Delft University of Technology

Assessment of urban freight travel characteristics

A case study of Delhi
Errrampalli, Madhu; Kayitha, Ravinder ; Chalumuri, Ravi Sekhar ; Tavasszy, Loriant A.; Borst, Jeroen ;
Chandra, Satish
DOI
10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.053
Publication date
2020
Document Version
Final published version
Published in
Transportation Research Procedia

Citation (APA)
Errrampalli, M., Kayitha, R., Chalumuri, R. S., Tavasszy, L. A., Borst, J., & Chandra, S. (2020). Assessment
of urban freight travel characteristics: A case study of Delhi. Transportation Research Procedia, 48, 467-
485. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.053

Important note
To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable).
Please check the document version above.

Copyright
Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent
of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons.
Takedown policy
Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights.
We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim.

This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology.

For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to a maximum of 10.
 





   




Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

/G6CHEDGI6I>DC
-:H:6G8=
+GD8:9>6

 
Q


LLL:AH:K>:G8DBAD86I:EGD8:9>6

ScienceDirect
Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485







!


 





  




 
 
   







 







 





! 







#+3/46
!6/3)/5'1
#)/+38/78
$6'375468'8/43
!1'33/3-
'3*
3:/6432+38
$!
/:/7/43
#"+386'1
"4'*
"+7+'6).
378/898+
""
+;


#+3/46
!6/3)/5'1
#)/+38/78
$6'375468'8/43
!1'33/3-
'3*
3:/6432+38
$!
/:/7/43
#"+386'1
"4'*
"+7+'6).
378/898+
""
+;

+1./

 
3*/'



!64,+7746
/:/1
3-/3++6/3-
'3*
+47)/+3)+7

+1,8
%3/:+67/8=
4,
$+).341-=
$%+1,8
#8+:/3;+-



+1,8
$.+
+8.+61'3*7



#+3/46
437918'38
#2'68
/8/+7$ 
 

$.+
'-9+
$.+
+8.+61'3*7



/6+)846
#"+386'1
"4'*
"+7+'6).
378/898+
""
+;
+1./

 
3*/'



1(-%
53)1(5

 
2*
-65

21
64%153246
%1(
/2+-56-'5
%1(
1(-%1
*4)-+,6
64%153246
0%4.)6
-5
):3)'6)(
62
+429
%6
%

2*

%&276


&;
  
2%(
*4)-+,6
'2156-676)5
%4271(

2*
626%/
*4)-+,6
028)0)16
%1(
6,)
%8)4%+)
53))(
2*
647'.5
21
1(-%1

42%(5
-5
%&276

.0,4
'28)45
21/;
 
.0
%
(%;
'203%4)(
62
 
.0
-1
()8)/23)(
'27164-)5
24)28)4
6,)
626%/
64-3

):3)15)5
-1'4)%5)5
%&276


(7)
62
6,)
()/%;5
%6
',)'.32565
&;
!4%153246
)3%460)16
%1(
!4%**-'
2/-')
62//
3/%<%5
)6'
!,)

924.-1+
'21(-6-215
2*
647'.
(4-8)45
%/52
()6)4-24%6)
%5
6,);
924.
*24
/21+
,2745
4)57/6-1+
-1
,-+,
564)55
%1(
*%6-+7)
/)%(-1+
62

%''-()165
!,)
1))(
-5
4)'2+1-<)(
*24
'2//%&24%6-21
%021+56
56%.),2/()45
62
-()16-*;
236-0%/
*4)-+,6
32/-'-)5
%1(
37457)
%
4%3-(

()3/2;0)16
2*
-03428)0)165
1
6,-5
(-4)'6-21
'4)%6-1+
&)66)4
(%6%
%1(
02()/5
%4) 1))()(
62
)1%&/)
3/%11)45
62
&)66)4
34)(-'6

*4)-+,6
028)0)16
%1(
()5-+1
&)66)4
-1*240)(
32/-'-)5
1
6,)
34)5)16
567(;
6,)
*4)-+,6
64%153246
(%6%
,%5
&))1
):,%756-8)/;

'2//)'6)(
62
%55)55
6,)
74&%1
*4)-+,6
',%4%'6)4-56-'5
2*
)/,-
24
6,-5
374325)
6,)
*-)/(
5748);5
1%0)/;
276)4
'24(21
64%**-'

5748);5
%6


/2'%6-215
%1(
*2'%/
32-16
5748);
%6

/2'%6-215
9-6,-1
6,)
'-6;
,%8)
&))1
'21(7'6)(
!,)
4)57/65
'%1
0%.)
%
+22(

(%6%&%5)
62
71()456%1(
6,)
*4)-+,6
',%4%'6)4-56-'5
2*
%
'-6;
%1(
-6
927/(
&)
,-+,/;
75)*7/
-1
()8)/23-1+
*4)-+,6
64%8)/
()0%1(

02()/5
%1(
%/52
)8%/7%6)
%334234-%6)
*4)-+,6
4)/%6)(
64%153246
32/-'-)5
*24
6,)-4
)**)'6-8)
-03/)0)16%6-21
21
6,)
74&%1
42%(

1)6924.
&;
6,)
32/-';
0%.)45
%1(
'21')41)(
%76,24-6-)5


© 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
=
 
!,)
76,245
7&/-5,)(
&;
/5)8-)4
"

This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
!,-5
-5
%1
23)1
%'')55
%46-'/)
71()4
6,)

$
/-')15)
,663'4)%6-8)'20021524+/-')15)5&;1'1(  

Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019
))44)8-)9
71()4
4)53215-&-/-6;
2*
6,)
5'-)16-*-'
'200-66))
2*
6,)
#24/(
21*)4)1')
21
!4%153246
)5)%4',
>
#!



+=;46*7
0G76C
!G:><=I
:A=>
>IN
*JI:G
DG9DC
!D86A
+D>CI
MI:GC6A
/G6K:A


DGG:HEDC9>C<
6JI=DG



;6M




2'/1
'**6+77
:GG6BE6AA>B69=J<B6>A8DB
B69=J8GG>C>8>C



P
 
/=:
JI=DGH
+J7A>H=:9
7N
AH:K>:G
1

/=>H
>H
6C
DE:C
688:HH
6GI>8A:
JC9:G
I=:

3
)
)
A>8:CH:
=IIE8G:6I>K:8DBBDCHDG<A>8:CH:H7N
C8
C9 


+::G
G:K>:L
JC9:G
G:HEDCH>7>A>IN
D;
I=:
H8>:CI>;>8
8DBB>II::
D;
I=:
2DGA9
DC;:G:C8:
DC
/G6CHEDGI
-:H:6G8=
Q
2/-
 

2352-1465 © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.

This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019
10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.053
468 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?


&+)',+"'&


5(,*+7
5$163257
,1
1',$

&=,9>;:=?
4>
,
60D
070809?
49
?30
491=,>?=@.?@=0
:1
,
9,?4:9
,>
4?
;=:A4/0>
>0=A4.0>
0>>09?4,7
1:=
;=:8:?492

0.:9:84.
,9/
>:.4,7
/0A07:;809?
,9/
;7,D>
,
>429414.,9?
=:70
49
4917@09.492
?30
;,??0=9
:1
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
0.:9:84.

,.?4A4?40>
,9/
48;=:A492
;=:/@.?4A4?D
9/4,
>;09/>


?:
 
:1
4?>
"
:9
?=,9>;:=?
,9/
7:24>?4.>
.:8;,=0/
?:
,9

,A0=,20

?:


49
:?30=
/0A07:;492
.:@9?=40>
9/4,9
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
8,=60?
4>
0C;0.?0/
?:
2=:B
,?
,
:8;:@9/

99@,7
=:B?3
$,?0
$
:1
,-:@?


-D
 
/=4A09
-D
?30
2=:B?3
49
?30
8,9@1,.?@=492
=0?,47
,>?8:A492

.:9>@80=
2::/>

:=
.:9>@80=
;,.6,20/
2::/>
"
,9/
0.:880=.0
>0.?:=>
B34.3
3,A0
7,=20
1=0423?

?=,9>;:=?
=0<@4=0809?>
,.=:>>
?30
.:@9?=D
B34.3
4>
2090=,77D
/:90
-D
=:,/
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
9
9/4,
=:,/
1=0423?

.:9>?4?@?0>
,=:@9/

:1
?30
?:?,7
1=0423?
8:A0809?
.:9>4>?492
:1

84774:9
30,AD
/@?D
?=@.6>
,9/

84774:9

7423?
/@?D
?=@.6>
.:A0=492
8:=0
?3,9

 
68
:1
=:,/
7092?3
.,==D492
8:=0
?3,9

&
84774:9
80?=4.

?:9
:1
7:,/
,99@,77D

!B492
?:
;::=
=:,/
.:9/4?4:9>
,9/
.30.6;:>?
/07,D>
?=@.6>
49
9/4,
?=,A07
1:=

/,D>
,
8:9?3
:9
,9
,A0=,20

.:8;,=0/
?:

/,D>
49
/0A07:;492
.:@9?=40>
&
,9/



&30
/07,D>
.:@7/
=,920
1=:8
14A0
;0=
.09?
:1
?480

?,609
49
,
5:@=90D
?:
,
3423
:1

&30
,A0=,20
>;00/
:1
?=@.6>
:9
9/4,9
=:,/>
4>
,-:@?

68
3:@=
,9/
,
?=@.6
49

9/4,
.,9
.:A0=
:97D
 
68
,
/,D
.:8;,=0/
?:
 
68
49
/0A07:;0/
.:@9?=40>
>@.3
,>
?30
'%
,9/
@=:;0

:=0:A0=
:9
,9
,A0=,20
?:?,7
?=4;
0C;09>0>
49.=0,>0>
,-:@?


/@0
?:
?30
/07,D>
,?
.30.6;:>?>
,9/
:9=:,/
1:=

1477492
49
1:=8>
=0<@4=0/
-D
A,=4:@>
2:A0=9809?
/0;,=?809?>
.30.6492
:1
/:.@809?>
,9/
;3D>4.,7
.30.6492
:1
?30

A034.70>
/=4A0=>
,9/
.:9>429809?>
-D
$024:9,7
&=,9>;:=?
!114.0>
,9/
?=,114.
;:74.0
,9/
.:770.?492
3423B,D
?:77
,9/

?,C0>
&30
B:=6492
.:9/4?4:9>
1:=
?30
?=@.6
/=4A0=>
,7>:
/0?0=4:=,?492
,9/
?30D
B:=6
1:=
7:92
3:@=>
=0>@7?492
49
3423

>?=0>>
,9/
1,?42@0
B34.3
70,/>
?:
,..4/09?>
&30=0
4>
49.=0,>492
=0.:294?4:9
49
9/4,
?3,?
?=,9>;:=?
491=,>?=@.?@=0

.:@7/
-0.:80
,
>0=4:@>
-:??7090.6
1:=
1@?@=0
0.:9:84.
2=:B?3
&30
900/
4>
=0.:294E0/
1:=
.:77,-:=,?4:9
,8:92>?

>?,603:7/0=>
?:
4/09?41D
:;?48,7
;:74.40>
,9/
;@=>@0
,
=,;4/
/0;7:D809?
:1
48;=:A0809?>


(/+,
,7<
$6
78'<
5($

&30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
.:9>4/0=>
0734
@=-,9
=:,/
90?B:=6
,>
:-50.?
:1
>?@/D
>
;0=
?30
09>@>
:1
9/4,
09>@>




0734
3,>


84774:9
;:;@7,?4:9
B34.3
=0.:=/0/
,
/0.0994,7
;:;@7,?4:9
2=:B?3
:1
,-:@?
 
&30
49.=0,>0

49
@=-,94E,?4:9
70,/>
?:
2=:B?3
:1
A034.@7,=
;:;@7,?4:9
49
@=-,9
,=0,>
,9/
?34>
>.09,=4:
,..070=,?0>
A,=4:@>
?=,114.

