Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Criminal Anthropology
Forensic Anthropology
4. Stature Determination
Odontology
Relevant History
The history of forensic odontology is written in the bible as it depicts the
scenario in the Garden of Eden. Bringing back the story of Adam and Eve where
the latter convinced Adam to put a bite mark in apple. Therefore, the history of
bite mark evidence (forensic dentistry) began with eating of forbidden fruit in the
Garden of Eden (Balachander, 2015)
Delhi gang rape case. In the history of India, criminal prosecution was
attained using dental forensics in providing evidence leading to death sentences.
Comparison was made on the arrangement of the teeth with the bite mark left on
the victim. According to the dental expert the photographs of bite mark seen on
the victim and structure of the dentition of the accused proved with some
accuracy. Six were arrested and among the five accused, two of the dentitions
matched with a bite mark (Voelker, 2020).
Forensic Odontology
Bite marks are often found on children who are abused, in a fight between
two persons, sexual assault, homosexual activities and rape.
Forensic dentists assist in crime solving by studying teeth and teeth
impressions. Dental records are often used to identify people. Because teeth are
one of the hardest substances in the human body, they are frequently well
preserved. Dental x-rays or records showing filings, position of the teeth, etc. can
help the forensic dentists find a match of teeth to individual. Eighty percent of the
time teeth impressions are used to identify unknown victims.
PHOTOGRAPHY
Photograph for court exhibit vary depending on what case being heard. In trial
preparation and case review, scene and autopsy photographs and reports are
investigated which are necessary for conviction and post-conviction appeals.
Existing documents must be photographed and enlarged before use as exhibit in
court. It should bear proper notations and arrows to illustrate what is being presented for
the clear understanding of those who have interest in the case. The enlarged
photograph paves way for interaction between witness or lawyers which allow more
effective connection with the court in presenting strategy in the case.
Iris Recognition
Iris recognition is one of the most important biometric recognition methods
because the iris texture provides many features such as freckles, coronas, stripes,
furrows, crypts, etc. Those features are unique for different people and distinguishable
which make it possible the differentiation among individuals (Shideh & Salarian, 2019).
It is the process of identifying people by the pattern of their irises through the use of
software and cameras designed to specifically collect iris images.
Iris recognition or iris scanning is the process of using visible and near-infrared
light to take a high-contrast photograph of a person’s iris. It is a form of biometric
technology in the same category as face recognition and fingerprinting.
DNA Fingerprinting
Deoxyribonucleic Acid (DNA) Profiling
The analysis of the DNA is known as the most powerful tool for human
identification because of its application in identity testing and parentage determination
(De Ungria, 2003). The development of forensic DNA technology had shown great
relevance in the administration of justice. The use of DNA technology has gained
acceptance in the field of forensic and life sciences, and courts in the USA, Europe and
Asia have availed of DNA evidence in deciding cases. There is no reason, then, why
DNA proof, when relevant under our Rules on Evidence, should be treated differently in
the Philippines (Vilches, 2002).
DNA in sexual assault cases
According to De Ungria (2003), the application of DNA in sexual assault
examines the transfer of biological material, between assailant and victim. The best
biological samples that may be used as DNA evidence are those obtained from the
victim and her clothing worn at the time of the assault. Sperm DNA is generally stable
up to 72 hours in the female reproductive organs, provided that the victim does not
bathe or wash during this time.
Sources of DNA may come from the.
a. Victim
b. Human handlers such as crime scene investigators, medico legal officers,
forensic analysts and lawyers
c. The perpetrator of the crime.
When do we say that the suspect is excluded as source of evidence?
When there is two or more mismatches between the evidentiary stain and
suspect’s reference sample necessarily excludes him as the source of the evidentiary
sample. The result of mismatches does not mean innocence, somehow it shows that
the suspect is not the source of the evidentiary sample.
When do we say that the suspect as possible source of evidence?
When the reference sample of a suspect is consistent with the DNA profile of the
evidentiary sample, then the suspect remains as a candidate source of the sample.
DNA Fingerprinting
DNA fingerprinting, method of identification that compares fragments of
deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) also called DNA typing. DNA is the genetic material found
within the cell nuclei of all living things. In mammals the strands DNA are grouped into
structures called chromosomes. Except for identical twins, the complete DNA of each
individual is unique.
