Professional Documents
Culture Documents
P OWER QUALITY is an important consideration in the simultaneously unlike existing studies which usually focus on
reliability and security of smart grids which is likely to be one voltage level (usually HV). Comparisons are made for
heavily impacted by the growth of Plug-in Electric Vehicles different charging regimes, rates and time zones for multiple
(PEVs) over the coming years [1]. In order to design and PEV chargers operating in residential networks. Based on
prepare smart grids for the adoption of PEVs, it is necessary to decoupled harmonic power flow (DHPF), the nonlinearity of
analyze the impacts that simultaneous PEV units charging PEVs and large industrial loads are incorporated into the
including their charging schemes, durations and rates will analysis. Residential and industrial linear and nonlinear load
have on performance and the power quality of smart grids. variations over a 24 hour period have been taken into account.
Specifically, the stresses imposed on local neighborhood The impacts on smart grid power quality in terms of voltage
circuits including distribution transformers, which are the profile, power losses (fundamental and harmonics), peak
weakest link in smart grids, needs to be ascertained. demand, and transformer loading, as well as, total harmonic
The battery chargers for PEVs have high ratings and distortions are investigated.
employ nonlinear switching devices which may result in
significant harmonic currents injected into the distribution
system [2]. Many papers have already studied the harmonic II. NEWTON BASED HARMONIC POWER FLOW
distortions generated by individual ac-dc converters of battery The analysis presented in this paper is entirely based on
charging circuitry [3-7]; however there are limited studies harmonic power flow solutions. A special algorithm has been
performed at the system level to gauge the power quality developed in MATLAB for this study in which the harmonic
impact of different charging patterns of multiple PEV users. power-flow calculation uses a decoupled approach. Decoupled
Depending on the charging pattern of multiple PEV users harmonic power flow (DHPF) is justified due to its acceptable
(e.g., off-peak and on-peak, slow/fast charging, etc), the accuracy and the fact that distribution systems consist of a
harmonic levels may rise to drastic levels that can increase large number of linear and nonlinear loads (e.g., PEVs) that
cause convergence and memory storage problems if the
harmonic couplings are considered [9].
P.S. Moses, S. Deilami and M.A.S. Masoum are with the Department of
Electrical and Computer Engineering, Curtin University of Technology, Perth,
At harmonic frequencies, the power system is modeled as a
Australia (paul.s.moses@gmail.com;s.deilami@postgrad.curtin.edu.au, combination of passive elements and harmonic current
m.masoum@curtin.edu.au). A.S. Masoum is with Transmission Maintenance sources. The general model of linear loads as resistances in
Delivery, Western Power, WA parallel with reactances is utilized [10]. The ac-dc converters
(amir.sherkatmasoum@westernpower.com.au).
of PEV chargers and industrial motor drives considered in the
analysis consist of nonlinear switching devices which inject
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
2
harmonic currents into the smart grid. With knowledge of the III. SMART GRID DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM WITH HIGH
current harmonic spectra, these nonlinear loads can be PENETRATION OF PLUG-IN ELECTRIC VEHICLES
modeled as parallel current sources each injecting harmonic In order to study the impacts of different charging rates for
currents at different frequencies into the system. multiple PEVs in a smart grid, a suitable network topology
The related admittance matrix is modified according to the must be assumed. This section describes the detailed smart
harmonic frequency [11-13]. The fundamental and the hth grid distribution system topology, load configuration and PEV
harmonic current of the nonlinear load installed at bus i with charging scenarios assumed for the analysis. The developed
real power P and reactive power Q are modeled as system includes the harmonic current injections from
I i1 = [( Pi + jQi ) / Vi1 ] * (1) nonlinear PEV loads and is solved through the modified
decoupled harmonic load flow algorithm described in Section
II.
I ih = C (h) I i1 (2)
PE V
Vs
ith 15
where C(h) is the ratio of the hth harmonic current to its
w l4
ks tia
or n
fundamental. The harmonic voltages are computed by solving
tw ide
Ne Res
the following load-flow equation:
Y h V h = I h. (3)
⎡⎛ H 1/ 2 ⎤
h ⎞
2
THDv = ⎜⎜ ∑ Vi ⎟⎟ / Vi1 ⎥ × 100%
⎢
⎢⎝ h ≠1 ⎠ ⎥ Daily
⎣ ⎦ residential load
(5) curve
⎡⎛ H 2⎞
1 / 2 ⎤
THDi = ⎢⎜⎜ ∑ I ih ⎟⎟ / I i1 ⎥ × 100%
⎢⎝ h≠1 ⎠ ⎥
⎣ ⎦
2
h ⎛ h h h ⎞
Ploss (i ,i +1) = Ri,i +1 ⎜ Vi ,i +1 − Vi yi ,i +1 ⎟ (6)
⎝ ⎠
Fig. 2. Daily residential load curve
and the total power loss, including losses at harmonic A. Smart Grid Distribution System
frequencies, for an m bus system is
Fig. 1 illustrates the smart grid distribution system topology
investigated in this paper. Unlike existing analyses which
h H ⎛ m −1 h ⎞
= ∑ ⎜ ∑ Ploss focus on one voltage level, a hybrid system consisting of high
Ploss (i ,i +1) ⎟ (7)
h =1 ⎝ i =0 ⎠ voltage and low voltage network topologies is developed to
study the impacts of multiple PEV charging on a smart grid.
