You are on page 1of 7

Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845

https://doi.org/10.1007/s00402-021-04199-y

ORTHOPAEDIC SURGERY

Distal radius fracture with concomitant ulnar styloid fracture: does


distal radioulnar joint stability depend on the location of the ulnar
styloid fracture?
Kyung Wook Kim1 · Che Ho Lee2 · Jae Heouk Choi2 · Joong Mo Ahn3 · Hyun Sik Gong2,4

Received: 24 March 2021 / Accepted: 28 September 2021 / Published online: 7 October 2021
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2021

Abstract
Introduction  Studies are conflicting regarding the relationship between ulnar styloid fracture (USF) location and distal
radioulnar joint (DRUJ) instability in patients with distal radius fracture (DRF) and concomitant USF. The objective of this
study was to determine the association of USF location with TFCC foveal tear and factors associated with DRUJ instability
in patients with both DRF and USF.
Materials and methods  Fifty-four patients with both DRF and USF who had wrist MRI examination before surgery were
analyzed. USF location (tip or base) and TFCC foveal insertion status (intact, partial tear, or complete tear or avulsion with
fractured fragment) were evaluated. DRUJ stability was assessed intra-operatively after fixation of the radius. Factors poten-
tially associated with DRUJ instability, such as age, gender, USF location, USF fragment gap, radioulnar distance, radial
shortening, and TFCC foveal tear, were analyzed.
Results  Among 54 patients, 37 (69%) and 17 (31%) had USF at the base and the tip, respectively. In patients with base
fractures, TFCC foveal insertion was found to be disrupted in 89% (33/37) patients (complete tear in 11 and partial tear in
22) but intact in 11% (4/37). On the contrary, in patients with tip fractures, the insertion was found to be disrupted in 88%
(15/17) patients (complete tear in 2 and partial tear in 13) but intact in 12% (2/17). After fixation of the radius, total 52%
(28/54) patients showed DRUJ instability. Especially, DRUJ instability was found in 57% (21/37) of ulna styloid process
base fracture patients and 41% (7/17) of ulna styloid process tip fracture patients. In univariate analysis, complete tear of
TFCC foveal insertion and wider USF fragment distance were associated with DRUJ instability.
Conclusions  Tears of TFCC foveal insertion are common in patients with DRF and concomitant ulnar styloid base fractures.
Based on the findings of this study, tear of TFCC foveal insertion seems to be also common in patients with DRF and con-
comitant ulnar styloid tip fractures. And also, DRUJ instability seems to be associated with a TFCC foveal tear independent
of USF location.

Keywords  Distal radius fracture · Ulnar styloid fracture · Distal radioulnar joint · Triangular fibrocartilage complex ·
Foveal tear · Magnetic resonance imaging

* Hyun Sik Gong Introduction


hsgong@snu.ac.kr
1
Distal radius fracture (DRF) is one of the most common
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Dankook University fractures in the upper extremity [1]. Previous studies have
Hospital, Cheonan, South Korea
2
reported that concomitant ulnar styloid fracture (USF) and
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Seoul National combined triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) injury
University Bundang Hospital, Seongnam, South Korea
3
are present in 50–65% and 35–55% of patients with DRF,
Department of Radiology, Seoul National University respectively [2–4].
Bundang Hospital, Seongnam, South Korea
4
Because of its close association with TFCC, USF usu-
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Seoul National ally indicates the possibility of a TFCC tear [5], which can
University Bundang Hospital, Seoul National University
College of Medicine, 300 Gumi‑dong, Bundang‑gu, cause DRUJ instability in DRF and result in residual wrist
Seongnam‑si 463‑707, Gyeonggi‑do, Korea pain, decreased range of motion, and decreased grip strength

