You are on page 1of 10

PROSPECT OF TRANSPORT DEMAND MANAGEMENT

STRATEGIES TO MANAGE TRAFFIC CONGESTION IN DHAKA

Tanweer HASAN Md. Mizanur RAHMAN


Professor Associate Professor
Department of Civil Engineering Department of Civil Engineering
Bangladesh University of Engineering Bangladesh University of Engineering &
& Technology (BUET) Technology (BUET)
Dhaka 1000, Bangladesh Dhaka 1000, Bangladesh
Fax: +880-2-966-5639 Fax: +880-2-966-5639
E-mail: tanweer20@gmail.com E-mail: mizanur@ce.buet.ac.bd

Abstract: The prospects of some market- and non-market based transport demand
management (TDM) measures as candidates of reducing traffic congestion in Dhaka are
discussed. It is suggested that the ever increasing travel demand of city dwellers cannot be
met by providing transport supply only. The main impediment to building new roadways is
the lack of resources and land. Despite the fact that Bangladesh is one of the poorest
countries in the world, the automobile registration is growing at a rate of 30% per year.
Therefore, it would be wise to think about implementing less costly, as compared to supply
side measures, TDM measures to reduce the gap between demand and supply. It is
emphasized in the paper that the market based strategies like pricing measures and employer
based TDM measures have good prospect, and the relevant authorities should undertake
necessary preparations so that they can be implemented within a reasonably short period of
time.

