Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T
his issue of MRDD Research Reviews addresses recent imately 26 days. This posterior site of closure is at approximately
advances in our understanding of normal and abnormal the lumbosacral level. Interaction of the neural tube with the
human brain development. The general emphasis of each surrounding mesoderm gives rise to the dura and axial skeleton,
article is one of the major events of human brain development, i.e., the skull and vertebrae.
beginning with neurulation and proceeding ultimately to my-
elination. The more specific emphases of each article are the Disorders
most recent insights into the individual developmental processes, Disturbances of the inductive events involved in primary
with a particular focus on advances generated by molecular neurulation result in various errors of neural tube closure, which
biological and genetic techniques. The final two articles address are accompanied by alterations of axial skeleton as well as of
the impact of advanced magnetic resonance (MR) techniques in overlying meningovascular and dermal coverings. The resulting
the delineation of the development of brain structure and func- disorders are considered next in order of decreasing severity
tion in the living infant. (Table 2).
Encephalocele PROSENCEPHALIC
Encephalocele may be envisioned DEVELOPMENT dum, the optic nerve chiasm, and the
as a restricted disorder of neurulation, involv- hypothalamic structures. The most
ing anterior neural tube closure. This con- Normal Development prominent of these developments is for-
cept, however, must be understood with Prosencephalic development oc- mation of the corpus callosum, the earli-
the awareness that the precise pathogen- curs by inductive interactions under the est components of which appear at ap-
esis of this disorder remains unknown. primary influence of the prechordal me- proximately 9 weeks, and by 12 weeks an
The lesion occurs in the occipital region soderm. The peak period involved is the independent corpus callosum is definable
in 70%– 80% of cases. In the typical oc- second and third months of gestation, at the commissural plate. Formation of
cipital encephalocele, the protruding with the earliest prominent phases in the the corpus callosum is completed by ap-
brain is usually derived from the occipital fifth and sixth weeks of gestation. The proximately 20 weeks of gestation. Major
lobe and is often accompanied by dys- major inductive relationship of concern insights into the molecular genetic deter-
raphic disturbances, involving cerebel- is between the notochord–prechordal minants of forebrain development have
lum and superior mesencephalon. mesoderm and the forebrain. The induc- been gained in recent years and will be
tive interaction influences formation of discussed in the article by Muenke and
Myelomeningocele much of the face as well as the forebrain, Cohen, this volume.
The essential defect in myelomen- and thus severe disorders of brain devel-
ingocele is restricted failure of posterior neural opment at this time usually result in strik-
tube closure. The occurrence of approxi- Disorders
ing facial anomalies as well.
mately 80% of all lesions in the lumbar Disorders of prosencephalic devel-
Development of the prosencepha-
(thoracolumbar, lumbar, lumbosacral) opment are considered best in terms of
lon is considered best in terms of three
area may reflect the fact that this is the last the three major events described earlier,
sequential events, i.e., prosencephalic forma-
area of the neural tube to close. The i.e., prosencephalic formation from the
tion, prosencephalic cleavage, and midline
neural lesion is represented by a neural rostral end of the neural tube, prosence-
prosencephalic development. Prosencephalic
plate or abortive neural tube–like struc- phalic cleavage, and midline prosence-
formation begins at the rostral end of the
ture in which the ventral half of the cord phalic development (Table 3). The spec-
neural tube at the end of the first month
is relatively less affected than the dorsal. trum of pathology varies from a profound
and beginning of the second month,
The axial skeleton is uniformly deficient, derangement, i.e., aprosencephaly, to
shortly after the anterior neuropore
and an incomplete though variable der- certain disturbances of midline prosence-
closes. Prosencephalic cleavage occurs most
mal covering is present. phalic development (e.g., isolated agene-
actively in the fifth and sixth weeks of
Myelomeningocele and its variants sis of the corpus callosum) that are some-
gestation and includes three basic cleav-
represent the most important examples of times not detected during life.
