You are on page 1of 6

The Optional Stop © Copyright 2001, CNC Concepts, Inc.

Winter 2001 Issue 50


Tips For Fanuc Control Users From CNC Concepts, Inc.
44 Little Cahill Road Cary, IL 60013 Ph: (847) 639-8847 FAX: (847) 639-8857

Adobe Acrobat Reader Admittedly, company manage-


The Optional Stop You’ll need Adobe Acrobat ment must be able to tell what peo-
Newsletter is now on Reader to view the newsletter. If you ple are doing. They must also be
don’t already have it, you can down- able to account for time spent if ac-
our web site! curate quoting is to be done. But the
load the reader from the newsletter
process of accounting for time must
We’ve always wanted to make our download page.
be simple, detracting as little as pos-
technical newsletter available to any- To download sible from normal responsibilities.
one requesting it, but printing and
Simply come to our website Again, most time accounting done
mailing costs have prevented us
(www.cncci.com) and click on in manufacturing companies is done
from freely distributing it. With our
Books and Publications. Near the for the purpose of production con-
website, we have the ability to post
bottom of the page under “Publica- trol and estimating. And I’ve seen
this newsletter in Adobe Acrobat
tions” click the link for The Optional very elaborate methods used - meth-
(PDF) format, as we’re currently do-
Stop Newsletter. The current issue ods so complicated that they don’t
ing so with our Instructor Notes
(and up to four of the most recent is- make much sense to manufacturing
newsletter. A recent flurry of cancel-
sues) will be available for down- people. Additionally, these account-
lations (due to mail contamination
loading. Click it to start the down- ing methods don’t help much when
scares) has finally pushed us over
load as you would any other PDF file it comes to making improvements in
the edge. From this issue on, we’ll
format download. If you have prob- the CNC environment. Managers
be posting The Optional Stop News-
lems downloading, please contact us can be lulled into a false sense of se-
letter on our website and making it
for help (847-639-8847). curity, since accounted numbers can
available free of charge. This is the
last issue that will be mailed to you. What about my paid subscrip-
tion?
When is each issue available In This Issue:
for download? If you have paid to receive The
Optional Stop, unless we hear from The Optional Stop Newsletter
The Optional Stop is published is now on our web site!...........1
you, we will simply continue send-
quarterly with each change in sea-
ing each new issue by mail until your A simple way of accounting
son. You’ll be able to download
subscription ends. If this is not satis- for time ...............................1
each new issue from the first day of
factory, contact us to receive a re-
each new season (about March 20, A helical interpolation rough
fund for the balance of your sub-
June20, September 20, and Decem- mill custom macro ................2
scription. We won’t be accepting
ber 20). We’ll also place a special Five axis alternatives .............3
any more renewals or new subscrip-
link on our home p age
tions. Are you breaking taps?...........4
(www.cncci.com) under “Recent up-
dates to this site” as soon as each M01 A quick test for tool length ......5
new issue is available. Product corner .....................5
Come visit our secure
A simple way of
ON-LINE STORE!
accounting for time Subscription Information:
Now you can purchase our CNC The Optional Stop is published quarterly by
training product on-line with a credit
card (Visa or MasterCard)! Come visit
I’ve been in many companies where CNC Concepts, Inc. and is distributed free of
people seem more concerned with charge to people downloading it from our
our recently updated site today!
accounting for time than they do website. Back issues are available, but a
Products include:
with making the best use of it. CNC $10.00 charge per issue will apply to any back
I CD-rom courses
I Books & publications people are often so concerned with isues not currently published on our site.
I Video courses monitoring and documenting the All techniques given in this newsletter are in-
I Mini-Vids
time spent on the various tasks they tended to make CNC usage more efficient,
www.cncci.com perform that little time is left to actu-
ally accomplish anything.
easier, and safer. However, CNC Concepts,
Inc. can accept no responsibility for the use or
misuse of the techniques given.

