You are on page 1of 5

Japan: Brazilian Nikkeijin menial and low-paying jobs or work in mar-

riage agencies. Like their male counterparts,


women migrant women also relocate in an attempt to
escape unstable economic and social condi-
Lucia E. Yamamoto
tions or political or religious oppression, but
The concept of migrant women as passive fol- what sets women apart from men is their expe-
lowers and secondary wage earners is rein- rience of gender discrimination: their inability
forced by emphasizing labor migration as to advance in the labor market, lower wages,
mainly masculine and family reunification as sexual discrimination, and other employment
feminine. However, in reality, migrant women discriminations.
are active participants in the migratory con-
texts when they support their family enter-
prises by performing unpaid jobs at home;
Migration and unequal opportunities
when they are employed by entrepreneurs as
part of a low-wage labor force through their Are unequal job opportunities a consequence
ethnic communities and work in mass produc- of the migratory policies of the sending and
tion in assembly lines; and when they are hired receiving countries? Some researchers point
as domestic workers or entertainers, or in other out that migration laws and regulations are not
jobs that are considered “feminine.” expressly discriminatory on the basis of gender,
Although women’s participation in interna- but that gender discrimination occurs when
tional migration has increased and their eco- regulations reinforce stereotypical images of
nomic participation as active members of the men and women. In other words, unfairness
society has also become visible in the past and inequality are the result of receiving coun-
century, they are limited by the job opportuni- tries admitting migrants as workers in gender-
ties in the labor market of the host country. specific jobs – such as men for agricultural
Like their male counterparts, migrant women seasonal work and women for domestic
are also overrepresented in occupations with work – and of sending countries reinforcing
few opportunities for promotion and advance- the inability of men or women to meet the
ment. Due to gender role division in the mar- qualifications for particular jobs in the host
ketplace, women are clustered in more country. This perspective is useful in explain-
“feminized” occupations that resemble their ing why in the past many Filipino women were
family roles in the household. allowed to enter Japan on entertainer visas.
The structure of the labor market is seg- Mobility across national borders becomes
mented along gender, class, race, and ethnic possible through the migratory policies
lines, and this places female and male migrants adopted by the sending and receiving countries
in different occupations in host societies. For and the political and economic processes
instance, in a study of non-Japanese Asian involved in migration itself. In addition, deci-
brides in Japan, Piper (2003) demonstrated sions to move are also a consequence of house-
that, although the newly married women have hold decisions (Tacoli 1999). A household’s
legal resident status and may work without any decision to migrate is based on lack of eco-
government occupational restrictions, they nomic mobility and knowledge of the possible
face great restrictions to jobs in the workplace. opportunities available to them. Most of these
If these wives manage to become full-time decisions are made in response to broader
workers, their positions are largely limited to social and economic changes in the global

The Encyclopedia of Global Human Migration, Edited by Immanuel Ness.


© 2013 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Published 2013 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
DOI: 10.1002/9781444351071.wbeghm317
2 japan: brazilian nikkeijin women

