Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REPUBLIC OF BULGARIA
IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAM
FOR DIRECTIVE 2002/96/ЕС ON WASTE ELECTRICAL AND
ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT AND
DIRECTIVE 2002/95/ЕС ON THE RESTRICTION OF THE USE OF
CERTAIN HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND
ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT
IN BULGARIA
SOFIA
AUGUST 2004
CONTENTS
I. BACKGROUND 4
V. FINANCIAL FRAME 42
2
V.2.2. WEEE, GENERATED BY NON-HOUSEHOLD USERS 47
V.2.3. FINANCING OF THE RESTRICTION OF USE OF HAZARDOUS COMPOUNDS IN
EEE 47
VIII. BIBLIOGRAPHY 61
3
I. BACKGROUND
Directive 2002/96/ЕС on waste electrical and electronic equipment is adopted by the
European Parliament and the Council and published in OJ L37 of 13.02.2003. The
Directive shall enter into force on the day of its publication and concerns the collection and
environmentally sound treatment of waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE). The
objectives of the Directive on WEEE are to reduce the amount of generated WEEE and to
cover most of the quantity of WEEE generated. Its management must lead to reuse,
recycling and other forms of recovery of such wastes. In addition, another purpose of the
Directive is to improve the general environmental performance of the stakeholders,
participating in the life cycle of EEE (producers, distributors, users and especially the
operators involved in the treatment and disposal of WEEE).
To help the management of this waste stream and to protect human health, European
legislation envisages restriction of the use of the hazardous substances in the production of
EEE (Directive 2002/95/ЕС on restriction of the use of certain hazardous substances in
EEE).
I.2. Timeframe
Directives 2002/96/ЕС and 2002/95/ЕС enter into force on 13.2.2003. Directive
2003/108/ЕС enters into force on 31.12.2003. The deadline for the transposition of the
Directives in the Member States is 13.08.2004. The following derogations from article 5 (5)
and article 7 (2) from Directive 2002/96/ЕС has been accepted:
§ For the Republic of Cyprus, Malta, Poland, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary,
Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia– 24 months
§ For Slovenia – 12 months
4
Directive 75/442/ЕЕС on waste
Recommendation 2001/331/ЕС of the European Parliament and Council of 4 April 2001
about the minimum criteria for organization of environmental inspections in Member States
5
II. ANALYSIS OF THE CURRENT STATUS IN BULGARIA
CONCERNING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
DIRECTIVES
II1.1.2. Stakeholders
The Directive concerns the following persons and organizations:
§ Competent authorities: Ministry of Environment and Water and its regional
bodies – Regional Inspectorates of Environment and Water (RIEWs), Ministry
of Economy, Ministry of Health and local authorities
§ Producers of electrical and electronic equipment, included in article 2, except
when they export their production outside the EU.
§ Importers of EEE
§ Distributors of EEE
§ Retailers of EEE
§ Households and users other than private households (business users)
§ Services centers and repair shops of EEE
§ Facilities for separate collection of WEEE
§ Facilities for treatment of separately collected WEEE
§ Facilities for recovery and disposal of WEEE
§ Transport companies, that are engaged in international transport of WEEE for
export
§ Non-government organizations and media
The definition of “Producer” is very important, because the Directive introduces the
“Producer Responsibility” principle and the producers should pay for the treatment,
recycling and some costs of the collection of WEEE. The Directive clearly states, that
“Producer” is a person that manufactures and sells under his own brand, resells other brands
or imports goods in the EU. For the purposes of reporting and trade within the EU, a
6
producer may be an exporter. The Directive doesn’t state any obligations for those business
organizations, which export outside the EU.
• Ordinance on requirements for treatment and transportation of waste oils and waste
oil products, promulgated State Gazette No 59/2000
• Ordinance on when permits for import, export and transit of waste is required and
the procedure of permits’ issuing – publ. State Gazette 66/2000
Special
• Ordinance on placing on the market fluorescent and other mercury containing
lamps and for treatment and transportation of spent fluorescent and other mercury containing
lams – publ. State Gazette 101/2000
WEEE is waste according to the national legislation. It’s included in the definition of “wide
spread waste” according to the Waste Management Act (WMA).
The WEEE, large amount of which is classified as hazardous waste according to Ordinance
No3 on classification of waste, requires treatment under the permit regime - article 37
WMA.
WEEE, which is not hazardous, according to article 12 (2) (1) of WMA may be collected,
transported and temporarily stored without permit, but the persons that carry out these
activities must be registered by the competent authorities.
According to Bulgarian legislation on waste classification, WEEE is in groups 16.02. and
20.01. This classification defines that there are whole appliances, as well as their
components, which are hazardous waste. For the purpose of protection of the environment
7
and human health, the management of WEEE, which contains hazardous substance, should
be performed only by entities holding the necessary permit.
It has to be considered, that the Directive regulates relations concerning equipment, which
wasn’t an object of regulation in the EU as well as in Bulgaria. In this direction it is
necessary that some new legal acts of the national legislation have to be adopted or the
existing ones to be amended, in order to prevent conflicts between national and
international acts and to ensure higher rate harmonization with the requirements of the
Directive.
Below are listed some basic recommendations for the harmonization of the legislation:
With a view of transposing of the Directive it is necessary one or more secondary legal acts
on WEEE to be adopted.
The provisions of the Directives may be transposed also through adoption of Ordinances on
essential requirements towards products, issued according to article 7 of the Act on the
technical requirements on products. This concerns mostly the requirements for placing on
the market and marking of EEE.
The Directive’s principle about the financial responsibility of the producers has to be
implemented through fulfilling of the requirements of WMA. As stipulated in the Directive
on WEEE, producers are responsible for the financing of systems for separate collection,
disposal and recovery. Harmonization of the Bulgarian legislation with the Directive on
WEEE requires the provisions on financial responsibilities of all producers and importers of
EEE to be adopted that as a minimum must ensure free take back of WEEE from end users.
It is necessary:
§ to determine legal penalties for violation of the regulations on WEEE
and
§ to define order and methods for providing the necessary information in accordance
with article 12 of Directive 2002/96 ЕС
The definitions of the Directive on WEEE, which don’t have legal description in the
national legislation, should be transposed.
It is envisaged that a single legal act will be adopted regulating EEE and WEEE, the actions
associated with WEEE, the concerned parties, their obligations, responsibilities and
relations, controlling authorities, penalties and so on. On the other hand through the
amendment of the legal acts, the regulations concerning WEEE have to be unified.
8
§ Ordinance on the essential requirements and evaluation of compliance of
household refrigerators, freezers, equipment for storage of frozen food products
and their combinations – publ. State Gazette 84/2002 г.
§ Ordinance on the essential requirements and evaluation of compliance of toys –
publ. State Gazette 62/2001 г.
§ Ordinance on requirements towards production and placing on the market of
batteries and accumulators and treatment and transport of waste from batteries
and accumulators – publ. State Gazette 61/2000
9
- Undertakes compulsory administrative measures.
Mayor of Municipality
- Develops and implements Programs on management of waste, generated on the
territory of the municipality;
- Controls the implementation of the municipal regulations issued under article 19
WMA, and the implementation of other legal acts concerning waste management;
- Organizes systems for separate collection of waste fluorescent and other lamps
containing mercury and determines the places for collection of spent batteries;
- Prevents throwing out of waste on not authorized places;
Producers:
§ Should be responsible for the financing of the implementation of the Directive;
§ Ensure that the products they put on the market are marked with the proper labels
and symbols, according to the requirements of the directive;
§ Prepare and keep data for the quantity of EEE, which they have put on the market or
have exported in the EU states and also the quantity and the types which they have
treated, recycled and/or disposed of on their own or through a third party;
10
§ Design products in a manner benefiting reuse, recycling and recovery of EEE and
their components;
§ Provide reuse, recovery and treatment information for each type of EEE put on the
market;
§ Have to provide information to the WEEE treatment and recycling facilities about
the different components and materials used as well as the content of dangerous
substances and preparations in EEE;
Distributors/ retailers
The distributors and retailers that sell products to the end users even if they are not included
in the definition of “Producer” should take back the wastes generated from the EEE sold by
them, which in any case is free for the households.