Based on this approach, a detailed network populated with The HV distribution feeder and LV residential networks are
linear and nonlinear loads, including PEVs, is analyzed to considered by expanding the IEEE 30 bus system [14] to
understand the power quality issues facing smart grid include several LV 415 (240) V sections. The LV networks
development. Voltage profiles, harmonic levels, system represent different residential zones and are based on realistic
loading and system losses (fundamental and harmonic) are data for a local neighborhood (see Appendix). Each LV
computed and compared for different charging approaches. network consists of 19 nodes representing customer
households, and potentially high penetrations of PEV charging
have been included. Six LV sections of this type, each with 19
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
3
B. Linear loads
A typical daily load curve based on true recordings of a
distribution transformer will be used to model the linear load
variations (Fig. 3) over a 24 hour period. In addition to this,
different PEV charging load profiles at various households
will be added at different time periods (e.g., on-peak, off- Fig. 3. Current waveform distortion for nonlinear PEV charger load
peak) to investigate the new loading patterns, system stresses TABLE II
and power quality issues. RECENTLY INTRODUCED PEVS ON THE
MARKET AND THEIR BATTERY CAPACITIES
C. Battery Chargers for Plug-in Electric Vehicles Recent PEV Models Battery Capacity [kWh]
PEV battery chargers have large ratings and employ highly Tesla Roadster[15] 54
nonlinear ac-dc converters which will distort the line current.
Many studies have investigated the generated current Nissan Leaf[16] 24
harmonics but the combined impact of multiple PEVs and GM Chevrolet Volt
their nonlinearities at the system level is uncertain. The [17] 16
harmonic current content of PEV chargers is difficult to arrive
Mitsubishi i-MiEV[18] 16
at because it varies with many factors such as initial battery
state of charge and charging profile. However, detailed Monte
Carlo simulation analysis performed by [2] has justified and For optimal battery life, a small portion of the battery rating
developed a typical mean current harmonic spectra which can is unusable. For a deep cycle PEV battery, it is reasonable to
be used for computations. Based on this, the PEV charger assume 80% of the rated battery life can be used resulting in
nonlinearities are modeled with the harmonic spectra shown in an available capacity of 12.8 kWh that the charger must
Table I obtained from [2]. deliver. Due to losses in the battery charger, the energy
requirement from the grid is actually greater than the stated
battery capacity. Therefore, a battery charger efficiency of
D. PEV Batteries and Charging Profiles
approximately 90% is assumed requiring 14.2 kWh of energy
For modeling PEV charging loads realistically, the battery from the grid to charge a single PEV.
capacities are of importance to determine reasonable charging The PEV battery chargers have high ratings compared to
rates. A survey was performed of the most recent PEV normal residential loads in order to charge the large batteries
productions to date and their stated battery capacities (Table in reasonable time periods. The charging power will be limited
II). A 16 kWh battery capacity per PEV is selected for this by the ratings of typical 240V ac household wiring and
study because it is expected that the lower end battery sizes electrical outlets. A standard single-phase 240V outlet
will be more affordable and therefore dominate the PEV (Australia) is rated to about 2.4 kW. Higher ratings are
market initially. possible if 15A and 20A outlets are installed for residential
TABLE I customers which can supply approximately 4 kW and 14.4 kW
TYPICAL LINE CURRENT HARMONIC CONTENT OF (single-phase and three-phase), respectively. Therefore, for
A PLUG-IN ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGER [2]
this analysis, PHEV charging rates (normal, medium and
Harmonic order h mag deg quick charging) within these outlet power limitations will be
1 100 -26
tested in residential areas for different charging time periods
5 25 -94
sufficient to charge a 16 kWh battery. Furthermore, two PEV
7 17 -67
penetration levels are assumed. For low penetration, 20% of
11 9 -67
13 5 -46 each 19 node residential system is populated with PEVs (i.e., 4
THDi 31.9 % PEVs per LV section totaling 24 PEVs). For high penetration
of PEVs, 80% of the residential house nodes are populated
with PEVs (total of 90 PEVs).
