Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rationale
A butcher or Meat shop business appears to be not only extremely profitable, but
also recession-proof. Individuals must eat even in the face of adversity. Because meat is
consumed on a daily basis, the industry doesn’t have any downtime – unless it’s during
Lent. Meat products have higher profit margins than other commodity goods.
Due to the African Swine Fever 2019 outbreak, many countries including
Philippines have taken an action, directing all government agencies including Local
Government Units to strictly implement and comply with the National Zoning and
Movement Plan for the prevention and control of ASF. Selling pork raised at one’s
residence is a popular, profitable way for Philippines citizens to make a living. Both pork
and chicken are the top consumed meats, but pork is the top consumed meat in the
country. The National Meat Inspection Service (NMIS) is an agency under the
Department of Agriculture which regulates all matters related to meat inspection and
Leyte, making it for the entrepreneurs to have a good opportunity to enter the butchery
industry. ASF is the worst disease to hit the Philippine swine industry in recent years.
private sector and veterinarians, seeks to control the spread of ASF and assist in the
repopulation of farms affected by the disease. During the implementation of the
prevent the entry and exit of pigs, pork, and pork products takes place.
These protocols negatively affect the livelihood of the families of Meat shop
owners that depends on pigs as a source of income, as means to capitalize savings, and as
‘safety nets’ during time of hardships. The LGU’s indemnification funds or “ayuda” to
the meat shop owners who are swine raisers whose hogs are intentionally depopulated,
and their suppliers of pigs that are not affected of ASF, are their primary hope for
survival. When the executive order has been lifted up, the meat shop business in
The outbreak jeopardizes several meat shop owners in their industry. The fact that
their business is regulated by the government, it is difficult for them to defy the law.
Some owners are not covered by social programs such as the Social Security System
(SSS) or PhilHealth (Lorenzo,2020). Meat shop owners primarily rely on their daily
sales. Thus, their income depends on their buyers. The more they provide the meat, and
the more the customers buy their products, the more they generate income. Most of the
owners are not covered by SSS or PhilHealth since they do not belong to a certain
social programs.
The main key of the study is finding the level of impact of “Bantay ASF sa
Baranggay” to the daily sales of meat shop owners, if there is a significant difference on
their sales before and during the implementation of the protocols. Believing that the result
will assist meat shop owners in understanding the situation if ever the ASF rises again, or
other phenomena that affects their business. Aims to enlighten all the precautionary
measures that should be followed, further knowledge on the compliance on the rules and
regulations imposed by the government and the possible consequences to those who
Our motivation for the thesis is that we both are interested in this topic, since it is
very relevant and it may affect our future in working life. Because of the changes that had
to be made in the middle of the outbreak, the changes could become the new normal in
the
future. So, we feel like this is the right time to research now in the midst of possible
change.
We are keen to find the changes that the ASF Outbreak brought to the managing part of
awareness about the level of impact between the daily income of meat shop owners
before and during the implementation of “Bantay ASF sa barangay”. Believing the fact
that there are many meat shop owners in Barangay Combado who are affected, and for
This study was anchored on the Prospect Theory, which was submitted by
Tversky and Khaneman (1992) and The Meat Inspection Code of the Philippines Act No.
9296.
The Prospect Theory views the concept that it is an advantage to consider current
situation positively for this will leads on selecting risky options. It facilitates prediction
into the near future about how a manager makes a decision during uncertainty.