13
Vol.:(0123456789)

840 Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845

[6–8]. Moreover, Palmer et al. [9] have reported that USF


at the tip is stable as the TFCC foveal attachment is intact,
while USF at the base is unstable as TFCC foveal detach-
ment can occur. However, studies are conflicting regarding
the relationship between USF location and DRUJ instability.
Some recent studies have reported that DRUJ instability is
not associated with the presence of USF or the location of
it in DRF patients [10–12]. Instead, other study revealed
that DRUJ instability closely correlated with the TFCC tear
rather than USF [13]. Furthermore, another study noted the
association between DRUJ instability and TFCC foveal tear
through the anatomical reconstruction of the deep fibers of
the radioulnar ligaments using tendon grafts [14].
The purpose of this study was to determine the associ-
ation of TFCC foveal tear with USF location and factors
associated with DRUJ instability in patients with DRF and
concomitant USF. Fig. 1  Using plain radiograph, the base and tip fracture of the ulnar
styloid process was defined. The base fracture was defined as the
below of the reference line which is defined as the halfway between
Materials and methods the base and the distal tip of the ulnar styloid process. The tip fracture
was defined as the above of the reference line (dotted line: reference
line)
Patients

This study was approved by our institutional review board. according to the standard MR protocol for wrist imaging
Using an electronic medical data record program, consecu- in our hospital. Musculoskeletal section radiologists’ MRI
tive 207 patients with DRF were retrospectively reviewed readings were reviewed for TFCC lesions. Diagnostic cri-
between December 2016 and September 2019, and 141 of teria for TFCC tears were established in discussion with
them had both DRF and USF. Seventy-four of the 141 had radiologists. A complete foveal TFCC tear included loss of
MRI examination for further evaluation of the TFCC and the continuity of the foveal fiber or complete bony avulsion with
others did not due to reasons, such as difficulty of timing the the foveal insertion attached to the fracture fragment. Par-
examination before surgery, claustrophobia, or limitation of tial TFCC tear was diagnosed when abnormal intermediate
insurance coverage. Those who have a history of surgery signal intensity was detected on T1 SPIR images with high
or have inflammatory disease on their wrist were excluded. signal intensity on T2 FFE reaching one of articular surfaces
Finally, 54 patients with DRF and concomitant USF who of TFCC. Two orthopedic surgeons who were blinded to
had MRI examination were analyzed. The average age of operative findings classified tears according to the diagnostic
these patients was 56 years (range 25–80 years). There were criteria.
14 men and 40 women.
Assessment of DRUJ stability
Radiographic evaluation of USF and TFCC
During surgery, the radius fracture was exposed with a
USFs were classified based on fracture line morphology. palmar approach and fixed with locking plate and screws.
In this study, the base of ulnar styloid process was defined After fixation, one surgeon performed stress test to check
as the conjoined line perpendicular to the ulnar axis and for residual DRUJ instability and end-point sensation. The
through the ulnar styloid fovea, and the reference line was radius was grasped with the forearm in a neutral position
defined as the halfway between the base and the distal tip of by the surgeon. The distal ulna, which was fixed between
the ulnar styloid process. According to the location of the the surgeon's thumb and index finger, was moved in dor-
fracture line relative to the reference line, USF was divided sal and palmar directions with respect to the radius. The
into the ulnar styloid base or tip fractures. Tip fracture was test was positive if the ulna was conspicuously displaced
defined as a fracture of the distal parts of ulnar styloid pro- relative to the contralateral side [15]. When DRUJ insta-
cess (Fig. 1). USF fragment displacement, radial shortening, bility was found after fixation of distal radius, an ulnar
and coronal shift were also assessed (Fig. 2). styloid process fixation, TFCC repair or immobilization
All MR examinations were performed on a 3.0 T unit in a longarm splint for 4–6 weeks were performed. Basilar
(Achieva & Ingenia; Philips Healthcare, Netherlands) styloid fragments were fixed with tension band wiring and

13
Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845 841

Fig. 2  a Measurement of ulnar styloid fracture fragment displace- of radial shortening. Distance is measured from the volar or dorsal
ment. Lines are drawn each along the long axis of the ulnar styloid margin of the sigmoid notch of distal radius to the base line of the
proximal and distal fracture fragment. Displacement degree is meas- ulnar head. The base line is determined as the adjusted location com-
ured as the connecting line between the proximal end of the distal pared to the contralateral plain radiograph; c Measurement of radioul-
fragment and the distal end of the proximal fragment; b Measurement nar gap distance. The average of the shortest volar and dorsal distance

