Student name: INSERT STUDENT NAME Marker (1st/2nd/3rd):

Unit Operation: INSERT UNIT NAME Assessor:

Final Mark (%): 100 Date:

Mark range
>40% 40 - 49% 50 - 59%
Introduction:
Description of project, specific unit
operation, and it's role and influence
within the overall process design
Check on calculations for this unit as
presented in the Group Report
Unit Design:
Justification for equipment selection - e.g.
choice of heat exchanger: shell and tube
or plate or spiral

Use of simplified design methods and

associated approximations and
assumptions (including sound
justifications)

Development of complex design

calculations taking into account chemical
engineering fundamentals. Whilst this
varies depending upon unit selection,
design complexities could include:
reaction kinetics, fouling, corrosion, non-
Newtonian effects etc

Material balance and energy balance

(manual)

Pressure drop calculations across the unit

Use of initiative and novelty when tackling

the design problem

Selection of design procedures and codes

Checks to ensure results are reasonable -

this could include comparison with similar
systems found in literature or other
relevant "guestimation" checks

Presentation of results with logical

progression and explanation as increasing
complexity is added to the design
methodology

Computer flow diagram and explanation

of algorithms (if applicable) as well as
comparison between results and manual
calculations
Unit Optimisation
Operational limits of design (max/min
flowrates)
Composition limits of design (max/min
input concentrations)
Upgrade options (if relevant) to mitigate
impact of changing circumstances
Mechanical Engineering Design:
Selection of materials
Calculation of thickness and weight of
vessels
Consideration of temperature, pressure
and expansion effects

Selection of design procedures and codes

Engineering drawings: Standard of side

view, end views, corss-section views and
magnified sections (if appropriate)
Outline Control System (for your unit):
Clarity of P&ID and consideration of
adequate control, including operational
influence on other units within the
process (if relevant)

Consideration of safety including relevant

use of HAZID and LOPA if/where relevant ,
including one example of a complete
LOPA calculation
Explanation of main control and safety
considerations within the text

Brief (max 2 page) summary of main Start

up/Shut down steps with clear indication
to pertinent safety considerations

Indication on main factors influencing

maintenance/cleaning of equipment
during operational lifetime
Summary:
Clear summary of the main Final design
and comments
Specification sheet for the unit
Overall Presentation:
Clarity of text and calculations
Clarity of computer algorithms (if
relevant) and listings
Effectiveness of illustrations
Effectiveness of references, literature and
other sources
Clarity of conclusions

Introduction: AAA Unit Design: BBB Unit Optimisation: CCC Mechanic

Introduction: AAA Unit Design: BBB Unit Optimisation: CCC Mechanic
st/2nd/3rd): INSERT STATUS HERE
INSERT ASSESSOR NAME HERE
INSERT DATE HERE

Mark range Mark Awarded Component

60 - 69% 70 - 79% 80 - 100% (out of 100%) mark (%)

100 5

100 40

100 15
 100 15

100 10

100 20

100 5

100 5

it Optimisation: CCC Mechanical Design: DDD Control and Safety: EEE Summary: FFF Presentation: GGG
it Optimisation: CCC Mechanical Design: DDD Control and Safety: EEE Summary: FFF Presentation: GGG
Notes

AAA

BBB

CCC
 CCC

DDD

EEE

FFF

GGG

y: EEE Summary: FFF Presentation: GGG

y: EEE Summary: FFF Presentation: GGG