Key Words: Traffic Congestion, Dhaka, TDM

1. INTRODUCTION The continuing growth reflects ongoing


migration from rural areas of Bangladesh to
Bangladesh is the seventh most populous Dhaka’s urban region. Such growth
country in the world with a current accounted for roughly 60 percent of the
population of 164 millions in an area of city’s growth in the 1960s and 1970s, but
144,000 square kilometres. Dhaka, the more recently the city’s population has also
capital city, was founded as a provincial city grown as a result of the expansion of its
in 1608. But with its emergence as the administrative boundaries. By contrast, the
capital of the newly independent country rate of natural increase in the city has been
Bangladesh in 1971, it has witnessed one of falling, as is the case in most Asian cities.
the fastest population growths (4.2 percent Dhaka’s population represents more than 40
annually) among megacities world wide. percent of the total urban population of the
The population has grown from around half country. Even though the total area of the
a million in 1965 to 15 millions in 2010, and city (metropolitan area) is around 1,500
it is anticipated to be the world’s fifth most square kilometres, approximately 80 percent
populous city, with an estimated population (12 million) of the population is
of 20.9 millions in 2025 (Population concentrated in the 360 square kilometres of
Reference Bureau 2010 and United Nations the Dhaka City Corporation area.
2009). Historically, Dhaka has grown in an
unplanned and haphazard manner leaving
inadequate space for transport
infrastructure. On the other hand, the rapid 2. TRAFFIC ENVIRONMENT IN
growth in urbanization has created a high DHAKA
growth in demand for transport facilities.
However, the inability to cater for this high Being the administrative, commercial and
transport demand, mainly because of cultural capital of Bangladesh, the mega city
unavailability of land, has eventually Dhaka has a major role to play in the
overwhelmed the transport capacity of the socioeconomic development of the country
city. The city streets remain congested for and in the era of regional and sub-regional
10 to 12 hours during any given weekday cooperation. But the existing transportation
(Siddique 2010). system is a major bottleneck for the
development of the city. Unplanned
Traffic congestion reduces the productivity urbanization, especially poor transportation
of urban agglomeration everywhere, but the planning and lower land utilization
consequences in developing country efficiency, has turned the city into an
megacities are even greater (TRB 2006). It inefficient transport provider. The rapid rise
is estimated that Dhaka’s contribution to in population along with increased and
national GDP is 15 percent (Hoque et al versatile urban land use patterns has
2005). Therefore, reducing traffic generated considerable travel demand as
congestion is a central element of economic well as numerous transport problems in
growth. Moreover, reducing congestion will Dhaka City.
also reduce automobile emissions, and thus
urban air pollution, which is currently a The transportation system of Dhaka is
major health problem in most megacities predominantly road based and non-
like Dhaka (TRB 2006). motorized transportation (mainly rickshaws)
has a substantial mode share. Dhaka’s road
The urban transport issues of mobility, network is nearly 3,000 kms (of which 200
congestion, safety and environmental km are primary) with few alternative
aspects are becoming increasingly important connector roads. Only 7% of total land
and critical in Dhaka. The rapid space is devoted to the roadway and
urbanisation process, high vehicular transport facilities. Approximately 400 kms
population growth, inadequate of footpaths are available for pedestrians of
transportation facilities and policies, varied which 40% are being occupied illegally by
traffic mix with high concentration of non- vendors and others (Rahman 2008). There
motorised vehicles, absence of a dependable are no marked bicycle lanes and cyclists
public transport system and inadequate share the road with other motorized and
traffic management practices and parking non-motorized vehicles. Traffic movements
facilities have created a significant at intersections are mostly operated
worsening of traffic and environmental manually by traffic police, even though all
problems in the city. The aim of this paper large intersections (a total of 70) are
is to assess the prospect of applying equipped with traffic lights and signal
transport demand management (TDM) controllers.
measures to the Dhaka situation. This paper
begins by highlighting the distinguishing The transport sector in Dhaka is comprised
features of Dhaka city traffic. Then, the of many different modes of travel-both
sections that follow elaborate different motorized and non-motorized. They often
transport demand management strategies use the same road space which results in a
applied elsewhere, and their prospects of high level of operational disorder, and
reducing the severe traffic congestion in significantly diminishes the efficiency and
Dhaka city. effectiveness of the existing transport
services. There are 527,285 registered
motorized vehicles in Dhaka of which and three-wheelers (3%). In addition to
147,283 are passenger vehicles. The level of these motorized vehicles there are over
motorization in Dhaka is very low- 35 500,000 rickshaws plying their trade in the
motorized vehicles or 10 passenger cars per streets of Dhaka (DTCB 2005).
1000 population. The number of motorized
vehicles grew from 303,215 in 2003 to On any given weekday, with just a cursory
527,285 in 2009 at an annual rate of 9.8 look at the streets of Dhaka city, one can
percent (see Figure 1). The number of easily conclude that the traffic situation is at
passenger car registrations each year is also crisis point. Waiting at intersections for 10-
increasing at a high pace from 4,734 in 2004 15 minutes, and a mile long queue of stalled
to 17,654 in 2009 (see Figure 2). This vehicles on major roadways are very
clearly gives an indication that the common. A 5-km trip will usually take 45
automobile dependency of city dwellers has minutes during peak hours. A recent study
been increasing over the years. Bangladesh found that all major intersections in the city
Road Transport Authority (BRTA) data also operate at well over their capacities
shows that (see Figure 3) there are 41 (Siddiquee, 2010) during most of the hours
percent of motor cycles in the vehicle mix, between 8:00 in the morning and.9:00 in the
followed by passenger cars (27%), evening.
Jeep/micro-bus (11%), bus (4%), taxi (3%),

Total Number of Registered Motorized Vehicles in Dhaka (2003-


2009)

600000

500000
Number of Vehicles

400000

Annual Growth Rate = 9.7%


300000

200000

100000

0
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Year

Figure 1. Total number of motorized vehicles in Dhaka, 2003-2009 (source: Bangladesh


Road Transport Authority (BRTA), 2010: www.brta.gov.bd)
Number of Yearwise Registration of Passenger Cars in Dhaka
(2004-2009)

20000

18000 17654

16000
Number of Paasenger Cars

14000 13749

12000

10000 10244

8000
7403 Annual growth rate = 30%
6000 5633
4734
4000

2000

0
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Year

Figure 2. Number of year-wise registration of passenger cars in Dhaka, 2004-2009 (source:


Bangladesh Road Transport Authority (BRTA), 2010: www.brta.gov.bd)

Composition of Motorized Vehicles in Dhaka

Other, 5%

Car, 27%

Motor Cycle, 41%

Jeep/Micro Bus, 11%

Taxi, 3%
Minibus, 2%
Bus, 1%
3-wheeler, 3% Truck, 6%

Figure 3. Motorized vehicle composition in Dhaka, 2009 (source: Bangladesh Road


Transport Authority (BRTA), 2010: www.brta.gov.bd)

