Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 5es 4Cs 21st Century Skills Learning

    Uploaded by

    Emran Alwaqfi
    34 views7 pages

    Original Title

    5Es_4Cs_21st_century_skills_learning

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    34 views7 pages

    5es 4Cs 21st Century Skills Learning

    Uploaded by

    Emran Alwaqfi

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 7

    HH

    HI8:CIJGNH@>AAHA:6GC>C<

    #6HB>C6&6>G8
    (52'D216@5'05<<9<3!6/?.?F.;1
    ;3<?:.A6<;'062;02
    );6C2?@6AF<3<?H@
    DGQH ,L:9:C
    ?6HB>C6 B6G>8=7 H:

    %&$&1  !* '') ')&'&**  $&# . !  *,*+* + + B6CJ6A 6C9 GDJI>C: ?D7H  IDL6G9H CDC
    GDJI>C: >CI:GE:GHDC6A
    #)%!% %  )#-%+ % +!- . !# + +  *$ +!$ 6C9 6C6ANI>86A ?D7H  0: A>K: >C 6 I>B: L=:G: C6I>DC6A 6C9
    #!-)!%*"!##*+&+ &*. &#)% $&+!-+!&% !%+ !* HD8>6A 7DG9:GH 9D CDI B:6C L=6I I=:N JH:9 ID  6C9 L=:C
    )*) #!*!%+ ++ +.%%.+ !%'')& * 8DBBJC>86I>DC6C98DDE:G6I>DC=6EE:CH>BJAI6C:DJHAN6C9
    +& *,**,##0 ')') &,) 0&,%*+ &) +  *+ %+,)0 <AD76AAN DK:G I=: IG69>I>DC6A CDI>DC D; HE68: 6C9 I>B: 45 
     )&,   (,%+!++!- % (,#!++!- $!/$+ &* 88:EI>C< I=6I I=: HNC:G<N D; I=:H: ILD EDL:G;JA ;DG8:H T
    '')&  . #&&" + +  +* & *'!!##0 +!#&)  C:L 8DBBJC>86I>DC 6C9 8DDE:G6I>DC EG68I>8:H T HIGDC<AN
    *!%&,)*&%(,!*!+!&%*&$!**!%*+%+,)0*"!##*.!+  6;;:8IHDJG8JGG:CI:9J86I>DC6A;G6B:LDG@H >CI=>HLDG@L:
    &,) *+,%+* ).!% )&$ +  !)%+ *!%+!! )*) 
    688:EII=:C::9;DG8=6C<:>CDJG8JGG:CI:9J86I>DC6C96>B
    /')!%*+ !*'')##*&)),%)2*
    *&)(,!*!+!&%&
    *&)
    *3 *$&#&)&%+$'&))0#)%!%
    ID8DC8:EIJ6A>H::9J86I>DC6AEG68I>8:HC:8:HH6GNID;DHI:GHI
    8:CIJGNH@>AAH -=>HA:69HJHIDI=:)GD7A:B,I6I:B:CI), 
    +)"$%,%&!&'$+% %*#$!&  $!!%'%&!   ), !DL 86C L: >BEGDK: HIJ9:CIH HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH
    %"&+ 68FJ>H>I>DCI=GDJ<=DJGI:68=>C<
    " "'-+(.-"('  -=:HE:8>;>8;D8JHD;I=>HLDG@>HI=::9J86I>DC6AEG68I>8:
     HL:A>K:>CI=::G6D;6JB6CXH96>B61:<12?;6AF45  6II=:.C>K:GH>IND;DGQH>CI=:0:7DCI:CI&6C6<:B:CI
    HD8>:IN8=6G68I:G>H:97NG6E>98=6C<: L=:G:C:LI:8=CDAD<N 6C9 :H><C EGD<G6B  -=: E6E:G EGDEDH:H 8=6C<:H ID
    <G69J6AAN HJ7HI>IJI:H IG69>I>DC6A B6CJ6A A67DJG  A>I:G6IJG: :9J86I>DC6A EG68I>8:H 76H:9 DC G:A:K6CI A>I:G6IJG:  6C9
    86AAH ;DG C:L  8G:6I>K: 6C9 >CCDK6I>K: LDG@:GH 45   ':L 6C6ANH>HD;HIJ9:CIHX;::9768@6;I:GJC9:G<D>C<HE:8>;>86AAN
    I:8=CDAD<>86A68=>:K:B:CIHH=6E:I=:;JIJG:LDG@EA68:6C9 I6>ADG:9.19:H><C8DJGH: 
    G:FJ>G:6C:LH:ID;H@>AAH -D7:67A:ID:;;:8I>K:AN8DBE:I:  'A?B0AB?2<3A52=.=2?
    >CI=:<AD76A:8DCDBN =DA9>C;DGB6I>DC
    6<:?D7H :BEADN::H
    -=:E6E:G8DCH>HIHD;;>K:H:8I>DCH ,:8I>DCEGDK>9:H6C
    D;I=:HI8:CIJGNBJHI7:EGDK>9:9L>I=G:A:K6CI:9J86I>DC
    6C9 IG6>C>C<  :H>9: 76H>8 H@>AAH BD9:GC :BEADN::H 6G: >CIGD9J8I>DCIDI=:IDE>8 &DG:DK:G I=:EGD7A:BHI6I:B:CI>H
    :ME:8I:9 ID 7: A>;:
    ADC< A>;:
    L>9: A:6GC:GH D; 8DCHI6CIAN 9:;>C:9 "C,:8I>DCI=::M6B>C6I>DCD;I=:A>I:G6IJG:DCHI
    8=6C<>C< I:8=CDAD<>:H  8G:6I>K: I:6B LDG@:GH 86E67A: D; 8:CIJGNH@>AAH>H<>K:C D8JH>C<DCI=:;DJC96I>DC6AFJ:HI>DC
    9::EI=>C@>C< 6C9<DD98DBBJC>86IDGH>C8GDHH
    8JAIJG6A6C9 D;L=6IHIJ9:CIHC::9ID@CDL L>I=6C:M6B>C6I>DCD;I=:
    >C8GDHH
    B:9>6H:II>C<HI=6I8DCI>CJDJHAN9:6AL>I=AD69HD; A>I:G6IJG: I=>H G:H:6G8= 6>BH ID 6GG>K: 6I 6 HNCI=:H>H D; 6AA
    >C;DGB6I>DC45 45 ,8>:CI>;>8G:HJAIHED>CI6II=:C::9;DG6 >9:CI>;>:9HI8:CIJGNA:6GC>C<;G6B:LDG@H ,:8I>DC9G6LH
    VEAJ<6C9EA6NWLDG@>C<;DG8: ;JIJG::BEADN::HI=6IL>AA7: ;GDBI=:6C6ANH>HL>I=DJGHIJ9:CIH6C99:BDCHIG6I:HI=:HI
    67A: ID 696EI 6C9 E:G;DGB L>I=DJI BJ8= IG6>C>C< 45  ,J8= 8:CIJGNH@>AAHI=:NC::9 "C,:8I>DCL:EG:H:CII=:G:HJAIH
    G:FJ>G:B:CIH EJI :CDGBDJH EG:HHJG: DC 8JGG:CI :9J86I>DC 6C9I=:6C6ANH>H AHD I=:6CHL:GIDI=:EGD7A:BHI6I:B:CI
    HNHI:BH6C96EEGD68=:H6H@>C<;DG9:K:ADEB:CID;8DBEA:M >H D;;:G:9  C8DBE6HH>C< B>HH>C< HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH 7N
    I=>C@>C< H@>AAH HJ8= 6H EGD7A:B
    HDAK>C<  8G>I>86A I=>C@>C<  8DJGH: 9:H><C  6 EGDEDH6A ;DG C:L :9J86I>DC6A EG68I>8:H >H
    8DBBJC>86I>DC  8DAA67DG6I>DC  6C9 H:A;
    B6C6<:B:CI 45  <>K:CID;DHI:GC:LH@>AAHC::9:9 >C6AAN ,:8I>DCEGDK>9:H
    .C>K:GH>I>:H 6C9L::9J86IDGH6G:JC9:GEG:HHJG:ID8DBEAN 8DC8AJH>DCH 
    L>I=HJ8=HI6C96G9H6C9EGDBDI::M8>I>C<A:6GC>C<68I>K>I>:H
    I=6ILDJA9G:HJAI>C68FJ>H>I>DCD;8DBEA:MH@>AAH45  "" ,-'-.+2,$"%%,*.","-"('
     "CI=>HE6E:GL:EG:H:CI6C96C6ANH:8=6C<:H>CIGD9J8:9 ':LB:9>6:G6=6H>CHE>G:9;6HI<GDLI=D;G:H:6G8=6GDJC9
    >C 6 C:LAN 9:H><C:9 8DJGH:  6G<J>C< I=6I I:68=>C< 6C9 I=: >9:6 I=6I C:L 8:CIJGN :9J86I>DC G:FJ>G:H C:L L6NH D;
    A:6GC>C< HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH 8DJA9 7: 6 K:GN :;;:8I>K: 6C9 A:6GC>C<  !DL:K:G  :K:C H8>:CI>;>8 A>I:G6IJG: 68@CDLA:9<:H
    EA:6HJG67A: 68I>K>IN  ,I>AA  7:;DG: L: 6GG>K: 6I I=: EGDEDH:9 I=6IID96NHHIJ9:CIH6G:9>;;:G:CI;GDBI=:HIJ9:CIH;GDBI=:
    BD9:AI=6I86I:GHIDI=:68FJ>H>I>DCD;HI8:CIJGNH@>AAH L: E6HI45 6C9I=6IDJGH8=DDA>C<HNHI:BH6G:CDI86I:G>C<;DG
    L>AA ;>GHI ADD@ 6I I=: EG:H:CI ID JC9:GHI6C9 L=6I L: =6K: I=:C::9H6C99:B6C9HG:FJ>G:9;DGI=:8DBEA:MH@>AAHD;I=:
    68=>:K:9HD;6G  BD9:GC LDG@EA68: 45  6C9 4 5 I=:G: >H CD 8DCH:CHJH
     %?</92:@A.A2:2;A G:68=:9DCL=6IHI8:CIJGNH@>AAH6G: 
    -=:HI6GI>C<ED>CI>CI=>HE6E:G>HI=:68@CDLA:9<:B:CI
    D; I:8=C>86A 69K6C8:B:CI L=>8= >CIGD9J8:9 I=: H=>;I ;GDB

