprise Analytics and IoT
Spend Management Experts
Nokia
1 FORM A DIVERSE
SELECTION COMMITTEE. 6 AVOID MODIFYING
YOUR SYSTEM. 8 DON’T (NECESSARILY)
PURCHASE THE
HELPDESK.
Select young and old, men and women, team members. Few systems do exactly
what you want, but Consider purchasing the
Include finance, operations, and safety in the decision- modifications are helpdesk for the first
making, not only for buy-in, but to make sure your huge expensive and you year, but it may be less
investment works for the entire organization. typically must pay to expensive to pay hourly.
port them to each new Price it out. In your
upgrade. Purchase a TMS organization, have one
2 SELECT A FORWARD-
THINKING AND
CONNECTED TMS PARTNER.
4 INVEST LIBERALLY IN
YOUR NEW SYSTEM.
that you can use as is or
modify your process to
or two super-users who
can be the last line of
In 2010, when it was a work with the TMS. defense before contacting
EDI is essential, but $7.5-million company, your TMS provider and
that’s the past. APIs and
blockchain are the future.
Atlantic Logistics invested
$125,000 in a new TMS. 7 CHECK SUPPLIER
REFERENCES.
incurring billable hours.
3 THINK ABOUT
ALL YOUR MODES.
ON MODULES.
Most systems offer a base
and migration costs,
and how long it takes to
Consider truckload, LTL, implement.
package and a plethora
drayage, air, multinational, of add-on modules.
and intermodal. Many Start small then expand
TMS solutions work well
10
when you can fully utilize INVEST IN TRAINING
in some modes; few work the extra power. Price FOR YOUR TEAM.
well in all modes. Make the add-ons initially so
sure that the system you know what your You can have the best tool, but unless your team knows
you choose meets your future expenditures will how to operate and utilize all the features, you are
core competencies and be. Ask for discounts if
does not hamper future squandering your investment. Be curious, explore, and
you purchase multiple
expansion. packages; prices are not learn the system well.
set in stone.
SOURCE: ROBERT HOOPER, CEO, ATLANTIC LOGISTICS
14 Inbound Logistics • August 2019
65
of retailers are unable to
track inventory through
their supply chain.
888-878-1177 sclogistics.com/inventory
VERTICAL
FOCUS
APPAREL
IT’S ALL IN THE JEANS
SIZING UP Once recognized as the go-to fashion
T H E A P PA R E L M A R K E T choice for nearly every occasion, jeans are
steadily taking up less room in consumers’
40%
OF ALL APPAREL SOLD
closets. Denim sales in the United States have
declined by nearly 14% over the past four
IN THE UNITED STATES IS years, reports The Wall Street Journal.
IMPORTED FROM CHINA No longer solely focused on aesthetics,
apparel consumers are now looking for eco-friendly clothing sourced from
$2,000 transparent, ethical supply chains. It will be interesting to see how denim brands
APPROXIMATE AMOUNT restructure their sustainable sourcing approaches to meet consumer needs.
AMERICANS SPEND ON APPAREL
EVERY YEAR J.Crew, for example, limits its inventory to products that come solely from
sustainable suppliers. Primark recently debuted a line of jeans made from organic
$340 billion
TOTAL RETAIL VALUE OF THE
cotton supplied by a sustainable sourcing program based in India.
Other apparel companies are less interested in sustainability and more focused on
LUXURY APPAREL MARKET keeping pace with athleisure brands such as Lululemon and Athleta, which continue
to attract dedicated customers. In 2017, imports of women’s elastic knit pants
$3 trillion
TOTAL VALUE OF THE GLOBAL
exceeded those of blue jeans, according to U.S. Census data, driving denim brands to
incorporate elements of comfort into their jeans.
TEXTILE INDUSTRY American Eagle and Levi’s, for example, are adding more stretch to their jean
designs in an attempt to gain favor with comfort-focused consumers. Although this
change will require the retailers to reconfigure their current sourcing methods,
shoppers looking for an easy fit will likely welcome the effort.
SOURCES: INKXE.COM,
STUDY.COM
The Transformer
Michelle Dilley was a 16-year supply chain veteran when
she realized she wanted to stay in this field for good. Her
Michelle Dilley revelation came after she left her job as a sourcing general
Chief Operating Officer, manager at Whirlpool to join health care provider Ascension
DSC Logistics
Health as vice president, supply chain.
“My role was to drive a major transformation initiative, from
how we did sourcing, procurement, and supplier qualification,
all the way through managing inventory, fulfillment, and
payment,” Dilley says. “It was a true end-to-end perspective.
I loved partnering with people to work toward eliminating
inefficiencies and waste up and down the supply chain.”
In February 2019, Dilley was named chief operating
officer at DSC Logistics, a CJ Logistics company, based in
Des Plaines, Illinois. Dilley had served as chief supply chain
transformation officer at DSC since 2017. She spoke with us
about her career development and recent activities.
by Merrill Douglas IL: What’s one experience early in your career that helped to
shape you as a leader?
I had a boss who wouldn’t allow me to move into a new role
that was going to help me expand my skill set. That taught
me to put people first. Think about their personal needs and
growth opportunities and fully support them. You’ll always find
a way to work through the organizational impact.
IL: Have you ever made a mistake that taught you such a
valuable lesson you’re actually glad you made it?
It happened early in my career, when I was doing financial
forecasting. We were working on a tight deadline with a lot
of data, using Excel spreadsheets. I trusted the information I
was getting. But then I discovered we were missing some data,
and as a result we had made some significant misforecasts,
Electrocomponents plc, an
industrial and electronic
products provider.
Debbie Lentz Answers the Big Questions
RESPONSIBILITIES: Global
distribution oversight, including
1 What’s a principle you try to
live by?
As you rise, you must lift. My job and my
3 How would you describe your job
to a five-year-old?
I ship stuff.
distribution centers, transportation,
inventory, export and import trade passion is to lift others, and especially
4
compliance, and pricing. women in business and supply chain Do you have
E XPERIENCE: Senior vp, chief
supply chain officer, Toys R Us.
who are around me. It’s something I’m any heroes?
Various executive-level positions very proud of. My parents. We were very typical
with Kraft Foods, including senior middle class people. They developed a
2
vp, customer service and logistics
with Kraft Foods North America;
If you had $1 million to start a wonderful family life for their children,
vp, manufacturing operations, new venture, what would you do? and now their grandchildren. They
coffee and vp customer service and I would help educate young girls in created the environment that laid the
logistics with Kraft Europe. Also
senior director, logistics operations
emerging countries and look for a foundation for my life and career.
and customer logistics at Nabisco. way to deliver water for villages. Then
EDUCATION: MBA, Operations
Management and Labor Relations,
University of Scranton, 1988; B.S.,
they wouldn’t have to walk 20 miles
a day to get water, instead of getting
an education.
5 What would you tell your
18-year-old self?
Go for it.
Business Logistics, Penn State, 1983.
and CEO at the time were closely change management team had sole be fun, but wanted to do something
watching the project. responsibility to work on operational different. No one knew supply chain or
That project definitely pushed me readiness throughout the company. logistics back then, so it was a fit.
out of my comfort zone. It was a real Also, you need to let people know Today, supply chain has evolved from
moment for leadership, but also for the things you want to do. Before my an emerging function, to a cost center,
significant career development. transfer to Zurich, I was fairly transparent to the C suite, reporting to the CEO. I’m
Because SAP changes the way people in terms of my desire to live and work at the executive table and a member of a
work, the organizational readiness for abroad. I was afforded that opportunity board of directors. Executives and boards
change management—for transforming and it was great. have realized that supply chain is critical
the way people work and interact with I didn’t go to college to be a supply to the success of a company.
each other—was probably the most chain major. I was a business major, It’s about delighting customers with
important aspect of the project, because but I realized that accounting was a exceptional service and value-added
it holds the biggest risk for failure. A little boring. I thought marketing would solutions and doing it efficiently. n
asi_halfpgIL_0819_final_• 7/27/19 1:40 PM Page 1
• Ace Hardware, which owns Q Kottke Trucking, a refrigerated, dry freight, and dedicated
and operates more than 5,000 services carrier, acquired Wayne T. Fellows, a trucking
stores worldwide, deployed the company focused on refrigerated less-than-truckload and
CBX Software Cloud Platform truckload services.
to streamline global product
development, sourcing operations, Q A&R Logistics, a provider of dry bulk transportation
vendor collaboration, and quality services, purchased Blue Water Plastic Transport, a dry bulk
assurance. Managing the process from product transportation, storage, packaging, and delivery service provider.
planning phase through vendor purchase order
placement, the CBX platform will benefit several
departments including merchandising, sourcing, > GOOD WORKS
compliance, and transportation.
