Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH PAPER
Mari Vainionpää*, Kati Salla*, Flávia Restitutti*, Marja Raekallio*, Jouni Junnila , Marjatta Snellman* &
Outi Vainio*
*Department of Equine and Small Animal Medicine, Pharmacology and Toxicology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine,
University of Helsinki, Finland
4Pharma Ltd, Espoo, Finland
Correspondence: Mari Vainionpää, Department of Equine and Small Animal Medicine, Pharmacology and Toxicology, Faculty of Veterinary
Medicine, Koetilantie 7, FI-00014 University of Helsinki, Finland. E-mail: mari.vainionpaa@helsinki.fi
Animals Eight healthy purpose-bred neutered Bea- Conclusions Superficial temperature changes can be
gles (two females and six males) weight seen and detected with thermography. MK-467
14.5 ± 1.6 kg (mean ± SD) and aged 3–4 years. used with MB resulted in increased superficial
temperatures and a decline in rectal temperature
Methods Each dog was sedated four times. Treat- compared to MB alone.
ments were medetomidine 20 lg kg)1 and butorph-
anol 0.1 mg kg)1 (MB) with or without MK-467 Clinical relevance The sedation protocol may influ-
500 lg kg)1 (MK). Both drug combinations were ence core temperature loss, and may also have an
administered IV and IM as separate treatments. A effect on thermographic images.
thermal camera (T425, FLIR) with a resolution of
Keywords butorphanol, dog, medetomidine, MK-467,
320 by 240 was used for imaging.
sedation, thermography.
The dogs were placed in lateral recumbency on
an insulated mattress. Digital (DFT) and metatarsal
footpad temperatures (MFT) were measured with
Introduction
thermography. Thermograms and rectal tempera-
ture (RT) were taken before and at 3, 10, 20, 30, 45 Medetomidine is an alpha-2-adrenergic agonist,
and 60 minutes after treatment. which is used widely in small animal practice. In
addition to its beneficial sedative and analgesic
Results At 60 minutes after drug administration, effects on the central nervous system, medetomidine
MFT was higher (p < 0.001) after MB+MK also causes some unwanted cardiovascular side
1
Thermographic imaging in sedated dogs Mari Vainionpää et al.
effects, such as vasoconstriction and bradycardia. 2003), modern infrared cameras are 10 times more
The medetomidine-induced vasoconstriction is sensitive. Thus thermography will detect changes in
mediated via post-synaptic alpha-2-adrenoceptors peripheral blood flow from the resulting changes in
located in vascular smooth muscle, and it results in heat loss (Varjú et al. 2004; Vianna & Carrive
an increased systemic vascular resistance and car- 2005; Stewart et al. 2007).
diac afterload (Pypendop & Verstegen 1998). Cen- The aim of this study was to record superficial and
tral alpha-2-adrenoceptors mediate cardiovascular rectal (for core) temperature changes in dogs during
depression, such as a decrease in blood pressure, sedation with medetomidine and butorphanol with
heart rate and cardiac output, by means of central and without MK-467. The superficial temperature
sympathetic inhibition and vagal activation was recorded with a thermal camera as an indicator
(Kobinger 1983). of potential peripheral heat loss in dogs.
In dogs, butorphanol is used frequently in com-
bination with medetomidine in order to improve the
Materials and methods
sedative and analgesic (Ko et al. 2000; Kuo &
Keegan 2004).
Animals
The peripherally acting alpha-2-adrenergic
antagonist MK-467 (also termed L-659’066) selec- Eight healthy purpose-bred neutered Beagle dogs (two
tively blocks the alpha-2-adrenoceptors outside the females and six males) were used for this study. The
blood-brain barrier (Clineschmidt et al. 1988). It dogs weighed (mean ± SD) 14.5 ± 1.6 kg, and were
has been shown to attenuate the peripherally aged between 3 and 4 years old. They were consid-
mediated cardiovascular effects of medetomidine ered healthy based on a thorough clinical examina-
(Enouri et al. 2008) and dexmedetomidine (Pagel tion, complete blood count and serum chemistry.
et al. 1998; Honkavaara et al. 2011) in dogs, and The study protocol was approved by the National
also in sheep (Bryant et al. 1998; Raekallio et al. Animal Experimentation Board of Finland (ESAVI-
2010). However, the effects of MK-467 on dex- 2010-07734/Ym-23) and the Ethical Committee of
medetomidine-induced sedation in dogs are minimal the Viikki Campus at the University of Helsinki.