;=:-708>
>@.3
,>
.:920>?4:9
,4=
;:77@?4:9
,9/
=0/@.?4:9
49
>,10?D
&30=0
4>
>429414.,9?
8:809?@8
49
2:A0=9809?
?:

?,60
?30
.4?D
7:24>?4.>
>D>?08
,>
>@>?,49,-70
/0A07:;809?
;=4:=4?D
$0.09?
A0=/4.?
-D
,?4:9,7
=009
&=4-@9,7
 &

:1
9/4,
:9
-,99492


D0,=>
:7/
?=@.6>
?:
09?0=
49?:
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
49
A40B
:1
3423
;:77@?4:9
084>>4:9
-D
?30>0

A034.70>
9
:=/0=
?:
>?@/D
,9/
@9/0=>?,9/
?30>0
4>>@0>
90B
;:74.40>
,=0
900/0/
,9/
499:A,?4:9
900/>
?:
-0

;=:8:?0/
&30
=:,/>
:1
0734
3,A0
9@8-0=
:1
?480
=0>?=4.?4:9>
1:=
2::/>
A034.70>
,9/
?30=0
4>

3:@=>
-,9
1:=
>:80

=:,/>
&30
=0>?=4.?4:9
4>
1=:8


?:



,9/

"
?:


"
1:=
8:>?
:1
?30
=:,/>
49
0734


(('
)25
7+(
5(6(17
78'<

0734
4>
69:B9
,>
:90
:1
?30
8:>?
,4=
;:77@?0/
.4?40>
49
?30
B:=7/
,>
?30
,4=
<@,74?D
49/0C
#
:1
8:>?
,=0,>
4>

,-:A0


0734
4=
":77@?4:9
$0,7?480
#


#
1=:8

?:


4>
49
=,920
:1
2::/
?:
8:/0=,?0
#

8:=0
?3,9


4>
.:9>4/0=0/
@930,7?3D
4=
:B


84>>4:9
1=:8
8:?:=
A034.70>
4>
:90
:1
?30
8,5:=
=0,>:9>

1:=
;::=
<@,74?D
49
0734
&30
?=,114.
.:920>?4:9
:9
0734
=:,/
4>
,>
49?484/,?492
,>
?30
;:77@?0/
,4=
?
B,>
,7>:

=0A0,70/
1=:8
?30
;,>?
>?@/40>
?3,?
,-:@?


1=0423?
A034.70>
.=:>>0/


.:@9?
>?,?4:9>
,?
?30
-:=/0=>
:1
0734
49

,
/,D
$$
 
70,=7D
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
3,>
4?>
1,4=
>3,=0
49
;:77@?4:9
,9/
.:920>?4:9
:1
0734
&30

,A0=,20
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
A034.70>
49
0734
4>
=07,?4A07D
7:B
49
:A0=,77
>4?@,?4:9
:B0A0=
/@0
?:
?480

B49/:B
=0>?=4.?4:9>
-D
7:.,7
,@?3:=4?40>
?30
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
A034.70>
A,=40>
/@=492
/4110=09?
?480
:1
?30
/,D9423?

:=
49>?,9.0
.0=?,49
?D;0>
:1
1=0423?
,.?4A4?40>
02
1@=94?@=0
/074A0=D
8476
A,9
0?.
,=0
,77:B0/
-0?B009



,9/

"
@=492
?3,?
?480
?30
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
A034.70
49.=0,>0>
?:

 
9
?30
9423?
,1?0=



,77

1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
,77:B0/
49
?30
.4?D
=0>@7?492
49
8,5:=4?D
:1
1=0423?
A034.70>
:9
0734
=:,/
90?B:=6
(>
?=@.6>

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 469

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



,9/
,@?:
=4.6>3,B>
1:=8
-,.6-:90
:1
@=-,9
2::/>
8:A0809?
49
0734
1:=
7:920=
/4>?,9.0>
:=
>3:=?
/4>?,9.0>
9:9
8:?:=4>0/
A034.70>
02
,948,7
.,=?
3,9/
.,=?
30,/
7:,/
.D.70
=4.6>3,B
,=0
0C?09>4A07D
@>0/
0>;0.4,77D
49
34237D

.:920>?0/
;,=?>
:1
?30
0734
@;?,


9:?30=
49?0=0>?492
1,.?
4>
?3,?
B4?3
:97490
>3:;;492
>;=00
.:8;,940>
,=0

@>492
:?:=4E0/
&B:
)30070=
&)
?=4;>
@>0/
,>
,
B,D
?:
9,A42,?0
?30
3423
/09>4?D
,9/
.:920>?4:9
:1
0734

 47,9509,
0?
,7



'9/0=>?,9/492
,9/
1:=0.,>?492
1=0423?
8:A0809?>
4>
.=4?4.,7
?:
;7,9
1:=
1@?@=0
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
49
?0=8>
:1
.,;,.4?D

,@2809?,?4:9
:;0=,?4:9
;=0>0=A,?4:9
>,10?D
,9/
>0.@=4?D
090=2D
,9/
0.:9:8D
49A0>?809?
900/>
,9D
/08,9/

1:=0.,>?492
8:/07>
,9/
/,?,
>:@=.0>
,=0
8:=0
,;;=:;=4,?0
1:=
;,>>0920=
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
?3,9
1:=
1:=0.,>?492
1=0423?

8:A0809?>
,9/
@9/0=>?,9/492
1=0423?
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
=0,?492
-0??0=
/,?,
,9/
8:/07>
4>
900/0/
?:
09,-70
;7,990=>

?:
-0??0=
;=0/4.?
1=0423?
8:A0809?
,9/
/0>429
-0??0=
491:=80/
;:74.40>
9
A40B
:1
?34>
?30
:-50.?4A0>
:1
?30
;=0>09?

>?@/D
3,A0
-009
.:9.0;?@,74>0/
,9/
,=0
;=0>09?0/
49
?30
90C?
>0.?4:9

 
%-(&7,9(
$1'
&23(
2)
7+(
78'<

&30
8,49
:-50.?4A0
:1
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
4>
?:
,>>0>>
?30
1=0423?
?=,A07
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
49
,9
@=-,9
,=0,
&30
.4?D
:1

0734
40
,?4:9,7
,;4?,7
&0==4?:=D
:1
0734
 &
9/4,
3,>
-009
>070.?0/
,>
>?@/D
,=0,
1:=
?34>
>?@/D
&30

20:2=,;34.,7
,=0,
.:A0=,20
,9/
?30
=:,/
90?B:=6
1:=
?30
>?@/D
,=0,
:1
&
3,A0
-009
>3:B9
49
?30
42


:=
?34>

;@=;:>0
,9
0C?09>4A0
;47:?
>?@/D
.:9>4>?>
:1
/4110=09?
1407/
>@=A0D>
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
1:=
?30
.4?D
:1
0B
0734

..:=/4927D
?30
80?=4.>
1:=
80,>@=0809?
:1
>@>?,49,-474?D
.4?D
7:24>?4.>
,=0
;=:;:>0/
1=:8
?34>
>?@/D



5*$1,6$7,21
2)
7+(
$3(5

>
?30=0
3,>
-009
A0=D
7484?0/
=0>0,=.3
.,==40/
:@?
49
9/4,
=07,?0/
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
49
@=-,9
,=0,>
?30
;=0>09?

>?@/D
B34.3
1:.@>0>
:9
>@.3
4>>@0>
-0.:80>
8:=0
=070A,9?
..:=/4927D
?30
?=,9>;:=?
>.09,=4:
:1
9/4,
,9/
0734

.4?D
3,>
-009
/4>.@>>0/
49
%0.?4:9


9
?34>
>0.?4:9
?30
900/
1:=
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
:9
1=0423?
?=,114.
,9/
0>?48,?4:9
:1

1=0423?
?=,A07
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
,7:92
B4?3
?30
/0?,47>
:1
?30
:-50.?4A0>
,9/
>.:;0
:1
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
,=0
24A09
&30

/,?,
.:770.?4:9
-D
.,==D492
:@?
A,=4:@>
1407/
>@=A0D>
4>
/4>.@>>0/
49
%0.?4:9

&30
0>?48,?4:9
:1
=0>@7?>
49
?0=8>
:1

1=0423?
?=,114.
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
,=0
24A09
49
%0.?4:9

,9/

=0>;0.?4A07D
&30

1=0423?
A034.@7,=
,9/
?=,A07
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
:1
0734
4>
/4>.@>>0/
49
%0.?4:9

9
?34>
>0.?4:9
?30
90?B:=6
70A07
1=0423?

0>?48,?4:9>
49
?0=8>
:1
A034.70
647:80?0=>
?=,A0770/
(&
1:=
1@?@=0
D0,=>
,=0
,7>:
/4>.@>>0/
%0.?4:9

49.7@/0>
?30

;=:;:>0/
80?=4.>
1:=
>@>?,49,-70
.4?D
7:24>?4.>
1:=
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
49,77D
%0.?4:9

/4>.@>>0>
?30
.:9.7@>4:9>

080=20/
:@?
:1
?34>
>?@/D


+
'$$+"'&
'&
' "*+"
+)"*


(1(5$/

>
809?4:90/
49
?30
;=0A4:@>
>0.?4:9>
?30
8,49
:-50.?4A0
:1
?30
>?@/D
4>
?:
/0A07:;
7:24>?4.>
80?=4.>
1:=
.4?D
:1

0734
9
?3,?
/4=0.?4:9
?30
14=>?
,9/
1:=08:>?
?,>6
4>
?:
.:770.?
?30
90.0>>,=D
/,?,
,9/
,
/,?,-,>0
900/0/
?:
-0

.=0,?0/
-D
.:770.?492
1=0423?
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
/,?,
=:,/
90?B:=6
0.:9:84.
/,?,
0?.
:=
?34>
;@=;:>0
,
9@8-0=
:1

?=,114.
>@=A0D>
3,A0
-009
;=:;:>0/
?:
-0
.,==40/
:@?
&30
/0?,47>
:1
?30
1407/
>?@/40>
.,==40/
:@?
49
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D

,=0
0C;7,490/
49
/0?,47
49
?30
1:77:B492
>0.?4:9


,67
2)
,(/'
859(<6

00;492
?30
:-50.?4A0
:1
?30
>?@/D
49
A40B
?30
1:77:B492
?=,114.
>@=A0D>
3,A0
-009
@9/0=?,609
49
?30
;=0>09?

>?@/D


87(5
25'21
5$)),&
859(<
&34>
4>
?:
0>?48,?0
?30
<@,9?@8
:1
?=,114.
09?0=492
:=
0C4?492
.4?D
:1
0734
,9/
?30

>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=,114.


87(5
25'21
8(67,211$,5(
859(<
&34>
4>
?:
.:770.?
?30
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
:1
1=0423?
?=,114.
09?0=492
:=
0C4?492

.4?D
:1
0734
>:
,>
?:
0>?48,?0
:=4249/0>?49,?4:9
!
?=4;
;,??0=9

470 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?










 









 




 




















 
 














 










 


#"!
 ! 

 
 "




  

!><

.:A:8I:9
.IJ9N
G:6
D;
)6I>DC6A
6E>I6A
/:GG>IDGN
D;
:A=>
)/
6C9
.JGK:N
'D86I>DCH
.DJG8:
"DD<A:
(6EH


2&$/
2,17
859(<
$7
200(5&,$/
5($6
$5.(7
/$&(6
&34>
>@=A0D
4>
?:
.:770.?
?30
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
:1

1=0423?
?=,114.
;7D492
B4?349
0734
>:
,>
?:
0>?48,?0
!
?=4;
;,??0=9


,'
/2&.
5$)),&
859(<
&34>
>@=A0D
4>
?:
0>?48,?0
?30
<@,9?@8
:1
?=,114.
,9/
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=,114.
:9
?30

=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734

&30
/0?,47>
:1
?30
,-:A0
>@=A0D>
,9/
/,?,
.:770.?0/
3,A0
-009
/0>.=4-0/
49
?30
1:77:B492
>0.?4:9>


87(5
25'21

5$)),&
"2/80(
859(<

&30
>429414.,9?
,8:@9?
:1
1=0423?
?=,114.
09?0=>
,9/
70,A0>
/,47D
.4?D
:1
0734
1=:8
/4110=09?
;,=?>
:1
?30
.:@9?=D

?34>
?=,114.
.,9
-0
.,;?@=0/
,?
?30
:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>
9
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
?30=0
,=0
8:=0
?3,9


09?=D
,9/
0C4?