Winter 2001 Issue 50 1


The Optional Stop

be manipulated to show just about ups. A setup person may, for exam- for your cycle time reduction pro-
anything a creative accountant wants ple, be busy changing inserts on one gram.
to show. machine while another is down for
setup. How would the setup person Which method is best?
account for this time? If he or she We’re not trying to encourage you
The only two activities
“logs” the time against insert chang- to change your accounting methods.
Assuming you have work for your ing, it won’t show up as part of setup But we are trying to expose potential
CNC machines (machines don’t sit time, yet the machine in setup is limitations. Our simplistic account-
idle due to lack of work), there are down - and based upon our defini- ing method work best when your
only two things happening with tion - this time must be considered as people are trying to make improve-
each machine. Machines are either part of setup. Of course, anything ments. It provides a very narrow fo-
in setup or their running production. that can be done to reduce the cus for anyone working to improve.
That’s it. There is nothing else. Be- amount of time a machine is down
fore you start to disagree, consider M01
between production runs will re-
our definitions of setup and cycle duce setup time, making the ma-
time. chine more productive, and should
Setup time is the time it takes to go be fair game for your setup reduc- A helical interpolation
from making the last workpiece in tion program. rough mill custom
the most recent production - to mak-
ing the first good workpiece (effi-
In similar fashion, an operator macro
may be in the middle of a production
ciently) in the next production run. run on a CNC machine when he or by Scott Lowe of Maha USA
The entire time a machine is down she is called away to perform some
between production runs (for any
reason) is setup time.
other function for the company (pos- I came up with this macro because
sibly performing secondary opera- we do a lot of hole making through
Cycle time is the time it takes to tions on another machine). Again, helical interpolation. This macro
complete a production run divided how is this time accounted for? If the makes it more efficient to write such
by the number of acceptable operator logs the time against the programs and you are also less
workpieces produced. secondary operation, it won’t show prone to make data entry mistakes
Based upon these definitions of up as part of cycle time (or produc- because this task has been lessened
setup and cycle time, you should tion run time) for the machine that considerably. This is being done us-
easily agree with our point that there sits idle. Of course, anything that ing custom macro B on a Fanuc 16M
are only two activities for CNC ma- shortens the time it takes to com- control.
chine tools. Admittedly, many activi- plete a production run will improve Here is the custom macro.
ties may be going on during setup cycle time, and should be fair game
have nothing to do with making set- :7100(HELICAL INTERPOLATION
ROUGH MILL)
New computer based training course! CD-ROM disk: 5.8 hours! (10-15-01)
CNC Turning Center Programming, #24=#5041 (X AXIS CURRENT POSI-
TION SYSTEM VARIABLE)
Setup, and Operation #25=#5042 (Y AXIS CURRENT POSI-
Affordable courseware for CNC turning centers! TION SYSTEM VARIABLE)
A very popular CNC machine type! 28 lessons! #30=[#1-#2]/2 (SUBTRACT CUTTER DI-
CNC turning centers are among the most popular types We further divide the key concepts into twenty-eight
lessons. Lessons range from under five minutes to just AMETER FROM HOLE DIAMETER/2)
of CNC machine tools. Most companies that have any
CNC machines have at least one. Unfortunately, over twenty minutes in length (total course presentation IF[#3EQ2]THEN#32=42 (CONDITIONAL
companies are finding it more and more difficult to find time is five hours fifty-two minutes on one CD-rom). BRANCH STATEMENT ESTABLISHING
and hire qualified CNC people. Many are realizing that The most popular control! CUTTER COMP RIGHT)
they must provide extensive training to new hires and All examples are shown in the format for the most popular
provide at least some continuing training to established control in the industry – the Fanuc control. Note that many IF[#3EQ3]THEN#32=41 (CONDITIONAL
employees. control manufacturers claim to be Fanuc-compatible. BRANCH STATEMENT ESTABLISHING
A proven method What you get! CUTTER COMP LEFT)
This affordable courseware makes it possible to train The CD-rom disk is jam-packed with 5 hours, 52 minutes
CNC people from scratch. While we assume the
G90G0Z3. (RAPID TO THREE MILLIME-
of information about CNC turning centers. By itself, it
student has some basic machining practice makes formidable training tool. It’s price is $149.00. TERS ABOVE PART)
experience, we assume nothing about their previous When purchased with the workbook answer combination G90G1Z0.F#9 (FEED TO Z ZERO)
CNC skills. Using our proven key concepts approach,
we bring students up to speed gradually – constantly
($30.00), you’ll be able to confirm that you truly G90G1G#32D#7X[#30+#24]F#9 (FEED
understand the material (28 exercises, one for each
building upon previously presented information – and lesson).
RADIALLY OUT TO SPECIFIED HOLE
we stress the reasons why things are done as
When purchased with the optional student manual SIZE)
importantly as how they’re done. Six of the ten key
concepts are most related to programming, and four
($60.00), you’ll have a way to easily review information #31=#6+0
after you finish the course.
are related to setup and operation. #33=0
If all items are purchased, we include a one-year
subscription to our newsletter, The Optional Stop. N10IF[#33LE#26]GOTO20 (CONDI-
The price for unlimited training? … $149.00 (courseware only) TIONAL BRANCH USED FOR REPETI-
Companion manual: $60.00, workbook/answer combination: $30.00 TION)