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    %DD@>C< ;DG 8DCH:CHJH  B6CN >CHI>IJI>DCH 6C9 H8=DA6GH L: ;G:FJ:CIAN ;6>A ID >BEA:B:CI HIG6I:<>:H ;DG HI 8:CIJGN
    LDG@:9DCDG<6C>H>C<HI8:CIJGNH@>AAH45 06<C:G45 H@>AAH 68FJ>H>I>DC  -D DK:G8DB: I=>H EGD7A:B 6C9 7:II:G
    EGDEDH:9 H:K:C @B?C6C.9 @8699@ I=6I HIJ9:CIH C::9 8G>I>86A EG:E6G: DJG HIJ9:CIH DJG 8DAA:6<J:H 45 D;;:G I>EH ;DG
    I=>C@>C<6C9EGD7A:B
    HDAK>C<8DAA67DG6I>DC6C9A:69:GH=>E :9J86IDGH B6@: >I G:A:K6CI  I:68= I=GDJ<= I=: 9>H8>EA>C:H 
    6<>A>IN 6C9 696EI67>A>IN >C>I>6I>K: 6C9 :CIG:EG:C:JG>6A>HB 9:K:ADE I=>C@>C< H@>AAH  :C8DJG6<: A:6GC>C< IG6CH;:G  I:68=
    :;;:8I>K: DG6A 6C9 LG>II:C 8DBBJC>86I>DC 688:HH>C< 6C9 HIJ9:CIH =DL ID A:6GC  699G:HH B>HJC9:GHI6C9>C<H 9>G:8IAN 
    6C6ANH>C< >C;DGB6I>DC 6C9 8JG>DH>IN 6C9 >B6<>C6I>DC  -=: IG:6II:6BLDG@6H6CDJI8DB: :MEAD>II:8=CDAD<NIDHJEEDGI
    6C6ANH>HD;&:IO456C9C6C>69DJ6C9A6GD456G:>CA>C: A:6GC>C< 6C9;DHI:G8G:6I>K>IN 
    EGDEDH>C< 8DG: HJ7?:8I @CDLA:9<: ;A:M>7>A>IN  696EI67>A>IN
    "CDG9:GID6C6ANH:=DLDJGI:68=>C<EG68I>8:H6I-=:,L:9>H=
    6C9 >CCDK6I>DC 8G>I>86A I=>C@>C<  8G:6I>K>IN 6C9 EGD7A:B
    ,8=DDA D; %>7G6GN 6C9 "C;DGB6I>DC ,8>:C8: HJEEDGI
    HDAK>C< 8DAA67DG6I>DC  69K6C8:9 8DBBJC>86I>DC  8GDHH

    68FJ>H>I>DCH D; HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH  L: =6K: I:HI:9 HIJ9:CIHX


    8JAIJG6A6C9HD8>6AH@>AAH -=:NHIG:HHI=:>BEDGI6C8:D;H:A;

    HJE:G H@>AAH >C 0:7 DCI:CI :H><C 6C9 &6C6<:B:CI


    9>G:8I>DC  EGD9J8I>K>IN 6C9 688DJCI67>A>IN  "C 6C6ANH>H D;
    EGD<G6B  -=GDJ<=I=>HE>ADIHIJ9N L:>9:CI>;>:9H>M
    H:K:G6A B6?DG ;G6B:LDG@H %6> 6C9 />:G>C< 45 >9:CI>;>:9
    EGD7A:BH ;68:9 7N HIJ9:CIH  -=:N G:69 6H ;DAADLH 
    B6CN DK:GA6EH >C ;G6B:LDG@HX I:GB>CDAD<N L=:G: 8G>I>86A
    "CI:G9>H8>EA>C6GN @CDLA:9<: IG6CH;:G 9>;;>8JAI>:H
     HIJ9:CIH
    I=>C@>C<  8DAA67DG6I>DC  8G:6I>K>IN  BDI>K6I>DC  6C9
    ;6>A >C 6EEAN>C< I=: @CDLA:9<: >CI:G9>H8>EA>C6GN   8GDHH

    B:I68D<C>I>DC6G:I=:BDHI;G:FJ:CII:GBH 
    8JAIJG6A H:II>C<H JC:6H>C:HH
     HIJ9:CIH 6G: CDI ;::A>C<
    9B>II>C< I=6I I=:G: L:G: B6CN 6II:BEIH ID 9:;>C: 6C9 A>HI 8DB;DGI67A: >C 8GDHH
    8JAIJG6A H:II>C<H   C<A>H= G:69>C<
    HI8:CIJGNH@>AAHL:EGDEDH:=:G:$:G:A>J@:I6A 456HDC: 9>;;>8JAI>:H
    HIJ9:CIHC::9ADC<:GI>B:IDG:696C9JC9:GHI6C9
    D; I=: BDHI 8DBEG:=:CH>K: DK:GK>:LH D; L=6I >H B:6CI 7N I=6C 6K:G6<: CDC
    C6I>K: G:69:G C::9H   H6;: <GDJE LDG@
    HI8:CIJGN@CDLA:9<: H@>AAH 6C9A:6GC>C< -=:>GBD9:A>H H:II>C<HEG:;:G:C8:
    >;LDG@>C<<GDJEH6G:G6C9DBAN6GG6C<:9
    76H:9DC8DBE6G>HDCD;9>;;:G:CIE:GHE:8I>K:H>CG:EDGIH 7NA:8IJG:GH DG7N6HD;IL6G: 68:GI6>CA:K:AD;JC:6H>C:HH>H
    6C9 7DD@H  $:G:A>J@ 6C9 8DAA:6<J:H 45 >9:CI>;>:9 I=G:: :MEG:HH:9   JC8DB;DGI67A: L>I= HEDCI6C:DJH K:G76A
    7GD6986I:<DG>:HL>I=I=G::HJ786I:<DG>:HL>I=>CI=:B -=: 6G<JB:CI6I>DC  6C9  6KD>9 =DC:HI E::G 6HH:HHB:CI
    
    I=G:: 7GD69 86I:<DG>:H 6G:  DJC96I>DC6A $CDLA:9<:
     6AI=DJ<=I=:A>I:G6IJG:HJ<<:HIHI=6II=:G:6G:69K6CI6<:H>C
    9><>I6A "- A>I:G68N  8DG: 8DCI:CI @CDLA:9<:  8GDHH
    E::GG:K>:L:GH7:>C<>9:CI>;>:97:86JH:HIJ9:CIHC::9IDA:6GC
    9>H8>EA>C6GN@CDLA:9<:!JB6C>HI>8$CDLA:9<:
    A>;: ?D7 ID<>K::68=DI=:G=DC:HI6C98DCHIGJ8I>K:;::9768@ >IH::BH
    H@>AAH :I=>86A :BDI>DC6A6L6G:C:HH 8JAIJG6A8DBE:I:C8: I=6IDJGHIJ9:CIH6G:CDIL:AAEG:E6G:9IDB6@:8G>I>86A6C9
    &:I6 $CDLA:9<:
     8G:6I>K>IN 6C9 >CCDK6I>DC  EGD7A:B 8DCHIGJ8I>K:8DBB:CIHL=:CI=:N6G:CDI6CDCNBDJH 
    HDAK>C< 6C9 8G>I>86A I=>C@>C<  8DBBJC>86I>DC 6C9
    0=:C 6EEAN>C< $:G:A>J@ :I 6A  H 45 BD9:A DC I=:H:
    8DAA67DG6I>DC 
    >9:CI>;>:9EGD7A:BH L:=6K:6GG>K:96II=:;DAADL>C<B>HH>C<
    8GDHH 9>;;:G:CI ;G6B:LDG@H 6C9 H8>:CI>;>8 A>I:G6IJG:  >I >H HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH   >CI:G9>H8>EA>C6GN @CDLA:9<: IG6CH;:G
    <:C:G6AAN 6<G::9 I=6I 6AA HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH 9:;>C>I>DCH 6G: 9>;;>8JAI>:H
    A68@D;8GDHH
    9>H8>EA>C6GN@CDLA:9<: 8GDHH