The law underpinning this study is the Republic Act 9296, also known as The
Meat Inspection Code of the Philippines. It is an act to strengthen the country’s meat
inspection system to assure safety and quality of meat and meat products for human
Hence, the “Bantay ASF sa Barangay” serves as the independent variable and the
daily income of the meat shop owner is dependent on the imposed implementation. All
aspects of their business operations declined ever since the implementation of the local
ordinances and protocols, thus, affecting all the elements composing their business, such
as the shop itself, their stocks/supplies, suppliers, and also its income. The relationship
between the income of the meat shop owners before and during the implementation of the
Demographic Profile
Years of Operation
Annual Income
Average numbers of weekly customers before and during the protocol
was implemented
Impact of “Bantay ASF sa Barangay” to the daily sales of the meat shop
owners
Challenges that each meat shop owner is facing during the implementation of
“Bantay ASF sa Barangay”
Figure 1. Theoretical and Conceptual Framework of the Study
Prospect Theory. This theory as described by Tversky and Khaneman (1992) Prospect
individuals make a strategic choice between probabilistic alternatives where risks are
into the near future about how a manager makes a decision during uncertainty. Decisions
are based on judgements. Judgements are assessments about the external state of the
world. They are made specially challenging under conditions of uncertainty, where it is
In connection with the study, the theory is closely related to the concept of
strategic choice and managerial decision-making under condition of risk. The decision
made by the meat shop owner may be associated with strategic choice, such as choosing
new suppliers and other alternatives to keep their business in the long run. On the other
with the meat shop owner’s alternatives to maintain their business despite the ASF
outbreak, it includes relocation of their business, acquiring new suppliers, and new
pricing strategies. The concept of adaptation aims to analyze the factors between the
environmental context and organizational structure, assuming the idea that the greater the
that is the country’s sole national controlling and competent authority on all matters
pertaining to meat inspection and hygiene both for locally produced and imported meat. It
was created under Presidential Decree No. 7 as National Meat Inspection Commission
and renamed as National Meat Inspection Service under R.A. 9296, otherwise known as
“The Meat Inspection Code of the Philippines, “As amended by R.A. 10536. NMIS is
tasked to formulate, promulgate and implement laws, policies, programs and projects
governing the post- harvest flow of meat in order to protect the interest and welfare of
consumers and promote the development of the livestock and meat industry. The Bantay
government, the private sector, and other organizations was launched as a way to mitigate
the spread of ASF. The program aims to improve biosecurity, implement strict
monitoring using biosensor test kits, and support the repopulation or restocking of swine
Hog repopulation and “Bantay ASF sa Barangay” (BABay ASF) program — led by the
Department of Agriculture (DA) in partnership with the local government units (LGUs),
hog raisers’ groups, and the private sector — is gradually boosting the local swine
industry towards recovery. The DA through its Agricultural Credit Policy Council
(ACPC) has initially set aside P500 M for lending to backyard raisers and micro and
small enterprises (MSEs) under its Agri-Negosyo (ANYO) loan program. As of July 30,
2021, the ACPC has lent P119.5 M to 1,274 small hog farmers and MSEs.
The law emphasized the necessary measures that would be implemented to secure
the health and welfare of the Filipinos. The recent strike of the ASF outbreak affects not
only the Hog raisers and Meat Industry but also the people, economy, and other sectors in
all aspects. Supply of pork and pork-related products suddenly decreased, especially on
those area which has a high record of ASF cases. In the study, the daily income of the
meat shop owners is the main focus since the issuance of local ordinances on the
implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay the operation of their business had to stop
temporarily. As for the lifting of the said checkpoint to prevent the entry and exit of pork
products, and the declaration of Barangay Combado as ASF-Free area, the delivery of
supplies continues as well as the operation of meat shop businesses. The depopulation of
hogs leads to shortage of supplies, and the new price ceiling that has been set for the
products lead to the decrease of income which is unusual from the income before the
crisis. With the above-mentioned theory and law, the researchers perceived that the issues
and challenges encountered by the meat shop owners which drastically affects their daily
income is in relation with the implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay. Hence the
The schematic diagram in Figure 1 outlines the flow of the study. It presents the
theory and law which supports the claim of the present study: the Prospect Theory as
alternatives where risks are involved and the probability of different outcome is unknown
and the Meat Inspection Code of the Philippines Act which states that it is a specialized
regulatory agency in the Department of Agriculture that is the country’s sole national
controlling and competent authority on all matters pertaining to meat inspection and
hygiene both for locally produced and imported meat. The diagram suggests that the
Prospect Theory and The Meat Inspection Code of the Philippines Act are the premises of
this study to examine the relationship between the daily income of the meat shop owners
before and during the implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay, and the possible
intervention to be proposed.
Barangay” to the daily income of meat shop owners in Barangay Combado, Maasin City.
1.3.1 Before
1.3.2 After
2. What is the level of impact of “Bantay ASF sa Barangay” to the daily sales of
3. What are the daily sales of the meat shop owner before and during the
4.1 Before
4.2 After
5. What are the challenges that the meat shop owners are facing during the
the impact?
There is a significance difference between the daily sales of meat shop owners
The study aims to determine the impact of the implementation of “Bantay ASF sa
Barangay” to the daily income of meat shop owners to gain additional information that
might be helpful for them. This study will help the meat shop owners to have the
knowledge of the policies and ordinances that are being implemented that needs strict
compliance. This will give them an idea on how to make strategies if ever they will face
uncertainties that might badly affect their business. This study will help their customers
to adjust and to know the policies and ordinances that are being implemented as they are
the one of those who buys the products that the meat shop owners produced. The
Barangay council will learn from the problems, solution, and recommendations in this
paper that will help them in developing programs that will be benefited by the entire
constituents. Future researchers could also use this as a reference which could help them
come up with new knowledge that the researchers haven’t discussed yet in this study.