TFCC tears were repaired with two PDS sutures through Factors associated with DRUJ instability
a bone tunnel. DRUJ stability was restored after repairing
the USF or TFCC (Fig. 3). Out of 54 patients, 28 (52%) showed DRUJ instability
after radius fixation. Compared to those with stable DRUJ,
patients with unstable DRUJ were significantly more likely
Statistical analysis to have a TFCC foveal tear, and a wider USF fragment dis-
tance (Table 1). In addition, patients with unstable DRUJ
The integrity of TFCC foveal insertion and clinical fea- tended to be younger, an USF at the base, wider radioulnar
tures according to the USF type (tip or base) were com- distance and wider radial shortening than patients with sta-
pared. Categorical variables were compared with Chi- ble DRUJ. Especially, DRUJ instability was found in 57%
square test or Fisher's exact test. Continuous variables (21/37) of ulna styloid process base fracture and 41% (7/17)
were compared with Wilcoxon signed rank test. Poten- of ulna styloid process tip fracture. However, such differ-
tially associated factors with DRUJ instability, such as ences did not reach statistical significance.
USF location, TFCC foveal tears, USF fragment gap, In univariate analysis, complete tear of TFCC foveal
radial shortening, and radioulnar distance were analyzed. insertion and wider USF fragment distance were associated
Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed using with DRUJ instability. Factors with p < 0.05 in univariate
logistic regression to find factors associated DRUJ insta- analyses were entered into multivariate analysis. Results of
bility. Factors with p < 0.05 in univariate analyses were multivariate analysis indicated that DRUJ instability was
entered into multivariate analysis. Statistical power was only associated with complete tear of TFCC foveal inser-
calculated using statistical software R (version 4.0.1). tion (odds ratio: 14.7; 95% confidence interval 2.4–91.0;
p = 0.016) (Table 2). Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC)
for TFCC tear was 0.78 for intra-observer reliability and
0.62 for inter-observer reliability.
Results

TFCC foveal tear according to the type of USF Discussion

Among 54 patients, 37 (69%) had an ulnar styloid base Studies are conflicting regarding the relationship between
fracture and 17 (31%) had a tip fracture. In patients with USF location and DRUJ instability in patients presenting
a base fracture, TFCC foveal insertion was found to be both DRF and concomitant USF. Nakamura et al. [16] noted
disrupted in 33 (89%) patients (complete tear in 11, partial that the USF location is closely correlated with DRUJ insta-
tear in 22) but intact in four (11%). In patients with tip bility, but they focused mostly on the location of USF rather
fracture, TFCC foveal insertion was found to be disrupted than the effect of TFCC tear. On the contrary, Kim et al.
in 15 (88%) (complete tear in 2 and partial tear in 13) but [10] and Mulders et al. [11] mentioned that fracture level
intact in two (12%) (Table 1). of USF does not affect the stability of DRUJ, but in those

13

842 Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845

Fig. 3  a, b Pre-operative plain radiographs of a 33-year-old man tal radius fracture and concomitant ulna styloid base fracture. h Pre-
with distal radius fracture and concomitant ulna styloid tip fracture. operative MRI showed that foveal fiber of the TFCC was attached to
c Pre-operative MRI showed a TFCC foveal tear (asterisk). d, e Intra- the styloid fracture fragment. i, j Intra-operative DRUJ instability was
operative DRUJ instability was detected and stabilization of DRF detected. Stabilization of DRF by palmar locking plate and USF by
by palmar locking plate and open TFCC foveal repair were done. f, tension band wiring was done, and stability of the DRUJ was restored
g Pre-operative plain radiographs of a 25-year-old woman with dis-