Carrier Transicold,
which provides HVAC,
> GREEN SEEDS refrigeration, fire,
security, and building
Logistics provider ATA Freight is automation technologies,
partnering with nonprofit Trees for gifted hunger relief
the Future to plant 100,000 trees organization Three
every year. Trees for the Future works Square Food Bank
with farmers in Sub-Saharan Africa with a Supra 960 truck
to plant trees and improve farming refrigeration unit, its highest-capacity single-temperature diesel-
practices to combat deforestation. powered truck. The unit will help Three Square Food Bank,
ATA Freight’s commitment to plant 100,000 trees which collected and distributed more than 47 million pounds of
annually will offset approximately 3.5 million pounds food and grocery products in 2018, ensure perishable food stays
of carbon. fresher, longer.
APPLES STEEL.
RUAN.COM
TAKEAWAYS
[ IN FOCUS]
P ersonalized medicine
poses many supply chain
challenges as well as opportu-
each country’s regulations,
such as sterilization labeling,
transportation modes in
chain intelligence. These
include artificial intelligence,
self-learning systems, data
3. Treatment-based
logistics and distribution
programs. This includes
nities in the Latin American varied terrains, accessibility to mining, and pattern recognition integrating patient and
region, finds a joint report by well-equipped facilities, and solutions that can learn from a shipment coordination for
DHL Global Forwarding and qualified doctors. constant information stream. specific disease treatments,
American Airlines Cargo. Economic and political 2. Technology innovations. allowing health and logistics
Personalized medicine can stability also play important Many carriers are already providers to collaborate
be considered an extension roles in how healthcare is investing to build a connected to deliver a patient-
of traditional approaches to delivered within countries. fleet. Forward-looking carriers centric experience.
treating disease. Physicians can Even when countries offer top- are also experimenting with 4. Increased collaboration
pinpoint a patient’s molecular notch healthcare systems, not semi-autonomous and electric between forwarders and
profile and suggest the right all residents have equal access vehicles, or with sharing carriers. Between them,
therapy. This, however, makes to the same hospitals, medical platforms. Other examples forwarders and airline carriers
it impractical to ship large personnel, technology, or just include integrating pilot use can deliver end-to-end logistics.
pallets to set locations. the internet. cases for drones that will Deeper collaboration will
To add to the complexities To help advance the enable further exploration of help them overcome the
in Latin America, there are no potential of personalized emergency logistics response challenges of personalized
regional standards for medical medicine, the report finds the tactics, particularly for last-mile medicine logistics.
The Wages of a
Driver Shortage
T here has been a significant change in the pace of pay moves
by carriers and historic mileage pay rates, finds the National
Transportation Institute (NTI) in its National Survey of Driver
Wages (NSDW) report for the first quarter of 2019.
In its quarterly study of key driver compensation categories
for over-the-road and regional fleets, NTI finds that, while the
acceleration of pay moves has decreased, the pay changes that
were made rank as substantial. The
Energizing Warehouse
“ TRENDS FROM
Q1 OF 2019 POINT
TO CONTINUED
industry is reaching uncharted territory in
the area of mileage pay, with rates of up to
65 cents per mile for solo drivers, the Q1 Sustainability
DIFFICULT Y IN findings note. To reduce energy costs for warehouse managers,
AT TR ACTING “Our subscribers tell us that, while faculty at Binghamton University, State University
AND K EEPING freight has dropped and driver churn of New York will develop and demonstrate a new
HIGHLY QUALIFIED (turnover) has increased, the need to warehouse energy storage process and solution that will
DRIV ERS.
” monitor driver pay attributes that produce
desired outcomes remains especially high,”
use solar panels, a stationary energy storage system,
and lithium-ion batteries on forklifts.
observes Leah Shaver, chief operating officer, NTI. “Some of With funding from The New York State Energy
these outcomes include referrals; safe, productive driving; and fair Research and Development Authority, researchers will
compensation for down time. work with The Raymond Corporation, a manufacturer
“We’re in a market with near full employment, and driver of electric forklift trucks and intralogistics solutions, to
expectations are raised after a record year in 2018. In these develop an economically viable storage demonstration
conditions, the driver situation changes rapidly,” Shaver adds.
project. The project is designed to demonstrate why
The NSDW also reports on trends related to guaranteed pay
a behind-the-meter storage system and controllable
and sign-on bonuses (see chart). While the sign-on bonus continues
forklift charging can be beneficial for warehouse owners
to hold a traditional spot in the driver recruiting toolbox, some
and the utility grid.
recruiters are beginning to take the viewpoint that guaranteed
Electric forklift trucks are traditionally powered
pay and transition bonuses better reflect a driver’s value, the
by lead-acid batteries, which can have an extended
NSDW notes.
recharge time of up to eight hours. In many high-use
warehouses, several of these shifts may overlap where
GUARANTEED PAY vs. SIGN-ON BONUSES each forklift truck may have two or three batteries
utilized per truck—one in use, one on recharge, and one
cooling down in storage. While lithium-ion batteries
provide great benefits to forklift users, the fast-charging
feature may create significant energy demands on
warehouse owners during peak times, which is why this
project was developed.
The proposed solution can turn warehouses into
a controllable energy hub that can be optimized to
support the power grid during normal and peak grid
conditions. Binghamton University will work with New
York State Electric & Gas to estimate the benefit and
impact of the proposed system on the grid. Preliminary
analysis will estimate how the system impacts the
SOURCE: NATIONAL SURVEY OF DRIVER WAGES, Q1 2019, NTI efficiency of the local circuit.
W
ith the end of summer in sight, of 3PLs saying they offer reverse logistics support
many logistics stakeholders are services. Continuous growth in reverse logistics is a
left wondering how supply chain surety for the rest of 2019 and beyond.
instability will impact the success of
the upcoming holiday peak season, their long-term Tariffs
forecasts, and day-to-day operations. This piece will Tariffs are a topic of daily discussion for most
analyze the current state of the U.S. logistics industry supply chain managers and business leaders.
to help shippers determine the best approach to While tariffs have been leveled at other major trade
some of the largest challenges. partners, the U.S.-China trade war has received the
Robert Kriewaldt
The following issues will likely define the supply most attention. The escalating trade dispute between
Senior Vice President
chain for the remainder of 2019: the two countries doesn’t show any signs of stopping,
Phoenix Logistics
rkriewaldt@phoenix3pl.com as negotiations have fallen apart multiple times.
www.phoenix3pl.com Amazon U.S. businesses are looking at increased costs
920-915-9746 Amazon now has a logistics network capable of on significant percentages of raw materials and
reaching most U.S. consumers within a day. Amazon components. Many American manufacturers and
announced a rapid expansion of its same- and one- retailers can no longer afford to eat the increased
day shipping services, sending the retail sector costs of importing goods and have begun to pass
into a panic. Other major players like Walmart have them on to customers.