7:.,?4:9>
1=:8
B34.3
?30
1=0423?
?=,114.
.,9
09?0=
,9/
0C4?
1=:8
?30
,/5:49492
>?,?0>
9,807D
'??0=
"=,/0>3
,9/

,=D,9,
:B0A0=
,-:@?

:1
?30
1=0423?
?=,114.
09?0=>
0C4?>
?3=:@23


8,5:=
:@?0=
.:=/:9
09?=D0C4?
7:.,?4:9>

,9/
,..:=/4927D
?30>0
7:.,?4:9>
3,A0
-009
>070.?0/
1:=
/,?,
.:770.?4:9
;@=;:>0
&30
20:2=,;34.
7:.,?4:9>
:1
?30>0
,=0

>3:B9
49
42


&30
/0?,47>
:1
?30>0
7:.,?4:9>
3,A0
-009
24A09
49
&,-70




&:
.:770.?
?30
1=0423?
?=,114.
A:7@80
/,?,
?3,?
,=0
09?0=492
49?:
:=
0C4?492
1=:8
.4?D
8,9@,7
80?3:/
:1

09@80=,?4:9
3,>
-009
,/:;?0/
49
?34>
>?@/D
&30
09@80=,?:=>
3,A0
-009
24A09
>@114.409?
?=,49492
,9/
/0;7:D0/
49
?30

1407/
?:
;0=1:=8
8,9@,7
.:@9?
:1
,77
?30
A034.70>
?D;0>
B34.3
,=0
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492
?30
:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9
&30

>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
1:=

3:@=
/@=,?4:9
>?,=?492
1=:8


?:


&30
09@80=,?4:9
:1
?30
?=,114.

3,>
-009
/:90
49
0A0=D

849@?0
,9/
,..:=/4927D
=0.:=/0/
49
;=0/0>4290/
;=:1:=8,
&30
?=,114.
A:7@80

09@80=,?4:9
:1
A034.70>
3,>
-009
/:90
1:=
,77
?30
A034.70
?D;0>
49
:=/0=
?:
@9/0=>?,9/
?30
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=,114.
49

?3,?
&30
A034.70
?D;0>
8,497D
.:9>4/0=0/
49.7@/0
,77
;=4A,?0
A034.70>
;@-74.
?=,9>;:=?
49?0=80/4,?0
;@-74.
?=,9>;:=?

1=0423?
A034.70>
,9/
9:98:?:=4>0/
?=,9>;:=?
A034.70>
:B0A0=
?30
A034.70>
?D;0>
.:9>4/0=0/
1:=
=0423?
&=,9>;:=?

,=0
/0>.=4-0/
49
42


 
87(5
25'21
5(,*+7
5$)),&
17(59,(:
859(<

;,=?
1=:8
?30
.7,>>4140/
?=,114.
A:7@80
.:@9?
?3,?
3,>
-009
.:9/@.?0/
,?
?30>0


:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>

49?0=A40B
>@=A0D
,7>:
.,==40/
:@?
?:
.:770.?
?30
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
:1
?30
1=0423?
A034.70>
?3,?
,=0
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492

0734
?3=:@23
?30>0
7:.,?4:9>
&30
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
@>492
;=0/0>4290/
<@0>?4:99,4=0
.:8;=4>492
?30

<@0>?4:9>
=07,?0/
?:
A034.70
/,?,
?=4;
/,?,
,9/
.:88:/4?D
/,?,
&30
<@0>?4:99,4=0
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
1:=

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 471

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



 3:@=
/@=,?4:9
,9/
.:770.?0/
/,?,
1=:8
?30
1=0423?
A034.70>
:9
>,8;70
-,>4>
&30
>,8;70
>4E0
.:770.?0/
,?
/4110=09?

:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>
,=0
24A09
49
&,-70


=:8
?30
&,-70


4?
.,9
-0
>009
?3,?
,
?:?,7
:1


>,8;70>
:1
1=0423?

A034.70>
B0=0
49?0=A40B0/
,9/
.:770.?0/
?30
A034.@7,=
,9/
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
/,?,
&30
/,?,
.:770.?0/
,?
?30
,-:A0

:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>
B:@7/
-0
1@=?30=
,9,7D>0/
?:
@9/0=>?,9/
?30
1=0423?
A034.@7,=
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
,9/
?=,A07

-03,A4:@=
:1
1=0423?
A034.70>

/67A:

.:A:8I:9
*JI:G
DG9DC
'D86I>DCH
;DG
!G:><=I
/G6;;>8
6I6
DAA:8I>DC
;DG

#DJG
JG6I>DC

.
*
.6BEA:
.>O:
D;
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H
$CI:GK>:L:9

)6B:
D;
I=:
*JI:G
DG9DC
'D86I>DC

)D
D9:
CI:G>C<
:A=>
M>I>C<
:A=>
/DI6A


*

696GEJG
DG9:G
)#







*


N6
)6<6G
DG9:G
(:=G6JA>


"JG<6DC
-D69





*


-6?D@G>
DG9:G
:A=>
"JG<D6C
MEG:HHL6N
)#


 
 


*


/>@G>
DG9:G
)#
 






*


.>C<=J
DG9:G
)#






*


'DC>
DG9:G





*


EH6G6
DG9:G
"/
-D69
6I
.=6=696G6





*


)#

NE6HH
"=6O>EJG





*


=>AA6
DG9:G
(6NJG
1>=6G


)D>96
'>C@
-D69





*


&6A>C9>
&JC?
DG9:G
.6G>I6
1>=6G


)D>96
-D69








/DI6A
 

48+

6+56+7+387
'8/43'1
/-.;'=

'
44*7
984
"/)07.';


(
44*7
&'3
&



















)
/-.8
422+6)/'1
$69)0
$

*
+':=
422+6)/'1
$69)0
$




+
918/<1+
422+6)/'1
$69)0
$

!><

.:A:8I:9
1:=>8A:H
/NE:H
DCH>9:G:9
JC9:G
!G:><=I
/G6CHEDGI
>C
I=:
+G:H:CI
.IJ9N



2&$/
2,17
5(,*+7
5$)),&
"2/80(
859(<

&30
1:.,7
;:49?
?=,114.
A:7@80
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
;=:;:>0/
B4?3
,9
,48
?:
.:770.?
1=0423?
?=,114.
?3,?
4>
;=48,=47D

;7D492
B4?349
?30
.4?D
&30
49?=,.4?D
8:A0809?>
-D
A,=4:@>
.:880=.4,7
A034.70>
3,A0
-009
.,;?@=0/
49
?34>
>@=A0D

&:
.:770.?
?30
1=0423?
?=,114.
A:7@80
/,?,
?3,?
,=0
09?0=492
49?:
:=
0C4?492
>070.?0/
1:.,7
;:49?
8,=60?
,=0,
8,9@,7

80?3:/
:1
09@80=,?4:9
3,>
-009
,/:;?0/
49
?34>
>?@/D
&30
09@80=,?:=>
3,A0
-009
24A09
>@114.409?
?=,49492
,9/

/0;7:D0/
49
?30
1407/
?:
;0=1:=8
8,9@,7
.:@9?
:1
,77
1=0423?
A034.70>
?D;0>
B34.3
,=0
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492
?30
>070.?0/

1:.,7
;:49?
7:.,?4:9
&30
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
1:=

3:@=
/@=,?4:9
>?,=?492
1=:8


?:


&30

09@80=,?4:9
:1
?30
?=,114.
3,>
-009
/:90
49
0A0=D

849@?0
,9/
,..:=/4927D
=0.:=/0/
49
;=0/0>4290/
;=:1:=8,
&30

?=,114.
A:7@80
09@80=,?4:9
:1
A034.70>
3,>
-009
/:90
1:=
,77
?30
1=0423?
A034.70
?D;0>
49
:=/0=
?:
@9/0=>?,9/
?30

472 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?

<@,9?4?D
:1
1=0423?
?=,114.
49
?3,?
,=0,
&30
A034.70>
?D;0>
.:9>4/0=0/
1:=
=0423?
&=,9>;:=?
,=0
24A09
49
?30
42


&30
>070.?0/
7:.,?4:9>
1:=
?34>
>@=A0D
,=0
24A09
49
&,-70

&30>0
7:.,?4:9>
3,A0
-009
>070.?0/
.:9>4/0=492
8,=60?

,=0,>
,9/
>3:;;492
,=0,>
&30
20:2=,;34.
7:.,?4:9>
:1
?30>0
;:49?>
,=0
>3:B9
49
42



/67A:

.:A:8I:9
'D86I>DCH
ID
DC9J8I
!D86A
+D>CI
.JGK:N
>C
:A=>

=DJGH

.6BEA:
.>O:
D;
!G:><=I

.
)D
!+
D9:
)6B:
D;
I=:
!D86A
+D>CI
)6IJG:
D;
'6C9
0H:JH>C:HH
8I>K>IN

1:=>8A:H
$CI:GK>:L:9



!+


O69EJG
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


*@=A6
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


GN6
+JG6
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


"=6CI6
"=6G
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


*A9
:A=>
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


.=6=96G6
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


(6C96L6A>
.67O>
(6C9>

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:





!+


.=6=96G6

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:
!DD9
"G6>CH
!D99:G





!+


"6O>EJG

!>H=

+DJAIGN





!+


DCC6J<=I
+A68:

-:I6>A
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H





!+


=6C9C>
=DL@

-:I6>A2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H

 



!+


.6GD?>C>
)6<6G

-:I6>A2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H

 



!+


'6?E6I
)6<6G

-:I6>A2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H

 



!+


+>I6BEJG6

-:I6>A2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H





!+


):=GJ
+A68:

-:I6>A2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H





!+


"6C9=>
)6<6G

2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H

 



!+


-6?DJG>
"6G9:C

-:I6>A2=DA:
.6A:
.=DEE>C<
6G:6H





!+


)6G:A6

!DD9
"G6>C





!+


)6?6;<6G=

!DD9
"G6>CH





!+


&:H=DEJG

!GJ>I

1:<:I67A:H






/DI6A
 


48+
#9(>/
'3*/
2+'37
69/8
'3*
&+-+8'(1+
'60+8


2&$/
2,17
5(,*+7
5$)),&
17(59,(:
859(<

;,=?
1=:8
?30
.7,>>4140/
1=0423?
?=,114.
A:7@80
.:@9?
?3,?
3,>
-009
.:9/@.?0/
,?
?30>0

1:.,7
;:49?
7:.,?4:9>

49?0=A40B
>@=A0D
,7>:
.,==40/
:@?
?:
.:770.?
?30
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
:1
?30
1=0423?
A034.70>
?3,?
,=0
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492

?30>0
8,=60?
7:.,?4:9>
&30
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
@>492
;=0/0>4290/
<@0>?4:99,4=0
.:8;=4>492
?30
<@0>?4:9>

=07,?0/
?:
A034.70
/,?,
?=4;
/,?,
,9/
.:88:/4?D
/,?,
&30
<@0>?4:99,4=0
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
1:=
 3:@=

/@=,?4:9
,9/
.:770.?0/
/,?,
1=:8
?30
1=0423?
A034.70>
:9
>,8;70
-,>4>
&30
>,8;70
>4E0
.:770.?0/
,?
/4110=09?
:.,7

":49?
7:.,?4:9>
,=0
24A09
49
&,-70

=:8
?30
&,-70

4?
.,9
-0
>009
?3,?
,
?:?,7
:1

 

>,8;70>
:1
1=0423?

A034.70>
B0=0
49?0=A40B0/
,9/
.:770.?0/
?30
1=0423?
A034.@7,=
,9/
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
/,?,
&30
/,?,
.:770.?0/
,?
?30>0

7:.,?4:9>
3,>
-009
1@=?30=
,9,7D>0/
?:
@9/0=>?,9/
?30
1=0423?
A034.@7,=
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
,9/
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
:1
1=0423?