According to the directive the distributors and retailers may depart from the requirement for
taking back of WEEE only in case the Member states can guarantee the returning of WEEE
through third parties or collective systems if it is not made more difficult for the final holder
and remain free of charge for him.
The life cycle of EEE and the material balance of WEEE are shown on the scheme below.
The scheme shows the stakeholders that are important for the life cycle of EEE as well as
the range of activities, which have to implement the requirements of article 7 (2) of the
Directive. On this basis an analysis of the currently available facilities for collection and
recovery of waste in Bulgaria has been made.
11
Scheme of the life cycle of EEE and the material balance of WEEE treatment
≥80%**
Consumers of EEE
Recycling of plastics
Recycling of rubber
business/households
Recycling of glass
≤20%** Disposal
* The second hand EEE has to be
facilities
accompanied by a certificate for
compliance with the standards
** article 7 (2) by categories EEE
12
II.2.1. Description of the facilities for collection and recovery of
waste in Bulgaria
In Bulgaria there are no treatment facilities for WEEE with enough capacity. There are
facilities for recycling of some of the materials used in WEEE. The larger companies for
recycling of ferrous metals are “Stomana Industry“ Pernik and Kremikovtsi; for non-ferrous
metals – “KCM” – Plovdiv, “Monbat” – Montana, OCK Kardjali; for plastics - “Himik”
Asenovgrad, “Phoenix Plastic” - Turgoviste; for glass – “Stind”, Drujba” etc.; for rubber –
“Gumi Eco” in v.Gaber. There are no companies for recycling of textile waste.
In Bulgaria, there is capacity for the recycling of the materials1 as follows:
§ plastics /polyethylene, polypropylene, polyvinyl chloride, polyethylene
terephthalate/ – 12 000 tones/annually,
§ glass – 60 000 tones/annually (used capacity in 2001 г. - 12 000 tones),
§ ferrous metals – 750 000 tones/annually
The existing broad network of service centers has great experience in the repairing of some
components of EEE and repairing of whole EEE. This is confirmed by the research made in
2002 in a pilot region (Burgas, Pomorie and Karnobat) aiming to assess the quantity of
РСВ-containing appliances and materials and the capacity for their environmentally sound
management in Bulgaria2.
The facilities for incineration with energy recovery, which were constructed during the last
few years, mainly incinerate hospital waste. As facilities for incineration with energy
recovery may be used the cement plants, which now are developing plans for incineration
of waste composite materials, plastics, textile etc.
Concerning the existing companies for collection and trade with wastes from ferrous and
non-ferrous metals there is detailed information, as this activity is under a license regime
and there is a register in the Ministry of Economy.
According to this register by 16.08.2004 in Bulgaria there are 520 licensed companies
trading with ferrous and non-ferrous materials. The number of companies is different in the
different regions of the country but some of them execute their activities in more than one
place. Summarized data about the number of the registered economic organizations
performing such activities in the different regions are presented in the table below.
1
The data is from the Implementation program for Directive 94/62/EC in Bulgaria
2
Origin, Quantity and Destination of PCB-containing Residues in Bulgaria, ARGUS GmbH and local
partners BalBok Engineering Co. and IC-ISI Innovation Center, the survey in the model region was conducted
in 2002
13
No Region Number of companies
5 Vidin 5
6 Vratza 20
7 Gabrovo 6
8 Dobrich 3
9 Kurjali 6
10 Kustendil 2
11 Lovetch 8
12 Montana 10
13 Pazardjik 17
14 Pernik 25
15 Pleven 10
16 Plovdiv 29
17 Razgrad 8
18 Ruse 22
19 Silistra 8
20 Sliven 8
21 Smolan 3
22 Sofia 27
23 Sofia (capital) 140
24 Stara Zagora 25
25 Targovishte 7
26 Haskovo 14
27 Shumen 16
28 Yambol 17
Some of these companies may serve as a basis for establishment of collecting sites for
separate collection and dismantling of WEEE after provision of additional equipment and
personnel training.
By 1 August 2004 in Bulgaria there is a system for separate collection and recovery (95%)
of waste from fluorescent lamps with one collection facility of 2500 m2 and two mobile
collecting facilities – 3.5 tones and 20 tones. This system covers the big enterprises that
possess spent fluorescent lamps. The separately collected waste is directed for recycling in
a plant in Germany. The system functions for a year and it is working with 10% of its
capacity.
Concerning the treatment of hazardous substances and components of EEE in Bulgaria
there are the following possibilities:
- PCBs in capacitors – the practice in the EU shows that the recycling of this type of
waste can not be undertaken and so it is incinerated in installation for hazardous
waste and disposed in mines. In Bulgaria there is an alternative for the disposal in
mines – permanent storage in licensed equipment (reinforced concrete container B-
B cube).
- Components containing mercury like switches and backlighting lamps – in Bulgaria
exists the practice that these components are collected separately by holders
different from households and consequently they are directed to recovery facilities
abroad meeting the requirements of the WEEE Directive and Regulation 259/93.
14
- Batteries – in Bulgaria the management of this type of waste is regulated by a
special ordinance which transposes the requirements of the Directive 91/157/EEC.
- Printed circuit boards in mobile phones generally and other appliances, with surface
more than 10 cm2 – currently in Bulgaria there are no licensed facilities for the
treatment of this kind of waste but there are opportunities for the construction of
such plants.
- Toners cartridges, liquid and pasty, as well as color toners – a project for the
construction of a facility for the recycling of this kind of waste is currently in
progress. A broadly used technique in Bulgaria is the refilling of the toner cartridges
by licensed companies.
- Plastics with brominated flame retardants – currently there are no licensed facilities
for the treatment of this kind of waste but there are opportunities for the
reorganization of existing plants for incineration with energy recovery to treat this
type of waste. Another way is to direct the waste to facilities abroad.
- Asbestos waste and components containing asbestos – in Bulgaria there are
technologies for the conditioning of this type of waste through its immobilization in
a cement matrix, which is used in the construction industry. According to Decision
2003/33/EC, after the immobilization the asbestos waste can be taken to landfills for
non-hazardous waste.
- CRT – there are no facilities for the treatment of these wastes in Bulgaria. It is
considered that this type of waste should be directed to facilities abroad.
- CFC, HCFC, HFC, HC – in Bulgaria there aren’t any plants for the extraction and
recycling of this kind of waste.
- Gas discharge lamps – in Bulgaria the management of this type WEEE is
determined by a special legal act and they are collected by the final holders, other
than households, and afterwards they are directed to plants for recycling abroad,
meeting the requirements of the WEEE Directive and Regulation 259/93. The
current system covers only the business users of this EEE.
- LCD - there are no facilities for the treatment of these wastes in Bulgaria. It is
envisaged that this type of waste should be directed to facilities abroad.
- External electrical cables – it is envisaged that they will be disposed in the facilities
for incineration with energy recover. The preliminary surveys PCBs in external
electrical cables in EEE in Bulgaria were not found.
- Components containing refractory ceramic fibers – in Bulgaria there aren’t any
facilities for the treatment and recovery of this kind of waste. The amount of EEE
containing such components in Bulgaria is very small and the construction of such
facilities is not economically efficient.
- Components containing radioactive substances – in Bulgaria there is very well
organized regulation system for radioactive waste management and thus there are
licensed facilities for its disposal. The extraction of the radioactive components
from the rest of equipment is strictly monitored. In every facility for metal recycling
each batch is checked for presence of radioactivity at the point of entrance.
- Electrolyte capacitors containing substances of special interest - there are no
facilities for the treatment and recovery of these wastes in Bulgaria. It is considered
that this type of waste should be directed to facilities abroad.
15
At the moment a lot of regional landfills for municipal waste are being constructed some of
which will be with cells for hazardous waste. The existing facilities for landfilling of
hazardous waste which are constructed and operated by the enterprises are used mainly for
landfilling of the wastes generated by their activities.