    G:A:K6CIIDB6CN6HE:8IHD;8DBEA:M8DCI:BEDG6GNA>;: -=:N 8JAIJG6A H:II>C<H JC:6H>C:HH 6C9  C<A>H= G:69>C<


    6G: JHJ6AAN G:;:GG:9 ID 6H 8DAA67DG6I>DC  8DBBJC>86I>DC  9>;;>8JAI>:H
    A68@D;8JAIJG6A8DBE:I:C8: H6;:<GDJELDG@
    9><>I6A A>I:G68N  8>I>O:CH=>E  EGD7A:B
    HDAK>C<  8G>I>86A H:II>C<H EG:;:G:C8:
     A68@ D; 8DBBJC>86I>DC 6C9
    I=>C@>C<  8G:6I>K>IN 6C9 EGD9J8I>K>IN  6H :HH:CI>6A H@>AAH ;DG 8DAA67DG6I>DC H@>AAH   JC8DB;DGI67A: L>I= HEDCI6C:DJH
    A>K>C<>C6C98DCIG>7JI>C<IDDJGEG:H:CIHD8>:I>:H "CG:8:CI K:G76A6G<JB:CI6I>DC
    A68@D;EGD7A:BHDAK>C<6C98G>I>86A
    E:96<D<>86A EJ7A>86I>DCH I=:H: =><=:G
    DG9:G I=>C@>C< H@>AAH  I=>C@>C<H@>AAH 6C96KD>9=DC:HIE::G6HH:HHB:CI
    ED>CIH
    9::E:G A:6GC>C< DJI8DB:H  6C9 8DBEA:M I=>C@>C< 6C9 6I 9>;;>8JAI>:H >C 6EEAN>C< 8G:6I>K>IN 6C9 >CCDK6I>DC H@>AAH
    8DBBJC>86I>DCH@>AAH 6G:6AHD86AA:9HDG;DJGHJE:GH@>AAH 45 
    ;DG I=: HI 8:CIJGN G:6I>K>IN  DBBJC>86I>DC  G>I>86A
    -D699G:HHI=>H9>H8G:E6C8N7:IL::C9:BDCHIG6I:9H@>AAH6C9
    -=>C@>C< 6C9DAA67DG6I>DC45 
    H@>AAHC::9:9;DG6HI8:CIJGNLDG@>C<:CK>GDCB:CIL:=6K:
    G<J>C< I=6I I=: 7GD69 6<G::B:CI DC L=6I HI 8:CIJGN 8G:6I:96C:LH:ID;8DJGH:HI=6I6EEANC:LB:I=D9H;DGHI
    67>A>I>:H6G:>HG:68=:9 >CI=:C:MIHJ7H:8I>DCL:ADD@6IDJG 8:CIJGN H@>AAH 68FJ>H>I>DC  "C I=: C:MI H:8I>DC  L: D;;:G 6C
    I:68=>C<EG68I>8:HL>I=>CI=:0:7DCI:CI&6C6<:B:CI6C9 :M6BEA: ;GDB EG6M>H 6C9 G:8DBB:C96I>DCH ;DG 699G:HH>C<
    :H><CEGD<G6B  I=>H>BEDGI6CIE:96<D<>86A9>A:BB6 
     <D1<D2A2.05 @A02;AB?F@8699@ """  ,-+- ",(+-!"' ,-'-.+2,$"%%,
    .C9:GHI6C9>C<L=6IHI8:CIJGNH@>AAH6G: >HHI>AA;6G6L6N :HE>I: L>9:HEG:69 8DCH:CHJH I=6I HIJ9:CIH C::9 XH  >I
    ;GDB6GG>K>C<IDI=:7:HII:68=>C<EG68I>8:H;DGHI8:CIJGN H::BH I=6I I=:H: H@>AAH 6G: 9>;;>8JAI ID I:68= 6C9 A:6GC 
    H@>AAH 68FJ>H>I>DC  +:H:6G8= 8DCIG>7JI>DCH JHJ6AAN 8DC8AJ9: DB7>C>C< 9>;;:G:CI E:96<D<>86A B:I=D9H ;DG I:68=>C< HI
    L>I= 6 G6C<: D; EG68I>86A G:8DBB:C96I>DCH ;DG I=: 8:CIJGN H@>AAH  L>I= I=: ;>:A9 D; HIJ9N 6I I=: 0:7 DCI:CI
    >BEA:B:CI6I>DC D; HI 8:CIJGN 8DBE:I:C8>:H  HJ8= 6H &6C6<:B:CI 6C9 :H><C )GD<G6B  6C9 ;D8JH>C< DC I=:
    >CI:<G6I>DC D; HI 8:CIJGN 8DBE:I:C8>:H >C 8JGG>8JAJB 6C9 D7H:GK6I>DCH ;GDB BN I:68=>C< :ME:G>:C8:  >C I=: C:MI
    6HH:HHB:CI  HIG6I:<>:H ID 69DEI >CCDK6I>K: I:68=>C< 6C9 HJ7H:8I>DCH L: EG:H:CI E:96<D<>86A 8=6C<:H 69DEI:9 DC
    A:6GC>C<EG68I>8:H7N;D8JH>C<DCEGD7A:B
    HDAK>C<6C9"- 9>;;:G:CIA:K:AH 
    A>I:G68N 88DG9>C<IDG:8:CIH8>:CI>;>8A>I:G6IJG:45A:6GC>C<
    HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH >H 6 9::E:G EGD7A:B I=6I G:FJ>G:H HI 
    8:CIJGNI:68=>C< K>9:CIAN >CDJG8JGG:CII:68=>C<EG68I>8:H

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
     5.;46;40<B?@212@64; <GDJE JG>C< L::@H I=:G:L:G:LG>II:C DG6A 6C9
    :A>:K>C< >C I=: EDL:G;JA >9:6 I=6I 7N VI:68=>C< ID96NXH EGD<G6BB>C<:M6B>C6I>DCH 
    HIJ9:CII=:H6B:L6N6HL:I=DJ<=IN:HI:G96NXH L:GD7I=:B  ':.99 <;96;2 <3396;2 4?<B= =?</92:/.@21
    D;IDBDGGDLWL=>8=L6H8D>C:9768@>CB>9
    I=8:CIJGN7N 0<99./<?.A6<;
    #D=C :L:N 4 5  6C9 ID HJEEAN DJG HIJ9:CIH L>I= BDG:
    DBBJC>86I>DC6C98DAA67DG6I>DCL>I=>C9>K:GH:<GDJEH6G:
    8=6C8:H ID 68FJ>G: C:8:HH6GN HI 8:CIJGN HJE:G H@>AAH  L:
    D; I=: JIBDHI >BEDGI6C8: >C 6 <AD76A>H:9 8JAIJG: 6C9
    =6K:HI6GI:97N8=6C<>C<I=:8DJGH:9:H><C -=:8=6C<:H6G:
    :8DCDBN -=:H:H@>AAH6G:I=JH8>I:96H:HH:CI>6AH@>AAH;DGI=:
    76H:9 DC I=: G:HJAIH G:EDGI:9 >C E:96<D<>86A G:H:6G8= ;DG
    HI 8:CIJGN LDG@>C< :CK>GDCB:CI 45  -=:G:;DG:  >C I=>H
    :M6BEA:H::45 45 45 45 45 45 45 456C9
    8DJGH: HIJ9:CIHLDG@:9>CHB6AA<GDJEH D;6B>C>BJBD;
    6G:6A><C:96ADC<$:G:A>J@XH:I6A 45HNCI=:H>H 
    6C96B6M>BJBD;B:B7:GH 
    ,IGDC<AN 6<G::>C< L>I= )G:CH@N 45 I=6I L: C::9 C:L
    GDJE LDG@ >H 6 L>9:AN 688:EI:9 B:I=D9 ;DG A:6GC>C< HI
    8JGG>8JA6IDG:;DGBE:96<D<NID;D8JHDCHIJ9:CIHXG:6A
    A>;:
    8:CIJGNH@>AAH45 45 6C94 5 NLDG@>C<>CG6C9DBAN
    68=>:K:B:CIH  L: 8G:6I:9 I=: 8DJGH: 8JGG>8JAJB I=6I
    8=DH:C>CI:GC6I>DC6A<GDJEH HIJ9:CIH8DDE:G6I:L>I=E:DEA:
    HE:8>;>86AANI6G<:IHHI8:CIJGNH@>AAH68FJ>H>I>DC -=>C@>C<D;
    D; 9>;;:G:CI 8JAIJG6A 768@<GDJC9H  -=JH  I=:N 7GD69:C 6C9
    6C:L8JGG>8JAJB6HCDI8DBEA:I:ANEG:8>H:6C9EG:
    H:I L:
    9::E:CHD8>6AH@>AAHX=DG>ODCH6C9EG68I>8:ID696EIID;JIJG:
    DEI:9 ;DG I=: K:GH>DC I=6I 6AADLH 6C9 :C8DJG6<:H 8G:6I>K: 
    9>K:GH: LDG@>C< :CK>GDCB:CIH  "C DI=:G LDG9H  HIJ9:CIH
    >CI:G68I>K: IG6CH;DGB6I>DCH 45  >B>C< ID :MEADG: I=:
    EG68I>8:8DBBJC>86I>DCDJIH>9:D;6L:AA
    @CDLC H6;:HD8>6A
    :;;:8IHD;:ME:G>:CI>6AA:6GC>C<45DCH68FJ>H>I>DC L:
    G:6AB6C9IG6>CHD8>6AH@>AAH 
    =6K: 8G:6I:9 I6H@H 76H:9 DC GJC:GH H :C<6<:B:CI 
    :MEADG6I>DC :MEA6C6I>DC :A67DG6I>DC 6C9:K6AJ6I>DC45>C  5.;46;40<B?@212@64;
    I=:G:6A
    A>;::CK>GDCB:CI  "CB6CN8DJGH:HD;DJGEGD<G6B L:JH:DG6AEG:H:CI6I>DC6C9
     (52A.@8.;1A520<B?@2@A?B0AB?2 E::G
    6HH:HHB:CI 6H 6 E:96<D<>86A IDDA  88DG9>C< ID
    A>I:G6IJG: 6E::G6HH:HHB:CI>H6L>9:AN688:EI:9B:I=D9;DG
    II:BEI>C<IDA:6GC6C9JC9:GHI6C9HDB:I=>C<C:L>C<G:6I:G
    9:K:ADE>C< A>;:ADC< A:6GC:GH L=D 6G: 86E67A: D; 8G>I>86A
    9:EI=>HCDI6A>C:6GEGD8:HH "CHJ8=6EGD8:HHI=:DC:L=D>H
    I=>C@>C<6C9H:A;
    :K6AJ6I>DC45 -=:8=6C<:H>CIGD9J8:9ID
    A:6GC>C< JH:H 7DI= >IH EG>DG :ME:G>:C8: 6C9 C:LAN 68FJ>G:9
    I=>H8DJGH:>HIDJH:DG6A9>H8JHH>DCL=:G:6HIJ9:CIH:C<6<:
    @CDLA:9<: 6C98DJEA:H>IL>I=I=:@CDLA:9<:<6>C:9;GDB
    >C8G>I>86AI=>C@>C< 9:;>C>C<HE:8>;>8FJ:HI>DCHI=6I><C>I:EGD
    C:L :MEADG6I>DCH  >C6AAN  I=: 9:K:ADEB:CI D; 8DC8:EIJ6A
    :I8DCIG69>H8JHH>DC 7HIJ9:CIH6G:<G69:9;DGI=>HHE:8>;>8
    JC9:GHI6C9>C< =6EE:CH I=GDJ<= 9>H8JHH>DCH 6C9 8G:6I>K:
    :M6B>C6I>DC BDB:CI  6C9 8 HIJ9:CIH 9:A>K:G LG>II:C E::G
    :;;DGIH 
    6HH:HHB:CI 
    -=:G:;DG: I=:I6H@>CI=:.19:H><C8DJGH:L6H9:H><C:97N
    >GHI ID9:A>K:G6<DD9 ;D8JH:9FJ:HI>DC HIJ9:CIHBJHI;>C9
    I6@>C< I=: :M6BEA: ;GDB I=: G:6A
    A>;: L:7
    EGD9J8I>DC
    :M>HI>C<DGH>B>A6G:M6BEA:H>CI=:>C9JHIGNIDHJEEDGII=:>G
    >C9JHIGN ,IJ9:CIHL:G:6H@:9ID9:H><C.1;DGHE:8>;>8JH:GH
    8=D>8:H  -=>H >H 6CDI=:G A:K:A D; A:6GC>C< ID A:6GC L=:G:
    I=6I 6G: ID 688DBEA>H= 6 HE:8>;>8 I6H@ DC I=: L:7  &DG:
    HIJ9:CIH LDG@ DC 7:C8=B6G@>C<  G:H:6G8= DC IG:C9H >C I=:
    HE:8>;>86AAN  I=:N L:G: G:FJ>G:9 ID 9:H><C 6 L:7
    76H:9
    L:79:H><C>C9JHIGN ;;:8I>K:DG6A8DBBJC>86I>DCL6HA>HI:9
    A:6GC>C<IDDAI=6IL>AA=:AEJH:GHJC9:GHI6C968=6C<:H>CI=:
    768@>C 6HDC:D;06<C:GXHHJGK>K>C<H@>AAH "CH>HI>C<DC
    8A>B6I: 8=6C<:  DG  7 I=: 8=6C<:H DC I=: 8GNEID8JGG:C8N
    JH>C< G:6A
    A>;: L:7 >C9JHIGN :M6BEA:H  6C9 7:C8=B6G@>C< 
    B6G@:I DG6CNI6H@8=DH:C 7:>C<>I6DG7 I=:H:8DC9
    =:AEH HIJ9:CIH ID <:I 8ADH:G ID I=: >9:6 D; 7:8DB>C< 6 L:7
    G:FJ>G:B:CI L6H ID 8=DDH: I=: HE:8>;>8 I6G<:I <GDJE  -D
    >C9JHIGN EGD;:HH>DC6A  ME:G>:C8>C< 7DI= GDA:H 45 7N
    9:K:ADE6L:7
    76H:9IDDA;DGI6H@6HIJ9:CIHL:G:67A:ID
    7:8DB>C<I=:EGD;:HH>DC6AH45DC9>;;:G:CIH>9:HD;I=:L:7
    8=DDH: ;GDB I=: ;DAADL>C< I6G<:I <GDJEH  :A:B:CI6GN
    9:K:ADEB:CIEGD9J8I>DCHE:8IGJB
    DC:GDA:L=:CI=:N6G:
    H8=DDAL=DC::9IDDAID:MEA6>CI=:>GHIJ9:CII=::;;:8IHD;
    .1 9:H><C:GH  6C9 I=: DI=:G L=:C I=:N 6G: .1 9:H><C
    8A>B6I: 8=6C<:  :MEA6>C I=: 8A>B6I: 8=6C<: :;;:8IH ID 6
    :K6AJ6IDGH =:AEHHIJ9:CIHIDG:A:6H:;GDBI:CH>DCH>CIGD9J8:9
    <GDJE D; HJE:G
    G>8= >C9JHIG>6A>HIH L=D 6G: 8A>B6I: 8=6C<:
    7N;68:
    ID
    ;68:E::G6HH:HHB:CI45 
    9:C>:GH6C9DHBDEDA>I6C6GI>8A:EJ7A>H=:9DCI=:L:7ID
    :MEA6>C I=:>G G:69:GH I=: :;;:8IH D; 8A>B6I: 8=6C<:  -D !:G:6<6>C L:6>B:9;DGHI=6IH=DJA986I:G;DG$>KJC?6XH
    9:K:ADE6L:7
    76H:9IDDA;DGI6H@7I=:NL:G:D;;:G:9I=: H456C9HIJ9:CIHEG68I>8:I=>C@>C<H@>AAHL=>A:;DHI:G>C<
    ;DAADL>C<I6G<:I<GDJEH"-:C<>C::GHLDG@>C<>C/DAKD"- 8G:6I>K>IN45 -=:86E67>A>INIDIG6CH;:G@CDLA:9<:68FJ>G:9
    L=D L6CI ID >CK:HI >C 8GNEID8JGG:C8>:H  I:68=:GH D; >CDC:8DCI:MI6C96EEAN>I>C6CDI=:G>H86AA:99::EA:6GC>C<
    N7:G<NB6CH>:I L=D C::9 6 IDDA ID :MEA6>C I=:>G HIJ9:CIH 6C9>HJH:9>CA>I:G6IJG:6H6<DD9IDDA;DG=:AE>C<HIJ9:CIH
    8GNEID8JGG:C8NB6G@:I6C9 6<GDJED;G:I>G:9LDB:CL=D 7:8DB: >C9:E:C9:CI 45  "I >H 6AHD 8DCH>9:G:9 6H 6 FJ>I:
    9:8>9:9ID>CK:HII=:>GG:I>G:B:CIEA6C>C8GNEID8JGG:C8N  >BEDGI6CIH@>AA;DGA>K>C<>CI=:HI8:CIJGN45 
    -=: I6H@ H=DJA9 =6K: 7::C 9:A>K:G:9 I=GDJ<= I=: >I:G6I>K: "CI=:C:MIH:8I>DC L:EG:H:CII=:HIJ9:CIHX:K6AJ6I>DCD;I=:
    9:K:ADEB:CI EGD8:HH  7N 8G:6I>C< 6 L:7
    76H:9 6GI:;68I 8DJGH: 
    EGD<G6BB:9>C+:68I 6C97NJH>C<IIG6@>;; ;DGI:HI>C<
    I=: H6I>H;68I>DC D; :68= >I:G6I>DC L>I= I=: HE:8>;>8 I6G<:I