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
4
TABLE III
IMPACTS OF PEV CHARGING RATE, PENETRATION AND CHARGING PERIOD ON THE POWER QUALITY OF SMART GRIDS
Low PEV Penetration (20%) High PEV Penetration (80%)
Max. Max.
Charging Rates
MAX
PLOSS Trans. MAX
PLOSS Trans.
voltage THDv voltage THDv
Charging Periods PEAK
PTOTAL Imax PEAK
PTOTAL Imax
deviation** [%] deviation* [%]
[pu] [pu]
[%] * [%]
5pm-8am 2.146 12.700 0.812 3.385 2.304 17.246 0.946 13.704
Normal Charge
6 Hr @ Pchg,max ≈ 5pm-2am 2.232 12.945 0.861 2.875 2.760 18.249 1.102 15.830
2.4 kW
5pm-11pm (peak) 2.275 12.986 0.884 2.837 3.239 18.826 1.181 15.830
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
5
Fig. 6. Total harmonic distortion of voltage at the worst performing bus. Figure 9. System power losses with high penetration of PEVs using
Quick charge rate and low penetration of PEV at different time zones medium charge rate at different time period
Fig. 7. Voltage profile of worst performing bus for low penetration of PEVs Fig. 10. Total harmonic distortion of voltage at the worst performing bus.
with quick charge rate and different charging periods Medium charge rate and high penetration of PEV at different time zones
Fig. 8. System load curve with high penetration of PEVs using medium Fig. 11. Voltage profile of worst performing bus for high penetration of
charge rate at different charging time periods PEVs with medium charge rate and different charging periods
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
6
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
7
Regulators Part III: The Numerical Results," Power Apparatus and Sara Deilami (S’09) received her B.S. degree in Electrical Engineering-
Systems, IEEE Transactions on, vol. PAS-104, pp. 3291-3297, 1985. Electronics in 2000 from Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran. She was
[15] "Tesla Motors - High performance electric vehicles," Tesla Motors, awarded a Curtin University Postgraduate Scholarship (CUPS) in 2010 is
2010, [Online]. Available: http://www.teslamotors.com/. presently working towards a Master degree in Electrical Engineering at Curtin
[16] "Nissan LEAF Electric Car," Nissan, 2010, [Online]. Available: University of Technology, Perth, Australia. Her interests include optimal
http://www.nissanusa.com/leaf-electric-car/. dispatch of shunt capacitors and LTC, harmonics, power quality and
[17] Chevrolet, "2011 Volt Electric Car," 2010, [Online]. Available: protection and renewable energy systems. She has eight years of industry
http://www.chevrolet.com/electriccar/. experience as an engineer working in consultant companies.
[18] Mitsubishi, "i MiEV Mitsubishi inovative Electric Vehicle," 2010,
[Online]. Available: http://www.mitsubishi-motors.com/special/ev/. Amir S. Masoum received his B.Eng. degree in Electrical Engineering in
2009 from the University of Western Australia (UWA), Perth, Australia. He
Paul S. Moses (S'09) received his B.Eng. (1st Class Hons.) and B.Sc. degrees is currently a Contract Networks Engineer at the Transmission Maintenance
in Electrical Engineering and Physics in 2006 from Curtin University of Delivery, Western Power, Kewdale, WA, 6105. Amir also has two years of
Technology, Perth, Australia. He received the W J Smith Memorial Prize for industry experience as a testing technician at Magellan Power, O’Connor,
Best Electrical Engineering Honors Thesis and the Don Watts Prize from the WA, Australia. His main interests are control and energy management of
Faculty of Engineering for the most innovative research project. He was renewable energy resources and power system.
awarded an Australian Postgraduate Award scholarship in 2009 and is
presently working towards a PhD degree in Electrical Engineering at Curtin Mohammad A. S. Masoum (SM’05) received his B.S., M.S. and Ph.D.
University of Technology. Since 2007, he has also been working as a research degrees in Electrical and Computer Engineering in 1983, 1985, and 1991,
scientist for the Defence Science and Technology Organisation (DSTO) in the respectively, from the University of Colorado at Boulder, USA. Dr.
Department of Defence, Australia, and is presently part of their Maritime Masoum’s research interests include optimization, power quality and stability
Platforms Division, Propulsion and Energy Systems Group. His research of power systems/electric machines and distributed generation. Currently, he
interests include nonlinear electromagnetic phenomena, power quality, smart is an Associate Professor and the discipline leader for Power System
grids and protection. Engineering at the Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, Curtin
University of Technology, Perth, Australia. He is a senior member of IEEE.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR). Downloaded on May 20,2023 at 04:40:37 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.