A DNA fingerprint is constructed by first extracting a DNA sample from body
tissue or fluid such as hair, blood, or saliva. DNA (DNA fingerprinting) was invented by
Alec Jeffreys in 1984 at the University of Leicester while studying the human myoglobin
gene. It was originally used to detect the presence of genetic diseases and soon came
to be used in criminal investigations and forensic science. The first criminal conviction
based on DNA evidence in the United States occurred in 1988. In criminal
investigations, DNA fingerprints derived from the evidence collected at the crime scene
are compared to the DNA fingerprints of suspects. The DNA evidence can implicate or
exonerate a suspect.
Uses of DNA Base Pattern Identification
1. Indicate paternity and maternity so it can determine biological parenthood.
2. Determine whether a suspect was at a crime scene. DNA can be found in blood,
hair, skin cells, semen or other genetic evidence left at a crime scene.
3. Determine the identity of a victim.
4. Used in the diagnosis of inherited disorders because early detection of these
disorders allows the parents and medical staff to prepare for proper treatment of
a child.
Problems in DNA Fingerprinting
The repeating patterns can only present a probability of the DNA match retrieved.
The probability might be 1 in 20 billion, so it is a reasonable match, but unlike a
fingerprint, repeating DNA patterns are not completely unique each person. A
probability might also be 1 to 20 billion, and this would leave a lot of doubt. The
probability values assigned help to determine the chance that the DNA fingerprint
belongs to the person in question. There is also room for error in probing techniques
used to acquired the DNA pattern. This present a problem for court cases because it
could give false results. Unlike fingerprints, there is no way to change the DNA
fingerprint. It cannot altered by any known treatment. It is the same for every cell, tissue
and organ in a person. DNA fingerprinting is also a way of giving a quantitative
assessment to an identification match. This allows for a better idea of the reliability of
the results.
Poroscopy
Points to Consider
1. Number of Pores
2. Distance between Pores (Interspacing)
3. Size of Pores
4. Shape of Pores
5. Position of the Pores on the ridge
Podoscopy
Podoscopy is the study of the plantar area of the food for the purpose of
identification. It is the scientific examination or study of the soles of the feet. “A term
coined by Wentworth and Wilder as a possible word, if ever needed, referring to the
study of the soles.”
CHIROSCOPY – is the science which deals with the study of the prints of the palms of
the hand.
Greek word:
Cheir – a hand Skopein – to examine
Ridgeology is the study of the uniqueness of all friction ridge skin formations and
their use as a means of personal identification. This term was coined by David
Ashbaugh of the Royal Canadian Mounter Police in 1983.
The term Ridgeology refers to a forensic identification science that is associated
with all the ridges on the volar areas and not just on the fingertips as Dactyloscopy or
fingerprint identification implies.
Dactyloscopy/Fingerprint
History of Fingerprints
In 1880 two major developments were achieved that ushered to a more holistic
acceptance of fingerprint use. Dr. Henry Faulds, an English doctor based in Japan,
wrote to publication Nature on the practical use of fingerprints for the identification of
criminals. His argument was supported by his studies and successful experiments on
permanency of one’s fingerprint. After Fauld’s breakthrough, Sir Francis Galton, a noted
British anthropologist, and scientist Charles Darwin’s cousin, devised the first scientific
method of classifying fingerprint patterns.
It was in 1882 when the first authentic record of official use of fingerprints was
noted in the USA. In 1891, Juan Vucetich, an Argentinian Police, used a system of
fingerprint as criminal identification based on Sir Francis Galton’s studies. Vucetich’s
classification system and individualization of prisoners through the use of fingerprints
were the first practical uses of the fingerprint science by law enforcement personnel
(Holder, Jr.,Et.al.).
Today, the US Federal Bureau of Investigation’s identification files are rapidly
approaching 200 million sets of fingerprints the largest collection in the world.
Origin of Fingerprints
The English first began using fingerprints in July of 1858, when Sir William
James Hershel, Chief Magistrate of the Hoogly district in Jungipoor, India, first used
fingerprints on native contracts. On a whim, and with not though toward personal
identification, Hershel had Rajyadhar Konai, a local businessman, impress his handprint
on a contract.
The idea was merely, to “frighten him out of all thought of repudiating his
signature.” The native was suitability impressed, and Hershel made a habit of requiring
palm prints and later, simply the prints of the right index and middle finger on every
contract made with locals.
According to his calculations, the odds of two individual fingerprints being the
same were 1 in 64 billion. Galton identified the characteristics by which fingerprints can
be identified. These same characteristics (minutiae) are basically still in use today and
are often referred to as Galton’s details.