challenged Amazon’s power move with similar While the trans-Pacific shipping industry saw
quick-shipping plans of their own, but e-commerce a short-lived boom as American and Chinese
Amazon's companies purchased excess inventory in advance of
businesses that don’t have that level of resources are
network, rightfully worried. tariff implementation, business is dropping off and
Many e-commerce companies have responded carriers have too much capacity. Domestic ground
increasing reverse to this new normal by purchasing or leasing real carriers are hurting as well because freight demand
estate near secondary markets, or by partnering is negatively impacted by the high levels of inventory
logistics volumes, held by U.S. importers.
with logistics providers with these resources. By
and tariffs are diversifying distribution and fulfillment assets, Many other industries beyond transportation are
internet retailers hope to reduce shipping times and struggling to adapt to this new trade environment
the issues that remain competitive. as well, including telecommunications giants,
will define the agriculture, automakers, manufacturers, and many
more.
supply chain for Reverse Logistics
As e-commerce dominates retail sales and
the remainder of omnichannel makes a surprising comeback, these Be Prepared
businesses must contend with an increase in returns. Amazon isn’t going anywhere, consumers won’t
2019. Consumers return billions of dollars in merchandise stop returning items, and it seems unlikely that the
they purchased online each year and they want the tariff wars will end in 2019. Unfortunately, supply
process to be easy and free (we can thank Amazon chain volatility is the new normal. All affected
again). logistics stakeholders should be diversifying
Shippers are turning to third-party logistics their assets, technology, suppliers, and partner
(3PL) providers for help in this area, with 24% of relationships to address these challenges and
respondents to the 2019 Annual Third-Party Logistics combat the risks and disruptions facing the supply
Study saying they outsource this process, and 44% chain in 2019 and beyond.
Carrier Relationships:
Core Carrier, Long Term, or Bid?
W
ith today’s volatile markets and ever- or plant closures due to delays, a reduction in
increasing consumer demands, a penalties can significantly outweigh the cost of
reliable, cost-effective carrier network is dedicated operations.
more important than ever. Developing • Carefully evaluate volume consistency
collaborative relationships with at least a handful to avoid expense for unused capacity and to
of highly aligned carriers will often result in better optimize contract terms.
service and rates; however the right mix of carrier • Discuss backhaul gainshare programs with
relationships will look different for every shipper. partner carriers to improve cost effectiveness.
Tim Studebaker
Senior Vice President, Maintain Service Levels with Core Carriers Identify Synergies with a Strategic Bid Process
Operations Building strategic partnerships with a select group A strategic bid process gives shippers the ability to
Red Classic of core carriers can be an effective way for shippers evaluate all potential carriers against the same criteria
info@redclassic.com to deliver on customer expectations. Core carriers and identify the best-aligned providers. Like carrier
www.redclassic.com can help shippers maintain consistent service levels, relationships, a bid process can take on a variety of
866-768-8809 reduce complexity in the supply chain, and maintain forms. Bids sometimes include an entire portfolio
company standards regarding safety and quality. of business, but more often focus on a single region
Because core carrier relationships are performance or include exemptions for parts of the business with
based, shippers can often improve quality by holding satisfactory performance. What to think about:
carriers accountable to agreed-upon KPIs. What to • Assess the effectiveness of current carriers.
think about: Evaluate current carrier performance,
Shippers must • Closely match shipping needs to carrier understanding that onboarding new carriers
understand strengths including equipment type, trailer can cause temporary supply chain disruptions.
pool usage, customer service capabilities, etc. • Be strategic. Bidding an entire portfolio at
their supply • Ensure data integrity and reporting tools are once can cause radical change within a supply
chain, capacity in place to accurately analyze carrier performance. chain. Assess how much change your supply
• Commit internal resources to building carrier chain can handle and use bids like a scalpel not
challenges, relationships and optimizing execution. a sledgehammer. Understand that changes you
make can cause major disruptions to carrier
and customer networks as well.
Mitigate Insecure Capacity with
requirements • Gauge your ability to analyze bid data. There
Dedicated Operations
is significant room for error when evaluating
Dedicated operations provide consistent capacity
before deploying and give shippers more control of service levels. bid data, especially when a bid file includes
thousands of lanes. Ensure data integrity to
a carrier When capacity is tight or volatile, contracted capacity
avoid errors and resource waste.
allows shippers to hedge against extremes in the
management market. While dedicated operations can be more Before deploying any kind of carrier management
strategy. expensive, often costs are stabilized, and levels of strategy, shippers must have a deep understanding
service are generally higher and more consistent. of their supply chain, capacity challenges, and
As shippers and carriers collaborate, additional customer requirements. An optimized carrier portfolio
opportunities to increase efficiency often materialize. will provide stable capacity, deliver on customer
What to think about: expectations, and improve cost effectiveness. No
• Conduct a detailed cost/benefit analysis. If matter the market conditions, strategic carrier
your company faces significant OTIF penalties management makes good business sense.
THOUGHT LEADERS
THOUGHT LEADERS
3PLLINE
by Derek Browning
Director, LeanCor
dbrowning@leancor.com | 859-283-9933
Choosing a 3PL:
How to Make a Mature Decision
Relationships between shippers and third-party logistics (3PL) Organizations that appreciate the
providers commonly focus more on tactical and operational need to align on purpose, value, strategy,
and culture will avoid the 1980’s-style
elements rather than strategic elements. 3PL selection method of identifying
three vendors, letting them fight it out,
When sourcing to 3PLs, the shipper’s The core purpose and value and negotiating tactical deal points.
RFP often focuses on lane costs proposition of some 3PLs is lower Instead, they will opt for an executive-
rather than strategic elements such as individual transaction costs and lane interview method where shippers and
systems integration, real-time visibility, coverage, while others have focused on 3PLs get to know each other, verify
and total-cost performance. The building robust carrier networks with areas of alignment or misalignment,
transactional lane-focused relationship delivery disciplines, high connectivity and wade into a relationship with the
is appropriate for companies looking for levels, and advanced optimization expectation that each party comes out
basic lane coverage and not currently techniques. Some 3PLs have rotating knowing about one another’s business
operating at a level of maturity to carrier networks with underfunded and understanding how to maximize
understand total-delivered costs. equipment and undertrained operators, value for each other.
For organizations that have matured while others invest long-term in In the final stages of this type of
beyond the tactical focus on lanes infrastructure, technology, relationships, negotiation, the focus is not on shaving
and coverage, a 3PL partner must and human development. 1% off final fees, but on strategic
play a strategic role, moving past just Each plays a role in today’s logistics connections that will produce 4x
transporting and storing to identifying world and will flourish when the right multiples on returns. It includes the
problems, implementing solutions, and match is made. upfront changes the organizations
adding systems-wide value. must implement to maximize
The 3PL must guide the shipper in WHY PARTNERSHIPS FAIL relationship effectiveness.
shifting its management system to better When organizations are strategically A 3PL partner aligned on purpose,
reflect the role supply chain plays in the or culturally misaligned, the partnership value, strategy, and culture can provide
business. It starts with decision making often dissolves with reluctance to far more value than what is seen in a
between the two partners. The shipper advance toward common goals. This transportation budget variance report.
and its 3PL partner should re-evaluate: usually results when the two parties Avoid old-school commoditized
• What is our core purpose? rush the sales and negotiations process approaches to negotiation and selection,
• What value do we create? and focus on functional area budgets, and don’t underestimate the value that
• Are we strategically aligned? only to find out they are misaligned and can be created with a partner aligned
• Are we culturally aligned? stuck with five years of conflict. with your maturity level. n
» 11 fulfillment warehouses
throughout California
» Same-day shipment,
with delivery in 1-2 days
to 65 million consumers
» Advanced wireless and bar
code technology to ensure
picking efficiency and accuracy
» Easy, fast integration with
your existing shopping cart
For importers, our close proximity to
West Coast ports makes Weber your
single-source solution for container
pick-up, pick/pack fulfillment and
parcel management.