    
    
    IIG6@>;;>H6;G::DCA>C:IDDAI=6I6EEA>:HI=:I=:DG:I>86A EG6<B6I>86C9=:9DC>8FJ6A>I>:H>C;AJ:C8:I=:HJ7?:8I>K:
    LDG@BD9:AI=6IK>HJ6AAN>AAJHIG6I:H6C986A8JA6I:H=DLI=: JH:GHXE:G8:EI>DC

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    "/  '%2,",  'B?C2F?2@B9A
    .1 :H><C 8DJGH: 6I I=: 0:7 DCI:CI &6C6<:B:CI 6C9 "CI=>HHJ7H:8I>DC I=:G:HJAIHD;7DI=B:I=D9H6G:EG:H:CI:9 
    :H><C:9J86I>DC6AEGD<G6BL6H9:H><C:9I=GDJ<= 6C9 :>C< ;JAAN 6L6G: I=6I  6CHL:GH DC 6 L:7
    76H:9 HJGK:N 
    G6C;DGI=:;>GHII>B:;GDB'DK:B7:G JCI>A#6CJ6GN   8DJEA:9L>I=>C;DGB6CIHI=6IIDD@E6GI>C6;D8JH:9
    <GDJE
    -=:8DJGH:L6HGJCC>C<7DI=>C6BEJH6C9DC69>HI6C8:  >CI:GK>:L 6G:CDIG:EG:H:CI6I>K:D;I=:<:C:G6AEDEJA6I>DCD;
    DCA>C: L>I=>CI:GC6I>DC6A6C9,L:9>H=HIJ9:CIH:CGDAA:9  HIJ9:CIH L:;>GHIEG:H:CII=:HI6I>HI>86A6C6ANH>HD;I=:HJGK:N 
    !:G: >CI=>HH:8I>DCB:I=D9 G:HJAIH 6C96C6ANH>HD;HIJ9:CIHX 6C9 I=:C I=: G:HJAIH D7I6>C:9 ;GDB I=: ;D8JH:9
    <GDJE
    8DJGH::K6AJ6I>DC6G:EG:H:CI:9  >CI:GK>:L 
     "2A5<1B@21
    
    ,I6I>HI>86A6C6ANH>HD;I=:HJGK:N>HEG:H:CI:9>C-67A:" 
    -D :K6AJ6I: HIJ9:CIHX E:G8:EI>DC D; A:6GC>C< I=GDJ<= .1
    :H><C 8DJGH: L: =6K: E:G;DGB:9 6 8DB7>C6I>DC D; -%" ,.+/2X,,--",-"%'%2,",
    FJ6CI>I6I>K:6C9FJ6A>I6I>K:6C6ANH>H 0:6>B:9;DG6B>M:9

    B:I=D9H HIG6I:<N ID 6GG>K: 6I 6 7:II:G JC9:GHI6C9>C< D; HI ++!*+!#%#0*!*
    *
    8:CIJGN I:68=>C< 6C9 A:6GC>C< 86HJ6AI>:H 45  *J6CI>I6I>K: & "!&"
    ! &!$(&"! !
    $&"!
    6C6ANH>H L6H JH:9 ID 8DAA:8I HI6I>HI>86AAN B:6HJG67A: 96I6 
     
        
    L=>A:FJ6A>I6I>K:B:I=D9H6>B:96II=:BDG:G:;>C:9E>8IJG:
    6C967:II:GJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;68=>:K:9:;;:8IH6C98=6AA:C<:H   
        
    AHD 7NB>M>C<ILDB:I=D9HL:=DE:ID7:67A:ID6GG>K:6I       
    6IA:6HIJEIDHDB::MI:CI 6<:C:G6A>O67A:8DC8AJH>DC     
     

    -=:FJ6CI>I6I>K:HJGK:NL6H8G:6I:97NJH>C<I=: ,,.'-
       
     
    IDDA L=:G: I=: L:7
    76H:9 HJGK:N L6H 8G:6I:9  ,IJ9:CIH       
    G:8:>K:96A>C@IDI=: FJ:HI>DCHHJGK:NL=:G:I=:NL:G:      
    67A:ID:MEG:HHI=:>GH6I>H;68I>DCI=GDJ<=%>@:GIH86A: 6C9699
          
    6 ;G:: LG>II:C 8DBB:CI 7:ADL D; :68= E6GI>8JA6G FJ:HI>DC 
    -=:FJ:HI>DCHEG:H:CI:97:ADL6G:>CHE>G:96C9;D8JH:9DC      
    >9:CI>;N>C<B>HH>C<HI8:CIJGNH@>AAH;GDB$:G:A>J@:I6A H  
         