He was able to discover the three families of fingerprint patterns – Arch, Loop &
Whorl. He is also credited for being the first scientist of friction skin identification who
established the first Civil Bureau of Personal Identification in London, England.
An Argentine Police Official began the first fingerprint files based on Galton
Pattern types. He developed his own system of classifying prints that was officially
adopted in Argentina and was used in most Spanish Speaking Country.
In 1892, Inspector Eduardo Alvarez, taking direction from Vucetich took digital
impression in crime scene. This led Vucetich in making the first criminal fingerprint
identification. He was able to identify a woman by the name of Rojas, who had
murdered her two sons and cut her own throat to place blame on another person. Her
bloody print was left on a door post proving her identity. She confessed of the murder.
On 2 April 1891, Henry was appointed to the office of the Inspector General of
the Bengal Police. In 1892 the police force adopted the anthropometric measuring
system devised by Bertillon for the identification of criminals.
Henry became interested in the work of Galton and others concerning the use of
fingerprints to identify criminals. Henry and Galton exchanged regular letters during
1894 discussing the merits of fingerprints.
In January 1896, Henry issued an order to the Bengali Police that criminal
records forms should not only display a prisoner’s anthropometric measurements but
also the prisoner / s rolled fingerprint impressions.
With the assistance of Azizull Haque and Hem Chandra Bose, Edward Henry
devised his classification system between July 1896 and February 1897. The Henry
fingerprint system enable fingerprints to be easily filed, searched, and traced against
thousands of others. The simple system found worldwide acceptance within a few
years.
On July 1, 1901, the first fingerprint Bureau in the UK was established at
Scotland Yard. His system of identification finally replaces the Bertillonage system of
identification in France (Anthropometry of Alphonse Bertillon).
NEHEMIAH GREW
Published a report before the Royal Society of London England describing the
ridges and the pores of the hands and feet.
MARRY E. HOLLAND
The first American Instructress in Dactyloscopy.
Henry P. Forest – Chief Medical Examiner of New York Civil Service Commission and
an American Preacher in fingerprint science in the US for the New York Civil Service
Commission to prevent applicants from having better-qualified persons to take the test
for them.
Skin is an essential organ of the human body. Finger, palm, and sole
areas of the epidermis display a series of friction ridges taking various forms and
shapes. These volar areas of the skin are known to display friction ridge skin.
Depending on the surface considered, we generally refer to them as fingerprints,
palm prints and sole prints.
The skin consists of two main layers: the outer skin or epidermis, and the
inner or true skin, known the dermis. The epidermis is constantly being worn
away and replaced by new skin generated by the upper layer of the dermis a
papillary layer (stratum mucosum) which is the source of the ridges known as
‘papillary ridges’. The sweat glands, located in the dermis, discharge sweat at the
skin surface through sweat pores found at the top of the ridges.
6 DELTA FORMATIONS
1. A bifurcating ridge
2. A dot
3. An ending ridge
4. A short ridge
5. A converging ridge
6. A point on a long ridge
Component Parts of Fingerprint Patterns
RIDGE SURFACE. The component of the friction skin that forms the fingerprint
impression.
1. RIDGES are the tiny elevation or hill like structures found on the epidermis
layer of the skin containing sweat pores.
2. FURROWS are the canal like impression, or a depression found between the
ridges which maybe compare with the low area in a tire thread.
SWEAT PORES is a small opening found anywhere across the ridge surface where the
sweat comes out.
SWEAT DUCT is a long host like structure that serves as the passageway for the sweat
that exits at its mouth, the pore.
SWEAT GLANDS are found in the dermis layer of the skin which is responsible for the
skin which is responsible for the production of the sweat (watery substance).
TERMINAL PHALANGE Is the bone that is covered with the friction skin having all the
different types of patterns and located near the tip of finger.
MIDDLE PHALANGE Is a phalange of the finger located at the middle of terminal and
basal phalange.
BASAL PHALANGE is a phalange of the finger located at the base portion just below
the middle phalange.
RIDGE FORMATION
Ridges begin to form on the human fetus during the 3 rd to 4th months of the fetus
(5 to 6 months before birth)
DERMAL PAPILLAE – Irregular blunt pegs composed of delicate connective tissues,
protruding, and forming the ridges of the skin, each containing a small opening or pores.