2 Issue 50 Winter 2001


Tips For Fanuc Control Users From CNC Concepts, Inc.

G90G#3I-#30G91Z-#6 (ONE FULL HELI- K(#6) = Z DEPTH PER ONE FULL HELICAL
CAL REVOLUTION) REVOLUTION Five axis alternatives
#33=#33-#31
GOTO10 Note that this custom macro will by Dennis Griffon of Tri-Tech Preci-
N20G90G#3I-#30 (ONE FULL REVOLU- cause multiple passes to be made sion Products, Inc.
TION TO CLEAN UP BOTTOM OF
until the depth per one full helical
HOLE)
G90G1X[#24-#30/4] (FEED OFF) revolution (K) is equal to the depth There are currently three alterna-
G90G0Z#18 (RAPID OUT OF HOLE) of hole (Z). Z must be evenly divisi- tives to achieve 4th and 5th axis ma-
G40D0 ble by K. Also, this custom macro re- chining capabilities:
M99 quires that you’re machining into the
Z0 surface. Simple modifications 1. Five-axis Machining Center
Here is an example of a calling would allow you to machine into 2. Tilting / Rotary Tables
command in the cutting program. any Z surface.
3. Spindle Head Attachments
Note that I load the tool, start the
spindle, make a prior move in XY, I establish variable #31 by adding I thought your readers might ben-
and instate tool length compensa- zero to variable #6(address K). Vari- efit from my insights about these al-
tion prior to calling the macro. Also, able #33 starts off at zero. As part of ternatives.
I use the metric mode, so all values the repetition process, I take variable Five-axis Machining Center -
are specified in millimeters. #33 and subtract variable #31 from it, There are currently more than fifteen
coming up with the current Z end (15) original- equipment manufac-
G65 P7100 A38.0 B19.05 C3.0 D4.0 point for the helical move. From the turers of five-axis machining centers
F1400.0 R20.0 Z-20.0 K2.0 example above, variable #31 equals sold in the U.S. These manufacturers
#6 (2.0mm) plus zero. When I sub- include all of the biggest names in
Here is what each variable in the tract #31 from #33, variable #33 be- manufacturing technology such as:
call statement represents: comes negative 2mm. With repeti- Cincinnati Milacron, Giddings &
tion, #33 becomes increasingly more Lewis (parent of Fadal Engineering),
A(#1) = HOLE DIAMETER negative (by 2.0 mm increments in Haas Automation, Deckle-Maho,
B(#2) = CUTTER DIAMETER this example. In block N10, if #33, is
C(#3) = CUTTER FEED DIRECTION Nicholas-Correa, SNK, Okuma,
(3=COUNTERCLOCKWISE, 2=CLOCK-
less than or equal to #26 (depth of Toshiba and Mitsubishi. The major-
WISE) hole) then the program will jump to ity of these machining centers are
D(#7) = CUTTER COMP OFFSET block N20. Number #33 keeps accu- large, powerful, accurate and expen-
NUMBER mulating depth until the condition in sive with prices averaging well
F(#9) = FEEDRATE IN MM PER MINUTE block N10 is met, in which case the
R(#18) = CLEARANCE PLANE above $500,000. The least expensive
loop is exited. 5-axis machining centers on the mar-
Z(#26) = DEPTH OF HOLE(ALWAYS A
NEGATIVE NUMBER) M01 ket today have a starting price of ap-
proximately $350,000. The chief
draw-back of these ‘lower cost’
New computer based training course! CD-ROM disk: over 6 hours! 5-axis machining centers is their
CNC Machining Center Programming, range of motion which is generally
Setup, and Operation limited to (+/- 35°). Work pieces
Affordable courseware for CNC machining centers! that require a steeper angle of cut
A very popular CNC machine type! 24 lessons! must be manually repositioned and
We further divide the key concepts into twenty-four
CNC machining centers are among the most popular
types of CNC machine tools. Most companies that have lessons. Lessons range from under five minutes to just restarted. Also, these machines are
any CNC machines have at least one. Unfortunately, over twenty minutes in length (total course presentation
time is just over six hours on one CD-rom).
somewhat less rigid than their 3-axis
companies are finding it more and more difficult to find
and hire qualified CNC people. Many are realizing that The most popular control! counterparts.
they must provide extensive training to new hires and All examples are shown in the format for the most popular
provide at least some continuing training to established control in the industry – the Fanuc control. Note that many Rotary Tables - Several manufac-
employees. control manufacturers claim to be Fanuc-compatible. turers now produce rotary or
A proven method What you get!
This affordable courseware makes it possible to train The CD-rom disk is jam-packed with over six hours of
tilt-rotary tables which can be
CNC people from scratch. While we assume the
student has some basic machining practice
information about CNC machining centers. By itself, it mounted to the bed of a (3-axis) CNC
makes formidable training tool. It’s price is $149.00.
experience, we assume nothing about their previous When purchased with the workbook answer combination machine. The table will hold and ro-
CNC skills. Using our proven key concepts approach,
we bring students up to speed gradually – constantly
($30.00), you’ll be able to confirm that you truly understand
the material (24 exercises, one for each lesson).
tate a part at various angles to pro-
building upon previously presented information – and
we stress the reasons why things are done as
When purchased with the optional student manual ($60.00), vide machine access to many sides
importantly as how they’re done. Six of the ten key
you’ll have a way to easily review information after you
finish the course.
of the part. Rotary tables have been
concepts are most related to programming, and four
are related to setup and operation. If all items are purchased (total: $239.00), we include a available for many years and are
one-year subscription to our newsletter, The Optional Stop.
used extensively by small and large
The price for unlimited training? … $149.00 (courseware only)
Companion manual: $60.00, workbook/answer combination: $30.00
machine shops around the world.
Contact CNC Concepts, Inc. (847-639-8847) to order! Simple rotary tables are available to