    BD9:A45 -=:FJ:HI>DCG:69H6H;DAADLH .EIDL=6I 
    :MI:CI I=: .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI >BEGDK:9 NDJG DG: DCI:CI J:ID>C67>A>INIDJH:I=:B:6CL>I=%>@:GH86A:6H6B:6HJG:
    $CDLA:9<:=DLBJ8=NDJ=6K:A:6GC:967DJII=:.1  D;8:CIG6AI:C9:C8N6H>I=6HCDB6I=:B6I>86AB:6C>C< > : 
    .E ID L=6I :MI:CI I=: .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI >BEGDK:9 NDJG L=6I LDJA9 7: I=: 6K:G6<: D; #<A .A .99 6C9 /@<9BA29F
    ><>I6A "- %>I:G68N  .E ID L=6I :MI:CI I=: .1 8DJGH: .4?22  I=: BDHI HJ>I67A: B:6HJG: >H ID ADD@ 6I I=: BDHI
    8DCI:CI>BEGDK:9NDJGGDHH
    9>H8>EA>C6GN$CDLA:9<:86C ;G:FJ:CIG:HEDCH:H DGB:9>6C ,I>AA I=:7:HIL6NIDK>HJ6AAN
    NDJ8DCC:8I9>;;:G:CI@CDLA:9<: 9>H8>EA>C:H7:II:G .E EG:H:CII=:9>HIG>7JI>DCD;I=:G:HEDCH:H>HIDJH:676G8=6GI
    ID L=6I :MI:CI I=: .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI 6C9 :ME:G>:C8: ><  6C9><   
    >BEGDK:9NDJG%>;: #D7,@>AAH9DNDJ;::ABDG:EG:E6G:9 
    ;DGNDJG;JIJG:A>;: ?D7 .EIDL=6I:MI:CII=:.18DJGH:
    8DCI:CI >BEGDK:9 NDJG JAIJG6A 8DBE:I:C8: 9D NDJ ;::A
    NDJJC9:GHI6C9I=:C::9HD;DI=:G8JAIJG:H7:II:G .EID
    L=6I :MI:CI I=: .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI >BEGDK:9 NDJG
    I=>86A BDI>DC6A L6G:C:HH 9D NDJ ;::A NDJ 7:II:G
    JC9:GHI6C9:I=>86A :BDI>DC6A=JB6C8=6AA:C<:H .EID
    L=6I:MI:CII=:.18DJGH:8DCI:CI6C9:ME:G>:C8:>BEGDK:9
    NDJG G:6I>K>IN 6C9 "CCDK6I>DC   .E ID L=6I :MI:CI I=:
    .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI 6C9 :ME:G>:C8: >BEGDK:9 NDJG )GD7A:B
    ,DAK>C<6C9G>I>86A-=>C@>C<,@>AAH .EIDL=6I:MI:CI
    I=: .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI 6C9 :ME:G>:C8: >BEGDK:9 NDJG
    DBBJC>86I>DC 6C9 DAA67DG6I>DC ,@>AAH  6C9   .E ID
    L=6I :MI:CI ,86A67A:%:6GC>C< IDDA =:AE:9 NDJG A:6GC>C<
    EGD8:HH ><  -=:%>@:GIH86A:76G8=6GI
    
    -=:HJGK:NL6HG:EA>:97NHIJ9:CIHDJID;:CGDAA:9 AA DG :6H>:G G:HJAIHX >CI:GEG:I6I>DC D; ><   I=: 8JHIDB>H:9
    HIJ9:CIH L:G: >CK>I:9 ;DG 6C DCA>C: DE:C
    :C9:9 >C
    9:EI= 8DADJG H8=:B: >H JH:9  -=: 7AJ: 8DADJG >H 6HH><C:9 ;DG 
    
    ;D8JH
    <GDJE >CI:GK>:L  !6K>C< >C B>C9 I=6I L: L:G: HI6GH ;GDBI=:96G@7AJ:;DGHI6G#<A.A.99IDA><=I7AJ:;DG
    >CI:G:HI:9 >C I=:>G >C9>K>9J6A :ME:G>:C8:H  E:G8:EI>DCH  HI6GH  G::C>H6HH><C:9IDI=:B>99A:D;I=:%>@:GIH86A: 
    ;::A>C<H DC IDE>8H D; >CI:G:HI  7JI 6AHD I=:>G E::G
    G:A6I:9 HI6GHDG#<A@B?2 DCH:FJ:CIAN N:AADL>HJH:9;DG
    HI6GH 
    68I>K>I>:H  L: DEI:9 ;DG 6 BDG: >C;DGB6A 8DCK:GH6I>DC I=6I L=:G:A><=IN:AADL>HJH:9;DGHI6GH/@<9BA29F.4?22.9<A 
    IG69>I>DC6AAN ;D8JH
    <GDJE >CI:GK>:LH 86C 9:A>K:G 45  GDB ><   >I >H :6HN ID H:: I=6I HIJ9:CIH :MEG:HH EDH>I>K:
    D8JH>C< DC I=: H6B: FJ:HI>DCH 6H 6 HI6GI>C< ED>CI  I=: 6II>IJ9:H67DK:;DG6AAFJ:HI>DCH7:H>9:*.EIDL=6I
    >CI:GK>:LL>I=HIJ9:CIHIDD@EA68:K>6I=:3DDBIDDA6C9 :MI:CI I=: .1 8DJGH: 8DCI:CI >BEGDK:9 NDJG JAIJG6A
    A6HI:96EEGDM>B6I:AN B>CJI:H  8DBE:I:C8: 

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
     I>B:H HIJ9:CIH :MEG:HH:9 8DC;JH>DC 67DJI A:6GC>C< +:68I
    ID<:I=:GL>I=.19:H><C 
    A56;8D<?86;46;6A2?.A6<;@D<?821?2.99FD299.;1529=21.
    9<AAD.@;<A092.?D52?2A523<0B@D.@D52A52?3<0B@6@<;
    ),<?92.?;6;4&2.0A;1A56;86AD.@.9<A<33B;92.?;6;4
    &2.0A/BA1<;<AA56;8D25.C292.?;212;<B45A3229@9682
    6AD.@7B@A.1121A<A56@0<B?@2/20.B@2F<B0<B91:.82A52
    .==960.A6<;6;&2.0A9682;<A.0AB.99FD2D2?2@B==<@21A<
    92.?;&2.0AK
    