A034.70>
&30
!=4249

0>?49,?4:9
!
/,?,
,7>:
,9,7D>0/
B4?3
=0>;0.?
?:
?=,114.
,9,7D>4>
E:90>
&+
?:
,>>0>>
?30

0C?0=9,7
?=,A07
,9/
,7>:
?:
.=0,?0
/,?,
-,>0
;=48,=47D
?:
0>?48,?0
?:?,7
1=0423?
?=4;>
,9/
!
8,?=4C
?:
/0A07:;
?=,A07

/08,9/
8:/07>
9,807D
?=4;
2090=,?4:9
,9/
?=4;
/4>?=4-@?4:9
8:/07>


,'
/2&.
5$)),&
"2/80(
859(<

9
:=/0=
?:
,>>0>>
?30
.@==09?
?=,114.
A:7@80
>4?@,?4:9
:9
?30
=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734
.7,>>4140/
?=,114.
A:7@80
.:@9?

>@=A0D>
,?
14A0
7:.,?4:9>
3,>
-009
;=:;:>0/
,9/
?304=
20:2=,;34.
7:.,?4:9>
,=0
>3:B9
49
42


&30>0
>070.?0/

7:.,?4:9>
:9
4/-7:.6
?=,114.
A:7@80
.:@9?
7:.,?4:9>
,=0




$492
$:,/
$,523,?



:99,@23?

"7,.0
!@?0=
4=.70



$492
$:,/
 ,=,49,
 

 
&!
=4/20
,9/




D;,>>

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 473

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



&:
.:770.?
?30
1=0423?
?=,114.
A:7@80
/,?,
?3,?
,=0
;7D492
:9
?30
>070.?0/
7:.,?4:9>
49
?30
.4?D
8,9@,7
80?3:/
:1

09@80=,?4:9
3,>
-009
,/:;?0/
49
?34>
>?@/D
>4847,=
?:
:@?0=
.:=/:9
?=,114.
A:7@80
.:@9?
>@=A0D
&30
09@80=,?:=>

3,A0
-009
24A09
>@114.409?
?=,49492
,9/
/0;7:D0/
49
?30
1407/
?:
;0=1:=8
8,9@,7
.:@9?
:1
,77
?30
A034.70>
?D;0>
B34.3

,=0
.=:>>492
?3,?
84/
-7:.6
7:.,?4:9
&30
>@=A0D
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
1:=

3:@=
/@=,?4:9
>?,=?492
1=:8


?:



&30
09@80=,?4:9
:1
?30
?=,114.
3,>
-009
/:90
49
0A0=D

849@?0
,9/
,..:=/4927D
=0.:=/0/
49
;=0/0>4290/

;=:1:=8,
&30
09@80=,?4:9
:1
A034.70>
3,>
-009
/:90
1:=
,77
?30
A034.70
?D;0>
49
:=/0=
?:
@9/0=>?,9/
?30
>3,=0
:1

1=0423?
?=,114.
49
?3,?
&30
A034.70
?D;0>
8,497D
.:9>4/0=0/
49.7@/0
,77
;=4A,?0
A034.70>
;@-74.
?=,9>;:=?
49?0=80/4,?0

;@-74.
?=,9>;:=?
1=0423?
A034.70>
,9/
9:98:?:=4>0/
?=,9>;:=?
A034.70>
9
.,>0
:1
?=,114.
A:7@80
/,?,
:9
?30

=08,49492
>0.?4:9>
?30
>?@/D
.:9/@.?0/
-D
$$


,?
A,=4:@>
49?0=>0.?4:9>
,9/
84/-7:.6
>0.?4:9
49
0734

3,A0
-009
@?474>0/
..:=/4927D
?30
.@==09?
?=,114.
A:7@80
,?
:?30=
7:.,?4:9>
3,>
-009
0>?48,?0/
1=:8
?3,?


)" !+
)"
!)+)"*+"*
+
,+)
')'&*


5(,*+7
5$)),&
"2/80(

&30
.:770.?0/
?=,114.
/,?,
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
49
?0=8>
:1
3:@=7D
A034.@7,=
?=,114.
/4>?=4-@?4:9
,9/
?=,114.

.:8;:>4?4:9
1:=
,77
?30
7:.,?4:9>
,9/
,
?D;4.,7
3:@=7D
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
?=,114.
A:7@80
,9/
?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
,?
$,5:6=4

:=/0=
 
:9
0734@=2:,9
C;=0>>B,D
4>
>3:B9
49
42

=:8
?30
42

4?
.,9
-0
>009
?3,?
?30
?:?,7
/,47D

A:7@80

3:@=>
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492
0734
?3=:@23
$,5:6=4
:=/0=
4>
49
?30
:=/0=
:1

?3:@>,9/>
,9/
?30
;0,6

3:@=
4>
:..@==492
49
?30
0A09492
-0?B009


,9/


=>
B4?3
,
;0,6
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
?
.,9
,7>:

-0
4910==0/
1=:8
?30
,9,7D>4>
?3,?
,-:@?

,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
;=4A,?0
A034.70>
8,497D
.,=>
,9/
?B:
B30070=>
&30

1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
4>
,-:@?

8,497D
.:9>4>?
:1
::/>
@?:>

&
&
,9/
&


0"'')$
.+3,&
#5
&()$+&
5/& 0"'')$
.+3,&
#5
3&+
5/& 0"'')$
.,/.1)2).-


  1  03$*1

32.
 
.2"+
0"'')$
.+3,&
 &()$+&1

.2"+
0"'')$
.+3,&
 &()$+&1

32.
)$*1("4 &20&.+
 ..%1
&( )$*1("4
31&1   1
 )&1&+ 
31&1  

 4.
!(&&+&01
"01 


 4.
!(&&+&01
 





 
"01









 







 

 

 




 
 



 
 


 
 
 



 

 
 



 





 
 



 
 


 
 




 


 





 


),& ),&












.2"+
")+5
.3+,&


!><

#DJGAN
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
A6HH>;>:9
/G6;;>8
1DAJB:
6C9
/G6;;>8
DBEDH>I>DC
6I
-6?D@G>
DG9:G
:A=>
"JG<D6C
MEG:HHL6N

&30
>@88,=D
:1
,77
?30


:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>
4>
;=0>09?0/
49
&,-70

,9/
?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
4>
;=0>09?0/
49

42

=:8
?30
&,-70

4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
8,C48@8
9@8-0=
:1
A034.70>
49
?30
:=/0=
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>

09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492
?3=:@23
$,5:6=4
:=/0=
1:77:B0/
-D
3,E4;@=
:=/0=
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?



?3:@>,9/>
,9/
,749/4
@95
:=/0=
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>
=:8
42

4?
.,9
-0

4910==0/
?3,?
,-:@?

,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
;=4A,?0
A034.70>
8,497D
.,=>
,9/
?B:
B30070=>
&30
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
4>

,-:@?

8,497D
.:9>4>?
:1

&
&
,9/
&


;7(51$/
5(,*+7
5$9(/

=:8
?30
,9,7D>4>
:1
=:,/>4/0
49?0=A40B
/,?,
,?
?30
>070.?0/


:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>
:A0=,77
;,??0=9
:1
0C?0=9,7

?=,114.
:1
?30
.4?D
:9
,
9:=8,7
B:=6492
/,D
,7:92
B4?3
?304=
.:8;:>4?4:9
B,>
0>?48,?0/
,9/
>3:B9
49
42

&30

=0>@7?>
=0A0,7
?3,?
,
?:?,7
:1
,-:@?


84774:9
A034.70>
09?0=
,9/
70,A0
0734
.4?D
:9
9:=8,7
B:=6492
/,D
B34.3
B,>

,-:@?

 
84774:9
A034.70>
49
 
$$
 
=:8
?34>
=0>@7?
4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
?30
0C?0=9,7
?=,114.
3,>

2=:B9
B4?3

;0=
,99@8
?
.,9
,7>:
-0
9:?4.0/
?3,?
?30
2::/>
?=,114.
1:=8>
,-:@?


:1
?30
?:?,7
?=,114.
B4?3

,9:?30=

:1
?=,114.
4>
.:8;:>0/
:1
>7:B
8:A492
A034.70>
%(
7460
-4.D.70
,948,7
.,=?>
0?.
&30
;,??0=9
:1

0C?0=9,7
1=0423?
?=,114.
49
?30
.4?D
:9
,
9:=8,7
B:=6492
/,D
,7:92
B4?3
?304=
.:8;:>4?4:9
B,>
0>?48,?0/
,9/
>3:B9
49

42

&30
=0>@7?>
=0A0,7
?3,?
,
?:?,7
:1
,-:@?


&3:@>,9/>
1=0423?
A034.70>
09?0=
,9/
70,A0
0734
.4?D
:9
9:=8,7

474 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?

B:=6492
/,D
,9/
,-:@?


:1
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
1:@9/
?:
-0
;,>>492
?3=:@23
?30
.4?D
B34.3
B,>
,7>:
,78:>?

>,80
49
?30
D0,=
 
$$
 

/67A:

.JBB6GN
D;
A6HH>;>:9
/G6;;>8
1DAJB:

=DJGH
6I
>;;:G:CI
*JI:G
DG9DCH
D;
:A=>

.
)D
*JI:G
DG9DC
6GH
JID
JH:H
/2
"

"1
'/
#/
(/
.(1
/DI6A









 



696GEJG
DG9:G











 

G?JC
"6G=
N6



 











)6<6G
DG9:G

 
 

 
 
 
 

 










 


-6?D@6G>
DG9:G


 
 

 


 
 
 



 




 




/>@G>
DG9:G










 





 
 



 


.>C<=J
DG9:G










 















'DC>
DG9:G



 

 
 
 
 
 
 

EH6G6
DG9:G
 

 
 
 








>AH=69
"6G9:C







 

 













"=6O>EJG
DG9:G










 




 
 


 

 


=>AA6
D6G9:G








 
 
 

&6A>C9>
&JC?
 





 






DG9:G









 

 

 
 



 





/DI6A










 

.,-7
$:3
;0+
807.
;0+
<)0+
'

311+5).(0

$58)/6
$
$58)/6
$

$58)/6
$

 <)0+

".)/6-(:6
(2*


33*6
873
 7-+5
'

33*6
%(2
#%

%



$:3
&-++0+5



.2.
86
  #1(00
(56

86+6 873 

  .,
(56




!><

/G6;;>8
DBEDH>I>DC
6I
>;;:G:CI
*JI:G
DG9DCH
D;
:A=>

=:8
?30>0
=0>@7?>
4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
?3:@23
?30
?:?,7
?=,114.
49.=0,>0/
1=0423?
?=,114.
=08,49
>?,29,?0/
,?

:@?0=
.:=/:9>
-0.,@>0
:1
90B
-D;,>>
=:,/>
.:80
,=:@9/
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
>@.3
,>
:4/,=0,?0=
:4/,
C;=0>>B,D

*,8@9,
C;=0>>B,D
@9/74,90>,=",7B,7
"
C;=0>>B,D
0?.
9
.,>0
:1
;,>>492
?3=:@23
?=,114.
&
3,>

,78:>?
 
>3,=0
1:77:B0/
-D
&
,9/
&
3,>
>3,=0
:1
,-:@?


0,.3
%8,770=
::/>
(034.70>
9,807D

,9/

(
3,>
,
>3,=0
:1
,-:@?


:1
;,>>492
?3=:@23
?=,114.
&34>
.,9
-0
,??=4-@?0/
?:
?30
1,.?
?3,?
?30
30,AD
A034.70>

?=,A07
7:92
/4>?,9.0>
.:8;,=0/
?:
7423?
,9/
>8,77
A034.70>











 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 475

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?




)" !+
)"
!)+)"*+"*
"&
+!
)&
)


5(,*+7
5$)),&
"2/80(
$7
2&$/
2,176

&30
.:770.?0/
1=0423?
?=,114.
/,?,
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
49
?0=8>
:1
3:@=7D
A034.@7,=
?=,114.
/4>?=4-@?4:9
,9/
?=,114.