studies, the location of USF was arbitrarily determined. can transmit through the broad TFCC foveal insertion and
Hence, compared to most of previous studies [10–12, 16, then through the ulnar styloid tip or can transmit from the
17], this study has significant advantages in that it identified ulnar styloid tip to the TFCC foveal insertion. In addition, it
the relationship between USF as well as TFCC foveal tear was found that DRUJ instability was associated with tear of
and DRUJ instability through imaging modality. Results of TFCC foveal insertion independent of USF location. There-
this study demonstrate that although tear of the TFCC foveal fore, the presence of an ulnar styloid tip fracture should not
insertion is more common and severe in patients with ulnar be regarded as a stable DRUJ in patients with DRF.
styloid base fracture, the tear is also common in patients Omokawa et al. [19] have reported that more than 5 mm
with an ulnar styloid tip fracture. Moreover, it demonstrates widening of DRUJ gap distance is the most important pre-
that DRUJ instability is associated with TFCC foveal tear dictor for DRUJ instability accompanying an unstable distal
independent of USF location. radius fracture. In addition, Kwon et al. [20] have reported
In the current study, TFCC foveal insertion was disrupted that initial distal radial shortening for more than 6.0 mm is
in 89% (33/37) of patients with ulnar styloid base fractures. one of risk factors of DRUJ instability. In this study, patients
Such result is expected in accordance with the anatomy of with unstable DRUJ tended to have wider radioulnar dis-
TFCC foveal insertion [18]. However, TFCC foveal inser- tance and wider radial shortening, although such difference
tion was also disrupted in 88% (15/17) of patients with ulnar was not statistically significant. It is assumed that even
styloid tip fractures and 41% (7/17) of them had DRUJ though the interosseous membrane which is another soft tis-
instability (Table 1). It is considered that the injury force sue stabilizer of the DRUJ can be injured or thin in patients

13
Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845 843

Table 1  Patient characteristics Overall Stable DRUJ Unstable DRUJ P value


and DRUJ stability
N 54 26 28
Ageª 58 [52–63] 60 [54–65] 58 [46–61] 0.068
Gender
 Men 14 5 9 0.279
 Women 40 21 19
Type of ulna styloid process fracture
 Tip 17 10 7 0.287
 Base 37 16 21
TFCC foveal tear
 No tear 6 6 0  < 0.001
 Partial tear 35 19 16
 Complete tear 13 1 12
Ulnar styloid process fracture fragment 2 [2–3] 2 [1–3] 2 [2–3] 0.048
distance (mm)ª
Radial shortening (mm)ª 4 [2–6] 4 [2–6] 4 [3–6] 0.465
Radioulnar distance (mm)ª 3 [3–5] 3 [2–4] 3 [3–5] 0.082

DRUJ distal radioulnar joint, TFCC triangular fibrocartilage complex;


ªmedian [IQR]

Table 2  Univariate and multivariate regression analyses for factors associated with DRUJ instability
Variable (event) Univariate analysis Multivariate analysis
OR 95% CI P value OR 95% CI P value

Age (year) 1.0 0.6–1.4 0.072


Gender (women) 0.5 0.2–1.4 0.283
Type of ulna styloid process fracture (base) 1.9 0.7–5.0 0.290
Presence of TFCC (complete foveal tear) 18.7 3.1–112.4 0.007 14.7 2.4–91.0 0.016
Ulnar styloid process fracture fragment distance (mm) 1.9 1.1–3.2 0.043 1.4 0.8–2.6 0.335
Radial shortening (mm) 1.1 0.9–1.3 0.387
Radioulnar distance (mm) 1.4 1.0–2.0 0.129

Boldface letters indicate significant value


OR odds ratio, CI confidence interval

with DRF and concomitant USF, it may prevent excessive patients, only who had MRI were included. Therefore, the
widening of radioulnar distance or radial shortening. selection bias caused by excluding patients without MRI
This study has several limitations. DRUJ instability could affect the incidence of the location of USF or the
assessment was performed only by physical examination, degree of the TFCC tear in the patient group. Moreover,
which could be subjective. However, clinical examination as only 54 (26%) of 207 patients had been finally enrolled,
has been used in previous studies [15]. It showed better it could significantly affect the validity of this study. And
correlation than imaging method and high interobserver more, the intra-operative stress test was conducted only in
reliability in the assessment of DRUJ instability [20]. neutral position. Performing stress test in neutral position
Besides, other soft tissue stabilizers for DRUJ were not as well as in full pronation or supination position could
considered. Recent cadaveric and biomechanical studies have been more accurate in identifying DRUJ instabil-
have reported that the distal oblique bundle or distal inter- ity. Finally, because of the lack of a unified perspective,
osseous membrane can act as a secondary stabilizer of the reference line of ulnar styloid fracture was arbitrarily
the DRUJ [21–23]. Although there was an effort to assess determined. Hence, if other classification method had been
its thickness in this study, it was not reliably identifiable used, there was a possibility that the type of fracture could
due to wave and destructive changes after fracture. Futher- have been changed.
more, in this study, Among DRF and concomitant USF