Furthermore, other Local Government Unit could use this study as a guide and reference
Barangay” to the daily income of meat shop owners in Maasin City proper, specifically in
Barangay Combado, Maasin City. This study is limited only to the 10 purposively and
Definition of Terms
For a better understanding of this study, the following terms are defined in the
ACPC (Agricultural Credit Policy Council) - synchronize all Agri-credit policies and
also tasked to monitor and evaluate the economic soundness of all credit programs.
Butchery - the work of slaughtering animals and preparing them for sale as meat
business
DA (Department of Agriculture) - is the executive department of the Philippine
Agriculture which regulates all matters related to meat inspection and hygiene
business, or individual
Pork Products - These products may include blood, bones, hides, skin, lard, feet (pig's
Product - a product is an object, or system, or service made available for consumer use
as of the consumer demand; it is anything that can be offered to a market to satisfy the
This chapter presents review of literature and studies related to the impact of the
implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay to the daily income of meat shop owners.
This attempt to review references that will be useful in relation to annual income of the
business, Implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay, sales of meat shop owners before
and during the ASF outbreak, the challenges encountered, and other factors influencing
the level of impact of Bantay ASF sa barangay to the daily sales of meat shop owner that
Annual Income
Annual income according to Business terms, is the total earnings within a one-
year period for a person or a business. It is common to mention the annual income on job
vacancy ads and on business reports. When speaking about annual income it is important
to make the correct distinction. There are two types of annual income. These are gross
annual income and net annual income. Gross annual income is the amount of money
earned before any deductions. For an employee, gross annual income includes wages,
bonuses, tips and any other financial incentives. Gross income for an employee is also
called gross pay. For a business gross annual income is the total revenue per annum
before the costs and other deductions are calculated for. Net annual income is the amount
of money earned after all the deductions have been made. In the case of an employee, the
net annual income is found by deducting all taxes and other fees to be paid from the gross
annual income. This is also called net pay. Net annual income for a business has already
factored in taxes, production costs and other costs associated with running the business.
the resources at its disposal. In the other words, the ability to earn profit is called
of the important tools for the efficient performance of any enterprise. Gnanasooriyar
efficiency and management guide to greater efficiency. Profitability is the entity's ability
to "produce" gain. Market economy requires profitability in the enterprise, after paying
taxes, not just to cover all its costs, but also to ensure expanded reproduction and
prosperity. Therefore, all these scholars confirm the authenticity of many economists that
the profitability is one of the important indicators for the efficient operation of an
enterprise.
The Bantay ASF sa Barangay program (BABay ASF), aims to control African
swine fever (ASF) and revive the livelihoods of both backyard and commercial swine
farmers through biosecurity, surveillance, and monitoring, as well as restocking of swine
farms affected by the disease. In the third quarter of 2019, the Philippines confirmed its
first case of African swine fever (ASF) in Rizal Province. More than a year later, over
400,000 hogs have been culled, thousands of barangays have been infected, and at least
P56 billion in losses were declared in the local hog industry due to the highly contagious
disease that is ASF. The first case of African Swine Fever (ASF) was reported in the
Philippines although it has been plaguing most parts Asia. Since then, even with the
constant efforts to stop its spread, it has reached various regions in the country, Eastern
Visayas is no exemption with Leyte being the province greatly affected. Municipalities in
the eastern part of Leyte province is now suffering from the mortalities of pigs that could
lead to severe economic loss. With this rising challenge in the local swine industry, the
government through the Department of Agriculture and its attached agencies has doubled
its efforts in mitigating the effects of ASF starting in the barangay level.
Mindanao. The program aims to improve biosecurity, implement strict monitoring using
PCR and ASF Nanogold biosensor test kits, and support the repopulation or restocking of
swine farms affected by the ASF. The program will also help affected local hog raisers in
their search for funding sources for alternative livelihood projects either from the
On January 10,2022 an executive order regulating the entry and movement of live
hogs, pork, pork-related products, and by-products into and within the province of
Southern Leyte and establishing African Swine Fever (ASF) preventive and control
measure was released. This aims to intensify the risk management, surveillance and
implementation in the barangay level. This would also provide capability building and
awareness to Barangay Biosecurity Officers (BBO). BBOs will serve as field responders
which the buyer receives the offering and the seller gets something of value in return
Edward and Ronald (2009) tried to find some antecedents of price sensitivity and
concluded that price sensitivity was positively related to perceived brand parity and
parity, and brand loyalty appear to mediate the influence of involvement on price
innovativeness as most of the product purchase decisions were being made based on price
rather than the brand or accessibility (Abdullah, Muhammad and Robel 2014). Chen and
Guan (2013) found price discounts can stimulate sales because of the downward demand
curve, but they can depress sales because consumers expected a lower price in the future.
