You are on page 1of 19

 LLL :AH:K>:G 8DB AD86I: EGD8:9>6

       



  
Available
online     
at www.sciencedirect.com

  .G6CHEDGI6I>DC,:H:6G8=*GD8:9>6



 ScienceDirect
    P
  
  
LLL :AH:K>:G 8DB AD86I: EGD8:9>6
    Transportation
  Research
  
Procedia 
48 (2020) 1968–1986     
  
 
  
   

  
 
 
    

  "        
"'&*,$+&+*)"-+"%"+'-&",%"&"
"##&##"*)!&*+"+,+"*!"'#/'(&
              
  
         
.;F:F:7D3B;6GD43@;L3F;A@3@69DAI;@9FD3@EBADF3F;A@67?3@6;@!@6;3     
;@@AH3F;H7EA>GF;A@E3@6?7F:A6E3D7
47;@97HA>H763@64ADDAI768DA?AF:7D5AG@FD;7E 'H7DF:7>3EF675367@G?7DAGE%3EE)3B;6+D3@E;F*KEF7?E:3H7
5A?7 GB ;@ H3D;AGE 5;F;7E >;=7" "'&*,$+&+*)"-+"%"+'-&",%"&"
%7FDA )3;>E  %A@AD3;>E 3@6 GE )3B;6 +D3@E;F *KEF7?E  +:7E7 EKEF7?E ?73@F 8AD
"##&##"*)!&*+"+,+"*!"'#/'(&
FD3@EBADFA8>3D97@G?47DA8B3EE7@97DE3FCG;5=;@F7DH3>EEB3@@;@9>7@9F:K6;EF3@57E:3H7E;?B>;8;76F:7>;87A8F:7
5;F;L7@E  +:7 ;@F7D5A@@75F;A@ A8 F:7E7 BG4>;5 FD3@EBADF ?A67E I;F: ;@F7D?76;3F7 BG4>;5 FD3@EBADF !(+ ;E @AI 3@
;?BADF3@F;EEG7@AFA@>K8DA?F:7GE7DBA;@FA8H;7I8ADE73?>7EEFD3H7>35DAEEF:75;FK 4GF3>EA8DA?F:73GF:AD;F;7ET

B7DEB75F;H7FA4734>7FAA887D:;9:7DCG3>;FKA8E7DH;57E +:7D3;>I3K >76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F;@!@6;35ADD7EBA@6EFA
F:7EB3F;3>B>3@@;@93DAG@6;F3@6:3E6;D75F;?B35FEA@BABG>3F;A@67@E;FK >3@6GE75:3@973@675A@A?K +:;EB3B7D
.;F:F:7D3B;6GD43@;L3F;A@3@69DAI;@9FD3@EBADF3F;A@67?3@6;@!@6;3 ;@@AH3F;H7EA>GF;A@E3@6?7F:A6E3D7
;E 3@ 3FF7?BF FA G@67DEF3@6 F:7 ;@F7D?A63> FD3@EBADF :G4E ;@ %G?43; 3@6 K67D3436 3@6 F:7;D BAF7@F;3> ;@ 8GFGD7
47;@97HA>H763@64ADDAI768DA?AF:7D5AG@FD;7E 'H7DF:7>3EF675367@G?7DAGE%3EE)3B;6+D3@E;F*KEF7?E:3H7
D3;>I3K >76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F;@!@6;3 +:;E;E35:;7H76F:DAG9:F:7;@H7EF;93F;A@A8EF3F;A@E3>A@9F:75A?B3D3F;H7>K
5A?7 GB ;@ H3D;AGE 5;F;7E >;=7 %7FDA )3;>E  %A@AD3;>E 3@6 GE )3B;6 +D3@E;F *KEF7?E  +:7E7 EKEF7?E ?73@F 8AD
@7I%7FDA>;@7E3@6D7H;7I;@9F:7BD7H3>7@FBA>;5;7E3@6F:7EF3=7:A>67DEF:3F53@;@8>G7@57F:767H7>AB?7@F3DAG@6
FD3@EBADFA8>3D97@G?47DA8B3EE7@97DE3FCG;5=;@F7DH3>EEB3@@;@9>7@9F:K6;EF3@57E:3H7E;?B>;8;76F:7>;87A8F:7
F:7EF3F;A@@A67E 
5;F;L7@E  +:7 ;@F7D5A@@75F;A@ A8 F:7E7 BG4>;5 FD3@EBADF ?A67E I;F: ;@F7D?76;3F7 BG4>;5 FD3@EBADF !(+ ;E @AI 3@
© 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
;?BADF3@F;EEG7@AFA@>K8DA?F:7GE7DBA;@FA8H;7I8ADE73?>7EEFD3H7>35DAEEF:75;FK 4GF3>EA8DA?F:73GF:AD;F;7ET
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
B7DEB75F;H7FA4734>7FAA887D:;9:7DCG3>;FKA8E7DH;57E
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of+:7D3;>I3K >76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F;@!@6;35ADD7EBA@6EFA
the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019
F:7EB3F;3>B>3@@;@93DAG@6;F3@6:3E6;D75F;?B35FEA@BABG>3F;A@67@E;FK >3@6GE75:3@973@675A@A?K +:;EB3B7D
 3FF7?BF FA G@67DEF3@6 F:7 ;@F7D?A63> FD3@EBADF :G4E ;@ %G?43; 3@6 K67D3436 3@6 F:7;D BAF7@F;3> ;@ 8GFGD7
;E 3@
D3;>I3K >76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F;@!@6;3 +:;E;E35:;7H76F:DAG9:F:7;@H7EF;93F;A@A8EF3F;A@E3>A@9F:75A?B3D3F;H7>K
N +:7GF:ADE (G4>;E:764K>E7H;7D - 
@7I%7FDA>;@7E3@6D7H;7I;@9F:7BD7H3>7@FBA>;5;7E3@6F:7EF3=7:A>67DEF:3F53@;@8>G7@57F:767H7>AB?7@F3DAG@6
F:7EF3F;A@@A67E 
(77D D7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8.')$'&)&'&+)&*(')+)*) *'!+/ 
© 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)

Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019

/.')* ,6>AL6N A:9JG76C9:K:ADEB:CI#CI:GBD96A-E6I>6A*A6CC>C<#C9>6 

N +:7GF:ADE (G4>;E:764K>E7H;7D - 

(77D D7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8.')$'&)&'&+)&*(')+)*) *'!+/ 

 
 / "  +*"&()+$#)" .$) ,# ( 
 (( ,# -+% (( )'&%)##$#*.&!  
/.')* ,6>AL6N A:9JG76C9:K:ADEB:CI#CI:GBD96A-E6I>6A*A6CC>C<#C9>6 


  / "  +*"&()+$#)" .$) ,# ( 


 (( ,# -+% (( )'&%)##$#*.&!  
2352-1465 © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the World Conference on Transport Research – WCTR 2019
10.1016/j.trpro.2020.08.008
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1969
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

 #(&$)($#

.;F:!@6;3>AA=;@98ADI3D6FAI3D6E3@7I397A8D3;>I3KEI;F:F:736H7@FA8?G5:3I3;F764G>>7FFD3;@E %A@A
)3;> 3@6@7I%7FDA>;@7E;@;FE+;7D3@6+;7D5;F;7E ;F475A?7E;?BADF3@FFAG@67DEF3@6F:77J;EF7@57A83EKEF7?
F:3F 7@5AGD397E AD ;@:;4;FE ;@F7D?A63> FD3@EBADF3F;A@ :G4E 3@6 F:7;D BAF7@F;3> ;@ F:7 8GFGD7 D3;>I3K >76 GD43@
67H7>AB?7@F;@!@6;3 )3;>I3KE 47KA@66AG4F :3H73@;?BADF3@FD7>3F;A@I;F:F:7GD43@67H7>AB?7@F3@6;8B>3@@76
6;>;97@F>K53@D7EG>F;@FAH;4D3@FGD43@EB357EF:3F53@36H3@5747FF7DCG3>;FKA8>;873@6835;>;F3F7?AD7367BFGD43@
?3@397?7@F +:7 B:KE;53> 5A?BA@7@FE A8 GD43@ FD3@EBADF 3@6 GD43@ GF;>;F;7E 3D7 7EF34>;E:76 4K F:7 5;FKTE EB3F;3>
@7FIAD=EI:;5:;@FGD@3D767F7D?;@764K;FEGD43@EB3F;3>EFDG5FGD7 66;F;A@3>>K F:7GD43@EB3F;3>EFDG5FGD7 AD?AD7
5A??A@>K>3@6GE7 ;EF:7BDA6G5FA8F:7;@F7D35F;A@47FI77@>3@6?3D=7FE3@6F:7D79G>3F;A@E 

)757@F>K  !@6;3@ )3;>I3KET *F3F;A@ )767H7>AB?7@F (DA9D3??7 :3E 8A5GE76 A@ ?3=;@9 D3;>I3K EF3F;A@E 3E F:7
7B;57@F7D A8 35F;H;F;7E I;F: F:7 D3;>I3K BD7?;E7E !@6;3@ )3;>I3KE    +:7 ;673 ;E FA D3;E7 D7H7@G7 8AD
?A67D@;L3F;A@A8EF3F;A@EF:DAG9:5A??7D5;3>67H7>AB?7@FA@D3;>I3K>3@6  AI7H7D F:75:3>>7@97EF:3F7?7D97
8DA?F:7;@E7DF;A@A8>3D97E53>7FD3@EBADF3F;A@;@8D3EFDG5FGD73@6;FE78875FA@D73>7EF3F7 CG3>;FKA8>;87 3@6AF:7D
;@F79D3F76 3EB75FE A8 GD43@ >;H;@9 3D7 BA;@FE FA 47 D7EA>H76 3E GD43@ !@6;3 ?AH7E ;@FA 3@ 7D3 A8 FD3@EBADF3F;A@
36H3@57?7@F  +:7 ;@:7D7@F 5:3D35F7D;EF;5E >;=7 >3@6 AI@7DE:;B  BD7E7@57 A8 ?G>F;B>7 EF3=7:A>67DE  H3D;7FK A8
5A?B7F;@9FD3@EBADF3F;A@3>EAD3;E7E5A?B>7J;F;7E;@GD43@67H7>AB?7@F 

!@F:;EB3B7DF:7BAF7@F;3>A8FD3@EBADF3F;A@67H7>AB?7@F3E3?3<ADFD;997D8AD9DAIF:;@!@6;3@5;F;7E:3E477@
7JB>AD76 F:DAG9:F:77J3?B>7EA8%G?43;3@6 K67D3436 +:7FIA5;F;7E:3H7477@E7>75F763ED7BD7E7@F3F;H7A8
@7I7D3A8D3;>I3KFD3@EBADF3F;A@67H7>AB?7@F;@F:78AD?A8%7FDA3@6%A@AD3;> I:;>7%G?43;:3E:368;H7K73DE
A8 %7FDA D3;>  K67D3436 EF3DF76 I;F: F:7 D3;>I3K A@>K ;@ &AH7?47D   >EA  %G?43; :3E 477@ 3 B;A@77D ;@
;?B>7?7@F;@93B>7F:AD3A8BA>;5;7EI:;5:?;9:F@AF476;D75F>K;@8>G7@5;@9F:7;@F7D?A63>FD3@EBADF3F;A@:G4E 4GF
53@835;>;F3F7F:7E3?7;8;@F79D3F76FA97F:7D +:7D;9;63@6E3>;7@FFABA9D3B:KA8%G?43;?3=7EF:77@F;D75;FK34;
6;D75F;A@3>D3;>FD3@EBADF5ADD;6AD +:;E;E3@7J3?B>7I:7D7GD43@FD3@EBADF:3E;@8>G7@576F:7>3@6?3D=7F3@6F:7
5;FKEFDG5FGD7I;F:AGF?G5:8AD?3F;H7;@F7DH7@F;A@7H7@BDA434>K3FA66I;F:D79G>3F;A@E !@%G?43; F:736<A;@;@9
3D73EFAF:7?3<ADEF3F;A@E:3H7477@:AEF;@9:;9:7EF67@E;F;7EA8BABG>3F;A@ 35F;H;F;7E3@6;@8AD?3>FD3@EBADF3F;A@
:G4I:;5::3H7477@>;@=76A@EGD8357 +:;E;@:7D7@FBAF7@F;3>A8:;9:67@E;FK3@6D3;> ;@F79D3F76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F
53@ 47 GF;>;L76 FA E:3B7 F:7 GD43@ 67H7>AB?7@F I;F: ?G>F; @G5>7; ;@EF736 A8 3DAG@6 A@7 AD FIA 7@FD3> GE;@7EE
;EFD;5FE   K67D3436  F:7 8;8F: ?AEF BABG>AGE 5;FK A8 !@6;3 :3E I;F@7EE76 3@ 7@AD?AGE 9DAIF: A8 BD;H3F7
H7:;5>7E6G7FAI:;5:;F:3E477@7JB7D;7@5;@9FD7?7@6AGEBD7EEGD7EA@;FEFD3@EBADFE7DH;57E +:7?7FDAD3;>BDA<75F
;EBA;E76FA9;H7 K67D3436 !@6;3TE;@8AD?3F;A@F75:@A>A9K3@6B:3D?357GF;53>BAI7D:AGE7 3B7AB>7 8D;7@6>K 9D77@ 
E73?>7EE>K5A@@75F76;@F7D?A63>?3EEFD3@E;FEKEF7? 