ITMATTERS
by Pratik Soni
Co-founder and CEO, Omnichain Solutions
310-696-1503 | pratik.soni@omnichains.com
Blockchain-as-a-Service: Building
Transparent Supply Chains For All
Early blockchain adopters are looking to the distributed ledger channels and regions where they are
wanted most—and fulfillment—finding
technology to connect disparate supply chains, enabling the closest distribution centers and
transparency between what’s happening downstream with transportation providers to fulfill orders.
consumers, upstream in production, and everywhere in between. Customers always get what they
want, when they want it, for a better
Adding more fuel to adoption is systems and databases, it’s difficult to get experience. Businesses get less wasted
Blockchain-as-a-Service (BaaS), which everyone on the same page. mileage in transportation and costs, and
gives businesses the ability to connect For instance, stores have their own greater profitability and business growth.
their supply chains through a simple internal enterprise resource planning Consumers want to spend their
internet browser. Using a subscription- and point-of-sale systems for managing dollars on products that are good for the
based model, BaaS platforms inventory and sales. These often exist environment and sourced from ethically
streamline complicated and expensive separately from the metrics used sound suppliers—amid other social
implementations, which means faster upstream in manufacturing, making it considerations. While price remains
return on investment. difficult to gauge real-time consumer a primary motivator, these secondary
BaaS platforms can integrate and log demand. Therefore, most resign considerations can be competitive
records from any accounting, inventory, themselves to reactive production and differentiators, but only if companies
or transportation management system, replenishment, which invariably leads to can guarantee they meet expectations.
creating a permanent, decentralized supply and demand imbalances. BaaS can help companies build that
ledger of all product movement and trust with an immutable record of
transactions, from source to shelf. GIVING MANUFACTURING VISIBILITY product provenance.
With real-time data flow and Through BaaS, manufacturing gains The most satisfying part of BaaS is
transparency throughout the supply visibility into what consumers are buying. that it democratizes blockchain, so that
chain, organizations can overcome It is possible to then find an equilibrium the technology is no longer limited to
many tough demand forecasting, between supply and demand— conglomerates with large budgets. Small
replenishment, inventory allocation, producing just the right amount of and mid-sized companies can also
and tracking and traceability challenges. product without excess, carrying costs, or achieve supply chain-wide transparency.
Many supply chains involve a the need for secondary markets. Through an affordable, subscription-
complicated mix of suppliers, production Add in geo-specific information on based model, BaaS offers scalability,
sites, warehouses, third-party logistics where demand is coming from, and accommodating organizations’ current
providers, and online and brick-and- organizations can optimize inventory needs with the flexibility to grow with
mortar retailers. With each using its own allocation—sending products to the them for years to come. n
THE CHOICE
IS LANDSTAR
FOR CAPACITY
TRUCKLOAD | LTL | HEAVY HAUL/SPECIALIZED | EXPEDITED | AIR | OCEAN | RAIL INTERMODAL | TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS
LANDSTAR.COM
SMB
SM
B
seems like product closer to the consumer,” says Steve Congro, director,
the Clash of the Titans, with Amazon, Walmart, The Home omnichannel fulfillment technology at 3PL Saddle Creek
Depot, and others battling for supremacy online and at Logistics Services in Lakeland, Florida.
the mall. But of course the retail landscape also comprises Big retailers also have the clout to negotiate favorable
countless small and mid-sized businesses—boutiques, local shipping rates, making it easier to offer free or inexpensive
chains, specialty stores, up-and-coming e-commerce sites, and shipping. “A small online retailer might not be able to
every combination in between. negotiate rates, because they might not have the type of volume
Smaller retailers have a tough time competing with the that Wayfair or Amazon does,” notes Janet Vito, vice president
giants. But among the best contenders, this challenge spurs the of marketing and sales at Austin-based uShip, an online
kind of creativity that could boost a business to success. platform that matches shippers of large items with carriers that
have space in their trucks.
MARKET SHARE AT ANY COST The battle for market share even drives some companies to
Perhaps the most obvious challenge smaller retailers face offer free shipping at a loss. For example, Amazon uses profits
is price competition. Large companies negotiate preferential from its cloud-hosting service, Amazon Web Services (AWS), to
deals with suppliers and win customers with low prices, which subsidize free shipping for its Prime service members.
they tout during events such as Amazon’s Prime Day and Another challenge for small and mid-sized retailers is how
everyone’s Black Friday sales. to gain name recognition and stand out from the crowd. Not
“The big guys are working hard to win market share at all of them have the wherewithal. That includes many of the
almost any cost. The small and mid-sized guys are left out,” says 100 brick-and-mortar home décor and furniture boutiques that
Steve Dowse, senior vice president of product management belong to Design Kollective, an online, membership-based
at Blume Global, in Pleasanton, California. Blume operates a marketplace with headquarters in Park City, Utah.
digital platform and applications shippers, carriers, and third- “A lot of these boutiques don’t know how to create a website
party logistics (3PL) providers use to manage supply chains. or how to send out marketing emails,” says Scot Pace, Design
Bargain pricing isn’t the only expectation that Amazon and Kollective’s chief operations officer. Design Kollective performs
its kind have instilled in buyers. “The biggest challenge for any those jobs for its members, helping them capture attention
retailer right now is, at a minimum, meeting the free, two-day locally and giving them a national presence.
shipping expectation that most e-commerce consumers have,” Smaller companies face a branding problem when they
says Sean Mueller, vice president of business development and supplement their own brick-and-mortar and e-commerce
solutions at Symbia Logistics in Edwards, Colorado. channels by also selling through online marketplaces run
The biggest retailers can deliver in one or two days because by their big competitors. “You might move product, but
they can afford to place inventory all over the country. “It puts you won’t build your name,” Congro says. A consumer who
• Less than one mile from the Atlantic Shipping Lanes • Rail connections throughout the U.S.
• Direct highway access • On-port Foreign-Trade Zone
• One traffic signal to Los Angeles • Ocean shipping to 150 ports in 70 countries
With more resources and possible, and orchestrate
clout than many shippers, fulfillment so a customer
third-party logistics (3PL) who orders, say, a living
companies offer advantages room suite will get a sofa,
that help smaller retailers chairs, tables, and rugs all at
hold their own against tough the same time.
By partnering with a 3PL, furniture
competitors. “We are building out a seller Burrow is able to broaden its
For instance, furniture distribution network with distribution footprint.
purveyor Burrow plans a 3PL that will allow us
to use a 3PL to broaden to support both needs,” don’t have the favorable to help the retailer hone
its distribution footprint says Ashutosh Panchang, shipping rates or contracts its supply chain strategy.
as it expands its product senior manager of business that a 3PL has,” says Sean Where should the company
assortment from operations at Burrow in Mueller, vice president of hold inventory to reduce
upholstered living room New York. “The third need is business development and transport costs? Which
seating to include rugs, building this network in the solutions at 3PL Symbia package design gives the
other accessories, and most capital-efficient way.” Logistics. customer a great unboxing
furniture for every room. If a 3PL holds inventory For retailers trying experience but also can
Today, a factory in in several strategically to deliver outstanding move efficiently and safely
North Carolina makes placed facilities, Burrow can customer service, a 3PL through the network?
the company’s modular shorten delivery time and may provide special, value- Finally, for a small retailer
furniture and ships it to cut parcel delivery costs. added touches, such as trying to become a big one,
customers throughout the However far products wrapping a product in a 3PL offers scalability. “We
United States. When its travel to reach end tissue paper and packing it can take five pallets to 100
catalog expands, Burrow consumers or brick-and- in a beautiful box with the pallets, or take a company
will rely on manufacturers mortar stores, a 3PL can merchant’s logo, or adding a from a few employees to 50,
in multiple locations. The often help a smaller retailer handwritten note. or back down if the product
company wants to deliver cut shipping costs. A 3PL may also have is seasonal,” Mueller says.
those products as fast as “Small shippers typically analysis tools
“Or if they want to offer free or strategy at Burrow, which works fulfillment partner
subsidized shipping, the retailer knows hard to give customers an easy and lets Burrow provide
exactly what it will cost ahead of time,” pleasant experience. a better response.