ages of the prosencephalon: 1) horizon-
faulty neurulation, because affected in- tally to form the paired optic vesicles,
fants usually survive. The major clinical olfactory bulbs, and tracts; 2) transversely Aprosencephaly and Atelencephaly
to separate the telencephalon from dien- Aprosencephaly and atelencephaly
cephalon; and 3) sagittally to form, from are the most severe of the disorders of
the telencephalon, the paired cerebral prosencephalic development. In aprosen-
Table 2. Disorders of hemispheres, lateral ventricles, and basal cephaly, the entire process fails to occur
Primary Neurulation—Neural ganglia. The third event, midline prosence- and the result is an absence of formation
Tube Defects phalic development, occurs from the latter of both telencephalon and diencephalon,
half of the second month through the with a prosencephalic remnant located at
Order of decreasing severity:
Craniorachischisis totalis
third month, when three crucial thicken- the rostral end of a rudimentary brain-
Anencephaly ings, or plates of tissue become apparent; stem. In atelencephaly the anomaly is less
Myeloschisis from dorsal to ventral these are the com- severe in that the diencephalon is rela-
Encephalocele missural, the chiasmatic, and the hypo- tively preserved. These anomalies are dis-
Myelomeningocele, Arnold-Chiari thalamic plates. These structures are im- tinguishable from anencephaly most
malformation
portant in the formation, respectively, of readily by the presence of an intact,
the corpus callosum and septum pelluci- though flattened skull and intact scalp.
2 MRDD RESEARCH REVIEWS ● NORMAL/ABNORMAL HUMAN BRAIN DEVELOPMENT ● VOLPE
Holoprosencephalies of a marked reduction in number of cor-
The holoprosencephalic/holote- Table 4. Disorders of tical neuronal columns but an apparent
lencephalic group of disorders represents Neuronal normal complement of the neurons per
the next most severe derangements of Proliferation—Micrencephaly column, i.e., normal size of columns.
prosencephalic development and specifi-
cally involve prosencephalic cleavage Diminished number of proliferative units Micrencephaly Vera
(?)—“radial microbrain” (genetics
(Table 3). In this category of disorders, unclear) The designation micrencephaly
the malformation of the forebrain may be Diminished size of proliferative units vera refers to a heterogeneous group of
so severe that there is marked disturbance (?)—“micrencephaly vera” disorders that appear to have, as the com-
of formation of both telencephalon and Familial mon denominator, small brain size, the
Autosomal recessive
diencephalon, and the term holoprosen- result of a derangement of proliferation
Autosomal dominant
cephaly is most appropriate. The essential X-linked recessive (Table 4). As discussed previously, in
abnormality is a failure of the horizontal, Genetics unclear (ocular abnormalities) most cases this conclusion cannot be
transverse, and sagittal cleavages of the Chromosomal translocation made unequivocally because of difficul-
prosencephalon. In the more common of Teratogenic ties in quantitating neuronal populations.
Irradiation
the severe cases, in which the telenceph- Metabolic-toxic (fetal alcohol Nevertheless, I refer to cases of micren-
alon remains as a single-sphered structure syndrome, cocaine, cephaly with no evidence of intrauterine
but the diencephalon is somewhat less hyperphenylalaninemia, etc.) destructive disease (e.g., cases secondary
affected, the term holotelencephaly may Infection (rubella, cytomegalovirus) to virus, toxoplasmosis, or fetal vascular
Sporadic (nonfamilial, unknown cause)
be more appropriate. insult), no evidence of gross derangement
of other developmental events (e.g., neu-
Disorders of Midline Prosencephalic rulation, prosencephalic cleavage, or mi-
Development gration of neurons), and no evidence of
The principal disorders of midline present in the subependymal location at severe, early, postnatal destructive dis-
prosencephalic development are consid- every level of the developing nervous ease. In the cases under discussion, the
ered best in terms of the normal events system. This highly critical process clearly brain is generally well formed but is very
centered around the commissural, chias- relates to the ultimate integrity of every small.