There is now an ever increasing urgency to city. Since the country’s independence in
mitigate the severe traffic situation of the 1971, several studies have been undertaken
to identify measures necessary so that the hours, instead of increasing roadway supply.
city can remain liveable. Unfortunately, Thus, TDM makes more efficient use of the
recommendations of those studies have current roadway system. The sections below
largely never been implemented. A lack of provide brief summaries of various types of
sincerity and inability to apprehend the market- and non-market based TDM
future scenario among the people in the measures that are effective in reducing
government are central to the Dhaka roadway traffic congestion. Note that
transport crisis. The government has extensive discussions about various TDM
recently adopted a Strategic Transport Plan strategies can be found elsewhere (TDM
(DTCB 2005) which lists a number of Encyclopaedia).
transport projects that should be
implemented to cope with traffic demand Road Pricing involves charging motorists
until 2025. There is a feeling that the directly for driving on a particular road or in
government plans to build elevated a particular area. There are a number of
expressways covering most of city areas, possible road pricing schemes involving
and a Bus Rapid Transit line along a north- various time periods, areas and means of
south corridor. The elevated expressway, if charging (Ison 2004). Two most successful
ever built, would naturally relieve the traffic road pricing schemes are London’s
pressure on the existing city streets. congestion pricing and Singapore’s
However, it is also worthy to note that the electronic road pricing. London’s
highway based capacity expansion measures congestion charging scheme was
are expensive, and may provide only modest implemented in February 2003, and traffic
congestion reduction benefits over the long impact assessed a year after showed
run, since a significant portion of added significant improvements in terms reduction
capacity is often filled with induced peak of auto uses, increase in bus ridership,
period vehicle traffic. No question that there reduction in delays, and increase in vehicle
is a large gap between the transport demand speeds (TfL 2004). In Singapore, the first
and supply of transport facilities. Two road pricing scheme, known as the Area
things can be done to reduce this gap- Licensing Scheme, was introduced in the
increase in supply or reduce the demand. restricted zone in 1975. In September 1998,
Building new roads and transport facilities the electronic road pricing system replaced
would be very difficult because of the the manual system for the restricted zone
scarcity of land and would be very and expressways. The benefits of the
expensive. Alternatively, more emphasis introduction of the electronic road pricing
should be given on ways to reduce travel scheme were an immediate increase of
demand through the adoption of suitable traffic speed by 22 percent, and total
transport demand management strategies to reduction of traffic in the restricted zone
narrow the gap between demand and supply. during the charging period by 13 percent
(Keong 2002).