3
Census 2001, volume I, book 3, NSI, Sofia 2002
16
Table 1. Allocation of the settlements by the number of
population
No Size - Settlements Settlements Population Population
inhabitants 2002
2001 2001 2002
1 Total 5336 5333 7891095 7845841
2 under 199 2288 2319 160690 164775
3 200- 499 1232 1226 406626 406379
4 500- 999 870 853 616262 604805
5 1000-1999 536 529 738154 728468
6 2000-4999 264 262 771855 768695
7 5000-9999 65 65 471052 477160
8 10000-24999 42 41 647682 647393
9 25000-99999 31 31 1605952 1664672
10 100000-499999 7 6 1373313 1269752
11 over 500000 1 1 1099507 1113742
(Urban residence)
Total 240 242 5473018 5461255
1 Under 999 2 2 974 915
2 1000-1999 12 14 18641 22355
3 2000-4999 85 87 287727 297218
4 5000-9999 60 60 439222 445207
5 10000-24999 42 41 647682 647393
6 25000-99999 31 31 1605952 1664672
7 100000-499999 7 6 1373313 1269752
8 over 500000 1 1 1099507 1113742
Rural residence
Total 5096 5091 2418077 2384586
1 under 199 2288 2319 160690 164775
2 200-499 1231 1225 406383 406152
3 500-999 869 852 615531 604117
4 1000-1999 524 515 719513 706113
5 2000-4999 179 175 484128 471476
6 5000-9999 5 5 31832 31953
17
As it seems the tendency of decreasing of the population continues and it is stronger in the
small settlements and especially the villages. The data above shows that about 1/3 of the
population lives in the villages which will impede the organization of systems of separate
collection of WEEE. The overall area of Bulgaria is 111 000 sq.m. The population density
is 72 people per sq.m. Significant part of the area of Bulgaria is agricultural. From the
overall 111001902 decares 63764817 or 57% are agricultural lands.
Major appliances
18
Number Average weight in kg Total weight in kg
Cookers, category 1 2286518 20 45730360
Microwaves, category 1 238334 15 3575010
Washing machines, category 1 1223799 55 67308945
TV, category 4 2284450 35 79955750
Freezers, category 1 741938 50 37096900
Refrigerators, category 1 2451931 25 61298275
Sum 9226970 32 294965240
Other appliances
PC, category 3 120851 20 2417020
Telephones, category 3 2112468 0.5 1056234
Others from categories 3 and 4 2717269 8 21279686
Sum 4950588 5 24752940
The Census covers only the main types of appliances in the households. These appliances
are from categories 1, 3 and 4, according the Annex IA of the Directive on WEEE. The
group “Others” used above covers all other appliances and equals the result of subtraction
of overall quantity of WEEE in the households measured in the census and the quantity of
the “major” households appliances. The partial distribution of appliances is shown below.
19
Partial distribution of appliances in the households, by type and weight4
Others
PC 8%
1%
Cookers
14%
T elephones
0%
M icrowaves
1%
Refridgerat ors
19%
W ashing
m achines
21%
Freezers
11%
TV
25%
Table 3 contains data on the availability of “major” appliances in households. Data are from
the Censuses 1985 and 2001.
4
NSI., "Census 2001"
5
Source: the database, containing processed results of the NSI’s conducted censuses 1985 and 2001.
20
per per
household household
Data in Tables 4 and 5 show the rate of contentedness of households with domestic
(category 1) and with consumer (category 3 and 4) equipment. The data are officially
published in the issues of NSI. The contentedness of the population with appliances within
the consumer equipment group by 2001 (color TV, video recorder, video camera, cable TV
set, satellite dish, audio system, telephone, mobile phone, home PC) according to the data
from the census in 2001 is shown in Table 4.
Table 3. Distribution of households and population according to number of units
within the consumer equipment group available in the households in 2001
No Number of units Inhabitants in the households Households
number % number %
1 Without any appliance 744518 9.5 336120 11.5
2 With 1 unit 1076636 13.8 491357 16.9
3 With 2 units 1840319 23.5 747378 25.7
4 With 3 units 1918215 24.5 651561 22.4
5 With 4 units 1198846 15.3 369974 12.7
6 With 5 units 614174 7.8 186295 6.4
7 With 6 units 294803 3.8 88836 3.0
8 With 7 units 109768 1.4 32778 1.1
9 With 8 units 25921 0.3 7678 0.3
10 With 9 units 4031 0.1 1216 0.0
As it is evident, 28.4% of the households have less that 2 units and only 10.8% have more
than 4 of all 9 consumer products.
The contentedness of the population with household appliances /big domestic appliances/
by 2001 (cooker, microwave, washing machine, dishwasher, refrigerator and freezer)
according to the above mentioned NSI survey also shows that 23.5% of the households
have less than 2 appliances and 19.8% of the households have more than 3 of the 6
appliances.
Table 4. Distribution of households and population according to number of large
domestic appliances available in the households in 2001
No Number of units Inhabitants in the households Households
number % number %
1 Without any appliance 639920 8.2 255703 8.8
2 With 1 1009049 12.9 428368 14.7
3 With 2 2035681 26.0 860030 29.5
3.1 Including with cooker and 1757501 22.5 757262 26.0
refrigerator
4 With 3 2286299 29.2 792444 27.2
4.1 Including with cooker, 1721567 22.0 583368 20.0
washing machine and
refrigerator
5 With 4 1389097 17.7 435836 15.0
6 With 5 410020 5.2 123415 4.2
7 With all 6 units 57165 0.7 17397 0.6
21
With a view of comparing the rate of contentedness of the households in Bulgaria and
Germany below it is presented table with the rates of of contentedness of the households in
Germany.
Table 5. Availability of large household appliances in households in
6 7
Germany and Bulgaria by years
Year Germany Bulgaria
Appliance 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2001 1985 2001
This table shows the large difference in the status of the households in Germany and
Bulgaria.
To estimate when the availability of appliances in households in Bulgaria will become
comparable with the status of the households in Germany, Table 7 contains a prognosis,
based on the data about the sales of household appliances by retailers. For the calculations
the decrease of the population and an increase of the sells at a rate of 4% annually
commensurable with the expected economic growth are taken into account.
Table 6. Retail Sales of Household Appliances, based on the data from
8
NSI and prognosis till 2010
6
Overview of the German Market of Household Appliances 2003/2004, GfK Marketing Services – ZVEI, Dec. 2003
7
processed data from Table 3
8
NSI Statistical Yearbook 2000, 2001, 2002 and 2003, р. 367-370
22
Year Retail Sold Sold Availability Available Household Average
sales of appliances in appliances in of appliances appliances in appliances number
domestic tones, units, in the households in the household
appliances conditionally conditionally households with households, appliances
in calculated calculated with accumulation kg per per
thousands assuming accumulation in tones inhabitant household
BGL average at the end of
weight of 25 the period, in
kg and thousand
average units
price of 250
BGL
2003 261 545 26 155 1 046 9 800 286 433 37 3,4
The prognostic results show that the low level of EEE consumption by households will be
kept. Only in 2006 households in Bulgaria will have average 4.7 units, e.g. the level of
availability of those domestic appliances per household in EU in 2000.
The factors influencing the implementation of requirements of Article 5 (5) of the Directive
in Bulgaria are the quantities of appliances in the households, the term of usage and the
potential for WEEE generation.
Regarding the appliances’ term of usage by 2006, the relevant data from the Census in 1985
should be taken into consideration.
According to these data in 1985 households had 5755000 household appliances (cookers,
washing machines, TVs and refrigerators) – overall 153000 tones /Table 3/. Since 1985 the
population has decreased from 8900 thousand inhabitants to 7900 thousand inhabitants.
Taking into account that this is a result of migration processes, the household appliances are
kept, even not used. To this quantity of EEE which is 91% from all EEE /the figure above/
we must add the rest of EEE which is 9% or 15000 tones. The whole amount of EEE in
households in 2001 is 168000 tones.
An assumption is made that, for the households possessing 4 or more household appliances
within the consumer equipment group, the purchasing of new TV set will lead to discarding
the old one. This means that if these 686 777 households (Table 4) buy one additional TV
set it will lead to discarding of approximately 24 050 tones end-of-life TVs (average 35 kg
per TV).