matic, and hypothalamic plates. The spe- system within the neural apparatus. The The presumed timing of these dis-
cific disorders observed are shown in Ta- fundamental aspects of this process and its orders involves the period of later prolif-
ble 3. likely sites of regulation are described in erative events by asymmetrical divisions
Agenesis of the corpus callosum, com- the article by Caviness and coworkers, of stem cells, i.e., onset at approximately
plete or partial, is a striking abnormality. this issue. 6 weeks in the human, with rapid pro-
The superomedial aspects of the lateral gression until approximately 18 weeks.
ventricles are deformed by the fibers of Disorders The most severely undersized brains
the cerebral hemispheres that were des- Disorders of neuronal proliferation would be expected to have the earliest
tined to cross in the corpus callosum and would be expected to have a major im- onsets and the most marked deficiency of
that, with agenesis, instead course longi- pact on central nervous system function. neurons in each cortical column.
tudinally as the bundles of Probst. With Because of difficulties in quantitating
partial agenesis, the posterior portion is neuronal populations, however, prolifer- Macrencephaly
nearly always affected. The association ative disorders are difficult to define. The designation macrencephaly
with disorders of neuronal migration may Even when the disorder is so extreme signifies a large brain and is a feature of a
relate to the fact that callosal develop- that the brain is grossly undersized, i.e., heterogeneous group of disorders that
ment and neuronal migration occur con- micrencephaly, or is oversized, i.e., ma- have not been well defined from the
currently in human brain development. crencephaly, it is extremely difficult to neuropathological standpoint. Neverthe-
Absence of the septum pellucidum, like define the nature and severity of the pro- less, it is quite clear that there are several
agenesis of the corpus callosum, is an liferative derangement by conventional entities in which the brain is generally
important clue to the presence of other, techniques. well formed but is unusually large. Ge-
clinically more serious abnormalities of netic varieties, suggestive of a derange-
prosencephalic development or of con- Micrencephaly ment in the developmental program for
comitant developmental events (e.g., Disorders apparently related to im- neuronal proliferation, have been de-
neuronal migration). One prominent ex- paired neuronal proliferation can be di- fined. As with micrencephaly, however,
ample of these disorders is the syndrome vided broadly into the so-called “radial until central neuronal populations can be
of absence of septum pellucidum with microbrain” and “micrencephaly vera” quantified more accurately, the conclu-
schizencephalic cerebral clefts (often mis- (Table 4). sion that we are dealing with proliferative
takenly termed “porencephaly”). disorders can be made only tenuously.
Radial Microbrain
NEURONAL PROLIFERATION In radial microbrain, the extremely NEURONAL MIGRATION
small brain has normal gyral formation,
Normal Development no evidence of a destructive process, and Normal Development
Major proliferative events occur no disturbance of cortical lamination. Neuronal migration refers to the
initially between 2 and 4 months of ges- The conclusion that the disturbance in- remarkable series of events whereby mil-
tation, with the peak period quantita- volves the early phase of proliferative lions of nerve cells move from their sites
tively in the third and fourth months. All events, which generates by symmetrical of origin in the ventricular and subven-
neurons and glia are derived from the divisions of stem cells the total number of tricular zones to the loci within the cen-
ventricular and subventricular zones, proliferative units, is based on the finding tral nervous system where they will re-
MRDD RESEARCH REVIEWS ● NORMAL/ABNORMAL HUMAN BRAIN DEVELOPMENT ● VOLPE 3
previous notions, based almost exclu- The nonlayered variety represents a disor-
Table 5. Disorders of sively on study of autopsy cases, i.e., that der of neuronal migration, and the classic
Neuronal Migration schizencephaly is rare, bilateral, and asso- four-layered variety is a postmigrational
ciated invariably with severe neurological disorder. The first type includes those cases,
Order of decreasing severity
Schizencephaly
deficits, have been shown to be incor- such as those with Zellweger syndrome, in
Lissencephaly—pachygyria rect. The clefts tend to be in the regions which concomitant migrational defects are