+:;EB3B7D?3=735A?B3D3F;H7D7H;7IA8F:767H7>AB?7@F8D3?7IAD=D7>3F76FAD3;>I3K >76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F
;@ %G?43; 3@6 K67D3436  5A?BD;E;@9 F:7 8A>>AI;@9 8AGD E75F;A@E  +:7 @7JF E75F;A@ 6;E5GEE7E F:7 >A53F;A@ 
67?A9D3B:;5E EA5;3> 75A@A?;5BDA8;>7E3@6FD3@EBADF3F;A@@7FIAD=FA;@FDA6G57FAF:7E7?3<ADGD43@399>A?7D3F;A@E 
*75F;A@>AA=E;@FAF:767H7>AB?7@F8D3?7IAD= 7@>;EFEF:7;@H7EF76EF3=7:A>67DE 3@67JB>AD7EF:7BA>;5;7EF:3F53@
;?B35F;@F7D?A63>FD3@EBADF3F;A@:G4E +:7EG4E7CG7@F*75F;A@5>3EE;8;7EF:7EF3F;A@E;@FAFKBA>A9;7E3@67J3?;@7E
F:767H7>AB?7@FBAF7@F;3>I;F:;@ ?7F7DED36;GE 3@6;8;F:3E477@835;>;F3F763@6B>3@@76AD36 :A5 *75F;A@
EK@F:7E;L7EF:753E7EFG6;7EI:;5:8A5GE7EA@F:7%7FDA$;@7;@%G?43;3@6@7I%7FDA>;@7E;@ K67D3436 

*;@57;@%G?43;F:7BA>;5;7ED7>3F76FAD3;>I3K >7667H7>AB?7@F3D7G@67D8AD?G>3F;A@3@6;@ K67D3436F:78;DEF


?7FDA>;@7E:3H7<GEF67H7>AB76 ;F?;9:F4773D>KFA5A@5>G6735A?B3D3F;H7EFG6KA8F:7FIA5;F;7E +:7D78AD7 I7
@776FA=77B>AA=;@93FF:7;@@AH3F;H73FF7?BFEF:3F4793@;@F:7FIA5;F;7E 

  &$)#

, 0&,+
1970 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

%G?43;;EF:753B;F3>5;FKA8F:7!@6;3@EF3F7A8%3:3D3E:FD3 !F>;7EA@F:7#A@=3@5A3EFA@F:7I7EF5A3EFA8!@6;3
3@6:3E3677B@3FGD3>:3D4AGD %G?43;5A@E;EFEA8FIA6;EF;@5FD79;A@E%G?43;;FK6;EFD;5F3@6%G?43;*G4GD43@
6;EFD;5F I:;5:8AD?FIAE7B3D3F7D7H7@G76;EFD;5FEA8%3:3D3E:FD3 +:7FAF3>3D73A8%G?43;;E  =?EC?; 
'8F:;E F:7;E>3@65;FKEB3@E =?EC?; I:;>7F:7EG4GD43@6;EFD;5FEB3@E =?EC?; FA97F:7D
355AG@F;@9 8AD  =? EC ?; G@67D F:7 36?;@;EFD3F;A@ A8%G@;5;B3> ADBAD3F;A@ A8 D73F7D
%G?43;%% +:7D7?3;@;@93D73E47>A@9FAH3D;AGE787@577EF34>;E:?7@FE F:7%G?43;(ADF+DGEF F:7FA?;5
@7D9KA??;EE;A@3@6F:7AD;H3>;&3F;A@3>(3D= I:;5:3D7AGFA8F:7<GD;E6;5F;A@A8F:7%% +:7%G?43;
%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@%%)I:;5:;@5>G67EBADF;A@EA8+:3@7 (3>9:3D3@6)3;9366;EFD;5FE;@366;F;A@FAD73F7D
%G?43; 5AH7DE3@3D73A8 =? EC?; 

K67D3436;EF:753B;F3>A8F:7EF3F7A8+7>3@93@3 >A53F76;@EAGF:7D@!@6;3 
K67D3436%7FDABA>;F3@D73 %;EA@7A8F:783EF7EF9DAI;@9?7FDABA>;E7E
;@ !@6;3 8AD?76 4K ?7D9;@9 F:7 8A>>AI;@9 7DEFI:;>7 7@F;F;7E G66:3 (GD@;?3
(DA<75FGF:AD;FK F:7K47D34367H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK F:7 K67D3436,D43@
7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK3@6 K67D3436;DBADF7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK !F5AH7DE
3@3D73A83BBDAJ;?3F7>K  =?*AGD57+*   K67D3436%7FDABA>;F3@
7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK %;EF:7GD43@B>3@@;@93GF:AD;FK8ADF:7 %
D79;A@ I:;>7 F:7 D73F7D K67D3436 %G@;5;B3> ADBAD3F;A@  % ;E
D7EBA@E;4>78ADF:75;H;536?;@;EFD3F;A@A8F:;E3D73 +:7 %;E6;H;676;@FA
LA@7E 5;D5>7E3@6 I3D6E 35:I3D65AH7DE3BBDAJ;?3F7>K B7AB>7 
*AGD57D73F7D K67D3436%G@;5;B3>ADBAD3F;A@


><  &D86I>DCD;'JB76>6C9"N9:G6769
"*,$.-%& / >C#C9>6

%G?43;;EF:7?AEFBABG>AGE5;FK;@!@6;3I;F:3@7EF;?3F765;FKBABG>3F;A@A8 ?;>>;A@3EA8  >A@9


I;F:F:7@7;9:4AD;@9D79;A@EA8F:7%G?43;%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@ ;F;EF:7E75A@6?AEFBABG>AGE?7FDABA>;F3@3D73
;@!@6;3 I;F:3BABG>3F;A@A8 ?;>>;A@3EA8  +:7BABG>3F;A@67@E;FK;E7EF;?3F76FA4734AGF B7DEA@E
B7DECG3D7=;>A?7F7D EC ?;>7 +:7D73D787?3>7EFA7H7DK ?3>7EPI:;5:;E>AI7DF:3@F:7@3F;A@3>
3H7D397 +:7AH7D3>>>;F7D35KD3F7A8F:75;FK;E34AH7B7D57@F I:;5:;E:;9:7DF:3@F:7@3F;A@3>3H7D397 

 K67D3436:3E3BABG>3F;A@A8 ?;>>;A@*AGD577@EGE  ;F;E!@6;3TEE;JF:>3D97EF?7FDABA>;F3@D79;A@ 


K67D34365;FK;E>A53F76I;F:;@F:7 %>;?;FE3@6:AGE7E ?;>>;A@B7AB>7;@3@3D73A8 ECG3D7=;>A?7FD7E 
+:7BABG>3F;A@67@E;FK;E7EF;?3F76FA4734AGF  B7DEA@EB7DECG3D7=;>A?7F7D +:7D73D787?3>7EFA7H7DK
 ?3>7E +:7AH7D3>>>;F7D35KD3F7A8F:75;FK;E  

 , &, ,+,*& +!& 0,./

%G?43; ;E F:7 7@F7DF3;@?7@F  83E:;A@ 3@6 5A??7D5;3> 57@FD7 A8 !@6;3 E A8  D757@F 7EF;?3F7E A8 F:7
75A@A?KA8F:7%G?43;%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@:3H7D3@9768DA?FA4;>>;A@(((?7FDA(D3@=;@9;F
7;F:7DF:7?AEFADE75A@6 ?AEFBDA6G5F;H7?7FDA3D73A8!@6;3 %G?43;355AG@FE8ADE>;9:F>K?AD7F:3@ A8
!@6;3E75A@A?K EA8   %G?43;7@<AKE3(7D3B;F3!@5A?7A8  +:;E;E :;9:7DF:3@  
>7H7>EA8  %G?43;:3EFD36;F;A@3>>KAI76;FEBDAEB7D;FK>3D97>KFA;FEF7JF;>7?;>>E3@6;FEE73BADFF;>>F:7 E 
+:7E73D7@AI;@5D73E;@9>K47;@9D7B>35764K;@6GEFD;7E7?B>AK;@9?AD7E=;>>76>34AGDEG5:3E7@9;@77D;@9 6;3?A@6
BA>;E:;@9 :73>F:53D73@6;@8AD?3F;A@F75:@A>A9K E%G?43;;EF:753B;F3>A8%3:3D3E:FD3 9AH7D@?7@F7?B>AK77E
?3=7 GB 3 >3D97 B7D57@F397 A8 F:7 5;FKE IAD=8AD57  %G?43; 3>EA :3E 3 >3D97 G@E=;>>76 3@6 E7?; E=;>>76 >34AGD
BABG>3F;A@  I:A BD;?3D;>K 73D@ F:7;D >;H7>;:AA6 3E:3I=7DE  F3J; 6D;H7DE  ?75:3@;5E 3@6 AF:7D EG5: BDA>7F3D;3@
BDA87EE;A@E $;=7?AEF?7FDABA>;F3@5;F;7E %G?43;3>EA:3E3>3D97;@8>GJA8B7AB>78DA?DGD3>3D73E>AA=;@98AD
7?B>AK?7@F +:75D;?7;@67J;@%G?43;;E D;?7!@67J %;6/73D &G?47A !@6;57E47FI77@ 3@6
 3D75A@E;67D76FA47S>AIT 
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1971
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

 K67D34363@6F:73D73EEGDDAG@6;@9;F8AD?F:775A@A?;55AD7A8F:7EF3F7D7BD7E7@F;@934AGF A8F:79DAEE


EF3F76A?7EF;5BDA6G5F +:7B7D53B;F3;@5A?7;@  I3E!&)  ,*  +*  +:775A@A?K
A8 K67D3436;E43E76A@FD36;F;A@3>?3@G835FGD;@9 F:7=@AI>7697E75FAD 3@6FAGD;E? !@F:7 E F:775A@A?;5
B3FF7D@ A8 F:7 5;FK 5:3@976 8DA? 3 BD;?3D;>K E7DH;57 :G4 FA 3 ?AD7 6;H7DE;8;76 75A@A?K  4GF F:7 E7DH;57 ;@6GEFDK
D7?3;@E3?3<AD5A@FD;4GFAD I;F: A8F:77?B>AK76IAD=8AD577@93976;@F:;EE75FAD  K67D3436:3E3>EA7?7D976
3E3:G48AD!+!+D7>3F76E7DH;57E;@F:75AG@FDK6G7FAE:;8F;@9AH7D@?7@FBA>;5;7EF:3F83HAGDF:77EF34>;E:?7@F
A8EG5:835;>;F;7E3@6F:7>3D977?B>AK34>7IAD=8AD57;@F:7D79;A@ 3E76A@EFG6;7E5A@6G5F768ADF:7+*  F:7
EA5;A 75A@A?;5 EFD3F3 ;@ K67D3436 5A@E;EF A8   GBB7D 5>3EE    ?;66>7 5>3EE 3@6   IAD=;@9 5>3EE  +:7
7EF;?3F76FKB7A87?B>AK?7@F4KA88;57 ;@6GEFDK 39D;5G>FGD73@6AF:7D;E   3@6D7EB75F;H7>K 
DAG@6 A8F:7 %BABG>3F;A@;ECG3>;8;76I;F:3F>73EF36;B>A?3 9D36G3F7ADBAEF 9D36G3F7679D77AD34AH7 
+:75D;?7;@67J;@ K67D3436;E D;?7!@67J %;6/73D &G?47A 

 .+/-,.00&,+,!"/+!"03,.(

%G?43;EBG4>;5FD3@EBADF5A?BD;E7EA8D3B;6FD3@E;FEG4GD43@D3;>I3K ?7FDA 3@6?A@AD3;> F:74GEE7DH;57EA8


F:7F:D77?G@;5;B3>;F;7E?3=;@9GBF:7?7FDABA>;F3@3D73 BG4>;5F3J;E3@63GFAD;5=E:3IE 3@6387I87DDKE7DH;57E 
?7FDA3@63?A@AD3;>EKEF7?:3H7477@36676;@F:7>3EF87IK73DE I:;5:;EB>3@@76FA9DAI8GDF:7D53F7D;@9FAF:7
B7DE;EF7667?3@6EA8F:75;FK +:77J;EF;@9EG4GD43@D3;>3@6F:74GE@7FIAD=3>D736K:3H79D73FAGFD735: I;F:I7>>
8G@5F;A@3>87767DEKEF7?E E;E5A??A@I;F:5A?B>7JGD43@EFDG5FGD7E F:7E76;887D7@F?A67EEA?7F;?7EAH7D>3B
3@6DG@B3D3>>7> 3FAF:7DF;?7EF:7K5DAEEAH7D AD7J3?B>7 ?3@KA8F:7@7IB>3@@76>;@7EIAG>6<GJF3BAE73@6>;@=
F:7@7FIAD=A8F:7D3;>I3K>;@7EFA4GEDAGF7E D7EG>F;@9;@BAF7@F;3>;@F7D ?A63>FD3@EBADF3F;A@:G4E I:;5:D7CG;D7E
676;53F763FF7@F;A@;@;FEB>3@@;@93@6;?B>7?7@F3F;A@ *G4GD43@EF3F;A@3D73E ;@F7D 5;FKD3;>F7D?;@3>3D73E ;@F7D 5;FK
4GEF7D?;@3>3D73EF:DAG9:AGFF:7EFG6K3D733D7FKB;53>>K5A@97EF76 $A53F76;@5>AE7BDAJ;?;FKFA5A??7D5;3>3D73E
3@6?3D=7FE 3@6EGDDAG@6764K;@8AD?3>?3D=7FEF:7K7JB7D;7@57;@5D73E;@9@G?47DA8H7:;5>7E3@6B767EFD;3@E 3>>
5A?B7F;@98AD>;?;F763H3;>34>7DA36EB357 

 ><  'JB76>-J7JG76C,6>A(:ILDG@-DJG8:H6
><    .G6CHEDGI (:ILDG@ -DJG8:
1>@>*GD?:8IH#C9>6C>I>:H *A6C:'69 1>@>B:9>6

1/".2& "/ %G?43;:3EF:7>3D97EFAD93@;L764GEFD3@EBADF@7FIAD=3?A@9?3<AD!@6;3@5;F;7E !@D73F7D


%G?43; D;:3@?G?43;>75FD;5*GBB>K3@6+D3@EBADF,@67DF3=;@9*+;EF:7>3D97EFBG4>;54GEFD3@EBADFE7DH;57
BDAH;67DI;F:38>77FEFD7@9F:A8 3@6AB7D3F;@9A@ DAGF7E  !FAB7D3F7EE7DH;57EI;F:;@D73F7D%G?43; 
3@6FA?3<AD67EF;@3F;A@EAGFE;67D73F7D%G?43; EB7D  63F3F:7D73D73FAF3>A8 4GE7EA@DA36B7D
63K3@6A@7 I3KB3EE7@97DFD;BEAD;9;@3F7663;>K;E34AGF ?;>>;A@ ?;>>;A@(3EE7@97D =? 63K +:7D7:3E
477@3675>;@7;@4GED;67DE:;B3FFD;4GF76FAD73EA@E>;=7D7>3F;H7>K:;9:FD3H7>F;?7E6G7FAFD388;55A@97EF;A@ 47FF7D
D7>;3@57A@!(+?A67EA@E:3D743E;E 7F5 %(  
1972 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

 &)35 ".2& "/  +:7%G?43;  


*G4GD43@)3;>I3K;EF:7A>67EF5A??GF7D 

D3;>;@E;3 8AG@676;@ !F;EAI@76  


4K!@6;3@ )3;>I3KE3@6 AB7D3F76 4K    
 

;FE.7EF7D@ )3;>I3KE3@67@FD3>  
)3;>I3KE6;H;E;A@E  %AEF 75A@A?;53>  

FD3@EBADF EG4E;6;L76 4K 9AH7D@?7@F A8    


 

!@6;3H;3)3;>I3K?;@;EFDK .;F:3>7@9F:   


  
 

 

A8 =? ;F:3E:;9:7EFB3EE7@97D67@E;FK 
;@ F:7 IAD>6    ?;>>;A@ B7AB>7 63;>K  6G .LD JID .6M> JH -J7JG76C ':IGD
?AD7F:3@:3>8A863;>K53B35;FKA8!@6;3@ 1=::A:G ,>8@H=6L ,6>A 'DCD
)3;>I3KE 12!F :3E 8AGD D36;3> >;@7E
   
