Professional Documents
Culture Documents
magazine which gives details of all the week's radio and television
programmes. In April 19 94 it subtitled its int roduc tion to a pro -
gramme wh ich previewed that year's entries for the Eurovisio n Song
Cont est as ' tips fo r Ie top'. Notice th e ' le'. It is an indicatio n of the
apparently w idespread assum ption that Euro pe is a place w here
eve rybody speaks Fren ch.
Th e British co ntinue to be very bad about learning o the r pe oples '
languages. Fluency in any European lan guage other than English is
generally regarded as exo tic. But there is not hing defensive or deliber-
ate about thi s att itu de . The British do not refuse to speak other
languages. They are just lazy.
QUE STIO N S
I In the early years of th e twentieth century. the on how you define it, is used in everyday speech
playwright and soc ial commentator George by o nly 3% to 12% of the population. So wh y
Bernard Shaw re m arked that an English man only is standard English w ith an RP accent the usu al
had to open his mouth to make some other m odel for people learning British English as a
Englishman despise him . What wa s he talking foreign language ? What justificati on can yo u
about' Would he say th e sam e thing toda y' find for thi s pra ctice '
2 In the 19 30S people in middle-class ne ighbour- 4 Do the social classes in yo ur co unt ry differ enti -
hoods o ften reacted angrily to th e building of ate them selves in the same ways as they do in
ho using estates for the wor king class nearby. In Britain? Do language, accent, clothes, money,
one area they even built a w all to separate the habi ts and attitu des play the sam e ro les in your
two neighbourhood s I Thi s co uld never hap pen co untry?
to day . Why not' W hat has cha nged? , Th is chapter considers several factor s that can go
3 Standard English is used ' naturally' in everyday towards creating a person 's sense of identity.
speech by between 1,% and 30 % of rhe popula- Some of these are m ore important in Britain and
lion in Britain (it depends how you define it). some are less important. Are the same factors
Recei ved pronunciation (RP), again depending the im portam o nes in yo ur co untry?
SU G G ESTI ON S
5
Attitudes
.. Land o f tradition The British , like the peop le of every country, tend to be attributed
A reputation for tradition can lead to
w ith certain characteristics which are supposedly typical. However,
its artificial preserv ation - o r eve n it is best to be cautious about accepting such characterization s too
its re-introduction. A notable easily, and in the case of Britain there are three particular reason s to
example is the Asquith taxi. This wa s be cautio us. The first three sections of this chapter deal w ith them in
introduced onto the streets of turn and com ment on several stereotyped imag es o f the British.
London in 1994. It is an exact replica
of Lo ndon taxis of the 19 305
(ex cept, of course, that it has Stereotyp es and chan ge
modern facilities - and a m o dern
Societies change over time w hile their reputation s lag behind . Many
mctcrl). It is deliberately des ig ne d
that vvay to appeal to tourists, w ho
thin gs w hic h are often regarded as typically British derive fro m
equate London with traditi on. bo oks , so ngs or plays w hich were wri tten a long time ago and w hich
Similarly , w hen Lo ndo n's fam ou s are no longer representative o f modern life. One exam ple of this is
red buses w ere privatize d (sol d to the popu lar belief that Britain is a ' land of tradi tion ' . Thi s is what
private companies) in the early
most tourist bro chur es claim (I> Land of tradi tion). The claim is based
199°5, the differen t bus companie s
on what can be seen in public life and on centuries of political con -
wanted to paint their buses in their
company co lours . The go vern me nt tinui ty. And at this level - the level of public life - it is undoubtedly
ruled that all buses had to Slay red true. The annual ceremony o f the state opening of Parliam en t, for
because that is what the peop le o f instance , carefully follow s customs which are centuries old (see
London wanted, and that is wh at the chapter 9) . So does the military ceremony of ' trooping the colour '.
government believed would help
Likewise, the cha nging of the gu ard outside Bucking ham Palace
the tourist trade .
never changes.
How ever , in their private eve ryday lives, the British as individuals
are pro bably less incl ine d to follow traditio n than are the people of
most othe r co untries. There are very few ancient customs that are
followed by th e m ajor ity of fam ilies on spec ial occa sion s. The
co untry has few er local parades or processio ns wit h genuine folk
ro ots than most other co untries have. The Engli sh language has fewer
sayings or pro verbs that are in common everyda y use than many
o ther languages do . The British are too individualistic for these
thi ng s. In addition , it should be not ed that they are the most enthusi-
astic vide o-watching people in the w orld - the very opposite of a
tradition al pastime !