3. OVERVIEW OF TDM STRATEGIES Ridesharing refers to carpooling and


TO REDUCE TRAFFIC CONGESTION vanpooling, in which vehicles carry
additional passengers. Ridesharing has
Congested streets and roadways result when minimal incremental costs because it makes
too many people want to drive on the same use of vehicle seats that would otherwise be
routes at the same time, particularly during unoccupied. Studies have shown that
peak commute hours or special events. ridesharing programmes can reduce daily
Transport Demand Management (TDM) vehicle commute trips to specific worksites
programmes focus on changing or reducing by 5-15%, and up to 20% or more if
travel demand, particularly at peak commute implemented with parking pricing (Ewing
1993). Transit related transport demand in vehicle trips could be as high as 24.5
management strategies emphasize percent with an average of 15.3 percent
increasing transit ridership by improving the (TCRP 1994).
efficiency of existing services. An improved
public transport service is required to
accommodate the solo drivers priced out of 4. PROSPECT OF IMPLEMENTATION
their cars due to road and parking pricing. OF TDM STRATEGIES IN DHAKA
Parking Management and Parking Pricing
are effective ways to reduce automobile In the developed countries, such as the US,
travel, and tend to be particularly effective the historical roots of TDM may be traced
in urban areas where congestion problems back to at least to World War II, when
are greatest. Efficient pricing of on-street company buses, carpools and staggered
parking would make urban driving more work shifts were used to attract employees
expensive but more efficient, due to lower and manage on-site congestion problems
levels of traffic congestion and the relative (Giuliano and Wachs, 1992). The policy
ease in finding a parking space near goals of accommodating traffic demand by
destinations, as well as providing new constructing new facilities started losing its
revenues. Fuel price increases can help feasibility in the 1980’s in the US due to the
reduce traffic congestion by reducing travel continued (and in some case explosive)
demand. INRIX (2008) results indicated that urban growth and automobile use, which
a 28% increase in average fuel prices during has led to unprecedented levels of traffic
the first half of 2008 contributed to a 3% congestion. By the end of the 1980’s, the
reduction in average national Travel Time expectations and structure of TDM
Index values. Alternative Work schedules programmes and policies changed
can also reduce peak period commute travel, dramatically. TDM programmes are now
and thus can reduce traffic congestion. typically mandatory rather than voluntary.
Distance-Based Fees (also called Pay-As- Policy changes to favour TDM measures
You-Drive, Mileage-Based and Per-Mile also took place in most of the European
pricing) tend to be economically more countries and in Asian countries such as
efficient and fairer than existing pricing Japan and Singapore.
practices. Converting fixed costs into
distance-based charges gives motorists a While the benefits of adopting various travel
new opportunity to save money when they demand management strategies are proven
reduce their mileage. Telework involves the in reducing automobile trips to a significant
use of telecommunications to substitute for amount, the developing country cities
physical travel, and gives people a way to mainly look at the supply side of managing
avoid travelling under congested conditions. transport demand to reduce the severe traffic
Employer based transport demand congestion. It is simply being overlooked in
management strategies (commute trip the developing countries that restricting
reduction programme, also known as travel demand can also be a rational strategy to
plan) include public and private sector reduce traffic congestion. It is encouraging,
programmes and services that encourage though, to note that research in some
employees to change their commuting developing countries like Malaysia,
practices, incentives that make publicly Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, and South Africa
provided travel modes more attractive, are looking at different travel demand
disincentives to solo commuting, and management measures that they think can
employer management policies that offer address the traffic problems in their
employees flexibility in travel mode respective cities (Kasipillai and Chan, 2008;
choices. A study of travel plans developed Ueckermann and Venter, 2008; Prandono et
by 49 employers showed that the reduction al, 2009). The suggested travel demand
management strategies include financial financial, which has made the automobile
measures like elimination of fuel subsidies, use more costly. The measures, however,
imposition of fuel taxes, increase of road were taken merely to increase the revenue
taxes, and congestion charging in Kula rather than as transport demand
Lumpur; congestion pricing and high management measures. The import tax on
occupancy vehicle lanes in Johannesburg; passenger cars is over 200 percent, the
and carpooling and bus lanes in Jakarta and registration cost is around 2-5 percent of the
Bandung in Indonesia. total price of the vehicle. The fuel (petrol
and octane) price is no longer subsidized,
While traffic has increased at a very high and currently priced at US $1.07 per litre.
rate, neither major capacity expansion These increases, however, had little effect
projects nor any improvements of public on the usage of automobiles because, the
transport services were implemented in automobile owners now use much cheaper
Dhaka during the last two decades. alternative fuel (converted natural gas),
Naturally, the question arises: Is it really the which costs only one third of the cost of
right time to consider the prospect of petrol. With respect to the total population
transport demand management when little (or families) of the city, only a few can
has been undertaken in terms of supply to afford to own an automobile, mainly
cater for the increased demand? The answer because of its high price (US $ 18,000-
would appear to be ‘yes’. Even though the 32,000). Therefore, the government, as part
government has endorsed the strategic of a transport demand management policy,
transport plan which recommends the can impose even larger financial measures
building of new highways and mass rapid without causing any equity concern for the
transit facilities, how far those targets can be larger portion of the city dwellers who are
achieved remains questionable. The two poor. To start with, the price of the natural
likely obstacles are limited resources and gas can be increased substantially. The fuel
lack of available land. Managing the flow of tax, road tax, and yearly fitness fee of
traffic during the construction period may automobiles can further be increased. An
also be a great concern. The transport area based road pricing scheme may also be
demand management measures, on the other considered to discourage the use of
hand, can be implemented within a automobiles. The labour is cheap, and a
relatively short period of time and are less paper based pricing can be a viable option.
costly (TRB 2006). There is a need to learn The financial measures can only be effective