.7EF7D@  7@FD3>  3D4AGD  3@6 +D3@E
3D4AGD  F BD7E7@F  %G?43; %7FDA
)3;>I3KE:3H7A@7AB7D3F;A@3>>;@7  ><   DBE6G>HDC D; BD9: HEA>I 6HH:HH:9 ;DG !G:6I:G 'JB76> >C   .- ;DG '',
=? ;@ >7@9F: I;F:  EF3F;A@E 3@6   -IJ9N6C9 '*;DG!G:6I:G'JB76>HIJ9N
B>3@@76 >;@7E ;@ FAF3>  %G?43; %A@AD3;>
:3EA@7AB7D3F;A@3>>;@7 =?;@>7@9F:I;F:EF3F;A@E3@6B>3@@76>;@7E;@FAF3> 

+D3@EBADF;@ K67D3436;EF:7@7FIAD=A8DA36E 
D3;>I3KE D3B;6FD3@E;FEKEF7?;@F:7EF3F7A8+7>3@93@3 
!F :3E 5A?BD7:7@E;H7 :;9:I3K @7FIAD=  +:D77
&3F;A@3> ;9:I3KE& B3EEF:DAG9:F:75;FK ;H7
*F3F7 ;9:I3KE* 479;@3F K67D3436 +:7!@@7D
);@9 )A36 !))  'GF7D );@9 )A36 ')) 3@6
>7H3F76JBD7EEI3KI7D75A@EFDG5F764KF:7 %
FA D7>;7H7 FD388;5 5A@97EF;A@  K67D3436TE BG4>;5
FD3@EBADF5A?BD;E7E3>;9:FD3;>EKEF7? %7FDAD3;> 5;FK
3@6 BD;H3F7 4GE E7DH;57E  F3J;E  3GFA D;5=E:3IE 3@6
;@F7D5;FK D3;> E7DH;57E  +:7 %7FDA D3;> E7DH;57E 3D7 3
@7I 366;F;A@ FA F:7 FD3@EBADF3F;A@ EKEF7? P A@7
E75F;A@A8F:7B>3@@76E7DH;575A??7@576AB7D3F;A@E
A@&AH7?47D   

><  "',D69(:ILDG@.- 


1/".2& "/ 

;FKGE*7DH;57E +:7E73D7DG@4KF:7+7>3@93@3*F3F7)A36+D3@EBADFADBAD3F;A@+*)+ FAF3>@G?47D


A84GEDAGF7E3D7;@AB7D3F;A@A@F:7DA36E8ADBG4>;5FD3@EBADFAF:7DF:3@:;D76 5A?B3@K ;@EF;FGF;A@GE7EI;F:
 4GEEFABE +:7FAF3>FD;BEB7D8AD?76;@F:7E7DAGF7EB7D63K3D734AGF +*  
(D;H3F7GE*7DH;57E +:7*F3F79AH7D@?7@FBDAH;67EE7DH;57EF:DAG9:*+.!&3BD;H3F7AD93@;L3F;A@DG@@;@9
F:7BG4>;5FD3@EBADF3F;A@ G7FAF:7:;9:355;67@FD3F73@6BA>>GF;A@53GE764KF:74GE7E E7DH;57EI7D7EFABB768AD
387IK73DE4GFD7EG?76;@  EA8@AI*+.!&DG@E 4GE7EI;F:;@F:75;FK>;?;FE+*  

&)35".2& "/$;9:F)3;>*KEF7? K67D3436:3E3>;9:FD3;>FD3@EBADF3F;A@EKEF7?=@AI@3EF:7%G>F;%A63>


+D3@EBADF*KEF7?%%+* +:7%%+*;EAI@763@6AB7D3F764K!@6;3@)3;>I3KE FAF3>A8%%+*DAGF7E3D7
AB7D3F;@9;@ % +:;EI3E>3G@5:76;@ 3@6:3E477@:73H;>K5D;F;5;L768AD;FEBAADBG@5FG3>;FK 34E7@57A8
87767D4GEE7DH;57EFAF:7EF3F;A@E3@683;>GD7FA3G9?7@F;FE7J;EF;@9E7DH;57E;@=77B;@9I;F:F:7D;67DE:;B+*
  
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1973
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0


><  'D96A-=6G:HD;.G>EHB69:>C"':M8AJ9>C<L6A@-DJG8:.- 

 &#*!$%"#(&"+$& 

 ',.0("%,)!"./

; $A53>AH7D@?7@F
D73F7D%G?43;3@64K7JF7@E;A@%G?43;%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@3@6 K67D3436:3H73BA>K57@FD;59AH7D@3@57
EKEF7?3EKEF7?F:3F:3E477@35=@AI>76976FAIAD=F:747EF8AD?7FDABA>;F3@D79;A@E  AI7H7D 39D73F@G?47DA8
E5:A>3DE 3@6 BD35F;F;A@7DE  :3H7 7EF34>;E:76 F:7 ?;EE;@9 >;@=E A8 9AH7D@3@57 47FI77@ F:7 FIA ?3<AD 397@5;7E 
%%)%G?43;%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK3@397@5KD7EBA@E;4>78ADD79;A@3>67H7>AB?7@F
3@6 %% %G@;5;B3> ADBAD3F;A@ A8 D73F7D %G?43; 3@ 397@5K D7EBA@E;4>7 8AD GD43@ 9AH7D@3@57 ;@ D73F7D
%G?43; D79;A@ (7F:7 7F 3>     *;?;>3D>K  K67D3436 ;E 9AH7D@76 4K AH7D>3BB;@9 3GF:AD;F;7E A8 K67D3436
%7FDABA>;F3@7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK %3@6D73F7D K67D3436%G@;5;B3>ADBAD3F;A@ % 

;;  +D3@EBADF3F;A@GF:AD;F;7E
&)3510%,.&0&"/ !@6;3@)3;>I3KE7@FD3>)3;>I3K .7EF7D@)3;>I3KDG@EF:7EG4GD43@D3;>I3KE3@6F:7>3D97
6;EF3@57 FD3;@E 8DA? 3@6 F:DAG9: %G?43;  I:;>7 F:7 ?7FDA FD3;@E 3D7 DG@ 4K %G?43; %7FDABA>;F3@ )79;A@
7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK%%);@B3DF@7DE:;BI;F:BD;H3F7E75FAD7@F;F;7E I:7D7D;67DE:;BEF3DF768DA?3ED757@F>K
3E  "G@7   +:7 %G?43; %A@AD3;> ;E 3 ?A@AD3;> EKEF7? 8AD F:7 5;FK A8 %G?43;  5A@FD35F76 4K F:7 %G?43;
%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@7H7>AB?7@FGF:AD;FK *;?;>3D>K D3;>I3KE3D7G@67DF:7BGDH;7IA8!@6;3@)3;>I3KE I:;>7F:7
%7FDA;EG@67DF:7EB75;3>BGDBAE7H7:;5>7E>;=7%G?43;%7FDA'@7(D;H3F7$F6%%'($3@6 K67D3436%7FDA
)3;>$F6 %) 

1/10%,.&0&"/ D;:3@?G?43;>75FD;5*GBB>K3@6+D3@EBADF,@67DF3=;@9*+AB7D3F7EE7DH;57EI;F:;@D73F7D
%G?43; 3@6FA?3<AD67EF;@3F;A@EAGFE;67D73F7D%G?43; +:7AF:7D?G@;5;B3>FD3@EBADF3F;A@3GF:AD;F;7EI:;5:
AB7D3F74GE7E;@5>G67E &3H;%G?43;%G@;5;B3>+D3@EBADF&%%+ #3>K3@ A?4;H>;%G@;5;B3>+D3@EBADF#%+ 
+:3@7 %G@;5;B3> +D3@EBADF +%+  %;D3 :3K3@63D %G@;5;B3> +D3@EBADF %%+  3@6 -3E3; -;D3D %G@;5;B3>
+D3@EBADF --%+  +:7E7 ?G>F;FG67 4GE 3GF:AD;F;7E IAG>6 @776 9;93@F;5 788ADFE FA F3=7 F:7? A@ 4A3D6 8AD
;?B>7?7@F3F;A@A83@KEKEF7?I:;5:BDA?AF7E;@F79D3F76FD3@EBADF3F;A@:G4E

;;;  (D;H3F7*75FAD

+:7BD;H3F7E75FAD:3E;?BADF3@FDA>7FAB>3K;@D3;>I3K >76GD43@67H7>AB?7@F3E
  3E:3D7:A>67DA8<A;@FH7@FGD75A?B3@;7EAB7D3F;@9 3@6?3;@F3;@;@9F:7FD3@EBADF;@8D3EFDG5FGD77 9 +:7
5A@FD35F 8AD %7FDA $;@7  %G?43; 5ADD;6AD I3E 3I3D676 FA F:7 %G?43; %7FDA '@7 (D;H3F7 $F6
%%'($  3 EB75;3> BGDBAE7 H7:;5>7  3@6 3 <A;@F H7@FGD7 5A?B3@K AI@76 4K )7>;3@57
!@8D3EFDG5FGD7 -7A>;3+D3@EBADF3@6F:7%%)  !@ K67D3436 ;FI3E3I3D676FA
K67D3436%7FDA)3;>$F6 %)I;F:67H7>AB?7@FD;9:FEFA$+ K67D3436%7FDA)3;>(D;H3F7$F6
1974 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

$+%) 
  367H7>AB7DA8EF3F;A@E$3DE7@3@6+AG4DA$+)73>FKI3E;@EFDG?7@F3>;@5A?;@9GBI;F:Q8;DEF+'
BDA<75FA8!@6;3R;@&3H;%G?43; =@AI@3E*73IAA6E7@FD3> 3@6
  3 67H7>AB7D A8 EF3F;A@ 67EF;@3F;A@E -# *=K ;FK ;E 3@ ;@F79D3F76 ?;J76 GE7 67EF;@3F;A@ B>3@@76 4K
%G?43;!@F7D@3F;A@3>;DBADF$;?;F76%!$3@6;E5A@F7?B>3F76FA;@5>G6767H7>AB?7@FA83I;67
EBD736A83EE7FE !@ K67D3436 $+%) F:75A@57EE;A@3;D7A8F:7%7FDABDA<75F 3>A@9I;F:67H7>AB;@9
F:7?7FDAD3;>FD35=E ;E3>EA7@F;F>76FAF:767H7>AB?7@F ?3;@F7@3@573@6AB7D3F;A@A857DF3;@D73>7EF3F7
B3D57>E3>A@9F:75ADD;6ADE +:7E7B3D57>E 5G?G>3F;H7>K4D3@6763ES K67D3436&7JFT 3D7:3@676AH7D
FA$+%)4KF:79AH7D@?7@F3@63>>AI3FAF3>B7D?;EE;4>74G;>FGB3D73A8 ?;>>;A@EC8F ?;>>;A@
EC ?  *A83D AGFA8B3D57>E :3H7477@67H7>AB763@63D75A?BD;E76>3D97>KA8?3>>E3@6D7F3;> 

 )++&+$"$1)0&,+/"2"),-*"+0,+0.,)

; D38F7H7>AB?7@F(>3@(
@73D>;7DH7DE;A@A8F:76D38F7H7>AB?7@F(>3@(    D7>73E76;@74DG3DK  BDABAE763FD3@E;F
AD;7@F76 67H7>AB?7@F +' EFD3F79K 8AD %G?43; +' LA@7E I7D7 5D73F76 3DAG@6 FD3@EBADF @A67E FA 7@5AGD397
EGEF3;@34>7 BA>K 57@FD;5 9DAIF: ;@ F:7 5;FK  3E I7>> 3E FA 8AD? 3 43E;E 4K I:;5: 388AD634>7 :AGE;@9 EFA5= ?3K 47
BDAH;676 ( BDA?AF76F:75A@EA>;63F;A@A87?B>AK?7@F@A67E;@F:7!E>3@6;FK 3EF7D@3@6.7EF7D@*G4GD4E 
+:7E73D78GDF:7D;@F79D3F76I;F:BG4>;5FD3@E;F5ADD;6ADE;@AD67DFA7@:3@57788;5;7@5K3@6FD3H7>5AEFE @8>AADEB357
;@67J*!A8 FAI3EBDABAE763>A@9F:7%7FDA$;@75ADD;6ADG@67DF:;E?75:3@;E? !FI3E3;?763F3HA;6;@9
6;EFADF;A@FAF:7?3D=7F4K5D73F;A@A8E53D5;FKA867H7>AB?7@FD;9:FE '@F:75A@FD3DK 7EF34>;E:;@9Q38D3?7IAD=
I;F:;@I:;5:?3D=7F53@5A?B7F;F;H7>KAB7D3F7R(  +:7(87>>G@67D:73HK5D;F;5;E?8AD;FE+'BA>;5K
I:7@;FI3ED7>73E763@6I3EEG4E7CG7@F>KE5D3BB76 

+:7 D7H;E76 D38F 7H7>AB?7@F (>3@     :3E 9;H7@ 3 @7I 3@6 E;?B>7 5A@57BF A8 *F3F;A@ D73
7H7>AB?7@F*5:7?7** EB7DF:76A5G?7@FQOF:767H7>AB?7@FA8>3@6E>A53F76I;F:;@ ?7F7DE8DA?F:7
57@F7DA87J;EF;@9AB7D3F;A@3>EG4GD43@3@6?7FDAD3;>I3KEF3F;A@E 3E;@6;53F76;@F:7(DABAE76$3@6,E7(>3@E:3>>
47FD73F763EF:7*F3F;A@D737H7>AB?7@F*5:7?7**R +:73D73G@67DEG5:E5:7?7E:3>>479AH7D@764KF:7
8A>>AI;@9D79G>3F;A@E%%) 

3  ?3J;?G?*!A8 E:3>>47B7D?;EE;4>7;@F:7*F3F;A@3D737H7>AB?7@F*5:7?7EG4<75FFAB3K?7@FA8
BD7?;G?53>5G>3F763F A8F:7>3@6D3F73EBD7E5D;476;@F:7@@G3>*F3F7?7@FA8)3F7EA8F:7K73DA8
9D3@F;@9EG5:67H7>AB?7@FE +:7BD7?;G?E:3>>475:3D976A@*!9D3@F76AH7D3@634AH7F:7B7D?;EE;4>7
0A@3>*! 'GFA8F:7FAF3>BD7?;G?  E:3>>47B3K34>7FAF:7GF:AD;FK3@6 FAF:7*F3F7AH7D@?7@F 
4  +:78;DEF ?A8F:7 ?E:3>>4773D?3D=768ADF:7D3;>I3KAB7D3F;A@E FD388;56;EB7DE3>835;>;F;7E3@6
B3D=;@9>AFE3@6@A;@6;H;6G3>67H7>AB?7@FEE:3>>47B7D?;FF76I;F:;@F:;E3D73 
5  !@53E7A8>3@6B3D57>EI;F:;@ ?4GFB3DF>K>A53F76I;F:;@F:7 ?47>F F:7AI@7DE:3>>47B7D?;FF76FA
GE7F:78G>>67H7>AB?7@FBAF7@F;3>A@>3@6E>A53F7647KA@6 ?8DA?F:7EF3F;A@ 
6  $3@6G@67DF:7E3;6E5:7?7E:3>>479AH7D@76;@355AD63@57I;F:F:7BDAH;E;A@E8ADF:7,0A@7 BDAH;676F:3F
@A;@6GEFD;3>67H7>AB?7@F7J57BF*7DH;57!@6GEFD;7EE:3>>47B7D?;FF76 
7  ?3J;?G?4G;>6;@9:7;9:FA8 ?7F7DEE:3>>47B7D?;FF76;@F:7*F3F;A@D737H7>AB?7@F*5:7?7 
8  %;@;?G?D;9:FA8I3KA83@K7J;EF;@9DA36I;F:;@F:7 ?E:3>>47?3;@F3;@763E ?3@6355AD6;@9>K 
@A5A@EFDG5F;A@E:3>>47B7D?;FF76I;F:;@ 8DA?F:757@FD7A8F:7DA36 