The re are m any exam ples of supposedly typical Briti sh habits
w hich are simply not typ ical any more. For exam ple, the stereotyped
An Asquith taxi
image of the London 'ci ty gent' in clu des the wearing of a bow ler hat.
In fact, this type of hat ha s not bee n commonly worn for a lo ng time.
Foo d and drink provide other exam ples. The traditiona l 'Bri tish' (or
... Swots parents to arrange extra pr ivate tuition for thei r ch ildren, even among
The slang word 'swot' was first used those who can easily afford it.
in publi c schools (see cha pter 14)" Anti -inte llec tual att itu des are held consciou sly only by a small
It describes someone wh o w or ks pro portion of the po pulation, but an indication of how deep they
hard and does well acade mically" It ru n in society is that the y are reflected in the English language. To
is a term of abuse" Swots are not verr refer to a per son as somebo dy who 'gets all their ideas from books'
popular. In the English mind. schol-
is to spe ak of them ne gatively. The word 'clever ' o ften ha s nega tive
arship is something rather strange
and exotic. so much so that the sight connot ations. It suggests some one who uses tricker y, a person w ho
of the ma nager of a footb all team cannot quit e be tru sted (as in the expression ' too clever by hal f ')
simply wr iung so met hing down (t- Swots).
during a match is considered worth y Evidence of thi s attit ude can be found in all four na tion s of the
of comment. During the 1990
British Isles. How ever, it is probably bett er seen as a specifically
English football Cup Final. when he
saw this happening. the BBC com- English characteristic and not a British one. The Scottish have alw ays
mentator said (Witham apparent placed a high value on education for all classes. The Irish of all classes
iron}"). 'And }"OU can see Steve place a high value on being qui ck , read y and able w ith words. The
Coppell's been 1O university - he's Welsh are fam ou s for exporting teacher s to other pans of Britain
takin g notes !'
and beyond .
Multicultura lism
The third reason for caution about gen eralizations relates to the large-
scale immigration to Britain from places outside the British Isles in
the twentieth cent ur y (see chapter 4). In its citi es at least , Britain is a
m ulticult ural socie ty. There are areas of london , for exam ple , in
w hich a distinctively Ind ian w ay of hfe predominates, w ith Ind ian
shops, Indian clothes, Indian langu ages. Because in the local schools
up to 90 % of the pupils may be Indian , a distinctively Ind ian style of
learning tends to take place.
These 'new British ' people have bro ugh t w idely di ffering sets of
attitudes with them . For example, while som e seem to care no more
about education for their children than people in tradi tional Eng lish
culture, ot her s seem to care about it a great deal more.
How ever , the diver gen ce from in di genous British attitudes in new
British com m un ities is constantly narrow ing. These com m unities
some times have their own newspapers but none have the ir own TV
stati on s as they do in the United States. Th ere, the nu mber s in such
com m un ities are larger and the physical space betwe en them and
othe r com m un ities is grea ter, so that it is possible for people to live
their w ho le lives in such comm un ities without ever really learning
Eng lish. Thi s har dly ever happens in Britain.
It is therefore still possibl e to talk abou t British characteristics in
gen eral (as the rest of thi s chapter does) . In fact, the new British have
made their ow n cont ribu tion to British life and attitudes. They have
probably he lped to make people more informal (see below ) ; they
have chan ged the na ture of the 'corner shop ' (see chapter 15) ; the
m ost popular, we ll-attende d festival in the whole of Britain is the
annual NOlting Hill Carn ival in London at the end of Augu st, w hich
is of Caribbean inspiration and origin .