.:8;:>4?4:9
,?
,77
?30
7:.,?4:9>

?D;4.,7
3:@=7D
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
?=,114.
A:7@80
,9/
?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
,?
E,/;@=




Entry Exit
Entry
Exit

472,852

(in 2009) 550,841
GAV LCV
(in 2009)


GAV LCV
28% 23% 23% 24%

HAV
MAV


MAV HAV
26%
 23% 26% 27%
  

 
    

  
 
 




  


 Passing  

Through


GAV
14%
LCV

19%
MAV
18%
Average


HAV
Growth 3% 49%

per annum


6
/DI6A
/G6;;>8




7
!G:><=I
/G6;;>8

!><

+6II:GC
D;
/DI6A
MI:GC6A
/G6;;>8
6I
*JI:G
DG9DCH
D;
:A=>

%,-E4
,9/4
4>
>3:B9
49
42

=:8
?30
42

4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
?30
?:?,7
/,47D
A:7@80

3:@=>
09?0=492

,9/
0C4?492
E,/;@=
%,-E4
,9/4
4>
49
?30
:=/0=
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
,9/
?30
;0,6
3:@=
4>
:..@==492
49
?30
84/9423?

-0?B009

,9/
 
=>
B4?3
,
;0,6
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?

1=0423?
A034.70>
=:8
?30
42

4?
.,9
,7>:
-0

4910==0/
?3,?
,-:@?

,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
::/>
@?:>
,9/
::/>
(,9>
&
4>
,-:@?

,9/
&
,9/
&
,=0



0,.3
?
.,9
,7>:
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
%7:B
:A492
(034.70>
%(>
,=0
,-:@?




-"&$%/
-##&
+(0)"
3
"%& ("
3," -"&$%/
-##&
+(0)"
3
0"(
3," -"&$%/
-##&
+),+.&/&+*

  ++!.

++!. 0(/&
2("
-0 '.


 1+
2("
-0 '.
 &$%/
-0 '.
 &"."(  *

+/(
-##&
+(0)"

+/(
-##&
+(0)"

 0(/&
++!. 


++!.
0/+
 ++!.
*

 2("
 


"%& (".

"%& (".

-0 '.
++!.


  0/+

  

  

 
1+
&$%/

-0 '.


  2("

-0 '.





 





 




 




 
 




 
 



 
 




 





 



 




 





 



 

 




&)" &)"
!+(/
385
%3081+


!+(/
385

  
+/(
&(3
+0()"  

!><

#DJGAN
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
A6HH>;>:9
!G:><=I
/G6;;>8
1DAJB:
6C9
/G6;;>8
DBEDH>I>DC
O69EJG
.67O>
(6C9>

&30
>@88,=D
:1
,77
?30
1:.,7
;:49?>
4>
;=0>09?0/
49
&,-70

,9/
?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
4>
;=0>09?0/
49
42

=:8

?30
&,-70

4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
8,C48@8
9@8-0=
:1
A034.70>
;0=
/,D
49
?30
:=/0=
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
09?0=492

,9/
0C4?492
?3=:@23
3,9?,
3,=
%,-E4
,9/4
1:77:B0/
-D
E,/;@=
%,-E4
,9/4
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
A:7@80
:1

,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
,9/
3,9/494
3:B6
=0,
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
=:8
42

4?
.,9
-0

4910==0/
?3,?
,-:@?

,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
::/>
@?:
,9/
::/>
(,9
&30
A034.70
?D;0>
:1
&
&
,9/
&
,=0
49

?30
=,920
:1
 


,9/

=0>;0.?4A07D
&30
:?30=
1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
,-:@?







476 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?

/67A:

.JBB6GN
D;
A6HH>;>:9
!G:><=I
/G6;;>8
1DAJB:

=DJGH
6I
>;;:G:CI
!D86A
+D>CIH
D;
:A=>

#6C9
C>B6A
N8A:


.
)D

!+
D9:

)6B:
D;
I=:
!D86A
+D>CI

"1
"
'/
#/
(/
/DI6A

6GI
6GI
->8@H=6L

->8@H=6L




!+


O69EJG
.67O>
(6C9>




 










!+


*@=A6
.67O>
(6C9>















!+


GN6
+JG6
.67O>
(6C9>






 



 




!+


"=6CI6
"=6G
.67O>
(6C9>

















!+


*A9
:A=>
.67O>
(6C9>


 
 











!+


.=6=96G6
.67O>
(6C9>

















!+


(6C96L6A>
.67O>
(6C9>



 













!+


.=6=96G6


 










 



!+


"6O>EJG











 



!+


DCC6J<=I
+A68:













 



!+


=6C9C>
=DL@

 
 











!+


.6GD?>C>
)6<6G


















!+


'6?E6I
)6<6G

       


!+


+>I6BEJG6

















!+


):=GJ
+A68:


 














!+


"6C9=>
)6<6G
















!+

-6?DJG>
"6G9:C

 













!+


)6G:A6



 







 


!+

)6?6;<6G=

 















!+


&:H=DEJG














 

<)0+

".)/6-(:

".)/6-(:


2.1(0
(57 33*6 33*6 33*6
%(2
  



(2*
(57 33*6
873

807.
;0+


 
$58)/6
$





$:3
;0+

$58)/
$


.,-7


311+5).(0

%+-.)0+
$

 

!><

!G:><=I
/G6;;>8
DBEDH>I>DC
6I
>;;:G:CI
!D86A
+D>CIH
D;
:A=>


,'
/2&.
5$)),&
"2/80(
859(<

9
:=/0=
?:
,>>0>>
?30
.@==09?
?=,114.
A:7@80
>4?@,?4:9
:9
?30
=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734
.7,>>4140/
?=,114.
A:7@80
.:@9?

>@=A0D>
,?
14A0
7:.,?4:9>
3,>
-009
.:770.?0/
&30
.:770.?0/
?=,114.
/,?,
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
49
?0=8>
:1
3:@=7D
A034.@7,=

?=,114.
/4>?=4-@?4:9
,9/
?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
,?
,77
?30>0
7:.,?4:9>

?D;4.,7
3:@=7D
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
?=,114.
A:7@80
,9/

?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
,?
$492
$:,/
 ,=,49,
4>
>3:B9
49
42

=:8
42

4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
?30
?:?,7
/,47D

A:7@80

3:@=>
:9
$492
$:,/
 ,=,49,
4>
,78:>?


?3:@>,9/>
,9/
?30
;0,6
3:@=
4>
:..@==492
49
?30
0A09492

-0?B009


,9/
 
=>
B4?3
,
;0,6
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>
=:8
42

4?
.,9
-0
4910==0/
?3,?
,-:@?

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 477

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



 
,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
;=4A,?0
A034.70>
8,497D
.,=>
,9/
?B:
B30070=>
&30
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
4>
,-:@?


8,497D

.:9>4>?
:1
::/>
@?:>
&
&
,9/
&
&30
>@88,=D
:1
?=,114.
:9
,77
?30
84/
-7:.6
7:.,?4:9>
4>
;=0>09?0/
49
&,-70


,9/
?=,114.
.:8;:>4?4:9
4>
;=0>09?0/
49
42

=:8
?30
42

4?
.,9
-0
4910==0/
?3,?
,-:@?
 
,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1

;=4A,?0
A034.70>
8,497D
.,=>
,9/
?B:
B30070=>
&30
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
4>
,-:@?

8,497D
.:9>4>?
:1
::/>
@?:>
&

&
,9/
&


0"'')$
.+3,&
#5
&()$+&
5/& 0"'')$
.+3,&
#5
3&+
5/& 0"'')$
.,/.1)2).-

  1 
.2"+
0"'')$
.+3,&
 &()$+&1

.2"+
0"'')$
.+3,&
 &()$+&1

  32.
)$*1("4   &20&.+
 03$*1  1
..%1
&(
)&1&+


    
31&1 32.

  4.
!(&&+&01   
31&1)$*1("4

 "01   
 

  "01
 
 

 
 







 

 

 









 



 
 



 
 


 
 
 



 

 
 



 





 
 



 
 


 
 




 


 





 


4.
!(&&+&01


),& ),&

!+(/
385
%3081+



!+(/
385


  
.2"+
")+5
.3+,& 

!><

#DJGAN
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
A6HH>;>:9
/G6;;>8
1DAJB:
6C9
/G6;;>8
DBEDH>I>DC
6I
)6G6>C6
DC
->C<
-D69

/67A:

.JBB6GN
D;
A6HH>;>:9
/G6;;>8
1DAJB:

=DJGH
6I
>;;:G:CI
(>9
AD8@
'D86I>DCH
D;
:A=>

.
)D
(>9
AD8@
6GH
JID
JH:H
/2
"

"1
'/
#/
(/
.(1
/DI6A

->C<
-D69



 




 
 



-6?<=6I






 
 

 

DCC6J<=I
+A68:










 




-:<6A
>C:B6




 
 
 
 
 
 

->C<
-D69


 

 
 







)6G6>C6








 
 













$/*
G>9<:




 
 
 
 
 

 






 



 


)#

NE6HH




 




 
 

.,-7
$:3
;0+
807.
;0+
<)0+
'

311+5).(0

$58)/6
$
$58)/6
$

$58)/6
$




<)0+


33*6
873

 ".)/6-(:6
(2*

7-+5
'


33*6
%(2
#%
% 


$:3
&-++0+5





.2.
86
#1(00
(56


86+6 .,
(56 
 873





!><

/G6;;>8
DBEDH>I>DC
6I
>;;:G:CI
(>9
AD8@
'D86I>DCH
D;
:A=>


)" !+
!",$)
&
)-$
!)+)"*+"*


*(
,675,%87,21


?:?,7
:1


1=0423?
A034.70>
,?


:@?0=
.:=/:9
7:.,?4:9>
,9/

 

1=0423?
A034.70>
,?

1:.,7
;:49?>
B4?349

.4?D
B0=0
49?0=.0;?0/
,9/
49?0=A40B0/
&3=:@23
?30
=:,/>4/0
49?0=A40B>
,20
:1
?30
A034.70>
B0=0
=0.:=/0/
,7:92

B4?3
:?30=
48;:=?,9?
?=,A07
.3,=,.?0=4>?4.>
,9/
,9,7D>0/
1:=
,77
?30
>,8;70/
A034.70>
=:8
?30
8:/07
D0,=

8,9@1,.?@=492
:1
A034.70
/,?,
?30
,20
:1
A034.70
3,>
-009
/0?0=8490/
,9/
,20
/4>?=4-@?4:9
4>
/0A07:;0/
1:=

/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70
?D;0>
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
.4?D
42


;=0>09?
?30
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
A034.70>
,>
;0=
?30

478 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?

D0,=
:1
8,9@1,.?@=0
,>
:-?,490/
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9
;:49?>
,9/
1:.,7
;:49?>
=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9
-0
1:@9/
?3,?
?30

80,9
,20
:1
1=0423?
A034.70>
4>
,78:>?
>,80
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
A,=D492
-0?B009

,9/

D0,=>

,9/
?30
>3,=0
:1


D0,=
,9/
8:=0
:7/
A034.70>
B4?349
?30
.4?D
4>
=,92492
1=:8


?:

,9/

?:

,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>

,>
>3:B9
49
&,-70





 
 
 
 

 (:6C
<:


(:6C
<:

! 

3:6GH



! 

3:6GH



  



  



 

3:6GH


 

3:6GH






















 
 

 






 
 

 








   




    
    
   

  
(:6C
<:
(:6C
<:
(:6C
<:


! 

3:6GH

! 

3:6GH
! 
 
3:6GH






  



  


  



 

3:6GH
 

3:6GH
 

3:6GH









 
 

 













 
 

 






 
 

 






     

!><
 
<:
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
>;;:G:CI
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H
6I
*JI:G
DG9DCH
6C9
!D86A
+D>CIH
L>I=>C
>IN
>C
:A=>

/67A:

.=6G:
D;

3:6G
6C9
(DG:
*A9
1:=>8A:H
L>I=>C
I=:
>IN
6C9
6I
*JI:G
DG9DCH

.
)D
'D86I>DC
<:
'/
#/
(/
"
"1






3:6GH






*JI:G
DG9DCH


(DG:
/=6C

3:6GH











3:6GH






2>I=>C
I=:
>IN


(DG:
/=6C

3:6GH







8(/
!6('

9
.,>0
:1
1=0423?
A034.70>
?B:
?D;0>
:1
1@07>
,=0
8,497D
@>0/
&30D
,=0
40>07
,9/
:8;=0>>0/
,?@=,7
,>

 
&30
1@07
@>,20
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
4>
>3:B9
49
42


=:8
42


4?
.,9
-0
>009
?3,?
0,AD
(034.70>
8:>?7D
@>0
40>07
B30=0
,>
::/>
@?:
,9/
::/>
(,9
,78:>?