;;  A?BD7:7@E;H7%A4;>;FK(>3@ 8AD 


+:7 %( ;67@F;8;7E 3@6 366D7EE7E F:7 ;EEG7E I;F: F:7 5GDD7@F ;@EF;FGF;A@3> 8D3?7IAD= I;F: 8A5GE A@ >35= A8
7JB7DF;E7;@+D388;5+D3@EBADF3F;A@(>3@@;@9 @9;@77D;@98;7>6 6;88;5G>FK;@5AAD6;@3F;@9I;F:7@FD3> *F3F73@6
$A53>AH7D@?7@F397@5;7E 3?A@9EF?3@K +AAH7D5A?7F:7;EEG7E?7@F;A@7634AH7 F:78A>>AI;@95:3@97E:3H7
477@EG997EF76;@F:7D7BADF

3 )7@3?;@9A87J;EF;@9+D388;57B3DF?7@F3E+D388;5+D3@EBADF3F;A@7B3DF?7@F EGBBADF764K+D388;5
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1975
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

6H;EADK (3@7> I;F: EF3=7:A>67DE FA 5AAD6;@3F7 >A53> 35F;H;F;7E  +:;E IAG>6 835;>;F3F7 ;@ 78875F;H7
5AAD6;@3F;A@I;F:D79;A@3>>7H7> EF3F7>7H7>3@657@FD3>>7H7>3GF:AD;F;7E
4 *FD7@9F:7@;@9 A8 +D388;5  +D3@EBADF3F;A@ 7B3DF?7@F 4K D75DG;F;@9 BAEF 9D36G3F7E I;F: 35367?;5
CG3>;8;53F;A@E 3@6 7JB7D;7@57 ;@ +D3@EBADF3F;A@ (>3@@;@9  +D3@EBADF3F;A@ @9;@77D;@9 3@6 ;9:I3K
@9;@77D;@9
5 D73F;A@A8(3D=;@97>>8AD78875F;H7B>3@@;@9 5AAD6;@3F;A@ AB7D3F;A@A8A@ EFD77F3@6A88 EFD77FB3D=;@9
835;>;F;7E
6 *=;>>+75:@A>A9KFD3@E87DFD388;57@9;@77D;@9 DA36E387FK FD3@EBADF3F;A@B>3@@;@9 :;9:I3K7@9;@77D;@9 
!* 7F5 F:DAG9:BDA87EE;A@3>AD93@;L3F;A@E

+:7D7BADF93H73EFDG5FGD76I3K8ADI3D6I;F:F:78A>>AI;@935F;A@E
3  (D7B3D77F3;>(DA<75F)7BADFE()
4  !@FDA6G57+D3H7>7?3@6%3@397?7@F?73EGD7E3@6;?B>7?7@F&%+?73EGD7E(3D=;@9BA>;5K3@6&%+
(A>;5K
5  *75GD7 7@5DA35:?7@F D7?AH3> 3>A@9 ?3<AD FD3@EBADF3F;A@ 5ADD;6ADE 3@6 D7EFAD7 53B35;F;7E FA E387>K 3@6
78875F;H7>K?AH7B7AB>73@6H7:;5>7E
6  !?B>7?7@F3F;A@ A8 BDABAE76 ;@EF;FGF;A@3> 5:3@97E ;@ +D388;5 7B3DF?7@F A8 %% 3@6 %G?43; +D388;5
(A>;57
7  !?B>7?7@F?73EGD7EFABDAF75F>A@9F7D?FD3@EBADF3F;A@5ADD;6ADEBDAF75F;A@A8);9:FA8.3K
8  )7H;7I3@6GB63F;@9A8FD3@EBADF;@H7EF?7@FB>3@E3@6BD;AD;F;7E7H7DKK73DE
9  !?B>7?7@FBA>;5;7EFABDA?AF7+D3@E;F'D;7@F767H7>AB?7@F3@6
:  !?B>7?7@F3F;A@A8!@F79D3F763D7*FDG5FGD73@65A??A@F;5=7F;@93?A@9BG4>;5FD3@EBADFEKEF7?E 


;;;  AGE;@9(A>;5K
EF736KEGBB>KA8>;H34>73@6388AD634>7:AGE;@9;EB;HAF3>FACG3>;FKA8>;87 ?AD7EA ;@5;F;7EI;F::;9:67?3@6
8AD :AGE;@9 +:7E7 :AGE;@9 53@ 47 BDAH;676 @73D F:7 FD3@E;F LA@7E  FA ;@5ADBAD3F7 F:7 >AI ;@5A?7 3@6 388AD634>7
:AGE;@9;@F:7?3;@834D;5A8F:75;F;7E +:7D7;E@A7J;EF;@9BA>;5K8AD>3@6GE767H7>AB?7@FE3>A@9F:7%7FDA5ADD;6AD
;@4AF:%G?43;3@6 K67D3436  AI7H7D 3EB7D3@,D43@7H7>AB?7@F7B3DF?7@F %G?43;@AF;8;53F;A@;@ 
F:7D7I3E3@3?7@6?7@FFAF:7BD7 7J;EF;@955A??A63F;A@)7E7DH3F;A@BA>;5K +:;E3?7@6?7@F67F3;>76AGF8AD
%7FDA53DE:76EAD%)+*EF3F;A@E3@;@57@F;H78ADF:7AD;9;@3>>3@6AI@7D +:7AI@7DA8F:7>3@6D7E7DH768ADEG5:
BGDBAE7E;E7@5AGD3976FAEG4?;F A8F:7B>AFI;F:F:75A@EFDG5F763?7@;FKA8FAF3>3D738D77A85AEF;@>;7GA8
5A@EFDG5F;A@3?7@;FK+)FD3@E87DA867H7>AB?7@FD;9:FE +:7AI@7D;EF:7@B7D?;FF76FA67H7>ABF:7D7?3;@;@9
 A8>3@68ADGE7EB7D?;EE;4>7;@F:736<A;@;@9LA@7I;F:8G>>B7D?;EE;4>7*!8>AADEB357;@67JA8F:77@F;D7B>AF
3@6B7D?;EE;4>7+)BAF7@F;3>A8F:77@F;D7B>AF 

  ,)& &"/.")0"!0,+!.+/-,.00&,+
!@D757@FB3EF F:7@3F;A@3> EF3F73@6>A53>9AH7D@?7@FE:3H75A?7GBI;F:EF3@63>A@7BA>;5;7EI:;5:;@8>G7@57EF:7
;@F7D?A63>FD3@E;F:G4E;@A@7I3KADF:7AF:7D !@F:;EEG4 E75F;A@ F:73GF:ADE7JB>AD7F:7E7BA>;5;7E3@6FDKFA93F:7D
;@8AD?3F;A@I:;5:I:7@5A?4;@7653@4D;@93@G?47DA8B>3K7DEFA97F:7DFA67H7>AB3EG557EE8G>EKEF7?8AD5D73F;A@
3@6EGEF7@3@57A8;@F7D?A63>FD3@E;F:G4E 

; (3D=;@9(A>;5K  
%G?43;:3EA@7A8F:7>AI7EFB3D=;@9BD;57FAA88;57D7@F3>D3F;AEA8  +:7K3D77H;67@F>K83D8DA?:3H;@9
B3D=;@9BD;57EF3=7355AG@FA8>3@6BD;57E3EEF3F76;@!@6;3TE&3F;A@3>,D43@+D3@EBADF(A>;5K  +:7
@7IB3D=;@9BA>;5KA8%G?43;:3E477@8AD?G>3F76;@ FA673>I;F:F:7G@?;F;93F76B3D=;@9BDA4>7?E;@%G?43; 
FBD7E7@FBDAH;E;A@E:3E@AF477@7EF34>;E:768ADF:7B3D=;@9A8;@F7D?76;3F7BG4>;5FD3@EBADF!(+H7:;5>7E;@3@6
3DAG@6F:7EF3F;A@E7J57BF*F3F;A@D73+D388;5!?BDAH7?7@F*5:7?7*+!*BDA<75F;@+:3@7I:;5::3EBDAH;676
8AD!(+H7:;5>7E +:7BA>;5K53F79AD;L7EB3D=;@9835;>;F;7E;@FAF:D77B3DFE3F79ADKST5AH7DE3D73E>;=7A>343 ADF
3@6&3D;?3@(A;@F I:7D7F:7B3D=;@95:3D97E:3>>47)E  B7D:AGD +:;E53F79ADK3>EA;@5>G67E3D73E3DAG@6D3;>I3K
EF3F;A@E3@6?3D=7FE !@53F79ADKST3D73E>;=7(D34:367H;3@6*;66:;H;@3K3=F:75:3D97EI;>>47)E  B7D:AGD !@
53F79ADKSTI:;5::3EA@7B3D=;@9>AF;@:7?4GD3@63@AF:7D;@F:7%3>343D ;>>3D73F:75:3D97I;>>47)E  
1976 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

+:7D7;E36;E5AG@FA@F:7E75:3D97E8ADBG4>;5FD3@EBADFH7:;5>7E&  

;;  'B7@*B357(A>;5K  
+:75GDD7@FEEF3FGEA8AB7@EB357E;@%G?43;3@6 K67D3436;E3>3D?;@94K3@KEF3@63D6EA8GD43@B>3@@;@9 !@
  F:7%%EGDH7KD7BADF76F:3FF:7B7D53B;F33H3;>34;>;FKA8AB7@EB357E;@%G?43;I3E EC ? I:;>7
K67D3436 :3E ;F 3F 3 >AI A8  EC ? B7DEA@  55AD6;@9 FA F:7 7@FD3> 9AH7D@?7@FTE ,D43@ 3@6 )79;A@3>
7H7>AB?7@F(>3@EAD?G>3F;A@!?B>7?7@F3F;A@,)(!G;67>;@7E F:7AB7@EB3573H3;>34>7;@GD43@
3D73EE:AG>647 EC? %G?43;TEAB7@EB357E8AD8D77BG4>;5GE7355AG@F8AD3?7D7 B7D57@FA8F:75;FKTEFAF3>
3D73 I:;5:;EEC =?E7J5>G6;@9F:7B7D57@FA8*3@<3K3@6:;&3F;A@3>(3D= ;@6G  I:;>7 K67D3436
:3E A8;FE>3@63EAB7@EB357 

!@%G?43; 3@7I'B7@*B357(A>;5KI3E5A@E;67D76;@73D>K  I:;5:3>>AI7693D67@E B>3K9DAG@6E3@6


D75D73F;A@ 9DAG@6E  FA 47 36ABF76 4K 5ADBAD3F7E  ;@6;H;6G3>E  @A@ 9AH7D@?7@F AD93@;L3F;A@E 3@6 D7E;67@FET
3EEA5;3F;A@E ,@67DF:7BA>;5K F:7E7B>AFE?3K4736ABF768AD3B7D;A6A88;H7K73DEA@B3K?7@FA8367BAE;FA8)E
 &A5A@EFDG5F;A@I;>>473>>AI76A@F:7E7>3@6E3F3>> 7J57BFFA;>7FE +:7D73D7 @G?47DA8AB7@EB357E 
B>AFE3>D736K9;H7@G@67D53D7F3=7DBA>;5K  (>AFE>78FFA479;H7@AGFG@67DF:7@7IBA>;5K H7D3973@@G3>
%%4G697F8AD?3;@F7@3@573@6GB=77BA8F:7E7AB7@EB357E;E!&) 5DAD7 +:79DAG@6EI;>>:3H7FA47=7BF
AB7@8AD3557EEFAB7AB>78DA?3?FAB? 3F3@A?;@3>7@FDK877A8)EFA)E @FDK8AD5:;>6D7@3@6E7@;AD
5;F;L7@EI;>>478D77 +:;E6D38FBA>;5KI3E8A>>AI764K3@;@F7D;?BA>;5K;@*7BF7?47D  +:7;@F7D;?BA>;5KD7H;E76
F:7?3;@F7@3@57B7D;A6FA?A@F:E 

;;;  3I=7D(A>;5K  *FD77F-7@6ADTE5F  


3I=7DE ;@!@6;33@6?3@KAF:7D*AGF:E;3@3@6*AGF: 3EF7D@5AG@FD;7E3D75A@E;67D76FA47F:7>;87>;@7A8F:7
EFD77FF:7KAB7D3F7A@ +:7K7J:;4;F3@65A??G@;53F7F:7>A53>5G>FGD7 =77BF:7EFD77FEH;4D3@F 4GEK3@6E387DF:3@3
67E7DF76A@7 +:7K3D73>EAF:7BDAH;67DA85:73B7DABF;A@E8AD8AA63@6D7F3;> '@F:7AF:7DE;67 BDA>;87D3F;A@A8EFD77F
H7@6ADE;@5A@97EF763D73E53GE7E83;>GD7FA?3;@F3;@:K9;7@7EF3@63D6E 8D77 8>AI;@9FD388;53@65ADDGBF;A@ !8F:7
:3I=7DE 3D7 D79G>3F76 3@6 >;57@E76  F:7K 53@ 47 B3DF A8 F:7 8AD?3> 75A@A?K  BDAH;6;@9 7?B>AK?7@F FA F:7 >A53>
BABG>3573@6D7H7@G78ADF:7>A53>9AH7D@?7@FE %%;@;FE@7I:3I=7DEBA>;5K :3E67?3D53F76EB75;3>LA@7E8AD
:3I=7DEFAAB7D3F7;@3@6I;>>?A@;FAD3@6D79G>3F7:3I=7DE +:7&3F;A@3>!@6;3 3I=7D(A>;5KA8 ?3@63F76
F:3F35;FKE:AG>6:3H73F>73EF3E?3@K>;57@E76:3I=7DE3E A8;FEFAF3>BABG>3F;A@ AD%G?43; F:;E3?AG@FEFA
 H7@6ADE KEA?77EF;?3F7E F:;E;E3>EAF:73BBDAJ;?3F7@G?47DA8G@3GF:AD;L76:3I=7DE;@%G?43; '@57
B>39G76 4K F:7 E;?;>3D BDA4>7?E  *;@93BAD7 :3E 6A@7 3 IA@67D8G> <A4 ;@ D79G>3D;L;@9 3@6 BDA?AF;@9 3I=7D
7@FD7BD7@7GDE:;B I:;5::3H7BDAH;67634AAEFFAF:7FAGD;E?4K3FFD35F;@9F:AGE3@6EA8FAGD;EFE7H7DKK73D 7J:;4;F;@9
F:7EA5;3>3@65G>FGD3>3EB75FEA8*;@93BAD7:3@;  