Vito says. “At every point, we want to “Changes to the
Working with uShip lets the small understand how customers are product can be
boutiques that belong to Design shopping and what considerations facilitated quickly,
Kollective deliver to any location in the they’re making, but also their pain with the same timeline as the original
United States—a service they could not points,” says COO Steve Finnern. order, getting it back to the customer in
otherwise have offered. Burrow’s supply chain supports one week.” Panchang says.
“That was a pain point for many this effort to deliver a great customer It’s important for small and mid-sized
of these stores,” Pace says. “They experience. Consider, for example, a retailers to make consumers feel great
were competing with the online customer who buys a sectional sofa and about shopping with them. “It could be
giants that can ship anywhere in the then, on seeing it in his living room, through over-the-top customer service,”
country.” Now the pain is gone. And, decides he’d actually like something says Congro. “Or through product
if they like, members can offer “free” larger, with arms in a different style. personalization or customization, which
shipping by building the transportation A standard furniture company might the big guys are not known for.”
cost, calculated by uShip, into the take four to 12 weeks to retrieve the “From small companies to large,
product pricing. original sofa and send a new one. But the customer’s experience and story
One competitive point where the tight relationship between the is everything,” says Mueller. “It’s how
small retailers may naturally excel is customer experience team, its supply you stand up to large companies and
customer service. Service is key to the chain team, and its manufacturing and successfully sustain growth and sales.” n
ONLINE
BY SANDRA
BECKWITH
POP UP
those of conventional retail stores. CPG companies must
WHEN STORES carefully plan the merchandise mix and quantities.
“Depending on how long they’re at a location, we
With the pop-up shop industry valued at $50 billion, it’s determine if we have enough storage capacity there or if
no wonder that this temporary store concept is gaining we should set up a separate warehouse space,” Newman
popularity with brands selling directly to consumers. says. Mobile shops are often shadowed by a backup truck
From the U.S. Soccer Fan Studio in Chicago’s West Loop carrying inventory for easy replenishing.
offering merchandise and photo opportunities during the The challenge for companies using these mini-stores is
FIFA Women’s World Cup to online fashion brand Cuyana luring shoppers. “One mistake brands make is counting on
testing the bricks-and-mortar option, brands are using local foot traffic to drive sales,” Newman says. “Instead, you
everything from short-term storefront rentals to mobile need to develop a compelling, unique offer or promotion.”
glass trucks to connect directly with consumers. Without the right mix that includes the best format for
While some consumer-packaged goods companies use brand goals, a visually appealing design, and an irresistible
pop-ups to create awareness, more see them as a way to sell offer, a pop-up store might just fall flat.
products directly to consumers.
“It’s a huge trend,” affirms Hope Newman, creative The U.S. Soccer Federation opened a pop-up shop for fans during
the 2019 FIFA Women’s World Cup and CONCACAF Gold Cup.
director of The Pop Up Shop Agency, which consults on,
creates, and manages pop-ups all over the country. “More
than half of the calls we get are for pop-up retail shops, and
our clients want to see sales results.”
With the movement often driven by millennials who are as
much about the experience as the merchandise, retail pop-
ups always include “Instagrammable” elements.
“We design every pop-up with Instagram in mind,”
Newman says. “You can’t just put clothing on racks and
expect people to take photos.”
Pop-up shops face supply chain challenges similar to
SELLS
focused his efforts on Angeles and overseas,
Instagram, the social media Fashion Nova goes from
platform used primarily sample to inventory in as
When Fashion Nova by the younger crowd. He few as one to two weeks,
founder and CEO Richard began giving free garments adding as many as 600 new
Saghian launched his low- to a small group of loyal items weekly.
priced, fast-fashion line of customers who regularly “The logistics behind this
women’s apparel in 2006, shared their fandom on are less interesting than That model has worked.
he used a traditional retail Instagram. Now numbering the demand-generation The most-searched for
approach—a handful of mall 3,000, these influencers model and the way it helps fashion brand on Google
stores. But in 2013, when he use tags #NovaBabe and the company differentiate with more than 16 million
saw other retailers selling #NovaStar when posing incredibly undifferentiated Instagram followers had
the same merchandise and posting in their trendy fashion,” says John Leeman, nearly $485,000 in revenue
online at higher price points, apparel. They’re joined a direct-to-consumer in 2018, according to
he added e-commerce to by well-paid influencers customer experience and eCommerceDB.
the mix. musician Cardi B and reality marketing consultant and Apparently, Instagram
But that’s where his TV star Kylie Jenner. former chief marketing marketing can be quite
catwalk veered off in a Working with 1,000 officer of FreshDirect. fashionable.
made a significant investment in its For example, the company is two-day delivery expectation in most of
omnichannel business in recent years. exploring whether it can skip the first the country.
During the past 18 to 24 months, the consolidation center that’s part of the “For some, this approach can let a
company has been focused on the “click conventional manufacturer-to-individual- brand become a fulfilled-by-merchant
and collect” model. store supply chain. Amazon Prime seller instead of using
“Some of our thinking involves One of the biggest differences CPG Fulfilled by Amazon,” says Patrick Cadic,
whether the packaging for in-store brands address when moving into vice president of sales and marketing
shopping is the same as what’s used for most of the new fulfillment models at Ware2Go.
click and collect. And, do these products involves shifting from pallet to piece It’s not just consumers demanding
ordered online and picked up at the store fulfillment in the distribution center. more of CPG brands, though. Retailers
have to follow the same path to get to Facilities designed for moving large, bulk that include Walmart are pushing
the store as what’s displayed inside?” says quantities—pallet in and pallet out— them, too. Stringent “on time in full”—
Scott DeGroot, Kimberly-Clark’s senior can’t accommodate the individual unit OTIF—requirements for deliveries make
director of transportation and interim picking and packing required without it critical to know where goods are in the
lead of global logistics. significant reengineering. supply chain at any time.
“The physical warehouse layout “Retailers are even adding thresholds
has to be evaluated. Brands ask, ‘Can I so, for example, if you get there too
force this channel into this warehouse, early, you’re penalized,” says Jim
or do I need to offload that to a third- Hayden, chief technology officer of Savi
party facility that’s managed by Technology. The Virginia company uses
someone else?’” says Adam Kline, senior sensors to deliver information about
director of product management at the location, condition, and security of
Manhattan Associates. in-transit goods.
That’s where Ware2Go steps in. There’s also the question of where to
Launched in August 2018 by UPS, the position product so a company can avoid
company has assembled a nationwide filling orders from multiple locations,
network of vetted warehouses and third- as Eaton saw with his vacation apparel
Retailers’ increasingly stringent “on party logistics providers. This makes purchase. Because the order came from
time in full” delivery requirements make
it critical to know where goods are in it possible for CPG companies of all a distribution center and five stores, he
the supply chain at any time. Location- sizes and types—from digitally native adds, “The retailer guessed wrong.”
based sensors from Savi Technology keep
companies informed about the location, startups to enterprise operations piloting That’s what more and more CPG
condition, and security of in-transit goods. a new approach—to meet a one- to brands are now trying to get right. Q
ECOMMERCE FULFILLMENT
As commerce has moved online, so has
The Shippers Group advanced technological
capabilities that interface with shopping carts
and maximize order processing efficiency. We
work hard to ensure the right goods reach the
right customer at the right time and at the
lowest cost. As e-commerce businesses grow,
this approach allows for scaling up when needed.