3 Issue 50 Winter 2001


The Optional Stop

provide 4th-axis capability to nearly the cost of custom fabrication and in- have heard, and seen people get
any 3-axis machine at a price ranging stallation.. away without one by running very
from $5,000 to $35,000. Tilt-rotary c) My company’s Tri-Tech Model low spindle speeds. But if you tap
tables can provide 4th and 5th axis 5412 head attachment is fully pro- many holes at all, the special holder
capability with a price range of grammable and can be used to con- is worth the money.
$35,000 to $75,000. The main vert nearly any 3-axis machining If you go with the floater, you can
draw-back of tilt-rotary tables is that center to a true, simultaneous 5-axis kick your spindle speeds back up to
they are limited to small parts that machining center. The M5412 has a normal. Just remember a couple
can be attached to the table itself. wide range of motion including tilt things:
Even the largest tilt-rotary tables can capability of +/- 90° and continuous (1) The spindle is still going to
reduce the working envelope of the 360° rotary motion. Because the “coast down”, even more so with
host machine by 60% to 70%. M5412 is a spindle attachment, it can higher spindle speeds. On most of
Spindle Head Attachments fall access all points of the machining our machines this translates into
into three categories - center’s work envelope. The M5412 about 1 turn for every 100rpm. Pro-
a) Indexable head attachments is portable and can be mounted, in gram the depth a little short to keep
such as the Tech-Nara, Gerardi or thirty (30) minutes, with no modifi- from coasting too deep, especially
Benz can be mounted to the spindle cation to the host machine. At nearly on blind holes.
of most 3-axis machining centers. 150 pounds, the M5412 is a heavy
The indexable head must be manu- duty attachment yet compact
ally repositioned to various angles of enough to attach to many smaller to
as much as 90 degrees in increments mid-size machines.