;H  >GEF7D)767H7>AB?7@F(A>;5K  
5>GEF7D67H7>AB?7@FE5:7?78AD%G?43;EG4GD4EI3E3@@AG@576;@  I:;5:;E3@7@5AGD397?7@FFA;@8;>>
3@6D767H7>AB?7@F !F3;?E3F36H3@5;@93>3D97D3D73I;F:EA5;3>3@65;H;5;@8D3EFDG5FGD7835;>;F;7E +:;EE5:7?7:3E
3>D736K477@3BB>;76;@%G?43;5;FK;@BDA<75FEEG5:3E:7@6;3L3DD767H7>AB?7@F +:79AH7D@?7@F:3E3BBDAH76
F:7E5:7?78AD+:3@7;@74DG3DK  3@68AD&3H;%G?43;;@  

H *F3F;A@)767H7>AB?7@F(DA9D3??7  
AH7D@?7@FA8!@6;3TE%;@;EFDKA8)3;>I3KE*F3F;A@)767H7>AB?7@F(DA9D3??7!@6;3@)3;>I3KE :3E
477@6G44763EQ>3D97EF+'BDA9D3??7;@F:7IAD>6R4KGF;>;L;@93DAG@6  75F3D7EA8BD;?7D73>7EF3F7>3@6A@
>73E7 8AD  K73DE  ;@5>G6;@9   EF3F;A@E 35DAEE F:7 @3F;A@  7@7D3> 9G;67>;@7E A@ D767H7>AB?7@F A8 S T  ST
3F79ADKEF3F;A@E ;67@F;8;7E%G?43;*+3@6%G?43;7@FD3>EF3F;A@E3E53@6;63F7E8ADD767H7>AB?7@F !FBD;?3D;>K
8A5GE7EA@B3EE7@97D3?7@;F;7E ;@F7D?A63>5A@@75F;H;FK ;@F79D3F76E387FK3@6E75GD;FK 3557EE >7;EGD7835;>;F;7E3@6
5:75= ;@835;>;F;7E 

'F:7D;?BADF3@F5:3D35F7D;EF;5EA8EG5:D767H7>AB?7@F3D73E8A>>AIE
 ;@3@5;3>%75:3@;E?+:7BA>;5K:AB76FA>7H7D397F:75A??7D5;3>67H7>AB?7@FA8>3@63;DEB357;@3@6
3DAG@6F:7EF3F;A@I:;5:IAG>697@7D3F7F:7D7H7@G78DA?F:7D73>7EF3F7FA3F>73EF5AH7DF:77@F;D75AEFA8EF3F;A@
D767H7>AB?7@F38F7D?77F;@9F:78G>>7JB7@6;FGD7A@D73>7EF3F767H7>AB?7@F3@6?3;@F7@3@57A4>;93F;A@E 
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1977
  !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

 +:7BDABAE3>EFA47;@5A@8AD?;FKI;F:$A53>7H7>AB?7@FA@FDA>&AD?E
 A@EFD3;@F;@5A??7D5;3>67H7>AB?7@F -353@FD3;>I3K>3@6 3;DEB357E:3>>@AF47EA>6G@67D3@K5;D5G?EF3@57E 
AD5A??7D5;3>67H7>AB?7@F 3H3;>34>7H353@FD3;>I3K>3@6 3;DEB357E:3>>47>73E76A@>KI;F:>73E7B7D;A6GB
FAK73DE !FIAG>67J5>G67D7E;67@F;3>67H7>AB?7@F 

H;  #;AE=(A>;5K3F%7FDA*F3F;A@
?3J;?G?A8 EC?A8S43E;55A@H7@;7@57TD7F3;>;EB7D?;FF763F?7FDAEF3F;A@E3>>AI;@98ADF:7BDAH;E;A@A8
+%E  43E;5 EF3>>E 7F5 +:;E ;E 4G;>F ;@FA F:7 67H7>AB?7@F 39D77?7@F E;9@76 I;F: %%)  !F :3E 477@ A4E7DH76
:AI7H7D F:3FF:7D7;E?G5:?AD7EB3573H3;>34>73FF:7?7FDAEF3F;A@EF:3@I:3F;E47;@95GDD7@F>KGE764K=;AE=E 
+:7BDA434>7D73EA@8ADF:;EG@67DGE75AG>647F:7>35=A853B35;FKFA?3@397EG5:7EF34>;E:?7@FE3@6>35=A85>3D;FK
A@F:7E:3D;@9A8D7H7@G797@7D3F76 

H;;  *=KI3>=G;67>;@7E
&AEB75;8;5BA>;5K8AD*=KI3>=E7J;EFE !@%G?43; 7H7@F:AG9:%%;ED7EBA@E;4>78AD4G;>6;@9E=KI3>=E ;@
34E7@57A88G@6E F:7A@GE>;7EA@%%) +:7%G?43;*=KI3>=(DA<75F;EF:77D75F;A@A8E=KI3>=E8ADB767EFD;3@
GE7;@F:7%G?43;%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@4K%%) !@3>> E=KI3>=E:3H7477@5A?B>7F76AGFA8I:;5:F:7
%%)5A@EFDG5F76 %*)3@6I3E5A@EFDG5F764K#3>K3@ A?4;H3>;%G@;5;B3>ADBAD3F;A@ +:7EGDH7K
5A@6G5F76 4K %%) E:AIE F:3F ?AD7 F:3@  >3=:E 5A??GF7DE ?3=7 GE7 A8 F:7 E=KI3>=  DG@@;@9 AH7D 
=;>A?7F7DE  +:7E7 I7D7 BD;?3D;>K ;@EF3>>76 FA 5A@@75F F:7 :;9: 67@E;FK EG4GD43@ D3;>I3K FA AF:7D ?A67E A8
FD3@EBADF3F;A@ 3@68AD788;5;7@F6;EB7DE3>A85A??GF7DE8DA?5A@97EF763D73EFAEFD3F79;5>A53F;A@E EG5:3E4GEEF3F;A@E 
F3J;EF3@6E E:ABB;@93D73E 7F5 *=KI3>=EI7D73>EAB3DFA8*+!*;@+:3@7 *=KI3>=E:3H73>EA477@5A@EFDG5F76
5A@@75F;@9F:7EG4GD43@D3;>I3KEF3F;A@FAF:7?7FDAEF3F;A@3F@6:7D;3@6:3F=AB3D 

 (($##),%$!$'

><  &D86I>DC'6ED;C9=:G>6C91"DC':IGD&>C:>C'JB76>

+:;EB3B7D5>3EE;8;7EF:7H3D;AGEEF3F;A@E3>A@9F:7?7FDA>;@7;@FIAFKBA>A9;7E?G>F; ?A63>;@F7D5:3@97:G43@6
?7FDA;@F7D5:3@97EF3F;A@E !F3FF7?BFE3@7>34AD3F7?3BB;@9A8E7>75F76EF3F;A@EG@67D8AD4AF:F:75;F;7E *F3F;A@
1978 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

3D73E 3D7 EFG6;76 3>A@9 I;F: ;FE 5A@@75F;A@ FA ;@F7D?76;3F7 BG4>;5 FD3@EBADF  EF3=7:A>67DE 3@6 5A@EFDG5F;A@ EF3FGE 
3?A@9EF AF:7D 5D;F7D;3  3E BAF7@F;3> EF3F;A@E I:7D7 F:7 ;@F7D?A63> FD3@EBADF3F;A@ :G4E 53@ 47 7@H;E;A@76 3@6
5A@E7CG7@F>KF:75:3>>7@97E3@6F:7BAF7@F;3>53@47;67@F;8;76 

 1)0&,!)+0". %+$"

+:;EFKBA>A9K8A5GE7EA@F:7%7FDAEF3F;A@EI:;5::3H7?AD7F:3@A@7?A67A8FD3@EBADF3F;A@E;FG3F765>AE7FA735:
AF:7DFA4734>7FA>7H7D397F:7BDAJ;?;FKA8F:7?A67EFA5D73F7367EF;@3F;A@ 

 +!%".&

.67A:  68I-=::I 'JAI> 'D96A#CI:G8=6C<: C9=:G>'JB76>


#CI:G8=6C<:H C9=:G>-J7JG76C,6>AL6N-I6I>DC1:HI:GC&>C: "6G7DJG&>C:
C9=:G> ':IGD -I6I>DC ':IGD &>C: 

C9=:G>JH:EDI6HI 1:HI 
>HI6C8:7:IL::C;JGI=:HI-I6I>DCH .D0:GHDK6P @B 
.D!=6I@DE6GP @B 
-I6@:=DA9:GH #C9>6C,6>AL6NH -. '))*&':IGD)C:)E:G6I>DC*G>K6I:&>B>I:9

-I6IJH C9=:G>':IGD-I6I>DC )E:G6I>DC6A

@6:7D;;E3B3EE7@97DD3;>EF3F;A@E7DH;@9F:7.7EF7D@>;@73@6 3D4AGD>;@7EA8F:7%G?43;*G4GD43@)3;>I3K +:7
EF3F;A@;@F7D 5A@@75FEF:7$;@7A8F:7@6:7D;?7FDAEF3F;A@ .;F:3BD7 7?;@7@F@G?47DA8B3EE7@97DE4A3D6;@9
63;>K  ;F :3E 477@ F7D?76 A@7 A8 F:7 4GE;7EF EF3F;A@E ;@%G?43;A@ F:7 7@FD3> >;@7  !@    F:7 EF3F;A@  3>A@9
I;F:"A97E:I3D;3@6AD793A@EF3F;A@E  I3E D7 67H7>AB76 3@6 7JB3@676 I;F: F:7 7JB7@6;FGD7 A8 !&) 
5DAD7,*?;>>;A@ !@366;F;A@ F:7EF3F;A@:3EFIA4GEEF3F;A@EAB7D3F;@9?AD7F:3@ 4GEDAGF7E E;9GD7
E:AIE ;F ;E 3 BAF7@F;3> ;@F7D?A63> FD3@EBADF3F;A@ :G4 I;F: )3;>I3K EF3F;A@E  %7FDA EF3F;A@  GE EF3F;A@E  3>>
;@F7D5A@@75F76I;F:*=KI3>=E3@6AAF AH7D4D;697E'  AI7H7D F:;E:3E477@6A@7AH7DF:7K73DE;@3@36:A5
?3@@7D 

':IGD&>C:
':IGD-I6I>DC
,6>AL6N&>C:
,6>AL6N-I6I>DC
) 
-@N16A@
JH:EDI
,D69


B

><  -I6I>DCG:6'6ED;C9=:G>>C'JB76>

" 1+!".!
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1979
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

$A53F76 ;@ F:7 :73DF A8 F:7 5;FK  *75G@67D3436 "G@5F;A@ ;E 3@
7J;EF;@9?3<AD;@F7D5;FKD3;>I3KEF3F;A@3@635A??GF7DD3;>:G4;@
F:75;FK !F;E8GDF:7D5A@@75F76FAF:7D7EFA8F:75;FKF:DAG9:F:7
   
K67D3436%%+*3@6F:74GEE7DH;57E3F)3F:;8;>7EF3F;A@ +:;E;E
A@7A8F:7?AEF?3<AD;@F7D5:3@97E>A53F76I;F:;@F:75;FK>;?;FE 
3>F:AG9: 3E K7F G@B>3@@76 ;@ @3FGD7  !F :3E D757@F>K 477@
G@67DF3=7@ G@67D F:7 !@6;3@ )3;>I3KET *F3F;A@ )767H7>AB?7@F B::GE:I
(DA9D3??7  E ;9GD7   E:AIE *75G@67D3436 3EF  .7EF
EF3F;A@EA@ADD;6AD3@63D75>AE7FA735:AF:7D I;F:3 35D7E
A8 B3D57> I:;5: 53@ 47 73D?3D=76 8AD +D3@E;F 'D;7@F76
7H7>AB?7@F+'FA;@F79D3F7H3D;AGE?A67E 

><    &D86I>DC '6E D; -:8JC9:G6769 6C9 B::GE:I >C


"N9:G6769

.67A:  68I-=::I 'JAI>P'D96A#CI:G8=6C<:P-:8JC9:G6769"N9:G6769


#CI:G8=6C<:H -:8JC9:G6769 $JC8I>DC ,6>AL6N -I6I>DC
-DJI=:CIG6A,6>AL6NHP#C9>6C,6>AL6NH
-:8JC9:G67696HI':IGD-I6I>DC':IGDDGG>9DG
-:8JC9:G67691:HI':IGD-I6I>DC':IGDDGG>9DG
,6I=>;>A:JH-I6I>DC
"N9:G6769''.-
>HI6C8:7:IL::C;JGI=:HIHI6I>DCH @B6EEGDM
.)*6G8:A 2:H 6I-:8JC9:G67691:HI':IGD-I6I>DC 
 =66EEGDM 
-I6@:=DA9:GH #C9>6C,6>AL6NHP-DJI=:CIG6A .:A6C<6C6-I6I:,D69.G6CHEDGIDGEDG6I>DC.-,. "', &.',
-I6IJH -:8JC9:G67696HI':IGD-I6I>DC )E:G6I>DC6A
-:8JC9:G67691:HI':IGD-I6I>DCP/C9:GDCHIGJ8I>DC
)I=:G:I6>AH H@NL6A@>HEGDEDH:98DCC:8I>C<-:8JC9:G67696HI':IGDHI6I>DCIDI=:G6>AL6NHI6I>DC;DDIDK:G7G>9<: 






><  -:8JC9:G6769-I6I>DCG:6 ><  -I6I>DCG:6'6ED;1"

 "0.,+0". %+$"00&,+

+:;EEF3F;A@FKB7:3E;@F7D5:3@97A8%7FDAEF3F;A@EI;F:;@I3>=;@96;EF3@57 

"/0".+4-."//&$%3500&,+
.7EF7D@JBD7EE ;9:I3K 344D7H;3F76FA. D74D3@6763E%39;5D;5=E. 6G7FA3@3?;@9D;9:FE673>;E
1980 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