@>0
 
,>
1@07
9
.,>0
:1
&
,-:@?

,9/

@>0
40>07
,>
1@07
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
.4?D
=0>;0.?4A07D


:1(56+,3
2)
5(,*+7
"(+,&/(

&30
:B90=>34;
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
,9/
>3:B9
49

42


=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9
-0
>009
?3,?
;=4A,?0
.:8;,9D
A034.70>
,=0
3423
49
.,>0
:1
30,AD
A034.70>
&
,9/

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 479

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



&
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
&30
;=4A,?0
A034.70
>3,=0
4>
,78:>?
>,80
1:=
7423?
A034.70>
&

,9/

(
B4?349
?30
.4?D
B30=0,>
4?
4>
34230=
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>






 






   

   

 

   


$ $ $(2/+5 $  %

$ $ $  %

 


 .+6+0
 

  .+6+0

!><

!J:A
0H6<:
<:
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H
6I
*JI:G
DG9DCH
6C9
L>I=>C
I=:
>IN
D;
:A=>

 
 






   

   

 
   


 

$ $ $(2/+5 $  % $ $ $  %

 

  


!+5632(0
.5+* !97
314(2< 397 !+5632(0
.5+* !97
314(2< 397

!><

*LC:GH=>E
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H
6I
*JI:G
DG9DCH
6C9
L>I=>C
I=:
>IN
D;
:A=>

 
8(/
)),&,(1&<

&30
8470,20
1@07
0114.409.D
49
?0=8>
:1
6874?=0
/,?,
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
,9/
>3:B9

49
42


=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
7423?
A034.70>
&

,9/
(
3,A0
34230=
1@07
0114.409.D

B34.3
,=0
8:>?7D
=@9
:9
 
0,AD
1=0423?
A034.70>
3,A0
1@07
0114.409.D
,-:@?

,9/

6874?=0
1:=
&
,9/
&

=0>;0.?4A07D
423?
A034.70>
9,807D
&
3,>
,-:@?

6874?=0
B30=0
,>

,9/
(
3,>
8:=0
?3,9


6874?=0








 
 





 




 



  









  !   





!><

!J:A
;;>8>:C8N
D;
>;;:G:CI
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H



,67$1&(
5$9(//('

&30
/4>?,9.0
?=,A0770/
/,?,
49
?0=8>
:1
68?=4;
68
49>4/0
.4?D
,9/
68/,D
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
3,>
-009

,9,7D>0/
,9/
>3:B9
49
42


=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
,A0=,20
?=4;
/4>?,9.0
:1
&
4>
,-:@?

68

,9/
1:=
&
4?
4>
,-:@?


68
B30=0,>
A034.70
?D;0
&
3,>
,-:@?

68
,9/
>8,770=
A034.70>
,=0
3,A492
,
?=4;

480 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?

/4>?,9.0
:1
,-:@?

68
77
?30>0
A034.70
?D;0>
?=,A07>
,-:@?
 
68
B4?349
?30
.4?D
9/
4?
.,9
,7>:
-0
:->0=A0/

?3,?
?30
8,C48@8
,A0=,20
/4>?,9.0
?=,A0770/
49
,
/,D
-D
?30>0
A034.70
?D;0>
4>
,-:@?

68
&34>
.70,=7D
49/4.,?0

?3,?
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70>
1,.0
7:?
:1
.:920>?4:9
,9/
:?30=
;=:-708>
?:
?=,A07
8:=0
/4>?,9.0>
49
,
/,D
0C;0=409.492

7:?
:1
/07,D>
,9/
49.=0,>0/
:;0=,?492
.:>?>




 



  







    


 




  

 






 





















$ $ $(2/+5 $  % $ $ $(2/+5 $  %
 

  





  




  







 
 




  


















$ $ $(2/+5 $  %

 



!><

>HI6C8:
/G6K:AA:9
7N
>;;:G:CI
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H


5(48(1&<
2)
5,36

&30
1=0<@09.D
:1
?=4;>
/,?,
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
,9/
>3:B9
49
42


=:8
?30
42



4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
423?
(034.70>
,=0
3,A492
8:=0
/,47D
?=4;>
,9/
0,AD
(034.70>
,=0
8:=0
49
!..,>4:9,7
?=4;>



 
 






   

   

 

   


 

$ $ $  % $ $ $  %

)(66.32(00< &++/0<
 


$5.&++/0< .&++/0< (.0<
 


)(66.32(00< &++/0< $5.&++/0< .&++/0< (.0<

!><
!G:FJ:C8N
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H
6I
*JI:G
DG9DCH
6C9
L>I=>C
I=:
>IN
D;
:A=>


#(,*+7
$55,('

&30
B0423?
.,==40/
-D
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
,9/
>3:B9
49
42


=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9

-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
&
(034.70>
,=0
.,==D492
,A0=,20
B0423?
8:=0
?3,9


?:990
B30=0
,>
&
A034.70
4>
.,==D492

,A0=,20
7:,/>
:1

?:990
&30
&
4>
.,==D492
,A0=,20
B0423?
,-:@?

?:990
,9/
>8,770=
A034.70>
7460

,9/
(

,=0
.,==D492
70>>
?3,9
,
?:990
@=?30=
,9
,9,7D>4>
3,>
-009
.,==40/
:@?
?:
,>>0>>
?30
>3,=0
:1
08;?D
A034.70>
,9/
?30

=0>@7?
4>
,7>:
;=0>09?0/
49
42


=:8
42


4?
.,9
-0
>009
?3,?
?30

 
A034.70>
,=0
=@99492
08;?D
:9
?30

=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734
@=?30=
?30
?:?,7
B0423?
.,==40/
-D
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70>
:9
?30
09?4=0
=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734

3,>
-009
0>?48,?0/
1=:8
,A0=,20
/4>?,9.0
?=,A0770/
,9/
B0423?
.,==40/
49
,
/,D
B34.3
.:80>
?:
-0
,-:@?
 

4774:9
0?=4.
&:990
&
;0=
/,D

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 481

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



# 
"

 
  
 

"$
!

 





 





  


  BEIN


 

    'D69:9
 



'/ #/ (/ " "1 '/ #/ (/ " "1




 




!><
K:G6<:
2:><=I
6GG>:9
6C9
.=6G:
D;
BEIN
1:=>8A:H
>C
>;;:G:CI
!G:><=I
1:=>8A:H

 
$77(51
2)
27$/
5(,*+7
5,36

9
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
?30
?:?,7
?=4;>
3,A0
-009
0>?48,?0/
1=:8
,77
?30
E:90>
B34.3
,=0
49
?30
:=/0=
:1
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
2090=,?0/
/,47D
49
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
&30
.:8;,=4>:9
:1
?:?,7
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
8,/0
B4?3

;,>>0920=
?=4;>
49
:=/0=
?:
@9/0=>?,9/
?30
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
49
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
,9/
>3:B9
49
?30
42


,
=:8

?30
42


4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
?30
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
4>
:97D
,-:@?

B34.3
4>
A0=D
49>429414.,9?
3:B0A0=
4?

4>
2:492
?:
4917@09.0
3@20
49
?=,114.
.:920>?4:9
,4=
;:77@?4:9
,9/
=:,/
>,10?D
=07,?0/
4>>@0>
:1
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
&30

;,??0=9
:1
?:?,7
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
.7,>>4140/
@9/0=
1:@=
.,?02:=40>
&30D
,=0



C?0=9,7

C?0=9,7




C?0=9,7

9?0=9,7




9?0=9,7
?:
C?0=9,7




9?0=9,7

9?0=9,7


..:=/4927D
?30
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
,9,7D>0/
,9/
=0>@7?>
,=0
>3:B9
49
42


-
=:8
?30
42


-
4?
.,9
-0
>009

?3,?
?30
8,5:=4?D
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
9?0=9,7

9?0=9,7
B34.3
4>
,78:>?
 
&30
9?0=9,7C?0=9,7
,9/
C?0=9,7
9?0=9,7
,=0
,78:>?
>,80
,-:@?

0,.3
,9/
C?0=9,7C?0=9,7
?=4;>
;,>>492
?3=:@23
,=0
,-:@?



 #
"" 
 "

"
 !


!G:><=I

$

/G>EH  

 $









+6HH:C<:G

/G>EH $
$

 



%
,%4)
2*
4)-+,6
!4-35
-1
!26%/
!4-35



&
%66)41
2*
4)-+,6
!4-35

!><

.=6G:
6C9
+6II:GC
D;
!G:><=I
/G>EH
>C
:A=>

&30
8:/,7
>;74?
:1
?30>0
1=0423?
?=4;>
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
,9/
;=0>09?0/
49
42


=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9
-0

:->0=A0/
?3,?
30,AD
1=0423?
A034.70
>3,=0
4>
,-:@?

49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>
,-:@?

49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>
,-:@?


49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>
,9/
,-:@?


49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>
9
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
1:=0.,>?492
:1
?30
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0

,7>:
.,==40/
:@?
-,>0/
:9
?30
/0A07:;0/
1=0423?
?=,A07
/08,9/
8:/07
$$
&'071?
& !


,9/
4?
B,>
1:@9/

?3,?
?30
?:?,7
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
2:492
?:
-0
,=:@9/

?3:@>,9/>
49
?30
D0,=
 

B4?3
,
2=:B?3
=,?0
:1

;0=
,99@8









482 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?


 #
 " 
 #
 "

"1 "1 '/

 '/ 
 " 



"





#/ #/
/6C@:G  (/

(/

/6C@:G 
   






 #
 " 
 #
 "
"1 " "1 '/

" '/ 
     







(/

(/ #/  #/

/6C@:G   /6C@:G 
 

!><

!G:><=I
(D96A
.EA>I
;DG
>;;:G:CI
/NE:H
D;
/G>EH
>C
:A=>


67,0$7,21
2)
5$)),&
2$'6
21
7+(
2$'
(7:25.

9
 
,9/
 
$$
3,>
.:9/@.?0/
,
>?@/D
?:
0>?48,?0
?=,114.
7:,/>
49
?0=8>
:1
A034.70
647:80?0=>
?=,A0770/

(&
:9
?30
=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734
,9/
,..:=/4927D
;=:50.?0/
1:=
?30
D0,=>


,9/


$$
 
'?474>492

?34>
/,?,
?30
;=:50.?4:9>
3,A0
-009
8,/0
1=:8
?30
2=:B?3
1,.?:=>
1:=
,77
?30
A034.70
?D;0>
&30
0>?48,?0/
(&
1:=



,9/
1:=0.,>?0/
(&
1:=
?30
D0,=
 

,=0
;=0>09?0/
49
42


=:8
?30
42


4?
.,9
-0
:->0=A0/
?3,?
?30

0>?48,?0/
?:?,7
?=,114.
7:,/>
49
?0=8>
:1
(&
,=0
,-:@?

4774:9>
,9/

4774:9>
49


,9/
 
=0>;0.?4A07D

&30
(&
-D
1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
2:492
?:
-0
,-:@?


4774:9
,9/


4774:9>
49


,9/
 
=0>;0.?4A07D
B34.3

4>
3,A492
,
>3,=0
:1
,-:@?

&30
2=:B?3
:1
?:?,7
(&
4>
49.=0,>492
B4?3

;0=
,99@8
2=:B?3
B30=0,>
1=0423?

A034.70>
2=:B?3
4>
,-:@?