An increase in price sensitivity strengthened the aforementioned two effects, and the
dominant effect determines whether price discounts can generate sales. Graciola, Toni
and Lima (2018)’s study results showed that store price image positively impacted on
customer repurchased intentions, with low and high price levels moderating these effects.
Price sensitivity also presented moderating effects. Andrée (2020) conducted a study of
They found Millennial consumers were less price sensitive in regards to product attribute,
and favor ethical consumption over price. Wang, Pham and Dand (2020) focused on the
link between perceived food quality and environmental consciousness and organic food
purchase intention. The result was that price sensitivity moderates the relationship
between perceived food quality and organic food purchase intention. Furthermore, price
certain firm actions undertaken by service employees can improve consumer loyalty,
product positioning, pricing, or online commerce. Given the wide variety of themes, Caro
et al. propose a classification of the topics representing the central challenges in retail
management, considering eight categories: (1) Inventory, (2) Pricing, (3) Assortment, (4)
Incentives, (5) Online retail, (6) Industry Studies, (7) Returns, and (8) Other topics.
Similarly, Mou et al. provide a complete review of the current state of research on
retail store operations using a classification of six research items/themes and seven
operational decisions. In their literature review, the authors classified a total of 255
journal articles, published from 2008 to 2016. The authors concluded that more than two
thirds of all papers fall in the “Inventory Management Decision” category, and, within
this category, that more than 95% focus on the themes of “Uncertainty”, “Perishability”,
and “Availability”.
A review of these themes quickly and clearly establishes their importance for
positively impacts both perishability and availability. Several studies have been made on
how to manage uncertainty. Among other relevant findings, it is curious to note that high
inventory levels make in-store logistics more prone to execution errors, causing a higher
risk for product shrinkage and shelf stockouts. In fresh products categories,
“Perishability” is the biggest concern of food retailers, not only because it negatively
affects the customer perception of quality, but also because of the monetary loss it
creates. Perishable products account for over 40% of sales in grocery chains, and, with
factors such as a limited lifetime, high safety and quality requirements, and short lead
time, they are requirements that are highly complex to manage Finally, “Availability” is
the online channels. Product availability, is defined as the probability of having a product
in stock when a customer order arrives. The higher the stock level on the shelves, the
lower the likelihood of an out-of-stock (OOS) situation; nevertheless, this would lead to
an increase in the capital holding costs, as well as the risk for product shrinkage.
References
Battisti, M., Beynon, M., Pickernell, D., & Deakins, D. (2019). Surviving or thriving:
The role of learning for the resilient performance of small firms. Journal
of Business Research, 100, 38–50.
Beach et al., (2008), R H Beach, F Kuchler, E Leibtag, C Zhen: The Effects of Avian
Influenza News on Consumer Purchasing Behavior: A Case Study of
Italian Consumers’ Retail Purchases.
Chen and Huang, (2019), Q Chen, J Huang: Measure the impact of epidemic events on
agricultural product market prices Statistics & Decision
Duan and Liu, (2020), C Duan, L Liu: The dynamic relationship of price fluctuation of
livestock and poultry products with the influence of African swine fever
in China: From the perspective of public opinion management
Gregory, G., Harvie, C., & Lee, H. (2002). Korean SMEs in the wake of the financial
crisis: Strategies, constraints and performance in a global economy, mimeo,
University of Wollongong
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A
TRANSMITTAL LETTER
August 5, 2022
Good day!
We, the researchers of Saint Joseph College, are currently doing a study entitled “The
level of impact of the Implementation of Bantay ASF sa Barangay to the daily sales of
Meat shop owners” as our research for the degree Bachelor of Science in Accounting
Information System at the Saint Joseph College, Maasin City. The study will help the
researchers to identify the level of impact of the implementation of ASF protocol to the
meat shop owners in Barangay, Combado, Maasin City.
In connection with this, we would like to ask your good office to allow us to conduct our
research study in your vicinity. We believe that you are with us in our enthusiasm to
finish the requirement as compliance for our subject and to develop our well-being. We
hope of your positive response on this humble matter. Your approval to conduct this
study will be greatly appreciated.