The Briti sh ha ve few living folk traditions and are too individ ualistic Lord Snooty illustrates the enthusi -
asm of British children for charac -
to have the sam e everyday habi ts as each other. Ho wever, th is does
ters from earlier times. He first
not mea n that they like change. Th ey do n' t. They m ay no t beh ave in appeared in the Beano, a chil dren's
tradi tio nal wa ys, but they like sym bo ls of tradi tion an d stability. For comic, in 19 38 . He is a you ng
example. there are some very untraditional attitudes and habits wi th English ar istocrat aged abo ut ten.
regard to th e famil y in m odern Britain (see cha pter 4) . Neverthele ss, w ho loves sneaking out of his castle
to play with local village children.
po lit icians often cite their ent hus iasm for 'traditional fam ily values '
He has always worn the same
(bot h parents m arr ied and living together. parents as th e main so urce
clothes. typical of wealthy young -
of aut honty for ch ild re n etc) as a way o f winning su pport. sters of an earlier age but by now out
In gen eral. the British valu e con tin u ity over modernity for its own of date. Surely. the children of the
sake. Th ey d o not co nside r it especially sm art to live in a new house 1990S wo uld prefer a present -day
and , in fact , th er e is prestige in livin g in an obviously old one (see hero wit h whom to iden tify? That is
wh at the ed itors of the Beanothought.
chapter 19) . They have a general sen timent al attachmen t to o lder,
In 199 2 they decided to give Lord
sup posed ly safer, tim es. Their Christmas cards usuall y depi ct scenes Snooty a rest. But loud protest fol-
fro m past centuries (see chapter 23); they like the ir pubs [ 0 loo k old lowed , and he quickly found a new
(see chapter 20) ; they we re relu ctant to chan ge their system of cur- job in The funday Times (the children's
rency (see chap ter 15). comic which is issued with The
Moreover, a look at ch ild ren's reading habits su ggests that this Sunday Timesnewspaper) . as well as
making further appearances in the
attitu de is not go in g to change. Publishers tr y hard to make their Beano.
books for child ren up -to -d ate. But perhaps the y needn't tr y so hard .
In 19 92 th e two m ost popular children '5 writers were noticeably
un -rnodern (they were bo th, in fact, dead ) . The m ost popula r of all
was Roald Dah l, w hose fantasy stories are set in a rat her o ld -
fashioned w orld. The seco nd m ost popular wr iter was Eni d Blyton,
whose stories take place in a co m fo rtable whi te m idd le-cla ss world
before the 19 605. Th ey co nt ain no references to other races or classes
and m ention nothing m ore modern than a radi o . In other words,
they are m ostly irrele vant to m odern life (Do Lord Snooty) .
Bein g different
Lord Snooty
The British can be parti cul arl y and stub bo rn ly co nser vative abo u t :0 0 C ThOJmon & Co lId 1989
anyth ing which is perceived as a to ken of Britishness. In these
matters, their co nservatism can combine wit h the ir individualism;
th ey are rath er proud of being different. It is , for example , ver y
diffi cult to imagine that the y will ever agree to change from driving
on the left -ha nd side of th e road to driving o n the right. It doesn 't
matter that nobody can think of any intrinsic ad vantage in driving on
the left. Why sho uld they change just to be like eve ryone else? Ind eed,
as far as they are concerned , not being like everyone else is a good
reas o n not to change.
Development s at European Un ion (EU) level which migh t cause
a change in so m e everyday aspect of British life are usually greeted
with su spici on and hostilit y. The case of double- decker buses (see
chapter 17) is an exam ple. Whenever an EU committee makes a
recommend ati on about standa rd izing th e size and shape of the se , it
pro voke s warn ings fro m British hus builders about 't he en d of the
double-decker bus as we know it ' . The British pu blic is alwa ys ready
1O listen to such predictions of doom .
Systems of measu rem ent are another exam ple. The Briti sh gove rn-
ment has been trying for years and years 1O prom ot e the metric
system and to get British peop le to use the same scales that are used
nearly everyw he re else in the world . But it has had only limited
success. British m anu factur er s are obliged to give the we ight of their
tins and packets in kilos and grams. But everybo dy in Britai n still
sho ps in pound s and ounces (see chapt er 15). The we athe r forecaster s
on the telev ision use the Celsius scale of temper atur e. But nearly
everybody still think s in Fahr enheit (see chapter 3) . British people
continue to measur e distances, amounts of Ii quid and the mselves
using scales of measurem ent that are not used anywher e else in
Eur ope (0- HoII' for? HOIl' big' HoII' much ') . Even the use of the 24 -hou r
cloc k is comparatively restricted .