C
of one degree. The repositioned While the “low priced” 5-axis ma-

N
head can then access all points of the chining centers are fairly rigid, they Fanuc
host machine’s working envelope. cannot match the rigidity of their Users!
The indexable head attachment is
not programmable and therefore
cannot perform simultaneous 5-axis
3-axis counterparts for significant
metal removal. The M5412 allows
the user to perform all significant
CTRAINING
machining. The head requires man- metal removal using the heavy duty
New CD-rom Courses!
ual intervention and another ma- 3-axis machining center then mount
No other training media offers the interactivity of
chine pass for each new angle re- the M5412 attachment software based training. Click on a lesson title, and
quired and cannot be set for com- you’re shown the topics for that lesson. Click on a
M01
plex angles or fractions of a degree. topic to see & hear content for that topic. When
you’ve studied all topics in a lesson, do an exercise
The head is designed for only light and check it. And then – on to the next lesson!
machining and is not suited for hard >Two Basic CNC Courses:
metals or significant metal removal. Are you breaking taps? 4 Machining center programming,
In spite of these limitations more setup & operation………….…$239.00
Editor’s note: This article was writ-
than 3,000 of these attachments are 4 Turning center programming,
ten by a person that did not provide a setup & operation………….…$239.00
sold annually with list prices in ex-
name from a company called Func-
cess of $10,000.
tion First Fabricating. If this person
>Two Advanced CNC Courses:
4 Advanced techniques with basic
b) Programmable - Two U.S. com- provides his or her name, we’ll gladly CNC features……………....…$189.00
panies (Dayton Machine Tool and include it in our next issue. 4 Parametric Programming for CNC
Bertsche Engineering Corp.) and at machining & turning centers...$795.00
least one German company manu- If your machine does not have a
CNC Mini-Vids!
facture and sell a programmable spindle encoder, you should be us-
head for attachment to large 3-axis One-hour (approx.) videos on selected CNC topics.
ing a “floating” tapping holder. The $179.00 each
milling machines. These heads are holder will extend or compress to 4 Setup time reduction for CNC
large, fairly accurate and expensive. make up for mismatches in speed 4 Cycle time reduction for CNC
Because of their size and weight they and feed. 4 Introduction to probing
cannot be mounted onto any of the 4 Machining center cutting operations
The spindle takes longer to re- 4 Introduction to Fanuc parameters
small to mid-sized machining cen- 4 Live tooling on turning centers
verse directions than the feed. A ma-
ters and are reserved for only the 4 Rotary device programming
chine with a spindle encoder will
largest gantry and bridge type mill- For complete information about these products (and
recognize this, and adjust the feed to
ing machines. Each installation re- more) come visit our web site! www.cncci.com
match (rigid tapping). If you don’t
quires custom fabrication and fitting. 44 Little Cahill Road Fax: 847-639-8857
have an encoder on your spindle, a Cary, IL 60013 Email: lynch@cncci.com
The price range of these head attach- Ph: 847-639-8847 Internet: www.cncci.com
floating tap holder is the way to go. I
ments is $175,000 to $350,000 plus

Winter 2001 Issue 50 4


Tips For Fanuc Control Users From CNC Concepts, Inc.

