Standard Method of Test
for
Resilient Modulus of Subgrade Soils and Untreated Base/Subbase Materials
1. SCOPE
LL This method covers procedures
for preparing and testing untreated sub-
grade soils and untreated base/subbase
materials for determination of resilient
modulus (M,) under conditions repre-
senting a simulation of the physical con-
ditions and stress states of materials be-
neath flexible pavements subjected to
moving wheel loads.
1.2” The methods described are appli-
cable to undisturbed samples of natural
and compacted subgrade soils and to
disturbed samples of subgrade soils and
untreated base/subbase materials pre-
pared for testing by compaction in the
laboratory. Methods of compaction in-
clude kneading, impact, static and vibra-
tory
1.3. The values of resilient modulus
determined with these procedures can be
used to calculate the physical response
of pavement structures,
NOTE 1—Test specimens and equipment
escribed in this method may be used to
cbtain other useful and related information
such asthe Poisson's ratio and rutting charac.
teristics of subgrade soils and base/subbase
‘materials. Procedures for obtaining any such
‘optional information are, however, beyond
{he scope of this method.
14 The values stated in SI units are
to be regarded as the standard,
2. REFERENCED DOCUMENTS
2.1 AASHTO Standards:
T 88 Particle Size Analysis
of Soils
Moisture-Density Re-
lations of Soils Using
a 25-kg (5.5-Ib) Ram-
‘mer and a 305-mm
(Q2-in,) Drop.
Specific Gravity of
Soils
To
AASHTO DESIGNATION T 292-91
Moisture-Density Re-
Iations of Soils Using
a 4S4kg (10b)
Rammer and a 457.
‘mm (18-in) Drop
Resistance R-Value
and Expansion Pres-
sure of Compacted
Soils
Unconsolidated, Un
drained Compressive
Strength of Cohesive
Soils in Triaxial Com-
pression
‘The Classification of
Soils and Soil-Ag-
sgregate Mixtures for
Highway Construction
Purposes,
T 234
M 14s
SUMMARY OF METHOD
3.1 A repeated axial deviator stress
of fixed magnitude, duration and fre-
quency is applied to an appropriately
prepared and conditioned eylindrical test
specimen. During and between the dy-
namic devistor stress applications, spe:
‘mens are subjected to a static all-around
sttess provided by means of a triaxial
pressure chamber. The resilient (recover-
able) axial strain response of the speci
‘men is measured and is used to calculate
the M,,
4. SIGNIFICANCE AND USE
4.1 The resilient modulus test pro-
vides a relationship between stress and
eformation of pavement construction
‘materials and subgrade soils for use in
Pavement design and structural analysis,
of layered pavement systems
42. The resilient modulus test pro-
vides a means of evaluating subgrade
soils and untreated base/subbase materi-
als over a range of stress states
5. DEFINITIONS
SA_Description of Symbols:
5.1.1; is the total axial stress (ma-
{jor principal stress).
S12 $, (minor principal stress) and
S; (intermediate principal stress) are as-
sumed equal and are the total radial
stress; that is, the applied confining pres-
sure in the tiaxial chamber,
NOTE 2—For tess which involve mes
surement of pore pressures of saturated spec
mens, the principal stresses referred to in
this section are acwally effective. principal
stresses, that isthe principal stress minus the
back pressure
31.3 S. = S, = S) is the deviator
tess, ie, the repeated axial stress,
Sd Ey is the total axial strain due
0S.
S_Eyis the resilient (recoverable)
axial strain due to Sq
5.1.6 M, = SJE, is the resilient mod-
ulus.
52 Terminology
5.2.1 Load duration i the time inter-
val the specimen is subjected to a devia-
tor stress.
$2.2 Cycle duration is the time in-
terval between successive applications of
2 deviator stress,
52.3 Shear strength isthe maximum
resistance of a material to. shearing
stresses. When required for this proce=
dure it is determined from the results of
‘method T 234-85,
52.4 Critical suess ratio is the nu-
teric value of the principal stress ratio,
SVSs, at which failure ofa test specimen
‘occurs. For tests involving measurement
of pore pressures of saturated specimens,
this is actually an effective critical
stress ratio.
$2.5 Viscoelasticity is the property
‘of materials whose strain is atleast partly
dependent on time and magnitude of
5.2.6 For purposes of this method
79780
specimens or soils will be designated
‘granular or cohesive as follows:
5.26.1 Granular specimens or soils
are those which meet the criteria of the
AASHTO Soil Classification System
group or subgroup nos. A-I, A-2-4, A-
2.5 and A-3. Materials which meet crite-
Fla of groups A-4 and A-5 and have a
‘maximum plasticity index of 6 shall be
considered granular.
52.6.2 Cohesive specimens or soils
are those which meet the criteria of the
AASHTO Soil Classification System
g10U Nos. A-2-6, A-2-7, A6 and AT.