By analogy, only for households with 4 and more domestic appliances the purchase of new
appliance will lead to discarding the old one. This means that if these 567648 households
(Table 5) buy one additional appliance with an average weight of 25 kg, approximately
14500 tones of WEEE will be generated (taking into account the term of usage of
household appliances of 20 for the EU states and reached level of contentedness of
23
households in Bulgaria by that year). Therefore, in 2006 it can be expected that 38 550
tones waste from end of life domestic appliances and end-of-life TV sets. 4200 tones should
be added to this amount- the waste quantity of the rest appliances (except TVs and large
household appliances), which represents 10 % of the total EEE quantity. The total WEEE
quantity, which is expected to be generated in 2005 is 42 833 tones.
As it is necessary to determine the capacity in Bulgaria needed to achieve the targets of Art.
5 of the Directive on WEEE, a prognosis for the potential for generation of WEEE in the
years after 2007 must be prepared – the WEEE potential. The prognosis is presented in
Table 8.
Table 7. Prognosis for quantities generated and separately
collected WEEE from households
The prognosis is based on the assumption that there will be 4% annual growth,
corresponding with the assumed growth of the sales of EEE.
The results presented in Table 8 are prepared to facilitate planning of the activities for
implementation of Art. 5 of the Directive. Establishment of a Registry containing data form
producers, importers of EEE, companies collecting WEEE after the establishment of
systems for separate collection and from the regular campaigns will allow the collection of
reliable information.
Table 8 shows, that only after 2008, the requirement for separate collection of 4 kg per
inhabitant will be reached. In that respect the requirements of art. 5 (5) of the Directive on
WEEE will be relevant for Bulgaria after 2008, if a rate of 62 % of WEEE covered by
systems for separate collection is achieved.
The percentage of WEEE covered by systems for separate collection is based on the data
from the Ministry of Environment of Germany. In Germany, in the year 2000, 400000 tones
(19%) of the generated WEEE were covered by the existing system for separate collection
and treatment. It is expected that in Bulgaria during the second year similar percentage of
WEEE covered by systems for separate collection will be achieved.
Except from private households, WEEE will be generated from other sources also. It is hard
to define the exact quantity of EEE respectively WEEE. For the purpose of the prognosis it
is assumed that the WEEE arising from private householders is about 45–50% from all
24
WEEE. This is based on estimates that in Germany this percentage is 46%. This percentage
is corroborated from the data of the National statistics for retail sales of EEE after 2000,
from which it can be assumed that 35-42% from the EEE are sold to private households.
25
III. ANALYSIS OF THE CAPACITY FOR THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE WEEE DIRECTIVE AND THE
ROHS DIRECTIVE
Requirements regarding the product design
Obligation: Encouraging the design and production of EEE in a manner facilitating the
dismantling and recovery, in particular the reuse and recycling of WEEE, their components
and materials.
Parties affected by this obligation:
§ Producers of EEE
§ Ministry of Environment and Water
§ Ministry of Economy
§ Ministry of Education and Science
§ Bulgarian Standardization Institute
§ Education facilities
§ Non-governmental organizations and the media
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Through standardizing documents
§ Including of disciplines, connected with “green design” in the education of
specialists in the different educational stages
§ Through popularization of the eco-labeling
§ Through consultations of the producers and importers with the service centers
and with the operators of facilities for recycling and other forms of recovery of
WEEE
Necessary capacity to fulfill this requirement:
Producers, as a directly affected party from this provision should comply their
standardization documents about EEE with the EU regulations and the international
standards on EEE. The same applies for the importers. It should be considered that the
resources invested at the stage of development of EEE can guarantee the receiving of eco
labeling and on the other hand – they will optimize the costs for the dismantling, recycling
and disposal, which are covered by them on the basis of the “producer responsibility”
introduced in the WEEE Directive.
Currently in Bulgaria Ordinance № 3 from 15 May 2003 on the National scheme about the
eco labeling was adopted . Department “Prevention activities” at MOEW coordinates the
activities of the National scheme on eco-labeling and the performance of the procedures for
receiving these labels9. Orders of the Minister of environment and water are about to
introduce specific requirements for the receiving of eco labeling for some of the product
groups covered by the WEEE and ROHS Directives.
9
Organizational structure of MOEW, art. 25 (13), publ. in State Gazette 104/1999., ammended SG
100/2000,.28/2001, 32/2001г.,.91/2001,.64/2002,3/2003,.93/2003,.107/2003,.31/2004.
26
There is an increasing coordination between the work of the Ministry of Environment and
Water and the Ministry of Education and Science. The inclusion of disciplines, connected
with “green design” and the popularization of the eco markings are a natural part of this
cooperation.
The popularization of the importance of the eco labeling among the population may be
performed also with the help of non government organizations and the media.
Obligation: Organizing systems, allowing final holders (households and similar users of
EEE) and distributors to return WEEE free of charge.
Parties affected by this obligation:
§ Producers of EEE
§ Importers of EEE
§ Distributors of EEE
§ Retailers of EEE
§ Local Authorities
27
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Take back of old appliances when selling a new one
§ Establishment of collective and individual take back systems
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
The functioning of the systems could not be possible without the participation of the
distributors of EEE, who have to ensure the take back of WEEE from private households
free of charge if the customer buys new appliance which is from the same type and
performs the same functions as the returned one. Bulgaria has relatively small experience in
the set up of collective systems. At the moment experience regarding waste packaging is
being gained.
The local authorities (mayors) shall adopt local Regulations and may take part in the
organization of the functioning of the systems.
Now in Bulgaria the necessary capacity is not present. The parties related to this obligation
need some time to be informed about their role in order to be able to estimate the necessary
administrative and financial capacity. In addition, currently there are no clear criteria for
defining the conditions for refusing of taking back because of WEEE pollution.
The establishment of the systems for separate collection is related with overcoming of the
difficulties with the low population density and the higher percentage of the rural territories.
28
On the other hand in the country there is not enough capacity for collection of this amount
of WEEE both regarding the lack of collection facilities and readiness of the business
organizations to perform the taking of the WEEE back. There are no individual or collective
systems. The currently functioning system for collection of waste fluorescent lamps now
covers only the generators other than households, while this obligation concerns the waste
arising from households and similar users.
29
Parties affected by this obligation:
§ Competent Authorities: Ministry of Environment and Water, Ministry of
Economy and Local Authorities
§ Centers for collection and temporary storage
§ Centers for dismantling, recycling and other forms of recovery
§ Research and development organizations
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Encouraging research and development activities including thought financing
such research
§ Implementation of new technologies
§ Exporting abroad the separately collected WEEE to centers for recycling and
other forms of recovery complying with the Directive
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
Currently in Bulgaria there are no facilities with enough capacity for dismantling,
separation of the wastes into material flows and separation of hazardous and non-suitable
for recycling substances and materials. “Stomana Industry” – Pernik operates installation
for shredding of metal waste but as a whole the manual dismantling of bulky WEEE
predominates.
The question about the ensuring the financing of the construction of such facilities and the
implementation of treatment technologies complying with annexes ІІ and ІІІ of the WEEE
Directive is at hand.
Recovery
Obligation: Stimulating the re-use of the separately collected WEEE
Parties affected by this obligation:
§ Local Authorities
§ Households and business users of WEEE
§ Non-government organizations and the media
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Sorting the WEEE to working and non-working in the separate collection
centers
§ Re-sale of the working appliances and components
§ Informing the population about the opportunity to by “second hand” appliances
and components
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
The fulfillment of this obligation does not demand significant additional resources if the
separate collection facilities are set up and functioning.
Obligation: Fulfillment by 31 December 2006 at the latest of the requirements about the
rates of recovery of the separately collected appliances according to their categories (except
category 8):
30
§ For WEEE falling under categories 1 and 10 of Annex IA:
o The rate of recovery shall be increased to a minimum of 80 % by an average
weight per appliance, and
o Component, material and substance reuse and recycling shall be increased to
a minimum of 75 % by an average weight per appliance;
§ For WEEE falling under categories 3 and 4 of Annex IA:
o The rate of recovery shall be increased to a minimum of 75 % by an average
weight per appliance, and
o Component, material and substance reuse and recycling shall be increased to
a minimum of 65 % by an average weight per appliance;
§ For WEEE falling under categories 2, 5, 6, 7 and 9 of Annex IA:
o The rate of recovery shall be increased to a minimum of 70 % by an average
weight per appliance, and
o Component, material and substance reuse and recycling shall be increased to
a minimum of 50 % by an average weight per appliance;
§ For gas discharge lamps, the rate of component material and substance reuse and
recycling shall reach a minimum of 80% by weight of the lamps.