(2) Since the holder can extend, stated tool length compensation handouts (63 handouts totaling over
it’s possible for the tap to have not value. This variable number may be 120 pages) to reinforce your under-
made it completely out of the hole different on other controls. standing of presented techniques. A
before the machine moves to the 135 page companion manual is also
next location (snap). Use a larger included.
R-plane to help avoid this. Product Corner: New Price: $239.00 includes 3 hours, 47
A couple of the controls we own minutes of presentation, 135-page
have features to compensate while
CD-rom Course: Setup companion manual, & 63 printable
“flexible” tapping. Fadal can use a reduction for CNC handouts (over 120 pages) in Adobe
P-code to adjust feed on the way out machining & turning Acrobat format. Adobe Acrobat
of the hole. P5, for example, reduces Reader is included on the CD.
the feedrate by 5% on the way out. centers! Courseware only: $189.00
Incon allows a D-code to dwell Get the most from your CNC ma- Special offer! Until January 31,
(feed) at the bottom to wait for the chines! 2002, you can get the full course (CD
spindle to catch up.
& manual) for $199.00! You can pur-
If you have the spindle encoder, During any CNC machine’s usage, chase the CD only for $149.00! Or-
nothing beats rigid tapping. there are really only two activities. der today!
Machines are either in setup or they
M01
are running production. Setup time
is the total time the machine is down New Instructor’s
between production runs. Cycle
A quick test for tool time is the time it takes to complete a Curriculum for Setup
length production run divided by the num- Reduction!
ber of good workpieces produced.
by Bob McRoberts Here’s another ready-made CNC
When machines are in setup, they
are not producing. Anything you can curriculum to help you teach
In appreciation for the help you’ve do to reduce setup time will improve CNC courses!
given me, I would like to offer you Paralleling our CD-rom course for
the productivity of your CNC ma-
an idea for your newsletter. setup reduction, this curriculum
chines. In this comprehensive 3
The problem: hour, 47 minute course, we’ll expose helps you teach live courses on
many techniques to help you reduce setup reduction. Instructor materials
I have a Mori-Seiki SH-403 Hori-
setup time and cost for the two most include slide shows with and with-
zontal Machining Center. On a spe-
popular types of CNC machine tools. out audio guidance (totaling over
cific job, the tool length is critical. If
We begin by presenting prelimi- 400 slides each), instructions, two
the tool length was too short, the
nary information, including basic written exercises (with answers),
spindle face would collide with the
premises that will help you under- setup reduction planning forms, and
tombstone. Therefore, I need to
stand how to improve machine utili- suggestions for group activities. Stu-
“test” the tool length to ensure that it
zation. Included are presentations dent materials include a 135-page
is long enough. I do so with custom
on justification issues and resources manual.
macro B. Here is a few lines of the
program that should give your read- you have available to reduce setup As with all of our curriculums, in-
ers the idea. time. structor’s materials are free with
We then present principles of your first order of student manuals
setup reduction; principles that can (minimum 20 to qualify for free in-
N1(T1 SPOT DRILL)
IF[#11001 LT 4.5]GOTO 902 (checks T1 be applied to any form of production structor materials).
tool length for 4.5" min.) equipment. We show two task types Download free samples on our
‘ related to setup, three general ways
‘ (body of program) website or request free samples

to reduce setup time, and four steps disk.
G0 G80 G91 G28 Z0.0 M9 (home ma- to implementing setup reduction.
You can see free samples for both
chine in Z axis) Finally, we show countless spe- t he CD -rom c ou r s e a n d t h e
GOTO 901 cific techniques you can apply to re-
N902 #3000=1 (TOOL TOO SHORT) instructor’s curriculum for setup re-
N901 M1
duce setup time in the approximate duction on our website!
order that setups are made - from
On my machine, the #11001 sys- preparation to make setups through www.cncci.com
tem variable returns the currently in- first workpiece inspection! In each
presentation, we include printable

Summer 1999 Issue 40 5


44 Little Cahill Road
Cary, IL 60013
Ph: (847) 639-8847
Fax: (847) 639-8857

The Optional Stop Newsletter Enclosed!


Mailroom: PAID SUBSCRIPTION ENCLOSED. Please assure delivery to addressee. Thank You!

Products That Address The Needs Of CNC Technology Today!


Use this handy form to request more information about our products.
CNC Video Courses:
!Machining Center Programming And Operation CNC Publications:
!Turning Center Programming And Operation !Machining Center Self Study Course
!Conversational Turning Center Programming & Op !Turning Center Self Study Course
!Custom Macro Programming !CNC Router Self Study Course
!Four Axis Turning Center Programming !Managing CNC Operations
CD-rom Courses: !CNC For Machining
!Machining Center Programming, Setup, & Operation !CNC Advanced Techniques
!Turning Center Programming, Setup, & Operation !CNC Accessory Devices
!Setup Reduction for CNC !The Optional Stop Subscription & Back Issues
!Parametric Programming
!CNC Router Programming, Setup, & Operation
!Advanced Techniques With Basic CNC Features

CNC Mini-Vids: CNC In-Plant Training:


!Related To Selected CNC Topics Like Setup !Basic CNC Courses
Time Reduction, Cycle Time Reduction, Probing !CNC Tune-Up - For your experienced People
CNC Course Curriculums For Instructors:
! Machining Center Programming And Operation
! Turning Center Programming And Operation
! CNC Setup Reduction for CNC
! CNC Router Programming And Operation
! Maximizing CNC Utilization (NEW!)
If other than above:
Name:
Company Name: Check Out Our Website!
Address: http://www.cncci.com/
Information about each of
City, State, Zip:
our products is on line!

You might also like