Materials which meet the criteria of
group nos. A-4 and A-S and have a
plasticity index greater than 6 shall be
considered cohesive
NOTE 3-Cohesive and granular designs
tions used in this test method differ from
those of M 145 and are made with regands
to the material's potential for viscoelastic be
havior. Materials of Section 5.2.62 are con
sideted viscoelastic while those of Section
5261 are not
5.2.7 “Base/subbase” refers to the
‘untreated layer or layers of specified ma-
terials placed between the concrete of
asphalt pavement and the subgrade. It
should be noted that different agencies
‘may use the tems base or subbase in
reference to the same material used in
the same pavement layer. Other agencies
‘may, however, apply these terms to dif
ferent materials used in separate pave~
‘ment layers,
5.2.8 “Subgrade” refers to the natu-
ral foundation or embankment soil which
hhas been prepared to support a pave-
‘ment system,
6. APPARATUS.
6.1 Triaxial Pressure Chamber—
‘The pressure chamber is used to contain
the specimen and confining fluid during
the test. A triaxial chamber suitable for
resilience testing of soils is shown in
Figure 1
G11 The chamber may requite addi-
tional outlets for electrical leads if inter-
nal electric measuring devices are used.
6.1.2 The chamber must be of suffi
a freater han or equal 0 the mois: impact
ture content 3 ime of con: kneading
<0 greater than the melatre content staie
e-aired water. If a removable type bot
tom platen is used, tighten it firmly to
the base ofthe triaxial chamber to ensure
‘an airtight sea,
NOTE 8—Some laboratory compacted
specimens have been subjected to an agi
petiod and will be enclosed by a membrane
and solid-end platens Refer to Section AI.13.
7.7.3. Remove end platens if placed
fn the specimen for an aging period and
carefully place the specimen on the bot-
tom test chamber platen.
7.7A_ If the specimen is to be satu-
rated, place a porous stone on the speci-
‘men and the top platen on the stone. For
‘unsaturated specimens the top stone is op-
tional
7.73. Ifamembrane has been applied
to the specimen for an aging period, at-
tach the ends to the top and bottom plat-
fens using O-rings. Otherwise, using
vacuum membrane enlarger” place a
‘membrane over the specimen and attach
the ends in a like manner.
7.7.6 Connect the bottom drainage
line to the bubble chamber and apply a
vacuum of 21 kPa (3 psi). If bubbles con-
tinue for more than a few seconds, check
for leakage caused by poor connections,
holes in the membrane, or imperfect seals
atthe end platens, When leakage has been
eliminated, disconnect the bottom drain-
‘ge line from the bubble chamber.
7.7.7 Xf intemal LVDT’s ate to be
Used, afix the LVDT clamps to the upper
‘and lower quarter points ofthe specimen.
Ensure that both clamps lie in horizontal
Planes. Install LVDT's tothe clamps and
connect them to the recording unit and
balance the recording bridges. After bal-
‘ancing the bridges, measure the distance
tie of onstruction
between the clamps tothe nearest 0.5 mm,
(0.02 in) and record this value
7.78 If an internal load cell is to be
used, set i in place on top of the speci
‘men platen,
7.7.9 Finish assembling the triaxial
‘chamber by seting the chamber cylinder,
cover, and loading piston in place. Secure
the cover. The loading piston should be
seated on the load cell or platen,
77.10 Centerthe triaxial chamber on
the loading device. If the LYDT's and
load ceil are external, set them in place.
7.7AL Adjust the loading device
such that there is contact between the
loading piston and load actuator of reac-
tion frame. Rebalance recording bridges
for LVDT's and the load cel
77.12 Connect the chamber pressure
line. If the specimen is a soft, silty, or
granular material, apply the lowest con-
fining pressure to be used in the test se~
quence to prevent the specimen from
slumping prior to testing.
‘713 If the specimen is to be satu-
rated, follow the procedures in Appen-
dix I.
8. PROCEDURE
NOTE 9—For specimens which have been
subjected to back pressure satraton, the con,
fining pressures refered to in this section are
sctually effective confining pressures, that is,
the cell pressure minus the back pressure
8.1 Resilience Testing of Cohesive
Soils:
NOTE 10—Gencrally, the small range of
confining pressure expected within subgrades
T 292
hha only a minimal effect on M, valves ob
tained from cohesive specimens. Therefore,
cohesive specimens shall be tested ata sing.
lar confining pressure representing a median
‘value for subgrades,
8.11 If not already done, apply a
21 kPa (3 psi) confining pressure, and
tebalance the recording bridges for the
LDT's and load cell
81.1.1 Open all drainage lines. Suf-
ficient time must be provided prior to
testing to allow any consolidation ofthe
specimen to occur. For saturated spec
‘mens, completion of consolidation may
be asertained by monitoring the spec
men's pore water pressure of the rate of
rise ofa column of water connected to
the specimen's drainage lines. For unsat
rated specimens, the rate of change of
specimen height may be monitored.
8.1.2 After the specimen has consol-
idated, drainage lines wil be closed for
Saturated specimens and opened for un.
