Comparative Analysis on Bobcat versus Wheelborrow

Manual loading with wheelborrow

Manning / shift Shifts per day Manning / day

Boiler 1 1 3 3
Boiler 2 1 3 3
Boiler 3 1 3 3
Boiler 4 1 3 3
Boiler 5 1 3 3
Boiler 6 1 3 3
Total 6 18
Labor cost, Php per day per man 600
Total cost per day, Php 10,800
Total cost per month, Php 324,000
Total cost per year , Php 3,888,000
Additional cost for labor benefits, 25% 972,000
Total Labor cost, Php 4,860,000
Unit cost of wheelborrow 2,500
Usage rate of wheel borrow / 1 month 12
Number of wheelborrow used per year 72
Total cost of wheelborrow per year, Php 180,000

Grand Total cost per year, Php 5,040,000

Difference, Php per year 1,023,797
 Loading with Bob cat

Manning / shift Shifts per day Manning / day

1 3 3
3
Labor cost, Php per day per man 600
Total cost per day, Php 1,800
Total cost per month, Php 54,000
Total cost per year , Php 648,000
Additional cost for labor benefits, 25% 162,000
Totla Labor cost, Php 810,000
Unit cost of Bobcat, Php 1,800,000 R 135 , 0.31 cu.m. bucket
Useful life of loader 10,000 hours
Useful life of loader 417 days
Cost of diesel fuel / liter , Php 43
Fuel usage , liters / hr 3.785 liters
Operating hours per day 24
Operating hours per month 720
Operating hours per year 8,640
Fuel consumption per year 32,702
Fuel cost per year 1,406,203
Grand Total cost per year, Php 4,016,203
R 135 , 0.31 cu.m. bucket cap.

say 1 unit / year

1 gallon / hr