    K:C I=DJ<= I=: HIJ9:CIH HI6GI:9 A:6GC>C< +:68I >C I=:
    EG:K>DJH 8DJGH:  H>C8: >I L6H CDI :M6B>C:9 >C I=>H 8DJGH: 
    B6CND;I=:B6GG>K:9CDIL:AAEG:E6G:9 
    ><  -=:B:9>6C9>HIG>7JI>DC76G8=6GI 
     (52?26@@<:B05A<92.?;6;&2.0A63F<B;2C2?B@216A/23<?2
    HB:CI>DC:97:;DG: B:9>6C9>HIG>7JI>DC><  EGDK>9:H6 .;1A52?26@@<:B05A<92.?;6;),+2@A.?A21A56@0<B?@2
    =:AE;JAB:6HJG:D;I=:8:CIG:D;I=:96I6H:I HDC:86CH:: D6A5:<@A<3A52=2<=92;<A/26;4B=A<@=221
    9J:ID=6K>C<6B:9>6C<G:6I:GI=6CB:6C I=>H>H686H:D;
    (JG HIJ9:CIH JHJ6AAN 6G: CDI BJ8= 6IIG68I:9 ID 8D9>C< 
    C:<6I>K: )6GHDCXH H@:LC:HH  DG 96I6 >H EJH=:9 ID I=: A:;I
    IDL6G9H 6 <G:6I:G CJB7:G D; HI6GH  > :  BDG: EDH>I>K: !DL:K:G I=:HIJ9:CIHD;.19:H><C8DJGH:G:EDGIA:6GC>C<
    6II>IJ9:H  +:68I6H>CI:G:HI>C<6C9HJEEDGI>C<I=:>G8G:6I>K>IN -D9:A>K:G
    I:68=>C< ;DG JC9:GHI6C9>C< 45 HIJ9:CIH H=DJA9 7: 67A: ID
    . ;A2?C62D?2@B9A.;1.;.9F@6@ E6HHI=::M6BH7JI:K:CBDG:>BEDGI6CI I=:NBJHI7:8DB:
    0=>A:LDG@>C<IDL6G9H6AA6HH><CB:CIH8DBEA:I>DCHIJ9:CIH 6JIDCDBDJHA:6GC:GH 
    JC9:G<D I=GDJ<= FJ>I: 8DBEA:M A:6GC>C< EGD8:HH I=6I
    8DBEG>H:H D; I6H@ H:A:8I>DC  EGD?:8I EA6CC>C<  HB6AA <GDJE (56@D.@.0AB.99FA5236?@AA6:2A5.A612.@F<B5.C2F<B0.;
    8DAA67DG6I>DC6C9C:<DI>6I>DC >I:G6I>K:HD;IL6G:9:K:ADEB:CI =BAA52:<;A52D2/=.42AD.@;<A@<5.?1A<6:=92:2;A
    >C+:68IJH:G:ME:G>:C8:.19:H><CI=GDJ<=JH:G
    8:CIG:9 A56;4@D6A5&2.0A.@6A0<B91/2D6A5.C.'0?6=A3<?2E.:=92
    9:H><CEG68I>8:H>BEGDK>C<L:7
    76H:96EEA>86I>DC76H:9DC  
    JH:GXH ;::9768@  H:B>C6GH  ;G:FJ:CI I:HIH 6C9 C:L
    DB7>C6I>DCD;A:6GC>C<6C9=6C9H
    DC:ME:G>:C8:H::BHID
    9:EADNB:CIH6C9;G:FJ:CI9:A>K:G67A:H "C9::9 6HA>I:G6IJG:
    =6K:7::CLDG@>C<L:AA 
    IG69>I>DC6AAN HJ<<:HIH 45  =:G: IDD I=: FJ6A>I6I>K: 96I6
    6AADLHJHID<:II=:BDG:G:;>C:9E>8IJG: &J8=>HLG>II:C>C  @92.?;6;4
    I=: 6869:B>8 A>I:G6IJG: 67DJI I=: A>B>I6I>DCH D; HIJ9:CI 88DG9>C<ID:6G96C90>AAHDC45 :ME:G>:CI>6AA:6GC>C<
    HJGK:NH 45 6C9 45 HI>AA HJ8= ;::9768@ >H JH:;JA  >CKDAK:H V68I>K: >BB:GH>DC  G:;A:8I>K: :C<6<:B:CI  6C9
    :HE:8>6AANL=:CHIJ9:CIH6G:>C;DGB:9 6H>CI=>H86H: I=6II=: H><C>;>86CI :ME:G>:C8:HW 45 E    -D 6GG>K: 6I I=: 7:HI
    G:HJAIH L>AA 7: JH:9 ID >BEGDK: I=: 8DJGH: FJ6A>IN  "C I=>H EDHH>7A: 8DC9>I>DCH ;DG 6GG>K>C< 6I I=: HIJ9:CIXH 68I>K:
    H:8I>DC  L: L>AA ;D8JH DC I=: BDHI ;G:FJ:CI IDE>8H I=6I >BB:GH>DC G:;A:8I>DCH6C9H><C>;>86CI:ME:G>:C8:H L:DEI:9
    D88JGG:99JG>C<I=:>CI:GK>:L  ;DGI6H@HI=6I:M68IANB>GGDGI=:G:6A>IN 0=:C6H@:9IDG:;A:8I
    DC I=: 8DCI:CI D; I=: 8DJGH: I=6I G:;A:8IH I=: G:6A>IN D; I=:
     (52=?</92:<3&2.0A
    L:7
    EGD9J8I>DCB6G@:IEA6CC>C< 8DDE:G6I>DCL>I=JC@CDLC
    -=:.19:H><C8DJGH:>H<>K:C9JG>C<I=:A6HIN:6GD;I=:0:7
    E:DEA: ;G:FJ:CIG:EDGI>C<6C96ADID;8=6C<:H 6C9I=:C::9H
    DCI:CI&6C6<:B:CI6C9:H><CEGD<G6B6HDC:D;I=:A6HI
    ;GDBI=:L:7
    >C9JHIGNB6G@:I HIJ9:CIH:MEG:HHH6I>H;68I>DC
    ?<;A2;1 12C29<=2? EGD;>A: 8DJGH:H  -=:G:;DG:  L=>A:
    >CI=:;DAADL>C<L6NH 
    LDG@>C< IDL6G9H 6AA 6HH><CB:CIH  8DBEA:I>DC HIJ9:CIH
    JC9:G<D6FJ>I:8DBEA:MA:6GC>C<EGD8:HHI=6I>H>CHE>G:96C9  9682 A52 612. <3 0?2.A6;4 . %?<720A %9.; .;1 D<?86;4 6;
    76H:9 DC 9>;;:G:CI EG68I>8:H ;GDB I=: G:6A
    A>;: L:7 6A2?.A6<;@@<6A329AA5.AD2.0AB.99F161.?2.9=?<720A!682
    9:K:ADEB:CI >C9JHIGN  JG>C< 6EEGDM>B6I:AN   L::@H  >C A56@6@5<DD20<B91/2D52;D2.0AB.99FD<?8D6A56A
    <GDJEH:II>C<H HIJ9:CIH6II:C9A:8IJG:H6C9>CI:CH>K:ANLDG@
    DC>I:G6I>K:HD;IL6G:9:K:ADEB:CI>C+:68IJH:G:ME:G>:C8: 0DG@>C<>C6<GDJEH:II>C<6C9I=:EG68I>86A>BEA:B:CI6I>DC
    H::BH ID =6K: 8G:6I:9 FJ>I: 6 G>8= :ME:G>:C8:  H 4 5
    .1 9:H><C I=GDJ<= JH:G
    8:CIG:9 9:H><C EG68I>8:H
    HJ<<:HI:90<;C2?@.A6<;.93?.:2D<?8A:6GC>C<7G>C<H6L>9:G
    >BEGDK>C<L:7
    76H:96EEA>86I>DC76H:9DCJH:GXH;::9768@ 
    HE:8IGJB ;GDBI=:GDA:D;I=:E::GH 8DAA67DG6I>K:A:6GC>C< 
    ;G:FJ:CI I:HIH 6C9 C:L 9:EADNB:CIH 6C9 ;G:FJ:CI
    6C9I=:L>9:G8DCI:MIJ6AA:6GC>C< 
    9:A>K:G67A:H 
    ,>C8:>CI=:8DJGH:L:9>9DJG7:HIIDB>GGDGI=:G:6A>IND;I=:  ?2.99F 96821 A52 D<?84?<B= A<<  1< ;<A 8;<D  .: 7B@A
    4B2@@6;4BA6;?2.9D<?8?2.996324B2@@;<A2C2?F/<1F6@
    L:7 EGD9J8I>DC EGD;:HH>DC6A B6G@:I  B6CN H>BJAI6C:DJH
    1<6;42C2?FA56;4$;26@;<A6;C<9C216;.99D5.A1<F<B@.F
    I6H@H D; 9>;;:G:CI C6IJG: L:G: >CIGD9J8:9  "C DI=:G LDG9H 
    HIJ9:CIH L:G: G:FJ>G:9 ID 9D EGD<G6BB>C< 6C9 JH: A.@8@A56;86AD.@?2.99F4<<1+2.?2>B6A25.==FD6A5A52
    ?2@B9A2C2;A5<B456A:.F/2D.@;AA5.A2E.0AA56;4D25.16;
    8DBEJI6I>DC6A I=>C@>C< L=>A: 8DCHIGJ8I>C< .1 9:H><C
    :6;1/BAD24<AA52=?<1B0AA5.AD2A56;86@/2AA2?A5.;D2
    EGD?:8IH45 :6G>C<>CB>C9I=6IHIJ9:CIH=69ID8DB7>C:
    5<=213<?
    ILDGDA:H6II=:H6B:I>B: 7J>A9:G6C99:H><C:G45 B6CN
    