British government s sometimes seem to promote this pride in
being d ifferent. In 199 3 the ma nagers of a pub in Slou gh (w est of
Londo n) started selling glasses of beer which they called 'swi fts'
(25 el) and ' larges' ( 50 el) , sm aller amounts than the traditional
... H ow far? H ow big? How much?
British equivalents of half a pi nt and a pint. You might th ink that the
Distances on road signs in Britain are au thor ities would have been pleased at thi s voluntary effort to ado pt
sho wn in mile s, not kilome tres, and
European habit s. But they we re not. British law dem ands that drau ght
peo ple talk about yards, not m etres.
If you described yours elf as being
beer be sold in pi nts and half-p in ts only. The pu b was fined £3, I 00
J 63 tall and we ighi ng 67 kilos a
by a court and was ordered to stop selling the 'continental' measur es.
British person w ould not be able to British gover nm ents have so far resisted pressur e from business people
im agine what you looked like. You to adop t Central European Tim e, rem ain ing stubbornly one hou r
would have [0 say you were 'five behind, and they contin ue to start their financial year not , as othe r
foot four' ( s feet and + inche s tall)
countries do , at the beginning of the calend ar year but at the
and weighed ' ten sto ne seven ' or
't en and a half stone' ( 10 stone and begi nn ing ofApril!
7 pounds). British peopl e th ink in
pounds and ounces wh en buying
their che ese, in pims w he n bu ying The love of nature
their m ilk and in gallons when
buying th eir pet rol. Americans also Most of the Briti sh live in towns and cit ies. But the y have an idealized
use this non -m etric system of visio n of the count ryside . To the British, the co unt ryside has almost
weights and m easures. non e of the ne gative associatio ns which it has in som e cou ntries,
Imperial Metric such as poor facilit ies, lack of ed uca tiona l oppo rtunities. unem ploy -
ment and povert y. To them , the countryside means peace and qui et,
I inch 2.54 centimetres
beauty, good health and no crime. Most of them would live in a
12 inches ([ foot) JO .48centimetres
count ry village if they thought tha t they could find a w ay of earn ing
3 feet ([ yard) 0. 9 2metres
1760 yards {t mile) 1.6 kilometres a livin g the re. Ideally, th is village would consist o f thatche d co ttag es
[ ounce 28.35 grams (see chapter I 9) built around an area of grass know n as a 'village
[6 ounces ([ pound) o.+S- 6 kilograms green ' . Nearby, the re would be a pond w ith ducks on it. Nowadays
[+ pounds ( I stone) 6.38 kilograms suc h a village is not actuall y very common , but it is a stereotypical
[ pint o.cstnres
picture that is w ell- kno wn to the British .
2 pints (I quar t) r.r e lnres
8 pints ( I gallon) +.6+lures
Some history conne cted with the building o f the Channel tunnel
(see chapter 17) provides an ins tructive exam ple of the British
attitude. While the 'chunnel ' was bein g built , there were also plans Ill- The Nati o nal Trust
to build new high-speed rail lin ks o n eit her side of it. But what route A not able ind icatio n of the British
would these new railway lin es take ? On the French side of the reverence fo r bot h th e co un tryside
cha nnel, co m munities battled w ith each ot her to get the new line and the past is the stre ng th o f the
built through their tow ns. It would be good for loca l bu siness. But National Trust. This is an officially
recognized charily whose aim is to
o n the Eng lish side, the oppos ite occurred. No body wanted the rail
preserve as much of Britain 's coun-
lin k nea r them ! Commun ities battled w ith each other to get the new tryside and as m an y of its histo ric
line bu ilt so m ew here else . Never mind about business, they wanted buildings as possible by acquiring
1O preserve their peace and quiet. them ' for the nat ion'. Wi th m ore
Perhaps thi s love of the countryside is another aspect of British than one-and -a-half m illion
conservatism. The countryside represents stability. Those who live me mbers, it is the largest conserva -
tio n org ani zation in the wo rld . It is
in to w ns and cities take an active interest in country ma tter s and th e
actuall y the third largest lando wner
British regard it as both a right and a pr ivilege to be ab le to go 'into in Britain (after the Crown and the
the co un try' w he never they wa nt to . Large area s of th e country are Forestry Commission ). It owns
official ' national parks' w he re almost no bu ilding is allowed . There more than /jOO mile s of th e coast-
is an organ ization to w h ich th o usands of enthusiastic co unt ry wal kers line . The im po rtance of its work has
belong , the Ram blers' Associa tion. It is in co ns tant batt le w ith land- been supported by several laws,
among wh ich is one wh ich doe s not
owners to keep open the pub lic 'rights of way' across the ir lan ds.
allow even the government to take
Maps can be bought which mark , in great detail, the routes of all th e over any of its land without the
public footpath s in the country. Walkers often stay at youth hostels. approval of Parliament .