Adva
n
medi ces in tech
c n
tough ine can ma ology, ne
k w
share pill to swa e managi regulatio
inform llo ng ns
ation w. Succes pharmac , and more
, and s e
embr ful supply utical sup personali
ace c p z
hang chains lev ly chains ed
e. BY erage a
KA R E new I
N KR
OL T,
L
RESPONSIBILITY.
all supply chain processes that can boost
stakeholders,”
RESPONSIBILITY. supply chain integrity
FISCAL
Celetaria says. include running driver
RESPONSIBILITY.
FAST PHARMA
Data processing
speed presents another
RESPONSIBILITY. shipments. When the
drivers stop to refuel,
obstacle. While the
private chains typical
TOGETHER
TOGETHER AT LAST. one person remains
with the vehicle at
AT LAST.
in supply chain and all times. In addition,
logistics are much the truck can arrive
faster than the public
People are having more goods delivered, for its pickup fully
chains used for faster, than ever before. Which means fueled, minimizing
cryptocurrencies,
C
your fleet is generating more emissions the number of stops it
it’s typically difficult
M
than ever
People arebefore.
havingWhat
moreifgoods
you could cut
delivered, will have to make on
for a company to your fleet’s carbon footprint to means
zero and the road.
faster, than ever before. Which
Y
W hen a company nears a major site selection decision and narrows its favorites to
two or three finalists, little often separates one community from another, says
Matt Ryder, managing principal with Cresa, a Washington, D.C.-based commercial
real estate firm. Energy, tax, and land incentives can be the final ingredient that kills or
clinches the bid of a potential location.
“When you get down to the last two or three cities, usually any of them are going
to work for a company,” says Ryder, whose practice includes economic development
incentives analysis and negotiation. “They’re all viable if they’ve made it that far. So it
becomes about deciding which one is special—which one is putting itself over the top.
It can be any number of things, but when there’s a match between the incentives offered
and the usability of those incentives for the company—that can be the key.”
Beyond their economic benefits, in areas with high property taxes, significant economic impact on a state
incentives play an integral role in site abatements, or PILOTS (payments in and local economy,” Ryder says. “So to
selection decisions. Incentives also lieu of taxes). Incentives also can help limit the value of incentives to tax credits
demonstrate how much a locality wants address challenges related to a limited or would be outdated. When a local or
a project and how reliable it will be as a untrained workforce. state economic developer comes forward
long-term partner. “Training programs are becoming with a more usable set of incentives
“We often start by evaluating how more important and more prevalent,” opportunities, that’s a good indication
incentives will play into the overall Brunson says. “With the economy they’re going to help the business in the
project economics,” Ryder says. “But approaching virtually full employment in longer term.”
then later in the process—when you many regions, workforce is increasingly In today’s competitive climate,
narrow the choice to a couple of becoming a driving factor in location incentives customized to a company’s
geographies—the conversation tends to decisions. Programs that allow employers needs can be essential.
shift toward the idea that a community is to hire under-skilled employees and train “If training and ramping up the
truly stretching to attract the business. them can be very effective.” workforce is the biggest need, then
“That means as we think about the The value of training-related incentives should address this area,”
operational life of the site selection incentives is tied to how easy they are Brunson says. “If high property taxes
project, which is typically a long-term to access and use. “The more reporting, affect operational profitability, then
decision, we feel like that community red tape, and third-party involvement property tax incentives are critical.”
will be a good partner in the future,” required, the less appealing they can be,”
he adds. Brunson notes. A PERSONAL APPROACH
The ability to use incentives is as Communities do not always have the
THE IMPORTANCE OF USABILITY critical as their nominal value. Localities flexibility within local and state laws to
The incentives’ value to a company sometimes offer incentives to a company develop fully customized incentives,
depends on the location of a site and the without studying the business. For though larger projects can allow for more
nature of the project, says Steve Brunson, instance, Ryder sometimes represents tailoring potential. Still, within existing
principal, credits and incentives, pre-profit technology companies that are frameworks, localities can ensure they
McGuire Sponsel, a specialty tax and not yet taxpayers. communicate the applicability of their
consulting firm based in Indianapolis. “The reality is that a company incentives to companies.
Incentives are especially important doesn’t need to be a taxpayer to have a Occasionally, localities give
POWERFUL INCENTIVES
Hoosier Energy, a generation and
transmission cooperative providing
wholesale electric power and services
to member distribution cooperatives
in central and southern Indiana and
southeastern Illinois, has demonstrated
a consistent commitment to
economic development.
Its dedicated economic development
team, which has expertise in site location
As part of its work with companies considering a move to its area, Hoosier Energy offers assistance, planning and zoning, and
in-house expertise to design and build electric infrastructure for large projects.
local and state incentives, prides itself on
preparing new and expanding companies
companies a host of available incentives, disadvantage often need a healthy to successfully do business in the region,
but “the company sifts through them incentive package to level the playing says Scott Bowers, vice president of
and realizes that not all of what’s being field with competitors. public policy and member services at
pushed is actually useful,” notes Ryder. “We plug incentives into the overall Hoosier Energy.
“The better approach is to say, net tax and gap analysis to get a The cooperative’s efforts in 2018
‘We’ve taken the time to understand comprehensive comparison of sites,” helped generate 2,515 new jobs in
your business, this operation, and your Brunson says. “The more gaps a site has, Indiana and Illinois and more than
objectives, and we’re going to come the greater the value of the incentives $730 million in new capital investment,
forward with a package that will be need to be to be competitive. Low-tax, while leading to the addition of 38.5
valuable to you,’” he adds. low-cost, and strategic locations may megawatts of new industrial and
McGuire Sponsel looks at three key come out on top even with smaller commercial load. Incentives are a key
components when evaluating incentives nominal incentive values.” piece of Hoosier Energy’s approach to
and comparing them across locations: economic development.
n Overall value THE BIG PICTURE “Hoosier Energy is committed to
n Form and utilization In short, companies in site selection economic development and we show
n The ability to bridge site- mode should analyze how they will it through incentives such as special
specific gaps use incentives. economic development rider (EDR)
For example, the higher cost of “When tax credits, deductions, discounts,” Bowers says. “For qualified
new construction that accompanies abatements, and other factors are commercial and industrial customers,
a good economy can be addressed involved, companies should pay close the EDR phases in their total cost for
with incentives. attention to the actual tax effect,” power over a 6-year span. The discount
“Tax increment financing (TIF) and Brunson recommends. “This may require starts at 30% in year one and the 6-year
industrial revenue bonds (IRBs) can be projections and multi-state analysis. averages net approximately 17% savings.”
valuable in providing capital for a project The last thing anyone wants on either In addition to the EDR discounts,
or reducing construction or financing side is for an incentive to fail to meet its Hoosier Energy’s board recently
costs,” Brunson says. “Large-scale objective. Companies need to remember created a pathway for large customers
industrial projects commonly involve that not all dollars are the same. They to purchase power directly from the
TIF or IRBs. must always analyze utilization.” open market.
“Just because an incentive offer is Providing a comprehensive incentive “This allows us to offer extremely
larger on paper doesn’t make it better,” package requires more than the work competitive rates to large industrial
he points out. Sites that are at a strategic of a single entity. The development power users,” Bowers says.
Beyond incentives such as the EDR Hoosier Energy collaborates with its the needs of each individual company
and the ability to allow customers to member distribution cooperatives, local considering relocation or expansion.
buy from the open market, Hoosier economic development officials, and The cooperative’s service territory
Energy can offer unique has a competitive
infrastructure solutions business environment
through financing and robust logistics
options, notes Bowers. infrastructure so that
The company also incentives often are “the
has in-house expertise WE CALL THEM cherry on top,” Bowers
SMART SITES.
to quickly design and says, for companies
build the necessary considering expansions
electric infrastructure. or relocations.