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    JGI=:GBDG: I=:G:A:K6C8:D;I=:8DCI:CI I:68=>C<I=GDJ<= (5.;8F<B3<?A56@0<B?@26A?2.99F0.:26;.A6:2D52?26A
    9>H8>EA>C:H 45 H::BH ID =6K: B6C6<:9 ID <>K: 6 ADI DC 6 D.@2.@FA</20<:26;@20B?2./<BAD5.AF<B5.C292.?;216;
    A:6GC>C<8JGK:  A52 =?<4?.: @< 09<@2 6;A< 4?.1B.A6<; #<D  8;<D D5.A 
    8;<D.;1.::B05:<?20<;3612;A6;:F8;<D92142D6A5
    -2.5 ;<D F<B 5.C2 A< D<?8 . /6A :<?2 =?.0A60.9  4B2@@
    ),.;16;3<?:.A6<;.?056A20AB?2
    (5.AD.@C2?FB@23B9BA.4?226AD.@C2?F5.?1A<92.?;
    &2.0A '6IJG6AAN  9JG>C< I=: ;D8JH
    <GDJE >CI:GK>:L HIJ9:CIH
    :MEG:HH:9 8G>I>8>HB IDL6G9H 69B>C>HIG6I>K: EGD7A:BH D;
    ,B6AA <GDJE H:II>C<H HJEEDGI 6C9 >BEGDK: =><=:G
    DG9:G
    8DJGH: DG<6C>H6I>DC  6C9 EGDEDH:9 9>;;:G:CI DG<6C>H6I>DC 
    I=>C@>C< 6C9 9:K:ADEB:CIH D; H@>AAH 45  -=6C@H ID I=:
    :K:CI=:8DCI:CID;I=:EJ7A>H=:99D8JB:CIH !DL:K:G H>C8:
    "CI:GC:I >I L6H :6HN 6C9 8=:6E ID JH: DCA>C: <GDJE HDAK>C<
    I=>HHIJ9N>HCDI;D8JH>C<DC>I HJ8=;::9768@>H9>HG:<6G9:9
    8DAA67DG6I>DC  <GDJE E:DEA: ;GDB 9>;;:G:CI 768@<GDJC9H 
    >CI=>HE6E:G 
    9>;;:G:CI C6I>K: A6C<J6<:H  6C9 JH: 9>;;:G:CI DCA>C: IDDAH
    L=:G:I=:NA:6GC=DLID8DAA67DG6I>K:AN8G:6I:DCA>C: ,I>AA   ;@D2?A<A52%'
    A:6GC>C<=DLIDA:6GC6C9;D8JH 8G>I>86AANI=>C@ ;>C97:II:G N9:H><C>C<:M6B>C6I>DCI6H@H6C9G:FJ>G:B:CIHI=6IB>GGDG
    HIG6I:<>:H 6G:I:8=CDAD<N
    >C9:E:C9:CIEGD8:HH:H  G:6A>IN L: =:AE HIJ9:CIH ID 68I>K:AN E6GI>8>E6I: >C L=6I
    )G:CH@N 45 86AAH 7:8DB>C< I=: EGD;:HH>DC6A 68IDG >C I=:
    +<?86;46;.A2.:6;@B05.12:.;16;40<B?@24.C2:2.;
    >C9JHIGN 6C9 A:6GC ;GDB :ME:G>:C8: 45  "C DI=:G LDG9H 
    6;@645A<35<D3BAB?2D<?896320<B919<<89682968216A.;1
    HIJ9:CIH A:6GC H T 8G:6I>K>IN  8DBBJC>86I>DC  8G>I>86A
    92.?;21.9<A3?<:6A
    I=>C@>C< 6C98DAA67DG6I>DC I=GDJ<=GJC:GXHH45;GDB
    ,>B>A6GAN 6H!D8@>C<HG:8DBB:C9:945 >CI=>H.19:H><C G:6A
    A>;: :ME:G>:C8:  :C<6<:B:CI  :MEADG6I>DC  :K6AJ6I>DC 
    8DJGH:I=:A:6GC>C<:CK>GDCB:CIL6H9:H><C:9I=GDJ<=I6H@H 6C9:A67DG6I>DC 
    L=:G: HIJ9:CIH 8DJA9 6EEAN I=:>G A:6GC>C< ID I=:>G DLC
    -=:EG:H:CI:96C6ANH>H>C,:8I>DC"/A:69HJHIDI=:6CHL:G
    :ME:G>:C8:H6C9>CI:G:HIH 
    IDI=:),H::,:8I>DC   -=:6CHL:GG:69H6H;DAADLH 
    AD.@C2?F6;A2?2@A6;4A<D<?8<;0?F=A<0B??2;062@K12C29<=
    ),%)2*
    *+ !%$&#!-*'&*!+!-)*,#+*&)+ 
    6A3<?.@=206360A.?42A4?<B=:2.;A22;.42?@(52F.?2.
    (,!*!+!&%&$!**!%*+%+,)0*"!##*
    C2?F163360B9A4?<B=A<12@64;3<?'<6AD.@C2?F6;A2?2@A6;4
    -=:G:;DG: L:86C6G<J:I=6IL=6IL:HDB:I>B:HB>HH>CDJG
    !6K>C<I=:8DJGH:HJ7?:8IH>BJAI6C:DJHAN6H6A:6GC>C<;>:A9
    IG69>I>DC6A :9J86I>DC
     8GDHH
    9>H8>EA>C6GN @CDLA:9<: 
    6C96IDDA :C67A:9L:7
    9>H8>EA>C:EGD7A:B
    76H:9A:6GC>C< 
    8G:6I>K>IN6C9>CCDK6I>DC 8DBBJC>86I>DC6C98DAA67DG6I>DC 
    (520<;;20A6<;@/2AD22;A5216332?2;A16@06=96;2@;39B2;06;4 EGD7A:B HDAK>C< 6C9 8G>I>86A I=>C@>C<  6C9 8JAIJG6A
    ),1236;6A29F/20.:2:<?2092.?A<:2A5?<B45D<?86;4D6A5 8DBE:I:C8:
    8DJA9:;;:8I>K:AN7:>BEA:B:CI:9>;L:DEI;DG
    6A@<09<@29F 86G:;JAAN EA6CC:9 GJC:GXH H ;DG 68FJ>H>I>DC D; H
    6EEGD68= DGH[H 
    "CI=>H8DJGH:GJC I=:CJB7:GD;>CI:GC6I>DC6AHIJ9:CIHL6H
    FJ>I: ADL  6EEGDM>B6I:AN    L=>8= >H BDHI EGD767AN I=: /  ('%.,"('
    G:6HDC I=6I FJ:HI>DC ;>K: * ;GDB -67A: " =69 I=: ADL:HI
    -=>H E6E:G D;;:GH 6 7G>:; 6C6ANH>H D; I:68=>C< HI 8:CIJGN
    B:9>6C K6AJ: -67A: "  ><     DG 7:II:G 8JAIJG6A
    H@>AAH 6EEA>:9 ID I:68=>C< 0:7 DCI:CI &6C6<:G 6C9
    8DBE:I:C8: 68FJ>H>I>DC BDG: >CI:GC6I>DC6A :CK>GDCB:CI
    :H><C:G )GD<G6B 6I I=: .C>K:GH>IN D; DGQH  -=: E6E:G
    LDJA9 7: L:A8DB:9  ,I>AA  I=>H >H =DL I=:N 9:H8G>7: I=:>G
    HI6GI:9L>I=6I=DGDJ<=A>I:G6IJG:G:K>:LIDJC9:GHI6C9L=6I
    A:6GC>C<:ME:G>:C8: 
    HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH 6G:  6C9 I:HI I=:>G >BEDGI6C8:  ;I:G
    ;:F5<:2B;6C2?@6AF92.?;21.9<A./<BAA52A<=60@/BA EG:H:CI>C<I=:8DCH:CHJHDCI=>HB6II:GL:EG:H:CI:9G:H:6G8=
    161;<A42AA5205.;02A<D<?8<;=?.0A60.96:=92:2;A.A6<; L=>8= 6H 6 HI6GI>C< ED>CI =6H EG:K>DJHAN >9:CI>;>:9 I=: ;68I
    AD.@4<<13<?6;A2?;.A6<;.9@AB12;A@A<0<:2.;192.?;3?<: I=6I >CDJG9:E6GIB:CI L:;6>A:9IDI:68=HI8:CIJGNH@>AAH
    2.05<A52? JE ID HDB: :MI:CI  %DD@>C< ;DG HJ88:HH;JA HIG6I:<>:H ;DG
    I:68=>C< HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH L: D;;:G:9 :M6BEA:H ;GDB
    II:C9>C< I=:>G A6HI N:6G  I=: B6?DG>IN D; >C;DGB6CIH HDJC9 G:8:CIAN6EEA>:9I:68=>C<EG68I>8:HI=6IL:G:9:K:ADE:976H:9
    >CH:8JG: CDIHD8DC;>9:CID;I=:68FJ>G:9@CDLA:9<: K:C
    DCGJC:GXHH;DGH45ID86I:G;DGHI8:CIJGNH@>AAH
    I=DJ<=6HH456G<J:HI=6II=:G:HJAID;HIJ9:CIHXA:6GC>C< 68FJ>H>I>DC  
    H=DJA9 G:HJAI >C HIJ9:CIHX 67>A>IN ID HE:6@ 6JI=DG>I6I>K:AN
    67DJI I=: 9>H8>EA>C: I=:N A:6GC:9  DJG HIJ9:CIH 6G: JHJ6AAN -=:G: 6G: ILD A>B>I6I>DCH ID I=>H G:H:6G8=  >GHI  I=: CDC

    =:H>I6CI>C<>K>C<HIGDC<6;;>GB6I>DCH67DJII=:>G@CDLA:9<:  G:EG:H:CI6I>K: HIJ9:CIHX ;::9768@ A>B>IH I=: 67>A>IN ID B6@:


    "CHI:69 I=:NJH:VJEID6C:MI:CIWDGH>B>A6G H6;:HI6I:B:CIH  <:C:G6A>H6I>DCH ID 6 L>9:G G6C<: D; I:68=>C< EG68I>8:H 
     D<B91 1236;6A29F @.F A< :F 3BAB?2 2:=9<F2? A5.A  5.C2 ,:8DC9  I=: :HI67A>H=:9 8=6C<:H >C I:68=>C< 6G: G:8:CIAN
    92.?;21 . 9<A A5.A  8;<D ./<BA 4692 D<?8  8;<D ), 9:K:ADE:96C9A6JC8=:9 > : >CA>B>I:98JAIJG6A9>K:GH>IN HD
    F2.5K L:86CCDIEG:H:CI6C:K6AJ6I>DCD;I=:BD9:A6C9>IH:;;:8IH
    DC 8JAIJG6A 8DBE:I:C8:  !DL:K:G  L: 7:A>:K: I=>H G:H:6G8=
    !DL:K:G  >C I=>H 8DJGH:  BDG: HIJ9:CIH 96G:9 ID I6@: BDG: D;;:GH 6 HDA>9 ;DJC96I>DC ID I=DH: L=D 6G: >CI:G:HI:9 >C
    6JI=DG>I6I>K:HI6C967DJII=:>G@CDLA:9<:  G:H:6G8=>C< ;JGI=:G I=: E6I=L6NH ID HJ88:HH;JAAN JH:
    $C2?.996AD.@C2?F4<<1%?</./9F0.;@.F8;<D), 8DCI:BEDG6GN B:I=D9H ;DG I=: 68FJ>H>I>DC D; HI 8:CIJGN
    H@>AAH 

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    0: 6G: 6AA 6L6G: I=6I L: C::9 6 BJ8= 7:II:G G:HEDCH: ID HI6I:L>9: >C>I>6I>K:  "C :2?60.; 1B0.A6<;.9 &2@2.?05 @@<06.A6<;
    <;32?2;02*.;0<BC2?.;.1./DA  
    G6E>9AN 8=6C<>C< 8DC9>I>DCH >C =><=:G :9J86I>DC L=:G: L:
    45 $6J;B6C $ #   L6NHIDHI8:CIJGNH@>AAHL=NHIJ9:CIH
    BJHIH=>;I6L6N;GDB6IG69>I>DC6AB>C9
    H:ID;I:68=>C<DCAN C::9I=:B6C9>9:6H;DGEG68I>86A>BEA:B:CI6I>DC  .==.29A.%6&20<?1 
    ;DG 8DG: 8DCI:CI @CDLA:9<: 45 6C9 I=GDJ<= DC: JC>FJ:  
     
    9>H8>EA>C: K:CBDG: DJG:9J86I>DCC::9HC:LE:GHE:8I>K:H 45 )G:CH@N &   -=:LDGA9C::9H6C:L8JGG>8JAJB 1B0.A6<;.9
    6C9 EDA>8>:H I=6I 86C =:AE >C 8DB76I>C< 8=6AA:C<:H >C I=: (205;<9<4F  
     
    45 $DA7     E=2?62;A6.992.?;6;4E=2?62;02.@A52@<B?02
    9:K:ADEB:CI D; 6 BDG: HJHI6>C67A: HD8>:IN 45  0=>A: <392.?;6;4.;112C29<=:2;A -EG:HH 
    ADD@>C<;DGC:LL6NHID>BEGDK:HJHI6>C67>A>IN6C9;>C9C:L 45 $J=AI=6J   &6C>DI:H % $ 6HE6G>  $   B6121
    L6NH;DGG:A:K6CI:9J86I>DCL:BJHI6EEGD68=>I6H6FJ:HI>DC ;>B6?F!2.?;6;46;A52 @A2;AB?F!2.?;6;46;A52 @A2;AB?F 

    I=6I9D:HCDI7:ADC<IDDCANDC:9>H8>EA>C: !DE:;JAAN I=>H %"( 


    45 DAA #G  0        =<@A:<12?; =2?@=20A6C2 <; 0B??60B9B: 
    HIJ9N 86C 7: JH:;JA 6H 6 HI6GI>C< ED>CI L=:C 9>H8DK:G>C< -:68=:GHDAA:<:)G:HH 
    ;68IDGHI=6I9G>K:I=:BDI>K6I>DCD;69DEI>DCD;HI8:CIJGN 45 /:C@6I6G6B6C  ,   ,>K6@JB6G  ,     C<6<>C< HIJ9:CIH >C
    H@>AAH6C97G>C<>C<I=:?DND;:9J86I>DC>CID=><=:G:9J86I>DC  GDJE 76H:9 %:6GC>C< I=GDJ<= :
    A:6GC>C< I:8=C>FJ:H >C !><=:G 9J86I>DC
    ,NHI:B  ;A2?;.A6<;.9 <B?;.9 <3 :2?46;4 (?2;1@ 6; '062;02 .;1
    ++', (205;<9<4F   
     