Patterns are the first level of detail used in the identification process and
recognition of the various fingerprint patterns are essential to the fingerprint officer.
a. No Core
b. No Delta
Ridge counting not applicable
Ridge tracing no applicable
1. Plain Arch – a pattern in which the ridges flows from one side to the other
without recurving, usually having a slight upward curve in the center,
making the pattern like an arch.
2. Tented Arch – a pattern where one or more ridges at the center forms an
up trust or make a sufficient rise giving the pattern of a “Tent” giving an
angle of 90 degrees or less.
1. Plain Whorl – a pattern consisting of two deltas and which at least one ridge
makes a turn through one complete circuit. An imaginary line drawn between
the two deltas must touch or cross at least one of the recurving ridges within
the pattern area.
2. Central Pocket Loop Whorl – a pattern which possesses two deltas with
core or more ridges forming a complete circuit which may be oval, spiral,
circular, or any variant of a circle.
Double Loop Whorl – a pattern consisting of two separate and distinct loop formations,
with sets of shoulder and two deltas.
2. Subject Factor. This refers to the physical characteristics of the individual. The
distinction is deciphering finger marks left by a male or female human being. The
friction ridges or prints belonging to young female adults are found to be finer
than those of men.
3. Nature of the surface. Latent fingerprints left on a smooth nonporous surface
will formally retain their usefulness longer than those impressed on a porous
surface. These very rough surfaces may retain the deposits of latent print
residue, but it is impossible to decipher the ridge characteristics left behind due
to the nature of the receiving surface.
Purposes of Sweat
1. Regulate temperature of the body
2. Moisten the skin
3. To remove waste and other skin toxic materials
4. Means of identification
Searching Latent Prints
The search of latent prints at a crime scene gives a big challenge to every police
officer assigned as fingerprint technician. Crime scene processing is very vital in order
to search for evidence like latent prints. Recognition of the areas where one is most
likely to find latent prints is an extremely important step in the examination of latent print
evidence.
Latent Print Development
Latent print development requires knowledge and skills to ensure its relevance in
crime detection and investigation. Once the potential area which is most likely to yield
fingerprint evidence is selected, a variety of techniques such as physical and chemical
methods can be used to process the surface and to develop friction ridge impressions.
Steps in the examination of any potential latent print
1. Visual examination (followed by photography if appropriate).
2. Fluorescence examination (followed by photography if appropriate).
3. Selection and application of an appropriate enhancement method(s) – physical
and/or chemical and/or digital enhancement followed by photography after each
process.
Materials needed for the Collection of Latent Print
One of the oldest, most common and most readily available methods for the
development of latent fingerprints are that of dusting a surface with a fine powder of
contrasting color. The use of powders depends on the object upon which the search is
being conducted. A wide range of powders is commercially available and their
formulation differs with each manufacture.
1. HINGE LIFTERS – come in many different color backgrounds to allow for the
visualization fingerprints developed with different color powders.
2. Rubber lifters – is a plastic cover with adhesive side.
3. Cellophane tape – is a high quality clear transparent tape.
Latent Print Techniques
1. Physical Development
When we touch something we leave behind some of our sweat and this in turn
can leave behind an impression of the ridge detail on your fingerprint, thus leaving a
fingerprint impression.
A fingerprint can be left on many types of surfaces. It can be made visible by
brushing it with a powder or treating it with chemicals in a lab. Similarly, if the fingers are
coated with ink or another substance such as paint, oil or blood, than a permanent
impression may be left on a particular item
2. Chemical Development
A visual chemical reaction between the reagent and one or more of the constituents of
human perspiration, to yield to a colored, luminescent, or radioactive product. In this manner the
ridge detail becomes visible and the prints can be photographed and further manipulated.
The latent fingerprint at the crime scene left behind by a suspect or victim may identify who
was at a crime scene and what he or she touched. It is important for defense attorneys to know,
and to inform the judges, that the techniques used to locate and identify fingerprints are far from
a perfect science. Understanding how fingerprints are located and lifted helps attorneys
recognize if defective analysis was performed by investigators on fingerprint technicians.
Locating Latent Fingerprints
Locating a latent fingerprint often requires vigilance. Latent fingerprints are suspected to
be present on the point of entry, objects attacked and point of exit.
The following are situation where latent prints maybe present:
1. Suspected murder weapon
2. Robbery note
3. Victim’s skin in an assault case
4. Broken window pane
5. Safe vault
6. Cell phone held in a hand
The type of fingerprint left behind usually determines the amount of time and effort
investigation must put into locating the print. Consequently, the type of surface where the latent
fingerprints are located serve as a basis in determining what appropriate development method
is applied.