The Yo uth Hostels Association is a charity whose aim is 'to help all,
especially young people of lim ited m ean s, to a gre ater kno wl ed ge,
love and care of the co untrys ide '. Th ei r hostels are cheap and rat her
self- co nsc iously bare and sim ple. There are more than 300 of them
around th e co untry, m ost of them in th e midd le of nowhere !
Even if they cannot get in to the co untrys ide, ma ny British people
still spend a lot o f their tim e w ith 'nat ure' . They grow plants. Gar -
denin g is one of the most popular ho bbies in the country. Even those
unlucky people who do not have a garden can pa rticipate. Each local
au thority o w ns several areas ofland w hich it ren ts very cheaply to
these people in sm all pa rce ls. O n these' allo tments', peo ple grow
mainly vege tab les.
Allotments in London
the streets with his tie round his waist and his collar unbuttoned. He ...Th e scruffy Briti sh
is no longer 'at work ' and for his employers to criticize him for hi s The British are comparatively unin -
appearance would be seen as a gross breach of privacy. Perhaps terested in clo thes. They spend a
because of the clo thing forma lities that many peop le have to follow low er prop o n io n of their inco me on
during the week, the British , unlike the peo ple of m any o ther cou n- cloth ing than peopl e in most othe r
European co un mcs do . Many people
tries, like to 'dress down' on Sundays. They can 't w ait to take off their
buy second-ha nd clot hes and arc
respectab le working clothes and slip in to something really scru ffy. not at all em barrassed to admit this.
Lots of men wh o wear suits during the week can then be seen in old If rou are somewhere in a Mediter -
sw eaters and jeans, so metimes with hol es in them . And male politi - ranean holiday area it is usually
cians are keen to get themselves photographed not wearing a tie possible to identify the British
wh en 'officially' on holiday, to show tha t they are really ordinary tourist - he or she is the one who
looks so badly dressed!
people.
This difference between formalities and formality is the key to
w hat people from other countries some times experience as a
cold ness among the British . The key is this: being friendly in Britain
ofte n involves sho w ing that you are no t bo thering w ith the formalit-
ies. This means not addressing som eone by his or her title (Mr, Mrs,
Profe ssor etc) , not dressing smartly when entertaining gue sts, not
shaking hands when meeting and not saying 'please' wh en making a
request. When they avoid doing these things with you , the British
are not being unfriendly or disrespectful, the y are implying that you
are in th e category 'friend' , and so all the rules can be ign ored. To
address someone by hi s or her title or to say 'please ' is to observe
for m alities and therefore to put a distance betw een the peop le
involved. The same is true of shaking hands. Altho ugh this sometimes
has the reputation of being a very British thing to do , it is actually
rather rare. Most people would do it on ly when being introdu ced to
a stranger or when me eting an acquaintance (but not a friend) after
a long tim e. Sim ilarly, most British peopl e do not feel welcomed if.
on being invited to some body 's house, they find the ho sts in smart
clothes and a grand table set for them . They do not feel flattered by
this, the y feel intimidated. It makes them feel they can 't relax.
It is probably true that th e British , especially the En glish, are more
reserved than the people ofmany other co un tries. They find it compar-
atively difficult to indicate friendship by open displays of affection.
For example, it is no t the convention to kiss w hen meeting a friend.
Instead , friendship is symbolized by behaving as casually as possible.
If you are in a British person 's house , and you are told to ' help
yourself' to some thin g, your ho st is not being rude or suggesting
tha t you are of no importance - he or she is sho wing tha t you are
com pletely accep ted and just like 'one of the family'.
In the last decades of the twent ieth cent ury, the general amo unt of
info rma lity increased. Buffet-type mea ls, at w hich peop le do no t sit
down at a table to eat, are now a co mmon form of hosp italit y.