from the experiences of the developed in reducing automobile use when there are
nations: ‘highways cannot eventually get comfortable and reliable public transport
you out of the congestion’. The high rate of services. The current conditions of public
automobile registration (see Fig 2) indicates transport services (mainly buses) in the city
that each year some non-automobile (bus are not at all promising. Therefore, before
and rickshaw) trips are shifted toward taking initiatives to make automobile use
automobile trips. This trend can be more expensive and take it to a level when
minimized if transport demand management people think of giving up their automobiles,
measures like improvement of transit the government should make every effort to
services as well as financial disincentives to start implementing the recommendations of
automobile users are implemented. the Strategic Transport Plan, especially
Transport demand management measures those about rail based (buses are susceptible
are, indeed, preventive in nature. And to traffic congestion) mass rapid transit
‘prevention is better than cure.’ facilities. An effective mass rapid transit
system can play even a bigger role in the
Pricing Measures: In recent years, the city. Almost thirty percent of the trips in the
government has taken actions, mainly city are made by rickshaws (DTCB, 2005).
While the developed nations are advocating pedestrian volume and the pedestrian
land developments where more people facilities provided. The school trips are also
would use non-motorized transport, too a cause of great concern. The school trips
much slow-moving non-motorized vehicles are mostly automobile trips. Except a very
in the stream can have adverse effects on the few, none of the schools have any form of
quality of flow of traffic (Hasan and school transport services to carry their
Monayem, 2003). It is reasonable to assume students. The traffic congestion in the early
that an affordable and reliable mass transit morning and early afternoon are caused due
system would attract a significant portion of to the school traffic. The government could
rickshaw travellers and would thus help to take steps to make it mandatory for the
reduce the number of rickshaws. school authorities, mainly private English
medium schools, to arrange student
In Dhaka, parking is virtually free and lacks transport services with medium sized buses.
proper enforcement and regulation. The If the school authority can ensure a safe and
parked vehicles occupy almost half of the reliable transport service, then a majority of
roadway in busy areas. As a result, the on- the students are expected to use the school
street parking significantly deteriorates the buses. Consequently, the amount of
quality of traffic flow (Hasan and automobile trips would be considerably
Monayem, 2003). Parking should not be reduced.
free since there is a cost in providing
parking spaces. The further increase in cost Alternative Work Schedules: In 2009, the
of driving an automobile due to parking government, in an attempt to reduce the
pricing would work as a deterrent to level of congestion, implemented staggered
increased use of automobiles. working hours for different types of
organizations. The working hours of
Employer Based Measures: Commuter trip schools, private organizations, and
reduction programmes have good prospects government organizations were staggered
in reducing automobile usage in the city. A by thirty minutes to an hour. The
significant portion of automobile work trips congestion, however, remains severe as
are attracted by the national and usual. The staggered working hours can
multinational commercial business only be effective when there are distinct
establishments. While mandatory travel peaks and off-peaks. The city streets are
plans may not be feasible at this moment carrying volumes well over their capacities
due to the lack of efficient mass transit for almost 12 hours, and as a result the
facilities, but provision of company vehicles changes in traffic volumes due to the
for the transport of employees can be made staggered working hours could not bring
mandatory. The companies may be allowed about any noticeable changes in the level of
to use some of their funds allocated for congestion.
‘corporate social responsibility’ in this
regard. For example, the company buses for Ridesharing: Even though Bangladesh is a
employees of ready-made garment moderately liberal Muslim country,
industries may not only meet their mobility carpooling may not be a good prospect in
needs, but also can help improve the traffic near future. People would prefer not to share
situation. The trips made by these workers their cars with others. However, a social
are entirely on foot. The high volumes of campaign about the benefits of carpooling
pedestrians often cause adverse effects on may bring some change. Vanpooling, on
the quality of traffic flow (Hoque et al, the other hand, may be worth considering.
2005). Therefore, accommodating majority The government may initially offer
of them into the company buses would incentives to private companies to operate
ensure a balance between the amount of
vanpooling on an experimental basis to see measures and employer based TDM
the level of acceptance among the travellers. measures have good prospect, and the
relevant authorities should undertake
Distance Based Fees and Telework: While necessary preparations so that they can be
it is true that ‘pay as you drive’ and implemented within a reasonably short
telework have the potential of reducing the period of time. It is also important to note
amount of automobile usage, their prospects that the transport demand management
as transport demand management measures policy can only be effective if in fact the
in Dhaka are not so promising. While the people involved change their travel
country is making continuous progress behaviour. There can be additional
technologically and the internet is widely problematic obstacles to the implementation
available in the city, it is still too early to of transport policies in a country like
think about these measures. Bangladesh. In some cases, the obstacles are
primarily institutional in nature and include
overlapping and uncoordinated institutional
5. CONCLUSIONS structures, inadequate or poorly trained
technical staff for planning and
Severe traffic congestion, in a city like implementation functions, a lack of legal
Dhaka, cannot be reduced to an acceptable capacity to enforce regulation and laws, and
level by building roadways only. To reduce limited institutional support for new, and
the gap between demand and supply, often poorly understood, policies. In other
transport demand management strategies instances, the major impediment to the
should also be considered. Both market and implementation of transport strategies is the
non-market based TDM strategies are political framework in which decision
discussed in this paper. The prospects of making takes place. These obstacles can be
these TDM measures as candidates of overcome through changes in legislation,
reducing congestion in Dhaka are also better training of personnel, and enhanced
discussed. It is emphasized in the paper that citizen participation.
the market based strategies like pricing