13

844 Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845

Conclusion worsening factor in distal radial fractures. Clin Orthop Relat


Res 376(376):229–235
4. Richards RS, Bennett JD, Roth JH, Milne K Jr (1997) Arthro-
Tears of TFCC foveal insertion are common in patients with scopic diagnosis of intra-articular soft tissue injuries associated
DRF and concomitant ulnar styloid base fractures. Based with distal radial fractures. J Hand Surg Am 22(5):772–776
on the findings of this study, tear of TFCC foveal inser- 5. Lindau T, Arner M, Hagberg L (1997) Intraarticular lesions
in distal fractures of the radius in young adults. A descriptive
tion seems to be also common in patients with DRF and arthroscopic study in 50 patients. J Hand Surg Br 22(5):638–
concomitant ulnar styloid tip fractures. It can be assumed 643. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1016/​s0266-​7681(97)​80364-6
that DRUJ instability due to a TFCC foveal tear is independ- 6. Geissler WB, Fernandez DL, Lamey DM (1996) Distal radioul-
ent of the USF location. Therefore, careful examination of nar joint injuries associated with fractures of the distal radius.
Clin Orthop Relat Res 327(327):135–146. https://​doi.​org/​10.​
DRUJ stability is recommended in patients with DRF and 1097/​00003​086-​19960​6000-​00018
concomitant USF regardless of its location. 7. May MM, Lawton JN, Blazar PE (2002) Ulnar styloid fractures
associated with distal radius fractures: incidence and implica-
Acknowledgements  We received statistical support from professor tions for distal radioulnar joint instability. J Hand Surg Am
Seung Hyun Won of Medical Research Collaborating Center (MRCC) 27(6):965–971. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1053/​jhsu.​2002.​36525
at Seoul National University Bundang Hospital. This study was sup- 8. Palmer AK, Werner FW (1981) The triangular fibrocartilage
ported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant complex of the wrist—anatomy and function. J Hand Surg Am
funded by the Korea government (Ministry of Science and ICT). 6(2):153–162. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1016/​s0363-​5023(81)​80170-0
9. Palmer AK (1990) Triangular fibrocartilage disorders: injury
Author contributions  All authors contributed to the study conception patterns and treatment. Arthroscopy 6(2):125–132
and design. Material preparation, data collection and analysis were 10. Kim JK, Koh Y-D, Do N-H (2010) Should an ulnar styloid frac-
performed by Kyung Wook Kim, Che Ho Lee, Jae Heouk Choi, Joong ture be fixed following volar plate fixation of a distal radial
Mo Ahn and Hyun Sik Gong. The first draft of the manuscript was fracture? J Bone Jt Surg Am 92(1):1–6
written by Kyung Wook Kim and Hyun Sik Gong. All authors read 11. Mulders MAM, Snethlage LJF, Keizer RJOM, Goslings JC,
and approved the final manuscript. Schep NWL (2018) Functional outcomes of distal radius frac-
tures with and without ulnar styloid fractures: a meta-analysis.
J Hand Surg Eur 43(2):150–157
Funding  This study was supported by the National Research Founda-
12. Quadlbauer S, Pezzei C, Jurkowitsch J et al (2020) Functional
tion of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Korea government (Ministry
and radiological outcome of distal radius fractures stabilized by
of Science and ICT) (Grant No. 2020R1A2C1005778).
volar-locking plate with a minimum follow-up of 1 year. Arch
Orthop Trauma Surg 140(6):843–852
Availability of data and materials  The data sets used and analysed dur- 13. Lindau T, Adlercreutz C, Aspenberg P (2000) Peripheral tears
ing the current study are available from the corresponding author on of the triangular fibrocartilage complex cause distal radioulnar