(Honkavaara et al. 2008; Restitutti et al. 2011).
Hypothermia is a well known problem in sedated
Study design
and anaesthetized animals. It can occur in animals
sedated with medetomidine (Vainio 1989) when no All dogs received four different treatments in a
active attempts have been made to maintain the randomized crossover design, with a minimum of
body temperature. However, it has been suggested 14 days’ washout period between treatments. The
that the peripheral vasoconstriction and the central drugs used in the treatments were medetomidine
redistribution of blood induced by alpha-2-agonists (Dorbene 1 mg mL)1, laboratories Syva S.A., León,
may enhance the maintenance of body temperature Spain), butorphanol (Butordol 10 mg mL)1, Inter-
by reducing cutaneous heat loss (Sinclair 2003). vet International B.V., Netherlands) and MK-467
Therefore, preventing the medetomidine-induced (Merck, Sharpe & Dohme, PA, USA). 10 mg of
peripheral vasoconstriction by MK-467, although MK-467 was solubilised into 1 mL of saline.
reducing peripheral resistance, may further impair The treatments consisted of the following combi-
thermoregulation. nations: medetomidine 20 lg kg)1 and butorphanol
Thermography is a non-invasive and safe method 0.1 mg kg)1 (MB) with or without MK-467
of detecting and visualizing changes in superficial 500 lg kg)1 (MK). Both combinations (MB and
temperature in animals (Schweinitz von 1999; MB+MK) were given IV and IM as separate treat-
Turner 2001; Kı́zková & Kunc 2007; Levet et al. ments. All drugs were mixed in the same syringe
2009). The temperature of an area of the body is a prior to administration. In treatments without MK,
product of cell metabolism and local blood flow saline was added to the syringe in order to keep the
(Head & Dyson 2001). If the superficial blood flow is administered volume constant. A catheter was
enhanced, the skin temperature increases due to inserted in the cephalic vein (for each dog) to enable
warmer blood coming to the surface from larger medications. After catheterization, the dogs were
vessels. Whilst the human hand and fingers are allowed to rest in the room for a minimum of 1 hour.
sensitive enough to detect only a ‡2 C difference in The dogs were then placed in lateral recumbency
temperature on the animal’s skin (Holmes et al. on a mattress made of insulating material, without
2012 The Authors. Veterinary Anaesthesia and Analgesia
2 2012 Association of Veterinary Anaesthetists and the American College of Veterinary Anesthesiologists
Thermographic imaging in sedated dogs Mari Vainionpää et al.
any covering blankets, in an ambient room tem- Three different temperatures were measured:
perature of 21 C. The thermal conductance of the rectal (RT), digital footpad (DFT) and metatarsal
10 mm insulation mattress (Nomalen, NMC Cell- footpad (MFT). MFT and DFT were recorded from
foam Oy, Finland) was low (0.039 W mK)1); the the thermograms using the software. The fourth or
material is used mainly for the insulation of houses. fifth digital footpad was used for the temperature
The same mattress was used for all cases. measurement depending on which footpad was
pointing directly to the camera (Fig. 2).
Thermometer, thermal camera and software
Statistical Analysis
A digital rectal thermometer for animals (Vet-Temp
1831, Microlife, Switzerland) was used to measure The differences in the change from baseline values
the rectal temperature. A thermal camera with a between the treatment groups and routes of
resolution of 320 by 240 pixels (T425, FLIR administration were assessed with repeated mea-
Systems Inc., Sweden) was used for imaging. sures analysis of covariance (RM ANCOVA) models.