At the same time , the tradition al reserve has also been breaking
down. More group s in society now kiss when meeting each other
(wom en and women, and men and women, but still never men
and me n!) .
Respect for privacy underlies many aspects of Briti sh life. It is not just The British are always talking about
the weather. Unlike many othe rs.
privacy in your own hom e w hich is important (see chapter 19) . Just
this stereotype is act uall y true to life.
as im portant is the indi vid ual's rig ht to keep in formation about But constant remarks about the
himse lf or herse lf private. De spite the incr ease in informality, i t is weather at chance meetings are not
still seen as rud e to ask people what are called ' personal' question s the result o f polite con ventions.
(for example, about how mu ch money they earn or about their famil y They are not obligatory. Rather, they
or sex life) unless you kn ow them very well. No tice that the conven- are the result of the fact that, on th e
one hand , to ask personal questions
tional formula on being introduced to some one in Britain , ' how do would be rude while, at the same
you do ?', is not interpreted as a real request for infor mation at all; time, silence would also be rude .
the conventional rep ly is not to 'answ er the que stion' but to reply The wea ther is a very co nvenient
by saying 'how do you do " too. topic w ith which to 'fill the gap' .
The modern British attitude to sex is an example of how, while
moral attitudes have cha nged , the hab it ofkeeping things private is ... Blind Date
still dee ply ing rained. British (like Am erican) publi c life has a reputa- Blind OGle is a ,wy popula r television
tion fo r dema nd ing pu ritanical standards of behaviour. Revelation s programme. In it, a member of one
about ext ra-marital affairs o r ot her deviatio ns from what is cons id- sex asks three mem bers of the
oppo site sex (w hom he or she
ered normal in pr ivate life have, in the past, ruined the careers of
cannot see) questions and then
many public figures. Thi s would seem to indi cate a lack of respect for chooses wh ich o ne to go OUI With.
privacy and that the Briti sh do not allow their politi cians a pri vate The que stions and answers are
life . However, appearances in th is matt er can be m isleading. In m o st always full of sexual innuendo. The
of these cases , the di sgrac e of the po litician co ncerned has n ot been audience lo ves it.
On one show in 19 9 3, one of thc
becaus e of h is sexual activity. It has happen ed because this activity
po ssible blind dates was a German
was m ixed up with a ma tter of natio nal sec urity. or invol ved breaking girl. In con versation with the sho w 's
the law or indicated h ypocri sy (in actin g agains t the stated policy of host, her kno wledge o fl anguages
the politician's part y) . In other words, the pri vate sexual activity had came up. The girl said, 'My teacher
a direct relevance to the po liti cian 's public role . The scandal wa s that told me that the qu ickest w ay to
in the se cases , the politicians had not kep t their private lives and learn a forei gn language is to have
sex with a native speaker. And you
public role s separate enough . W hen no such connec tio ns are
know, it really works!' Uproar!This
involved , there are no negative consequen ces for the politicians. In remark caused the loudest audience
fact when , in 199 2, a leading politician ann ounced that five years reaction , the most hysterical laughs,
previou sly he had had an affair with his secretary, hi s popularity which the sho w had ever known.
actually incr eased! The show 's popularity is precisely
because sex is possibl y on the
In 199 2 a million copies of very explicit and realistic videos with
agenda, bur this was the first time
titles such as SuperVirility, Better Sex, The Gay Man's Guide (0 Safer Sex and that anyone on the programme had
The Lovers' Guide w ere so ld in Britain. There wa s some de bate about actually admitted to having sex. Very
whe ther they sho uld be banned. However, an opinion poll showed uri- British!
that the British pu blic agreed that they were not 'porno graphic' but
'e ducat ional' . Three out of four of those asked were happy for the
video s to be freely on sale. Examples such as this suggest that mod ern
Briton s have a positive and open attitude to sex. However, they
continue to regard it as an absolutely private matter. Sex may no
lon ger be ' bad ' , but it is still em barr assing. Take the example of sex
educat ion in schools. Partly because of worries about AIDS, thi s is
no w seen as a vital part o f the schoo l curriculum . It is the legal
responsibi lity o f schools to teach it. However, research in the early
The television programme 'Blind Date'
I 990S sugges ted that little o r no sex educatio n w as taking place in