3?7FDAEF3F;A@A@$;@7A8F:7%G?43;%7FDAE7DH;@9F:7@6:7D;EG4GD4A8%G?43; !@6;3 !F;EF:78>39E:;BEF3F;A@


A8F:7>;@73@6I3EAB7@76FAF:7BG4>;5A@"G@7  

.67A:  68I-=::I ':IGD#CI:G8=6C<:-I6I>DCP1"'JB76>

#CI:G8=6C<:H 1"&>C:6C9
-I6@:=DA9:GH '))*&':IGD)C:)E:G6I>DC*G>K6I:&>B>I:9
'',
-I6IJH &>C:DE:G6I>DC6A &>C:EA6CC:9

 *"".-"0

.67A:  68I-=::I ':IGD#CI:G8=6C<:-I6I>DC B::GE:I"N9:G6769

#CI:G8=6C<:H B::GE:IDGG>9DG
-I6I>DCH>O:8DC;><JG6I>DC &6G<:HI':IGDHI6I>DCP BADC<6C9 BL>9:
0:GI>86AHI68@>C<D;ILDHI6I>DCH
DGG>9DGP&DL:G*A6I;DGB&:K:A
DGG>9DGP/EE:G*A6I;DGB&:K:A
-I6@:=DA9:GH &.',
-I6IJH )E:G6I>DC6A
ME:8I:9G>9:GH=>E  8DBBJI:GHE:G96N
)I=:G9:I6>AH *G:H:C8:D;QE6>9R6C9QJCE6>9RODC:HL>I=>CI=:HI6I>DC6HL:AA6HG:I6>A6G:6H 
.>8@:I>C<'6?DG,:I6>AD88JGH6IDC8DJGH:&:K:A :CIGNIDL=>8=9D:HCDIG:FJ>G:6I>8@:I 

?77DB7F ;E 3 ?3<AD 5A??7D5;3> 3@6 76G53F;A@3> :G4 >A53F76 ;@


K67D34363@6;E=@AI@3E!@6;3TESG@A88;5;3>!+FD3;@;@9:G4T +:77@F;D7
3D733>EAI;F@7EE7E:;9:>7H7>EA8B767EFD;3@3@6H7:;5G>3DFD388;56GD;@9
B73= :AGDE +:7?77DB7F ?7FDA EF3F;A@ ;E 3 ?3<AD ;@F7D5:3@97 EF3F;A@
B>3@@7647FI77@ADD;6ADE3@6 !F;EG@;CG73E;F:3EF:7;@F7D5:3@97
3FFIA6;887D7@F>7H7>E !F3>EA3>>AIED7F3;>I;F:;@F:7EF3F;A@3D738ADGBFA
 EC ? 8AD8AGD?A6G>7FKB7E 

 $"%&(* #!,'' ><  B::GE:I-I6I>DCG:6>C"N9:G6769

 /"01!5,#"0.,&+"

><  ,>9:GH=>E>HIG>7JI>DC;DGI=:':IGD&>C: -DJG8:,:A>6C8:#C;G6HIGJ8IJG:

+:7%G?43;%7FDA;E3B>3@@76GD43@D3;>FD3@E;FEKEF7?F:3F3;?EFA;?BDAH75A@@75F;H;FK8ADB7AB>7D7E;6;@9;@
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1981
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

3D73E;@%G?43;F:3F3D7@AF5A@@75F764KF:7EG4GD43@D3;>I3KEF3F;A@ +:7%3EF7D(>3@8AD%G?43;%7FDAI3E
5A??;EE;A@76 4K F:7 %G?43; %7FDABA>;F3@ )79;A@ 7H7>AB?7@F GF:AD;FK %%) I;F: F:7 A4<75F;H7 A8
;?BDAH;@9F:7FD388;53@6FD3@EBADF3F;A@E57@3D;A;@F:7%G?43;%7FDABA>;F3@)79;A@%%) +:7D73D7@AI>;@7E
I:;5:3D7BDABAE76;@B:3E7E 5AH7D;@93FAF3>A8=?;@6;EF3@57 'GFA8F:;E $;@7;E3>D736K8G@5F;A@3> I:;>7
AH7D3>>5A?B>7F;A@A83>>F:7D7?3;@;@9>;@7E;E7JB75F76;@  EB7D%%) 36;EF3@57A8FA=?E:3E477@
5A@E;67D763EF:753F5:?7@F3D733DAG@6735:?7FDAEF3F;A@ +:7?7FDAEKEF7?;EB>3@@768AD;@F7D5:3@97E3F?3<AD
@A67EEG5:3E::3FD3B3F;*:;H3<;+7D?;@GE %G?43;7@FD3> !@F7D@3F;A@3>A?7EF;5;DBADFE7F5 

%7FDA $;@7  I3E ;@;F;3F76 G@67D F:7 !@6;3@ +D3?I3KE 5F    !@    F:7 7B3DF?7@F A8 ,D43@
7H7>AB?7@F4DAG9:FF:7%G?43;%7FDAG@67DF:7%7FDA)3;>I3KEA@EFDG5F;A@A8.AD=E5FA8 +:;E:363
?3<AD;?B35FA@F:78;J3F;A@A883D7E 3EG@67D@7I5F %%'($ I3E9D3@F76F:73GF:AD;FKFA8;JF:783D7E 38F7D
A4F3;@;@9D75A??7@63F;A@E8DA?F:73D7;J3F;A@A??;FF77 

+:73;?A8F:;E53E7EFG6K;EFAEFG6KF:7;?B35FA8%7FDA$;@7A@F:7EGDDAG@6;@95;FK834D;5 %7FDA$;@7;E
F:78;DEF?7FDAD3;>EKEF7?;@FDA6G576;@%G?43;;@  !F5A@@75FE-7DEAH3;@F:7I7EF7D@EG4GD4EFA:3F=AB3D
;@F:773EF7D@EG4GD4EA8%G?43; E3D757@F>K;?B>7?7@F76FD3@E;F5ADD;6AD;@34DAI@8;7>6E57@3D;A F:;E53E7
BDAH;67EF:7ABBADFG@;FK
M +AEFG6KF:7;@F79D3F;A@A8$;@7I;F:F:77J;EF;@9FD3@EBADF3F;A@@7FIAD=E8AD?3>3@6;@8AD?3> 7J;EF;@9
4G;>6;@9E3@65;FKEFDG5FGD7 3@6
M +A7J3?;@7F:75:3@97E;83@KE77@;@F:7>3@6B3D57>E3>A@9F:7>;@73@6@73DF:7EF3F;A@E

3+"./%&- +! "2"),-"./  %G?43; %7FDA $;@7  ;E 5A@57;H76 A@ F:7 G;>6 'B7D3F7 +D3@E87D ?A67> 
I:7D7%%):A>6ED7EBA@E;4;>;FK8ADD;9:F A8 I3K73E7?7@FE3@6)7>;3@57!@8D3EFDG5FGD7:3@6>7EF:75;H;>IAD=E
3@663K FA 63KAB7D3F;A@A8F:7>;@7 )7H7@G78DA?F:783D7E 36H7DF;E7?7@FE3@6=;AE=E9A7E6;D75F>KFA)7>;3@57
!@8D3EFDG5FGD7  +:7D7 3D7 AF:7D 397@5;7E F:3F AB7D3F7 ;@ F:7 GD43@ D73>? EG5: 3E %%  D;:3@?G?43; >75FD;5
*GBB>K3@6+D3@EBADF*+ )3;>I3KE7F5I:;5:3>EA:3H73EF3=7;@F:767H7>AB?7@FA8F:7%7FDA5ADD;6AD +:7
E5AB7A8F:;E53E7EFG6K;E>;?;F76FAF:78A>>AI;@9FIAB3D3?7F7DE
 $3@6,E7; 7 F:75:3@97;@F:7@3FGD7A8>3@6GE7E
 +D3@EBADF3F;A@; 7 B767EFD;3@!(+@7FIAD=E EFD77F67E;9@7F5 

.,'" 0 ,*-,+"+0/  %G?43; %7FDA $;@7  I3E ;@FDA6G576 I;F: F:7 ;@F7@F A8 ;?BDAH;@9 F:7 73EF I7EF
5A@@75F;H;FK;@F:75;FK G@67D(:3E7A8F:7%3EF7D(>3@8AD%G?43;%7FDA !F7JF7@6E8DA?-7DEAH3;@F:7I7EF7D@
EG4GD4EFA:3F=AB3D;@F:773EF7D@EG4GD4E +:7D73D7EF3F;A@EA@F:;E?7FDA5ADD;6AD F:7?3<ADA@7E47;@9-7DEAH3 
@6:7D;3@6:3F=AB3D +IA;@F7D5:3@97E3D75D73F763F@6:7D;3@63F:3F=AB3D I;F:F:7EG4GD43@D3;>I3K>;@7E 
.;F:F:7;@FDA6G5F;A@A8F:;E?7FDA>;@7 F:7FD3H7>F;?78DA?:3F=AB3DFA-7DEAH3I3ED76G576FA?;@GF7 
%7FDA>;@73>EABDAH;67E;?BDAH765A@@75F;H;FKFAF:77?B>AK?7@F:G4EA8*(0%! 

") /00" "2"),-*"+0 ),+$ ',. .+/-,.00&,+ ,..&!,./  +D3@EBADF3F;A@ ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 75A@A?;5E
:3H7 :;EFAD;53>>K BDAH7@ FA :3H7 3 BAE;F;H7 ;?B35F A@ D73> 7EF3F7 H3>G7E ;@ 3 5;FK >;=7 %G?43; P D7E;67@F;3> 3@6
5A??7D5;3> BDAB7DF;7E >A53F76 5>AE7 FA FD3@EBADF3F;A@ ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 F7@6 FA 5A??3@6 3 BD7?;G?  !@67B7@67@F
3@3>KE7EA8BD;5;@9D7H73>F:3FBDAJ;?;FKFA3%7FDAEF3F;A@53@E;@9>7 :3@676>K355AG@F8AD3B7D57@FH3D;3F;A@;@
>3@6H3>G7E F:7AF:7D835FADE47;@9>A53F;A@ 6;EF3@57A8F:7>3@68DA?F:757@FD3>BA;@F3@6;@5A?79DAGBE 7H7>AB7DE
;@F7D7EF;@BDA<75FE@73DF:7%7FDA:3E477@;@5D73E;@9E;@57F:7EF3DFA85A@EFDG5F;A@ .;F:F:75A??7@57?7@FA8F:7
BDA<75F F:7EGDDAG@6;@9D79;A@:3E678;@;F7>K7JB7D;7@576357DF3;@4AA?;@F7D?EA8@7IA887D;@9E3@6BD;57:;=7E 
)3F7EA@4AF:F:75A??7D5;3>3@6D7E;67@F;3>?3D=7F:3H7;@5D73E76 
 %G>F; ?A63>;@F7D5:3@973F:3F=AB3D3@6@6:7D;;E7@34>76F:DAG9:F:75A@EFDG5F;A@A8E=KI3>=EI:;5:5A@@75F
F:7D3;>I3KEF3F;A@FAF:7%7FDAEF3F;A@ 
 %AEFA8F:7@7I67H7>AB?7@FE;@F:7-7DEAH3FA@6:7D;EFD7F5:3@6;@F:7*3=;&3=3FA:3F=AB3DEFD7F5:3D7
D7E;67@F;3>;@@3FGD73EE:AI@;@;9GD7 

2".)) .,'" 0 .*"3,.( +:7%G?43;%7FDA;E5>3EE;8;763E3SBG4>;5H;F3>;@8D3EFDG5FGD7BDA<75FT4KF:7
AH7D@?7@FA8%3:3D3E:FD3A% %%):3E477@67E;9@3F76F:7S(DA<75F!?B>7?7@F3F;A@97@5KT8ADF:7%7FDA
4K F:7 A%  AD ;?B>7?7@F3F;A@ A8 %7FDA $;@7   3 *B75;3> (GDBAE7 -7:;5>7 *(- I3E ;@5ADBAD3F76 G@67D F:7
1982 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

A?B3@;7E5F  8AD?;@9%G?43;%7FDA'@7(HF $F6%%'($ +:7%%'($;E3<A;@FH7@FGD75A?B3@K


8AD?764K)7>;3@57@7D9K$;?;F76 3)7>;3@57DAGBA?B3@K -7A>;3+D3@EBADF D3@573@6%%) E
B7DF:7A@57EE;A@9D77?7@F F:7;?B>7?7@F3F;A@B7D;A6I3EFA478DA? FA 3@6BDA<75F5AEFI3E7EF;?3F76
FA473DAG@6)E 5DAD7E -;34;>;FK3BG@6;@9-A8)E  5DAD7E;EBDAH;6764KF:7AH7D@?7@F 

><    (:L :K:ADEB:CI J>A9>C< /H: *:G8:CI6<: >HIG>7JI>DC P -I6I>DC


L>H:

 ,*-.&/,+ "03""+ 1*& &+"  +!


5!".!"0.,%/"

+A ;67@F;8K F:7 BAF7@F;3> A8 F:7E7 FD3@E;F 5ADD;6ADE ;@


67H7>AB;@9;@F7D?A63>FD3@EBADF3F;A@:G4E3@6FAG@67DEF3@6
F:7 5:3>>7@97E 3@ !@6;3@ GD43@ E57@3D;A BAE7E  F:7 ?7FDA
5ADD;6ADE ;@ %G?43; 3@6 K67D3436 I7D7 7H3>G3F76  3@6
7@>;EF76;@F:78A>>AI;@9F34>7 
><  -DJG8:!DD<A:6GI= M>HI>C<&6C9/H:*A6C   
.67A: DBE6G6I>K:K6AJ6I>DCD;'JB76>6C9"N9:G6769

 'JB76>':IGD&>C: "N9:G6769':IGD*=6H:

#C>I>6AAN #C9>6C.G6BL6NH8I  #C   *'JC>8>E6A.G6BL6NHDCHIGJ8I>DC )E:G6I>DC


!DK:GC>C<

:E6GIB:CID;/G76C:K:ADEB:CI7GDJ<=II=: '6>CI:C6C8:>AA  
'JB76>':IGDJC9:GI=:':IGD,6>AL6NH
8I

DCHIGJ8I>DCD;1DG@H8I  

J>A9 )E:G6I: .G6CH;:GBD9:A). :H><C J>A9 >C6C8: )E:G6I: .G6CH;:GBD9:A ).