Polymicrogyria of the rolandic and sylvian fissures and present in cerebrum as well as in brainstem
Heterotopias involve predominately frontal areas. or cerebellum, or both. In these instances,
Focal cerebrocortical dysgeneses the deepest collection of neurons appear to
Agenesis of corpus callosum may
accompany these disorders. Lissencephaly and Pachygyria represent heterotopic neurons, arrested
In lissencephaly, i.e., “smooth during migration. The second variety of
brain,” the brain has very few or no gyri. polymicrogyria includes those cases with
Two anatomical types of lissencephaly evidence of laminar neuronal necrosis in
can be distinguished. In Type I lissenceph- the cortex after the apparent completion of
side for life. The peak period for this aly, the cerebral wall is similar to that of migration. Such examples of this postmi-
occurrence is the third to fifth months of an approximately 12-week-old fetus. grational polymicrogyria include those
gestation, although neuronal migration The layers consist, from the pial surface, cases associated with carbon monoxide ex-
can be detected in certain areas of the of an outermost relatively cell-poor mar- posure at approximately 20 –24 weeks, as
cerebrum as early as the second month ginal layer, a diffuse cellular layer con- well as with other less well-defined intra-
and slightly after the fifth month. Regu- taining primarily pyramidal and other uterine insults. In these patients, the
lation of the timing and direction of these neurons characteristic of lower layers of sparsely cellular gliotic third layer represents
many simultaneous migrations must be cortex, a zone of heterotopic neurons in an area of laminar cortical necrosis, and the
highly ordered, but only recently has in- columns, and an innermost band of white fourth layer is composed not of heterotopic
sight been gained into these control matter. The pathology indicates that the neurons but of neurons of the deeper layers
mechanisms. These mechanisms and, in diffuse outer cellular layer contains neu- of previously formed cortex.
particular, the insights gained from stud- rons that were destined to comprise the
ies of human disorders by molecular ge- deep layers of cortex but were never dis- Neuronal Heterotopias
netic techniques, are discussed in the ar- placed by subsequent migrations, the The least severe of the migrational
ticle by Walsh, this volume. neurons of which comprise the hetero- disturbances, neuronal heterotopias, are
topic layer. In Type II lissencephaly, the collections of nerve cells in subcortical
Disorders appearance is quite different. The menin- white matter, apparently arrested during
Disorders of neuronal migration ges are thickened and adherent to the radial migration from the periventricular
usually result in overt disturbances of agyric cortical surface. The resulting ra- germinative zones. Such collections are
neurological function. Migrational dis- diographic appearance of the cortex has constant accompaniments of the more
turbances often are associated with clin- led to the term “cobblestone lissenceph- severe migrational disorders. At the other
ical deficits from the first days of life. aly.” The cortex is represented by clusters end of the spectrum, small collections of
Seizures are most often the dominant and circular arrays of neurons, with no neurons in cerebral white matter are not
early neurological sign. Nonetheless, the recognizable organization or lamination, unusual incidental findings at autopsy.
least severe of these disorders (i.e., cere- separated by glial and vascular septae.
bral neuronal heterotopias) is probably Large heterotopic collections of neurons Focal Cerebral Cortical Dysgenesis
present to some degree in all of us. The are prominent. (Dysplasia).
advent of MRI scanning has increased In pachygyria, the features are sim- With the advent of MR scanning
markedly the ability to identify these dis- ilar to those described for lissencephaly and removal of cortical anomalies for in-
orders in vivo, has demonstrated the rel- but less marked. The gyri are relatively tractable epilepsy, there has been increas-
atively high prevalence of the disorders, few, unusually broad, and associated with ing recognition of focal disorders of neu-
and has shown their broad clinical ex- an abnormally thick cortical plate. The ronal migration to cerebral cortex. The
pression (see later discussion). The major microscopic features are similar to lissen- lesions have been described as focal ce-
disorders are listed in Table 5 in order of cephaly, although the abnormalities are rebral cortical “dysgeneses” or “dyspla-
decreasing severity. less marked. sias.”