Parties affected by this obligation:
§ Competent authorities: Ministry of Environment and Water
§ Producers and importers of EEE
§ Centers for dismantling, recycling and other forms of recovery
§ Research and development organizations
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Encouraging research and development activities including through financing
such research
§ Implementation of new technologies
§ Exporting abroad the separately collected WEEE to centers for recycling and
other forms of recovery complying with the Directive
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
The fulfillment of this obligation demands significant financial resources. Currently in
Bulgaria there is no capacity for its entire fulfillment.
There are no existing facilities specialized in WEEE treatment or meeting requirements of
Annexes II and III of the Directive.
The capacity for recycling of materials in Bulgaria is as follows:
§ metal – practically unlimited
§ plastics /polyethylene, polypropylene, polyvinyl chloride, polyethylene
terephthalate/ - 12 000 tones per year
§ glass – 60 000 tones per year (used capacity in 2001 г. – 12 000 tones)
31
To evaluate the capacity for meeting the requirement of article 7 (2) of the Directive,
several scenarios were made. In the scenarios WEEE are separated in three groups and the
results are conforming to the three targets, set in the Directive:
§ Group 1 - categories 1 and 10
§ Group 2 - categories 3 and 4
§ Group 3 - categories 2, 5, 6, 7 and 9
The data for the possibilities for recovery and recycling of the different components and
materials from the three groups are presented in Annex I. It’s shown there that several
material flows are formed, which can potentially meet the requirements (as percentage
content) regarding recycling and recovery. The analysis of the capacities in Bulgaria for
recovery in conformity with the Directive these flows revealed the following:
1. As it was mentioned above Bulgaria has not enough capacity for separation of the
collected WEEE by materials and components and separation of the fluids and the
hazardous components form the waste. , e.g. there are no conditions for forming
material flows which afterwards to be sent to the existing recycling facilities or facilities
for incineration with energy recovery and/or facilities for disposal.
2. There is capacity in Bulgaria for recycling of ferrous and non-ferrous metals.
3. There is capacity in Bulgaria for glass recycling. However the waste flows of glass
destined for recovery as a result of the implementation of Directive 94/62/EC on
packaging and packaging waste and Directive 2000/53/EC on end-of-life vehicles
should be taken into account.
4. In Bulgaria there is capacity for plastics such as PE, PP, PET and HDPE, but there is no
capacity for other types of plastics used in EEE. There is a need to develop and
introduce technologies for recycling such plastic waste. Like the glass waste flow, the
quantities of plastic waste from other waste flows should be taken into consideration.
5. In Bulgaria there is no capacity for treatment of WEEE, containing hazardous
components or substances. There are no functioning technologies or facilities in
operation to treat hazardous waste resulting from WEEE treatment. A facility for
treatment of waste toner cartridges is planned to be constructed.
6. There are no facilities for incineration with energy recovery. The existing cement plants
are suitable for this purpose but up to now only one of them poses permit for
incineration of waste. It is expected that in near future the other plants will be
reconstructed with a purpose of incineration of waste with energy recovery. The waste
accepted in these facilities should be pre-treated - sorting, balling etc.
From the data presented in Annex 1 it is obvious that for the achievement of the targets for
recovery, reuse and recycling of WEEE of Group 1 the country should ensure recycling of
significant quantities plastics and glass. For these materials targets for recovery and
recycling should be attained in accordance with the requirements of Directive 94/62/EC and
the capacity of the existing installations will be used almost to its full extent. According to
the Program for Implementation of Directive 94/62/EC for the period 2006-2009 the
following quantity of packaging waste should be recycled:
32
Quantity plastic waste
[tones] 5904 8346 13285 16148
Quantity glass waste
[tones] 18618 22673 28178 33616
Table 9 shows that during the period after 2008 the capacity of the installations for
recycling of plastic waste will be filled up and in 2007 the country should recycle double
quantity glass waste comparing to the quantity recycled in 2001. Moreover for achievement
of the targets set in Art. 7 (2) (a), waste for which there is no wide spread practice such as
rubber, concrete, textile, organic materials should be recovered.
The lack of enough capacity for incineration with energy recovery and recycling of plastics
and glass hinders even at greater extent the attainment of the targets set in Art. 7 (2) (b).
The equipment in Group 2 contains less percentage of metals which requires the percentage
of recovery of the other components mainly plastics and glass to be increased. Furthermore
this WEEE is composed of components containing hazardous substances (CRT, printed
circuit boards, monitors of liquid crystals etc.) for which there are no facilities for recovery
WEEE of Group 3 contains large quantities plastic and glass. Moreover considerable part of
the plastic contains brominated flame retardants, which additionally hinders the recycling
and finding of markets for the recycled materials.
There are no facilities for recovery of waste gas discharge lamps and measures are taken for
export for recovery abroad. At present the lamps exported abroad are delivered to facility
that guarantees above 90% recycling rate Currently there is no mechanism for financing of
the collection and recovery of waste gas discharge lamps from the households.
Due to the problems for recycling and recovery of WEEE described above, the targets of
Art. 7 (2) of Directive 2002/96/EC should be attained gradually. Bellow it is presented
prognosis for the quantities and the percentage of recovery, recycling and reuse of WEEE.
33
Group 2 536,2 25,04% 2230,7 25,04% 4639,8 25,04% 7479,3 25,04%
The necessary infrastructure for treatment and recovery of WEEE can be established after
the adoption of legal act for WEEE, the designation of the responsibilities of the
stakeholders concerned and the provision of the needed funds by each responsible party.
The accounts and the quantities listed in Table 10 and Annex 1 are only for the WEEE
collected from private households. The WEEE collected form the sources other than private
households should be added to this quantity. As a minimum this quantities should be
increased with 25 – 50 % which should be taken into account when planning the
infrastructure for achievement of the targets for recycling and recovery of WEEE.
In order to gain experience till the construction of new facilities the export of WEEE may
be a good solution for reaching the objectives listed in article 7 of the Directive. The export
of waste for recycling abroad will cost averagely 350 EUR per tone depending of the type
of WEEE and its condition. This cost should be taken into consideration in the decision
making process about the development and implementation of new technologies for
treatment of WEEE. This scenario should be examined in detail because it will reduce the
initial financing and thus on one hand it will allow the setting up of separate collection
facilities and on the other hand there is already experience of the export of fluorescent
lamps.
34
§ Distributors of EEE
§ Retailers of EEE
§ Households and business users of EEE
§ Non-government organizations and the media
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Marking of the equipment by the producers and importers
§ Providing user information at the moment of sale and through Local Authorities,
non government organizations and the media
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
The fulfillment of this obligation does not require significant additional resources from the
producers, distributors and control authorities. In Bulgaria there is enough capacity to meet
this requirement. At the moment there are requirements for labeling. The label certifies that
the appliances are in conformity with requirements set in the ordinances based on article 7
of the Act on the technical requirements towards products.
This requirement is very important for meeting the objectives of the Directive because it
will contribute to the voluntary participation of the users in the separate collecting facilities
for WEEE. Such participation will lead to the reduction of the costs for collection of
WEEE.
35
put on the market collected through all routes and systems, reused, recycled and recovered
in the country as well as the waste exported by weight or if this is possible by numbers.
Parties affected by this obligation:
§ State Agency for Metrology and Technical Surveillance
§ Commission for trade and consumer protection
§ Ministry of Environment and Water
§ Regional Inspectorate of Environment and Water
§ Bulgarian EEA
§ National Statistical Institute
§ Bulgarian Custom Agency
§ State Agency for Metrology and Technical Surveillance
§ Commission of Trade and Consumer Protection
§ Producers of EEE
§ Importers of EEE
§ Facilities for separate collection of WEEE
§ Facilities for recycling and other forms of recovery of WEEE
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Creating of a register of the producers, importers and the facilities for separate
collection, recycling and other forms of recovery
§ Gathering information about the appliances put on the market
§ Gathering information about the life cycle of WEEE by facilities, weight and
numbers
§ Ensuring public access to the register
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
This obligation is very important for the financing of the activities connected with WEEE
and the control of the attainment of the targets for separate collection, recovery and
recycling. The improvement of the coordination between the affected institutions is
essential. The creation of such register will require resources and time.