;0=
,99@8





  

6GH
 /LD
2=::A:GH


JIDH 

 "DD9H
1:=>8A:H  







JH:H


 
/DI6A  





 





 


 
 
 
 
 

           





78/2'8+*
/3
!6+7+38
#89*=

!><

HI>B6I:9
1:=>8A:
&>ADB:I:GH
/G6K:AA:9
6N
;DG
9>;;:G:CI
1:=>8A:
/NE:H
;DG
>;;:G:CI
3:6GH

 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 483

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?




)'('*
+)"*
')
,*+"&$
"+/
' "*+"*
 

&,6492
49?:
,..:@9?
:1
?30
149/492>
1=:8
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
,9/
49A09?:=D
:1
?30
74?0=,?@=0
B4?3
?30
,48
?:
,==4A0
,?

,
=0,>:9,-7D
.:8;70?0
-@?
8,9,20,-70
74>?
:1
49/4.,?:=>
?:
80,>@=0
0B
0734G>
;0=1:=8,9.0
49
?30
,=0,
:1
%
?30

74>?
:1
49/4.,?:=>
3,>
-009
,==4A0/
,>
;=0>09?0/
49
&,-70

B34.3
,7>:
49.7@/0/
>@220>?0/
@94?>
,9/
>:@=.0>
1:=

80,>@=0809?
9
:=/0=
?:
,>>0>>
?30>0
;,=,80?0=>
1:=
.4?D
:1
0734
,
>@=A0D
.,9
-0
@9/0=?,609
,8:92
,77
?30
7:.,7

,@?3:=4?40>
,9/
;:74.D
8,60=>
1=0423?
:;0=,?:=>
,9/
0C;0=?>

/67A:

'>HI
D;
$C9>86IDGH
ID
(:6HJG:
):L
:A=>RH
+:G;DGB6C8:
>C
I=:
6G:6
D;
.JHI6>C67A:
>IN
'D<>HI>8H
.'

6I:<DGN
$C9>86IDG
+6G6B:I:G
4JC>I5

8DCDB>8


':K:A
D;
GD69
>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:
-D69
>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:
9:CH>IN
4A6C:
@BH@B5

":C:G6A

K6>A67>A>IN
D;
>CI:GBD96A
IG6CHEDGI
688:HH
)D
D;
>CI:GBD96A
=J7H
688DG9>C<
ID
INE:
G6>A
>CA6C9
L6I:GL6N
6>G
45

IG6CHEDGI

HNHI:B
DHI
D;
8DC<:HI>DC
K:G6<:
8DC<:HI>DC
9:A6N
4K:=
=DJGHN:6G5

-D69
FJ6A>IN
+:G8:CI6<:
D;
GD69
JC9:G<D>C<
B6>CI:C6C8:
E:G
N:6G
45

!>C6C8>6A
=:6AI=
/G6CHEDGI
7J9<:I
4-+5

8DCDB>8
Q
':K:A
D;
H:GK>8:
;DG
GD69H
(:6C
HE::9
D;
;G:><=I
K:=>8A:H
4@B=5

AD<>HI>8H

-:A>67>A>IN
D;
IG6K:A
I>B:

IG>EH
9:K>6I>C<
;GDB
B:6C
IG6K:A
I>B:

H:GK>8:
FJ6A>IN

DHIH
D;
IG6CHEDGI
H:GK>8:H
/DI6A
8DHIH
D;
9:A>K:GN
(:6C
8DHIH
;>M:9
6C9
GJCC>C<
8DHIH
E:G
9:A>K:G>:H

88:HH>7>A>IN
;DG
;G:><=I
K:=>8A:H
+:G8:CI6<:
D;
688:HH>7A:
GD69H

E:G
K:=>8A:
86I:<DGN
45

CK>GDCB:CI6A

"G::C=DJH:
<6HH:H
2:AA
ID
L=::AH
"#"
:B>HH>DCH
;DG
0!/
4IDC
*:FN:6G5

C:G<N
:;;>8>:C8N
/DI6A
:C:G<N
JH:9
688DG9>C<
ID
;G:><=I
IG6;;>8
KDAJB:
4(%IDC
@B5

>G
EDAAJI>DC
/DI6A
:B>HH>DCH
D;
6>G
EDAAJI6CIH
+(
)*M
4@<N:6G5

0G76C
6G:6
JH:9
;DG
0!/
+:G8:CI6<:
D;
JG76C
6G:6
JH:9
;DG
0!/
DJI
D;
IDI6A
8>IN
6G:6

.D8>6A
/G6;;>8
H6;:IN
$C?JG>:H
6C9
;6I6A>I>:H
>CKDAK>C<
;G:><=I
K:=>8A:H
45

%D7H
BEADNB:CI
>C
8>IN
AD<>HI>8H



'&$,"&
%)#*

'9/0=>?,9/492
,9/
1:=0.,>?492
1=0423?
8:A0809?>
4>
.=4?4.,7
?:
;7,9
1:=
1@?@=0
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
49
?0=8>
:1
.,;,.4?D

,@2809?,?4:9
:;0=,?4:9
;=0>0=A,?4:9
>,10?D
,9/
>0.@=4?D
090=2D
,9/
0.:9:8D
49A0>?809?
900/>
,9D
/08,9/

1:=0.,>?492
8:/07>
,9/
/,?,
>:@=.0>
,=0
8:=0
,;;=:;=4,?0
1:=
;,>>0920=
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9
?3,9
1:=
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?,?4:9

49
?0=8>
:1
@9/0=>?,9/492
1=0423?
?=,A07
-03,A4:@=
,9/
1:=0.,>?492
1=0423?
8:A0809?>
=0,?492
-0??0=
/,?,
,9/

8:/07>
4>
900/0/
?:
09,-70
;7,990=>
?:
-0??0=
;=0/4.?
1=0423?
8:A0809?
,9/
/0>429
-0??0=
491:=80/
;:74.40>
9
A40B

:1
?34>
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
3,A0
-009
.:9.0;?@,74>0/
?:
>?@/D
:9
@=-,9
7:24>?4.>
9
0C?09>4A0
;47:?
>?@/D
4>
.,==40/
:@?

1:=
?30
.4?D
:1
0B
0734
40
,?4:9,7
,;4?,7
&0==4?:=D
:1
0734
 &
9/4,
3,>
-009
>070.?0/
,>
>?@/D
,=0,
D

.:9/@.?492
0C?09>4A0
1407/
>@=A0D>
80?=4.>
:1
.4?D
7:24>?4.>
/0>429
:1
80,>@=0809?
>D>?08
,9/
/,?,
,.<@4>4?4:9
49

?30
.4?D
:1
0734
3,A0
-009
/0A07:;0/
9
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
;:>>4-70
1=0423?
80?=4.>
1=:8
?30
A,=4:@>
1407/
>?@/40>

3,A0
-009
80,>@=0/
,9/
?30
>@88,=D
4>
24A09
-07:B

•
!9
,
9:=8,7
B:=6492
/,D
,
?:?,7
:1
,-:@?


84774:9
A034.70>
09?0=
,9/
70,A0
0734
.4?D
B34.3
3,>
2=:B9
B4?3


;0=
,99@8
,-:@?

 
84774:9
A034.70>
49
 
&30
1=0423?
?=,114.
1:=8>
,-:@?


:1
?30
?:?,7
?=,114.
B4?3

,9:?30=

:1
?=,114.
4>
.:8;:>0/
:1
>7:B
8:A492
A034.70>
7460
-4.D.70
.D.70
=4.6>3,B>
,948,7
.,=?>
0?.

•
,C48@8
9@8-0=
:1
A034.70>
49
?30
:=/0=
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492
?3=:@23
$,5:6=4
:=/0=

1:77:B0/
-D
3,E4;@=
:=/0=
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
?=,114.
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>
,9/
,749/4
@95
:=/0=

B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
?=,114.
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>


•

?:?,7
:1
,-:@?


&3:@>,9/
1=0423?
A034.70>
09?0=
,9/
70,A0
0734
.4?D
:9
,
9:=8,7
B:=6492
/,D
,9/
,-:@?



:1
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
1:@9/
?:
-0
;,>>492
?3=:@23
?30
.4?D
B34.3
B,>
,78:>?
>,80
49
 
&3:@23

484 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?

?30
?:?,7
?=,114.
49.=0,>0/
1=0423?
?=,114.
=08,49
>?,29,?0/
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
-0.,@>0
:1
90B
-D;,>>
=:,/>
.:80

,=:@9/
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
>@.3
,>
:4/,=0,?0=
:4/,
C;=0>>B,D
*,8@9,
C;=0>>B,D
@9/74,90>,=
",7B,7
"
C;=0>>B,D
0?.


•
&30
1=0423?
A034.70
?D;0>
9,807D
::/>
@?:

::/>
(,9
(
&
&
,9/
&
,=0
1:@9/
,?
09?=D
,9/

0C4?
7:.,?4:9>
:1
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
9
.,>0
:1
;,>>492
?3=:@23
1=0423?
?=,114.
&
3,>
,78:>?
 
>3,=0
1:77:B0/
-D

&
,9/
&
3,>
>3,=0
:1
,-:@?


0,.3
%8,770=
::/>
(034.70>

,9/
(
3,>
,
>3,=0
:1
,-:@?


:1

;,>>492
?3=:@23
?=,114.
&34>
.,9
-0
,??=4-@?0/
?:
?30
1,.?
?3,?
?30
30,AD
A034.70>
?=,A07
7:92
/4>?,9.0>
.:8;,=0/

?:
7423?
,9/
>8,77
A034.70>

•
=:8
1:.,7
;:49?>
>?@/40>
B4?349
?30
.4?D
4?
3,>
-009
:->0=A0/
?3,?
8,C48@8
9@8-0=
:1
A034.70>
;0=
/,D
4>
49
?30

:=/0=
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
09?0=492
,9/
0C4?492
?3=:@23
3,9?,
3,=
%,-E4
,9/4
1:77:B0/
-D
E,/;@=
%,-E4

,9/4
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
,9/
3,9/494
3:B6
=0,
B4?3
,9
09?=D
0C4?
A:7@80
:1

,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
?
3,>
,7>:
-009
1:@9/
?3,?
,-:@?

,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
::/>
@?:

,9/
::/>
(,9

(
49
?3,?
&30
A034.70
?D;0>
:1
&
&
,9/
&
,=0
49
?30
=,920
:1
 


,9/

=0>;0.?4A07D
&30
:?30=

1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
,-:@?




•
&30
84/
-7:.6
?=,114.
>?@/40>
=0A070/
?3,?
?30
?:?,7
/,47D
A:7@80

3:@=>
:9
$492
$:,/
 ,=,49,
4>
,78:>?



?3:@>,9/>
B4?3
,
;0,6
A:7@80
:1
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>


F
 
=>
&30
>@88,=D
:1
?=,114.
:9
,77
?30
84/

-7:.6
7:.,?4:9>
>3:B>
,-:@?
 
,=0
.:9>4>?492
:1
;=4A,?0
A034.70>
8,497D
.,=>
,9/
?B:
B30070=>
&30
1=0423?

?=,9>;:=?
4>
,-:@?

8,497D
.:9>4>?
:1
::/>
@?:>
&
&
,9/
&

•
&30
80,9
,20
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
4>
,78:>?
>,80
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
A,=D492
-0?B009


,9/

D0,=>
,9/
?30
>3,=0
:1


D0,=
,9/
8:=0
:7/
A034.70>
B4?349
?30
.4?D
4>
=,92492
1=:8


?:

,9/

?:


,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>

•
&30
1@07
@>,20
/4>?=4-@?4:9
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
=0>@7?>
>3:B>
?3,?

0,AD
(034.70>
&
,9/
&
8:>?7D
@>0
40>07
B30=0
,>
::/>
@?:
,9/
::/>
(,9
,78:>?
@>0
 
,>
1@07

9
.,>0
:1
&
,-:@?

,9/

@>0
40>07
,>
1@07
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
.4?D
=0>;0.?4A07D


•
&30
:B90=>34;
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30
.4?D
3,>
-009
,9,7D>0/
,9/
1:@9/
?3,?