Lifting a latent print is a means to make a permanent impression of the fingerprint. Lifting a
print can be accomplished on either flat surfaces or round surfaces. Lifting a print usually
involves a rubber tape with an adhesive surface which is applied to the fingerprint, leaving an
imprint on the tape. Often times, a flat object, such as a ruler, will be slowly swiped across the
top of the tape to ensure that there are no bubbles or ripples in the tape that will affect the
imprint. Next, the tape is carefully peeled off the surface and a plastic cover is placed on the
adhesive side of the tape to prevent disruption of the print. Identification information and a
description of the location of the print should be written on the back of the tape or card.
The skin is known as the largest organ and the first line of protection in the human body. It
covers the body from head to toe and is referred to as friction ridge skin. Obtaining legible
recordings of these areas of the skin is vital for subsequent comparisons to latent impression
recovered from crime scene, for comparison against previous records, or for input into
automated fingerprint identification system (AFIS).
Inked prints, record prints, standards, and exemplars are all terms that are used to describe
the recording of these unique details. In taking the inked fingerprints of a living person, it
considers the recording of the rolled impression and plain impression.
Post-mortem Fingerprinting
One of the most challenging, and also rewarding, aspects of latent print examination is
the determination of the identity of deceased individuals. Most human remains are available for
examination soon after death. Hence, fingerprint identification is relatively simple and the
standard procedure of black printer’s ink and post mortem fingerprint cards are utilized.
However, when a body is burned, decomposed, macerated, or mutilated more scientific
measures are employed. The nature of the samples utilized will differ depending on the
condition of the skin and the remains.
PLAIN ARCH A a
TENTED ARCH T t
PLAIN WHORL W w
ACCIDENTAL WHORL X x
NOTE: the diagonal symbol should be used in loops (Radial and Ulnar).
Fingerprint Classification Formula
The original Henry System, as it was adopted by Scotland Yard in 1901, converted ridge
patterns on all 10 fingers into a series of letters and numbers arranged in the form of a fraction.
Key Major Primary Secondary Sub-Secondary Final
Is the summation of all numerical value assigned to whorls appearing in fingerprint chart
which are numerators and denominators plus the pre-established fraction of 1/1. It is always
represented by numerical value.
Steps to be followed:
a. Look for the Whorl Pattern
b. Pairing of the ten fingers print impression into five groups that is:
Pair 1 Right thumb and right index Finger 1 and 2
Pair 1 16
Pair 2 8
Pair 3 4
Pair 4 2
Pair 5 1
2. Secondary Division
This division is obtaining by writing the Capital letter symbols (taken from the index
fingers) and the small letters (from thumb, middle, ring and little finger)
a. By capital letters- all letters appearing at the index finger with the right as the
numerator and left index denominator. (A, T, U, R, W, C, D, X)
b. Small letters- only letter r (radial), a (plain arch), and t (tented arch) are included. (r,
a, t)
3. Sub-secondary Division
This is done by ridge counting of loops and ridge tracing of whorls appearing in the
index, middle, and ring fingers of both right and left hands. It is represented by only letters
using the I-M-O system for the whorl and the I-0 system for loop.
It only shows that arches (plain and tented) are not included in the ridge counting and
tracing but it is represented by a symbol dash (-)
Whorl patterns: Plain, Central, Double or Accidental whorls will be ridge traced and the
result will either be Inner (I), Outer (O) or a Meeting (M).
Loops patterns: Radial and Ulnar will be ridge counted and the answer will be
dependent on what finger they appear.
Index finger: 1-9꞊ I
10 or more ꞊ 0
11 or more ꞊ 0
14 or more꞊ 0
4. Major Division
This is similar to Sub-secondary division though it is applies to the thumb only and ridge
counting has been modified
(1) Whorl patterns꞊ Ridge tracing I, O, M
(2) Loop patterns꞊ Ridge counting S, M, L
(3) Arch patterns꞊ Dash (-)
Tables A Tables B
1-11꞊ S 1-17꞊ S
12-16꞊ M 18-22꞊ M
17 or more ꞊ L 23 or more꞊ L
5. Final Division
This is done by ridge counting of loops and whorls from the two little fingers. In this
division whorls are ridge counted not to be ridge traced.
This division is derived by getting the ridge count of the first loop formation appearing in
the ten fingers except the two little fingers. In case of absence of a loop, the first whorl will
be ridge counted following the rules of ridge counting a whorl under final division.