“Moreover, we’re able YO U ’ LL C A LL TH EM A N O - B R AI N ER “We often can offer
to move quickly to meet an EDR or a creative
company needs because electric rate structure
we are not required to
go before the Indiana
WHAT ARE Smartt Sites? to complement a larger
state and local incentive
Utility Regulatory offer,” Bowers says.
Commission,” “Additionally, we work
SHOVEL-READY for development
Bowers adds. closely with economic
Hoosier Energy, ON-SITE municipal electric service development partners
which is based in to provide the necessary
WATER & SEWER within 500 feet
Bloomington, Indiana, infrastructure that
serves 18 member WITHIN 5 MILES of Interstate or Interstate-quality highway provides companies
electric cooperatives—a with reliable, affordable
jurisdiction that covers REVIEWED AND QUALIFIED by consultants and engineers power onsite when they
59 counties. Generation need it.”
includes coal, natural That customer
gas, and renewable Tarboro Statesville service component is
energy resources, and a reminder that site
power delivery through selection decisions
a nearly 1,700-mile and the role of local
transmission network. partners in working
“A growing number US 70 to accommodate
of companies are the preparation and
approaching us to maintenance of new
help them meet their sites have a myriad of
renewable energy goals,” components. Economic
TARBORO BUSINESS PARK/
Bowers says. “Hoosier development and site
COMMERCE CENTER: INDUSTRIAL PARK
Energy has been selection experts say
90+ acres 44.25 acres
proactive in adding incentives can be a
$10,000 per acre $27,500 per acre
renewable energy stimulus, but ultimately
options to its overall should be part of a
portfolio so we’re ready larger analysis.
to help. To learn more about these properties “Incentives play
“If a company and our growing list of other Smart Sites, a role, but that role
contact Brenda Daniels at 800.768.7697
chooses to locate at shouldn’t be over or
ext. 6363 or bdaniels@electricities.org.
a member-served under emphasized,”
site today, 7% of its Brunson says. “The total
power will come from project will also include
renewable energy,” he says. “This state economic development officials tax effects, workforce availability and
number will increase to 10% in the to develop comprehensive incentive cost, transportation costs, utility costs,
coming months.” packages that are customized to fit and more.” Q
àèæäñõèïìäåïüëäñçïèçìùèõöèæäõêòöëìóðèñ÷öúì÷ëïèööæòñêèö÷ìòñäñçðòõèæòññèæ÷ìùì÷ü÷ò÷ëè
Üòø÷ëèäö÷äñçðäõîè÷öäõòøñç÷ëèúòõïçõèöøï÷ìñêìñêõèä÷èõóèõéòõðäñæèéòõüòøõåøöìñèöö
:KHQ\RXWKLQNEXVLQHVVVXFFHVVWKLQN)ORULGDƬUVW
Port Canaveral | Port Everglades | Port of Fernandina | Port of Fort Pierce | JAXPORT
Port of Key West | Port Manatee | PortMiami | Port of Palm Beach | Port Panama City
Port of Pensacola | Port of Port St. Joe | Port St. Pete | Port Tampa Bay
1 1 0 1 C H A N N E L S I D E D R I V E , T A M P A , F L O R I DA 3 3 6 0 2
W W W . P O R T T B . C O M | 8 0 0 -7 4 1 -2 2 9 7
FLORIDA: CLEAR SAILING
“These larger ships will bring more
cargo capacity that ultimately translates
into jobs, economic impact, and
generational impact for years to come,”
Anderson says.
FACILITATING E-COMMERCE
Yet another illustration of Florida’s
ahead-of-the-curve logistics advantages
is its responsiveness to the growing
importance of e-commerce.
E-commerce is no longer a trend but
a well-established distribution channel.
In order for brands to earn client
loyalty, they need to fulfill orders from
their omnichannels in the timeframe
expected. Ameriworld Fulfillment, a
Miami-based logistics company Ameriworld Fulfillment specializes in drop-ship and Miami-based logistics company that
e-commerce operations, providing fulfillment solutions for cosmetics, footwear, toy, hardware, specializes in drop-ship and e-commerce,
and fast-fashion companies.
understands the industry requirements
Together with its terminal operator inspection areas, as well as a CBP AG and is able to handle a high daily volume
partner Ports America, Port Tampa Specialists lab. of orders.
Bay is aggressively building out its In the port’s 2018 State of the Port Ameriworld has been in the product
infrastructure—including the expansion report, Port of Tampa Bay President and distribution business, also known
of paved storage, new berths, additional CEO Paul Anderson summarizes the as fulfillment, since its inception in
gantry cranes, and equipment, as well as port’s progress: “Not only did Port Tampa 2003, affording the company much-
new on-dock transload facilities—to stay Bay experience its second consecutive needed expertise in the ever-evolving
ahead of growing demand. record revenue year, but we began to e-commerce world. Julian Rubio,
Port Tampa Bay’s facilities and see a convergence of several initiatives Ameriworld’s CEO, says he considers
experience accommodate a diverse including major infrastructure projects, the company’s key advantages to be its
mix of cargoes, from containers and real estate agreements, and new cargoes. human capital and innovation.
refrigerated commodities to break- “In fiscal year 2018, our record With its controlled temperature
bulk, roll-on/roll-off and heavy lift operating revenue of more than $59 area, expiration dates, and lot numbers
(with necessary storage, laydown, crane million represented a double-digit control, Ameriworld effectively serves
capacity, etc.), and immediate highway increase of 11% and was attributed to all many industries. These include
and rail connections. primary revenue streams including cargo cosmetics, as well as the footwear, toy,
Last-mile issues are not a concern at categories as well as growth in industrial housewares, supplements, hardware,
Port Tampa Bay. “We have a dedicated maritime real estate development and and fast-fashion industries, among others
truck ramp directly outside the gate, our cruise business which, for the that benefit from the company’s robust
connecting the Port to I-4 (east/west) and first time in our history, surpassed one reverse logistics system.
I-75 (north/south),” Elliott says. million passengers.” “We understand our clients’ success
Another major infrastructure In its 2019 report, the port will have hinges on a fast and efficient fulfillment
expansion was the recent opening of even more to cheer as the Big Bend and distribution chain that is flexible
Port Logistics Refrigerated Services’ new Channel Improvement project was and adaptive to the rapid changes in
state-of the-art refrigerated warehouse. completed earlier this year. The project, the technological and digital world,”
The Tampa Bay region is Florida’s hub more than a dozen years in the making, says Business Development Director
for the grocery/food and beverage sector effectively brought together five public- Cloudya Esther.
and is located in the heart of Florida’s private partnership entities (U.S. Army “We already have a highly efficient
agriculture industry. With on-site Corps of Engineers, Florida Department paperless operation that specializes in
dedicated fumigation services, this of Transportation, Tampa Electric, drop-ship and e-commerce orders,” she
135,000-square-foot cold storage facility Mosaic, and Port Tampa Bay) to deepen adds. “We also have our own in-house
has 6,348 racked pallet positions, 148 and widen the channel at Port Redwing IT department that allows us to integrate
reefer plugs, on-site USDA and CBP for larger ships. with our clients’ ERP systems as well
Get in Touch!
+1 (305) 777-0548
info@ameriworld.com
www.ameriworld.com
CITY
E-COMMERCE
IN THIS SECTION:
E-Commerce
TRANSPLACE www.transplace.com
Transplace is the leading provider of transportation management services and
logistics technology, helping manufacturers, retailers and distributors optimize
supply chain operations and increase financial performance. Offering a complete
suite of transportation management, strategic capacity, and cross-border and
global trade services, Transplace’s customizable logistics solutions and best-in-
class technology give businesses greater control of their transportation operations
and enhanced visibility of shipments and overall supply chain performance.