reasonable request. joint instability after distal radial fractures. J Hand Surg Am
25(3):464–468
Code availability  Not applicable. 14. Spies CK, Langer MF, Müller LP, Unglaub F (2020) Reconstruc-
tion of the deep fibers of the distal radioulnar ligaments facili-
tating a tendon graft-Adams’ procedure. Oper Orthop Traumatol
Declarations  32(3):262–270. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s00064-​019-​00638-7
15. Kim JP, Park MJ (2008) Assessment of distal radioulnar joint
Conflict of interest  On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author instability after distal radius fracture: comparison of computed
states that there is no conflict of interest. tomography and clinical examination results. J Hand Surg Am
33(9):1486–1492. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1016/j.​jhsa.​2008.​05.​017
Ethical approval  This study obtained institutional review board 16. Nakamura T, Moy OJ, Peimer CA (2021) Relationship between
approval from Seoul National University Bundang Hospital (SNUBH fracture of the Ulnar styloid process and DRUJ instability: a
IRB-B-2009/637-104). biomechanical study. J Wrist Surg 10(02):111–115
17. Quadlbauer S, Pezzei C, Jurkowitsch J et al (2018) Early com-
Consent to participate  Not applicable. plications and radiological outcome after distal radius fractures
stabilized by volar angular stable locking plate. Arch Orthop
Consent to publish  Not applicable. Trauma Surg 138(12):1773–1782
18. Kirchberger MC, Unglaub F, Muhldorfer-Fodor M et al (2015)
Update TFCC: histology and pathology, classification, examina-
tion and diagnostics. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 135(3):427–437
References 19. Omokawa S, Iida A, Fujitani R, Onishi T, Tanaka Y (2014)
Radiographic predictors of DRUJ instability with distal radius
1. Chung KC, Spilson SV (2001) The frequency and epidemiology fractures. J Wrist Surg 3(1):2–6. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1055/s-​0034-​
of hand and forearm fractures in the United States. J Hand Surg 13658​25
Am 26(5):908–915. https://​doi.​org/​10.​1053/​jhsu.​2001.​26322 20. Kwon BC, Seo BK, Im HJ, Baek GH (2012) Clinical and radio-
2. Fujitani R, Omokawa S, Akahane M, Iida A, Ono H, Tanaka Y graphic factors associated with distal radioulnar joint instability in
(2011) Predictors of distal radioulnar joint instability in distal distal radius fractures. Clin Orthop Relat Res 470(11):3171–3179.
radius fractures. J Hand Surg Am 36(12):1919–1925. https://​doi.​ https://​doi.​org/​10.​1007/​s11999-​012-​2406-4
org/​10.​1016/j.​jhsa.​2011.​09.​004 21. Arimitsu S, Moritomo H, Kitamura T, Berglund LJ, Zhao KD,
3. Lindau T, Hagberg L, Adlercreutz C, Jonsson K, Aspen- An K-N, Rizzo M (2011) The stabilizing effect of the distal
berg P (2000) Distal radioulnar instability is an independent interosseous membrane on the distal radioulnar joint in an ulnar

13
Archives of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery (2023) 143:839–845 845

shortening procedure: a biomechanical study. J Bone Jt Surg Am Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
93(21):2022–2030 jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
22. Kim YH, Gong HS, Park JW, Yang HK, Kim K, Baek GH (2017)
Magnetic resonance imaging evaluation of the distal oblique bun-
dle in the distal interosseous membrane of the forearm. BMC
Musculoskelet Disord 18(1):1–5
2 3. Watanabe H, Berger RA, Berglund LJ, Zobitz ME, An K-N (2005)
Contribution of the interosseous membrane to distal radioulnar
joint constraint. J Hand Surg Am 30(6):1164–1171

13

You might also like