The fulfillment of this obligation will require additional resources for the administrative
cost from all affected parties.
36
§ Ministry of Environment and Water
§ Regional Inspectorate of Environment and Water
§ Ministry of Health
§ Regional Hygienic- Epidemiological Inspectorates
§ Bulgarian Institute of Standardization
§ Producers of raw and refined materials
§ Processing companies
§ Suppliers of components of EEE;
§ Companies for assembling of EEE;
§ Producers of EEE;
§ Service centers of EEE;
§ Facilities for treatment, recycling and other forms of recovery of WEEE
§ Research and development centers
Possible ways to fulfill this requirement:
§ Informing the companies about the requirements of the Directive
§ Coordination of the national standards with the acts of the EU
§ Development of substitute substances
§ Popularization of the voluntary certification by ISO 14000 before the
enforcement of the Directive
Necessary capacity to fulfill this obligation:
All different participants in the production chain of EEE - producers of materials, suppliers
of components, assembling companies and producers10 – will be affected by the ROHS
Directive. The distribution of the expenses for the implementation of the Directive will
depend on the market structure on the certain sector of EEE. As part of these costs fall on
the consumers this means that they will bear some of the expenses which will probably be
different in the different sectors and products. It is assumed that EEE is only small part of
implementation of these substances. In a short period the suppliers of components probably
will have to bear the greatest part of the cost. But in long term this additional costs probably
will be taken by the assemblers and/or producers. The amount of this cost will depend on
the market structure.
In Bulgaria there isn’t any data for the presence of producers of BFR. As the use of lead,
cadmium and hexavalent chromium in EEE is estimated to be less than 10% of their use,
the restriction of the use of these substances in new EEE is expected to have relatively
small impact on the producers of raw and refined materials.
While the restricted substances enter the production stream of components the products
which use the components afterwards may have to be adapted or redesigned to ensure that
they will function with the new components. It is also possible that some companies will be
vertically integrated and so the research and development, production of components and
10
The supply of components and the assembly of the appliances may be performed by local producers or
abroad. This process is different by companies.
37
final assembly of the products will be made in the same place, in that case these companies
will be directly affected at all levels. If there is no need for changes of the design of the
products as a result of changes of the components then the producers at the end of the
production chain will be affected indirectly.
At this stage it is very hard to define the exact expenses as the restricted substances will be
used in some specific products more than in others and thus some sectors will be more
affected then others. In addition not all companies in the different business sectors will be
affecter equally, because some of them will not produce or will produce relatively small
amount EEE while some will not deal with or will deal with relatively small amount of
WEEE.
38
IV. ORGANIZATION FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF
DIRECTIVE ON WEEE AND DIRECTIVE ON ROHS IN
BULGARIA
39
§ legal
§ economic
§ technical
§ informational
The legal aspect of the problem is the absence of secondary legislative act to impose the
responsibilities for WEEE management and to establish the necessary financial mechanism.
The economic aspect of the problem is related to the shortage of financial resources and
working mechanisms for their collection. First come the costs for control of the
implementation of the requirements of the Directive. Second – capital costs for establishing
collection treatment and recovery and recycling facilities. On the third place are the
organizational costs for producers and importers and for retailers for taking the WEEE back
and document turnover. Not to be missed are the costs for technological renovations for
production of new EEE to meet the requirements of RoHS and WEEE Directives.
The technical aspect of the problem is related to the selection of strategy for technical
assurance of WEEE management. The treatment technologies must meet the requirements
of art 7 (2) of the Directive on WEEE. Technical issue is also the capacity of retailer to take
back WEEE from households and from users other than private households (after 13th of
August 2005). The number of shops for EEE and their distribution according to space are
presented in Tables below. Data are from the NSI Statistical Yearbook 2003.
It can be expected based on the above data, that only 5% of the retail shops will actually
have the capacity to take back appliances. That means that the role of the State and local
authorities is of key importance for implementation of the Directive on WEEE.
The informational aspect is related to the way of generating, delivering, colleting and
processing of information, which will assure both implementation of the Directive and
compliance monitoring, enforcement and reporting.
The key-stone implementation activities are as follows (listed according to their priorities):
1) Development of legislative act transposing WEEE and RoHS Directives
40
– Defining type of schemes to guarantee collection, treatment and recovery of WEEE.
2) Establishment of registry and implementation of system for collection of information
about
– Producers of EEE in Bulgaria
– Importers of EEE
– Wholesalers of EEE
– Retailers of EEE
– Information about the weight and/or number of electrical and electronic equipment,
placed on the market, by type and by producer and importers
– Facilities for separate collection of WEEE
– Facilities for treatment and recovery of WEEE together with data about the
technologies applied
– Individual and collective schemes
– Use of hazardous compounds in production of EEE
3) Enhancement of the qualification of control authorities
4) Raising awareness, knowledge and interest among the stakeholders, especially:
– Producers of EEE in Bulgaria
– Importers of EEE
– Wholesalers and retailers of EEE
– Business users
5) Construction of facilities and establishment of schemes for separate collection
6) Construction of facilities for dismantling, separation, recycling and other forms of
recovery and/or directing collected WEEE to existing facilities for treatment abroad
7) Informing public about the danger for the environment and human health from
uncontrolled disposal of WEEE and about separate collection options.
41
V. FINANCIAL FRAME
42
№ Placement of the RIEW Number of Population Population Density of Number of
facility (town) households in towns, the collection
in the % population facilities
covered in the
region region,
persons
per sq.m
2 Burgas RIEW Burgas 156005 423547 70.60 50 1
3 Varna RIEW Varna 248130 677230 75.30 80 1
RIEW Veliko
4 Veliko Tarnovo 172134 437297 69.60 66 1
Tarnovo
RIEW Montana
5 Montana 211012 555368 57.30 53 1
and Vratza
6 Pleven RIEW Pleven 179157 481936 62.60 57 1
RIEW Plovdiv
7 Plovdiv 360017 1022495 65.30 97 2
and Pazardjik
8 Russe RIEW Russe 199614 560574 57.00 69 1
RIEW Smoljan
9 Haskovo 197758 570193 57.80 47 1
and Haskovo
Pernik (for
10 RIEW Sofia 224352 585606 65.00 43 1
Sofia-district)
11 Sofia - town RIEW Sofia 459765 1170842 95.40 846 2
RIEW Stara
12 Stara Zagora 277443 760573 66.20 63 1
Zagora
13 Shumen RIEW Shumen 123098 342067 57.80 59 1
TOTAL 2921887 7928901 15
AVERAGE 224761 609915 68.60 72
This organization allows the average distance for WEEE collection to be as low as 50-60
km. which leads to decrease in the operational costs. Thus, each collection point will collect
and transfer further 600 tones WEEE annually in the first years of implementation of the
Directive in Bulgaria.
The validity of this choice is proved by the practice of one of the leading German
companies in the field of waste management and waste recycling. It operates 400 collection
points and 14 recycling facilities in Germany, with capacity of 246900 tones per year. Their
average capacity per collection point is 620 tones per year, and the average distance
covered is 50 km.
43
holders, WEEE collection and transportation, book keeping, reporting and accounting. The
responsibilities of the above mentioned personnel will also include sorting of WEEE in the
facility as suitable or non-suitable for direct re-use. Those suitable for re-use can be sold
directly from the facility or given for charity.
Annual operational costs of a facility consist of:
- Average costs per employee are 8000 BGL per year (social and medical insurance
included) or total 120000 BGL per 15 employees
- Consumables – electricity and water supply, heating during the winter, telephone,
etc. – 1000 BGL per month or 12000 BGL per year
- Transport of WEEE – 400 shipments * 1.5 tones each * 100 km per ply * 1 BGL/km
average for own and hired transport means = 40000 BGL
- Administrative transport – 3000 km per month * 0.40 BGL/km prime costs = 1200
BGL per month or 14400 BGL per year
- Printing materials and other costs for informational campaigns – 10000 BGL per
year
The overall costs per year per collection facility are 196400 BGL or about 100000 EUR. If
the facility operates full scale, the costs per tone will be 150 EUR.