*GD?:8I
'D9:A

'JB76>':IGD)C:*G>K6I:&I9'')*&>H6C "N9:G6769':IGD,6>A&>B>I:9>HI=:-*08G:6I:97N-I6I:
-*08G:6I:97:IL::C'', ,:A>6C8: !DK:GCB:CI;DG*=6H:
#C;G6HIGJ8IJG:6C90:DA>6.G6CHEDGI;DG&>C:  "'6C9!"'6G:I=:'JC>8>E6ADGEDG6I>DC6C9
<:C8>:H
#CKDAK:9

'JB76>':IGDEDA>I6C,:<>DC:K:ADEB:CI ':IGDEDA>I6CJI=DG>IN 68>A>I6IDGH;DGA6C968FJ>H>I>DC 


JI=DG>IN'',>HG:HEDCH>7A:;DGG><=I D; L6N E:GB>HH>DCH:I8
:6H:B:CIH &.':IGD,6>A"N9:G6769&>B>I:9>HI=:DC8:HH>DC6>G:
,:A>6C8:#C;G6HIGJ8IJG:6HI=:EG>K6I::CI>IN>H 6C9>HG:HEDCH>7A:;DG8DCHIGJ8I>DC 96N ID 96N DE:G6I>DCH #I
G:HEDCH>7A:;DG8>K>ALDG@H6C996N ID 96NDE:G6I>DCH  G:8:>K:HG:K:CJ:;GDB;6G:H 69K:GI>H:B:CIH G:I6>A6C9.)
#IG:8:>K:HG:K:CJ:;GDB;6G:H 69K:GI>H:B:CIH6C9
@>DH@H
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1983
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

.) G:A6I:9 .) G:A6I:9


6GA>:GK:GH>DCD;I=:9G6;I:K:ADEB:CI*A6C  1=:CI=:B:IGD9:K:ADEB:CIEA6CL6H8DBEA:I: 6C6B:C9B:CI
L=>8=EGDEDH:96.)HIG6I:<N;DG'JB76>6C96C L6HB69:IDI=:B6HI:GEA6CD;I=:!G:6I:G"N9:G6769'JC>8>E6A
-#D; ID6ADC<I=:':IGD&>C:8DGG>9DG=6H DGEDG6I>DC!"' >CIGD9J8>C< BL>9:QBJAI>EA: JH:R
7::CH8G6EE:9 .=:G:>HCD:M>HI>C<EDA>8N;DGA6C9JH: ODC:HDC:>I=:GH>9:D;I=:B:IGD8DGG>9DG .=>HG:<JA6I:H
*DA>8>:H

9:K:ADEB:CIH6ADC<I=:':IGD8DGG>9DG  G:9:K:ADEB:CID;EADIH 7J>A9>C<A>C:H6C9B>C>BJBEADI6G:6H>C


 I=:ODC: 
,:I6>A6I-I6I>DCH 
B6M>BJBD; HFBD;Q76H>88DCK:C>:C8:R ,:I6>A6I-I6I>DCH
G:I6>A>HE:GB>II:96IB:IGDHI6I>DCH6AADL>C<;DGI=: 1:AA9:;>C:9G:I6>AHIG6I:<NL>I=>CHI6I>DCH 68=HI6I>DCL>AA
EGDK>H>DCD;.'H 76H>8HI6AAH:I8 #I=6H7::C =6K:G:I6>AHE68:HG6C<>C<;GDB  ID HF;IID
D7H:GK:9=DL:K:G I=6II=:G:>HBJ8=BDG:HE68: HFB #CI:G8=6C<:6C9HE:8>6AHI6I>DCHL>AA=6K:G:I6>AHE68:H
6K6>A67A:6II=:B:IGDHI6I>DCHI=6CL=6I>H7:>C< G6C<>C<;GDB ID HF;IID HFB  INE:H
8JGG:CIANJH:97N@>DH@H  D;G:I6>ABD9JA:H6K6>A67A:9:E:C9>C<DCI=:H>O:D;I=:HIDG:

'DHID;I=:C:L9:K:ADEB:CIH6ADC<I=:':IGD .DD:6GANIDD7H:GK:>BE68ID;':IGDDCHJGGDJC9>C<G:6A
8DGG>9DG6G::>I=:GG:H>9:CI>6ADG8DBB:G8>6A>CC6IJG:  :HI6I: AAEA6CC:9G:6A:HI6I:9:K:ADEB:CI>HJC9:GI=:
:K:ADEB:CI
6ADC<':IGD

,:9:K:ADEB:CID;EADIH6C98=6C<:>C7J>A9>C<JH:H>C DC8:HH>DC6>G:RH.)HIG6I:<N> : 68GDHH<DK:GCB:CI6AADII:9


,:6AHI6I:

I=:1"ID'6GDA(6@6HIG:I8=  EADIH6ADC<I=:':IGD8DGG>9DG 
DGG>9DG

'DHIC:L8DCHIGJ8I>DCH6G:7NEG>K6I:9:K:ADE:GH
 'DHID;I=:C:L7J>A9>C<H6G:8DCHIGJ8I:97NI=:
DC8:HH>DC6>G:> : &.', 

0:GI>86A'>M:9/H:INEDAD<N> :  &6G<:ANH>C<A:JH:7J>A9>C<HD7H:GK:9>CI=:8DCHIGJ8I:9.)
:K:ADEB:CI

G:H>9:CI>6A 8DBB:G8>6AL>I=6H=DE;GDCI>C-6@>(6@6 E6G8:AHPBDHIAN8>C:B6I=:6IG:H .=:H:6G:L6AA:99:K:ADEB:CIH


.NEDAD<N
J>A9>C<

IDC9=:G>HIG:I8= DBB:G8>6AIDL:GH6C9G:HI6JG6CIH L>I=CD9>G:8I8DCC:8I>DCIDI=:':IGD &DL:GA:K:AHD;I=:


.G:C9H

ID86I:GIDD;;>8:8GDL9H "><=G>H:G:H>9:CI>6A<6I:9 7J>A9>C<86I:GIDE6G@>C< 


8DBBJC>I>:H>CC9=:G> 0:GHDK6HIG:I8= 

06G>:H  0:GNADL 9:HE>I:7:>C<EG: EA6CC:96C9:M:8JI:97N6H>C<A:


9=:G:C8:

*G>C8>EA:H

*ADIH8ADH:GIDI=:B:IGDHI6I>DC=6K:68I>K::9<:H 6<:C8N 
ID.)

L>I=K>HJ6AANE:GB:67A:6C9E=NH>86AAN688:HH>7A:
;GDCI6<:H .=DH:;JGI=:G6L6N6G:<6I:9 

(>A  '>C>B6A 'DG:A>@:.G6CH>I$(.:K:ADEB:CI  D8JH


8IJ6A

#CI:CI

>HDCB6M>B>H>C<EGD;>I67>A>IND;I=:EADIH 
.)

'JAI> BD96A>CI:G8=6C<:6I!=6I@DE6G6C9 'JAI>BD96A>CI:G8=6C<:=J7HEGDEDH6AH=6K:CDIN:I7::C


C9=:G>>H:C67A:9I=GDJ<=I=:8DCHIGJ8I>DCD; 6EEGDK:9I=:<DK:GCB:CI -@NL6A@8DCC:8I>C<-:8JC9:G6769
.G6CHEDGI6I>DC

H@NL6A@HL=>8=8DCC:8II=:G6>AL6NHI6I>DCIDI=: G6>AL6N6C9B:IGDHI6I>DC>HEGDEDH:9 
':IGDHI6I>DC  *6G@>C<;DG':IGD6C9CDC ':IGDJH:GH>HEGDK>9:9L>I=>CI=:


.LD L=::A:GE6G@>C<6IHI6I>DCHD7H:GK:9  .) 


DGB6A#*.HI6C9HCDIEA6CC:9 #C;DGB6A6JID :I6>A:9IG6CHEDGI6I>DCEA6CH;DGHI6I>DC6G:6H=6K:7::C
E>8@ JEED>CIH=6K::B:G<:9C:6GI=:HI6I>DC:CIGN EG:E6G:97JICDIN:I6EEGDK:97NI=:<DK:GCB:CI 
:M>IH 86JH>C<6ADID;8DC<:HI>DCD7H:GK:9DCI=:
, ) 1

#CI:G 6<:C8N8DAA67DG6I>DCHD7H:GK:9HJ8=6H .>: JEHL>I=EG>K6I:I6M>H:GK>8:H /7:G )A6PDCI=:86G9H


8DCC:8I>K>IN

':IGD*=:G>6C9)A6  'D7>A>IN6G9ID7:>CIGD9J8:9;DGH:6BA:HHBD7>A>IN68GDHH
&6HIB>A:

)A6I6M>E>8@ JEED>CIHAD86I:96I':IGDHI6I>DCH ':IGD 7JH:I8


L>I=9>H8DJCI:9;6G:H;DG':IGDJH:GH 

G6C9>C<69K:GI>H>C<DC6;:LHI6I>DCH7N )K:G6AAHIG6I:<N>HB>HH>C< 7JI6II:BEIH6I<>K>C<:68=


6AI:G>C<HI6I>DCC6B: < '6<>8G>8@H1"HI6I>DC HI6I>DC6JC>FJ:>9:CI>INI=GDJ<=HIG::I>BEGDK:B:CIH6GDJC9I=:
=6AA:C<:H B6@>C<

:I8 HI6I>DC=6K:7::C86GG>:9DJI *J7A>8EA6O69:H><C:96I6I:GB>C6A


'6?DG *A68:

HI6I>DC 

*G:H:C8:D;BJAI>EA:6<:C8>:HL>I=K6GN>C<GDA:H =6AA:C<:H;68:9L:G::>I=:G9J:ID8=6C<:H>CAD86AEDA>8>:H
6C9G:HEDCH>7>A>I>:HL>I=>CI=:JG76CG:6AB HJ8=6HI=:(:L&6C98FJ>H>I>DC8IDG9J:IDDC H>I:
9>;;>8JAI>:H>C;>C6A>O>C<6C98DCHIGJ8I>C<8:GI6>CE6GIHD;I=:
':IGD8DGG>9DG
1984 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

 $#!)'$#  !!#'$(#(!

><    ,:A:K6CI HI6@:=DA9:GH ID 6 ,6>A >CI:<G6I:9 JG76C


><    *DA>8>:H G:A:K6CI ID 6 ,6>A >CI:<G6I:9 JG76C
9:K:ADEB:CI
9:K:ADEB:CI

+:78A>>AI;@9A4E7DH3F;A@EI;F:D75A??7@63F;A@E5AG>69A3>A@9I3K;@;?BDAH;@9F:7I3KF:7D3;>I3BA>;5;7E
5AG>68A5GEA@F:78A>>AI;@95A@F7@F

  &7768AD3BD7 7?BF;H7;@F79D3F76>3@6GE7 FD3@EBADFBA>;5K


3D?3D=;@9F:7LA@78ADEF3F;A@D7>3F7667H7>AB?7@FE;?;>3DFA%G?43;TE53E7I:7D7F:7 8;DEF ?A8F:7 ?
E:3>> 47 73D?3D=76 8AD F:7 D3;>I3K AB7D3F;A@E  FD388;5 6;EB7DE3> 835;>;F;7E 3@6 B3D=;@9 >AFE 3@6 @A ;@6;H;6G3>
67H7>AB?7@FEE:3>>47B7D?;FF76I;F:;@F:;E3D73 66;F;A@3>>K F:7BA>;5K5AG>68A5GEA@

  %G>F; ?A63>:G4B>3@@;@9
%G>F; ?A63>:G4ED7CG;D73676;53F76B>3@@;@9EFD3F79KFA78875F;H7>K:3@6>7F:7FD3@E87DA8B3EE7@97DE GDD7@F>K 
F:7D7;E@AEG5:B>3@@;@9EFD3F79K;@B>3573F@6:7D;AD:3F=AB3D D7EG>F;@9;@B767EFD;3@3@6H7:;5G>3D5:3AE3FF:7
;@F7D5:3@97E 

  7E;9@3F;A@A8DA>7E3@6D7EBA@E;4;>;F;7E8ADH3D;AGEEF3=7:A>67DE
%G?43;TE53E7BD7E7@FEF:7;@F7D7EFEA8?G>F;FG67397@5;7E %%);EF:7B>3@@;@9397@5K I:;>7%%;E
D7EBA@E;4>78ADF:763K FA 63KGB=77BA8F:7)'.G@67DF:7%7FDA>;@7 3D75A>>75F;A@6G7E>;7I;F:F:7BD;H3F77@F;FK
I:;>73@K47@78;FE6G7FA;@5D73E76BDAB7DFKF3J5A>>75F;A@9AFAI3D6E%% .;F:;@F:;E8D3?7IAD= ;F;E35:3>>7@97
FA7J75GF73EGEF3;@34>7FD3@EBADF3F;A@67H7>AB?7@F?A67>G@>7EEF:7BAI7DEA8B>3@@;@93@67J75GF;A@>;7I;F:3
E;@9>7397@5K AD5>73D>K6;H;676 EB75;3>BGDBAE7H7:;5>7I;F:?7?47DE8DA?F:7EF3=7:A>67DE;EF:773E;7EFI3KFA
AH7D5A?7F:74GD73G5D35K 3E7J:;4;F764K4AF: K67D34363@6%G?43;TE53E7 

  (D;AD;F;L;@9F:7>736;@9DA>7A8F:7(D;H3F7*75FAD
5>73DH;E;A@E:AG>6478AD?G>3F763@6B>3@@;@9E:AG>6476A@78ADF:767H7>AB?7@FA83FD3@EBADF3F;A@DAGF7 >;@7 
+:7BA>;5KE:AG>6BDAH;678ADAI@7DE:;B8ADBD;H3F7E75FAD );E=E:3D;@98ADF:7(((?A67>E:AG>647;?BDAH76 %AEF
A8F:7D;E=;E4AD@74KF:7BD;H3F7E75FAD 7EB75;3>>K6G7FA67>3KE;@:3@6;@9AH7DF:7>3@6 3D4;FD3F;A@;EEG7E D7EADF;@9
83D78;J;@9;EEG7E )'.73E7?7@FE 7F5 3E7J:;4;F764KF:753E7A8 K67D3436 +:78D7CG7@F5:3@97E;@%3EF7D(>3@
;@6G57E@G?47DA8D;E=E8ADF:7BD;H3F7E75FAD;@F7D7EF76;@BGD5:3E;@93>3@6@73DF:7EF3F;A@3@667H7>AB;@9;F +:7D7
E:AG>6 47 3 5>3GE7 8AD ?3;@F7@3@57 3EE;9@;@9 D7EBA@E;4;>;FK  I:7@ 3 5A>>34AD3F;H7 BDA<75F ;E G@67DF3=7@ 4K F:7
9AH7D@?7@F3@63BD;H3F7E75FAD7@F;FK 
Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986 1985
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0

  )79;A@3>3@6$A53>AH7D@?7@F
+:7 >3@6 AI@7DE:;B 3DAG@6 F:7 EF3F;A@ 9;H7E 3@ GBB7D :3@6 FA F:7 9AH7D@?7@F 5A@57D@76  ;@ F:7 BDA?AF;A@ A8
67H7>AB?7@F3DAG@6FD3@E;FEF3F;A@E (3D=;@93@6*!;@57@F;H7E9;H7@I;F:;@ ?D3@97A87J;EF;@93@6GB5A?;@9
?7FDAEF3F;A@E %7FDAD3;>I3K67BAFE3@6*+67BAFE:3@676AH7DFA(G4>;5.AD=E7B3DF?7@F(.3D7B>3@@76
FA4767H7>AB76 +D3@E;F'D;7@F767H7>AB?7@F8AG@6?7@F;A@;@7H7>AB?7@F(>3@E ;@%G?43;4GF>;?;F76
9G;67>;@7EI7D7BDABAE76FA;?B>7?7@F;F D38F7H7>AB?7@F(>3@ 3>EA?7@F;A@EF:7BA>;5K3E*F3F;A@D73
7H7>AB?7@F*5:7?7**  AI7H7D ;F:3E>;?;F76;?B>;53F;A@EFA7@5AGD397F:767H7>AB?7@F 

