COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

S.NO STUDY ANALYSIS MAHATMA PHULE MANDAI, PUNE ABU DHABI CENTRAL MARKET INFERENCE

PROJECT DETAILS
• CLIENT GOVERMENT OF UNITED ARAB EMIRATES MUNCIPLE CORPORATION OF KALABURAGI
PUBLIC
A
• ARCHITECT WALTER DUCAT , VASUDEV KANITKAR FOSTER + PARTNERS
• YEAR OF ESTABLISHMENT 1882 2014 2023
AREA DESCRIPTION
• TOTAL SITE AREA 46,068.67 sq ft (4,279.919 m2 ) - 105 ACRES 689416 m2 – 170 ACRES 7 ACRES

B
• BUILT UP AREA 36,000 sq ft --- -

• FLOOR SPACE INDEX 70% --- COVERAGE AREA - 55%

LOCATION
• CITY SHUKRAWAR PETH, PUNE MAHARASHTRA INDIA ABU DHABI , UNITED ARAB EMIRATES KALABURAGI, KARNATAKA, INDIA

C • CONNECTIVITY AIRPORT -30KM AIRPORT – 36KM RAILWAY STATION – 7 KM

RAILWAY STATION – 4KM RAILWAY STATION – 5.4KM AIRPORT – 17 KM
MUNICIPAL TRANSPOSRT BUS STATION – 0.5KM TRANSPORT BUS STATION – 1KM TRANSPORTION BUS STATION - 11KM
BUS RAPID TRANSIT SYSTEM – 2KM METRO STATION – 5.4KM
AT THE SITE LEVEL
• ACCESSIBILITY (ACCESS TO THE SITE) AMBRELLA ROAD AL HISN ROAD RAM MANDIR ROAD

• SITE ENTRANCES AND EXITS THERE ARE 8 ENTRY AND EXIT TO THE MARKET TOTAL MAIN 6 ENTRY\EXIT
AND 2 SERVICE ENTRY\EXIT

• ORIENTATION NORTH-SOUTH DIRECTION SOUTH – EAST DIRECTION NORTH SIDE

• TOPOGRAPHY FLAT LAND BROWN SAND PLAIN LAND WITH SOME VEGETATION

• SITE SURROUNDING THE SITE IS SURROUNDED WITH MORE OF RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL THE LAKE PARK – 0.8KM
AREAS. HERITAGE PARK – 0.4 KM RAM AMNDIR-0.5KM
NMC SPECILATY HOSPITAL – 0.8 KM ATHARVA HOTEL 0.3KM
D DHANVANTRI HOSPITAL 0.1KM

• MOVEMENT MODES ( VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN) ROAD AND PATHWAYS ARE THE SAME. SEPARATE MODES
• WIDTH OF INTERNAL ROADS 3-4METRES ----

• SOIL CONDITION LOUSE SANDY SOIL BLACK SOIL

• SITE USAGE (ZONING OF SITE , ACTIVITY DISTRIBUTION) IT IS USED AS PUBLIC MARKET COMMERCIAL SHALLOW AND LATERICTIC SOIL
• PARKINGS TOWARDS EAST SIDE. UNDER GROUND PARKING 5% OF TOTAL LAND
4 WHEELER 2.5 X 5.5M
DRIVEWAY MINIMUM 2.5M WIDE
175 SQ.M OF FLOOR AREA
PARKING CAN BE PROVIDED AT SETBACK
AT BUILDING LEVEL
• BUILDING ENTRANCES THERE ARE 8 ENTRANCES FOR THE MARKET. MAIN ENTRANCE ON SOUTH EAST SIDE

• NO OF BLOCKS ONE BLOCK THE BUILDING IS DIVIDED IN 2 BLOCK

E
• NO OF FLOORS GROUND FLOOR G+4 FLOORS
• CIRCULATION (INTERNAL H&V) THE INTERNAL CONNECTIONS ARE LIKE OLD CITY ROADS

• VOIDS (CHARACTER OF OPEN SPACES)

ARCHITECTURAL FEATURES
CONSIDERING ALL THE ARCHITECTURE FEATURES OF THE MARKET IS DESIGN THE PERFORATIONS IN THE ROOF AND INTERIOR PANELS
F • BUILDING GEOMETRY AND LAYOUT
VERY WELL BUILDING. THE BUILDING IS TOTALLY USED OF LOCALLY AVAILABLE A PATTERN DEVELOPED WITH A SCHOLAR OF ISLAMIC ARTS
MATERIALS , A LOCAL STONE EXPOSED WALLS AND MANGLORE TILES ON ROOF CONTINUE OUTSIDE, WRAPPING THE PODIUM BUILDING IN A TEXTURED
• BUILIDNG MATERIALS
ONLY TWO MATERIALS ARE USED FACADE.THE DESIGN OF THE PANELS IS BASED ON OCTAGONAL FORMS.

SIGN DRG NO :
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN - VIII
SHEET NO : B.ARCH VII SEM A
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
DATE : DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE PDSSA