For some types of WEEE (such as fluorescent lamps, TVs, monitors and PCs), if the
existing recycling facilities that fulfill the requirements the Directive, are very expensive it
will be economically preferable to export them for recovery abroad. Moreover the
consumers of recycled materials are not in Bulgaria but abroad.
44
For other types of waste (such as cookers and washing machines), it is possible to organize
very quickly treatment facilities (at the collection points or at existing collection and
recovery installations) that will ensure meeting of the recovery targets. In this way, the
actual average price for collection and recovery of WEEE could be reduced below 450 EUR
per tone.
V.1.6. Summary
Summarized information about the necessary funds for implementation of WEEE Directive
in Bulgaria is presented in the table below.
Type of expenses Comments
1. Development of 100’000 EUR This is an estimate of the initial costs for
legislative act and activities, that are essential for
Registry implementation of the Directive and which
shall be realized by 2006.
2. Registry annual 75’000 EUR This is an average estimate and includes
maintenance personnel, consumables, transportation,
technical support and other operational
costs.
3. Construction of 3’750’000 EUR 15 facilities for separate collection are
WEEE separate 250000 EUR per facility planned to be established in the first years
collection facilities of implementation
4. Operational costs 1’500’000 EUR There are 15 facilities for separate
for the WEEE 100’000 EUR per collection of WEEE.
separate collection facility It is assumed, that facility will process
facilities 150 EUR per tone about 650 tones WEEE per year
WEEE
5. Treatment of At the moment it is Export of WEEE for recycling will cost
separately collected impossible to about 635 EUR for 2006.
WEEE provide sound Recovery of WEEE in Bulgaria meeting
estimation for requirements of art. 7 (2) of the Directive is
neither capital nor possible only for some waste, not for all.
operational costs
V.2. Financing
In Bulgaria, financial obligations of stakeholders are stipulated in the Waste Management
Act. According to it, recovery and disposal costs are covered by:
1. waste holders;
2. entities, that place on the market products, forming at the end of their usage wide-spread
waste, pay product charges. The rate and way of payment of this charges is stipulated by
a legal act adopted by the Council of Ministers of Bulgaria. Product charges can be
waived if these legal entities prove to the Minister of Environment and Water that they
fulfill their obligations for separate collection and recovery according to the WMA and
its ordinances.
Forms for waiving product charges are individual implementation of obligations for
separate collection and recovery or collective schemes (recovery organizations) for WEEE
management. The latter approach has the following advantages:
- optimization of waste management costs;
- promotion of new, highly effective and economically viable technologies
for recovery and recycling of WEEE;
45
- control over the finances, put in the system by the producers;
- reaching the maximum high rate of re-use of components of WEEE (for
example if the producers use the recycled components in their maintenance centers).
Analyzing the possible options for financing, one must consider the difference that the
Directive set between “historical” and “new” WEEE, and between WEEE from households
and from other sources (business users).
46
the WEEE quantities that given Recovery organization or individual producer should
collect. Similarly, when the amount of product charges is determined for a given type of
equipment, not only the costs for collection of the WEEE generated during the current year
but the costs for collection and recovery of the “old” WEEE of the respective type as well
as the market share of the persons that put on the market the same type of equipment and at
the same time are members of Recovery organizations or fulfill their obligations
individually must be taken into account.
47
VI. REQUESTED TRANSITION PERIODS
The expected date for accession of Republic of Bulgaria to EU is 1st of January 2007.
Bulgaria requests the following transition periods:
§ Due to absence of specific legislative act and financial mechanisms for collection
of the necessary funds, the organization of systems for separate collection of
WEEE can not be realized before 31.12.2006.
§ There are no facilities for WEEE treatment – shredders, facilities for dismantling,
separation into material flows, separation of fluids and hazardous substances
§ There are no facilities for waste incineration with energy recovery, except cement
production plants, that should be reconstructed
§ The available capacity for material recycling is only for some of the material
streams – metal and depolluted and sorted glass.
48
§ Significant investments are necessary to establish facilities meeting requirements
set in art. 7 (2) and for development of waste collection systems and dismantling
centers.
49
VII. ACTION PLAN
The proposed Action plan covers the period 2005 – 2007 and includes the main measures and activities that have to be fulfilled in order to meet the objectives of
the implementation program of Directive 2002/96/EC and Directive 2002/95/EC. The structure of the Action plan is compiled with the targets and priorities listed
in the Program.
The target of implementation of this plan is to achieve optimum balance between the different legislation, institutional, economic and technical
measures and the implementation of an integrated approach for the management of WEEE. The plan defines the responsibilities of the different
institutions and organizations involved in the management of WEEE connected with the realization of the stated measures and activities, the
expected expenses and the sources of their financing.
1.1 Updating the code register so as to comply to the 31.03.2005 NSI Institution budget
activities connected with waste management and
particularly WEEE. 30.06.2005
Registration of all parties by the new codes is demanded.
1.2. Discussion on the possibility of starting a project for the 31.12.2004 MOEW
research of the current state of the life cycle of WEEE in
and out of the households in a model region
Starting a project for the research of the current state of 31.12.2004 MOEW 70 EMEPA
the life cycle of WEEE in and out of the households in
model region
51
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
1.3. Application of different prices for the treatment of WEEE permanent Operators of - -
according to the hazardous substances they contain treatment facilities
1.4. Coordinating the measures and activities on WEEE with 31.06.2005 MOEW - -
those on PCBs and PCTs according to the National
program for waste management 2003-2007
OBJECTIVE HEALTH PROTECTION
2
2.1 Introduction and control of restrictions of the use of Permanent after State Agency for - -
hazardous substances in EEE which become wide spread the enforcement Metrology and
waste of a legal act Technical
Surveillance
Commission for trade
and consumer
protection
2.2. Introduction of “cleaner technologies” in the industry 31.12.2007 BIA, Branch 100 Industry, External
associations financing
2.2.2 Training on using the developed technologies 31.12.2007 BIA, Branch 10 industry, External
associations financing
52
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
2.3. Defining the conditions when the distributors of EEE may 31.06.2005 Labor inspection
- -
waive take back of the WEEE in order to guarantee the MOEW
safety and health of their personnel with regulations about
WEEE
OBJECTIVE RATIONAL USE OF THE NATURAL RESOURCES TROUGH INCREASING OF THE RECYCLED AND RECOVERED
3 WEEE
3.1. Introduction of legal restrictions and prohibitions for the 31.12.2005 MOEW - -
discharge of WEEE in the stream of mixed municipal
waste
3.2. Discussing the possibilities for applying of financial 01.01..2005 MLSP, MEER, - -
measures for restriction of the import of second hand EEE MOEW, MF, ME
until Bulgaria joins the EU in order to meet the targets of
Directive 2002/96/EC for the recovery of the EEE
currently available in Bulgaria
3.3. Introduction of systems for separate collection of WEEE Permanent Producers and Up to 500 for Producers and
for its recovery importers the set up of a importers
Municipalities collection site
Up to 200 for
annual
operational
expenses per
site
3.4. Requirements about the separate collection and According the Municipalities, - -
transportation of WEEE should be included in the waste regulation Companies
management programs and municipal contracts on requirements
collecting and transportation of WEEE
53
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
3.5. Exploring the possibilities for recovery of different types 30.09.2005 Industry МРРБ, 25 EMEPA
WEEE MOEW,
3.6. Introducing of quantitative targets for the recovery of 31.12.2005 MOEW - -
WEEE, according to the Directive 2002/96/ЕС
3.7. The facilities for recovery of waste should be adapted into 31.12.2007 Operators of facilities Depending on Operators of