economy. Migrant workers can sometimes Nikkeijin women and their families
leave the country independently, but the deci-
sions involved are typically made at the house- In an attempt to understand how expectations
hold level (Tacoli 1999). For instance, to attain about migrant women’s roles are negotiated
their goals, household members choose who through the migration experience, this exami-
among them is best suited to migrate and nation of the life course of Japanese Brazilian
support the other family members, thus setting women migrants during and after migration to
the migration process in motion. Japan provides an important insight into the
In order to understand how decisions are practical opportunities and constraints that are
made, we need to consider factors such as the gender-specific. One question that is crucial is
networks that migrants utilize in sending and how the process of women working abroad is
receiving countries, the family’s life course, the translated into gains in personal autonomy and
aim of migration, the job opportunities avail- self-confidence and how these gains influence
able to them, and the legal procedures of negotiations about women’s role expectations.
migration. The unstable and unequal work The demographic profile of Brazilians in
conditions experienced by male and female Japan (known as Nikkeijin) has changed over
migrants undoubtedly influences how the the past 35 years of migration. In the late 1980s,
migrants and their families deal with job the population was primarily composed of
opportunities in the host society. This is mag- Japanese who had previously migrated to
nified by the fact that many more job oppor- Brazil and were returning to Japan and second-
tunities for migrant women have emerged in generation Japanese Brazilians holding dual
the early 21st century than in the past. citizenship. As Japanese nationals, Nikkeijin
Nonetheless, household decision-making is migrants could work without legal restrictions.
not free of tension and conflicts. Households Since the revision of Japanese immigration law
tend to be organized on the basis of coopera- in 1990, the Nikkei Brazilians (Japanese Brazil-
tion, reciprocity, and consensus, but the deci- ians) who gained rights have expanded to
sions made are often the product of conflicts become second- and third-generation migrants
and tensions arising from the desire for eco- and their families. Until the revision of the law,
nomic autonomy and traditional family roles it was estimated that more than one-quarter of
like the altruistic mother and the dutiful the Brazilian Nikkeijin population residing in
daughter (Tacoli 1999). It should be empha- Japan were women. Their numbers gradually
sized that women’s migration decisions and increased and, in 2010, the percentage was 45.6
capacities are linked to household changes percent (Immigration Bureau of Japan 2011).
according to their life course, as well as to their In the two decades that have passed since
expected contribution to the well-being of migration started, around 50 percent of the
their household. The altruistic behavior of Brazilian population have obtained permanent
migrant women almost always reflects the residence visas (eijuken). It is too early still to
demand to put their family’s well-being before determine if the population is settling down
their own. However, we should view such permanently in Japan. Data from the Immigra-
behavior not only as self-sacrifice but also as a tion Bureau of Japan (2011) indicates that the
reflection of acting independently in one’s own Nikkeijin continue to move between Brazil and
self-interest. As Tacoli indicates, “gender ideol- Japan. Of the Brazilians who entered Japan in
ogies exert powerful constraints over women’s 2010, 50 percent have left more than once.
autonomous behavior by guaranteeing protec- The Brazilian families’ circulatory move-
tion and social acceptability for those who ment has been described by researchers as
remain within its parameters while penalizing immigration without the concrete intention to
those who trespass them” (1999: 674). Within immigrate. Despite the long period Nikkeijin
that context, migrant women negotiate their families have lived in Japan, Brazilian workers
gender roles. typically have no intention to settle down
japan: brazilian nikkeijin women 3

there; yet at the same time, they do not know viewed worked at the family grocery store
when they will return home. These uncertain before migrating. No matter how long or hard
living conditions discourage them from par- she worked, her brothers would inherit the
ticipating in the affairs of local communities, property and she would have no rights to the
which drives the population to continue a cir- family inheritance. Anxious about her eco-
culatory migratory pattern. nomic future, the woman decided to move to
The Brazilian workers’ migration is occur- Japan. While she was working there, her mother
ring in the spaces where ethnic business, inter- became ill in Brazil, so after working for 20
national phone services, ethnic newspapers, months in Japan she returned home because of
and bank services have been established in her duty to care for her mother. The inform-
both countries. In those spaces where migrants ant’s behavior reveals more than a passive
find work and livelihoods, migrants and their acceptance of the expected gender role and the
families maintain a strong linkage with those manner in which Nikkeijin women negotiate
they have left behind, especially as advanced their family positions as daughters. At home,
communication technologies have prolifer- the woman spent her time caring for her
ated. These technologies, however, cannot mother and managing the money she had
totally heal the emotional costs of living trans- earned while working in Japan (e.g. investing
nationally. For instance, articles published by in real estate). When the Christmas season
influential magazines and newspapers in Brazil ended, she was ready to make her second
speak of the suffering of children left behind journey to Japan.
by their mothers, of family disintegration, and Through the experiences of interviewees in
of the divorces that occur as a consequence of these two places, Japan and Brazil, we can
the migration process. However, in spite of the understand how Nikkeijin women organize
emotional tensions, many transnational Brazil- their life in both spaces. Broadly speaking,
ian families feel their migration experience has Japan is the place where women can work and
been positive. In the next section I shall discuss gainfully earn, and Brazil is where women live
how Japanese Brazilian women deal with the or want to live, as they must negotiate family
gender role expectations within this transna- issues and relations. Both spaces are inter-
tional context. connected and are familiar to her. Living in
transnational spaces, the woman can rearrange
Transnational family migration and economic and social conditions whereby she
enjoys a comfortable life in Brazil with the
gender role expectation: a case study
commodities bought with the money saved in
Audrey Kobayashi and Valerie Preston (2007) Japan, and, supported by the co-ethnic com-
point out the paradox of the transnational munity there, she lives in an environment
family’s objective of maintaining a strong, which resembles Japan as closely as possible.
cohesive, and prosperous family by separating The case study provides us with an accurate
their members to different places. Undoubt- description of how Japanese Brazilian women
edly, the family unit is crucial and Johanna deal with their expected roles while living in
Walters (2003) explains that the success two places. Another interviewee returned to
achieved by transnational families like Chinese her home three times in a period of eight years
migrant families is built on a patriarchal struc- in Japan. Her first trip to Brazil was a tempo-
ture. The success of the family’s strategy of rary return. She went back for two months
capital accumulation relies upon established with the promise to return to the same work-
notions of familial loyalty to ensure that disci- place, to do the same job tasks. Although she
pline is maintained across borders. We find had lived with her family until her trip to
some similarities among Japanese Brazilians. Japan, upon her return she found conditions
For instance, a 39-year-old and unmarried were not as they had been previously: “All the
Japanese Brazilian woman who was inter- time I was asking my mom if I can do this or
4 japan: brazilian nikkeijin women