Saturated specimens
NOTE 11—Cohesive soils generally ex
hibit viscoelastic Behavior. Resilient deforma-
Yions may, therefore, be sensitive to the
oad duration
8.1.3 Adjust the loading device to
produce the fixed load duration selected
from Table 1 and a fixed cycle duration
of between 1.0 and 3.0 seconds, Load
and cycle durations should be chosen to
provide « minimum 0.85-second period
of relaxation between the end and begin-
ning of consecutive load repetitions as
illustrated in Figure 6.
8.14 Begin the test by applying
1000 repetitions of a deviator stress of
21 kPa (3 psi) or 41 KPa (6 psi). The
lower deviator stress shall be used for
specimens with shear strengths less than
‘or equal to 48 kPa (1000 psf). The higher
deviator stress shall be used for speci-
mens with shear strengths greater than
48 kPa (1000 psf). Shear strengths are
determined by the Unconsolidated, Un-
drained (UU) method of T 234-85. This
sequence constitutes specimen condi-
Wioning and is intended to eliminate the
effects of any specimen disturbance due
to sampling, compaction, and specimen
preparation procedures. This load condi-
tioning also aids in minimizing the ef-
fects of initially imperfect contact be-
tween the end platens and the test spee-7292
METHODS OF SAMPLING AND TESTING
787
TABLE 4 Test Sequence for Cohesive
b. Rectangul
load duration (0.05 to 1.0 secon:
lar Wave Form
is)
yele duration (1.0 to 3.0 seconds)
(C= period of relaxation (minimum 0.85 seconds —cohesive specimens)
‘miniraum
FIGURE 6 Typical Load
8.14.1 Monitor the permanent axial
deformation occurring during the condi-
tioning phase. Should the permanent
‘axial strain occurring during the last 900
conditioning repetitions exceed 1 per-
Cent, the deviator stress should be limited
0 50 percent ofthe shear stress at failure.
The criterion of failure is defined by
T 234-85,
8.14.2 Monitor the post-condition-
jing permanent axial deformation
Uiroughout the remainder of the test
Should postconditioning permanent
axial strain exceed 5 percent, the test
shall be terminated,
8.14.3 After the specimen condi-
tioning phase is complete, the testing
Phase should begin immediately without
allowing time for dissipation of pore
pressures,
8.15 Apply a minimum of 50 repeti-
tions of the smallest deviator stress to
be included in the test. If in-service
stresses are not known, the test sequence
(09 seconds-—granular specimens)
fave Forms
in Table 4 may be used, Record the
average recoverable axial deformations
of the last five repetitions,
NOTE 12—Swess states shoud be selected
to cover the expected in-service range. Data
obtained at unrealistic stress levels may ad
versely affect the regression analysis, Table
4s presented to delimit the range of stress
levels possible, It may be necessary for the
testing agency o exclude certain sess states
oF include others,
8.15.1 To determine the maximum
number of repetitions necessary, com:
ae the recoverable axial deformations
at the 20th and SOth repetitions. If the
difference is less than 5 percent of the
smaller, record the average recoverable
axial deformation of the last five repeti-
tions. Ifthe difference is preater than 5
percent apply an additional 50 repetitions
at this stress state. Repeat the comparison
for the SOth and 100th repetitions. Con-
Specimens
Devitor
Sequence Suess No.of
Phase No. (kPa)*_Repettions
Specimen Bie
Conditioning _1__1s#* 1000
2 a
aw
Testing 48
sa
6195
Taos = tp
‘Use for specimens wit sheng Seat 48 kha
0010p
‘e+ Use for specimens wih sheng srength
5 H8> APs (1000p,
Ieptions necesay 6 0. The maxims econ
5 per Section 8.1.51 and mot be seleterminc fr
NOTE: Conining pes fr al eva sess
152 ws pe
tinue applying additional sets of 50 repe-
tions and repeating the above compari-
son between the last and 50th previous
repetition, until the difference is equal
‘o or less than 5 percent of the smaller
value. When this criteria is met the num
ber of repetitions applied shall be consid-
ered the maximum necessary and the
average recoverable axial deformation
for the last five repetitions will be re-
corded. This process shall be terminated
after 200 repetitions are applied.
8.1.6 Increase the deviator stress to
the next desired level. Determine the
‘maximum number of repetitions neces-
sary at this stress by the method de-
scribed in Section 8.1.5.1 and apply to
the specimen. Record the average recov.
‘rable axial deformations of the last five
repetitions for each deviator stress.
8.1.7 Continue the steps of Section
8.1.6 until testing at all dsized deviator
stresses is completed.
BLL If a backpressure was used,
reduce it to zero, then reduce the confin-
ing pressure to zero
8.1.9 Disassemble the triaxial cham-
ber and remove all apparatus from the
specimen, Use the entire specimen for
the final moisture content determination,
Record this value on a form for cohesive
soils as shown in Figure 4.788,
8.2. Resilience Testing of Granular
Materials—Procedures. of this. section
‘are used for specimens of granular sub-
grade soils and base/subbase materials,
8.2.1 Allow the specimen to consoli-
date as in Section 8.1.1.1,
8.22 If not already done, open or