The freeware FLIR QuickReport 2.1. (FLIR, 2011) The models consisted of a baseline covariate, the
was applied to interpret the thermographicy images. main effects of treatment, the period and time point
The person taking the thermal images was unaware of measurement as well as two-way interactions of
of the treatment. period*time point and treatment*time point as fixed
effects and the main effect of dog, in addition to two-
way interaction terms of period*dog and time
Thermal imaging
point*dog as random effects. Group differences were
The upper hind leg of the recumbent dog was the estimated from the model parameters. Ninety-five
region of interest in this study. The hind leg was percent confidence intervals (95% CIs) and p-values
positioned on a holder made of the insulation mat- were calculated for the estimated group differences.
tress material to minimize the effects of the sur- A p-value of <0.05 was considered statistically
roundings or heat from a human hand holding the significant. All temperature results are reported in
leg (Fig. 1). Thermographs and rectal temperatures degrees centigrade.
were taken before administering the treatment All statistical analyses were performed with the
(baseline) and repeated 3, 10, 20, 30, 45 and SAS System for Windows, version 9.2 (SAS
60 minutes after the treatment. Institute Inc., NC, USA).
Results
(a) The RT was lower with MB+MK than with the MB
treatment regardless of the route of administration
(b)
(e) (d)
(c)
(b)
(a)
Mean rectal temperatures by treatment group and Mean metatarsal footpad temperatures by treatment
time point group and time point
40.0 40
39.5 38 § * *° *° *° *°
§
38.0
*° 32
37.5 30
37.0 28
36.5 26
36.0 24
MB+MK IV MB IV MB+MK IV MB IV
35.5 22
MB+MK IM MB IM MB+MK IM MB IM
35.0 20
0 3 10 20 30 45 60 0 3 10 20 30 45 60
Time point Time point
Figure 3 Mean rectal temperatures (±SD) in degrees C in Figure 4 Mean metatarsal footpad temperatures (±SD) in
dogs (n = 8) treated with MB or MB+MK IV or IM. degrees C in dogs (n = 8) treated with MB or MB+MK, IV
*Statistically significant difference between MB+MK IM or IM. *Statistically significant difference between MB+MK
and MB IM (p < 0.05) and between MB+MK IV and MB IV and MB IV (p < 0.05) and between MB+MK IM and
IV (p < 0.05). MB IM (p < 0.05). §Statistically significant difference
between MB+MK IV and MB+MK IM (p < 0.05).
MB
IM
MB
IV
MB+
MK
IM
MB+
MK
IV
the responses, which leads to a significant difference regulate heat loss, and vasodilative agents can
between the treatments over time. When comparing enhance cooling during drug effect (Dı́az & Becker
the routes of administration with the MB+MK 2010).
treatment, differences were seen in the MFT and Rectal temperature is routinely used as an indi-
DFT. The superficial temperature change was faster cator of core temperature and an animal’s thermal
with intravenous than with intramuscular admin- status although it is known that many factors (for
istration. With MB, no differences were seen in any example, the presence of faeces and local blood flow)
of the responses between the administration routes. can influence the results (Robinson et al. 1998). In
The results indicated that when the peripheral blood the present study, we opted for RT measurement
flow was enhanced by a given medication since it is used commonly in clinical settings.
(MB+MK), heat loss was also, as expected, signifi- In humans, the heat emitted from the body is not
cantly higher and could, if not treated appropriately, trapped inside insulating fur as in dogs, and direct
lead to hypothermia more easily than with MB measurement of skin temperature is possible (Gaze-
alone. rani & Arendt-Nielsen 2011; Park et al. 2011). In
In our study, the dogs were isolated from the table the present study the thermograms were taken from
using an insulating mattress. This did not seem to the soles of the dogs’ feet (footpads) that can more or
be completely adequate for keeping the RT from less be compared to human skin. In our study the
declining further when the animals were sedated dogs were acclimatised to the room temperature for
with MB+MK as opposed to MB. Heat is known to a minimum 1 hour before starting the study,
dissipate through the skin via radiation, convection, although a study on horses has suggested that no
conduction and evaporation (Turner 2001), conse- adjustment or equilibration time is required for
quently cooling the skin surface. Sedated and performing thermographic imaging (Tunley & Hen-
anaesthetized animals have an impaired ability to son 2004). Since exercise has also been shown to
2012 The Authors. Veterinary Anaesthesia and Analgesia
2012 Association of Veterinary Anaesthetists and the American College of Veterinary Anesthesiologists 5
Thermographic imaging in sedated dogs Mari Vainionpää et al.