compliance with the environmental legislation and installations the facilities and
companies’ installations
programs for
WM
3.8. Supporting the construction of additional facilities for permanent Industry Depending of Private
recovery of waste and reconstruction of the currently EMEPA the investments,
existing installations (plastic waste, waste from ferrous companies’ EMEPA
and non ferrous metals, glass waste, textile waste, rubber programs
waste and other arising in the processing of WEEE) 4 000
annually for
low interest
credits
3.9. Construction of installations for the recovery of WEEE 31.12.2007 MOEW Private
Recovery investments
organizations External financing
EMEPA
3.10. Exploring of possibilities for introducing tax concessions 31.12.2007 MF, MOEW - -
and additional incentives for the recycling companies
54
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
55
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
5.2. Improving the control on the Implementation of the permanent RIEW, EEA - -
requirements for depositing of waste including monitoring
and penalties for the landfill operators who violate the
construction and operation requirements
5.3. Improving the control over the unauthorized disposal and permanent Municipalities, RIEW Municipal
incineration or other form of uncontrolled disposal of budgets incomes
WEEE from penalties
5.4. Identification of all companies whose activities require 31.12.2006 RIEW, EEA - -
permit for activities with WEEE
5.5. Issuing permits for activities with WEEE and controlling permanent RIEW, MOEW Industry, through
their implementation. the taxes for
Adding these permits to the Registry on WEEE licensing
OBJECTIVE LEGAL REGULATION OF THE WASTE MANAGEMENT AND ACCELERATION OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
6 THE LEGISLATION AND POLICY IN THIS FIELD
6.1. Transposing Directive 2002/96/EC and Directive 31.03.2005 MOEW 15 EMEPA
2002/95/EC and the EU decisions in the field of WEEE
management in the national legislation
6.2. Amendment of the municipal ordinances for the 31.12.2006 Municipalities - Municipal
collection storage and transportation of WEEE according budgets
to the targets of the national legislation
6.3. Updating the municipal programs regarding WEEE 30.09.2004 Municipalities - Municipal
management budgets
56
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
6.4. Developing of a methodology for defining and prognosis 31.12.2005 Municipalities, 20 EMEPA,
the quantity and morphological content of WEEE MOEW Municipal
budgets
6.5. Revising the regional development plans in order to set up 31.12.2005 Regional - -
regional treatment facilities for WEEE and administration
implementation of other initiatives connected with WEEE
management
57
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
7.4. Labeling of EE appliances in order to provide user 31.12.2006 Producers of EEE
information about the requirements that EEE should not
be illegally disposed
7.5 Gathering information from the producers about the Permanent Producers of EEE
components, materials and substances in EEE they
produce in order to facilitate the treatment and recovery of
WEEE and providing it to the treatment facilities
7.6 Getting information about the weight, amount of EEE put Permanent Operators of facilities
on the market in Bulgaria and collecting, reuse, recovery for the treatment of
and export of WEEE through which the meeting of WEEE, NSI, CA
objectives of the Directives are controlled
OBJECTIVE STRENGHTENING OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE CAPACITY OF THE INSTITUTIONS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE
8 WASTE MANAGMENT
8.1. Training of the experts in the RIEW to control, issued 31.07.2005 MOEW 10 (without STATE
permits and implementation of legislation of WEEE the costs for BUDGET,
management, including appointment of additional appointment External
personal of additional financing
personal)
8.2. Controlling the compliance with the permits for the Permanent after RIEW State budget
treatment of WEEE including periodical checks of the licensing (MOEW)
WEEE treatment facilities
8.3. Improving the municipal administrative capacity for Permanent Municipalities Municipal
control of the collection of WEEE from households budgets
including increasing personnel
58
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
8.4. Training the experts in the municipalities involved in the Permanent Municipalities 40 (annually) EMEPA, External
implementation of legislation of WEEE management MOEW financing
8.5. Regular national meeting and discussion of mayors, 31.12.2006 MOEW, 10 EMEPA
producers and importers of EEE and representatives of the MUNICIPALITIEWS
competent institutions on WEEE management
OBJECTIVE INCREASING THE INVESTMENTS IN THE SECTOR AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PRINCIPLES
9 “PRODUCER RESPONCIBILITY” AND “POLLUTER PAYS” IN THE SYSTEM FOR INTEGRATED WASTE
MANAGEMENT
9.1 Preliminary discussion of the proposed regulations with 01.03.2005 MOEW
the participation of all interested parties
59
No Measure/activity Deadline Responsible Expected Proposed source
(implementation institutions and expenditures of financing
period) organizations (thousands
BGL)
10.2. Publishing information on the problems of WEEE permanent MOEW, EEA 25 (annually) EMEPA,
management External
financing
10.3. Organizing an information campaign for the population, 31.12.2006 MOEW 10 for each EMEPA,
local authorities and business companies including the Producers and campaign Producers and
treatment centers operators about the proper treatment of importers importers, traders,
WEEE Municipalities External
financing
60
VIII. BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. A report on the accounting implications for producers and business users of Electrical
and Electronic Equipment of articles 8 and 9 (including potential amendment) of the
EU Directive on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment, KPMG, 14 November
2003
2. Assessment of Responses to the Second Consultation Document: WEEE and RoHS
Directives, www.erm.com, April 2004
3. Bulgaria Country Commercial Guide FY2001, Computer Hardware Market,
http://www.factbook.ro/countryreports/Bu_ComputerHware_mkt.htm, 04.08.2004
4. Discussion paper of 28 March 2003 by the UK Government, Scottish Executive,
Welsh Assembly Government, Northern Ireland Administration on the
Implementation of Directives of the European Council and Parliament 2002/96/EC of
27 January 2003 Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) & 2002/95/EC
of 27 January 2003 Restriction of the Use of Certain Hazardous Substances in
Electrical and Electronic Equipment (ROHS), Department of Trade and Industry, UK,
28 March 2003
5. Electrolux Sustainability Report 2003,
http://ir.electrolux.com/html/sustainabilityreport2003/index_8.phtml?header=print,
09.08.2004
6. Final Report Origin Quantity and Destination of PCB-containing Residues in
Bulgaria, Submitted by ARGUS – Statistik und informationssysteme in Umwelt und
Gesundheit GmbH, Berlin, BalBok Engineering Co, Sofia, IC-ISI Innovation Centre –
Iron & Steel Research Institute, Kremikovci, Berlin, October 2002
7. Guideline Disposal of White and Brown Goods Decree, Ministry of Housing, Spatial
Planning and the Environment Wastes Department, The Hague, 16 July 1998
8. Proceedings from: OECD Workshop on Extended & Shared Product Responsibility:
Economic Efficiency and Environment Effectiveness, Washington D.C., USA,
December 1-3, 1998
9. Report, WEEE & Hazardous Waste, prepared by AEA Technology, March 2004
10. Solutions for Implementation of the WEEE Directive into a national WEEE
regulation, RWE Umwelt Elektrorecycling GmbH, 16.08.2004
11. Technical report 65, Waste management facilities, Electronic catalogue, prepared by
Thomas Weibenbach, European Topic Centre On Waste, European Environment
Agency, Copenhagen, 2001
12. WEEE frequently asked questions about the household appliance industry’s appraisal
of Directive 2002/96/EC on WEEE, prepared by CECED, 22 January 2004
13. International Trade of Bulgaria 2003, NSI, Sofia, 2004
14. Local Authorities in Bulgaria 2003, NSI, Sofia, 2003
15. Environment 2002, NSI, Sofia 2004
16. Census 2001, Vol 1, Book 3, NSI, Sofia, 2002
61
17. Census 2001, Vol 1, Book 4, NSI, Sofia, 2003
18. Census 2001, Vol 1, Book 5, NSI, Sofia, 2003
19. Census 2001, Vol 2, Book 1, NSI, Sofia, 2003
20. Economic and Administrative Regions in Bulgaria 1997-2001, NSI, Sofia 2003
21. Statistical Year Book 2003, Data on 2002, NSI, Sofia 2003
22. Unified Classificatory of the administrative and territorial entities in Bulgaria, NSI,
Sofia 2001
23. NSI, Letter 336/05.08.2004 г.
24. Registry of MI, http://www.mi.government.bg/ind/lic/oochmc.html#restor,
16.08.2004
62
Annex 1
[kg.] [t.] [ %]
63
Copper 828079,11 828,0791 3,76%
Containing hazardous
substances 0 0 0,00%
64
Ozone depleting
substances 198843,673 198,8437 0,90%
65
Energy recovery 506383,814 506,3838 6,77%
66
Recycling 47181,4982 47,1815 12,89%
67
Disposal 37775,8935 37,77589 10,32%
68