REFERENCES

Dhaka Transport Coordination Board (2005) Strategic Transport Plan for Dhaka. Final Repot,
Luis Berger Group and Bangladesh Consultants Limited.

Giuliano, G. and M. Wachs (1992) Responding to congestion and traffic growth:


Transportation Demand Management. UCTC No. 86, The University of California
Transportation Centre, University of California at Berkeley.

Hasan, T. and M. A. Monayem (2003) Traffic operating conditions on two primary arterials
in Metropolitan Dhaka. Proceedings 2nd Annual paper Meet and International
Conference on Civil Engineering, The Institute of Engineers, Bangladesh, 137-148, July
2003.

Hoque, M.M., B. Khondokar and MJB Alam (2005) Urban transport issues and improvement
options in Bangladesh. Proceedings Canadian Transport Research Forum (CTRF)
Conference, Toronto, Canada, 2005.
Hoque, M.S., T. Hasan and M.A. Waresh (2005) Effects of pedestrian underpasses on traffic
flow characteristics. Proceedings 84th Annual Meeting, Transportation Research Board
(TRB), Compendium of Papers CD-ROM, Washington, D.C, 2005.

INRIX (2008), The impact of fuel prices on consumer behaviour and traffic congestion,
National Traffic Scorecard, Special Report October 2008.

Ison, S. (2004) Road User Charging: Issues and Policies, Ashgate Publishing Limited.

Kasipillai, J. and P. Chan (2008) Travel demand management: Lessons for Malaysia. Journal
of Public Transportation, Vol. 11, No. 3, 41-55.

Keong, C.K. (2002) Road pricing: Singapore’s experience. Proceedings IMPRINT-


EUROPE Thematic Network: “Implementing Reform in Transport Pricing: constraints
and solutions: learning from best practice,” Brussels, 23-24, October 2002.

Population Reference Bureau (2010). World Population Data Sheet. Washington, D.C.,
www.prb.org, visited 05 November 2010.

Prandono, S.Y. Rachmat, and N.D. Pitaloka (2009) Level of acceptance of the TDM
implementation in Indonesian cities. Journal of the Eastern Asia Society for Transport
Studies, Vol 8.

Rahman, M.S. (2008) Future mass rapid transit in Dhaka city: Options, issues and realities.
Jahangirnagar Planning Review, Volume 6, 69-81.

Reid Ewing (1993) TDM, growth management, and the other four out of five trips,
Transportation Quarterly, Vol 47, No. 3,. 343-366.

Siddiquee, M. A. K. (2010) A GIS based advanced traveller information system for road
network in Dhaka City. Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of civil Engineering, Bangladesh
University of Engineering and Technology, Dhaka.

TDM Encyclopaedia. Victoria Transport Policy Institute, Victoria, Canada


(www.vtpi.org/index.php)

Transit Cooperative Research Program (1994) Cost effectiveness of TDM programs,


Working Paper, No. 2, COMSIS Corporation.

Transport for London (2004) Assessment report: Initial performance assessment. audit
commission, November 2004.

Transportation Research Board (2006) Transport options for megacities in the developing
world. National Research Council, Washington, D.C.

Ueckermann, T.M. and C. Venter (2008) International experience with road and congestion
pricing and options for Johannesburg. Proceedings 27th Southern African Transport
Conference, 593-606, 2008.

You might also like