3.

Summary of Case Study

3.1 Summary of Calculation

Table 7.1 : Stability Check

Type of check Value Remarks

Actual,FOS 1.67
Sliding

Limit,FOS 1.25
Ratio 1.33
Check OK
Actual,FOS 2.00
Overturning

Limit,FOS 1.50
Ratio 1.34
Check OK

504.93
Contact Base Pressure

2
Actual Soil Pressure ( kN/m )
With Backside Water Pressure

300.00
Allowable Soil Pressure ( kN/m2 )
Long Term
1.68
Ratio

NG
Check

532.04
Contact Base Pressure

2
Actual Soil Pressure ( kN/m )

375.00
Allowable Soil Pressure ( kN/m2 )
Short Term
1.42
Ratio

NG
Check
Actual Settlement, mm 85.74
Settlement

Permissible Settlement, mm 50.00

Stability Check

Ratio 1.71
Check NG
Actual,FOS 4.26
Sliding

Limit,FOS 1.50
Ratio 2.84
Check OK
Actual,FOS 6.02
Overturning

Limit,FOS 1.50
Ratio 4.01
Check OK
Without Backside Water Pressure

286.13
Contact Base Pressure

2
Actual Soil Pressure ( Kn/m )

300.00
Allowable Soil Pressure
Long Term
0.95
Ratio

OK
Check
Contact Base Pressure

Actual Soil Pressure ( kN/m2 ) 321.47

Allowable Soil Pressure ( kN/m2 ) 375.00

Short Term
Ratio 0.86

Check OK
Actual Settlement, mm 46.64
Settlement

Permissible Settlement, mm 50.00

Ratio 0.93
Check OK
 Type of check Value Remarks
Actual,FOS 3.55

Sliding
Limit,FOS 1.25
Ratio 2.84
Check OK
Actual,FOS 4.17
Overturning

Limit,FOS 1.50
Ratio 2.78
Check OK

393.17
Contact Base Pressure

2
Actual Soil Pressure ( kN/m )

300.00
In Dry Condition
Stability Check

Allowable Soil Pressure ( kN/m2 )

Long Term
1.31
Ratio

NG
Check
Contact Base Pressure

2 402.01
Actual Soil Pressure ( kN/m )

Allowable Soil Pressure ( kN/m2 ) 375.00

Short Term
Ratio 1.07

Check NG
Actual Settlement, mm 64.19
Settlement

Permissible Settlement, mm 50.00

Ratio 1.28
Check NG

Table 7.2 : Section Check

Type of check Value Remarks

Actual, Mpa 9.13
Allowable, Mpa 8.5
Stress on Concrete
Ratio 1.07
Check NG
With Backside Water Pressure

Actual, Mpa 135.38

Allowable, Mpa 240
Stress on Comp. Steel
Ratio 0.56
Check OK
Actual, Mpa 366.12
Allowable, Mpa 240
Stress on Tension Steel
Ratio 1.53
Check NG
Force,Mpa 0.46
Capacity,Mpa 0.27
Strength Check

Shear Check
Abutment Stem

Ratio 1.69
Check NG
Actual, Mpa 4.87
Allowable, Mpa 8.5
Stress on Concrete
Ratio 0.57
Without Backside Water Pressure

Check OK
Actual, Mpa 71.32
Allowable, Mpa 240
Stress on Comp. Steel
Ratio 0.30
Check OK
Actual, Mpa 231.01
Allowable, Mpa 240
Stress on Tension Steel
Ratio 0.96
Check OK
Force,Mpa 0.22
Capacity,Mpa 0.23
Shear Check
Ratio 0.93
Check OK
 Type of check
Value Remarks
Provided(mm2),
28d@140 4398.57
2
X-Direction Required(mm ), 5894.98
Ratio 1.34
Check NG
Top

Provided(mm2),
20d@180 1745.56
2
Y-Direction Required(mm ) 2264.4
With Backside Water Pressure

Ratio 1.30
Check NG
Provided(mm2),
32d@110 7311.82
2
X-Direction Required(mm ) 4871.8
Ratio 0.67
Bottom

Check OK
Provided(mm2),
20d@180 1745.56
Y-Direction Required(mm2) 2259.6
Ratio 1.29
Check NG
Force,Mpa 0.361
Abutment Foundation

Capacity,Mpa 0.27
Shear Check
Strength Check

Ratio 1.34
Check NG
Provided(mm2),
28d@140 4398.57
X-Direction Required(mm2), 2348.6
Ratio 0.53
Check OK
Top

Provided(mm2),
20d@180 1745.56
2
Y-Direction Required(mm ) 2264.4
Without Backside Water Pressure

Governed By Min, 0.12%

Ratio 1.30
Check NG
Provided(mm2),
32d@110 7311.82
X-Direction Required(mm2) 2781.9
Ratio 0.38
Bottom

Check OK
Provided(mm2),
20d@180 1745.56
Y-Direction Required(mm2) 2259.6
Governed By Min, 0.12%
Ratio 1.29
Check NG
Force,Mpa 0.189
Capacity,Mpa 0.27
Shear Check
Ratio 0.70
Check OK
 Type of check
Value Remarks
Provided(mm2),
28d@140 4398.57
X-Direction Required(mm2), 4309.71
Ratio 0.98
Check OK
Top

Provided(mm2),
20d@180 1745.56
2
Y-Direction Required(mm ) 2264.4
Governed By Min, 0.12%
Ratio 1.30
Abutment Foundation

Check NG
In Dry Condition
Strength Check

Provided(mm2),
32d@110 7311.82
2
X-Direction Required(mm ) 4303.8
Ratio 0.59
Bottom

Check OK
Provided(mm2),
20d@180 1745.56
Y-Direction Required(mm2) 2259.6
Governed By Min, 0.12%
Ratio 1.29
Check NG
Force,Mpa 0.132
Capacity,Mpa 0.22
Shear Check
Ratio 0.60
Check OK
FOS : Factor of safety