;=4A,?0
.:8;,9D
1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
3423
49
.,>0
:1
30,AD
A034.70>
&
,9/
&
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>
,9/
B4?349
?30

.4?D
&30
;=4A,?0
.:8;,9D
,9/
;0=>:9,7
1=0423?
A034.70
>3,=0
4>
,78:>?
>,80
1:=
7423?
A034.70>
&

,9/
(

B4?349
?30
.4?D
B30=0,>
;=4A,?0
.:8;,9D
1=0423?
A034.70
>3,=0
4>
34230=
,?
:@?0=
.:=/:9>


•
&30
8470,20
1@07
0114.409.D
49
?0=8>
:1
6874?=0
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
3,>
-009
:->0=A0/
?3,?
7423?

A034.70>
&

,9/
(
3,A0
34230=
1@07
0114.409.D
B34.3
,=0
8:>?7D
=@9
:9
 
0,AD
1=0423?
A034.70>

3,A0
1@07
0114.409.D
,-:@?

,9/

6874?=0
1:=
&
,9/
&
=0>;0.?4A07D
423?
A034.70>
9,807D
&
3,>
,-:@?

6874?=0
B30=0
,>

,9/
(
3,>
8:=0
?3,9


6862
:1
 

•
&30
1=0423?
A034.70
?D;0>
?=,A07>
,-:@?
 
68
B4?349
?30
.4?D
,9/
?30
8,C48@8
,A0=,20
/4>?,9.0
?=,A0770/
49
,

/,D
-D
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70
?D;0>
4>
,-:@?

68
&34>
.70,=7D
49/4.,?0
?3,?
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70>
1,.0
7:?
:1

.:920>?4:9
,9/
:?30=
;=:-708>
?:
?=,A07
8:=0
/4>?,9.0>
49
,
/,D
0C;0=409.492
7:?
:1
/07,D>
,9/
49.=0,>0/

:;0=,?492
.:>?>

•
&30
1=0<@09.D
:1
?=4;>
:1
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
,9,7D>4>
>3:B>
?3,?
423?
(034.70>
,=0
3,A492
8:=0
/,47D
?=4;>

,9/
0,AD
(034.70>
,=0
8:=0
49
!..,>4:9,7
?=4;>

•
=:8
?30
=0>@7?>
:1
B0423?
.,==40/
-D
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
4?
3,>
-009
:->0=A0/
?3,?
&
(034.70>
,=0

.,==D492
,A0=,20
B0423?
8:=0
?3,9


?:990
B30=0
,>
&
A034.70
4>
.,==D492
,A0=,20
7:,/
:1

?:990
&30
&

4>
.,==D492
,A0=,20
B0423?
,-:@?

?:990
,9/
>8,770=
A034.70>
7460

,9/
(
,=0
.,==D492
70>>
?3,9
,
?:990


•
&30
>3,=0
:1
08;?D
A034.70>
4>
,-:@?

 
,.=:>>
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70
?D;0>
@=?30=
?30
?:?,7
B0423?

.,==40/
-D
?30>0
1=0423?
A034.70>
:9
?30
09?4=0
=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734
3,>
-009
0>?48,?0/
?:
-0
,-:@?
 
4774:9

0?=4.
&:990
&
;0=
/,D


•
9
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
?30
?:?,7
?=4;>
2090=,?0/
/,47D
49
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
1=:8
,77
?30
E:90>
,=0
0>?48,?0/
?:
-0
,-:@?


?3:@>,9/>
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
&30
149,7
1=0423?
8:/,7
>;74?
1:=
/4110=09?
1=0423?
A034.70>
9,807D

&
&
,9/

&
>3:B>
,78:>?
0<@,7
>3,=0
A,=D492
-0?B009

B30=0
,>
(
3,>
,-:@?

>3,=0

•
&30
8,5:=4?D
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
9?0=9,7

9?0=9,7

B34.3
4>
,78:>?
 
&30
9?0=9,7C?0=9,7

,9/

C?0=9,79?0=9,7

,=0
,78:>?
>,80
,-:@?

0,.3
,9/
C?0=9,7C?0=9,7

?=4;>
;,>>492
?3=:@23
,=0

,-:@?


 Madhu Errampalli et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 467–485 485

66'25'11/
+8
'1
$6'375468'8/43
"+7+'6).
!64)+*/'



?



•
&30
,9,7D>4>
:1
8:/,7
>;74?
:1
?30>0
1=0423?
?=4;>
>3:B>
?3,?
30,AD
1=0423?
A034.70
>3,=0
4>
,-:@?

49
.,>0
:1


&=4;>
,-:@?

49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>
,-:@?

49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>
,9/
,-:@?


49
.,>0
:1

&=4;>

•
&30
>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
4>
:97D
,-:@?

,9/
;,>>0920=
?=4;>
,=0
,-:@?

49
?30
.4?D
:1
0734
&3:@23
?30

>3,=0
:1
1=0423?
?=4;>
4>
A0=D
49>429414.,9?
4?
4>
2:492
?:
4917@09.0
3@20
49
?=,114.
.:920>?4:9
,4=
;:77@?4:9
,9/
=:,/

>,10?D
=07,?0/
4>>@0>
:1
?30
.4?D
:1
0734

•
&30
1=0423?
?=4;>
,=0
0>?48,?0/
?:
49.=0,>0
?:
,-:@?

?3:@>,9/>
-D
?30
D0,=
 

B4?3
,
2=:B?3
=,?0
:1

;0=

,99@8


•
&30
0>?48,?0/
?=,114.
7:,/>
49
?0=8>
:1
A034.70
647:80?0=>
?=,A0770/
(&
:9
?30
=:,/
90?B:=6
:1
0734
1:=
?30

D0,=


,9/
1:=0.,>?0/
(&
1:=
?30
D0,=
 

,=0
,-:@?

4774:9>
,9/

4774:9>
=0>;0.?4A07D
&30
(&

-D
1=0423?
A034.70>
,=0
2:492
?:
-0
,-:@?


4774:9
,9/


4774:9>
49


,9/
 
=0>;0.?4A07D
B34.3
4>

3,A492
,
>3,=0
:1
,-:@?

&30
2=:B?3
:1
?:?,7
(&
4>
49.=0,>492
B4?3

;0=
,99@8
2=:B?3
B30=0,>
1=0423?

A034.70>
2=:B?3
4>
,-:@?

;0=
,99@8

•
&,6492
49?:
,..:@9?
?30
149/492>
1=:8
;=0>09?
>?@/D
,9/
?30
49A09?:=D
:1
?30
74?0=,?@=0
,
74>?
:1
49/4.,?:=>
?:

80,>@=0
0B
0734G>
;0=1:=8,9.0
49
?30
,=0,
:1
%
3,>
-009
;=:;:>0/

9
?30
;=0>09?
>?@/D
1:@=
48;:=?,9?
;=4:=4?40>
1:=
?30
1@?@=0
3,A0
-009
4/09?4140/
B34.3
.:@7/
-0
;,=?
:1
,
5:49?

84>>4:9
>?,?0809?
:1
?30
.:770.?4A0
:1
>?,603:7/0=>
?:
,.340A0
>@>?,49,-70
@=-,9
1=0423?
>D>?08>

•
$0/@.?4:9
:1
902,?4A0
0110.?>
:1
@=-,9
1=0423?
?=,9>;:=?
B3470
8,49?,49492
;=:/@.?4A4?D

•
/09?414.,?4:9
:1
B:=6,-70
@=-,9
1=0423?
>:7@?4:9>
49.7@/492
=:,/8,;>
?:B,=/>
/,?,
?::7>
,9/
,;;=:;=4,?0

=0>0,=.3

•
9.=0,>0
:1
?30
69:B70/20
-,>0
49.7@/492
/,?,
.:770.?4:9
8:/07>
,9/
>.09,=4:>

•
:77,-:=,?4:9
B4?3
:?30=
>?,603:7/0=>
?:
=0,74E0
>:7@?4:9>
?:B,=/>
>@>?,49,-474?D

#&'.$ %&+*

&30
;=0>09?
;,;0=
3,>
-009
;=0;,=0/
1=:8
?30
>?@/D
?4?70/
02,.4?D
:24>?4.>
0?=4.>
&::7>
,9/
0,>@=0>
1:=

%@>?,49,-474?D
!
>;:9>:=0/
-D
&30
):=7/
,96
=:@;
@9/0=
?30
@7?4
:9:=
&=@>?
@9/

%@>?,49,-70

:24>?4.>
&%
%.3080
:9?=,.?
:

 
B34.3
B,>
.,==40/
:@?
-D
%$$$
0B
0734
49

,>>:.4,?4:9
B4?3
&'071?
&30
0?30=7,9/>
,9/
& !
&30
0?30=7,9/>
&30
,@?3:=>
B:@7/
7460
?:
?3,96
,77
?30

?0,8
808-0=>
B3:
,=0
;,=?
:1
?30
!
;=:50.?

)&*

/$
$$(
6A8JII6
 
*E:G6I>DC6A
;;>8>:C8N
D;
!G:><=I
/G6CHEDGI6I>DC
7N
-D69
>C
$C9>6
%D>CI
.IJ9N
-:EDGI
/G6CHEDGI
DGEDG6I>DC
D;
$C9>6

/$
6C9
$C9>6C
$CHI>IJI:
D;
(6C6<:B:CI
6A8JII6

9>I>DC
 

:CHJH
 
:CHJH
D;
$C9>6
"DK:GCB:CI
D;
$C9>6

:A=>
>G
+DAAJI>DC
-:6A
I>B:
>G
,J6A>IN
$C9:M
 
=IIE6F>8CDG<8>IN9:A=>

>G
)DL
 
=IIEH6>GCDL<DK>C9:M8;B68I>DC6F>76H>8H6F>


(D0
 
:8DC<:HI>C<
/G6;;>8
>C
:A=>
-:EDGI
D;
I=:
#><=
+DL:G:9
DBB>II::
(>C>HIGN
D;
0G76C
:K:ADEB:CI
"DKI
D;
$C9>6
%JC:
 

--$
 
0G76C
-D69
/G6;;>8
6C9
>G
+DAAJI>DC
>C
:A=>
:CIG6A
-D69
-:H:6G8=
$CHI>IJI:
--$
!>C6A
-:EDGI
.D8>:IN
D;
$C9>6C
JIDBD7>A:

(6CJ;68IJG:H
.$(
 

"JEI6
.
 
-DA:
D;
)DC

(DIDG>O:9
/G6CHEDGI
>C
>HIG>7JI>DC
D;
"DD9H
>C
I=:
(:IGDEDA>I6C
>IN
D;
:A=>
/G6CHEDGI6I>DC
-:H:6G8=
+GD8:9>6

AH:K>:G
+J7A>H=:GH
1DA

EE
Q

)>A6C?6C6
:
6@H=>
)DB:H=

DA>6
"::I6B
/>L6G>
6C9
%DH:
#DA<J>C
1:G6H
 
0G76C
!G:><=I
>C
:A=>
=6G68I:G>HI>8H
6C9
(D7>A>IN

-:HIG>8I>DCH
1- !
-:H:6G8=
G>:;

- 
 
1DAKD
-:H:6G8=
6C9
9J86I>DC6A
!DJC96I>DCH
1- !

--$
 
:K:ADEB:CI
6C9
EEA>86I>DC
D;
/:8=CDAD<>:H
;DG
.JHI6>C67A:
/G6CHEDGI6I>DC
.0./-).
:CIG6A
-D69
-:H:6G8=
$CHI>IJI:

--$

!>K:
3:6G
+A6C
+GD?:8I
/G6CHEDGI6I>DC
(D9JA:
!>C6A
-:EDGI
+A6CC>C<
DBB>HH>DC
 

--$
/0
:A;I
/)*
 
(:<68>IN
'D<>HI>8H
(:IG>8H
/DDAH
6C9
(:6HJG:H
;DG
.JHI6>C67>A>IN
( "'*"
.$-
--$
):L
:A=>
>C

6HHD8>6I>DC
L>I=
/0
:A;I
/=:
):I=:GA6C9H
6C9
/)*
/=:
):I=:GA6C9H
!>C6A
-:EDGI
/=:
2DGA9
6C@
"GDJE
(6N