PORTS
RETAIL LOGISTICS
CITY
RETAIL LOGISTICS
IN THIS SECTION:
Retail Logistics
LYNDEN www.lynden.com
Over land, on the water, in the air—or in any combination—Lynden
has been helping customers solve transportation problems for almost
a century. Operating in such challenging areas as Alaska, Western
Canada and Russia, as well as other areas around the globe, Lynden
has built a reputation of superior service to diverse industries.
RUAN www.ruan.com
With Ruan, you can take advantage of door-to-door shipping solutions without
the hassles and overhead associated with owning and operating your own
fleet of trucks. We have more than 5,200 employees operating, servicing and
coordinating some 3,400 power units and 5,600 trailers out of more than 100
locations throughout the continental United States. But you get more than just
drivers and equipment—we become an extension of your team, advocating
for your bottom line. Find out why the right partner can drive costs out of
your supply chain—call 866-RUAN-NOW or visit our website—ruan.com.
SITE SELECTION
WAREHOUSING
video
whitepapers
NOT YOUR
MODERN TOOLS fail to digitize their processes are missing valu-
able opportunities to ensure peak performance
As CFOs move beyond traditional accounting and capitalize on business opportunities.
responsibilities to take on strategic roles in their
organizations, many realize that they can do more Implementing a digital model of the global sup-
MAMA’S 3PL
to optimize their global supply chains. Spread- ply chain provides that quantum leap. It makes
VKHHWVHPDLOVDQGSDSHUDUHQRORQJHUDQHHF- it possible to share, process, and analyze infor-
tive way to gain control of today’s far-reaching mation. These methods provide for reduced
supply chain. costs and risks and enable “digital agility” — the
brass ring of supply chain success. This digiti-
Incrementally enhancing the current operational zation creates control and ownership over the
model will only provide incremental improvements, global supply chain and reduces dependency on
at best. A quantum leap requires transformative third-party providers, point solutions, and man-
whitepapers
W H I T E PA P E R
OVERCOMING THE
BEYOND TRANSPORTATION SAVINGS CHALLENGES OF
LEVERAGE FREIGHT AND PARCEL AUDIT DATA TO UNLOCK BUSINESS INSIGHTS
PRIVATE FLEET
MANAGEMENT WITH
OUTSOURCING
EXPANDING FROM B2B to B2C The obstacles are enormous for every company that operates its
own private fleet. There are a growing number of complex regulations
A Guide to Effective to follow and a shortage of qualified drivers. At the same time,
operating and insurance costs are increasing, and there is a greater
need for flexibility to meet a range of customer expectations. An
Ecommerce Fulfillment
increased reliance on new technology, including the federal mandate
to use electronic logging devices, makes operating a private fleet
more complicated.
Beyond Transportation Savings: Expanding from B2B to B2C: Overcoming the Challenges
Leverage Freight and A Guide to Effective of Private Fleet Management
Parcel Audit Data E-Commerce Fulfillment With Outsourcing
Offered by enVista Offered by Saddle Creek Logistics Offered by J.B. Hunt
Some companies may not understand Today, more and more business-to- Private fleets once seemed to be the
how reliable freight and parcel audit business (B2B) companies are adding best way for companies to carry out
providers can improve strategies and business-to-consumer (B2C) channels. their operations. However, with today’s
results. Leveraging data provided They’re connecting directly with end increased costs and driver shortage,
by transportation insights is key to customers for better engagement, companies may want to consider an
unlocking valuable information and improved control of their brand, and alternative. Outsourcing can provide
identifying your supply chain’s weak greater profitability. To learn how many benefits to your business,
spots. This free whitepaper introduces B2C fulfillment differs from B2B and while dodging obstacles that your
the steps needed to make the most of what you need to know to deliver the company might face with a private
your freight and parcel audit data, so optimal customer experience, check fleet. To discover the advantages of
you can make informed decisions. out Saddle Creek’s latest free e-book. outsourcing over using a private fleet,
download this free whitepaper.
podcast
Mark Nix
Fulfillment Innovations
> Kardex Remstar vertical
buffer module: The LR 35
vertical buffer module is
designed to pick small parts
quickly in warehouses. It
comes with picking software
that lets users optimize routes
and accurately pick goods.
Additionally, the module easily
integrates into existing systems
and serves as a storage solution
as well.
> UNEX roller rack: Designed to boost order picking efficiency, the roller
rack improves sight lines and access to products for warehouse workers.
Inventory is replenished from the back without interrupting order picking
in front. SKU storage is up to seven times denser per bay than pallet rack
storage, which means up to 80% less travel time for pickers.
read range, accuracy, and motion tolerance, letting it scan and Tel Aviv, starting in
September 2019. To support
even poorly printed barcodes. this new service, the cargo
airline awarded contracts to
WTA Aviation and Swissport
> 3PL BlueGrace Logistics is and includes verified real- capabilities. It includes in Israel. Sales agent WTA
helping shippers find the time data with qualification load affinity analysis, which will market the 22 tons of
right truck for their loads with and compliance information. identifies shipments that daily cargo capacity onboard
its Carrier File inside BlueShip can be combined into a Virgin Atlantic’s Airbus
TMS, a new proprietary data > GlobalTranz Enterprises multi-movement route, and A330-300 flights while
mining platform that filters launched GTZamp carrier match functionality, Swissport will provide cargo
through carrier records to (Automated Movement which matches loads with handling services for the air-
find optimal transportation Planning), a digital freight carriers based on factors line at its warehouse terminal
options for every shipment. matching solution with such as volume covered, at Ben Gurion International
Carrier File contains more multi-movement planning on-time performance, and Airport.
than 500,000 carrier files and predictive analytics seasonality.
SAVE UP TO $300!
on Conference or Get FREE Exhibit Pass!
Register by August 22 at PARCELforum.com
SADDLE UP...
for the only conference dedicated to the warehousing,
picking, packing, distribution and delivery of parcels.
PARCEL FORUM19
DALLAS OCT0BER 28-30
THE SMALL-PACKAGE SUPPLY CHAIN SHOW
POWERED BY
TRANSPORTATION PARTNER GLOBAL LOGISTICS TECHNOLOGY PARTNER TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT PARTNER MATERIAL HANDLING PARTNERS SHIPPING SYSTEMS TECHNOLOGY PARTNER CONFERENCE CONTENT PARTNER
SCHOOLING
THE PEAK SEASON
Soaring back-to-school order volumes
have supply chain managers sharpening their
skills and fine-tuning fulfillment operations.
RECORD
SPENDING
Families with children in
elementary through high school
plan to spend an average of
$976.78
K12’s peak distribution season— Calcuso needs to do its homework.
the number of course material kits sent The largest e-commerce distributor
to students spikes from about + $34 from 2018 of educational and office supplies in
400 to 13,000 + $7 from record-setting 2017 Germany handles surging back-to-
per day. • school order volumes across Europe,
$80.7B
with the Descartes pixi warehouse
With the help of UPS, K12 passes the management system.
test. Each year K12 sends: Projected 2019 spending The solution gets going as soon as
• 1.2 million books on back-to-school and Calcuso consumers place an order
• 500,000 customized kits back-to-college shopping online, communicating with the
• 114,000 laptops down from last year’s company’s existing e-commerce
$82.8 billion
• 77,000 printers due to the lower number of households platform, customer relationship
with children in elementary through management platform, carrier
high school in the U.S.
In 2018, UPS processed 6,000 different platforms, and external sales channels
• to help Calcuso master its entire supply
types of items for K12, totaling nearly
SOURCE: NATIONAL RETAIL FEDERATION
10 million individual pieces. At the chain with minimal manual intervention.
end of the school year, UPS helps K12
sort about 4 million returned items so Calcuso is now studying the
they can be recycled, refurbished, and possibility of expanding operations
reused for the next school year. in North America.
Few franchises in history succeed in winning three consecutive championships, but of those who do,
history remembers them as one of the greatest of all time. Echo is proud to join this elite category of
three-peat champions in being voted as this year’s 2019 Inbound Logistics #1 3PL.