+:75GDD7@FEF3F7A83883;DE;@4AF:F:7E75;F;7EBD7E7@FEF:75:3>>7@97E3@6:;9:>;9:FEF:7BAF7@F;3> +:;EIAG>6
D7CG;D75A?BD7:7@E;H7;@HA>H7?7@F8DA?F:79AH7D@?7@FE3FH3D;AGE>7H7>E 3EI7>>3E>736;@9DA>78DA?F:7BD;H3F7
E75FAD I:;5:IAG>6@7767@5AGD397?7@F8DA?F:7BA>;5;7E !@6;3@5;F;7E I;F:;FEBGE:8AD67H7>AB?7@F3@67EB75;3>>K
FD3@EBADF3F;A@@7FIAD= 53@6AI7>>I;F:3BD77?BF;H73BBDA35:;@B>3@@;@98ADD3;>;@F79D3F7667H7>AB?7@F ;@HA>H;@9
3>>EF3=7:A>67DE 

&#'
H>6C:K:ADEB:CI6C@  =IIEH LLL 697 DG< H>I:H 9:;6JAI ;>A:H EJ7A>86I>DC  E6G@>C< EDA>8N 6H>6 E9;
CDC   :K:ADEB:CID;,6>ADGG>9DGH .=:(6K>'JB76>ME:G>:C8: (6K>'JB76>H C 
CDC C 9 &.,:6AIN 3)CA>C:4K6>A67A:6I=IIEH LLL ACIG:6AIN 8DB H:6LDD9H LDG@ 6HEM
CDC C 9 -:6LDD9,6>AL6NHI6I>DC 3)CA>C:4K6>A67A:6I=IIE LLL 8>98D B6=6G6H=IG6 <DK >C '*5-:6LDD9G6>AL6N5HI6I>DC 6HEM388:HH:9
 4 
69<:G>  '     $JAN   .=: .>B:H ); #C9>6  *GDEDH:9 .=6C: :6HI -.#- ID 7: 7:II:G  7><<:G  ,:IG>:K:9 ;GDB
=IIE I>B:HD;>C9>6 >C9>6I>B:H 8DB 8>IN I=6C: *GDEDH:9 .=6C: :6HI -.#- ID 7: 7:II:G 7><<:G 6GI>8A:H=DL  8BH
JH>C:HH -I6C96G9     =IIE LLL 7JH>C:HH HI6C96G9 8DB 6GI>8A: :8DCDBN EDA>8N B6=6G6H=IG6 6CCDJC8:H C:L =DJH>C< EDA>8N
   5 =IBA
GDD@>C<H #CHI>IJI>DC     !AD76A 8>IN !*   G8=>K:9;GDB I=: DG><>C6A DC  '6N    ,:IG>:K:9    ;GDB
=IIEH LLL 7GDD@>C<H :9J G:H:6G8= <AD76A B:IGD BDC>IDG 

=DC@6G %   '6G8= .=6C:>I:HH6NI=:NRG:/(Q-.#-R #,:IG>:K:9;GDB;I:GCDDC=IIE 6;I:GCDDC98 >C 8>IN C:LH I=6C:>I:H H6N
I=:NG: JCH6I>H;>:9 6GI>8A:5
**,  =IIE LLL 8EEG >C LE 8DCI:CI JEAD69H    #CI:GB:9>6I: *6G6 .G6CH>I -IJ9N E9;
:CHJHD;#C9>6     "N9:G6769<G:6I:G"N9:G67698>IN G8=>K:9;GDBI=:DG><>C6ADC -:EI:B7:G  ,:IG>:K:9   
;GDB=IIE LLL 8:CHJH  8D >C 8:CHJH 8>IN  =N9:G6769 =IBA

G>B:#C9:M =IIEH LLL CJB7:D 8DB 8G>B: G6C@>C<H ?HE


:K:ADEB:CI ' D   ."('/(##*&),*),.#)(#.20&)*'(.*&( .=6C: 
( =IIE LLL 9C6>C9>6 8DB BJB76> G:EDGI BJB76> C:L E6G@>C< EDA>8N <:IH 6EEGDK6A 
( =IIE LLL 9C6>C9>6 8DB BJB76> G:EDGI 7B8 H 8DBEG:=:CH>K: BD7>A>IN EA6C ID I=GJHI 8DCHIGJ8I>DC D; B>HH>C< A>C@H 
:E6GIB:CID;,:A>:;6C9,:=67>A>I6I>DC!DK:GCB:CID;'6=6G6H=IG6'JB76>*A6CG8=>K:9;GDBI=:DG><>C6ADC '6G8= 
,:IG>:K:9   ;GDB
=IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7     =IIE B9BJ B6=6G6H=IG6 <DK >C E6<:H 'JB76> BJB76>EA6C-=DL E=E
:E6GIB:CID;8DCDB>86C9-D8>6A;;6>GH/( *DEJA6I>DCD;JG76C6<<ADB:G6I>DCHL>I= >C=67>I6CIHDGBDG:>C I=DJH6C9H P
  #C9>6  G8=>K:9 ;GDBI=: DG><>C6ADC  $JC:   ,:IG>:K:9    ;GDB
=IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7      =IIE :H6 JC DG< JCJE >C9:M 6HEE6C:A
L>K:9> -=6G96':=GDIG6 ,6=JA  DB76N.=:>I>:H1>I=>C B>C:C8::H><CH E 
(#C9>6 '6N  'JB76>H;>GHIB:IGDB6N8=J<>C'6G8=  ,:IG>:K:9   ;GDB=IIE LLL 9C6>C9>6 8DB BJB76> G:EDGI
BJB76> H ;>GHI B:IGD B6N 8=J< >C B6G8=    
!=6C>    ,:8>E:;DG-J88:HH"DL->C<6EDG:"6L@:G:CIG:H6B:ID: #CHI>IJI:D;*DA>8N-IJ9>:H    
!DK:GCB:CID;#C9>6'>C>HIGND;,6>AL6NH,6>AL6ND6G9   !:C:G6A!J>9:A>C:HDC,:9:K:ADEB:CID; 6I:<DGNHI6I>DCH7N
>CK>I>C<DE:C7>9H;GDB>CI:G:HI:9E6GI>:H (D   &' 1-   *6GI #
">C9J  =IIE LLL I=:=>C9J 8DB DE>C>DC DE :9 '6M>BJB >IN B>C>BJB HE68: 6GI>8A:   :8:
#C9>6C ,6>AL6N     #C9>6C ,6>AL6NH -I6I>DCH ,: 9:K:ADEB:CI *GD?:8I  88:HH:9 DC  :7GJ6GN    ;GDB
=IIE LLL >G>8:C <DK >C >G>8:C >G>8:C596N   5-..#)( ,0&)*'(. #,#( E9;
#C9>6CMEG:HH 
$,-.   =IIE LLL ?G:6HI 8D ?E  >CK:HIDG 6G   E9; 6G5  6AA E9;
1986 Mishkat Ahmed et al. / Transportation Research Procedia 48 (2020) 1968–1986
 !%+$)&*(')++"'&*)!)'"  0 

&I9 &HHD8>6I:H-DJI=H>6*KI &I9 DBEG:=:CH>K:'D7>A>IN*A6C;DG!G:6I:G'JB76>M:8JI>K:-JBB6GN3,:EDGI4  'JB76>'JC>8>E6A


DGEDG6I>DCD;!G:6I:G'JB76>  
&:L>H A6G6    :7GJ6GN.=:.>B:HD;#C9>6 :A=> CDI'JB76> #C9>6H:8DCDB>886E>I6AP.>B:HD;#C9>6 G8=>K:9;GDBI=:DG><>C6ADC
 :7GJ6GN    ,:IG>:K:9     ;GDB =IIEH I>B:HD;>C9>6 >C9>6I>B:H 8DB 8>IN BJB76> :A=> CDI 'JB76> #C9>6H :8DCDB>8
86E>I6A 6GI>8A:H=DL  8BH
& HHD8>6I:H -DJI= H>6 *KI  &I9  (:L :A=>  #C9>6 >C ?D>CI K:CIJG: L>I= & #CI:GC6I>DC6A &I9  6C696  .-    DBEG:=:CH>K:
.G6CHEDGI6I>DC-IJ9N;DG"N9:G6769':IGDEDA>I6CG:63,:EDGI4 
'', '6G8=   ,:EDGIDC'6HI:GEA6CD;>INL>9:,.- 'JB76>H C 
'JB76> ':IGDEDA>I6C ,:<>DC :K:ADEB:CI JI=DG>IN '',  'JB76> /G76C #C;G6HIGJ8IJG: *GD?:8I  G8=>K:9 ;GDB I=: DG><>C6A DC 
:7GJ6GN  ,:IG>:K:9  ;GDB=IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7      =IIE LLL BBG96BJB76> DG< EGD?:8IH5BJ>E =IB
'JC>8>E6A DGEDG6I>DC D; !G:6I:G 'JB76>  >IN *GD;>A: D; !G:6I:G 'JB76>  ,:IG>:K:9    ;GDB
=IIE 9B B8<B <DK >C H>I:H 9:;6JAI ;>A:H 9D8JB:CIH 8>IN5EGD;>A: E9;
':=I6  '6CI=6C %    :8:B7:G   #C9>6I>B:H  HI6I>DCH H:I ;DG 6   8GDG: B6@:DK:G,:IG>:K:9     ;GDB
=IIEH I>B:HD;>C9>6 >C9>6I>B:H 8DB 8>IN BJB76>  HI6I>DCH H:I ;DG 6   8GDG: B6@:DK:G 6GI>8A:H=DL   8BH
'D/'>C>HIGND;/G76C:K:ADEB:CI   -IJ9NDC.G6;;>86C9.G6CHEDGI6I>DC*DA>8>:H6C9-IG6I:<>:H>C/G76CG:6H>C#C9>6
'',  =IIEH BBG96 B6=6G6H=IG6 <DK >C =DB:
'JC>8>E6A DGEDG6I>DC D; !G:6I:G 'JB76>  :K:ADEB:CI *A6C   
=IIE EDGI6A B8<B <DK >C >G? EDGI6A 6CDCNBDJH FA99:KEA6C<J:HI5JH:G:C<A>H=
(6I>DC6A #C;DGB6I>8H :CIG:'6=6G6H=IG6 -I6I: :CIG: 'JB76> -J7JG76C G8=>K:9    
;GDB=IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7      =IIE LLL B6=6G6H=IG6 C>8 >C =IBA9D8H 8I>K>IN BJB76>5HJ7 E9;

(6G:H= %6B6I=  &6MB6C ->C<=    (DK:B7:G  ". ':9>6 ">C9JHI6C .>B:H  /C8AD< 'JB76> C9=:G> HI6I>DC 6I 7G:6@>C<
ED>CI  ,:IG>:K:9     ;GDB =IIEH LLL =>C9JHI6CI>B:H 8DB BJB76> JC8AD< BJB76> 6C9=:G> HI6I>DC 6I 7G:6@>C< ED>CI HIDGN
-N D;&D%< +?LH@.+( =IBA
(.0 =IIE LLL C9IK 8DB BJB76> C:LH DCAN  ;:B6A: 8DEH ID <J6G9  A6@= LDB:C DC BJB76> IG6>CH 
(#% (   '6N -.#-,*),. 'JB76>'>GGDG E  
*:I=: !6C9=>6C9.6C9:A   =IIEH BEG6 J7 JC> BJ:C8=:C 9:   !DK:GC>C<5'', E9;
*G:HH#C;DGB6I>DCJG:6J !DK:GCB:CID;#C9>6   )8ID7:G *G:HH#C;DGB6I>DCJG:6J 'JB76> #C9>6HI6IH'>AA>DCEAJH8>I>:H>C#C9>66H
E:G:CHJH  =IIE E>7BJB76> <DK >C H8G>EIH 9:I6>A 6HEG:A:6H:#9 #-
*L  (DK:B7:G!AD76A8>IN!*G6C@>C<H    G8=>K:9   ;GDBI=:DG><>C6ADC'6N  ,:IG>:K:9   ;GDB
=IIEH L:7 6G8=>K: DG< L:7      =IIEH LLL J@B:9>68:CIG: EL8 8DB >B6<:A>7G6GN 9DLCAD69':9>6 6H=M':9>6:I6>AH#

,>8=6*>CID6C9'6CI=6C%':=I6  $JC:  .=:.>B:H!GDJE.>B:HD;#C9>6 C9=:G>HI6I>DCODC:>H7JH>:HIIG6CH>IED>CI,:IG>:K:9
   ;GDB=IIEH I>B:HD;>C9>6 >C9>6I>B:H 8DB 8>IN BJB76> C9=:G> HI6I>DC ODC: >H 7JH>:HI IG6CH>I ED>CI 6GI>8A:H=DL   8BH
.=: 8DCDB>8 .>B:H     'JB76> ':IGD 8ADH:G ID DE:G6I>DCH  ID <:I HE::9 8:GI>;>86I: I=>H L::@  *.#  ,:IG>:K:9     ;GDB
=IIE :8DCDB>8I>B:H >C9>6I>B:H 8DB >C9JHIGN IG6CHEDGI6I>DC G6>AL6NH BJB76> B:IGD 8ADH:G ID DE:G6I>DCH ID <:I HE::9 8:GI>;>86I: I=>H
L::@ 6GI>8A:H=DL   8BH
.=: >C6C8>6A MEG:HH     (D G:HE>I: ;DG 'JB76> ':IGD 6H EGD?:8I 8DHI ?JBEH 7N   E:G 8:CI  ,:IG>:K:9     ;GDB
=IIE LLL ;>C6C8>6A:MEG:HH 8DB 6G8=>K: CD G:HE>I: ;DG BJB76> B:IGD 6H EGD?:8I 8DHI ?JBEH 7N  E:G 8:CI  
.=:.>B:HD;#C9>6   EG>A -:MG6I>D<D:HJE>CHI6I: G8=>K:9;GDBI=:DG><>C6ADC -:EI:B7:G  ,:IG>:K:9   ;GDB
=IIEH I>B:HD;>C9>6 >C9>6I>B:H 8DB 8>IN =N9:G6769 -:M G6I>D <D:H JE >C HI6I: 6GI>8A:H=DL   8BHG:;:GG6A*'
/(1DGA9>I>:H>C  
=IIEH LLL JC DG< :C 9:K:ADEB:CI 9:H6 EDEJA6I>DC EJ7A>86I>DCH E9; JG76C>O6I>DC I=:5LDGA9H58>I>:H5>C5 596I657DD@A:I E9;

You might also like