     4 5 !P@@>C:C ) #PGK:AP , &P@>I6AD
    ,>:<A $ =DC:C  'PN@@> ) 
    45 6JB6C 3   %>FJ>9BD9:GC>IN )DA>IN 6B7G>9<:  /6AIDC:C -   )G:E6G>C<I:68=:G
    HIJ9:CIH;DGIL:CIN
    ;>GHI
    8:CIJGN
    45 /DD<I # GHI69 ( :9:  &>H=G6 )   =6AA:C<:HID A:6GC>C< EG68I>8:H )+)  6 ;G6B:LDG@ ;DG :C=6C8>C< 8DAA67DG6I>K:
    A:6GC>C<6C9H8=DDA>C<>CI=:9><>I6AC:ILDG@:9LDGA9D;I=:HI8:CIJGN  EGD7A:B
    HDAK>C<6C9HIG6I:<>8A:6GC>C<H@>AAH (2.052?@.;1(2.056;4   
    <B?;.9<30<:=BA2?.@@6@A2192.?;6;4 
      
     
    45 0DGA9 8DCDB>8 DGJB     ':L K>H>DC ;DG :9J86I>DC 45 D6H:
    #:A>C:@    )6G@:G  #   !:GG>C<IDC  #     ,IJ9:CI
    .CAD8@>C< I=: EDI:CI>6A D; I:8=CDAD<N  0DGA9 8DCDB>8 DGJB  :C:K6  G:;A:8I>DC 6C9 A:6GC>C< I=GDJ<= E::G G:K>:LH  @@B2@ 6; 1B0.A6<;.9
    ,L>IO:GA6C9  &2@2.?05   
     
    45 $6N # $JBB:G;:A9    GDB96I6IDE:GHDC6AJH:GBD9:AH 45 H=L>C ) DJ9  6A@>CH , D6I: $ !6AA:II  %><=I   
    ;DGA>;:\ADC< A>;:\L>9:A:6GC:GH ?6A6@5<B?;.9<31B0.A6<;.9(205;<9<4F  &8JC: /    &23920A6C2A2.056;46;56452?21B0.A6<; ADDBH7JGN
    
     
      )J7A>H=>C<
    45 769O> !   -G6>C>C<HI
    8:CIJGNLDG@:GH68IH ;>8I>DC6C9 45 !:HH:
    >7:G  ,     *J6A>I6I>K: DG B>M:9 B:I=D9H G:H:6G8=
    B:BDGN>AAJH>DCH ;A2?;.A6<;.9&2C62D<31B0.A6<;   
      >CFJ>GN6EEGD68=:H,DB:ADDH:<J>9:A>C:H;DGEJ7A>H=>C<>CH:MGDA:H 
    45 ,I:<:B6CC  $  #       DC;:HH>DCH D; 6C :9J86I>DC6A 45 GDLC:  %   6CE:DEA:I6A@ID<:I=:G67DJII=:>GEG68I>8:H
    EHN8=DAD<>HI GDCI>:GH>CEHN8=DAD<N     D8JH <GDJEH  =JBDJG 6C9 I=: H:CH>I>K: 9NC6B>8H D; :K:GN96N A>;:  ?2. 
    45 6HI:AAH  &     -=: >BE68I D; I=: >CI:GC:I DC HD8>:IN 6 <AD76A  
      
    E:GHE:8I>K: 5.;42 82F2@@.F@<;5<D6;A2?;2A6@05.;46;4<B?96C2@  45 A68@BDG:  #     869:B>8 E:96<D<>:H  FJ6A>IN AD<>8H 6C9
    45 )G:CH@N &   ><>I6AC6I>K:H 9><>I6A>BB><G6CIHE6GI $;A52 E:G;DGB6I>K: JC>K:GH>I>:H K6AJ6I>C< I:68=>C< 6C9 L=6I HIJ9:CIH L6CI 
    5<?6G<;  
     'AB162@6;56452?21B0.A6<;   
     
    45 DGG><6C  )  -     )G:E6G>C< ,IJ9:CIH DG 0=6I 0: 6CXI 45 $6;6> 2 JG@: *   DBEJI:GEGD<G6BB>C<<D:H768@ID
    )G:E6G:-=:BDG (2.056;4!2.?;6;46;6452?1  H8=DDA )=>:AI6$6EE6C  T 
    4 5 +:><:AJI=  &   "CHIGJ8I>DC6AI=:DGN6C9I:8=CDAD<N;DGI=: 45 6GG / ,I:E=:CHDC    G>C<>C<8DBEJI6I>DC6AI=>C@>C<
    C:LE6G69><BD;:9J86I>DC &2C6@A.121B0.06I;.6@A.;06.    ID $
     L=6I >H "CKDAK:9 6C9 L=6I >H I=: GDA: D; I=: 8DBEJI:G H8>:C8:
    45 :>H>C<:G $    HI8:CIJGNH@>AAH0=6I6G:I=:N6C9=DL9D :9J86I>DC8DBBJC>IN 0:;?<.1@   
     
    L:6HH:HHI=:B ==9621"2.@B?2:2;A6;1B0.A6<;   
      45 CIL>HIA: '   (2.056;43<?B;12?@A.;16;4.AB;6C2?@6AF22=
    45 06<C:G-   -=:<AD76A68=>:K:B:CI<6E0=N:K:CDJG7:HI .==?<.052@.;116@A6;0A6C2D.F@<3A56;86;4 )6A<G6K:&68B>AA6C 
    H8=DDAH9DCII:68=I=:C:LHJGK>K6AH@>AAHDJG8=>A9G:CC::9U6C9L=6IL: 45 :6G9  0>AHDC # )   E=2?62;A6.992.?;6;4.=?.0A60.9
    86C9D67DJI>I ':L2DG@ '26H>8DD@H  4B6123<?A?.6;6;40<.056;4.;121B0.A6<; $D<6C)6<:)J7A>H=:GH 
    45 &:IO  ,     9>IDGH DGC:G HI
    :CIJGN ,@>AAH  (52 '062;02 4 5 %6JG>AA6G9       (2.056;4 .@ . 12@64; @062;02 B6916;4
    (2.052? 
      =21.4<460.9=.AA2?;@3<?92.?;6;4.;1A205;<9<4F +DJIA:9<: 
    45 C6C>69DJ  $   A6GD  &     HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH 6C9 45 (7:GHI .  6AA>;6 # 6GG>DAH ' />A6G:<JI    -G6>C>C<
    8DBE:I:C8:H;DGC:LB>AA:CC>JBA:6GC:GH>C(8DJCIG>:H  :BDI>DC6A 6C9 HD8>6A 8DBE:I:C8:H >C =><=:G :9J86I>DC -=: H:B>C6G
    45 %6>    +   />:G>C<  &     HH:HH>C< HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH B:I=D9DAD<N 6452?1B0.A6<;6;B?<=2  
     
     
    "CI:<G6I>C<G:H:6G8=;>C9>C<H "C.;;B.9:22A6;4<3A52#.A6<;.9<B;069<; 45 !D8@>C<H        "C8AJH>K: A:6GC>C< 6C9 I:68=>C< >C =><=:G
    "2.@B?2:2;A6;1B0.A6<;*.;0<BC2?.;.1.  :9J86I>DCHNCI=:H>HD;G:H:6G8= -<?86452?1B0.A6<;0.12:F 
    45 $:G:AJ>@  $  &>H=G6  )  6=CD:     -:GGN  %     0=6I 45 6HH  +     >HGJEI>C< DJGH:AK:H -=: EGD7A:B D; A:6GC>C< >C
    @CDLA:9<:>HD;BDHILDGI=-:68=:G@CDLA:9<:;DGHI8:CIJGNA:6GC>C<  =><=:G:9J86I>DC 45))'?2C62D  
     
    <B?;.9<3646A.9!2.?;6;46;(2.052?1B0.A6<;   
      45 '<  0   ,JHI6>C67>A>IN6C99J86I>DC)DA>8N ;0F09<=216.
    45 $>KJC?6       MEADG>C< I=: ):96<D<>86A &:6C>C< 6C9 <3'B@A.6;./696AF6;6452?1B0.A6<;'=?6;42?5.: 
    "BEA>86I>DCHD;I=:HV,JE:G,@>AAHW;DGI=:HI:CIJGNI=GDJ<=GJC:GXH 
    %:CH:HD;$CDLA:9<:DCHIGJ8I>DCID"BEGDK:):96<D<>:HD;I=:':L 
    %:6GC>C<)6G69><B ?2.A6C21B0.A6<;     
    45 ,66K:9G6  + (E;:G /    %:6GC>C<HI
    8:CIJGNH@>AAH 
    G:FJ>G:HHI
    8:CIJGNI:68=>C< %5629A. .==.;  
      
    45 &6G>8 #   "'-+-"/," '((%%(+-"/ 
    +-)+(#-(+,-'-.+2%+'"' ';A2?;.A6<;.9 
    <B?;.9<;+++ ;A2?;2A  
      
    4 5 +6C96AA  #  !    #D=C :L:N  
      -=: #DJGC6A D; 
    )=>ADHDE=N  
     
    45 /N<DIH@N % ,  -=:)GD7A:BD;I=:JAIJG6A:K:ADEB:CID; 
    I=:=>A9 #DJGC6AD; :C:I>8)HN8=DAD<N  
     
    45 GJC:G  #  ,    -=: 8I D; >H8DK:GN  !6GK6G9 9J86I>DC6A 
    +:K>:L  
      
    45 +6K>IO # !>MHDC ' C<A>H= & &:G<:C9DAA:G #   EG>A  
    .H>C< EGD?:8I 76H:9 A:6GC>C< ID I:68= HI 8:CIJGN H@>AAH >C9>C<H ;GDB 6 
    
    

    Authorized licensed use limited to: Qatar Foundation (Qatar National Library). Downloaded on December 20,2021 at 07:52:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

    You might also like