that thing in the house. I felt like a guest in my could think about their family’s expectations
own home.” In fact, she was on vacation. She and became aware of the gap between their
brought her family souvenirs and electrical lives in Brazil and in Japan, but those experi-
appliances, and the money earned in Japan was ences did not bring about change in their
spent on buying a new house in Brazil. Her gender roles.
second return home was different from the
first. Having been engaged in the same job for SEE ALSO: Gender and migration; Japan:
three years working on an assembly line in collapse of empire and repatriation; Japan:
Japan, she felt overworked and stressed and colonization and settlement; Japan: Korean
decided to go back home for medical treat- Zainichi migration; Japan: Nikkeijin migration
ment, without any thought of returning to
Japan. During her stay in Brazil her parents
and relatives began to press her to marry. She References and further reading
stayed there for eight months and again Bryceson, D. & Vuorela, U. (2002) The
returned to Japan. Some years ago, she returned transnational family in the twenty-first century.
home to Brazil again, but now married. Her In D. Bryceson & U. Vuorela (eds.),
parents’ and relatives comments’ about her Transnational Family: New European Frontiers
marriage were, “Yattto kekkon shita, ne” (You and Global Networks. Oxford: Berg.
have finally married) and “Mo omiai shina- Buchanan, S. H. (1979) Haitian women in New
kutemo ii, ne” (You don’t need to have an York City. Migration Today 7(4), 19–25, 39.
Hugo, G. (1995) International labor migration
arranged marriage).
and the family: some observations from
Living a married life in Japan, she feels her
Indonesia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 4,
life has changed completely. Now she manages 273–301.
household chores and tries to balance her Immigration Bureau of Japan (2011) Seifu tokei
job and household responsibilities. Although no sogo madoguchi (June 30, 2011) [Alien
household chores are demanding, she is satis- registration data]. Immigration Bureau of Japan.
fied with married life. Looking back upon At www.e-stat.go.jp/SG1/estat/List.do?lid=
her experience abroad, she said: “I have matured 000001074828, accessed Aug. 1, 2011.
in a lot of ways, and I feel confident about Kobayashi, A. & Preston, V. (2007)
myself.” Transnationalism through the life course: Hong
Kong immigrants in Canada. Asia Pacific
Viewpoint 48, 151–167.
Conclusion Menjivar, C. (1999) The intersection of work and
gender: Central American immigrant women
Many scholars have explored the influence of and employment in California. American
migrant women’s paid work on changing Behavioral Scientist 42, 601–627.
gender roles. They point out that, despite Pedraza, S. (1991) Women’s and migration: the
gender inequalities in the labor market and social consequences of gender. Annual Review of
workplaces, migrant women generally gain Sociology 17, 303–325.
personal autonomy and independence. It is Piper, N. (2003) Wife or worker? Worker or wife?
important, however, to make clear whether or Marriage and cross-border migration in
not these gains can automatically be assumed contemporary Japan. International Journal of
to have changed gender roles or relations. As Population Geography 9, 457–469.
Piquero-Ballescas, M. R. (1996) The expanding Ds
the case studies have demonstrated, while the
and the Filipino women in Japan. In
informants felt that their experiences abroad
International Female Migration and Japan:
gave them self-confidence and autonomy, they Networking, Settlement and Human Rights.
continued to perform according to their Tokyo: International Peace Research Institute,
expected roles. They felt strange returning to Meiji Gakuin University.
their home country, and needed to find ways Tacoli, C. (1999) International migration and the
to cope with life at home. Living abroad, they restructuring of gender asymmetries: continuity
japan: brazilian nikkeijin women 5

and change among Filipino labor migrants in economic immigrants in Vancouver. Canadian
Rome. International Migration Review 33, Geographer 47, 219–234.
658–682.
Walters, J. L. (2003) Flexible citizens?
Transnationalism and citizenship amongst

You might also like