Sincerely yours,
The Researchers
Noted by:
Ivan Jake Gonzales, CPA Nacional V. Mercado
Adviser City Mayor
TRANSMITTAL LETTER
August 5, 2022
Dear Sir/Ma’am:
We, the researchers of Saint Joseph College, are currently doing a study entitled “The
level of impact of the Implementation of Bantay ASF sa Barangay to the daily sales of
Meat shop owners” as our research for the degree Bachelor of Science in Accounting
Information System at the Saint Joseph College, Maasin City. The study will help the
researchers to identify the level of impact of the implementation of ASF protocol to the
meat shop owners in Barangay, Combado, Maasin City.
I have identified you as a meat shop owner here in Barangay Combado, Maasin City. For
this, I am hoping that you would be able to participate in our study. I would like to ask
your permission that I will be allowed to collect your data that will be used in the
research. Rest assured that all your information will be treated with utmost respect and
confidentiality.
Please allow us to make initial contact with you or your representative so we can further
discuss the details of our research. Our contact number is 0915-982-4505 and email
address is kennethdiabordo@gmail.com .
We are looking forward to your positive response and favorable action on this study.
Sincerely yours,
The Researchers
Noted by:
Ivan Jake Gonzales, CPA
Adviser
APPENDIX B
INFORMED CONSENT
Upon reading and signing this document, I am giving my full consent to be a
participant of the research that will be conducted by Kenneth G. Diabordo of Saint
Joseph College, Maasin City, Philippines. I understand that it will be part of their study,
and it will focus on “the level of impact of “the implementation of Bantay ASF sa
barangay to the daily sales of meat shop owners”.
I understand that I am being asked to participate in a research study at Saint
Joseph College. If I agree to participate in this study, I will be interviewed and be asked
to answer some questions in the questionnaire for approximately 20 minutes regarding
the issue concern. The interview will be recorded. No identifying information will be
included when the interview is transcribed. There is no known risk associated with this
study. The interviews and survey will be conducted right here in my shop wherein my
business is situated. I also understand that the researchers may contact me for more
information in the future.
I am fully aware that I may not participate in the study if I am younger than 18
years old. I realized that my participation in the study is entirely voluntary and I may
withdraw from the study at any time I wanted to. If I decide to discontinue my
participation in this study, I will continue to be treated in a usual customary fashion.
I understand that all the data gathered in this study will be kept confidential.
However, the information may be used in research publications. If I need to, I can contact
the researchers anytime during the study.
The study has been explained to me. I have read and understand this consent
form, all my questions have been answered and I agree to participate. I understand that I
will be given a copy of the consent form.
This study will benefit the respondents, constituents, barangay council, and local
government units.
_________________ ______________________
Date Respondent’s signature
_________________ ______________________
______________________
______________________
______________________
Researcher’s Signature
APPENDIX C
RESEARCH INSTRUMENTS
Survey Questionnaire
“The impact of the implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay to the daily sales of
meat shop owners”
Instructions: Please answer the questionnaire to the best of your knowledge. Kindly
place a check mark “☐” in the appropriate box that represents your response and write
down correct information on the space provided. Rest assured that your response will be
treated with utmost confidentiality.
I. Demographic Profile
2. Years of operation:
☐Below 5 years
☐5 to 10 years
☐11 to 15 years
☐20 years over
3. Annual Income:
☐Below 300,000
☐300,001 – 500,000/year
☐501,000 – 800,000/year
☐1,000,000 over/ year
During the outbreak aside from having a meat shop business, I also hae
other sources of income
III. Instruction: Choose the responses from the statement below by checking the
appropriate boxes.
Daily sales of meat shop before the implementation of Bantay ASF sa barangay
☐Below 10,000
☐10,001 – 40,000/day
☐40,001 – 60,000/day
☐60,001 – 80,000/day
☐80,001 – 100,000/day
☐100,000 over/day
IV. Interview
APPENDIX D
CURRICULUM VITAE
Kenneth G. Diabordo
Barangay: Olot, Tolosa, Leyte
Birthdate: March 15,2000
Mother: Ma. Grace G. Diabordo
Father: Pedro O. Diabordo
Religion: Roman Catholic
Civil Status: Single
Nationality: Filipino
Mobile No: 0915-982-4505
Email ad: kennethdiabordo@gmail.com
EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND
Elementary Malbago Elementary School
Malbago, Bontoc, Southern Leyte
2011 – 2012
CURRENT AFFILIATIONS:
Junior Philippine Institute of Accountants (JPIA) – SJC Chapter
______________________