Kobinger W (1983) Central blood pressure regulation: Robinson JL, Seal RF, Spady DW et al. (1998) Comparison
involvement of presynaptic or postsynaptic, a1- or of esophageal, rectal, axillary, bladder, tympanic, and
a2-adrenoceptors? Chest 83, 296–299. pulmonary artery temperatures in children. J Pediatr
Kuo W, Keegan R (2004) Comparative cardiovascular, 133, 553–556.
analgesic, and sedative effects of medetomidine, mede- Schweinitz von DG (1999) Thermographic diagnostics in
tomidine-hydromorphone, and medetomidine-butorph- equine back pain. Vet Clin North Am Equine Pract 15,
anol in dogs. Am J Vet Res 65, 931–937. 161–177.
Levet T, Mertens A, Devisscher L et al. (2009) Distal limb Simon EL, Gaughan EM, Epp T et al. (2006) Influence of
cast sores in horses: risk factors and early detection exercise on thermographically determined surface tem-
using thermography. Equine Vet J 41, 18–23. peratures of thoracic and pelvic limbs in horses. J Am
McCafferty DJ (2007) The value of infrared thermography Vet Med Assoc 12, 1940–1944.
for research on mammals: previous applications and Sinclair MD (2003) A review of the physiological effects of
future directions. Mammal Rev 37, 207–223. alpha2-agonists related to the clinical use of medetom-
Pagel PS, Proctor LT, Devcic A et al. (1998) A novel al- idine in small animal practice. Can Vet J 44, 885–897.
pha2-adrenoceptor antagonist attenuates the early, but Stewart M, Webster JR, Verkerk GA et al. (2007) Non-
preserves the late cardiovascular effects of intravenous invasive measurement of stress in dairy cows using
dexmedetomidine in dogs. J Cardiothorac Vasc Anesth infrared thermography. Phys Behav 92, 520–525.
12, 429–434. Tunley BV, Henson FMD (2004) Reliability and repeat-
Park J, Jang WS, Park KY et al. (2011) Thermography as a ability of thermographic examination and the normal
predictor of postherpetic neuralgia in acute herpes zoster thermographic image of the thoracolumbar region in
patients: a preliminary study. Skin Res Technol 18, 88– the horse. Equine Vet J 36, 306–312.
93. Turner TA (2001) Diagnostic thermography. Vet Clin
Pypendop BH, Verstegen JP (1998) Hemodynamic effects North Am Equine Pract 17, 95–113.
of medetomidine in the dog: a dose titration study. Vet Vainio O (1989) Introduction to the clinical pharmacology
Surg 27, 612–22. of medetomidine. Acta Vet Scand Suppl 85, 85–88.
Raekallio MR, Honkavaara JM, Vainio OM (2010) The Varjú G, Pieper CF, Renner JB et al. (2004) Assessment of
effects of L-659,066, a peripheral a2-adrenoceptor hand osteoarthritis: correlation between thermographic
antagonist, and verapamil on the cardiovascular influ- and radiographic methods. Rheumatology 43, 915–
ences of dexmedetomidine in conscious sheep. J Vet 919.
Pharmacol Ther 33, 434–438. Vianna DML, Carrive P (2005) Changes in cutaneous and
Restitutti F, Honkavaara JM, Raekallio MR et al. (2011) body temperature during and after conditioned fear to
Effects of different doses of L-659’066 on the bispectral context in the rat. Eur J Neurosci 21, 2505–2512.
index and clinical sedation in dogs treated with dex-
medetomidine. Vet Anaesth Analg 38, 415–422. Received 21 December 2011; accepted 10 April 2012.
Ring EFJ (2006) The historical development of thermom-
etry and thermal imaging in medicine. J Med Eng
Technol 30, 192–198.